6 ms·
>> - free, for entertainment purposes, is in my opinion one of the most amazing things going at present. Except that it isn't. All that classic NASA space fo
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> - free, for entertainment purposes, is in my opinion one of the most amazing things going at present.
Except that it isn't. All that classic NASA space footage was shared because it was copyright-free. As products of the US federal government they were not subject to copyright protection. They were transmitted and used everywhere. When "The Six Million Dollar Man" or "Buck Rogers" wanted to use NASA launch footage (or USAF crash footage) they just did. No questions asked.
SpaceX footage isn't from the US fed. It is private and therefore protected copyright. It cannot be used anywhere anytime. We all must ask SpaceX for permission. Use it in a manner that SpaceX disagrees with and you can expect lawyers. You wont see the failure footage from SpaceX ever used as nasa footage was used by countless scifi productions.
So no, this is no amazing thing. While modern footage is a visual feast, in terms of freedom it is a step down from what we once had. I think those running TV news networks (or youtube, or any other distribution network) would rather return to the old system whereby they could use footage however they liked. We won't ever see SpaceX crash footage used for much of anything.
What I am talking about. Six Million Dollar Man opening:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bGO57y4td-c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bGO57y4td-c
Original NASA footage: (Crash at about 2:00)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=50dDWT48b9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=50dDWT48b9M
- optimiz3 7y ago> But SpaceX footage isn't from the US fed. It is subject to copyright. It cannot be used anywhere anytime. We all must ask SpaceX for permission. Use it in a manner that SpaceX disagrees with and you can expect lawyers. So much pessimism. I think it's great a private for profit corporation is doing as much as it is given it has no obligation to do so.
- sandworm101 7y ago>> as it is given it has no obligation to do so. That's the big change, the lack of obligation. If SpaceX is going to be fulfilling government contracts, on government facilities/ranges, using countless government employees, resulting footage should be free. It hasn't happened yet, but with human spaceflight nearing we may see SpaceX drafting license deals in a manner NASA never contemplated.
- MoronInAHurry 7y agoSpaceX recently relicensed their photos to an Attribution-NonCommercial license, when previously they were effectively public domain under Creative Commons Zero: https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/88449p/spacex-just-retroactively-put-copyright-restrictions-on-its-photos https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/88449p/spacex-just-retroa...
- sandworm101 7y agoYup. The last thing SpaceX wants is to see somebody else make a buck from their footage. We have seen NASA logos in a thousand scifi productions. We will never see the SpaceX logo used in such a manner.
- mrtnmcc 7y agoIs that pure speculation? SpaceX isn't protesting the countless YouTube videos and derivative works from their launches.
- zlsa 7y agoAre you expecting SpaceX to allow their (copyrighted) logo to appear in various media without requesting permission first? NASA's copyright policy is the exception, not the rule.
- greglindahl 7y agoSpaceX's trademarked name and logo are still limited by the usual trademark stuff even if they're in public domain video or images. NASA's copyright policy is US government wide, it's just that most of the rest of the government actively dodges it by hiring photographers and letting them own the copyrights.
- zlsa 7y agoI meant that the US government policy is the exception compared to US law, not to the rest of the government. Private companies should not be required to make anything public just because their customer is NASA (or the US government, for that matter.)
- dylan604 7y agoI think if you are receiving public/govt/fed money to do your mission(s), then the footage should also abide by the non-copyrightable footage as well.
- dahfizz 7y agoWhy? NASA partners with SpaceX and other space companies on specific projects. For example, NASA needed a special crew module and so they commissioned SpaceX to design and build the crew dragon. I don't see why having NASA as a customer means SpaceX loses the right to private property. If a government agency decided to become a paying customer of your SaaS project, should you be forced to open source all your code because you are now receiving public money? I suspect the answer is the same as with the SpaceX footage - the public may benefit if it was released, but it seems an unreasonable burden.
- dylan604 7y agoSimple, because it's my money that paid for it. That's the reason NASA footage is public domain. It's publicly funded with tax dollars.
- dahfizz 7y agoSpaceX is not 100% NASA funded. NASA contracts SpaceX for a specific product and nasa receives that product. In other words, you do get what you pay for. Do you believe that any software the government buys must be open sourced? Your tax dollars buy plenty of iPhones and Macs. Should apple release all their software and hardware to you?
- dylan604 7y agoI think you are reading too much into my original statement. I did NOT say I think 100% of all SpaceX footage should be made public domain. I specifically stated that if it is funded by govt funding, then it should.
- NortySpock 7y agoI think they're finding some good PR and passive positive lobbying (where fans write their congressperson about all the cool stuff we can do in space) is coming from their publicity. They're also putting pressure on their competitors (Boeing, Northrop Grumman, etc) by constantly being in the news. Where is ULA's reusable rocket stage? Where is Arianespace's Starship competitor? Why is NASA building a disposable rocket?
- shadowgovt 7y ago"Free as in advertising," not "free as in speech."
- tomphoolery 7y ago> I think those running TV news networks would rather return to the old system whereby they could show the footage whatever and whenever. I don't think the opinion of "those running TV news networks" really matters all that much when we're talking about space.
- jtms 7y agoGadflies everywhere
- paulmendoza 7y agoI think he just means he likes watching rockets launch.
- tripzilch 7y agoIt's important for the future of our sci-fi movies. They ought to be using SpaceX-branded stock footage instead of what, rendering space scenes like a bunch of cavemen?
- Dylan16807 7y agoThe quote says right there "for entertainment purposes". Stock footage is not that. And come on, being able to use NASA footage in your own works is one of the least exciting parts about space travel.
- nexuist 7y ago>Use it in a manner that SpaceX disagrees with and you can expect lawyers. You wont see the failure footage from SpaceX ever used as nasa footage was used by countless scifi productions. SpaceX literally uploaded a video of all their crashes spliced together in a comedic montage. It's called How Not to Land an Orbital Rocket Booster. https://youtu.be/bvim4rsNHkQ https://youtu.be/bvim4rsNHkQ Even crash footage is good PR for them. There are still millions of Americans who do not know what SpaceX is or what it does.
- xingyzt 7y agoThe crash compilation is public [1] because they were tests with minimal customer risks involved. You wouldn't find footage of CRS-7, with its dozens of NASA payloads, disintegrating on any of SpaceX's official media channels. [1] But not public domain. It's still copyrighted.
- hartator 7y agoYou mean this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OAX7UFd70M8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OAX7UFd70M8
- kortilla 7y agoSciNews is not one of SpaceX’s channels.
- KiwiJohnno 7y agoSpaceX have unlisted their CRS-7 broadcast, but they have not taken it down. Here it is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZeiBFtkrZEw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZeiBFtkrZEw
- yreg 7y ago>We won't ever see SpaceX crash footage used for much of anything. We will if SpaceX allows it. How can you be sure they won't?
- anoncake 7y agoWe can't be sure they will, that's the problem.
- johnghanks 7y agoClassic HN. Finding a way to spin something great into something negative.
- EasyTiger_ 7y agoIt’s tiring.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rcw4256 7y ago> Use it in a manner that SpaceX disagrees with and you can expect lawyers. This is probably true, but it's hard to be certain that they'd prevail. Has this actually been tested in court?
- growlist 7y ago> So no, this is no amazing thing. Putting the legal aspects to one side, do you not think it's amazing? If not, what would it take to impress you?
- tripzilch 7y agoEverything major ever attributed to the USA for all eternity. And otherwise it's not amazing. Seems pretty obvious what they are about. Or maybe there are several people with very specific interests about what logos appear in the stock footage used in hypothetical documentary style near future science fiction movies ... Except technology achieved many other things besides shooting rockets into space, one of which is really good CGI, so it's really not about the ability to tell a good visual story.
- jcims 7y agoIf you want SpaceX produced footage to be public domain, ask NASA to put it into the contract. Pretty simple.
- azernik 7y agoNASA broadcasts and public-domains all SpaceX launches where they're the customer.
- thelittleone 7y agoThe fact the content is copyright makes it no less amazing to witness (at least for me and many friends). It has been a source of inspiration in a time of predominantly divisive news. The quality of the coverage has set a new bar for space companies / agencies. That alone is amazing because we all get to benefit.
- debrice 7y agoI've seen plenty of SpaceX crash footage used by others than SpaceX. While you might have a point when it comes to Intellectual Property, I think you're taking that a bit out of proportion.
- rolltiide 7y ago> As products of the US federal government they were not subject to copyright protection. This really is not a good assumption. The federal government has plenty of ways around this. The federal government can buy copyrights, and also enter into work for hire arrangements with contractors and employees. When naked and operating without contracts, the federal government does have this default status, simple boilerplate copy and pasted contracts change this.
- tjpnz 7y agoGo back and watch the livestream Boeing had when they were testing the Starliner.
- airstrike 7y ago> Except that it isn't. Except that it is. Free as in beer, not as in freedom.
- taneq 7y agoI can watch every launch live from my desk in glorious HD with multiple camera views, telemetry, and expert commentary. It costs nothing to watch. This is freaking amazing.
- ufmace 7y agoI don't much care for this take. In my opinion, a private and profitable space company is a massive, game-changing advancement in human progress. Maybe, just maybe, we'll actually send people to the planets when it's in somebody's direct financial interest and ability to do so, rather than have to beg a bunch of image-sensitive politicians to fund it. Against that possibility and chance, I honestly don't give a damn about whether or not some of the footage is public domain. I'd rather argue about who has the right to do what with various bits of launch footage from our Martian colony. Beats the heck out of having more public domain launch footage to use in sci-fi movies, and having our crowning achievement in human space exploration being a handful of short missions to the Moon that left behind absolutely no useful infrastructure, and was only done to show up our geopolitical rivals.
- tripzilch 7y ago> No questions asked. Unless it's critical or satirical of the military, like Starship Troopers.