34 ms·
What can you use instead of Google and Facebook?
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoDuckDuckGo is really changing my world. It’s like I’m seeing a whole other internet I was missing before with Google search results. I get much more relevant answers and less SEO targeted garbage that says all the right words usually while saying nothing at all. I was skeptical, but I encourage you to give it a try if you haven’t before.
- 300bps 7y agoAnd the first page of results isn’t mostly ads.
- okasaki 7y ago... yet,
- edm0nd 7y agoDDG is awesome. They have been experiencing a surge of growth, https://duckduckgo.com/traffic https://duckduckgo.com/traffic Yandex is another site I've been using for reverse image searches. I find it to be better than Google and Bing. Bellingcat has a great article on it, https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/how-tos/2019/12/26/guide-to-using-reverse-image-search-for-investigations/ https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/how-tos/2019/12/26/guid...
- kazinator 7y agoDDG fails on "Single Unix Specification Issue 7". Google takes you straight to the online installation at https://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/ https://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/ DDG finds this: https://publications.opengroup.org/c181 https://publications.opengroup.org/c181 where the "Read HTML Edition Online" button is a non-working dud. Still switching to DDG for most searches, though.
- sgolecha 7y agoMy wife still uses Google as her default search engine on her phone while I switched to DDG years ago. I dread using her phone to search anything.
- psv1 7y ago> I was skeptical, but I encourage you to give it a try if you haven’t before. I have - I found the results far less useful than Google's, the whole experience far more frustrating and it noticeably slowed down my work.
- paulgb 7y agoI find it's a mixed bag -- sometimes DDG is better, sometimes Google is. It kind of reminds me of the old days pre-Google-dominance when you'd try Alta Vista and then Lycos or Excite if you didn't get what you were looking for. Cynically, I wonder if Google has gotten to the point where they realize that serving the absolute most relevant results means they sell less ads. Of course, I don't think anyone is ordered not to make search quality better, just that incentives/resources get reallocated to things other than ten-blue-link quality.
- m-watson 7y agoI agree entirely with how you described the search experience. I would often try three or four ways to get a website I wanted back in the day. I am finding myself learning what search engines I like more for specific types of searches. Some times that means google, some times DDG, and who knows throw Bing int here.
- druddha 7y agoI agree that the DDG results, especially for software development related searches, are often worse than searching Google or StackOverflow directly. So here's my workflow: 1. Search DDG. If I find a decent result, I stop here. 2. Append !so to the end of the search. This searches StackOverflow directly. If this works, I stop here. 3. Append !g to the end of the search. This searches Google directly. This way Google becomes a last resort. Also worth noting that you can actually navigate DDG search results using vim keybindings without the need for a plugin: something Google dropped support for a few years ago.
- psv1 7y agoMy concern about Google isn't big enough to justify going through this.
- bitL 7y agoI tend to switch over to Qwant when DDG fails to deliver sometimes. That combo works quite well.
- drewmol 7y agoUsing DDG with Bangs ( add '!G' to a search string to query google, '!W' for Wikipedia, etc.) has really eased my transition.
- citizenkeen 7y agoWhen somebody brings up DDG's bangs, someone else will often chime in "yeah, but you can make your own in browsers so who cares?" That was often my response. But the fact that there are community-maintained bangs is really nice. Bangs for all kinds of websites I probably wouldn't have made, but there they are. And since I'm often jumping on new computers, I don't need to bring/import my preferences. Just change the browser's search to DDG, then all my known bangs (and unknown!) are there.
- baddox 7y agoI don't think that's the best criticism of bangs. The best criticism is that your query already gives you what you want if you just type it into Google without the bang.
- Joeri 7y agoSame for me. It’s “good enough” and the results page is cleaner. I used to get poor results for dev topics and image search but both have improved over time. I only use google for shopping searches, because it gives me better results for my country (belgium).
- reaperducer 7y agoI'm at about 90% Duck these days, and 10% Google. But I'm not sure it's because Duck got better, or because Google got worse. Google's results just seem less and less useful for the kinds of searches I do. A recent example: There was a news event near where I live earlier this week. It made national headlines briefly. Yesterday I wanted to know if there was anything new about it. So I hit the duck with my search query and it showed newspaper web sites that had updated the story about three hours before, and some TV web sites that had stories from the previous night. I wanted to make sure I wasn't missing anything, so I did the same search in Google. Big G's results were all at least three days old, and most were re-posts of re-posts of re-posts published on random web sites on the other side of the planet. So, I continue to use the duck. And I've learned a lesson that I really shouldn't second-guess myself and think that maybe Google, with its trillion dollars to spend, isn't any better after all.
- ogre_codes 7y agoGoogle got too polluted with adverts it became intolerable. More or less across the board.
- stanferder 7y agoSomeone should start a company called "Google 2010".
- DudeIsJammin 7y agoI think google has stayed the same for the most part. But because they want to crack down on misinformation, and things of that nature they have said recently that when it comes to political topics/news they want to stick to "trusted" sources. That's why if you search for a political topic on google/youtube, you're probably not going to get many non mainstream sources
- krisgee 7y agoI use Duck for most searches now but I find if I'm trying to ask a question or search weird error codes or something Google is still better for that. I still use duck to input but use the g! command.
- chx 7y agoSo I need a 1m long C7-C8 extension cord. Not a 30cm, not a 50cm, not a 1.8m, I need 1m long. Let's search: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=c7+c8+extension+cord+%221m%22&t=h_&ia=shopping https://duckduckgo.com/?q=c7+c8+extension+cord+%221m%22&t=h_... let's force the titles: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=intitle%3Ac7+intitle%3Ac8+extension+cord+intitle%3A1m&t=h_&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=intitle%3Ac7+intitle%3Ac8+extensio... That's completely broken, the titles contain none of the three things asked for. yeah, I am not hopeful with duckduckgo either. I mean, Google is just as bad but I am pretty dismayed by the results these days.
- bitL 7y agoDDG's quality actually decreased in the past year as now they seem to ignore explicitly required stuff in a query quite often. It used to be you just used quotes and got what you wanted, but these days that might get ignored. "-" for excluding similar popular words also seems to have stopped working.
- y-c-o-m-b 7y agoI thought it was just me remembering incorrectly if DDG supported quotes and includes. Could have sworn this worked before. Thanks for confirming you're also having this problem.
- LegitShady 7y agoif you put a space between 1 and m your results get better.
- rikkus 7y agoFirst result for me on DDG is that very thing on Amazon.co.uk
- conception 7y agoIf you do need google Startpage.com is anonymized google.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TheRealDunkirk 7y agoI'm consistently surprised that this comment comes up here so often. I've tried DDG at length, many times, and I always go back to Google because I find it SO much better for programming-related questions. Maybe the denizens of HN are accustomed to using SO's built-in search? But that's still only a piece of the larger puzzle. I get a lot of mileage from blog posts as well.
- thrwaway69 7y agoYou are not alone. It highly depends on what you search for even if it's programming related. Google provides great results for common old-ish and repeated questions but you will notice less diversity - which can be pretty frustrating when you aren't looking for a definite answer. You will find that it will give you old results from w3schools, codeacademy, SO, etc. Some of which shouldn't go into production...
- djsumdog 7y agoJust set your default to DDG and, when you can't find something, search again with "!g". DDG also lets you jump to specific sites ("!w for the pedia, !yt for the Youboobs, !imdb, !rt, etc).
- s_dev 7y agoYou're not missing anything. Google is far better than DDG and I'm shocked people claim otherwise because it's so fairly self evident. That said I try to use DDG when I can but I don't lie to myself that I'm using it because it has better results -- it doesn't. It has better approach to privacy and thats why I use it. The fact that they know less about the searcher intrinsitcally means the results of searches will be worse.
- Crash0v3rid3 7y agoI sometimes feel that we are in this echo chamber. These threads always follow the same patterns, someone asks if they know of an alternative search engine and a HNer quickly mentions they have gone to DDG and haven't looked back. DDG is decent but not even close to the search quality of Google. I know the folks here want to see Google dethroned but DDG won't do it.
- jerf 7y agoI find myself increasingly wishing they'd have some sort of subscription or something. Even if it did nothing to start, I'd like to be a customer, instead of an eyeball. Otherwise as nice as it is now, it's still inevitably headed down the same trajectory as Google, just not as far along yet.
- monsieurgaufre 7y agoDDG is bad as soon as you're not in the US of A and/or speak any language that is not english.
- djsumdog 7y agoWhat about Russian? I'm not sure if they still do, but at one point they licensed a large chunk of their index from Yandex.
- monsieurgaufre 7y agoAs I don't speak russian, I can't answer you.
- Nextgrid 7y agoNo idea but I’d be curious to know the answer.
- jredwards 7y agoIt's not very good for english speakers in the US, either. The bang syntax is fantastic, but the search results are crap. Didn't someone demonstrate pretty conclusively that underneath all of the specialization it was just bing?
- Crash0v3rid3 7y agoIt's Bing and a few other sources. They also claim to have their own web crawler but I've never seen it crawl any of my pages before.
- bobbylarrybobby 7y agoDuckDuckGo can't even answer simple queries like "how old is Donald Trump", "president of France", "how tall is the Eiffel Tower", "distance from earth to Moon", and "distance from earth to sun"; it forces you to search its results for the answer. For all of queries, Google and Bing give you the answer front and center without making you click links or read the result snippets. Bing even has an interactive solar system viewer when you search for that last query. These days search engines are supposed to be able to surface and present information from sources without user intervention. DuckDuckGo cannot do this (yet).
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoNeither did Google back in the early 2000s. But people still used it and loved it. I would say DDG2019=Google2007 or better in terms of search quality. Instead of thinking that I must use the best search engine, regardless of the ethics of its business model; think that I will use the good enough search engine from among those with ethical business models. Edit: I would additionally like to add that Google's search quality peaked early to mid 2010s, so DDG is not far from peak known search engine quality.
- baddox 7y agoPeople got along just fine before the Internet existed too. This mode of argument is not particularly constructive.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoJust tried. PoFrance: answered in first 3 blurbs (link not needed). Eiffel: 1st three. Moon distance: Fifth. DDG will answer some directly, like "10 feet to meters". Could be better.
- monkeynotes 7y agoI tried DDG, I actually try it out intermittently. I ditched it again, this time because when I searched for an address it doesn't seem to scope the results to where I am located and gives me a similar address somewhere else. Small little things like that are a pain to work around and something I take for granted in Google search. It's taken a long time for Google to get so good at what it does. I notice that if I am watching a YouTube video and then go to Google to search for something related, the autocomplete basically knows what I am likely to search for. Say what you will about that but it is pretty amazing technology.
- pawelk 7y agoTo each their own. The things you have listed as advantages of Google are basically the same reasons I do my best to stay away.
- monkeynotes 7y agoI totally get that. It's a paradox that to have super useful search results you step very close to the edge of what's acceptable for the search provider to know about you. The amount of shit Google knows about me is quite honestly frightening. Google has over 10 years of my emails. That alone is more than most people know about me. Then there is years of search history, and location history (yes, I have both enabled). And finally a Google home in almost every room in the house. Oh, and a Pixel phone. And Google drive, photos... You get the idea. I think at this point it's too late to save my privacy. I am apathetic and resigned to hoping the future isn't as dystopian as it is often feared to be.
- senthil_rajasek 7y agoWhy are Google and Facebook in the same jail? What breach of privacy is Google guilty of?
- prophesi 7y agoHistorically speaking, Google is the one who innovates ground-breaking privacy-violating technology, and Facebook copies them a year or two later with much less tact.
- senthil_rajasek 7y agoName the privacy violating technology. How and please be specific. I can give examples of FB violating user privacy. Cambridge Analytica.
- prophesi 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_concerns_regarding_Google https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_concerns_regarding_Goo... They are the pioneers of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveillance_capitalism For specific technologies: Their search engine. Their Ad network. Google Maps / StreetView. Android OS. Google Home. Google Nest. Google Chrome. Chromebooks.
- newscracker 7y agoThere are too many to list. An online search is a better idea. Here are two instances: Google was (and probably still is) tracking your location on Android even when you turned off location services and storing it against your account. Google signed you in automatically into Chrome whenever you signed in to a Google property. This change removed the ability to keep your Chrome browsing data strictly locally. After some Internet outrage, this was reversed.
- rezeroed 7y ago"About – Senthil Rajasekharan Senthil Rajasekharan is a standup comedian from Minneapolis/St. Paul who started doing comedy in 2010."
- anderspitman 7y agoGoogle is relatively straight forward to replace. Inexpensive 80% solutions exist for most of their services. Maps is a notable exception. As for Facebook you're fighting against the greatest network effects in the history of mankind.
- arkitaip 7y agoI had zero issues quitting Facebook but replacing Gmail and Android? That's going to be really tough considering Gmail is my online identify hub and Android facilitates so many utility services (banking, electronic identification, money transfers, etc).
- anderspitman 7y agoRegister a domain if you don't already have one and get Fastmail for 5 USD/mo (includes a calendar as well). If Gmail.com is your online identity hub, then you're not in control of your online identity.
- arkitaip 7y agoRight but what about Android? What's the point of setting up email at my own domain - which I already have - when Google can track everything through Android?
- anderspitman 7y agoHey you're not wrong there. It's atrocious what Google has done to Linux on Android. We badly need an alternative smartphone that's actually built to be a tool rather than an ad optimization platform. Apple is better on that front, but they also want to ram their vision of what a computer is down your throat.
- bluGill 7y agoBetween firefix, duck duck go, and gmail used only to register the phone: google doesn't have much on me anymore. They still have too much thanks to all the trackers (firefox is getting better at blocking) but much less. Now if I could get people to put useful videos someplace other than youtube.
- Damogran6 7y agoIncreasingly, all Google is learning about me is the junk mail. I get 150 emails a day and one legitimate one everty two to three days. The rest of it is Youtube notifications and newegg sales.
- iamdamian 7y agoHere’s a question: How do we adopt a replacement and avoid creating an identical situation in 10 years? I wonder how many people donate to/pay for/enable ads on DuckDuckGo, for example.
- anderspitman 7y agoIncentives have to be aligned. Open protocols at a minimum.
- codebook 7y agoThis. Why ppl can move to another email provider? Because email protocol is public! (even some tricky protocols are added such as DKIM) So, I hope any new social platform or communication platform has a public interface.to communicate with its replica. Mastodon can be an example but it is not widely spread yet .
- iamdamian 7y agoHow will an open protocol help prevent this search issue in the future?
- laurex 7y ago(As someone working on an actual alternative to Facebook,) this article seems to mention FB but only really present Google alternatives. That said, I've switched all my default search engines to DDG, which would be even more great if I didn't have to type -yelp for most of my searches.
- have_faith 7y ago> working on an actual alternative to Facebook Ditto, would love to hear what direction you're taking it in?
- laurex 7y agoThe product (not "mine," I'm a part of the team) has millions of users and ridiculously high review scores. We don't have ads or sell user data, but we make it possible for families and close friends to have real relationships despite scheduling issues or different time zones. If you haven't heard of this product, it may be because it's a family-oriented app with less tech-world adoption than mom-adoption. But fundamentally, it's not about feeds, because there's really not a way I can see that that type of UI doesn't take you down a rabbit hole rather than into a positive feeling about yourself and your relationships.
- josefresco 7y agoAs much as I appreciate DDG getting more press, this article is low quality. No alternatives to Facebook are mentioned, only that you can use Signal, & ProtonMail instead of WhatsApp.
- anderspitman 7y agoThere's still no realistic alternative to FB. It's a social network, not a service.
- westpfelia 7y agoTitle mentions alternatives to Facebook, but then doesn't list one? For anyone looking for something there is Diaspora. For a twitter alternative check out Mastodon.
- snisarenko 7y agoAlso If you have hard time figuring out which mastodon instance to join, I am working on a mastodon aggregator, to help you browse through the content without registering. https://mastodonia.club https://mastodonia.club
- have_faith 7y agoI'm actually building an alternative to Facebook for people fed up with Facebook and just want to stay in touch with people and not much more. I would go as far as calling it a glorified address book with some extra features for having up-to-date contact details for everyone that has granted you the privilege of having them and a very cut down version of the feed. Which brings me to the question of monetisation. I don't want ads or data collection of any kind so my first thought is to have a basic free account and a cheap premium account that lets you upload and share photo albums and that sort of thing. Thoughts on this strategy or possible privacy respecting alternatives?
- anderspitman 7y agoFWIW, I'll almost certainly never use another social network that's not open source, or at the very least built on simple open protocols. Best of luck.
- have_faith 7y agoI respect the stance, and it's not an avenue that I've ruled out, but it's not a priority for me for the moment. Especially with the primary concerns that I'm addressing at first is the destructive incentive structure constructed by ad and data supported social networks.
- ori_b 7y agoMonetization is a perverse incentive. I'm willing to run my own services, maybe pay someone to host for me, but I don't want a company with an incentive to maximize eyeball time.
- have_faith 7y agoHaving every single user run and manage their own software or pay another service to run it for them doesn't seem practical or efficient to me but I would be interested in ideas to the contrary.
- maxk42 7y ago
- u801e 7y agoDuckDuckGo, IRC, and usenet would work.
- zzo38computer 7y agoYes, I use IRC and Usenet; I suggest these and also Unusenet (which, like Usenet, is based on NNTP and can be used with NNTP software). Search is the only function of Google that I use, although I do not need to make searches on Google much. Sometimes I find what I want on Wikipedia, sometimes in local documentations (in man pages and so on), sometimes bookmarked stuff, etc. So, I do not need the Google search so much, but sometimes it is helpful (and sometimes it is worthless; I try to find something but whether I try Google or DuckDuckGo, I cannot find any).
- reaperducer 7y agoThe article talks mostly about e-mail and search, but you know what's still the best social network on the interwebs? E-mail. When I dumped social media two years ago, I gave my "friends" my e-mail address. Now, instead of getting an endless stream of reposted political image captions and photos of people's lunches I get messages about the things that are actually worth seeing: news about family, friends, life events, funny stories — all without the dross and anger-inducing cruft of a social media "feed." E-mail has all of the benefits of social media: photos, group chat, near-instant delivery; with none of the drawbacks: tracking, advertising, stalking, third-party influences. More importantly, what happened is that I found out who my actual friends are. I think the whole social media "friends" button has cheapened the word. We don't make a distinction between friends, acquaintances, associates, and people we just know. Your real friends will e-mail you.
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoRun your own! https://runyourown.social/ https://runyourown.social/ Federated social media could be the solution.
- ori_b 7y agoSolution to what problem?
- icebadger 7y ago> tracking, advertising, stalking, third-party influences
- ori_b 7y agoI wasn't aware those were problems with email.
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoBecause you just discovered computers, apparently.
- fortran77 7y agoDuckDuckGo and nothing.
- chewz 7y agoNothing is actually very decent alternative to facebook. I am using it for seven years now.
- suyash 7y agowhat's a good alternative to gmail?
- rajasimon 7y agoRegister your own domain name and use superhuman or any email client. This is the best way.
- prophesi 7y agoFor email clients, Thunderbird on desktop, FairEmail on Android. All open-source. It should be pretty straightforward for them to deduce what your Gmail SMTP settings are, and you'll be able to add your emails from other providers as well. If you mean actual email providers, that'll be a bit harder to find. Most of the good ones don't have a free tier. FastMail is solid. ProtonMail has a free tier, but you have to pay to access the IMAP/SMTP bridge (which lets you use it with Thunderbird/FairEmail).
- gravitas 7y agoOne thing that many don't talk about - what about Contacts, presuming we're using the Google Contacts integration? Email for me is kind of useless without being able to manage Contacts right alongside it, which Google integrates extremely well on Android.
- prophesi 7y agoYeah, that's very true. I'm not sure what good alternatives there are for Contacts/Calendar/etc. You'd need to find a good service that can sync your CalDAV/CardDavs, as the best part about Google's Contacts is that you simply need to login to your account to get them all back on a new device. I personally run my own NextCloud instance for that, which is obviously not a viable option for those without the time or technical skills to maintain that.
- hellofunk 7y ago> Google knows everything you have ever searched for I thought this was an optional setting. It shouldn’t be saving or collecting this data if you have that turned off in your Google account. Hope so!
- zakember 7y agoI would assume that while they don't tie your search with your username (when you turn it off), they would still store it anonymously to your location, IP address, browser, etc. to 'improve their results using Machine Learning'. Theoretically, this could be used to identify you if all those parameters were unique to you
- 0xff00ffee 7y agohttps://runyourown.social/ https://runyourown.social/
- stiray 7y agoSwitch to own hosted searx instance. http://asciimoo.github.io/searx/admin/installation.html http://asciimoo.github.io/searx/admin/installation.html One search is sent to multiple search engines and results shown as one. Just go to settings and select qwant and ddg.
- DavideNL 7y agoIf it's own hosted, what's the difference? Whether i send queries to Google from my browser, or from my own hosted Searx instance, it's the same thing: a query from one of my static ip-addresses to Google (or other search engines.) It seems to only make sense if this Searx instance is public and your queries are mixed with others. And in that case you have to trust whoever runs this Searx instance won't sell your data just like Google does.
- scambier 7y agoInstall it on a VPN?
- DavideNL 7y agoThen why use Searx, i might as well use a VPN + Firefox.
- stiray 7y agoYou got point in your scenario it is just convinient (it still prevents fingerprinting) In mine it mixes 5 people search, is using proxy that goes over vpn to shared ip on other side of europe. And it agregates results, sorts them by results on multiple search engines not just one.
- DavideNL 7y ago> it still prevents fingerprinting I seriously doubt that, because the % of people using Searx is very small compared to for example Chrome. This should make you very unique in terms of fingerprinting. Also note that simply changing the User Agent is possible in a browser as well, you don't need a self hosted Searx for that.
- annadane 7y agoIt's not fair to the public that FB bought up Insta/Whatsapp. That is a true lack of choice. If it were just FB, fine, ignore it, don't use it, use Whatsapp. But no, they get to buy up competition whilst telling us how much our privacy and integrity is taken seriously
- fredley 7y agoFacebook and Insta I can (and do!) live without. Whatsapp though, is the main method of communication, and particularly group communication for all of my friends. It's almost impossible to leave.
- dadarepublic 7y agoI empathize. It's the same situation in reverse for many people. The social networks I'm on is where my friends and/or fam are at. It becomes very hard to leave once you've imprinted your social network onto a social network platform. A very common situation.
- aloukissas 7y agoI've converted most of my friends to Signal. Easy switch. [edit] The native desktop app is even better than WhatsApp's (doesn't stream data from your phone).
- vonquant 7y agoI'd say you were a lucky one. Persuading my contacts to move and explaining my rationale has been a long, arduous and still not quite complete process. People seem to struggle with envisaging how a lack of privacy will harm them personally.
- h4waii 7y agoI've also got most to switch to Signal. On Android, it's much easier as it can handle both SMS and Signal messages, so there's much less friction for usage. Group chats are also fairly decent on Signal, I just wish there was a way for an "admin" to exist to moderate users in the group.
- snpriyanshu 7y agoWhat can we use instead of the BBC and NYTimes?
- progx 7y agoWhy must i use facebook? A search engine, ok, but facebook?
- newscracker 7y agoSo you can avoid using a search engine and just ask your “friends” on Facebook whatever you want an answer for and benefit from their collective wisdom? The answers may not be instantaneous, but you’d be connecting with humans instead of with machines. /sarcasm
- ogre_codes 7y agoAfter ditching Facebook for the past month I’ve realized it doesn’t really need a replacement for it’s primary features. For talking to friends I just use messenger and email more, plus I have a blog and I do occasionally cross post blog posts to Facebook. Google is fairly easy to replace. Aside from occasional second-opinion searches the only google service I use is Gmail and that only from remote clients... I should replace it but I’m just a bit lazy.
- aquaticsunset 7y agoI'm in the same boat. Left Facebook years ago and realized I was naturally going to keep up with people in my social circles anyway. Email, text, and group messages make it a little bit harder, but the interaction is so meaningful instead of an all you can eat buffet of "social interaction".
- SitePrice 7y agoYes I also use DuckDuckGo, just a pity that it's not as well known
- dogma1138 7y agoA better question is how you use or create an alternative to X without becoming X in the long run. Facebook is kings because of its market share which is why people use it. There are ways of communicating with a close group of friends that don’t involve social media but for people who want to keep in touch with a large social circle there is really no alternative. And far as the gmail replacement goes then it’s by far the easiest thing to find an alternative for and also probably the least important one. I have a feeling that people who rely heavily on emails to stay in touch also probably don’t use social media so Facebook isn’t an issue for them. However the problem is that due social pressure it’s a most impossible to drop from a platform without having it affecting your relationships. Sure people switch as groups and slowly migrate from one platform to another but overall trying to drop X for Y tends result in you using both or quickly switching back.
- Priem19 7y agoHe mentions Brave browser, but Vivaldi browser combined with uBlock Origin (and uMatrix if you're savvy enough) works best for me as I want nothing to do with ads. Telegram is another fantastic messenger. Concerning social media, you don't really need it: https://www.quitfacebook.org https://www.quitfacebook.org.
- capableweb 7y agoWorth noting that Brave is a open source browser while Vivaldi is not.
- lloydde 7y agoI’m excited by the https://planetary.social/ https://planetary.social/ announcement this week. “We’re building an open and humane alternative to Facebook” https://mobile.twitter.com/rabble/status/1220075601337315328 https://mobile.twitter.com/rabble/status/1220075601337315328
- subpixel 7y ago> Revenue for creators > Keep some posts back for paid subscribers. This is not what I want in a Facebook alternative.
- 0ld 7y ago> If you want to get started with Planetary, the first thing you need to do is download the app from the Apple App Store. [0] Seriously? And they call this "planetary"? [0] https://planetarysupport.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/360036491114-Getting-started https://planetarysupport.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/36003...
- rajasimon 7y agoI don't have Facebook account and I'm happy with it. Now I"m using only Whatsapp because of all our family in there. I will get rid of whatsapp in few months. And I'm okay with duckduckgo.
- muzani 7y agoSocial media is about the social aspects, the media aspects, or a little of both. HN and news aggregators covers the media aspect just fine. Social is a lot harder - you want to know what your old classmates are up to and what interests them.
- choward 7y ago> you want to know what your old classmates are up to and what interests them Honestly, no I don't.
- fuball63 7y agoI'm attempting to start a forum for my friend group using good ole phpbb. Its been an interesting challenge trying to get adoption, but as more of us are dropping facebook, we need a place to coordinate events. It's been a fun experiment so far.
- neiman 7y agoFor IM there are too many alternatives to count. For search there are a few, DDG is the best known imo, however, none of them is as good as Google's search engine, especially when it comes to Hebrew (my mother tongue). As for Facebook itself, the problem is that it's offering now a combination of social media, photo storage, discussion groups and an IM platform - to name a few. It's not easy to make an alternative to something so complex.
- kodt 7y agoWhen 90% of the people you email are on Gmail or GSuite does Proton mail really help? Yeah you get end to end encryption for other Proton mail users, but I don't know a single one. Google is going to have all of my emails anyway. As for Facebook it is best just to quit. I don't even use Facebook to keep in touch with friends anymore. The value in Facebook is some of the groups. Local neighborhood groups seem to be the best source of information or things happening around your area if you care to know about it. Also different hobbies/interests have local FB groups that are the most active place for discussion with far more users than a small subreddit or dying forum community. Perhaps I am old but I don't know a single person that uses Whatsapp or Signal. Everyone just uses old fashioned SMS or iMessage if they have iPhones.
- Jommi 7y agoYou're living in a US bubble.
- kodt 7y agoI admit that but switching to Signal does me no good if no-one I know uses it. I am not saying no-one should switch.
- brewdad 7y agoAt least Signal is seamless once you set it up. I use it for all of my SMS/MMS messages even though my immediate family and a couple of other contacts are the only Signal users I text.
- philligr 7y agoI'd like to get my friends and family on Signal or Riot but I can't get anyone to use them. Everyone uses SMS (or talks about using Whatsapp but might or might not actually). I was using Google Hangouts long before Whatsapp or Signal started being taken up and now they assume that's what I'd prefer, like that's how I should be communicated with, even when I'd prefer something else. It's strange.
- 7y ago
- muks 7y agoI wish well-done XMPP/Jabber clients that do voice come up. If you are an XMPP protocol developer / implementer reading this, thank you for what is there so far. Please don't stop. If you have been watching the news this week about Jeff Bezos.. I don't like that someone can share a message/picture/video on WhatsApp and crack into a phone. There are too many closed source vendor components in an Android phone even if you're using an open source phone OS like Lineage OS, and these may go stale over time or have something vulnerable in them on purpose. WhatsApp always seems to need a phone. It works in a web browser in an inconvenient manner that still needs the phone to login. It is a centrally controlled system. While Signal is open source, it is also centrally controlled. I prefer and hope Jabber implementations get much better. Spam for Jabber can be managed the way it is managed for email. Some spam would get through, but it does on WhatsApp too. Email hasn't gone away or lost its place because it's federated (distributed). It works on multiple platforms, and if you don't like a particular way of doing email, there are a lot of choices. Jabber is similar for instant messaging, but it can do with a renaissance. (I use Jabber at work and home, but the clients I use such as Conversations don't have the features and experience that WhatsApp/Telegram do.) The oldest and most used services are federated - HTTP, email.. and at the start of a communication - DNS. WhatsApp, Facebook, etc. are very entrenched services. It's not enough that you move from WhatsApp - your family, friends, businesses that you work with, all have to use the new service you are switching to, so you can chat with them on that other service. It's easier to switch your search engine. :) DuckDuckGo has worked very well for web search for me. I use it about 95% of the time and Google Search the other 5%.
- FpUser 7y agoGoogle maps with Street View, Translate and Search are 3 things I would not want to loose. FB - If it disappears tomorrow I would not even notice.
- pgcj_poster 7y agoIf it supports the languages you use, deepl.com is as good or better than Google Translate these days.
- VikingCoder 7y agoI'm pretty sure the next thing I want to use is very similar to sandstorm.io, but instead of apps being centralized, they're federated. The OS will moderate the connections between services. The services will just see messages and contacts.
- freeAgent 7y agoUnfortunately, it's a lot more difficult to fully switch away from Google than this article gets into. If you use a smartphone, your only real options for OS are Apple and Google. Sure, one can install a custom ROM on an Android phone, but that is well beyond the scope of most people's interest or ability, not to mention that it would lead to warranty issues. If you're using a stock Android phone, Google will know where you all at all times with extreme precision.
- dbingham 7y agoWe need a replacement for the universal public forum. In my community, Facebook has essentially become the public square. It's where most of the local public political dialog happens. It's where I get my local news, it's where I find out what my local representatives are doing, and it's where I can converse with them - and the rest of the community - about what local government should be doing. This is all so valuable that I just can't walk away from it. I would be completely cut out of local events. The news media does an extremely poor job of reporting - and we have an unusually vibrant local news sector (I think in no small part because we have such an active political and governance community on Facebook). So much of it is network effect, I just don't even know how we'd go about creating it in a new service, even if a new service were created that served the purpose better.
- lazyjones 7y agoYour local news sector has no community/forum functionality?
- irrational 7y agoI've never used Facebook (or Instagram or any other Facebook technology - as a web developer I've even eschewed React in favor of Vue), so I'd say you don't need anything instead of Facebook. Google on the other hand is a bit tougher for me. I use Firefox instead of Chrome. DuckDuckGo instead of Google Search. iPhone instead of Android. Apple Maps instead of Google Maps. I still use Google Docs, but only for working on files with coworkers - I don't have anything personal in Google Docs (I use a variety of other tools like Evernote and Excel for personal stuff). The one I'd like to move away from, but haven't found a good replacement, is Mail.
- auiya 7y agoIf you use the Internet, you'll never fully cut Google out of your life. They have their tendrils in damn near every aspect of the Internet whether you know it or not. https://gizmodo.com/i-cut-google-out-of-my-life-it-screwed-up-everything-1830565500 https://gizmodo.com/i-cut-google-out-of-my-life-it-screwed-u...
- StreamBright 7y agoI am pretty much planning on stopping to use the web at all. The only two sites I would really miss are Wikipedia and StackOverflow. Google's search results got shittier and shittier over the years, and facebook took content filtering to the next level of stupidity while making it possible to spread anti-vaxing propaganda on an unprecedented scale.
- riffic 7y agoNews media (the bbc, for one huge prime example) can put resources behind its own implementation of ActivityPub. It would be smart to do so.
- hkai 7y agoPeople I know are switching to Chinese messaging apps and social networks. There's less negative coverage about them even though their privacy practices may be slightly worse.
- silentsea90 7y agoHow does search work for end to end encrypted apps/email? If they can't read it, they can't index it either. Does the index live locally?
- chillacy 7y agoBefore IMAP, people stored their own mailboxes locally. I imagine you'd just build local search indexes like Thunderbird back in the day.
- tyfon 7y agoMy extended family and I are using diasp.eu (a diaspora pod) with paid accounts. So far it's been working fine, we only need it to share photos in a closed environment. I haven't had an account at facebook since around 2012.
- capableweb 7y agoHow to you convince the entire extended family that they should use a paid account for something they can do for free, working (functionally on the surface) the exact same way?
- pramodzion 7y agoI know this is not an exact replacement for Facebook, but y'all should check https://storry.io https://storry.io We are also planning to add a lot of cool features including end-to-end encrypted chat system.
- kerkeslager 7y agoSearch: DDG is the obvious answer. But also reducing usage of general search is a major life improvement. Wikipedia and Stack Overflow have reasonable built-in searches, as do most sites I view as reasonable sources of information. Most discoverability comes from feeds (blogs, HN, Reddit)--searching limits you to terms you've already thought of. General search seems to lead either to the places already mentioned in good cases, and to low-quality results that waste time and mislead you in bad cases. You can save time and improve thought process by going more directly to sources. Email: Fastmail. But again, just using email less is helpful. My most common form of communication is using text messages to set up meeting in person. Facebook: Does this even need a replacement? I haven't made any intentional effort to replace Facebook since I stopped using it, and don't feel any sense of loss. The same goes for Twitter/Instagram. The only thing these services ever did for me was make me feel angry, lonely, or inadequate. Random side note: Stack Overflow has a serious content quality and up-to-date-ness issue. An alternative is using documentation, reading code, and mastering debuggers/REPLs. This gives you a much better understanding of your tools, and gives you much better solutions as a result.
- fossuser 7y agoGeneral search is still valuable for finding random programming examples that don't appear on Stack Overflow - there are a lot of blogs that usually have some helpful example. For FB if there was something that allowed event planning, but didn't require people to create accounts for it (basically event planning with RSVPs, but handled through email or text). It'd be nice if this extended to optional accounts that had up to date contact information - this is the main thing I'd worry about missing (though I think Apple could just implement this by optionally pushing changes to the people in your phone with your contact information when it changes). For Twitter - there's a lot of value if you curate people you're interested in and engage with their tweets. People you would otherwise have no access to and interesting discussions/links/discovery happen there. Twitter can be great, but requires some effort. I think this would be helped by 'index lists' of users that are interesting to follow for new people (though this would cause a similar bubble issue that financial indexes have) but at the moment looking at someone you find interesting for who they follow is a decent way to find people.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoI started thinking about blocking Google shortly after I (think it was on Google Earth) got shown my current location as a picture of the parking lot outside the apartment I was sitting in. The pix looked like it was taken from 50 feet up. The clincher: G+ insisting I start using my real name on a 4-year-old Blogger account. SiyoNAHra.
- jonathankoren 7y agoA google alternative to gcal would be great
- DayDollar 7y agoHow can you escape network effects? Not at all. Thats what they are. You cant force the public to leave this abusive relationship with a privately owned main street. The only thing that could do that- is another layer around the whole eco-system, that subverts it and surplants it. I can not see anyone of the alternatives trying this. Those who pose a real danger (instagram, using the want for generational different medias) are bought. The only way to escape, is to encourage institutional blindness in big companys. Convince microsoft that a desktop windows needs to be on there cellphones and tablets. Convince google that no product except of search is actually viable- and these little turtles should all die fast before even reaching the ocean. Tell facebook, that all that is longterm sellable is user-data, not user-usefullness. The best way to archieve a new competitor, is internal self-sabotage of market dominant forces.
- paulhodge 7y agoIt's pretty hard to 100% replace Facebook, but a more feasible strategy is a gradual/piecewise approach. Opt for non-Facebook alternatives for certain tasks when you can. Like if you're going to share a photo album with family, you could always email them a link to Flickr/Dropbox/etc instead. Anything that reduces Facebook usage is good.
- nif2ee 7y agoHow many organized shilling posts for DDG are enough, @dang? isn't 3 in the top page within 72 hours enough for you or you people too get paid for it? I am really not surprised that this journalist, just like most who get paid under the table, shilled for 3 of the most disgusting tabloid-tier tech companies of our time with the most aggressive marketing and astroturfing techniques in one article.
- known 7y agohttps://prism-break.org/en/all/ https://prism-break.org/en/all/ is comprehensive
- bananamerica 7y agoFor me, Facebook is useless I could easily avoid Google if I had to. But WhatsApp is frequently unescapable.
- acd 7y agoAlternative to social media. See real people in the real world. The social interaction will make you and others happier. Call people via voice instead of texting them its more personal. Alternative to Google: Use Duckduckgo and a VPN+privacy extensions.
- based2 7y agohttps://framalab.org/ https://framalab.org/