12 ms·
Surveillance on UK council websites [pdf]
- pier25 7y agoSorry for the editorialized title but it was too long...
- dang 7y agoThat wasn't editorialized, that was a gallant attempt to fit both the site guidelines and the 80 char limit. The only thing I'd have done differently was take out "Brave" from the title, since it's in the domain next to the title, and since they provide enough mentions of "Brave" themselves. (Submitted title was "Brave uncovers widespread surveillance of UK citizens on UK council websites".) It's moot now because we switched to the pdf and taken its shorter title.
- pier25 7y ago> that was a gallant attempt to fit both the site guidelines and the 80 char limit Well thank you kind sir
- zionic 7y agoWell that's just depressing. Having the fact that you accessed a government addiction help website packaged and commoditized then sold to the highest bidder just screams moral bankruptcy.
- Nursie 7y agoIt's hardly news that most of the UK government websites, either at the local or national level, report all your activity to foreign corporations, particularly google analytics. I've raised this with the website creators through their helpdesk system, and on here when they've posted, but been either told that it's fine (they anonymise the data! We trust them!) or just ignored. It doesn't seem to sink in that giving such a company complete and unfettered access to details on how the UK public interacts with its own government might be a problem.
- Normal_gaussian 7y agoIt may be hardly news to you; but it is to me. --- I've just taken a look around my local councils site. I've gone onto the benefits pages, the disability pages, and a few random pages. There are literally zero trackers here. I have a first party cookie set to the value "1". All images and JS are served first party, with the exception of typekit (adobe) fonts. All images and JS are, without a deep dive, benign. https://www.testvalley.gov.uk/ https://www.testvalley.gov.uk/
- Nursie 7y agoPerhaps my turn of phrase was less than ideal there.... but yeah, I've been pissed off about this for a while but got nowhere. Some of the stuff in this report is worse, of course, than just including GA. (edit - Just looked at test valley site there, it brings in google analytics, though seems clean otherwise. Also Hey neighbour! I'm based in Southampton at the moment)
- Normal_gaussian 7y agoAhh, the part after the hyphens is something I wrote after the initial comment I didn't mean it to sound so abrupt. Notably my test method was completely and utterly flawed - I used a Firefox Private Browsing window forgetting it blocks content-trackers (like GA). Still, having now visited it properly it is as you say. And Hey! I'm down in soton every week :D
- dboreham 7y agoPretty hard core to invent a whole local government for test purposes..
- Nursie 7y agoHa, this came up the other day. Non technical guy suggests we just insert 'Test' into the distinguished name of certificates we want to mark as 'not for production'. We pointed out that one of the many reasons that's a terrible idea is that the Test Valley exists.
- MrAlex94 7y agoSo I have read this report, but it would be good if there were some example URLs of where this is happening. Take for instance Lambeth's website (https://www.lambeth.gov.uk https://www.lambeth.gov.uk). I've browsed through a few public facing pages and the council tax payment pages. The report says Lambeth shows 1 real time bidding, 1 social and 5 Google "trackers". From my network requests I see: -> Google Translate and its resources (CSS etc.) -> Google Font -> jQuery and a bunch of various modules -> leafletjs (OSS Map library) -> Google tag manager -> The social links at the bottom are just links, no requests or trackers. Note: None are blocked by PB, only cookies are denied) Nothing out of the ordinary here (although you could argue against GTM on a council website). I'm not seeing what's at risk here? And according to the report, the above requests should be ignored in the results? Caveat 1: > This is not a complete study. Third party tools commonly used by websites for chat bots, designing the page, soliciting email subscription, profiling visitors for the Council’s own user data base, text to speech, CDN, fonts, non-Google analytics, etc. are not counted in this study. (See “table notes” on page 20 for a list of what is counted). > While these do expose a user’s behaviour to the companies concerned, we exclude them here in order for simplicity.This study highlights what we view as the most dangerous third party data collection and profiling. To compare, the landing page that this report is hosted on has the following "trackers"/requests: -> Brave.com Analytics request that is blocked -> Google Fonts -> Google Tag Manager -> Google Analytics (blocked by PB) -> Mapbox -> Scorecard research (blocked by PB) -> Newrelic -> Slideshare (blocked by PB) -> Leaderapps -> Tableau -> Vimeo (cookies blocked by PB) Edit: Sorry - PB is Privacy Badger. As for my personal feelings, "widespread surveillance" makes it appear as though there is some sort of malicious intent here. I have a few friends (and mother) who have previously or currently work for local councils, there is no money for this sort of thing. At worst I believe any actual issues are due to ignorance (which isn't an excuse) but could be easily remedied. This is way too dramatic for what should be a "Hey ICO, these councils are potentially not doing things properly, could you have a look?". Instead you'd think Brave have uncovered a PRISM level conspiracy on the local government level. Poor taste IMO.
- jey 7y agoWhat’s PB?
- frou_dh 7y agoInvisible trackers aside, it's simply gross that local government sites have banner ads on them. Have some pride and/or taste!
- sandwell 7y agoEspecially since they are publicly funded, so UK citizens are paying to have their data transmitted to unknown parties and advertised at. Oh, and if you don't pay it? Fuck you. The government will send bailiffs to seize your property to pay the bill, or imprison you for up to 3 months.
- mpeg 7y agoWhen you actually look at the sites, it's clear Brave hasn't done their homework or don't really understand the online ad ecosystem. For example, Enfield council ( enfield.gov.uk ) is using Google's ad server (DFP) set to show only internal ads. All their advertising is for cross-promoting projects and sites that Enfield council is involved with, including pest control, social lettings, a publicly-funded golf course, school meals... It's not showing ads from GDN (Google Display Network) or elsewhere, it seems to only show these internal promotions.
- jszymborski 7y agoRight, but are you suggesting that the Google ad servers are not going to use that information to sell to these visitors on other websites that are showing ads from the GDN?
- motohagiography 7y agoIt's quite likely a contracted web developer is using a "free" library that had these trackers built into it. It's also possible this is corruption, as it's a question of where the revenue from that data was going. If it's going to some web developer's account that's a problem. The RTB aspect of this story makes it clearly disingenuous, but getting interaction data to improve services is something you would expect a progressive public service to do. Crying wolf on this could do a lot more harm than good to the risk averse cultures of public services. I hope they've got the story right.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoThe entire article and "report" are so aggressive that it makes it difficult to extract any nuance out of it other than that I should use Brave. Is the core issue that council websites are using real-time bidding for their ads? Is this specific to the UK?
- sandwell 7y ago> Is the core issue that council websites are using real-time bidding for their ads? Yes. These websites are used to support a variety of public services, e.g. disability, poverty, drugs, or alcoholism services. Brave believes that sending tracking information about people accessing this information is a breach of privacy.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoAnd is "real-time bidding" an otherwise uncommon ad strategy that is relatively specific to the these websites? If it is, then I can understand the alarmism, but otherwise this news can be compressed to "UK council websites use targeted ads," right?
- farazbabar 7y agoNo. The issue is the means used to target ads on this site are transmitted back to ad servers and used outside this context which is a nightmare scenario.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoIs this not how targeted ads are expected to work?
- komali2 7y agoWhy are there ads on a website funded by taxes?
- butler14 7y agoThis is one of the downsides of using an ad-blocker It's literally never occurred to me, as a user of these websites, that local government websites would even have adverts on them -- let alone Google AdSense / junk from Google's Display Network.
- basilgohar 7y agoHow is this a downside to using an ad-blocker? I think it's quite the opposite. An ad-blocker would prevent most of this external JS from being loaded.
- lozaning 7y agoI've so successfully created a personal technology environment that hides ads, that I have no situational awareness about what these companies are up to. If someone out there is selling my healthcare data and running ads around it directed towards just me, I'd never know, but I'd want to.
- JohnFen 7y agoSo block tracking, not ads.
- dspillett 7y agoUnfortunately the two are often intimately linked, so that is not really practical.
- JohnFen 7y agoI'm not sure what you mean. You're right that the two are usually intimately linked. What I've found by blocking tracking is that as a result of this intertwining, blocking tracking usually also blocks the advertising engaging in the spying. I don't use an adblocker. I block tracking. It's pretty nearly as effective as an adblocker, so that seems practical to me.
- blibble 7y agoI suspect the root cause of this issue is the average web developer not realising that including any third party javascript gives total control of the page to whoever controls the included URL
- choathedolls 7y agoThe average developer knows this even if you're an absolute lover of all things JS. Whether or not the developers were forced to include them due to certain constraints is another issue.
- Grumbledour 7y agoI am kind of sick of this excuse. While I suppose every developer here was in a situation where they had to include something they did not want, I also know that none of my colleagues would care or even think about including external scripts, trackers or other crap. Possibility would be high they would be the ones suggesting it. And I have met many developers who think that way. And looking at a plethora of open source projects, which many would assume should have many developers more conscious of these kind of issues suggest this is more than anecdotal evidence. Most people, developers included, probably even most developers on hacker news, don't care at all. We should not always try to push responsibility on someone else when it is us who builds this kind of crap often without even protesting.
- foxyv 7y agoAdvertising is starting to edge towards the side of "Universal Evil." We need some serious regulatory controls on this stuff because it is getting out of control. GDPR is a step in the right direction, but sites and advertisers are pretty much flouting it at this point.
- oefrha 7y agoA better link would probably be the actual report, “Surveillance on UK council websites” https://brave.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Surveillance-on-UK-council-websites_compressed_version.pdf https://brave.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Surveillance-on... At least that report doesn’t start every sentence with “Brave”.
- dang 7y agoOk, we've changed the URL to that from https://brave.com/ukcouncilsreport/ https://brave.com/ukcouncilsreport/. Thanks!
- 627467 7y agoI don't want to be overly critical here but If we rush to call this 'widespread surveillance' (intended or not) I worry that we'll quickly start losing words/expressions to describe the stuff that snowden unveiled or whethever the government does in China...
- salawat 7y agoHow ya figure? It's same in type. Pervasive monitoring/metadata collection is an attack. PRISM/CALEA/ubiquitous surveillance via facial recognition, social credit scoring don't just magically stop being linguistically addressable because we've tossed another specific example into the generic bucket. It just means that we're getting better at identifying exploitative forms of unnecessary data collection. Unless I'm reading your statement wrong, I'm just not seeing a here your worry comes into play. There's no Orwellian language leak there, and I'm usually pretty sensitive to that just because it does drive me nutswhen people try to do that intentionally.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThe source for the story clearly has a specific political bias regarding its interpretation of privacy. That political bias doesn't impinge on the facts of the report though (merely that Brave believes it's worth surfacing loudly).
- alharith 7y agoSo the right to privacy is a political agenda item now? I don't get what you are saying, can you please clarify?
- shadowgovt 7y agoWhether pseudonymized background data collection constitutes a violation of right to privacy is a hot-button political topic. The GDPR has put a stake in the ground on this but is not the final say on the matter.
- licebmi__at__ 7y ago
- nottorp 7y ago[quote] This report should spur Elizabeth Denham, the UK Information Commissioner, to finally enforce the GDPR. It is 17 months since formal evidence from Brave and complaints about breaches of data protection laws were filed before the ICO. [/quote] Oh really? Hello BRexit?
- gniv 7y ago> Hello BRexit? I was curious about this and searched a bit. According to this website [1] the GDPR is still in force until the end of the year, and in addition there is a UK-GDPR law, very similar to the EU GDPR, which took effect on Feb 1st. So there are two regulations now, not zero. [1] https://www.cookiebot.com/en/uk-gdpr/ https://www.cookiebot.com/en/uk-gdpr/
- whalesalad 7y agoI guess the irony of a 'tweet this' href after every single bullet point was lost on the author.
- toyg 7y agoCouncil are the victims here. They are forced to debase themselves because central government, in the Tory era since 2010, simply offloads competencies to local authorities, without allocating extra funds or even slashing existing ones. So the priority has become to keep the lights on and find every way possible to monetize anything remotely monetizable, from parking to this (as well as cutting tons of jobs, closing libraries and so on). Councils are literally going bankrupt, but voters can’t make the link and keep voting for “low taxes” in Westminster and “the Council should do everything” at home, then complain when pigs can’t manage to lift off and fly.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThat kind of fiscal « downloading » is also a way to keep wealth within your council, and poor areas can just get bent because they’ll have more needs, but the least ability to get revenue. (If council’s primary revenue source is council tax within their own council).
- adwww 7y agoThat would be nice... but councils can only increase tax by <2% per year, and most of their revenue comes from a 'grant' by central government, which has been cut ~40% in the last decade.
- toyg 7y agoYep - "egoistic firewalling" is basically how Tory HQ sold the strategy to the local authorities they controlled (peppered with rebalancing some formulas so that they would get more than in the past, taken from more deprived areas they didn't control); then turned around and slashed so hard, the first towns to declare bankruptcy were their own [1][2][3]. And what do they do in London? Blame councils, of course! [4] [1] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/feb/02/tory-run-council-runs-out-of-money-to-meet-obligations https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/feb/02/tory-run-cou... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/may/18/tory-council-at-risk-of-bankruptcy-slams-broken-funding-system https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/may/18/tory-council... [3] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/local-council-bankruptcy-government-complacency-public-accounts-committee-meg-hillier-a8429606.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/local-council... [4] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/nov/11/cameron-hypocrisy-cuts-letter-oxfordshire-council https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/nov/11/cameron-hyp...
- weekay 7y agoWhat is interesting is the fact that none of the revenue / income from advertising if any, is showing in the accounts of the council. Checked a few at random and none of the account statements mention income from ads. Begs the question then not just of moral bankruptcy but of accounting this. If it's not implemented for income to the council then why ?
- pier25 7y agoMaybe there is a document somewhere that enforces certain practices when making websites for public institutions?
- lbriner 7y agoUnfortunately not, otherwise it would be easier to enforce consistency. The simple truth is that councils like many companies are not specialist developers but are expected to run high-quality web applications. Add in some Consultants who may have conflicting interests or lack of knowledge, semi-skilled staff, a friend-of-a-friend who told you to use X on your site, third-party web developers and a marketing team who need the "analytics" and you end up with this mess. Like many companies, GDPR seems right down the list. The most troubling part of all for me was that the ICO acknowledged the illegality but didn't follow up. Sums up Britain to a tee! (I'm a Brit)
- asdfasdf1231 7y ago> If it's not implemented for income to the council then why analytics? To better serve you? to think-of-the-children?
- godelski 7y agoCareful, some people may not pick up on that sarcasm.
- gowld 7y agoDid you cross-reference to the councils whose websites are serving ads? Perhaps the ads are run by 3rd party web hosting providers. Just a guess.
- shadowgovt 7y ago"This report should spur Elizabeth Denham, the UK Information Commissioner, to finally enforce the GDPR." What is the status of GDPR in the UK now that Brexit has occurred? Is the UK still beholden to the terms of the law, or does the UK have a parallel law that applies now that they're no longer part of the EU?
- rux 7y agoGDPR is currently entirely valid and enforced until December 2020. After that point it is believed that an entirely compatible law will continue to exist - currently the understanding is that the UK will be considered to have adequate equivalency therefore making it a safe third party country to transmit data for processing. No hard guarantees until the end of the year though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- CommanderData 7y agoInterested in some of these comments, no doubt places like these are getting astroturfed more and more.
- paulcarroty 7y agoUK has the biggest number of cameras per m^2 in world. Sadly, it's common pattern. Cool business idea: Mr Robot style hoodie with tracking protection.
- theseadroid 7y agoAnd only by then you'll realize how many people don't really care and the ones wearing the hoodie will be singled out with special attention from state.
- dnh44 7y agoWell someone has been fined for disorderly behaviour for covering their face. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7036141/Police-fine-pedestrian-90-facial-recognition-camera-row.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7036141/Police-fine...
- awinter-py 7y agoI've been on government sites (ny.gov, IIRC) that use google-provided captchas for form submissions sucks but not sure it's immoral -- submission fraud is a hard problem to deal with and if captchas help, .gov should use them
- Animats 7y agoHere's the service promoting advertising on Government web sites in the UK.[1] From their FAQ: Q: "Could the data collected be used to exploit individual circumstances?" A: "There is no intention to do this. In all forms of advertising, companies want to appear in front of the people most likely to buy their products or services." "Just as an advertiser will choose an ad space in a publication because of its readership and relevant editorial content, so an advertiser online will use data from cookies to target their ads to people who would be most interested." "So, a user browsing for information on a benefits webpage might be shown ads relevant for people on a budget, like for reduced price travel or supermarket price cuts on everyday items or a comparison website to find the best tariff on gas and electricity." The Enfield council's cookie disclosure page includes cookies from most known trackers.[2] This is an amusing read. [1] https://can-digital.net/generating-income-from-council-websites-can-advertising-network/ https://can-digital.net/generating-income-from-council-websi... [2] https://new.enfield.gov.uk/privacy-notice/#6 https://new.enfield.gov.uk/privacy-notice/#6
- Nextgrid 7y agoSeems like they aren’t aware of the law or explicitly violating it and hoping to get away with it (which unfortunately isn’t a bad strategy considering Google and Facebook are still around). The thing with the law (the GDPR in this case) is that it applies to everyone equally. It doesn’t matter whether your intentions are good, if the law says you can’t collect certain data without explicit user consent then you shouldn’t be doing it regardless of how good your intentions are.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoWhat good intentions? That quoted FAQ walked around the core point: advertising is, for the most part, exploiting. > So, a user browsing for information on a benefits webpage might be shown ads relevant for people on a budget, like for reduced price travel or supermarket price cuts on everyday items or a comparison website to find the best tariff on gas and electricity. Or payday loans, or get-rich-quick schemes, or gambling, or news articles about how the elite is oppressing them, or "save your money on power bill by bundling it with your mobile service" borderline scams. It's not like the government, or the company that wrote that FAQ, will be actively filtering the ads to ensure that only the honest win-win deals are shown.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoThe title of the submission seems very much like a clickbait: the context makes it sound like it refers to government surveillance, not sending data to private American companies to serve ads.
- tomlong 7y agoIn the appendix table, South Oxfordshire is listed as South Oxfordshite.