14 ms·
The Rise of “Movie-Set Urbanism”
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kozakor 7y agoCities are growing. the pace of life is changing
- tapejek 7y agoExisting urbanism makes me stressed. Even a shopping mall visit can bring a lot of negativity. A lot of people and noisy. On the contrary, I want peace, comfort and calm. For me, saving is watching at home with my family a good film about eternal values. I use https://pirateproxy.space/ https://pirateproxy.space/ to find interesting films. It's so good when I can watch a movie in silence and family circle
- olah_1 7y agoI love StrongTowns. They do a great service in bringing many different political dispositions together for common, practical goals of simply better living. Often times, what they advocate for can be championed by Distributists, Libertarians, and Socialists alike. Because usually what divides these camps is mostly questions of scale and not the actual end goals.
- francisofascii 7y agoProbably the best fit are geolibertarians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism
- mc32 7y agoI’m not sure this is totally a rip from Hollywood or a kind of modern Potemkin city. I see this in old districts too. Facade in the front parking in the back. Strip malls are the inverse. With strip malls it looks ugly but you can tell at a glance if there is parking. The older form you don’t know till you drive around the back on a typically one-way street. The modern take is like the Emeryville Bay Street shopping center or Santana Row in SJ/Sta Clara. It’s obviously artificial but people like it. In addition at least Santana Row integrates housing into the mix.
- mattrp 7y agoI agree that Santana Row is particularly well done... but I think the author is reminiscing for something more like downtown Palo Alto. What he misses is a few things: a) Palo Alto can hold onto its old town feel because it’s literally the epicenter of Facebook, google, sand hill road and Stanford university. Some random town in Florida isn’t going to have all that. B) in places like Florida, Phoenix, Las Vegas, Houston, etc, it’s simply not feasible to constrain parking when a good part of the year no one wants to walk a half mile or more to get groceries. There are other ways for places to be nice and not look like an early 1900s town center... I’d submit Austin as an example: it’s totally car centered but has lots of intriguing and distinct neighborhoods and plenty of variety while also being quite suburban and housing quite a lot of strip mall retail. The small downtown can also be very restrictive and expensive for lower income families. For example, in New Jersey, and eastern PA there are quite a few quaint little towns. Oh sure their town centers are full of small restaurants and dog grooming, pharmacies and banks, but conspicuously absent are grocery stores. I know of whole towns with 10-40k residents and not one grocery store. It’s worse in places like Chicago where lack of access to quality fresh produce has been linked to higher rates of crime. These small towns create high rates of NIMBY-ism and while they do retain their turn of the century charm, I would suggest that it’s just as Hollywood as the new urbanism but in different ways. I think we can all agree strip malls probably weren’t the best invention and new urbanism isn’t perfect but at least developers are trying to do something appealing rather than just put up another crappy building with nail salons and vape shops.
- pkroll 7y agoIn Chicago, is the link between crime and lack of access to decent produce one way, or the other? Nobody wants to put grocery stores (or most stores) in high-crime areas.
- bluGill 7y agoHard to say. Most people who I've seen speculate tend to conclude that both are dependent variables and the cause is something else. (generally something along the lines of poor people making bad choices - whatever bad choice means to the group speculating)
- beowulfey 7y agoBeen seeing these kinds of developments pop up a lot lately. The research triangle of NC is getting a lot of these with all their rapid development, and I've seen them around where I live currently. The problem is they are really nothing more than a bandaid. They don't solve infrastructure problems, and they still encourage people to get into their cars (creating traffic) and driving to some place else far from their homes. My point is, I don't see the purpose. They look fake, they feel fake, and I still have to drive there. It's not encouraging walking that much. It feels like a theme park, but at least at Disneyland they still pull the parking way outside the main park.
- claudeganon 7y agoIf you want to see real, “movie-set urbanism” go check out some of the newly gentrified neighborhoods in LA, like Highland Park. It looks like a set designer did a week’s research in Brooklyn and came back with some kind of illness that causes people to open terrible restaurants. By contrast, long standing neighborhoods like the fashion district in downtown LA, Lincoln Heights, Monterey Park, are so vibrant with amazing businesses and food that serve their local communities. It’s night and day.
- lucraft 7y agoThe second example just seems to be a shopping mall without a roof.
- Steltek 7y agoI think he's barking up the wrong tree. The problem isn't "movie set urbanism", it's just boring, old "too much parking". Too much parking creates sparseness which reduces walkability. But putting parking behind stores ("movie sets") creates a human scale street space. While organic urban growth should be cherished, there are extreme cases, like most American towns and cities, where urbanism needs to be forcefully bootstrapped. In this case, we're artificially accelerating the evolution of a neighborhood and skipping over the early rural and suburban forms, going straight to a small urban core. I can see the long term hope of infilling those parking lots with more buildings as the town grows outwards.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoIf you don't have of street parking you get congestion as people park on streets - that is the reason why planners mandate of street parking.
- ch4s3 7y agoI my recommend “The High Cost of Free Parking” by Donald Shoup to get a sense of what planners actually think about street parking.
- vonmoltke 7y agoMy home town in Florida, and the town I just moved out of in New Jersey, think of street parking as a cash cow.
- michaelt 7y agoI've heard of towns that attempt to solve this by marking roads residents-permit-parking-only, then only issuing one parking permit per house. Of course, it's not a perfect solution - you need exceptions for the elderly and infirm who need regular care visits; some sort of guest permit for anyone who hires tradespeople; and people who need a work vehicle have to do without a non-work vehicle, or be forced out. And it's a whole lot more fair if you set the rule before people buy the homes, rather than imposing it later.
- Nasrudith 7y agoReminds me of Facadism as part of the larger pattern of cargo culting trends in development to try to gain the benefits of the "new way" without deeper changes resulting in nothing really different. On the parking issue and related housing shortages I wonder how viable an attempted rail primary based housing development project to a major city would be in the US for NIMBY dodging. Apparently that is fairly common in Japan along with new rail line loops receiving housing developments and subway/train station centered commercial districts. In theory existing neighborhoods would scale up and add public transit as density rises but in practice they complain like hell over any changes. Optimistically successful examples could give a kick in the pants to NIMBYs as their property value drops anyway due to the competition of a new area and they realize commutter trains aren't the devil or a waste of money but reduce road traffic.
- CalRobert 7y agoI think this is the idea behind culdesac (no private cars or parking in development, on light rail, carshare at periphery) but we'll see how that pans out.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoIt wont work this is single young architects work that lead to high rise disasters in the 1970's and 60's
- msla 7y agoNo private cars in the development? OK, that means the housebound can't live there, because people like home health nurses can't be asked to drag equipment and other supplies from the closest parking to wherever the person lives. With many First-World countries looking at aging populations, this is going to limit the appeal of such developments.
- kaybe 7y agoClearly some exemptions will be made as always, we just have to hash out which ones.
- ropiwqefjnpoa 7y agoSo his issue is people needing someplace to park their cars? They arranged the buildings in an aesthetically pleasing way to disguise all the parking, I say bravo.
- oftenwrong 7y agoThey really nailed the angles on those photos.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe very existence of personal transportation in the form of current size vehicles works against "walkability". It is clear one cannot have both.
- sandoooo 7y agoWhy is there no multilevel parking? All that space can't be cheap. Is there zoning laws against it?
- rtkwe 7y agoI've often wondered that, why parking structures aren't considered more as a medium term solution to increasing density while not having to revolutionize public transit. Probably a combination of the cost to build and resistance to having one next to buildings because they're usually pretty ugly if I had to guess.
- bluGill 7y agoBecause roads for all those cars take space as well. In a low density city it isn't a big deal (other than the expense of building all the roads), but as you move up the density levels your roads start to get full. Parking structures are common, and a useful part even the densest cities. They don't solve all the problems though and so are not a solution or even a mitigation.
- jnwatson 7y agoIn many parts of Florida, land is cheap.
- mattlondon 7y agoAgreed - often in London the parking is underground, under the building where people live, rather than huge swathes of car park etc. It wont work for high-rise buildings of course, but for slightly-less-central blocks that are say 4 to 6 floors, each apartment gets a parking space.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>All that space can't be cheap. It is, and it's why dense housing can't compete. Cars are cheap, fuel is cheap, land is cheap. In the short term, other costs, such as harm to walkability, lack of community, pollution, etc are not quantifiable or too far out in the long term to make it a viable business proposition to go with density.
- rayiner 7y ago> Until you deal with the parking problem—which is done by building truly mixed-use places where people can meet their daily needs without hopping in the car—you haven’t created true urbanism. Daily needs means jobs for both you and your spouse, which won’t be in some random subdivision in Florida. It means schools, which don’t appear to be there either. It means the kids’ after school activities, again, missing from this plan. And if you don’t have kids or a spouse, then you should just live in the city anyway. This is an alternative to the sprawling suburban subdivision, not a downtown block. Developers create these “drive to urbanism” layouts (like Reston Town Center in Northern Virginia) because thats what’s workable given the planning constraints of the larger system. This happens in “real cities” too. When I lived in a newly-redeveloped area of downtown DC, we still ended up driving a lot. My work was on the other side of town. The grocery store across the street was an awful, over priced Safeway. My daughter’s school was over in Georgetown, a 30 minute drive away. Driving is unavoidable unless these communities are highly self contained.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ses1984 7y ago>Driving is unavoidable What about public transport?
- dsr_ 7y agoReston has public transport. Most of Florida doesn't. A shiny nickel says that the pictured development has a nod to public transport in the form of a shuttle van that loops around the parking lots and the main street once every hour or so.
- rayiner 7y ago1) The US is not structurally capable of building public transit. For suburban areas like this, light rail is workable. But it costs us as much to build light rail as it costs other countries to build fully underground automated subway systems. 2) These are suburbs, so there is no rhyme or reason to where things might be located. It can literally take hours to do a route that you could do in a car in 30 minutes.
- oftenwrong 7y agoFlorida is almost entirely a place where you need a car to do anything. It is so absurdly spread-out that even driving at high speed on their high speed roads is a remarkably slow way to get anywhere. If people cannot park there, they cannot get there. Even if you built a real urban walkable neighbourhood with housing, stores, schools, offices, churches - a place where people could truly walk to all of their daily needs - the people that lived there would still need multiple cars per family in order to access the outside world. It would be like living on an island. Attempting to leave on foot would be like trying to swim across the ocean. If you don't die of dehydration or exhaustion first, you will probably killed by a shark/car before you get anywhere. Ironically, about 1 in 4 Florida drivers are uninsured. One fake town centre is merely a tiny, amusing symptom of a giant chicken-and-egg problem.
- bluGill 7y agoIf it really was as a walkable neighborhood some people could get rid of the car. There would still be a lot of cars but we would have the start of people not having cars. Walkable means several possible jobs, a library, courthouse, many retailers at several price points including discount retail where you buy your daily groceries and clothing.
- chapium 7y agoThis is where the false urbanism comes in. Chicago for examples is in many ways a network of these islands. However they collide with each other giving a nice network effect. Its far from a perfect example, I feel its still rather sparse in design as to accommodate cars but there is less parking in general. This plot as a designed urban center is very much like one of these islands but without adjacent neighborhoods to fill in any local gaps.
- papito 7y agoYou start somewhere. If you have multiple dwelling buildings, there will be more people per square mile. Then local business come in. People from the outside may not be accommodated in terms of parking, but at least people who live in the neighborhood don't have to fire up the car to get some milk. It's not that different from a neighborhood in, say, Queens.
- aga98mtl 7y agoWhile not perfect, this type of development is already a step-up above the unwalkable so called "power center". They have great upgrade potential when we'll figure out public transport. The parking lots closest to the walkable public strip can be turned into mixed use buildings. Solving infrastructure and public transit problems is not the job of real estate developers. It is our job as a society. There has to be political consensus on how we want our communities to be planned. The developer will then do what they can with the rules we impose. Unfortunately, the consensus is largely that we love cars. Maybe we should be paying for influential people to spend a month without a car in a walkable european city.
- mattlondon 7y ago> Maybe we should be paying for influential people to spend a month without a car in a walkable european city. It is not just being walkable in European cities - it is also a lot to do with workable public transport. Sure, I could walk the 2 miles from Point A to B, but in a bus/tram/metro/train that will take 5 mins rather than 30 walking it. Even then though it is often only workable right in the center of town where there is a lot of good coverage. Most people will live further out where affordability is more realistic. At least for me about "half-way" out from the center of London, getting to my local grocery store is a 33 minute walk, 27 minute bus (assuming I did not have to wait at the stop at all first), or just an 8 minute drive. Note also that the bus would be a £3.40 return ticket, which is enough for about 2.5-3 litres of petrol. A toyota prius that can do about 3.7l/100KM means that for the price of a bus ticket you could cover about 68KM (~42 miles) or for a tesla 3 that gets 240Wh/mile charging @ £0.24/khw you'd get about 95KM (~59 miles). For the case of this example where it is about a 5 mile round-trip, you'd be looking at 9 or 12 return trips to the grocery store depending on if you took the prius or the tesla, for the cost of a single round-trip on the bus. It is doable without a car, but not easy. You get into a situation where you are trading off trying to carry 20+KG of shopping back on the (crowded) buses vs taking multiple separate trips a week (...and the £3.40 monetary cost + minimum 54 minute travel time cost). And it might be raining (not easy to hold an umbrella when you have 16 carrier bags you are trying to lug). With a car you can easy haul back many 10s of KGs of shopping in one trip, while staying dry, with just 16 minutes spent getting there and back ... and in a car you are guaranteed a seat too :) Personally I did the trade off and found that having a car for day-to-day life is just so much easier (not just for shopping but for all sorts), but obviously I'd never drive into the centre of London (if nothing else, there is nowhere to park) and happily walk + get the tube when in the centre of town. Driving to work just feels 100% alien here :)
- hirundo 7y agoWhen manually driven cars become a rare exception expect these layouts to change again. Instead of vast parking lots somewhat integrated with the destination, cars in surplus to immediate requirements drive themselves to "inconvenient" staging lots or back to their corporate homes. Developments become more dense again.
- Swenrekcah 7y agoThat's probably true, but in the intervening 75 years, cities would do well to build up their public transport.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe only thing that will cause cities to build up public transport is if people start living in more dense quarters. And the only thing that will make people start living in more dense quarters is if the cost of moving people and all the mass associated with their lives increases drastically. Therefore, the only solution is to cause the price of fuel to rise dramatically, or wait for the consequences of fuel use to raise the cost for us. And then once people are living in smaller homes in higher density environments, a city government will be able to propose public transportation that is actually feasible.
- Swenrekcah 7y agoI agree. Also cities and municipalities should charge for road usage.
- Asooka 7y agoI wonder why we don't see more developments with underground parking. Imagine a three-level underground parking space with a small public park on top. Access would be gated to residents of the surrounding buildings. You should still have some above-ground parking for deliveries, friends visiting, etc. but you can have the majority of parking underground.
- jnwatson 7y agoUnderground parking being expensive is the main reason. Still, it is pretty common here in Northern Virginia.
- jnwatson 7y agoThis style is not new. The earliest planned community in Reston VA built 50 years ago [1] uses this approach, except the housing is more integrated. Housing above the shops and immediately adjacent produces the ambiance of a walkable community around a lake. Still, it has to be surrounded by parking lots. There’s just no way around it unless you move all the work and the schools there too. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Anne https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Anne
- ses1984 7y agoOr have like... A bus stop.
- crazygringo 7y agoCorrect it's no vibrant, bustling organic downtown. But it's still a helluva lot better than nothing at all. The suburbs I grew up in? There were a bunch of shitty strip malls, and a single indoor mall with a single food court with zero natural lighting, taken over by teenagers after school because it was literally the only place to congregate besides the parking lot outside the supermarket. There was no local "center" at all for community. This kind of development would have been a huge life upgrade. Yes it's still built around parking -- but if life is already built around cars in suburbia, there's literally no alternative. Without parking, nobody can get there in the first place. This article seems to be dismissing the better because it only wants the perfect. Edit: to people replying this is still terrible or no better than a mall... look at the photos. This has paths to stroll along, a waterfront, trees, outdoor dining/cafes, building facades that aren't horrible to look at the way painted flat concrete is. You can hang out here and it looks nice. I think some people here must just not be aware of how horrible and ugly strip malls and 1970's-era indoor malls can be. This is objectively a gigantic upgrade for some people.
- mc32 7y agoA bit more expensive but they could add a few underground floors for parking. In cold , snowy climates this might even be an advantage. This would waste less surface area to parking lots but would add some cost.
- wingdom 7y agoExcept this particular development is in Florida, where you can't go under ground, and hurricane building codes make building up more complicated and expensive. As a Florida resident, I would love to see more parking garages, so parking takes up less ground surface area.
- dsr_ 7y agoIt appears likely that we are going to have to write off at least half of Florida in the next century, so any building at all seems counterproductive compared to finding better places to live.
- kop316 7y agoI wish the author would hit the non-walkability a bit harder. To get from one section to another, cross a street. To get from one side to another, you have to cross several streets. There is one area that did the same thing where I live (The Greene Town Center). I cannot simply think of why I would want to live there, and I was their target demographic! I really can't walk around inside of The Greene without having to watch traffic (I am simply amazed at how recklessly folks drive in there). If you look at both the Greene and that picture, the roads are pervasive in there. The suburban neighborhood I live in is actually more walkable! I can walk through a park to get to the library, I have to cross a single one lane road to get to a Kroger, and I can walk within the neighborhood on the street with almost no concern for traffic (heck, it has better sidewalks then the Greene!) If you really want to attract people to live there, make the place actually an area where you only need a car to drive to/from work (and try to bring jobs to there!). Bring Grocery Stores, Schools, a community center, local restaurants to the area. Have a park! Make it so I can walk/cycle to places surrounding the area. Shove parking/cars out of the way. Heck, even downtowns have the same issue. The downtown in Dayton only has Second Street Market that could pass as a grocery store (don't get me wrong, that place is awesome, but it's only open Fri-Sun). I thought about living downtown, but once again, I have to drive to get anywhere anyways. I have no incentive to live downtown.
- atombender 7y agoYou should check out the rest of the blog. The authors focus on walkability a lot.
- leviathant 7y agoI first encountered this kind of shopping center in the suburbs of Philadelphia. Main Street at Exton struck me as incredibly strange - it's a strip mall dressed up to look like an urban downtown, right down to parallel parking spots on the street. Once you do park, it is actually fairly walkable. A couple of years later, after having moved to Philadelphia, there was something I wanted to grab at a store in Main Street at Exton. There's a regional rail station a half mile from the shopping center, so I hopped a train. The absurd thing about this particular arrangement, which otherwise sounds like a great way to connect nearby markets, is that there is no sidewalk between the train station and the shopping center. The station sits where a major local road meets a major highway, so one way or another, you're crossing six lanes of traffic to get past the local road, and you have to cross two major highway four-lane on/off ramps as you go under the highway overpass, walking along a beaten grass path with only a curb between you and the traffic. Exton Mall's another mile up the road, and while there's sporadic sidewalks between the two malls, I've never bothered with that walk. Given the proximity of this shopping center to public transit, I don't think it's a big leap to suggest that the decision to exclude sidewalks was at best a classist choice, at worst a racist choice. I live in a part of Philadelphia that's unusually pedestrian friendly, all things considered. I can walk to pick up groceries (except I get those delivered), the hardware store, coffee shops, restaurants, galleries, all manner of everyday things that, when I lived in the exurbs, I had to hop in the car and drive anywhere from 5-30 minutes to get to, and it's fantastic. We've also got more methods of public transit than almost anywhere in the world (not saying the coverage is great, mind you), and I've been here long enough that despite all the challenges that come with living in an old urban center, I hope I never have to go back to a suburban lifestyle. It was clear from the moment I pulled up to "Main Street" that these psuedo-downtowns miss the point.
- werber 7y agoThis makes me think of a lot of development projects in Detroit. They are promised to be these new urban multipurpose spaces and we don't even end up with the facade. Just tons of parking lots where there were supposed to be life.
- chasd00 7y agothese are popping up in the DFW suburbs where they can be built from scratch. The standard setup is retail at street level with apartments on top and parking underground or at least concentrated in one large garage. They're not completely car free in the center of the development but it doesn't make sense to drive on the interior, there's no point. I think the streets on the inside are there mostly for fire/emergency access. It's ok I guess, the developments are like walking around an amusement park but it's retail instead of games and rides. Another setup I see in the exurbs are planned communities. You basically take everything a neighborhood needs and build a wall around it. My sister lives in one on a lake, it's pretty neat, everyone drives golf-carts around instead of cars which is funny/interesting. Also, they have their own holiday festivals and events so the community is pretty close knit. My sister's kids know all the other neighborhood kids and all the parents know each other. The parents keep an eye out and so the kids are given a lot of freedom to roam and do kid stuff they wouldn't normally be able to do in the standard suburban neighborhood with heavy and fast traffic everywhere.
- ghaff 7y agoYou can have largely pedestrianized areas in the interior with these sorts of things but, in general, you need to provide parking because a lot of people are going to need/want to use a car to get to them even if they're on some sort of transit route. They also tend to work better in moderate climates. One example of something along these lines in the Bay Area is Santana Row. Very clearly artificial but still relatively pleasant.
- gowld 7y agoPeople with jobs and families like these neighborhoods because they provide a walkable downtown main street with access to jobs. Strongtowns is becoming Jacobin like in its militancy against compromises that serve real people in the real world.
- crmrc114 7y agoIts almost as if we built a building... then put all the stores inside of it. People could walk around without concern for the weather or cars. Hell we could surround it with parking even! -Pre-2000's Mall designers Screw the building lets just cram the stores up close to each other in an outdoor square with trees and surround it with, parking. -Post 2010 Mall designers
- logfromblammo 7y agoThis sort of development is crying out for a big parking garage near the highway, and an automated train to shuttle people between the parking structure and the walkable/bicyclable city core. That, along with commercial-under and residential-over vertical zoning, is the bridge we need between traditional suburban sprawl and walkable cities. You can't walk around if you can't get there, and you won't want to stay if you can't leave.
- Bootwizard 7y agoI live in a place exactly like this in Florida called Baldwin Park. It's much better designed and I love living here. The main difference is a few things (and these really matter to me): 1. All the parking is parallel parking along all the streets. This ensures that the number of businesses don't need their own massive ugly parking lots 2. There are actually apartments here above the businesses, so that it's always active, the people that live here keep the businesses below in business. We have everything from lawyers to gyms to dentists right below my feet in a single square mile. 3. This is actually a community. We have multiple community events and I can just show up and be there. We have a big shopping day every first Friday of the month where local merchants will set up tents and sell their stuff. They also do some event for nearly every holiday. 4. The entire town center is walkable. A square mile of walkable businesses, a park, a pool, etc.
- gshdg 7y agoThe key difference in what you describe is that there are apartments above the businesses. Mixing residential and commercial in a walkable way is what makes a real community. The shopping center described in the article is nothing like that.
- kop316 7y agoIs it in Orlando? If so, that actually looks like a pretty nice area! Judging by what I saw on the map, that would be a nice place to live. If one looks at the map, you see multiple parks surrounding the area, an elementary and middle school that appears to be walkable, a sizeable grocery store, and a lake to walk around. While it looks to have a lot of streets still throughout, it looks to be much more than just an outdoor mall.
- Bootwizard 7y agoYeah it is in Orlando :) It's a great place to live, tons of parks around, literally everything I need within walking or biking distance. We even have a 30 mile bike trail that starts from here. I was just using my area as an example of how this model can work if designed well.
- djmobley 7y agoI’m bullish on autonomous electric vehicles making these kind of neighborhoods perfectly sustainable and, for many people, preferable to higher density walkable neighborhoods.
- turc1656 7y agoThe main issue he cites seem to be parking taking up so much space. Wouldn't a parking deck solve this? Build a 6 story garage and the 18% goes to 3%.
- rjkennedy98 7y agoParking garages are enormously expensive. They can cost up to 50k per space. For instance the parking garage at the Chinese theater cost as much as the theater itself
- turc1656 7y agoWow, really? Did not know or expect that. Not intuitive that they should be that expensive. In my mind they are just giant blocks of shaped concrete and should be extraordinarily simple to put together compared to something like a mall. What makes them so expensive?
- lotsofpulp 7y agohttps://watrydesign.com/insights/top-10-issues-affecting-cost-of-building-a-parking-space https://watrydesign.com/insights/top-10-issues-affecting-cos...
- lnanek2 7y agoHe complains it is all parking, but there's solutions to that. Here in Santa Monica there's a whole row of public parking buildings a few blocks from all the popular downtown areas (beach, pier, 3rd street promenade, mall, etc.). So if you shell out the money, you can compress the parking into one block along the otherwise active walkable downtown area. In this case the developer must have just calculated it's cheaper to have parking lots. As someone who grew up in Manhattan, though, I do kind of laugh that he considers that development plan non-walkable. I was always happy to walk across the island east/west and only took subways north/south, so his impossible to walk to shopping center part of the development looks trivially walkable to my Manhattan self...
- atombender 7y ago"Walkable" doesn't mean you can't walk (although it sometimes means that, too, of course). By most measurements, walkability refers to a pedestrian's ability to reach amenities such as grocery stores within a short time (e.g. 5 minutes). By that metric, almost all of Manhattan is extremely walkable. Manhattan does have many isolated "deserts" where you can find yourself surrounded by just residential buildings (parts of UWS and UES, for example), or a heavy concentration of businesses, parking, industry (e.g. 11th-12th Ave around Hudson Yards, for example). Until a decade ago or so, the Finance District used to be pretty dead at night. And so on. There's fairly low "pain threshold" in the US before people discard walking as an alternative and just go in their car. We all know the satiric image of the American who jumps in their car to go one block; in my experience (as a European living in the US), there's a certain amount of cultural indoctrination that has persuaded Americans that transportation by car is absolutely necessary.
- bluGill 7y agoIf 99% of your trips cannot be reasonably made by walking you don't think to walk for that last 1% either
- saikit 7y agoAmerican Village in Okinawa is exactly like this. Outside of Naha, getting around Okinawa strangely feels like an American suburb.
- CapricornNoble 7y agoI blame Okinawa's abysmal public transit situation on: 1. The US administering the island until 1972, while Japan itself was undergoing very effective reconstruction and public works projects post-war. 2. The mainland Japanese government treating the Okinawans almost like unwanted red-headed step-children. And yes, the southern third of the island has the building and traffic density of an urban area with the inconvenience of American suburbs. Almost the entire population has at least a kei car, unless you work in a snack bar/kabakura (where transportation is often provided, and your job involves getting shit-faced drunk every night so you can't drive home anyway). American Village is also my least-favorite place to go on the island: the traffic to get into that area is abysmal, especially after 4pm, and during the summer the brutal heat, sunlight, and humidity makes walking around between the buildings unappealing. Ashibina Outlet Mall is similar, but at least has slightly better overhead cover to protect from the sun.
- saikit 7y agoI guess they resolved the heating issue with an even more American institution. Stepping into Aeon Mall Rycom is a like a localized version of my youth in New Jersey.
- buckminster 7y ago> these places tend not to hold their value over time, and to feel very dated after a couple decades. Is anybody building property near the coast of Florida hoping for more than a couple of decades of value? Sea levels are rising.
- geebee 7y agoSounds like we may be experiencing the revival of the folly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folly I suppose extreme income inequality, along with deteriorating urban conditions that plague public spaces, could actually push society toward a folly based, key-card access future.
- Animats 7y agoThe trouble with "mixed-use development" is that an apartment building does not generate enough business for its ground floor shops. Which is why many of them are vacant. Or turned into low-value places like nail salons.
- bluGill 7y agoVery true. I estimate you need 15-20 floors above ground floor shopping to fill all the spaces. This based on observations that in Paris (4-5 stories) there is a block of ground floor shopping and then 3-5 without. Since I'm not an expert on Paris (never been there only seen picture and read reports) take that with some salt... Also most apartment developers don't know how to rent commercial spaces. So some ground floor spaces are vacant because it was only put in to allow the apartments above and so it isn't actually possible to get a commercial lease. (commercial leases allow a lot of remodeling and have other terms different from the standard residential lease, so anyone looking that a commercial lease will refuse the space)
- Animats 7y agoIt's definitely a problem with the "mixed use" buildings going up on the SF peninsula. The ground floor stores are marginal, vacant, or used as office space. A 5-story building can't support a convenience store by itself. There have been startups which tried convenience stores that were giant vending machines, but that hasn't been successful. Amazon Go didn't really work out; there are a few stores, but no major deployment. There's a startup in China which puts automated stores in a shipping container sized box, but that hasn't been successful in the US.
- jarjoura 7y agoI'm confused. Every suburban city in California has the "main downtown" area facade with vast parking lots behind it. This design has been around for almost a century and works in lower density areas. Do we all want sophisticated public transit? Sure! However, let's be realistic. Where would the public transit take you? How many residents would you need to make it sustainable? Another thing, does the OP want NYC/SF building density in Florida? You could cram 10k people into a .5 mile area, sure. Then you would have HUGE under developed areas all around and no where for 10k people to go explore. Then there wouldn't even need to be public transit.
- Balanceinfinity 7y agoThe origin of the mixed use movement (and the rebirth of cities) is The Death and Life of Great American Cities (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Death_and_Life_of_Great_American_Cities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Death_and_Life_of_Great_Am...). The upshot is that mixed use is the holy grail. Here, I can't tell is residential mixed in with commercial - that's how you get people out of cars. It says mixed use - does that means there's commercial and residential in the same space? In my mind that's what makes for a city.
- at-fates-hands 7y agoThis has been going on a for a long time now. I remember working as an installer for a high end AV company in the early 2000's. We installed pricey home theaters and distributed audio for the rich suburban folks. I remember several "planned communities" where they had small strip malls on the outside of the community, and then it was all high end craftsman and cape cod style houses on the interior. They had removed as many streets into the main center of the community as possible. In order to get to two of the houses we were working on, we had to park several hundred yards away and walk in to the houses. Sure, it was awesome for the kids as they could go about their business without fear of high speed traffic, but it was a royal pain to heft in all the wiring boxes, tools and other stuff we needed to do our job. I also noticed, all the houses were reduced to two car garages. When I started talking to one of the owners, he gave me a litany of things they had to agree to before being able to build their homes. The strict building codes forbid three level houses, more than a two car garage, and each lot had to leave a strict percentage of "green" space - aka grass on each lot, and you were required to have a porch (you know, to encourage "community" and bonding with your neighbors) which also had a bunch of requirements you had to meet. There were other ones, but those were the ones which always stood out to me. In short, they were trying to create some kind of a movie like community in every sense.
- reggieband 7y agoOne thing I dislike about this new trend is it supplants true community spaces. There is a downtown in the suburb I live in now but it is a place no one other than junkies and homeless go. A few business cling to life there but I don't know how since there is no foot traffic. Some development company created one of these outdoor malls about 10 minutes outside of the downtown. It has a cinema, a few big box stores (including a Walmart super-center). They even got it right with mostly underground parking giving the outdoor mall a high-level of walkability between stores that have fronts directly on the wide side walks. The security keeps all of the undesirables away and there is a public playground for kids. It's like the commercial equivalent of a gated community. I find it unsettling and I wish we took public money to revitalize the downtown rather than creating these segregated spaces.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- seltzered_ 7y agoDrew Austin (aka kneeling bus) talks about a similar perspective in “The city as weakly-escaped reality (revisiting the holey plane): https://youtu.be/9HL2bh_EMyk https://youtu.be/9HL2bh_EMyk I don’t think the principle of hiding parking is necessarily bad though. Cohousing designs for this way to facilitate more interaction with neighbors. It’s just one aspect though among others (consensus management, etc.)
- rospaya 7y agoI thought that it was a ripoff of the town from the Truman Show.
- petsormeat 7y agoThe most surreal of these developments that I've visited is the Town Square of Copperopolis, California.[1] It's not visually unappealing, but is a rather odd addendum to a historic 19th c. town which apparently won't suffice for tourists or affluent retirees (not enough parking). It's just as managed and tidy as the developments discussed here. Speakers on light poles blare top 40 hits from the 1950s, for some reason. [1] https://www.gocalaveras.com/location/california/gold-country/copperopolis-california/ https://www.gocalaveras.com/location/california/gold-country...
- narrator 7y agoThe structure of America being car dependent is that the "youths" who mayor Bloomberg recently commented commit 95% of murders don't have cars or gas money to get there. The car dependent lifestyle is to create areas where undesirable elements are excluded. In many areas "youths" gather in shopping malls and so forth and generate a lot of petty crime, vandalism, shoplifting, playing loud music and generally making everyone uncomfortable. Dead malls and downtowns have declined because of excessive presence of "youths". For example, Halloween in San Francisco's Castro got cancelled permanently because "youths" showed up and started shooting at each other. If you make it hard to get places, these "youths" tend to not show up and keep everything nice, peaceful and upscale. Without the "youths" problem, America would have a far lower homicide rate and public transit, bikes, walkable neighborhoods, free public festivals and all that stuff would be far more popular.
- superduperuser 7y agoWoah
- achenatx 7y agoWe have a couple of developments in austin the "domain" which is an outdoor mall integrated with tons of apartments and a ton of actual jobs. The entertainment district serves those who live there, but is probably good enough to attract people from north austin who dont want to go downtown. It is disappointing to see classic strip malls continuing to be built in the suburbs with massive parking lots, when this dense form of living works so well. https://www.google.com/maps/place/The+Domain/@30.4006016,-97.7273151,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x8644cc71ec3d3b05:0x77c4a76c643f0420!8m2!3d30.4006016!4d-97.7251211 https://www.google.com/maps/place/The+Domain/@30.4006016,-97... There is another development "mueller" which took the old airport and turned it into a neighborhood. It is much less commercial but the parks make it amazing. There are a ton of amenities, but the amenities are car centric. There are some jobs, but not quite enough. As a kid with a bike though there are multiple pools, movie theater, ice cream shop, pizza within biking distance. The small backyards means that everyone gathers at the park to play. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mueller,+Austin,+TX/@30.2984571,-97.7095403,15z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x8644b5fe5b3bfc47:0x78dc0a5de60a06d6!8m2!3d30.2986834!4d-97.700371 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mueller,+Austin,+TX/@30.29... Both of the developments are heavily influencing the areas around them Austin is trying to fix old neighborhoods with an updated land development code. The NIMBYS are out in force - they absolutely love the neighborhood character of their car dependent semi suburbs. I live in "northwest hills" which was developed in the 60s-80s. The developer didnt do a bad job (lots of multi family, missing middle, and SFH), but all the commercial is heavily on one side down a steep hill, which means most of the SFH people are physically separated from the multifamily/commercial area. That means huge parking lots and everyone driving. The commercial should have been pushed more into the SFH area. The city is trying to increase density via zoning and the neighborhood is going crazy. There should be commercial along mesa between far west and spicewood springs rd. The city is upzoning it to 4 plexes which is a step in the right direction. https://www.google.com/maps/@30.3499372,-97.7681162,15z https://www.google.com/maps/@30.3499372,-97.7681162,15z