18 ms·
Starlink Is a Big Deal
- allears 7y agoI have heard wildly differing estimates of the potential bandwidth Starlink will offer to individual consumers, at what prices, and how efficient/effective their mesh networking and ground station strategy will be. I'm taking a wait and see attitude, but it would be very cool if they actually came up with a telecom killer.
- ianai 7y agoI’m expecting it to start as a service for rural subscribers and maybe people who travel? I tried to calculate it at one point and got something like 250/mo for 25-100mb/s, iirc. No claims on accuracy though.
- 0x445442 7y agoAgreed... I'm really pulling for Starlink and have fantasies about the day I can give Cox the middle finger.
- pwthornton 7y agoI don't think the purpose is to battle fiber and copper being laid on the ground. There are a lot of places where that is too expensive too do or the situation is not politically stable enough to do so. Land-based solutions are going to be cheaper and faster for many situations and people, but this gives us another tool to expand connectivity.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoGiven the title, I assumed this was a link to this awesome article: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/11/02/starlink-is-a-very-big-deal/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/11/02/starlink-is-a-...
- dang 7y agoDiscussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21431717 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21431717 Another big deal discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21397285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21397285
- sneak 7y agoI am OP and have never seen this. Thanks for the link! I too love the Mother Earth Motherboard essay.
- pwinnski 7y agoI am skeptical of anything like 600Mbps being offered to anyone at anything like an affordable price, but overall, sure, globally-available internet seems like a good thing. Too bad we have to give up the night sky for it, though.
- Trombone12 7y ago> Too bad we have to give up the night sky for it, though. Oh, I wasn't aware we were getting any choice in the matter? Isn't this SpaceX just putting whatever they want up there?
- TheCraiggers 7y agoThese low orbits won't last forever. If nobody pays for them, they'll all be gone in a few years.
- genzoman 7y agoGiving up some of the night sky for the billions of humans that live in rural areas, or live in countries where the physical internet is controlled by oppressive governments hellbent on withholding information from its citizens is worth it. The trillions of dollars it would take to build out infrastructure (and maintain) in Africa and India is worth it. In fact, even 20 Mbps would be life changing in bringing information to ~10-15% of humans is worth it.
- TheCraiggers 7y agoI'm glad you think it's worth it. I'm not as sure, personally. Especially since your examples don't hold water with me. Oppressive governments that don't like the internet aren't going to just allow the transceivers. They need line of sight to the sky and even if you hide them, detecting them would be trivial. Super rural areas and 3rd world areas have their own set of problems. I'm thinking of the OLPC type issues here. I'm all for spreading knowledge, but these areas have far bigger issues than internet access. Personally, I view this as just another bulldozing a place of nature to build a hospital or something like that. Is that hospital useful? Undoubtedly. Is it worth having one less place of nature? Debatable. The only difference is scale. We're talking about the destruction of a place of nature for the entire world. Over dramatized? I don't think so- there are many examples of people talking about looking up at the stars in wonderment, driving them to great things. Maybe that will still happen when there are thousands of satellites streaming by, but nobody has that foresight.
- chrispeel 7y agoI'm not convinced that Starlink will provide access to the "half of the human beings (who) are not online yet." Of course that would be good, yet my guess is that Starlink will target people in developed nations who are in rural areas, or people who want low latency. Maybe Starlink could serve people w/o internet if a whole village buys a subscription, or if a cell provider uses Starlink as backhaul for voice? Still seems expensive for the third world that the author is talking about.
- durkie 7y agoWhy wouldn't it trickle down? I feel like all new technologies start out with rich people/early adopters subsidizing mass adoption costs (refrigerators, TVs, computers, cell phones, electric cars)
- pkolaczk 7y agoThe problem is that rich people live in areas that have good mobile coverage, and Starlink won't be very attractive to them. LTE can offer transfers better than 600 Mbps with lower latency today, and covers 99% of population (in the developed countries). 5G will get over 1 Gbps per sector and it's coming soon.
- mgiampapa 7y agoRich people have boats, by definition these are people with too much money to spend and is a huge market. Airplanes? This will revolutionize coverage on long haul non-polar flights. Trains? Buses? These both have density issues with the existing cellular network. How many times have you come to a halt in a traffic jam only to have horrible cellular coverage due to the local cell site being overwhelmed? 5G doesn't solve any of these use-cases. There is plenty of room for adoption of starlink at premium prices.
- learn_more 7y agoWith enough people in once place, Starlink will suffer from congestion just like a cellular network. I don't think it's fundamentally different in that regard. But great for boats indeed!
- chasd00 7y agohopefully it makes inet service on planes better
- dkersten 7y agoCompanies like Viasat are already offering that. A couple of years ago, they were talking about how they wanted to offer free internet to all passangers (with enough bandwidth that everyone could stream HD movies, thanks to the new satellite they launched in 2017). I'm not sure how the rollout is going, though, or if the airlines want to do this. I guess the airlines can make a fortune overcharging passengers for internet.
- h2odragon 7y agoI'm a viasat customer. Most days, github.com doesn't exist for me. Anything using SSL is going to fail 30% of the time anyway, and 50%+ of the time after they restrict our bandwidth for the month. Even if they could provide better service, I wouldn't hold my breath in expectation of it.
- jerrysievert 7y agoif there's an option for turning off caching, or "network speed up" in your modem, turning it off helped for me when I was trapped with hughesnet for a while. moved me up to about 75% of GitHub.com requests working. essentially, their caching mechanism was broken for a ton of the sites I went to visit.
- dkersten 7y agoWhen I was at Viasat, there was a difference between what was provided to consumers (Exede) and what they were providing to airlines with their new satellite. The new one has much higher bandwidth than their older one. I’m not sure if the new satellites will service consumer internet too as I left the company before Viasat-2 became fully operational.
- nordsieck 7y ago> A couple of years ago, they were talking about how they wanted to offer free internet to all passangers (with enough bandwidth that everyone could stream HD movies, thanks to the new satellite they launched in 2017). I'm not sure how the rollout is going, though, or if the airlines want to do this. I guess the airlines can make a fortune overcharging passengers for internet. The only thing that makes sense to me right now is what airlines are already doing: serving cached video from a server on the airplane.
- cyounkins 7y agoEven in small areas we have CSMA (listen before talk) collisions in 2.4/5G bands that create high latency variance [1]. You can only have one transmitter per channel. With Starlink there will be many ground-based transmitters that can't do CSMA (because they are directional). How many channels are available could depend on the dedicated bandwidth, but I have a hard time believing we won't see significant transmit collision issues. [1] https://blog.parsecgaming.com/how-your-wifi-band-impacts-low-latency-connections-9f1e538a63dd https://blog.parsecgaming.com/how-your-wifi-band-impacts-low...
- wmf 7y agoCSMA is basically the worst MAC protocol. When performance matters you use TDMA.
- wahern 7y agoStarlink will use something like OFDM. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthogonal_frequency-division_multiplexing#Space_diversity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthogonal_frequency-division_... From the famous IEEE article at https://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/wireless/the-end-of-spectrum-scarcity https://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/wireless/the-end-of-spectr...: > Moreover, interference is not some inherent property of spectrum. It's a property of devices. A better receiver will pick up a transmission where an earlier one heard only static. Whether a new radio system "interferes" with existing ones is entirely dependent on the equipment involved. Consequently, the extent to which there appears to be a spectrum shortage largely depends not on how many frequencies are available but on the technologies that can be deployed. Many regulations intended to promote harmony of the airwaves have instead, by putting artificial limits on technology, created massive inefficiency in spectrum utilization.
- Barrin92 7y ago>"Hundreds of cities and dozens of countries, fine for living but previously entirely unsuitable for a place of business, will blink from red to green on the map once Starlink goes live." this reads like a marketing piece rather than actual analysis. Throughput of a single satellite is 20Gbps. The finished constellation if I recall correctly is supposed to be about 12k satellites. So about ~250.000Gbps. So assuming you offer everyone a 100MB/s connection, that's... one city? And that doesn't account for transmission between the satellites or satellites not in range and so on, and the fact that those satellites are short-lived and need to be replaced. How is this supposed to be economical or scale compared to regular terrestrial networks? And one point on the social impact. We have heard this idea that you just need to 'connect people' over the internet to somehow give every disadvantaged place economic opportunity for decades now. This isn't how the real world works. Everyone still runs to California/their national equivalent You can count the areas where the VC money goes on one hand. Putting a satellite in the sky over Siberia isn't going to upend the social realities of geography.
- Dunedan 7y agoIt's a shared medium, as is internet via cable. The 100MB/s or whatever they'll offer will be the peak throughput you can achieve. Aside from that they already have plans to send up 30.000 more satellites [1] and of course future satellites might also have a significantly higher throughput. [1]: https://spacenews.com/spacex-submits-paperwork-for-30000-more-starlink-satellites/ https://spacenews.com/spacex-submits-paperwork-for-30000-mor...
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoYou can do a lot of business with much less bandwidth than that. Isn’t this more about getting them ability to send emails and read text and information and not things like livestream?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- grahamburger 7y agoThat's true for dedicated circuits but no residential or even small business Internet plans are dedicated. You can put at least 200 customers on a 1 gigabit connection and they'll still get 100 Mbps+ speedtests even during peak usage times of the day.
- modeless 7y agoJust going to plug my Starlink tracker here: https://james.darpinian.com/satellites/?special=starlink https://james.darpinian.com/satellites/?special=starlink It tells you when to go outside and look up to see the satellites as they pass over your house. It's a cool sight to see because there are up to 60 of them crossing the sky at the same time in a line.
- pupppet 7y agoThis is great!
- TheCraiggers 7y agoThat is a beautiful website. Great job.
- ynniv 7y agoCould you add dates and time zones to the events? I want to manually add one to my calendar correctly.
- modeless 7y agoTimes are always displayed in your local time zone according to your OS/web browser settings. Now that you mention it, I should put an "add to calendar" link in there.
- modeless 7y agoI finished the "add to calendar" feature, and also I started converting and displaying time zones (if you choose a location that's outside your local time zone).
- saberdancer 7y agoThank you! I was looking for this today but I didn't bookmark it last time. Bookmarked it this time though!
- saganus 7y agoIt would be nice if I could select the location manually, since I don't like sharing my location directly by a prompt. When I got the location permission request I denied it and then it says there were no sightings available for the next 5 days :(
- dls2016 7y ago> the hard work of SpaceX to make cheap, reusable rockets an everyday reality Are they a reality?
- sneak 7y agoThe F9 that launched 60 satellites this morning was on its third or fourth flight.
- kanox 7y agoSpaceX has ~80 launches and recovered the booster ~40 times so the technology is very real and fully operational. The "cheap" part is somewhat questionable because current prices are lower but still comparable to those of traditional providers. This is likely because fixed costs are high and there is limited demand from satellite operators. A big part of the reason SpaceX is jumping into the satellite business is to create demand for itself and fully exploit Falcon 9 technology.
- bisby 7y agoThe launch today happened on the 3rd flight of the booster. They have a few cores now which have flown 4 times. At this point, prices are a coming down, and it is effectively assumed that any SpaceX core will fly at least twice. That covers cheap and reusable. Cheap at least compared to the market (I still can't afford it), and 2 flights is re-use. "Everyday" might be a stretch by the literal definition. But "commonplace" wouldn't be. No one gets super excited about re-flown cores anymore.
- ryuukk_ 7y agoonly the retarded americans can believe in this shit and tesla the world is already using and building such technologies americans think they are the first, and the best the rest of the world is aware of their lies when will america wake up? probably after being nuked, wich should happen soonish
- rsync 7y ago"HFT firms will be the first customers, seeking a few-millisecond reduction in the transmission of realtime data between markets. Starlink has already said as much, and I think they rely on this as their first and primary source of revenue." I am not sure this is a good prediction ... the shaving of milliseconds that has been pursued by HFT firms (and other such actors) has progressed to the point where they are measuring cable lengths inside the datacenter. Even at a greatly reduced orbit, I can't believe that bouncing up and down via satellite as part of your link could be any part of a time-arbitrage recipe in 2020 and beyond ...
- Denvercoder9 7y agoLight in fibers travels at around 2/3rds of the speed of light, while in air or vacuum it travels at (approximately) the speed of light. So a path through space can be 50% longer, and your signal will still arrive at the same time. Consider that the distance between New York and London is ~5500km, and these satellites are only ~500km up, that gives you quite a bit of margin to be faster.
- mhh__ 7y agoThe same argument is true of WiFi over a network cable. Depends on the packet loss on the way down. You also potentially might have to send more data for security reasons too. Also, if the satellite is halfway between them (without taking the curvature of the earth into account, assuming a flat earth and the signal only goes through one satellite), the signal still has to travel 5590 km to cross the Atlantic (at almost c). Probably a solvable problem but not a trivial one.
- cperciva 7y agoIt might be if you're arbitraging markets against each other. Starlink orbits are at 340 km, i.e. 1.1 ms altitude; if you're sending data between London and New York, you can afford 2.2 ms of uplink/downlink if it allows your signals to travel at c instead of 0.7c.
- rtkwe 7y ago
- buboard 7y agoYet people flock to cities en masse and in acceleration. The most technically educated/capable flock to even fewer cities, even where connectivity is terrible. Centralization of technology is a reality and what could be more centralizing than a single-interest entity controlling the global satellite network. Starlink is surely a big deal, but of limited applicability.
- Jamwinner 7y agoOdd, most of the smartest tech people I know fled the cities years ago. The city is where you go when you arent the brightest, because all the easy jobs are there.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- partiallypro 7y agoI am actually pretty excited for it. My parents don't have access to high speed internet (that is reliable) outside of 4G (which is either very expensive or has tight data caps,) so finally they might be able to get themselves Netflix, etc.
- mrfusion 7y agoI don’t understand how you can make functional satellites so small? That they can launch 60 at once. Usually a launch just has one satellite.
- akira2501 7y ago> can make functional satellites By reducing their "function" until they're basically a battery with a radio repeater strapped onto it. Obviously it's a bit more complicated, but there's very little these satellites actually have to _do_.
- sneak 7y agoThe Starlink satellites additionally have krypton ion thrusters for stationkeeping as well as to raise their orbits from their 290 km deployment altitude up to the 550 km service altitude.
- lutorm 7y agoion thruster, star trackers, phased array antennas, reaction wheels, torque rods, solar panels... they pretty much do everything every other satellite does.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoLots of launch providers and various 3rd parties have been providing rideshares for a while. e.g. there's the big thosuand pound payload, with an extra rack of cubesats to take advantage of extra fairing capacity. The starlink satellites are relatively small, but they're still larger than Sputnik for example. ISRO has launched 100+ satellites at a time, although I believe those were mostly cubesats which are an order of magnitude or two smaller than the Starlink sats
- mch82 7y agoEngineers keep shrinking communications, computer, and power technology. Launch services keep coming down in cost. Check out all the stuff people are accomplishing with CubeSats, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CubeSat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CubeSat
- pier25 7y ago> For reference, my last flat in Berlin (the capital of the largest economy in the EU), on the ground on a main street in the city center, was serviced with approximately 14MBps ADSL, and this was the fastest offering available from any vendor. 14Mbps in Berlin? How is this possible? I had 20Mbps in Mexico City almost a decade ago. A family member who lived in the same building at the time had 100Mbps symmetrical.
- iagovar 7y agoMostly policy. Spain deployed a lot of fiber in the las 10 years that we've got little towns with multiple symmetric 600mbps offerings. If it can be done in Spain, it can be done in Germany.
- pier25 7y agoMy father lives in Mallorca and he has fiber with 400Mbps I believe.
- pimterry 7y ago+1 on Spanish internet, there seems to be fast (100Mbps+) internet available pretty much everywhere. EU-wide, the official goal (https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/broadband-europe https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/broadband-euro...) is to have 100Mbps available to every EU household by 2025, with 1Gbps & 5G in all major cities.
- herova 7y agoBecause it's Germany. Cash only, slow internet, roads without speed limit - Germany.
- Tepix 7y agoNo, 14mbps in Berlin is an outlier. The average bandwidth in Germany is higher than that. In my city in large areas i can get 400mbps via cable and 250mbps via VDSL. Pretty soon cable providers in Germany will upgrade their entire network to DOCSIS 3.1 enabling gbit bandwidth.
- Havoc 7y ago>access to the global network, intelligent and resourceful people located virtually anywhere can operate on substantially similar footing to anyone else Great article, but this part is just false. Africa is blanketed with internet access already - often way ahead of 1st world (I recall reading an article about Seattle getting LTE-A and thinking...wait...got that a year ago). It doesn't quite create the magic the author implies. A bit like writing code doesn't mean you can create the next big app. A lot of ingredients go into it
- djannzjkzxn 7y agoDo you have any data on the true prevalence of cell data coverage in Africa? A coverage map would be cool, but an estimate of the % of people who live in a covered location would also be useful.
- martinald 7y agoTo take a random example I'm familiar with Uganda has 97%+ LTE-A population coverage, which is as good if not significantly better than the US. External bandwidth costs are also coming down massively as loads of new submarine fiber cables are connecting africa. However, even a basic smartphone will cost 400%+ of many people's monthly income. Penetration of feature phones is high though as they are so cheap. Starlink imo will not be transformational for these places. It will be extremely useful for somewhat niche cases like rural broadband in the US, cruise ships and planes. It won't work well in cities or even suburban areas (20gigabit per sat is only 2,000HD video streams - which a small city of 100k will completely swamp).
- denni9th 7y agoUganda is much smaller than the USA, and more densely populated. Country-wide LTE makes a lot more economic sense there, especially when you consider that mobile internet is the primary way of connecting to the Internet in Africa.
- shkkmo 7y agoI am in the process of building out a boxtruck with solar panels and a big batter and I am eagerly waiting for starlink to roll out public Access so I can get an antenna and park my new home office in very rural areas and work comfortablely.
- mch82 7y agoTo me the article misses the bigger deal: SpaceX launched 60 satellites in a single launch & ~250 in ~8 months! Under 9000 satellites have ever been launched in 756 months, since 1957. That’s a launch rate increase from 12/month to over 31/month.
- stillwater56 7y agoAs someone with very little background (but a lot of interest) in space tech, could you share a little about what results that growth in launch rate will have?
- nexuist 7y agoNot OP but basic economics dictates that high demand = high supply (i.e. low prices). The entry barrier to launching a satellite is lower today than it ever has been before. Civilian entities from private companies to high school clubs have successfully launched cubesats from SpaceX rockets. We will basically see what happened to computing happen to space. Remember the mainframes of the 70s that cost millions and only governments and megacorps could afford? Remember how those gave way to the personal computer, the laptop, and eventually the smartphone and tablet? Now, it's pretty unlikely that every citizen in the country will get their own cubesat, but what is more likely is that if you are a normal private citizen who has an idea predicated on having a satellite overhead (think: localized aerial surveys, more accurate GPS, real time weather updates), you will be able to put together the capital needed to get that satellite launched. Personally I'm excited to see the rise of satellite "cloud" services, like AWS, in which one satellite can use its sensors and cameras to serve hundreds of thousands of customers at once. How cool would it be to spend $20/mo to host a global satellite based chat service for you and your friends?
- rkangel 7y agoThey've gone for a large constellation of small satellites with short lives, which is a set of design choices that all feed into each other. Satellites are traditionally designed to last for a long time because they're so expensive to launch. As such they're also expensive to make, and it's slow to iterate on them. Being in low-earth helps the launch cost (on top of the existing SpaceX advances). Putting out 60 per launch helps too.
- teeray 7y agoHonestly, I’m just excited for the more mundane future of having an alternative to Comcast/Spectrum and the corresponding drop in prices that will hopefully come along with it.
- aylmao 7y agoUnfortunate that it is taking the invention of reusable rockets and a huge constellation of satellites to happen. And not just, you know, regulation.
- ogre_codes 7y agoWhat this article didn't mention is the potential for this to significantly disrupt commercial internet monopolies in regional markets. If service is $45/ month for 100GB, a lot of people will drop Comcast in a hurry.
- cold_fact 7y agofuck xfinity. AT&T fiber at my apartment is 300+ mbps up for half the price of comcast's 75+ i've been using last 6 years
- ogre_codes 7y agoThat’s kind of my point, Comcast generally sucks and anyone with a choice avoids them.
- shaklee3 7y agoIt didn't mention it because that's not true. This is targeted for enterprise, and there are no plans to sell cheap internet at the price the antenna costs.
- ogre_codes 7y agoMy understanding is that this would become more widely available as it rolls out, and the article supports this idea as well: > This is not just a game changer for people like you and I, living in relatively populated places struggling against greedy last-mile monopolists So I was wrong that it was omitted, the article explicitly makes it clear that it's going to be a game changer even for people with existing internet. Also it makes it pretty clear that the service is going to affect individual users and not just enterprises: > Starlink means that you can go live in the woods in Siberia if you like > some automakers will likely build them into the roofs of cars or trucks
- shaklee3 7y agoThe article uses no factual basis to back it up, though. In order for it to be competitive against existing internet, it needs to be as cheap. Their current pizza-box phased array antenna was likely too expensive, so now they have a motorized hybrid that moves the phased array on top. That will be significantly more money and less reliable than your existing cable. There are existing solutions, like o3b to cover underserved areas with high speed internet. They pivoted to cruise ships because the equipment is too expensive. If you have a link other than this blog showing otherwise, please provide it.
- TheWoolRug 7y agoThis author and many in the comments seem to have their bits and bytes mixed up.
- sneak 7y agoWhat did I mix up? I believe I quoted all transfer figures in bits/s, as is custom. Edit: oops, those Bs should be lowercase. Will update post soon. Thanks for the bug report!
- atbpaca 7y agoYeah! Let's give internet access to everyone! Let's do that without thinking on the consequences like widespread misinformation and screwing scientific research. But hey, it's good for the business!
- macawfish 7y agoRight now there are only 60 and you can already see them? How about when there are 12,000 or 30,000 or however many they wanna put up there? It's going to cover the entire night sky. I feel claustrophobic just thinking about it. I don't want this and I have a feeling I'm not alone in that.
- spectramax 7y agoWhy? We are covered by thunderstorms, fog and rain; not a problem.
- aylmao 7y agoI'm not. Climate is not global or permanent, but a constellation of satellites like this pretty much is.
- gridspy 7y agoThere is a lot of evidence that the albedo is going to reduce. For one the satellites are climbing higher at the moment. The solar panels are also oriented to catch the light currently as the sun sets. It might not be as bad as you are worried about.
- coding123 7y agoHonestly I hope someone figures out how to shoot these down. I feel like the planet isn't getting a say. In fact only a few people are getting a say that this network should even exist. Astronomy is dead. A dark sky with just stars, yeah dead.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 7y agoAren't the satellites in LEO only visible for a short time after sunset?
- raattgift 7y agoThis landed earlier today. https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10952 https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10952 tl;dr: starlink and its competitors pose serious Earth-based observation problems across the spectrum (§§4.1-4.2) especially for faint variable objects which require long exposures and for which any missed pixels matter. The missed-pixels problems run around the clock, not just when the sattelites are visibly flaring, as do non-visible-spectrum noise problems.
- themeiguoren 7y agoFrom a first-principles perspective, it's baffling to me why this would ever be a serious problem. We know the ephemerides of all objects in Earth orbit, and they are traveling at a fast enough angular speed to not linger in an observational spot. We're not working with long-exposure film here - we can manipulate pixels over time. On a technical level it should be trivial to mask out the pixels where satellites are located at each moment. I think 1% is far too high a guesstimate, but say that artificial satellites end up covering 1% of the full night sky (for context the moon takes up under 0.001% of the sky's area). That still leaves you with 99% observability - hardly an effect on the amount of data you can bring in, especially compared to such problems as clouds. Dead-simple algorithms to erase satellite trails are available for hobbyists right now: https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-blogs/imaging-foundations-richard-wright/satellites-begone-how-to-remove-satellite-trails-from-your-astrophotography/ https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-blogs/imaging-foun... And more complex ones for professional astronomers should still be super simple to implement compared to many of the algorithms astronomers have to wrangle with.
- gitgud 7y ago> Billions of people, blocked from accessing the Internet due to lack of infrastructure or local greed or fraud related to same, are presently kept from participating in the global knowledge economy. Starlink will remedy this, to some extent. Isn't covering the world in a blanket of satellites from a single company the epitome of a global Monopoly? I'm worried about such a future controlled by SpaceX...
- threeseed 7y agoI wouldn't worry about it. If SpaceX does become a monopoly it will simply be treated as a utility and forced to offer FRAND wholesale pricing to anyone who wants it. And the fun part is that SpaceX being global will have to negotiate with each country that it wants to operate in. Good luck with that.
- retrac 7y agoThere are multiple competitors with similar plans on the drawing board already. And unlike with geosynchronous orbit, there's no practical limit to the number of satellites in very low-earth-orbit. If Starlink is profitable, I would fully expect multiple competing networks before long.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoCompetitors won't achieve until there's competition for SpaceX launch service. Bezo seems to be most ahead, but also super far from offering commercial launches.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aylmao 7y ago> Isn't covering the world in a blanket of satellites from a single company the epitome of a global Monopoly? shivers. My gripe with this comment is the subtle neo-colonial undertone it has too. "The world needs saving from their inefficient local authorities! It's their fault other countries don't enjoy the spoils of modernity. Luckily this charitable Westerner will bring you under their efficient global empire... ermm, company".
- kahnjw 7y ago>Connectivity will be the great equalizer in the future. These words could have come from an article about: the internet, mobile phones, telephones, morse code With minor modification also: automobiles, the printing press, the steel plow, airplanes, the cotton gin, antibiotics, etc. None of them were true equalizers, they were incremental steps forward at best.
- nexuist 7y agoThey are not equalizers, they are amplifiers. The steel plow fed a man, the cotton gin clothed him, antibiotics cured his cough and an airplane took him from his old country to a new one where he learned how to drive so he could deliver the morning paper. The goal should never be to lower the ceiling. The goal is to raise the floor.
- apatters 7y agoIs the optimism about being able to bypass censorship really valid? SpaceX may be resistant to the censorship demands of some governments, but a lot of other things need to happen to get someone online. To begin with you need to acquire Starlink's receiver, which probably makes it inaccessible to North Koreans for example, and difficult to acquire for citizens of any country that has efficient import controls. Then you have to use it without being detected. I have no idea whether that is easy or hard -- can you put the receiver in a covert location? Can the government drive a van around your neighborhood and detect signals going to and from the receiver, or triangulate it in some other way? If it bypasses existing censorship infrastructure in a given country and Starlink refuses to comply with censorship, you can guarantee that country will make it illegal, and in some cases introduce some scary penalties for using it (i.e. prison).
- tachyonbeam 7y agoSo, I think you're mostly right, but not for these reasons. People have been sneaking forbidden things past borders for a long time. Think of the drug trade. Every country has a chemical drug trade it seems, even countries where the penalty is death such as Thailand. Then you also have to think that countries like China... Will be the countries making those Starlink receivers, so Chinese people looking to bypass the firewall may not have to get the equipment around any borders. They might be able to pick them up at the back of the factory, or when they "fall off a truck". I also think it might be somewhat difficult to detect and track receivers down. You need specialized equipment to triangulate receivers, multiple vehicles. AFAIK Starling satellites use phased array antennas, which, if I understand correctly, might mean that they can sort of direct a beam towards you, and your dish will be pointed at the sky, not wasting power directing waves in every direction. That makes triangulation significantly harder than it would be for a cellphone. That being said, Elon Musk can't just enable Starlink everywhere. China has enormous political leverage and a powerful military, and Tesla just finished building a new factory there. He can't just give them the middle finger. The official policy will be to either comply with the Chinese filtering rules, or not offer Starlink in China. Still, if Elon does care about censorship, maybe he will leave some kind of backdoor... Maybe it will be surprisingly easy to "crack" your Starlink receiver and set it to a fake country code, and suddenly have access to unfiltered US-region internet from anywhere (think mod chips). Then, China and other countries may not care enough to crack down. People routinely bypass the Chinese firewall using VPNs, and as far as I know, they're not going to prison for it. Hopefully it remains that way.
- alexfromapex 7y agoOnce Starlink is ready everyone needs to ditch Comcast and AT&T since they’ve been screwing us for years
- joak 7y agoFor more technical information, I recommend reading this: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/11/02/star https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/11/02/star link-is-a-very-big-deal/ Strange enough the title is similar: starlink is a very big deal
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y ago> * For reference, my last flat in Berlin (the capital of the largest economy in the EU), on the ground on a main street in the city center, was serviced with approximately 14MBps ADSL, and this was the fastest offering available from any vendor.* That seems really low to me. I was under the impression that Europe had generally better internet access than in the US. Comcast delivers much better speeds than that even to boondocks cities, let alone major metropolitan areas?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tchocky 7y agoIt has. I have 100mb/s in Berlin. Seems that his street is not connected well, or he lives too far away from the distribution node, there is also 1gb/s cable in some streets.
- sneak 7y agoThe location in question was in Skalitzer Strasse, only 50-100m from Lausitzer Platz and Görlitzer Park. I had better connectivity to Freifunk via their churchtower hub in Lausitzer Platz than I did to the actual internet. You'd think something that central would be better connected, especially directly along the U1. Oh well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 7y ago> SpaceX will be pressured by the governments in the jurisdictions where their staff reside (where their physical threats of enforcement can be carried out) to selectively censor/blackout or otherwise wiretap use of the system, ostensibly for military purposes, in another tragic case of stupid, outdated nationalistic thinking trying to force its way into outer space and cyberspace. They will comply, silently and without fanfare, as all of the other telecommunications carriers have, excepting with great recognition the brave Joseph Nacchio, because they don’t want to suffer the same fate he did. Anyone remember the SWANsat project,[0] which was going to use a VPN service[1] as its client gateway? They called it "SWANSAT LIBERTY™ Suite". Somehow, I doubt that Starlink has anything like that in mind. But still, one could use it with any anonymity network, unless that was somehow blocked. 0) http://swansat.com/ http://swansat.com/ 1) https://web.archive.org/web/20100813004230/http://www.swansat.com/liberty.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20100813004230/http://www.swansa...
- ex3ndr 7y agoComparing speed to ADSL is ridiculous. Slow ground internet is not a technology issue, it is a political issue. Even in russia in most major cities everyone (!) have optical (!) fiber directly (!) in their apartment (!). If you want you can get 10GB in your average home. In USA in SF in Bernal Heights i can get RF link with 30mbits at best for ~5x price.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sneak 7y agoThe nice thing about global systems is that they short-circuit all local issues, both tech and political. As someone else pointed out, I anticipate Starlink will benefit even non-subscribers by motivating other providers to minimally compete.
- pmontra 7y ago> SpaceX will be pressured by the governments in the jurisdictions where their staff reside (where their physical threats of enforcement can be carried out) to selectively censor/blackout or otherwise wiretap use of the system, It's easier than that. To provide a low latency service satellites can't just forward the signal to other satellites and beam it down to a base station on the other side of the planet and back. It would take too long. StarLink needs base stations (on Earth) close to the terminals of their users: terminal -> satellite -> base station -> internet -> base station -> satellite -> terminal So if a country doesn't want its citizens to use StarLink it only has to deny permissions to build base stations there. Of course that's useless for small countries with a base station in a nearby country, but it's OK for large countries. Or they could welcome a base station: it will be connected to the local internet and be subject to all the usual monitoring and censorship. A different take to the same issue: probably StarLink has to apply as an ISP in every country they want to service (take money from people there). This means a base station there or not. From [1] > 2019 April - SpaceX files for 6 base stations for Starlink. Locations: North Bend WA, Conrad MT, Merrillan WI, Greenville PA, Redmond WA, Hawthorne CA, Brewster WA > 2020 - Service to be offered across the contiguous United States and Canada [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/wiki/index#wiki_what_kind_of_latency_is_expected.3F_isn.27t_satellite_internet_latency_very_high.3F https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/wiki/index#wiki_what_kind_...
- iso947 7y agoLatency will be lower for intercontinental distances if its forwarded from satellite to satellite, as the signal propagates at light speed in a direct line rather than 2/3rds in a non direct fibre. Inmarsat technocrat offsr broadband to North Korea, they aren’t registered there. Some countries won’t let you import a bgan, but if you do you can get access.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoOn long distances it's faster via Starlink than fiber. Also, Starlink gonna use p2p, so perhaps your solar roof can make extra $$ by providing internet for the rest of the planet.
- Jemm 7y agoLight grey on white is horrible.
- sneak 7y agoI am happily open to alternate suggestions. I am not a designer and my website is a perpetual work-in-progress, so any guidance you can offer there is helpful and appreciated. I used to never post because I didn’t think it was “done” or “ready”, but I decided to ship regularly and work on it as I go. Better is the enemy of good! sneak@sneak.berlin
- gumby 7y agoIn the middle of this document is a reference to Joseph Nacchio who appears to be a rare CEO who was punished for respecting his customers' civil rights. Up until that moment he was lauded as a go-getter CEO. I remember my impression of him at the time was that he was simply a tough CEO who could also be a bit of a jerk to his team. But he refused a government request to break the law and shortly thereafter was arrested. I don't know the merits of the government's case, but it was suspicious that nobody else in his notoriously corrupt industry ever got into trouble for their quite blatant corruption. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Nacchio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Nacchio
- sneak 7y agoHe’s out of jail now. I have always wanted to interview him.
- atatatko 7y agoI'm curious, how Great Chinese Firewall and Russian Censorship Agensy going to fight this threat? Iron dome?
- malux85 7y ago> For reference, my last flat in Berlin (the capital of the largest economy in the EU), on the ground on a main street in the city center, was serviced with approximately 14Mbps ADSL, and this was the fastest offering available from any vendor. I have unmetered gigabit fiber (1G UP 1G DOWN) In london
- specialist 7y agoThe important question here is if Starlink will to generate enough revenue to keep SpaceX solvent. From an analysis I read, there isn't enough external demand for SpaceX to be viable, profitable. So they created their own internal demand as well as a potential alternate revenue stream.