11 ms·
If you are already spending >$200K per employee, spending another $10K to make them even 10% more productive is a bargain.
by paxys 7y ago
If you are already spending >$200K per employee, spending another $10K to make them even 10% more productive is a bargain.
- paulie_a 7y agoMost enterprises don't spend >200k an employee. Do people really believe that is a normal salary?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sciencewolf 7y agoFully loaded costs (health benefits, 401k matching, cost of computer, HR business partners, etc.) for an employee are roughly 2x what their salary is. So yeah, 200k is a good estimate.
- runako 7y agoThat's still very high. Average salary is much lower than $100k in the US. Even among college grads with 10+ years of experience, $100k is still a high-end job paying a high-end salary. It's nowhere near the average.
- downrightmike 7y agoTake out all the low wage workers that don't use any apps, and the average goes up.
- jitl 7y agoThe assumption is a $100K salary. The other $100K is benefits, management, overhead, etc.
- duxup 7y agoI don't know about most enterprises but I'm guessing any given cost per employee includes a lot more than salary.
- blowski 7y agoIn London, I'd guess the median salary for most enterprises is around £30-40K. National insurance, a desk, and a few other benefits are probably £20K on top of that.
- user5994461 7y agoIf you're talking central London, that should be a fair bit higher.
- blowski 7y agoI'm going on my recent experiences in the City (i.e. the financial district).
- panzagl 7y agoRecruitment, payroll, HR, facilities are other costs.
- spencerwgreene 7y agoThe fully loaded cost of an employee for a business is not the employee's salary. "The fully-loaded costs of employees are much higher than their salary: exactly how much higher depends on your locality’s laws, your benefits package, and a bunch of other HR administrivia, but a reasonable guesstimate is between 150% and 200% of their salary." -https://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/
- sweeneyrod 7y agoMost employees' salaries are not 100k.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Most employees' salaries are not 100k I'd hypothesis that most employees on whom companies spend $10k for cloud software are making $100k+.
- runako 7y agoObviously the fully-loaded cost of an employee goes beyond the cash compensation. But even so, the average salary in the US is < $60k. Use whatever multiplier you want, $200k is way high. Companies are spending far less than $200k/employee all-in. So to slightly rephrase the OP's question: > Do people really believe that $100k is a normal salary?
- freepor 7y agoYes but companies that are spending $60K on an employee aren’t spending $10K on their SaaS.
- mm89 7y agoI don't know much about jobs outside of tech, but I know most of them at the entry level to a few years of experience in accounting, finance, real estate, etc. do not pay much over $60k (if that) and pretty much all of those jobs are going to use things like Salesforce or other expensive SAAS tools and software.
- ac29 7y agoSalesforce "Enterprise" is $1800/user/year [0], and presumably large enterprises are negotiating better rates than the published ones. Every single employee would need to be using five and a half packages like this at full list price to hit $10k/year.
- creaghpatr 7y agoIn Sales you would have SFDC plus some kind of enablement tool like Salesloft/Outreach plus a prospecting tool like Sales Navigator or DiscoverOrg plus enterprise Gmail plus a communication tool like Zoom; and then there's the analytics stuff, the HR/finance parts, etc...10k is probably way too high an estimate but 5k is believable for a B2B startup with a scaling sales team.
- runako 7y agoI won't quibble too much with the precision of the $10k number, which will vary widely. But it's pretty obvious that a basic "customer support" combo like Office 365 + Okta + Zendesk + Intercom + Slack + Zenefits starts to add up to a meaningful percentage of the employee's take-home compensation. (Remember these are positions where $20/hr is a good rate.) And remember, the comparison figure for managers over 50 is roughly $0, which approximates the spend on these functions as far back ago as 2008.
- throwaway55554 7y agoFactoring in all compensation, that is still a ridiculous figure.
- taleodor 7y agoExactly this. Unfortunately, way too often I see execs saying "that's too expensive, we just have to do it manually" instead of using good tool. Then what happens is somebody making $100+/hour would spend several hours to do the job that would be covered by a tool that costs under $50/month.
- papito 7y agoBecause most business in the United States is done despite the management, not because of it.
- cpach 7y agoIs it different in other countries?
- fludlight 7y ago> Because most work in the world is done despite the management, not because of it. FTFY
- genghisjahn 7y agoWhere’s the list of awesome companies that succeed without managers?
- Retric 7y agoValve and other flat organizations arguably qualify. Various tiny small startups may qualify depending on what people mean by managers.
- groby_b 7y agoValve is, by all accounts, a toxic cesspit that's ruled by various influential cabals. They still have a hierarchy, they just aren't explicit about it. At least for Medium, "Holacracy" pretty much imploded. Zsppos switched from it to an internal marketplace - which is, oddly, controlled by excecutives. Flat organizations beyond a certain size either move away from flatness officially, create unacknowledged hierarchy, or fail. I'm really not aware of a single large-scale example that still works. This is much different for small orgs - there's something about org size that requires some sort of centralization. (I think it's communications overhead + complexity exceeding the limit of what a single person can keep in their mind. I'm not 100% convinced, but these are the pressure points I usually see)
- throwaway5752 7y agoThey are just going to pay their employees less. Companies have to be profitable, temporary exceptions notwithstanding, and the money has to come from somewhere.
- brianr 7y agoAs long as the purchased software is worthwhile (i.e. it makes employees more effective; the company gets more output per employee expense dollar), this trend should actually increase employee pay. Higher output per employee allows a higher salary per employee while still being profitable.
- p_l 7y agoIt also allows to pocket more money instead of paying it to employee. Remember, many people in USA believe that corporation has duty to increase shareholder value. And similar stupid ideas.
- throwaway5752 7y agoNot sure if you are being facetious, but that's in fact the law. The board is a fiduciary of shareholder (investor) money. Is that a great idea for society? Not sure, until it changes we live in the world we live in. And on the productivity point, that makes a good theoretical case but it is just not demonstrated by historical data. In the US, in the past 50 years, it even has a name (the pay-productivity gap or the wage gap). You can look at productivity vs wages since 1970 and see how they have not correlated. Further, you can go into income and wealth inquality growth over the same time (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_inequality_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_inequality_in_the_Unite...) and see how the wealth generated by the productivity gains has been highly concentrated in the top 0.1% and 0.01% wealthiest. Some people will talk about real or nominal wages (adjustments with something called the Implicit Price Deflator) that show wages purchasing power increasing, but I think one can look at costs of home, college, and medical care and other critical things in social mobility that have increased in cost far exceeding inflation as complications to that idea.
- mc32 7y agoQuestion is how much would it cost to host in-house, taking all costs into consideration (personnel, regulatory, etc)
- jariel 7y ago"spending another $10K to make them even 10% more productive is a bargain." $200K is not a good benchmark for what companies spend. Median salary in the US is about $50K [1] Average overhead per/employee is 18-26% [2] So a $10K spend for 10% increase in productivity on someone earning about $60K ... is not a bargain. But there's a problem with this, because SaaS can be 1) Individual productivity 2) Operational productivity 3) Product spending (i.e. like GMaps integration as a feature in your product) So 1/2 and 3 represent a very different type of calculus to the point wherein that kind of spending should definitely fall into different buckets for accounting. [1] https://www.thebalancecareers.com/average-salary-information-for-us-workers-2060808 https://www.thebalancecareers.com/average-salary-information... [2] https://beebole.com/blog/how-to-calculate-the-real-cost-of-an-employee/ https://beebole.com/blog/how-to-calculate-the-real-cost-of-a...
- briandear 7y agoIt isn't about what the spend per employee, but about the revenue earned per employee. > Median salary in the US is about $50K The median company isn't necessarily spending $10k per employee for software.
- amylene 7y agoThere is also opportunity cost - what could the employee have worked on that would have made you more money?
- maerF0x0 7y agoSaaS also comes with - Process mismatch / impedance : The software is unlikely to be able to do exactly what you want how you want. The human likely is able - Vendor lock in: If the SaaS decides to change how it works, or the prices you now have a leaving cost - Expenditure on someone else's competitive advantage: If you use tool X likely there is no reason your competitor cannot. You both use it, no net advantage gained over competitor. If you develop the expertise in house (likely the harder thing) then you have an advantage over your competitor. Of course this has to be balanced with what will be your competitive advantage and what will not - Harder to manipulate: You cannot fire 1 of your SaaS and tell the other 2 to do the work
- 7y ago
- 76543210 7y agoMy bigger concerns is that it creates dependency, prices go up, and you either deal with it, or you change systems which is hugely costly. FOSS as much as possible.
- vkou 7y agoFOSS is free if your time is worthless. There's plenty of situations in business where using it is an incredibly good idea. There's even more situations where you're better off just paying for a service.
- zozbot234 7y agoYou can pay for third-party support based on FOSS, and you'll still avoid being locked in to a single supplier.
- whatsmyusername 7y agoI'm indifferent on the supplier lock-in. Mainly because our biggest supplier is AWS and they're >%50 of the market.
- vkou 7y ago1. You can, and it makes sense for FOSS projects with real support ecosystems, like RedHat, or for freemium FOSS projects, that explicitly sell support. 2. You can still be locked into a single-supplier when you pay for third-party FOSS support. In fact, most third-party FOSS support comes from a single supplier. 3. FOSS that doesn't have a sustainable business model attached to it rarely serves the needs of enterprises. There's FOSS alternatives to Sharepoint, but what's your FOSS alternative to Tableau? Salesforce? Slack? Will you actually save money by using it, compared to just paying a vendor?
- zozbot234 7y ago> There's FOSS alternatives to Sharepoint, but what's your FOSS alternative to Tableau? Salesforce? Slack? From a purely technical POV, I'm pretty sure that feasible alternatives exist to all of these, e.g. I don't think Tableau's data viz product does anything that couldn't also be done with relative ease in R. Of course, these commercial offerings extend way beyond the purely technical domain where FLOSS makes the most sense; but that has little to do with "sustainable business models" - R itself is plenty sustainable on its own - and a lot to do with extremely niche or obscure "needs of enterprises" that FLOSS projects are either not clearly aware of, or not very interested in supplying. Niche and obscure problem domains have always been problematic for the open source model, this is nothing new.
- jcelerier 7y agohow many 0.0001% of employees does that represent though ? 200k is more than what the average CEO makes (gross) in france (150k€)
- akhilcacharya 7y agoInclude health insurance, retirement match, employer side payroll taxes, equipment, etc. I don’t make nearly that much but I easily cost my company more than that.
- jcelerier 7y ago> Include health insurance, retirement match, employer side payroll taxes, all of these three are included in the gross in france
- jsight 7y agoWhat about the ones that cost thousands to decrease productivity?
- fishnchips 7y agoImmediately made me think of Jira.
- jsight 7y agoThat's funny, I was thinking of all of the things people pay even more for to replace Jira.
- whatsmyusername 7y agoJira's awful except for all the other options :3 It's a lowest common denominator product. Which is fine. I use it for anything I need to share on and Trello for organizing, "in my own head." I won't even look at sharepoint.
- cosmodisk 7y agoAlternatives?
- fishnchips 7y agoDepends on the context, I guess. I'm generally more comfortable with lightweight things - like GitHub projects for software and Trello for everything else.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoi'm sure there's like a bazillion lower cost alternatives.
- mikorym 7y agoI think maybe I misunderstood the headline then. Is the expectation that your employees cost > $200k or is that not qualified? In some companies / countries you spend $10k per employee.
- hinkley 7y agoThe person who convinced me to [pay for a personal license for] Jetbrains instead of torturing myself with Eclipse just passed on the questions that had convinced him to do it: How much does it cost you for Jetbrains? How many technical books is that? Is in worth that many books a year for a decent tool?
- maerF0x0 7y agoYou say with certainty that which is uncertain to the prospective buyer.
- adamc 7y agoBig if.
- TAForObvReasons 7y agoIf your SaaS services more than 10x their prices (which happened to many SaaS like Segment), suddenly $10K/yr -> $100K/yr and the calculus changes
- polskibus 7y agoWhat if you spend $50K per employee?
- snoman 7y agoThis is reductive. If "10% more productive" translated into >= 10% more revenue as a percentage of their wage, it would make sense but it varies so wildly, that it's not a useful statement. Some will translate to increased revenue, a few times over, (which incentivizes the vendor to increase the price accordingly) and some will be net negative.