22 ms·
Shout out to nextdns.io, they run a global pi-hole grid. OK, it’s better, but conceptually. ”Block ads, trackers and malicious websites on all your devices. G
by Terretta 7y ago
Shout out to nextdns.io, they run a global pi-hole grid. OK, it’s better, but conceptually.
”Block ads, trackers and malicious websites on all your devices. Get in-depth analytics about your Internet traffic.
Protect your privacy and bypass censorship. Shield your kids.”
All you do is point your DNS at it. (Or let one of their apps point DNS for you.)
But I really like the ethos:
”NextDNS was founded in May 2019 in Delaware, USA by two French founders Romain Cointepas and Olivier Poitrey. Olivier has been working on Internet infrastructures for the last 20 years. In 2005, he founded Dailymotion, the largest video sharing service after Youtube and the most popular European website in the world at the time. He is currently Director of Engineering at Netflix, working on Open Connect, Netflix's home CDN also known as the CDN moving about 30% of the total US Internet traffic. Romain and Olivier closely worked for years at Dailymotion on many different projects. Romain ended up leading the mobile & TV department.”
”We are true supporters of the net neutrality and Internet privacy. We believe that un-encrypted DNS resolvers operated by ISPs are detrimental to those two principals. Alternative solutions like Google DNS or Cloudflare DNS are great, but we think more actors need to step up and provide alternative services to avoid centralization of powers.”
In ~8 months it’s gotten mom proof while also being something I can recommend to techos. For me, it’s been more reliable than the enterprise Zscalar DNS filtering, and more configurable than other filters, particularly in allowing ad blocking and custom block lists and white lists along a rich set of built-ins.
I’m at 7% blocked out of 4 million queries in last couple months.
Ads & Trackers 256,212
Facebook 7,150
Spotify 1,245
Messenger 1,027
Snapchat 938
Twitter 916
I should note that I don’t use Facebook, Spotify, Messenger, Snapchat, or Twitter.
- choeger 7y agoThat all sounds great, but what is their business model? How do I pay them for their service?
- kevsim 7y agoIt's $2/month for unlimited requests, apparently: https://nextdns.io/pricing https://nextdns.io/pricing
- busymom0 7y agoThat's surprisingly very reasonably priced.
- squarefoot 7y agoPricing is surely very reasonable, but I'm not comfortable with the idea of paying for not getting something. The whole system is flawed and building businesses on a flaw is a step in the wrong direction if we want to fuel motivation to solve that flaw.
- grogenaut 7y agoThe city of flint has a lot of water theyd like to sell you, it comes with extra so it follows your model. You should also love basic Hulu, they sell you a version that comes WITH added ads, such benefit. In reality there are plenty of places you are paying for refined or filtered products. Organic or pesticide free foods, gas (you or your supply chain use it), higher end CPUs (less defects), it goes on and on.
- low_common 7y agoYou're also paying for the Internet access. Go build one and we'll pay you.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoIs it? You can run a DNS server on a watch.
- thebruce87m 7y agoNot on my watch
- buschkowitz 7y agoIt is free during beta. Then essentially a freemium model: https://nextdns.io/pricing https://nextdns.io/pricing.
- glitchc 7y agoI checked. It seems to be free for the first 300,000 queries per month, then switches to a regular DNS (no blocking). Unlimited queries are $1.99 per month. https://nextdns.io/pricing https://nextdns.io/pricing
- amelius 7y agoOk, but by paying you basically hand them your personal information which they can now tie to your internet access patterns. So now, besides your ISP, there's one more party with this info. EDIT: they accept cryptocurrencies, so the problem is slightly less critical.
- tremon 7y agoIn case you use their DOH service (or TLS), it's only them, not your ISP.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 7y agoI do something similar by running CoreDNS on a pi with a bunch of blocks on domains. Works very nicely with caching as well, and the data stays where I expect it.
- cocochanel 7y agoCool, sounds great! I went to NextDNS website only to find out they run Google Analytics...
- Krasnol 7y agoIs it blocked if you use their DNS? ;)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Terretta 7y agoYes
- MrStonedOne 7y agoWhat should they use? And don't say matomo until it supports drilling down byond one level.
- Kovah 7y agoIn this particular case I find it very dishonest: they talk about net neutrality and privacy protection but use Google Analytics. It does not matter if GA or Matomo is the best solution, they made the decision to use GA and thus don't seem to value their customers data that much.
- franga2000 7y agoWhat is it with this all-or-nothing attitude? GA provides objectively superior data and they probably get a lot of value from it, otherwise they wouldn't be using it - value which allows them to grow their business which ultimately benefits their users. (at least for me) Considering the value of their service, GA on their marketing page seems like a very small compromise. If you don't like it you are free to block it - hell, they literally provide a service to do so.
- buro9 7y agoI use nextdns, it's excellent. However beware that it's not a "set and forget" solution. Example: This morning I did my occasional sweep of what I've blocked where, and to see if there's a new allowed domain in top N that should've been blocked. What I found is that ocsp.int-x3.letsencrypt.org.edgesuite.net is blocked by "kowabit.de - bl*cklist of death". I've added that to my whitelist now, I want certificate revocation to not be blocked.
- HelenePhisher 7y agoStrange, cannot find any entry related to LE in the list: https://blocklist.kowabit.de/kwbtlist.txt https://blocklist.kowabit.de/kwbtlist.txt
- scurvy 7y agoWhy would anyone block all of Akamai? This is the problem with user-generated-lists; sometimes the user clearly has no idea what they're doing.
- 3xblah 7y ago"He is currently Director of Engineering at Netflix, working on Open Connect, Netflix's home CDN also known as the CDN moving about 30% of the total US Internet traffic" There is something about CDNs and DNS, usually not good. According to Paul Vixie, that is how we ended up with EDNS0 despite the objection of IETF. Wonder if this company gets permission to share data with Netflix. I would read the terms carefully. Hopefully people will choose to run their own Pi-Holes on their home networks, preferably without pointing them at third party "upstream" DNS providers.
- patrec 7y agoHow does your own DNS server substantially help, given that it needs to get its data somewhere?
- tremon 7y agoBy distributing its requests across the many authoritative servers for the domains you visit. The only one that still sees all your DNS requests is the ISP.
- kasey_junk 7y agoIn the US at least the major ISPs are likely the worst people to see your dns queries as they are actively selling that data to advertisers.
- code51 7y agoNextDNS is great. However with these tools, problems appear when you specifically want to display your Firebase dashboard etc. directly going to a service from the "tracker" itself = analytics.google.com Marking at domain level is too generic to wrestle with this problem.
- cryptonym 7y agoYou could have an alternative browser with unfiltered DOH for this. Or maybe that's the right level... if tracker should be blocked then I guess it's better to not fuel this business.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoMaybe a silly question, but how do they identify you? Simply based on your IP address?
- ikornaselur 7y agoYou'll have a unique 6 character id, which you'll use as a subdomain or path in dns-over-https For example, if your id is abc123 DNS-over-HTTPS https://dns.nextdns.io/abc123 https://dns.nextdns.io/abc123 DNS-over-TLS abc123.dns.nextdns.io You also have ipv6 hostnames, which has the id in it
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- franga2000 7y agoAs a fallback for standard UDP DNS over IPv4, they do use your IP address in a rather clever way: they have multiple IPv4s so you can have different rule sets for different devices under the same IPv4 and they identify which ones by linking the two addresses together (NET1->DNS1 gets RULES1, NET1->DNS2 gets RULES2, etc.).
- quindecagon 7y agoLogs of requests can be viewed at: https://my.nextdns.io/configuration/abc123/logs https://my.nextdns.io/configuration/abc123/logs Can anyone who knows your id also view your logs?
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoand what prey, does a global pi-hole grid give that an actual RaspPi and pi-hole can't? What does it add? Given they are based in Delaware, USA my starting point is far below zero privacy trust: Nextdns are gathering maximum possible data from everyone's DNS queries and selling it, or proposing to use it for advertising soon(tm). Enough independent reviewing and auditing might eventually persuade me that's unfair, maybe. If they actually cared for privacy why not incorporate in the EU and proudly wear full GDPR compliance? Or CA's upcoming privacy legislation?
- buro9 7y agoDNS-over-TLS is what they add. Which is great, because then you can configure your Android to use nextdns as the private DNS provider and thus all adverts and tracking in your mobile apps and websites are covered too, even when you're away from your home network.
- OJFord 7y agoYou can configure the same on your own PiHole, or VPN to the network it's on. I think the value is convenience, all this is done for you, no maintenance.
- buro9 7y agoMy understanding is that pi-hole does not support DNS-over-TLS. Are you saying that it does? I've just looked and cannot find mention of it. I know one can install stubby to achieve this, but now the convenience of nextdns is greater.
- erikbye 7y ago> My understanding is that pi-hole does not support DNS-over-TLS. You have to run Unbound, as well.
- OJFord 7y agoPresumably it's just convenience for people that don't want to run their own.
- Shaddox 7y agoWhat's the advantage in using this over something like say, Blokada?
- tilolebo 7y ago1. You can a share your config across all your devices. Also works on desktops (AFAIK Blokada is just for mobile) 2. You can create multiple configs and easily switch between those 3. Works everywhere (Pi-hole is very cool but only works within the local network you set it up, AFAIK) 4. On my smartphone Blokada regularly stopped, probably because I use an energy saving profile. I could never keep it running for longer than a few days, no matter what I tried. NextDNS seems to work fine so far, had it running for some weeks without a single crash
- Shaddox 7y agoThanks for the clarification.I'll give it a trial run to see how it pads out for me.
- EA 7y agoRegarding #3: you could run PiVPN on your PiHole device and remote into the PiHole. Mobile browsing on the go without ads!
- ryanmercer 7y ago>On my smartphone Blokada regularly stopped, probably because I use an energy saving profile. I had an issue with it stopping every couple of minutes, recently I figured out it was Google Fi's VPN causing it to stop after noticing it was only doing it on my phone with a Fi sim and not on my device with a Sprint sim. At some point Fi updated it so that the VPN is always on instead of only turning on when it finds an unsecured wireless network and automatically connected you (which is extremely rare where I live).
- Sohcahtoa82 7y ago> 3. Works everywhere (Pi-hole is very cool but only works within the local network you set it up, AFAIK) I run a PiHole on an AWS EC2 instance, then VPN to it on my phone. The VPN is configured so that only DNS requests get sent to it and all other traffic just goes straight through the LTE connection so that I'm not paying for all the traffic through AWS.
- threatofrain 7y agoBut at the current time I feel CloudFlare has more reputational skin in the game, that they're merely selling off spare capacity as opposed to making a separate business model work, and they don't offer logging as a service although they can certainly break their promises at a reputational risk. In time NextDNS can build up their reputation perhaps to a point even exceeding CloudFlare, but right now I feel those who are joining early are "paving the way" via risk to their privacy.
- pergadad 7y agoTo my knowledge 1.1.1.1 does not offer as blocking? Or are you referring to some other cloudflare offer?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Legogris 7y agoThey're most likely referring to the provider reselling your data (basically you're trading scattered tracking on many providers to NextDNS getting all your DNS lookups, which can be resold without your knowledge)
- Terretta 7y agoYou are correct. Cloudflare’s DNS does not assist you with blocking ads and trackers.
- auiya 7y ago> founded [..] in Delaware, USA by two French founders This sets off my spidey sense. Delaware is known to be a hot bed of fly-by-night corporations and front companies used exclusively for shady dealings[1]. I'm not saying that's the case here, but proceed w/ caution. [1] https://www.transparency.org/news/feature/delaware_the_us_corporate_secrecy_haven https://www.transparency.org/news/feature/delaware_the_us_co...
- chrisrhoden 7y agoIt's also an extremely common place to set up a legitimate business. > More than 50% of all U.S. publicly traded companies and 63% of the Fortune 500 are incorporated in Delaware. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delaware https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delaware
- JohnFen 7y agoDelaware is used as the base for a lot of corporations of all stripes. It's because they provide an enormous tax advantage. I actually had an argument with my business attorney about this many years ago. He wanted me to incorporate in Delaware for the tax benefit. I wanted to incorporate in my own state because that's the right thing to do.
- mrfancy 7y agoNextDNS's anycast network seems to be built on top of M247 and Vultr. I wonder if it is stable enough.
- scurvy 7y agoThere are a few others in there as well: https://bgp.he.net/AS34939 https://bgp.he.net/AS34939
- Naracion 7y agoI'm sorry for my ignorance, but how does NextDNS compare to 1.1.1.1 by Cloudflare? I've been using 1.1.1.1 for some time. For me it has worked fairly well in the USA where my connection speed is ~200mbps. While I was in India, 1.1.1.1 caused substantial slowdowns, in some cases made a few websites unusable. Typically I had it disabled. I'm unsure why this was happening because the website says it makes web browsing faster--I do not have the technical chops to understand this, so would anybody be kind enough to explain in a layman's language? Would NextDNS and 1.1.1.1 differ in terms of speed? https://1.1.1.1 https://1.1.1.1
- lozaning 7y agoI dont think the increase in speed is a result of you getting responses to DNS queries any faster, it's simply that if you only need to load the content you want and none of the content you dont (ads and whatnot), then the stuff you do want to see has that much more bandwidth available.
- mderazon 7y agoThey some track record before I can start trusting them. That's why I wish the Signal foundation started building 1. Password managers 2. DNS providers
- mderazon 7y agoSo if I am running both Nextdns and adblocker locally, is there any point ? Which one is blocking first ?
- CraftThatBlock 7y agoI do the same and together they work the best I find. Ad-blockers act at a different level than DNS blockers so can catch things that the DNS didn't (DNS only had domain, while ad-blockers have the full path)
- mderazon 7y agoBut the order of evaluation is first local ad blocker then dns blocker I guess, right ?
- CraftThatBlock 7y agoFrom what I understand yes
- whycombagator 7y agoWonder how this compares to AdGuard[0] [0]https://adguard.com/en/adguard-dns/overview.html https://adguard.com/en/adguard-dns/overview.html EDIT: They have a lot more products than just DNS (if you poke around the site)
- OkGoDoIt 7y agoThank you for sharing this! I have never heard of them before, but I switched from Cloudflare to it after reading your comment and I’ve been a very happy user for the past 4 days :-)