20 ms·
Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study
- raindropm 7y agoand here I am, at my newly renovate office with gasp open plan. We have some cliché things like table tennis desk, rock climbing space(that no one have a time to climb, of course) and garden plot with fresh vegetable(just for show off at new office opening day), that HR staff told us that employee can plant their own after that(good luck with that) Everything about it screams pretentious and dumb. What's better, we have a meeting room that decorate like a kitchen, with no door and the wall that is not rise to the ceiling, if you know what I mean. The noise level comes from that 'meeting room' is just unbearable. The worst meeting room design I've seen in my life. The only thing I can do is put on my trusty noise-cancelling headphones, thanks god for this miraculous technology in this noisy world.
- slumdev 7y ago> The only thing I can do is put on my trusty noise-cancelling headphones That's not literally the only thing you could do. You could quit. I'll never again make the mistake of hiring on somewhere without first seeing the working environment. Too many times...
- raindropm 7y ago> That's not literally the only thing you could do. You could quit. Well, that's one big choice to make haha.
- erikbye 7y ago> The only thing I can do is put on my trusty noise-cancelling headphones, thanks god for this miraculous technology in this noisy world. Noise-canceling headphones help a lot, but I've tried all the most expensive, top-of-the-line ones, and unless you play some sound (which, no matter what you play, is tiring in the long run) you can still hear people talk, they just remove the lower frequencies.
- venantius 7y agoThis article is from 2018 and gets posted pretty regularly. I happen to agree with its core thesis but I'm not sure we get anything out of having it on the front page again.
- jcriddle4 7y agoUntil companies start to drop open office plans I hope to see articles like this fairly often.
- padraic7a 7y agoMostly I think every posting offers those stuck in open plan offices a chance to vent and to realise that the layout is objectivly awful. Knowing that so many others feel the same way and that the terrible experience isn't due to your own (weak! distracted! worthless!) personality is certainly worth something.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoGood point - I stumbled on the article again and decided to post it. It already has ~20 comments, and it's on the front page. My take is that even if the article is not the best on the topic, the conversation about it is happening. I don't think there's an article out there that I would consider far superior to this. If there is, please post it, I'd upvote it in a heartbeat. Context: I mostly work remote (a combination of luck, laziness, and my ability to ask for things I really want), but every time I have to be in the office (like today, leaving home in ~30 minutes), I have a weird, unpleasant feeling. I know I don't like open floor plans. I particularly don't like that people walking behind me can see my monitor. I don't like that I can't take calls without disturbing others. Or that getting a private room to talk or make a video call is difficult. Yesterday, for example, I had to leave a room where I was having a call because someone else had booked it, but I needed to extend the call by another ~15 minutes, so I ended up finishing it in the corridors next to the restrooms. And mind you, I work with (not for) a great firm, people are super nice - but nobody seems to fully understand how toxic an open office space can be for people. Finally, I also don't like that startups trying to partially solving these problems are getting funded like crazy, based on a relatively crappy product [0] and an expensive price tag. [0]: https://room.com/ https://room.com/
- rrauenza 7y agoIsn't increasing workspace density the real reason this is done with collaboration just used as the public rationale?
- DevKoala 7y agoI am convinced too.
- Mikeb85 7y agoPretty much. Real estate is expensive.
- montagg 7y agoI’d be really curious how much of a hit to people’s salary they would be willing to take, or the reduced capabilities of their business, to get an open office environment. I worked with an internal team that created a brand new office for a decently-sized tech company. We had this exact debate: open or closed. We explored closed, or versions of it (see Spotify’s team rooms as a great example of a compromise), but the end result was the same: if we expected to grow substantially and expand our business a lot, real estate would be the biggest bottleneck. We’d literally have to pay people less and deliver slower if we wanted to make that trade off, and all the companies we talk to who had gone with some form of closed office had shifted to open over time because the costs were huge. We did the next best thing, because we definitely heard the concerns of people that getting work done at work really was harder than it should be: we created as much private space for 1-2 people as possible that lots of people could use, so you got to decide whether you were in at your desk mode or heads down mode. Several years later, this seems to work all right. There’s still a desire to work from home occasionally, and my teams are pretty understanding about that. Even with the open office plan, though, we still have to rent virtually every open space around us.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI'd easily take a 10% paycut to get a cubicle again. (Whether 10% actually covers the extra costs, I don't know.)
- monkeynotes 7y agoI am not sure why employees would message and email more if they can just turn their chair around to chat about something they are working on. Does anyone have experience of this? I have worked in open plan offices since 1999 and I've never experienced productivity problems. If anything I'd expect working in a cube would lead to more time wasted cruising websites since your screen is more obscured. I dunno, I've only worked in cubes a handful of times.
- rgblambda 7y agoI've never really worked in a cubicle (once had a mid tower PC and dual monitors acting as partitions to the front and left) but wouldn't an advantage of an open plan office over a cubicle be that you can see your manager walking towards you from a mile off and be able to quickly look like you're working.
- t-writescode 7y agoThese issues sound a lot like managers not trusting employees to get work done, which sounds like a bigger issue.
- LeSaucy 7y agoNot to mention that as knowledge workers, a lot of the value+ideas you provide come from reading and research that is not explicitly work related. I encourage my team to spend time doing non-related research and work/tinker on finding new things they are interested in, and to not feel guilty if I walk by and they have reddit or hn open/visible. That being said, working in an open office is like being stuck in a plane of purgatory.
- lxcfan 7y agoThis, but, for both sides. Managers should trust their employees to get stuff done, and not micromanage their time. Employees should get stuff done whether their managers are watching their every move or not, and, trust their managers to not be micromanaging their time. We both need to create a trustworthy relationship. I have no sympathy for employees who do not do work without being forced to any more than I do for bosses who want to micromanage every minute of employee time or every website they visit. You're both hurting all of us.
- techntoke 7y agoYou don't like having 100 distractions to help you work better?
- tannerc 7y agoNot every solution will solve every problem for every person. Some people thrive in open environments, some don’t. Some people need accidental encounters to propel innovative change, some don’t. To say these types of cultures are “dumb” (or even the opposite) is akin saying “peanut butter is the worst possible thing you could ever eat!” just because you’re allergic to it.
- influx 7y agoMy hypothesis is that this style of office is detrimental to most software engineers. Not sure how to prove that though!
- vikramkr 7y agoA randomized controlled trial with some clear prospectively defined measure of detriment would be how to prove that. Actually running a trial like that is going to be logistically near impossible though.
- rcthompson 7y agoThe OP's point is that open plan offices don't even encourage things they claim to encourage, like those "accidental encounters" that may be helpful for some people. In an open-plan office, everyone ends up avoiding in-person interaction because of how distracting it can be to those around them.
- tannerc 7y agoA research paper with n = 2 (companies) isn't exactly representative. Anecdotally, I've seen the complete opposite (where in-person interactions happen far more because of the open floor plan) at three large companies. So the point stands: open floor plans will not produce positive results for every organization, that's to be expected.
- agentultra 7y agoMore than Agile? Snark aside, I have a personal office and I love it. I don't like to listen to constant noise/music to cancel out the other noise/music. I like being able to have private calls without all of the noise in the background. If I'm working on something particularly difficult I like closing my door and having peace and quiet. I also enjoy the sense of ownership and prestige. It's nice feeling like I matter and my space and attention are worth something. Working in an open office is too chaotic for me. Being around people is exhausting and distracting. I like to have a space I can retreat to for a few hours and get some deep work done. Silence is usually what I appreciate the most.
- ryandrake 7y agoJust to get the alternate view out there too: I had an office once with a door that closed. As an extrovert it was awful. I felt lonely all day. The only way to get any human contact besides email and text was to leave and go walk the halls or find some common area. I ended up pretty much never using it and instead worked from the break room. From time to time they’d give me an officemate to share the office, but they were all extroverts too, so of course were never around. Different strokes for different folks. I love open offices and wouldn’t go back to closed ones if given the choice. I also have difficulty WFH for the same reasons. More employers should offer more choices, as everyone is different and what suits one worker might be awful for another.
- bluGill 7y agoIf you have an office environment you should NEVER have an open office policy. The extroverts who like interaction/interruptions won't be in their office in the first place, while those who hate it need their door closed.
- amluto 7y agoAt one point I had an office that I shared with a couple other people. I had shelves, blackboards, and a couple people to talk to. Outside the office was common space. It was great! Downside: the arrangement was likely quite expensive.
- 7y ago
- WWLink 7y agoThe only way to make an open office tolerable is to give its inhabitants a lot of space. You can resist the temptation to cram people in by giving them really big desks. My comfort level is, if I can smell my coworkers, then we're sitting too close.
- jackfoxy 7y ago35+ years in the IT workforce here. Yep, dumbest idea ever. The vast majority of my office time was in cubicles, which are pretty good. Usually enough privacy to get things done. I did have a glassed-in private office for about a year at one company. That was productivity heaven. In retrospect I was dumb to leave that company when I did, but they started demolishing offices for cubicles about 2 years later. It is all about efficient use of real estate. I've been at a millennial run company for the last 6 years, first 4 in open space. What a productivity fuck, for all the often repeated reasons. And I really consider them de-humanizing. I gave up on trying to explain this to management years ago. Working from home the last 2 years. Whenever I do visit the home office nothing gets done. Looking at what my colleagues do, I think they only ever get much done on work form home days.
- generalpass 7y ago> It is all about efficient use of real estate. In many cases the Federal tax code can also be the driver of these decisions because the amortization on building upgrades is way longer than cubicles. However, tables over cubicles is likely something else. To me, it's just cheap, like how call centers used to be (even they have cubicles now).
- dehrmann 7y ago> The vast majority of my office time was in cubicles, which are pretty good. I remember watching "Office Space" circa 2000 and it looked pretty soul crushing, and working in pre-FAANG big tech around 2006, it felt very mechanical and depressing. I get your gripes, but I think some is also rosy retrospection.
- moron4hire 7y agoI understand what you're saying, but it's really more that we didn't know just how bad it could get. Cubicle farms were "soul crushing", because they came about from the same management practices that eventually led to open-floor plans: treating people as cost centers rather than people, micromanaging measurable real-estate costs at the expense of unmeasurable productivity. And while one can theoretically make good software in open-floor-plan-environment/current-whipping-boy-programming-language-of-the-month/etc., the existence of such things is a big sign on the door "we probably don't care about craft".
- CivBase 7y ago> They start using email and messaging with much greater frequency than before. Couldn't the same focus that drove the open-office transition also be responsible for driving more effective communication tools? Or just more collaboration in general, which naturally results in an increased use in communications tools? Or maybe the tools have just been improving over time, which results in an entirely unrelated increase in use? There are so many potential explanations here. This seems like a non-point.
- pidg 7y agoThe author of the article (and, presumably, most businesses) are living in the past. I work in an open-plan office in a place that makes heavy use of the latest collaboration software, and it works great. There is virtually no use of email or IM internally. Just persistent chat and collaboration with Teams.
- achow 7y ago> The Harvard study, by contrast, undercuts the entire premise that justifies the fad. And that leaves companies with only one justification for moving to an open plan office: less floor space, and therefore a lower rent. From beginning this was the reason - because when planning for the office the cost difference between open/close office would show up in the Excel files - loss of productivity no Excel or Project Mgmt software can capture (it is hand-wavy stuff for CFO office). Apart from rent, the cost of HVAC (heating, cooling) is drastically reduced - installation, operation and maintenance - open office has more efficient distribution due to no obstructing walls, lesser duct outlets - in closed office plan, each office needs to have at least one outlet, most of the time more than one. Then ofcourse saving on drywalls, doors, locks, etc.
- whatsmyusername 7y agoYep, and I've used those arguments to justify working from home permanently before. Last time I just found out when the bean counters were coming around and worked from home the days they were in the office. When the plan came out and they hadn't figure out a slot for me I just told them I work from home and started doing it full time. Problem solved. Caveat: It helped we were an acquisition. Roles and norms were very in flux. I'd done work in other areas to pass off all my onsite responsibilities to the purchaser.
- swishbroom 7y agoCost saving measure.
- abawany 7y agoI was reading "Bloomberg by Bloomberg" over the weekend and I thought his opinion on the topic was relevant since I believe Bloomberg was one of the first major workplaces that placed everyone in tight open-office type environments. My understanding of his opinion on the topic was: yes there are distractions but you also learn new things. Fundamentally I think there is considerable misunderstanding between people who subscribe to the above view and people (like me) who see considerable personal performance improvements when allowed to work distraction-free. It is not clear to me that "concentration spaces" and etc. are a solution/concession since IME most of the time they are filled with people on phone meetings; even if you find an empty one, you will still hear the people next to you due to the thin walls and the necessary loudness. Edit: the relevant part in the book was at page 163 for my edition in the chapter "Management 101".
- mumblemumble 7y ago> yes there are distractions but you also learn new things I've found that, in open plan offices, attempting to mentor or be mentored on something is a great way to earn dirty looks from anyone who's unfortunate enough to be sitting nearby. If you do it often, people will start griping about you behind your back. Mini meeting rooms can work, when you can find them, for about a year. After that, the company will respond to complaints that people will hang out in them for hours on end (which I could swear was the point, but I digress) by requiring them to be reserved ahead of time in Outlook. Which puts the brakes on using them for genuine collaboration, because reserving meeting rooms in Outlook is a minor hassle, especially if you're a Linux or Mac user, and it's ultimately easier and less demoralizing to just not talk to each other than it is to play a game of, "Mother may I," whenever you want to have an impromptu discussion.
- beart 7y agoThe reason you can't hang out in them is because there are never enough rooms... which is really the root of the problem.
- mumblemumble 7y ago
- cormacrelf 7y agoLoving the video at the bottom where they exhibit one of those people whose careers are tied to the success of their new open office layout. Very chef's kiss.
- british_india 7y agoLaying the groundwork for the attack on Bloomberg
- jodrellblank 7y agoWhat happened to Joel Spolsky’s blog-famous push for private offices in Fog Creek Software, when he moved to StackExchange did they carry that idea on? If open plan offices are so bad for “productivity”, why don’t they get selected out by market forces? Is it Price’s Law, the square root of the number of employees do half the work, and the rest doesn’t matter if they have offices or cattle desks, high or low productivity - what most of us do doesn’t matter enough to matter?
- epicureanideal 7y agoI think bad productivity office plans don't get selected out by market forces because almost everyone is doing it. And the small number of companies not doing it are still competing with a much larger number of companies in a situation where luck is a big part of the outcome. So the effect gets drowned out, I'm thinking.
- bcrosby95 7y agoI've worked in a variety of settings, and my favorite is a small team in a conference room/tiny open office. 3-8 people. People tend to be respectful of each other's concentration at that number of people. And since you're in the same team, most interruptions are likely to be useful to other members of the team. But if we wanted to just bother 1 specific person, we would just use instant message. Our manager worked in the same conference room too. But he would step outside for any calls he had to make. It also gave an exiting "small startup" feel for me, even when working for a large company.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jcims 7y agoSame, best setup for me was quads of corner desks with high exterior walls, making a sort of open room of four that were faced away from each other but within earshot. The cubes had sliding frosted glass windows between quads that you could open to talk to the adjacent team. Also high natural light with moderate ceiling lights and good task lighting on ample desk surface. This was at a premium EDI firm in the 90’s. It was awesome.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoSame here. Team rooms are the best. You can actually collaborate there and still get some sense of privacy. It’s a also a real team builder.
- justbees 7y agoSame! I worked in a setting like that and it was by far the most productive environment I've been in as far as pure work volume and concentration. Basically people were in tiny open offices sorted by teams (i.e. frontend, backend, copywriters). Our group kept the room pretty dark and no one talked, we just messaged each other. I realize that description can sound a little creepy, but it was blissful. Open office-wise the best was getting a desk that was in a corner around a pony wall. So I had a wall (conference room) at my back, a pony wall at my left and a desk facing towards me, which is almost like a wall in front. Also the people I was sitting near could control the lights on our side of the wall. We kept only half on and it was super helpful. I think bright fluorescent lighting is a little distracting. Maybe not distracting, but not awesome.
- dualboot 7y agoThe other side of this is that a very large percentage of folks in our industry seem to have social anxiety-spectrum issues. Folks without those don't seem to understand how much energy is being burned through just being out in the open and on display for all of your coworkers. It's not something I, personally, have control over. The time I've spent in "open concept" work places, I finish every day frustrated with my ability to accomplish tasks and physically and emotionally drained. That takes a very serious toll over time. I've moved on from jobs due to this type of work environment.
- turk73 7y agoTotally agree. Open concept at my place is beyond ridiculous. I'm not a zoo animal. Zero privacy, bathrooms are disgusting, kitchen is disgusting. I just give up. I work at home as much as possible.
- JohnFen 7y ago> I've moved on from jobs due to this type of work environment. Me too. The last job I had was with a top tier company whose products nearly everyone reading this owns and uses. The open office workspace is why I quit. It was an intolerable hell.
- carlmr 7y ago>a very large percentage of folks in our industry seem to have social anxiety-spectrum issues. It seems like it, I wouldn't like a cubicle. I think open offices aren't ideal. I'd prefer a team room, but between solitude and open I pick open.
- 7y ago
- mmhsieh 7y agothis story has been posted multiple times but it should be reposted in new form over and over until all the pointy haired bosses have read it and repented
- mmhsieh 7y agothey claim it is to promote interaction but it is also to squeeze more desks into a unit of space. do the geometry and it is obvious.
- knightofmars 7y agoI realize it's opinion, but I'm amazed that people think cubicles are privacy. I get that you feel more productive and that there is likely a reduction in visual distraction but it's an illusion of privacy, it ends up being a "lesser of two evils" scenario. Providing everyone with an office that has a closing door (while more expensive) has the highest productivity outcome. Fun dive into history, the guy who invented cubicles regretted doing it[1]. [1] https://www.history.com/news/why-the-inventor-of-the-cubicle-came-to-despise-his-own-creation https://www.history.com/news/why-the-inventor-of-the-cubicle...
- munificent 7y agoI think you may be taking "privacy" a little too literally. A "privacy fence" in your backyard does not literally shield your entire property from observation. But it interrupt sightlines and lower how "social" the space feels. When it comes to focus and productivity, that is often enough.
- knightofmars 7y ago"When it comes to focus and productivity, that is often enough." Based on your own personal criteria of what "enough" is. And what you're attempting to optimize for. An office is a place where people are intended to be productive. If _real_ privacy enables people to be the most productive then optimizing for something else (cost) is quite possibly a huge mistake on a long running timeline. Having been in cubicles, I've overheard enough conversations from co-workers that should have been private related to both business and personal life. I don't know what your experience is, but having spent years in a "cube farm", I'm intimately aware of the differences between having a cube and an open office. Distractions in a cubicle may be reduced but noise, smells, and other distractions are the facts of life when you have over a certain number of people within a small enough area. I've lived it, it's a half-measure and while it may improve productivity over an open office it's also just a cost-saving measure with the side-effect of having a tax write-off at the end of a day.
- thanatropism 7y agoMuch of the contemporary world is driven by how opex and capex accounting. Open-plan office make perfect sense if you consider how visible real estate costs are, and how subtle and variable productivity it is. If "Management" micromanaged productivity as some people expect here, they'd fire everyone showing signs of ADHD.
- pradn 7y agoI'm currently at the Google NYC office and no one here says it's more efficient. It's just a way to pack more people into valuable real estate. Full stop.
- dkersten 7y agoThe best office I've experienced (but sadly only visited for two week, the branch I worked at had typical open plan garbage) had the building split into sections where along both sides were small single-person offices (large enough that two people could sit at a desk and work, or 3 to 4 people could sit for a meeting) with closing sliding doors. In the space between the two rows of offices was a small amount of hot-desk space (maybe 6 to 8 desks), some armchairs and sofas and a conference table with projector. The layout was basically: +--+--+--+--+--+ | | | | | | +- +- +- +- +- + | |HHHH CCC ####| | +- +- +- +- +- + | | | | | | +--+--+--+--+--+ Where H was the hotdesk space, C the casual sofas/armchairs with coffee tables, and # the conference table with projector against the wall on one end. Not drawn to scale, of course.
- floren 7y agoThis is my favorite kind of setup. I call it the "Unix Room" model, because it's sort of like what I saw at Bell Labs: Private offices for staff, but people would also work in an open area often (it helped that they just had terminals scattered around and you could sit at any one of them). I've worked in such an environment and loved it, but of course it costs more space than any of the other alternatives.
- dkersten 7y agoYeah, it really was the best of both worlds. People tended to keep their doors open to signal it was ok to interrupt them, but if they needed to get work done, they just close the doors. People also spent a lot of time in the center areas, when it made sense to do so, eg when they were doing something that could be done in a more relaxed environment, or to brainstorm or chat with others.
- whalabi 7y agoLetting people choose how they work, how revolutionary!
- madhadron 7y ago
- throw0101a 7y agoSo is the consensus: * private offices > shared offices > cubicles > open-plan offices
- ajkjk 7y agoI like open offices. I feel like you only hear the angry voices on subjects like this. I would get so depressed in a closed office that I just wouldn't work there, so you'd never find me in one. I'm also a person who had to be at cafes or libraries to do good work. Working at home drives me crazy. But I think offices should accommodate every kind of person.
- DGAP 7y agoOpen offices are popular because they're cheaper to build than private offices, no one making these decisions ever believed they were doing it to "increase collaboration."
- pwthornton 7y agoI don’t know about this! There are so many bad management fads. How does one choose? I am actually amazed that people don’t take management more seriously and don’t follow actual research. It’s amazing that we spend so much on employees and then leave so much of what happens to essentially personal beliefs and astrology.
- koala_man 7y agoPeople seem to either love or hate it. Has anyone ever worked in both an open layout they liked, and an open layout they disliked? If so, what was the difference?
- SoylentOrange 7y agoTo combat some of the anxiety I had about people looking over my shoulder at my monitors, I bought a privacy filter for one of my screens. It has really improved my personal feeling of being watched.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dominotw 7y agoisn't this for cost savings though? I don't think its a fad.
- neilobremski 7y agoIt's harder to have conversations in an open office because they disturb non-participants. I find myself wasting time booking conference rooms when I could have simply popped into so-and-so's office. I remember a long long time ago when the company I worked for did a big move and went from offices to cubes. I was young and naive and willing to try the experiment but within a month or two I regretted the change and things haven't gone back since. I'd prefer sharing an office rather than an entire floor.
- celeritascelery 7y agoMy company keeps threatening to make this change. But just before they do something happens and they say they don’t have the budget. When they do actually make this change I think I will look for another job.
- mlochead 7y agoOne of primary points of article is that open office plans have resulted in less communication and collaboration. However, I have to wonder if it's just a timing thing, where the expansion of open office plans have also coincided with the more expanded use of tools like Slack, which has resulted in less in person collaboration overall.
- dqpb 7y agoThe nice thing about open office plans is that executives aren’t the only people who get to enjoy natural light.
- lliamander 7y agoOne of the biggest things I miss not being in a cubicle is that I no longer have my own whiteboard. Without whiteboard space, you hamstring a developers ability to think and to communicate with others.
- anthonypasq 7y agothere is this revolutionary technology called paper that still exists
- lliamander 7y agoAh excellent! Glad to know the invention of the whiteboard was completely superfluous.
- lliamander 7y agoYou know, I tried it[1], but it's still got some kinks to work out. [1]https://www.dropbox.com/paper https://www.dropbox.com/paper
- kazinator 7y agoThe interaction will take place if it is scripted in a dialog. Open-plan offices are useful in movies and dramas that have office settings or scenes. It makes these scenes more dynamic, since several characters can see each other across the room and interact directly, and lots of "extras" can be shown in a single camera angle. I have a feeling that such scenes may have driven some of the open office initiatives in actual workplaces. ("It was so cool in that movie ...").
- rochak 7y agoCouldn't agree more. I have a problem where I can't concentrate on anything if there are people talking around me. I have to put on my headphones and put on some soft music but sometimes even that is not enough. I don't know if this is a problem with me or many people, but I need silence to think clearly. It is also the reason why I fail interviews where the company is interviewing many people in parallel in the same room. How the hell is anyone supposed to solve a problem with people constantly murmuring all around you?
- lliamander 7y agoNow that we've established open office spaces are bad, where can I find more examples of what a good office space should look like?
- ksd482 7y agoI am a millennial (born in '88) and I would LOVE to have a cubicle. My first job was at Cisco in San Jose, California which had cubicles. I was fortunate enough to be introduced to the corporate environment with cubicles. I loved my cubicle. Like you said: just enough privacy to get things done. People would come by only if absolutely necessary otherwise they would mind their own business. Having cubicles also prevented useless chatter. Then I left that company and my productivity and mental peace has never been the same. Not even near.
- Velofellow 7y agoI think people's experiences and what they consider cubicles vary widely. When I started, I had a true cubicle with a standing 'U' shaped desk around the cube perimeter, which could've housed two employees. The cubicles had tall walls (7ft) so there was some actual privacy. those were Cubicle Nirvana, but for density reasons have seen two iterations of smaller, and smaller cubes. 'drive-by' type meetings were easy to accommodate without disrupting others. Currently, our cubicles are a honey-comb type arrangement. (think pods of three cubicles on one side, two on the other) There is no privacy, and rows behind you leave 18" of space to the employee behind you. Gone are the tall walls for working while standing. Edges of the cubicles do not stand proud of the desks, so it's not much to work with. We've seemingly taken the worst of both worlds when it comes to cubicle AND open office concepts. I wouldn't even know what to call it, other than awful.
- JohnFen 7y agoIronically, we have collectively forgotten why cubicles were invented, and why office workers originally hailed them as wonderful things: they ended the open office workspaces that were dominant at the time.
- bitwize 7y agoIndeed. This was a common office layout through much of the 20th century: https://youtu.be/5cNJNKkCQ2E https://youtu.be/5cNJNKkCQ2E
- notduncansmith 7y agoI work in an open office environment. I never thought I’d say this, but it works excellently; there’s always energy in the air, collaboration is easy, and it’s a great space to hold company all-hands meetings. I’d say there are 4 keys to making this work: 1) The founders have a great sense of aesthetic and our office is a beautiful space as a result (also stays very clean), meaning it stays less stressful and promotes a positive mood. This may not be strictly necessary but it sure helps it not feel like the hellscape that “open office” evokes. 2) There are plenty of closed-room office spaces available if you need focus time 3) Both of our open-office sections are in rooms much bigger than the rows of desks, so despite having a large number of people in one room, it never feels crowded 4) There is Sonos in both open-office areas and people are pretty good about not hogging it or playing obnoxious/too-loud music I’ve also worked in open offices that were nightmarish, but saw these same factors (minus the aesthetic portion) make for an effective office environment elsewhere as well. Music, breakout offices, and non-desk space seem to be the musts (but do decorate nicely because it matters more than I ever would have thought before). EDIT: I should add that it’s usually pretty quiet, and the music very low. I don’t consider it a distraction, but I also like my coworkers’ music so this may not work for everyone. Also, headphones are universally respected as a “do not disturb” signal.
- dkersten 7y ago> it’s a great space to hold company all-hands meetings. I've never been in an all-hands meeting that was actually useful. Usually its a bunch of guys bragging about how great they are in roundabout ways. > There is Sonos in both open-office areas Oh god. That alone would want me to not work there. I don't want to listen to someone else's music (most of the time, I don't want to listen to music at all -- I work from home now, thankfully, and spend most of the day without any noise or music at all. Silence is amazing. I don't want to be overstimulated all day every day)
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoMy job is 'focus time' 95% of the day. So I need to monopolize on of those office spaces. Hey! Just put a sign on the door - Joe's Office. And we're back to closed offices. It all depends on the job.
- acd 7y agoTotally agree. IT and other staff needs peace and quiet to concentrate to be productive. People interact less in open plan offices and tend to put on head phones to silence the noise. Since you produce less in open plan offices yes they are not smart. Also there is link to noise pulltion and overall health. Open Office spaces will be more noisy than private offices. https://www.pac-intl.com/pdf/NoisePollutionTakesTollonHealthandHappiness.pdf https://www.pac-intl.com/pdf/NoisePollutionTakesTollonHealth... Plus you are more likely to get sick in an open office, for example if you neighbor sneezes. "Compared to cellular offices, occupants in 2-person offices had 50% more days of sickness absence [rate ratio (RR) 1.50, 95% confidence interval (95% CI) 1.13–1.98], occupants in 3–6-person offices had 36% more days of sickness absence (RR 1.36, 95% CI 1.08–1.73), and occupants in open-plan offices (>6 persons) had 62% more days of sickness absence (RR 1.62, 95% CI 1.30–2.02)." Link to study https://www.sjweh.fi/show_abstract.php?abstract_id=3167 https://www.sjweh.fi/show_abstract.php?abstract_id=3167 https://www.rivier.edu/academics/blog-posts/the-price-of-collaboration-open-office-environments-and-employee-productivity/ https://www.rivier.edu/academics/blog-posts/the-price-of-col...
- onion2k 7y agoIT and other staff needs peace and quiet to concentrate to be productive. I'm not disputing that open plan offices are unproductive, but if you run a company it's just much cheaper to have an open plan office. In many places in the worls rent is high enough for more complex layouts that it would be cheaper to have a few extra junior staff than to have a different office structure. While it could definitely be less productive, it might actually be more profitable to have an open layout. This doesn't really explain why companies that build their own offices stick to open plan, but it's definitely the reason for small companies.
- acd 7y agoIncreased real estate prices has removed private offices for many.
- RivieraKid 7y agoFor me the problem is not really distractions (I don't care if people interrupt me from time to time, in fact I like it). My problem is the mental strain that stems from lack of privacy, the knowledge that people can see me and my monitor all the time, it's like there's a background process in my mind that checks whether what I want to do (move a lot in my chair, comment on HN, eat something) is ok with people around me. And this constant monitoring and self-control is tiring.
- decebalus1 7y agoThat's by design. Look up 'panopticon'
- switch007 7y agoFoucault wouldn't be surprised at all at the prevalence of open-plan offices.
- acephal 7y agoOr JIRA and its abuses
- lioeters 7y agoThe association of open-plan offices to the Panopticon: > ..The fact that the inmates cannot know when they are being watched means that they are motivated to act as though they are being watched at all times. Thus, the inmates are effectively compelled to regulate their own behaviour. > ..Foucault used the panopticon as metaphor for the modern disciplinary society in Discipline and Punish. > He argued that discipline had replaced the pre-modern society of kings, and that the panopticon should not be understood as a building, but as a mechanism of power and a diagram of political technology. > ..In the landmark surveillance narrative Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949), George Orwell said: "there was of course no way of knowing whether you were being watched at any given moment ... you had to live ... in the assumption that every sound you made was overheard, and, except in darkness, every movement scrutinised."
- 7y ago
- Dirlewanger 7y agoDon't think they're any worse than any other layout, most implementations are just lazy. There needs to be sane guidelines (no music overhead playing, relatively quiet, move discussions into a closed room) or obviously it won't work. I prefer it over cubicles.
- anthony_barker 7y agoIBM did some productivity study in the 70s. Top productivity was 2 people in an office. I had one of those IBM offices back in the day. Great for IT productivity.
- devmunchies 7y agoWhat do you do about gas? I work remote in my own rented space and I can let one RIP without thinking about it. BRRRRRRRRRRRRRPPPPPPP... PFFFFFTTtt... I can't imagine its comfortable holding it in until you use the bathroom.
- soapboxrocket 7y agoSo I worked in a legacy industry and they co-located a couple of teams near our biggest client. They decided to put in place an open office concept for the engineers and support staff, and gave the VPs and sales guys private offices. Especially when we first moved into the office the VPs loved to take the customers on a tour and stand at the top of the space and tell them how great this open office was. I was in a bad mood one time when this happened and the VP asked me if I agreed (with the customer) and I said, "it is perfect for what it was built for, it was built to show our customers how many resources we have and to imply that we have no walls separating our BUs from working together." He was not happy, but also had no lines of responsibility to me or my business segment. And like all open offices it was loud so everyone put on headphones and we had zero cross-BU interaction and very low inter-BU interaction. At one point corporate tried to push a no headphones rule because it looked bad when they brought in customers and it did not land well in the cube dwellers. A compromise was reached to not allow headphones when customers leadership visits where planned, about once a month. My biggest problem with the design was that they guy in the desk that faced me spent around 80% of his time on conference calls. Now he wasn't loud at all, almost never said anything on these calls, but he would sit silently with his headset on staring directly at me the whole time. Now he wasn't looking at me, just looking forward but it was really disconcerting. What I always find funny about the whole concept is that the open cube was really first imagined by Taylor as he tried to apply physical labor efficiencies into the office world. You would have everyone in an open office with the manager slighly raised up behind everyone so he could monitor them to ensure everyone was working at peak efficiency. Plus the modern leader of open offices, a company I forgot the name of in Colorado implemented and pushed open offices into the modern world, and then killed the practice internally in less than 2 years.
- robertoandred 7y ago> he would sit silently with his headset on staring directly at me the whole time Sorry, but this image is hilarious.
- sct202 7y agoI hate the open office plans with no view blockers or ones that are too low that peoples eyes peek over. It's so distracting to see movement or peoples eyes that I now deliberately lower my chair as far as it goes so that the tiny short wall blocks everything.
- habosa 7y agoThere are definitely problems with the open office but one thing I can say is that there is truly a different energy to the office when it's open and people can chat spontaneously. Some of my best projects have started this way, as have all my office friendships. I'd definitely get more heads-down work done in a private office setting. However in that setting I'd mostly be annoyed I couldn't just work from my home office, since I'd be commuting to spend 80%+ of my time alone anyway.
- ipnon 7y agoCan you describe this different energy and some of these best projects?
- JohnFen 7y ago> when it's open and people can chat spontaneously That so different from my experience at two companies using the open office scheme -- at both of those, spontaneous chatting was very, very rare because it so easily disturbs everyone not involved in the chatting. When I've worked in both cube farms and companies that had real offices, spontaneous chatting was common.
- 0xffff2 7y agoI never understand this line of reasoning. I have my own office. It's right next to most of my team's offices. My door is open 90% of the time. If someone wants to chat spontaneously, I don't think walking 15 feet is going to stop them.
- b1ur 7y agoYou'd be surprised, it doesn't seem like a lot but there is a big difference between having to stand up and walk over and leaning over, or kicking your chair over.
- Izkata 7y agoYeah, a lot of our random chats start because of a stray thought said aloud, not even to anyone. If someone nearby needs a break, they pick up on it.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoThe dumbest thing about open office plans is everyone puts on headphones and wants to communicate through Slack. I've got an idea. Let's all commute to the office and pretend we're remote!
- commandlinefan 7y ago> puts on headphones In addition to which, music in your ear can be just as distracting when actually trying to focus on learning something new as a co-worker blabbing on a conference call. The assumption behind open offices is that nobody will ever need to learn anything new: the exact opposite of what this new “knowledge economy” was supposed to be about.
- PaulStatezny 7y agoAgreed. I regularly wear earplugs with headphones over them, blasting white noise. That way I can block out the noise of loud conversations 10 feet away without (1) getting distracted by music or (2) damaging my hearing. It's kind of ridiculous, but if I'm going to get focused work done it's my best option. I'd get more done in a library-like space or an office for sure.
- Virtuoso 7y agoDon't downvote me for having an unpopular opinion, but aren't too many social media / youtube / hn / reddit distractions in today's world, and an open-plan office helps diminuate them?
- briandilley 7y agoWhat about team based offices? Where a team of ~4 or ~5 people share an office?
- munificent 7y agoThis is my favorite layout. My hunch is that tech companies shy away from this in part because team sizes change pretty frequently and it's more hard to physically accomodate that.
- sandmansandine 7y agoThere are a good amount of job boards which allow you to search for or only show remote jobs, I think a job board which allows filtering open-plan offices would be super useful.
- lacker 7y agoThis article is not paying any attention to the main justification for open-plan offices, which is that they are cheaper. This is especially important in areas with expensive real estate, or where the total office space is limited.
- munificent 7y agoDid you not read the entire article? > The Harvard study, by contrast, undercuts the entire premise that justifies the fad. And that leaves companies with only one justification for moving to an open plan office: less floor space, and therefore a lower rent. > But even that justification is idiotic because the financial cost of the loss in productivity will be much greater than the money saved in rent. Here's an article where I do the math for you. Even in high-rent districts, the savings have a negative ROI.
- Apocryphon 7y agoIf workers rights or material concerns won’t inspire software engineers to consider organizing, perhaps day to day work “lifestyle” hassles like open offices will. It’s been often repeated that developers eschew organizing because one can always go and find a better paying job if they don’t like the work environment they’re in- but good luck trying to find a workplace that gives the average developer their own office instead of adhering to the industry standard. Perhaps if engineers had some type of labor union, professional association, or guild, then they can collectively stand up to management and get rid of annoyances like open offices. Why not? If it’s something universally unpopular with hackers, yet embraced by management, doesn’t that provide a valid use case for organizing? Or are we just going to forever grouse about it until management loses interest on their own and embraces an even worse floor plan fad? And consider the other nearly-ubiquitous or common annoyances in tech- unpaid overtime, lack of support for remote work, whiteboard interviews. Why don’t the workers in the industry rally to solve them, if those in charge are unwilling to? If we care so much about “disruption”, why are we so content with the status quo of work? Upton Sinclair said of The Jungle that he was aiming for the public’s heart and hit it in the stomach. Perhaps software engineers will not be appealed to by arguments or neither the heart, nor the stomach- but of the flow.
- duxup 7y agoMan "The Jungle" ... that's a far far cry from open offices. Open offices is a crazy reason to organize / take the union route.
- Apocryphon 7y agoIt is, but engineers are compensated at (relatively) crazy levels , so different incentives will need to be given for them to organize. Sometimes social change occurs over the most trivial of issues- certainly wars have been fought over less. And again, what’s the solution to a problem that management almost universally ignores, while workers mostly detest, if applying organized labor pressure isn’t feasible? To wait for management to change their minds? To invent cheap real estate where each engineer can be granted their own office? To fight for remote work- so another industry standard that would also involve either mgmt. fads to change or workers to collectively protest?
- duxup 7y agoI worked in an office that was redesigned several times. After the last round of absurdly low / no cube walls. I bought myself some shooting earmuffs to block out the noise / a socially friendly way of signaling to others I should not be interrupted. It was telling that within a week half the team had amazon boxes on their desk and similar earmuffs. Now for very small teams with EVERYONE handling the situation properly. I think the open space can work, but it has to be VERY specific to department and folks who work well together. Eventually I ended up in a quiet corner of the office with half a dozen folks who were really good about talking to each other and it was super efficient ... but MAN that is not something you can just "make happen" and if one person / manager (especially managers) is bad about it... it's a mess.
- johnminter 7y agoI had a cubicle before they were popular - at Florida State U as an undergraduate from 1973-1977. They were great for studying and I could monitor my experiments in the lab just outside my cubicle. I had a small office in grad school and in my first job I shared an office with another scientist for a couple of years before I got my own. Having a space of my own made it easier to concentrate. Because I worked in a analytical sciences lab, interruptions were frequent (clients dropping of samples ), so I learned to get in 1-2 hrs before most others so I could focus on critical projects. The commotion in open bull-pens really interrupts one's train of thought and greatly reduces productivity.
- gumby 7y agoThe cubicle was invented as a way to liberate workers forum open plan offices. Then it became perceived as soul crushing. The work was the problem.
- cjfd 7y agoNormally I don't suffer that much from having roommates but today I was diagnosing a difficult problem and the noise from people talking to each other, then on the phone, then leaving, then coming back and so on. Every time that happened my train of thought was lost again. It was pretty terrible. Incidentally, the problem was a memory leak in asynchronous code and the cause turned out to be the google test framework keeping a reference to a future that could otherwise have been destroyed.
- ww520 7y agoWeWork charges more on office than open desk. That shows the office is more valuable. People pay more to get office because they can produce more to justify the cost. That shows office is better for productivity.
- jmilloy 7y agoRegardless of your personal preference, it should be obvious that offices and productivity are not one-size-fits-all. We seem to enjoy sharing personal anecdotes and preferences here regarding open plan, cubicles, home office, etc, and I find these discussions interesting. But I think the OP is a bit more interesting, because it summarizes some studies about both personal productivity and interactive teamwork. Furthermore, they make the argument that it is a bad "management fad". In other words, since different folks/teams/projects work best in different arrangements, when an office accomodates all sorts, it should succeed, whereas management that forces any one arrangement will fail for some people. The fact that it is a fad is precisely the problem inasmuch as causes management to select open plan offices exclusively.
- 0xff00ffee 7y ago'fad'? 30+ years working in cube farms for major Semiconductor and Operating System companies. (cough shmintel cough cough microshmoft) They ain't going away. Why? Because offices with doors are extremely expensive compared to wide-open spaces. It isn't going away.
- opo 7y ago>...Because offices with doors are extremely expensive compared to wide-open spaces. No not really. In the bay area (and likely lots of other places), the costs of employee salary, benefits, etc are a lot more than the costs for rent.
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoI said compared to wide open spaces, not compared to employee costs.
- opo 7y agoThe usual cost argument for open floor plans is that by devoting less square feet to each employee, you save money on rent. (The costs to actually put in a door and some sheet rock walls is a one time expense that isn't very high in comparison to the monthly costs for rent.) The reality though is that if employees are less productive, any savings in rent will be small compared to the costs associated with lower worker productivity.
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoOh, now I understand your point. That makes a lot more sense. I've bought into the "offices are more expensive" for years but never considered the one-time costs as more of a write-off / deprecation.
- nybblesio 7y agoOpen-plan offices are but one of many symptoms of the much larger problem in the software engineering industry today: nobody in "the business" understands what we do. I started working professionally in the industry in the late 1980s. Since that time, I regret to say that the people who hire we software engineers don't see us as anything but factory labor. To wit: - We've evolved into a world with "Agile", which our paymasters have defined as the equivalent of warehouse/factory/shop floor process. Each engineer is "the same"; thus, swappable; - In this view of the world, the only valuable thing to do is the tiny little sliver of work in front of you. Spending time on anything related to real engineering is verboten. When you're eventually asked why the application is slow, producing work faster isn't possible, or new features are difficult to implement, your "technical" answers about "the code", "the design", and/or the "architecture" are derided as "lazy work" and "not valuable". We just don't understand "the business"; - Since you're a factory laborer now, and there is no expectation that you must "think" to do this job, the notion that you require privacy is laughable. "The business" does not give the shop floor guys privacy, why should they give it to you? Oh, and how long do you suppose it will be before you must ask permission to use the bathroom? Just like factory workers; - Since you obviously don't need to "think", after all you just have to crank out that next ticket/card/story, then being interrupted isn't an issue. As the foreman of a factory floor, I can reallocate my "resources" however I see fit. After all, they're all assembling the same "widget", right? - If you're lucky enough to not be in the physical fish bowl of the modern software engineering shop floor, then you're expected to be tethered to some god awful chat client. Again, what you're doing isn't complicated, right? You don't have to plan. You don't need to design. You don't need to think. That's what all the tools, and frameworks, and geegaws they spend big money on are for! So if you get pinged constantly by 20 different people for 8 hours -- and your work isn't getting done -- there is something wrong with you; - If you are unlucky enough to be in the fish bowl itself, then being interrupted now includes both the physical and virtual; - Meetings are what "the business" does and what we do isn't important, obviously. So whatever "top of the stack" issue is critical to them at any given moment in time overrides any worthless thing you might be doing. The simple truth is that software engineering is a low prestige career in the majority of companies. There are a handful of real software vendors that still, on some level, grasp what it is we do. However, the vast majority gave up decades ago and just decided to treat us like factory workers. Welcome to the software industry in the 21st century.
- conductr 7y agoI like how it’s discussed as a surprise side effect. Collaboration and productivity are inversely related. Adding collaboration can rarely ever increase productivity and the fact that we needed years of open office plans and a Harvard study to tell us this is insane.
- Misdicorl 7y agoMeta response. There has to be a better way to aggregate than having this same article (effectively) pop up every other week. And then like 30% of all hiring/firing/workplace discussions devolve into the open floor plan discussion. The responses are always the same and the conversation hasn't moved an inch in five years. No, its not that hard to just hide the submission and close the comment chains which veer. But my brain constantly says 'what if someone said something new and novel on the subject?!'. So its friction for me because I'm either spending 10 minutes reading a rehash or 5 minutes thinking 'I should just glance at it just in case' The problem with reddit's solution is discoverability. Also, who would want a feed dedicated to kvetching/discussing open floor plans? Some/lots of people clearly want the articles and discussion, but would anyone actually subscribe to a feed like that?
- anon9001 7y ago> There has to be a better way to aggregate than having this same article (effectively) pop up every other week. I disagree. I think this is actually the best way HN can bring about change, even though the arguments haven't changed in years. IMO the reason these posts get upvoted is out of protest and to raise awareness. HN is probably the most influential source in tech. If every time you look at HN there's threads complaining about something, it must be pretty important. After watching memes travel around the internet and cross over into mainstream thinking, I put a lot of weight on how much HN's front page matters. Slashdot used to have a similar effect, then Digg, then Reddit, now HN.
- deepsun 7y agoWell, HN votes are (at least designed) not for liking/protesting, but to give feedback that something was interesting and curious.
- LeonenTheDK 7y agoIIRC it's similar for Reddit (I believe it's meant to be if the comment contributes to the discussion or not). Few people seem to follow it though.
- jefftk 7y agoHere's the paper: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.2017.0239 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.201... Roughly, they found two big companies that were about to switch "from assigned seats in cubicles to similarly assigned seats in an open office design, with large rooms of desks and monitors and no dividers between people's desks". Roles included "technology, sales and pricing, HR, finance, and product development, as well as the top leadership". They compared interaction metrics before and after the change.
- chadlavi 7y agoThis realization at the top levels of tech companies cannot come soon enough.
- Havoc 7y agoWorks for me. I can see and hear most of the people I’m responsible for and everyone is generally on the same page since everyone overheard everything. It’s more collaborative work than say programming though so I can see how it doesn’t work for all
- ulfw 7y agoGod I couldn't agree more. Sadly most of my last couple of jobs found it so hip and cool for even the CEO to have 'no office' (in reality each and everyone had a 'meeting room' only bookable by them with personal affects in them. Uhuh. No 'office')
- ulfw 7y agoFor me the best thing by far are the extremely rare "team open offices" where you put anywhere between 10-20 people inside that all work on the same type of product. Much better than your team of 10-20 people sitting in a room fitting 400 people.
- opo 7y agoThose team offices can hurt collaboration and innovation even more than open floor plans. In large companies, the random conversations between people from different teams is often the key to innovation and getting problems solved early. A team room means that to ask a co-worker on another team a simple question or to see what they are working on becomes a big deal because you are entering that other team's space and interrupting a dozen people - unless you really know the other person well, people just are hesitant to do it. In big companies, there usually isn't a problem with communicating within a team - the problems occur when teams aren't communicating with people in other teams.
- boromi 7y agoFor me privacy is key. I get anxious when people are staring at me working.
- let_var 7y agoSomething else to think critically - 1. Open space has a greater chance to skew your peer evaluations. Social aspects ends up being the numero uno factor. With cubicles you know others thru their work. This is not entirely black and white, but I strongly believe there's some truth to it. 2. Deep thinking is difficult if not impossible in open spaces. I was fortunate enough to start my career in cubicle in a research lab. That was fantastic! I had a dip when I was introduced to open space. Got lucky again with another company that had cubicles. For the last 5 years, it has been open space mayhem.
- ehmish 7y agoAs a millennial who has worked in open plan environments all my career, open plan offices are pretty good, so long as you've got headphones. I've got no problem with people interrupting people of they need me, but otherwise the noise of people chatting about things is completely drowned out by the music. The benefit is that if you've got an issue that you can't solve yourself you literally just have to just walk across the room at most to ask someone, which reduces the friction of doing that and thereby increases the likelihood hood of me doing it, meaning I spend less time blocked on solving a problem that others have solved before.
- musicale 7y agoAt one large company I am aware of they actually asked people what they wanted and the overwhelming response was walled offices with doors, even if they were small. So that's what they built, and it was very popular. Most of them had outward and inward windows with blinds that could be closed, which was also nice. Unfortunately over time the company shifted to open plan for newer buildings since that enabled them to cram more people into smaller spaces.
- bobly_today 7y agoI’m personally more productive and happy in open office layouts due to ease of communication and the psychology of a pseudo-computer lab setting. Granted I recognize I’m likely in a minority here. I even came from large personal offices and prefer the open office layout
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eapen 7y agoReading this while a recent re-org has made it feel like I am sitting in a market and working. At the very least, if they separated PMs and managers away from developers.
- jariel 7y agoIt's not a management fad, it's a financial fad. It's mostly about the money, nothing else. Short term gain (saving money) is much easier to calculate than anything else.
- artsyca 7y agoLook the open plan works amazingly at libraries but there's one rule: no talking
- marto1 7y agoWouldn't be surprised if there are 1000+ comments under this one. I don't think any sane programmer would be entirely on board with the entire open office fiasco if completely honest of course. My favorite bit on this topic starts here https://youtu.be/7fdQJ5ry_NI?t=2393 https://youtu.be/7fdQJ5ry_NI?t=2393 .
- peterhunt 7y agoThe article doesn't mention that open-plan offices let you allocate much less square footage per employee. In high-rent markets like American tech hubs, this is a very real priority for tech companies (especially cash-strapped startups).
- veeralpatel979 7y agoI wonder if ease of setup has something to do with the popularity of open offices, especially for startups? 1. After choosing an office setup, a company is not likely to change it unless it needs to 2. You can set up an open office in an afternoon. Buy some desks and chairs from Ikea and let people arrange them 3. On the other hand, I wouldn't know where to start in order to procure cubicles/private offices. 4. Also, setting up cubicles and private offices involves some construction work. So it takes longer Also: open offices may be used to try to create a culture of openness and egalitarianism (if even the managers are made to use desks). For large companies, the reasons above don't make sense, but they do for startups, in my view.
- xp84 7y ago^- THIS. And to be fair, it's probably nearly always the right decision for a startup that has no idea if it will even be able to put out its first product. Sinking like $300k into an office build-out of any kind before you hire your first key staff would be nuts. So a startup pretty much automatically is gonna start out looking like what you described in #2. And the inertia keeps them with that setup even after they have the funds to do it right. AND then the big companies wanted to "skin" their environments to look like a startup - so they opt for commercial open office furniture that, while the costs are still dramatically more than the IKEA route, usually offers little actual advantage over the $60 tables and chairs of the real early-stage startup.
- veeralpatel979 7y agoIf I build a startup that gets to the stage where I'm hiring people, I'm going to consider providing offices (private or shared) for my engineers, as a way to attract talent. I'm surprised more employers aren't doing this. Yes it costs more but (1) you get a lot more output out of your employees and (2) it helps you hire and retain good employees.
- erikbye 7y agoMy biggest gripes with open-plan offices (aside from the usual productivity cost): - Listening to coworkers' lengthy private calls. - You can't talk in confidence with any of your coworkers, so the only talks you have, the only things you say, are what you are OK with everyone nearby hearing. It hurts possible relationships/bonding (probably a positive for management), but it also hurts professional growth. - When we ask questions, we learn from each other and solve problems; we get things done. However, many are not that cool with asking what they think might be a stupid question (or one that reveals a lack of knowledge). With several people nearby listening in? Forget it!
- devmunchies 7y ago>You can't talk in confidence with any of your coworkers, so the only talks you have, the only things you say, are what you are OK with everyone nearby hearing. It hurts possible relationships/bonding. very insightful. makes perfect sense. Even a mild joke might offend someone so you subconsciously decide to not say it in public, which definitely prevents bonding.
- CM30 7y agoThey're also a genuine hassle/pain for anyone who happens to be on the autistic spectrum, or who has trouble with social anxiety in general. As someone in that situation, open plan offices are basically a recipe for constant stress and sensory overload. Either way, it's worrying given those in said situation are statistically likely to find it challenging to find employment as it is, and software engineering/web development/programming is an area which is seen as more suitable for them. As for why it's so common? Well there are a few reasons given in other comments, but I suspect a major one is that managers/boss/CEOs tend to be more extraverted than average. So they end up going with office designs that they would have wanted to work in, not ones their employees would work better in.
- glun 7y agoA pair of noise cancelling headphones does wonders for minimizing distractions in an open office.
- monkin 7y agoIt's interesting to see how studies like that change over time. I remember many from early 2000 saying that open-space are mind-changing and better for productivity. Few examples: http://www.luchetti.com/links/cwe_neocon.pdf http://www.luchetti.com/links/cwe_neocon.pdf, https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/pages/0902covstory_offices.aspx https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/pages/0902cov... or https://www.apa.org/monitor/may02/cubicle https://www.apa.org/monitor/may02/cubicle I never cared about office design, until only I can see my screen. Just hate when people watch how I work, ask questions or giving unwanted advice.
- loco5niner 7y agoIt doesn't seem like those studies say that... Here are quotes from all 3 links. > Becker concedes that no office environment is perfect. In open offices, for example, there will still be those who irritate peers by bellowing into the phone. Wireless phones may be one solution to such problems, he says, but a more ideal one is giving workers a choice of work environments to fit the demands of different tasks--what he calls the "cafeteria-style office." > The three most often reported workplace qualities that have the greatest effect on individual and team performance, as well as job satisfaction, were ranked as follows: 1. Ability To Do Distraction-Free Solo Work 2. Support for Impromptu Interactions 3. Support for Meetings and Undistracted Groupwork > ...he’s identified the 10 most important predictors of job performance. The top two are: The ability to do distraction-free work for teams and individuals. The ability to have easy, frequent, informal interactions. > For Brill, the equation is simple: Workers spend the majority of their time in private or near-private activity. As a result, he advocates giving each person a private office, no matter how small.
- uoaei 7y agoThis jives with my personal experience. I feel like I'm distracting the whole office if I go over to talk to a single colleague.
- cmsonger 7y agoFor the first time in a VERY long career, I joined Google a few years ago, which is an open office company. The thing I noticed in the first week: Everyone avoided eye contact all the time. The thing I noted after six months: I'd learned to avoid eye contact at all times. So I'm kind of not surprised. It was counter intuitive to me that open office was less social; but personal experience suggests that open office is less social.
- devmunchies 7y agoI've been working remote and i don't remember this. Is it because you don't want people to talk to you? Kind of like avoiding eye contact with someone who is going to ask you for money?
- clarry 7y agoIf you pay attention to people at all, it has a potential to distract you from whatever work you're trying to focus on, every time. If you're in a space where you have people moving about and coming and going in and out of your field of view, you need to learn to pay no attention so that you don't get distracted all the time. The best way is to focus on the screen in front of you and avoid making accidental eye contact with people.
- cmsonger 7y agoI seek (or sought) eye contact. When I first joined it was crazy how much walking through the halls and around the desks people avoided eye contact. Then I figured out it was because you saw them too much. There are so many times a day you can look at and say hello to co-workers without it just being weird.
- leto_ii 7y agoSince I started following HN I've seen these types of articles being posted with some regularity. The findings usually point in the same direction and the press write-up always tries to come up with explanations for why companies decide to do open space offices, how these were thought to improve collaboration etc. At my previous job I have worked for 4 years exclusively in an open space, sometimes even with hot-desking (including for developers and data scientists!). The impact on my ability to focus and on my mood has been catastrophic. Over time I ended up losing a lot of my ability for deep focus and I became stuck in this mode of superficial thinking that pushed me to switch between a bunch of menial tasks all the time. My firm belief is that open plan offices are used simply because they're the cheapest way to cram people in a space. The lack of walls and barriers makes it really easy to add desks, the cost of furnishing the place is minimal, management can always walk up to people to delegate tasks or ask questions etc. I think that this so-called fad is here to stay as long as employees (and especially those in tech) do not collectively demand some changes.
- marcosdumay 7y ago> as long as employees (and especially those in tech) do not collectively demand some changes If my employer has a procedure that reduces the productivity of everybody that they hire, why should I care? It does not reduce my competitivity, and my salary is set by the market, not by any single employer.
- dijit 7y agoI think the parent gave a good example of how it affected him long term. And I have to say the experience is mirrored with me. My attention span is not even 1/10th what it was when I started in this industry (where I had a team-office), and I don't think it would return very quickly if ever. There could be other factors, for sure, but your brain is a muscle, if you do not exercise it (focus) then it will atrophy.
- leto_ii 7y ago> and my salary is set by the market, not by any single employer Employers do have a tendency to collude though. The market for labor is very far from perfect. In most places even tech workers don't really get to negotiate much when they get a job offer. You should also realize that if most companies have open plan offices your range of options reduces quite a lot. What are you gonna do, only work for the 10% of companies that have other office plans?
- pimmen 7y agoOpen plan offices became more frequent because office area is more expensive because real estate has become more expensive. That's at least my guess of how we ended up in this mess that everyone knows is bonkers.
- pacifika 7y ago2018
- leoplct 7y agoSupposed a new startup wants to redesign its office taking this into consideration. Where to start? Ikea doesn't sell cubicles. Any solution on the market?
- user00012-ab 7y agoEvery open office I've worked in, the decision to have an open layout was made by people that were in offices.
- loco5niner 7y ago... and remained in offices (whether an official office, or a conference room that became an "unofficial" office)
- tonfreed 7y agoAlways worked in open plan offices, would never work in cubicles. I'd find it soul destroying if I felt like I was alone all day. The thing that shits me is hotdesking. That there is some bullshit. I worked with a client on site where everything was a hotdesk, I had to fight for the good monitor setups every day and deal with a clean desk policy which meant my notes and shit were always in my locker when I needed them.
- yellowapple 7y agoFrom the paper: > an F2F interaction was recorded when three conditions were met: two or more badges (i) were facing each other (with uninterrupted infrared line-of-sight), (ii) detected alternating speaking, and (iii) were within 10 m of each other. Condition (i) seems like it'd result in a lot of false negatives in various situations common in open-office environments, e.g. two people talking to each other without actually leaving their desks (especially if they're across from each other, since that'd mean there's likely at least one screen in the way).
- neycoda 7y agoC'mon, the original title was better: "Open-Plan Offices Are the Dumbest Management Fad of All Time"
- purplezooey 7y agoWtf. Stack ranking is far from dead.
- nojvek 7y agoProbably has been said before. I think there is a healthy balance of open/closed office hybrid spaces In closed offices, not everyone can have windows and natural light. Open offices lend better to that. Hybrid being assigned open desks and bookable/shareable closed rooms of various sizes. One person box to 30 people conference rooms. A quiet room (library). A boom box room with a jukebox. Honestly I love hybrid with a healthy balance of work 2/5 days from home. I have set days of meetings and planning “shit” Set days of getting the shit done. Yin Yang!