19 ms·
Why Japan is so successful at returning lost property
- shujito 7y agodiscipline, education and culture
- rs999gti 7y ago> discipline and culture Monoculture
- makapuf 7y agoDo you say that with a negative or positive tone ? It's hard to tell from your answer. And if so, why ?
- jshevek 7y agoI took it as an observation or speculation of cause and effect. There is no judgement (positive or negative) needed for this.
- m4rtink 7y agoSo like a monorepo ? ;-)
- acidtoyman 7y agoIt's both a myth that Japan is, or ever has been, a "monoculture", and quite the leap to assume a "monoculture" would produce such behaviour.
- BlameKaneda 7y ago"Tamura describes the concept of 'hito no me'; the ‘societal eye’. Even without a police presence, no theft will occur while there is hito no me. But left in a place where there is no one watching, thefts do occur." "Likewise, in Shintoism everything, from rocks to trees, possesses a spirit. While organised Shintoism is a minority practice in Japan, omniscient objects permeate the culture....if you are always being watched and your natural disposition is to think of others first, it is natural that you would be bothered to hand in the lost item." The concept of "standing out" is a bit foreign in collectivist cultures like Japan, and getting blamed/shunned/etc for stealing would be mentally taxing.
- LeoTinnitus 7y agoThat is how I analyzed it for the most part since there was such a wide variance between countries. Eastern Europe really stood out to me and I believe that may have to do with a generation of people that were used to the surveillance state of post-communist society. In the US, the social impact generally means little, however the economic and time one matters a lot (via jail or fines). Post-communist states might be still conditioned to live in a culture where people are used to corrupt police that ENSURING you have nothing damning is far better than taking a risk and dealing with getting out of that.
- vearwhershuh 7y ago"What’s in it for the finder to be honest enough to hand in the item?" By asking this question, you deny yourself access to its answer.
- ghostbrainalpha 7y agoWhen you take a basic moral truth, but then phrase it so that it will not immediately be apparent what you are saying.... You create the appearance of profound wisdom. And often book deals.
- munificent 7y agoStudies have shown people recall information better if they had to put some effort into acquiring it. Sometimes a profound wisdom lodges better if the "ah-ha" moment occurs in the reader's mind and not on the page.
- GuB-42 7y agoWhy? That's the kind of question that makes up the entire field of game theory. In every situation, the most natural strategy is to maximize personal gains. That's how natural selection works. But when people don't act like that, it means there must be some opposing force, normally one that benefits society. There is a lot to learn here, in fields as diverse as biology, economics, computing, and of course, games.
- vearwhershuh 7y agoExactly.
- reroute1 7y agoExactly what? > By asking this question, you deny yourself access to its answer. ... No it doesn't?
- someone7x 7y ago> In every situation, the most natural strategy is to maximize personal gains. The iterated prisoner's dilemma begs to differ. There are many many situations where cooperation is both natural and optimal.
- jrsdav 7y agoI experienced this while visiting Japan. While doing a transfer on the Shinkansen in Hiroshima, I left my camera bag at a noodle kiosk on the platform (around $3k worth of equipment). Didn't realize it until 2 hours after getting on the next train. When we arrived at our destination, I told my friend we were meeting (a Japanese native) what happened, and she reassured me that it would be right where I left it (said something about there being a "taboo" with the Japanese and touching other people's private property). So we walked over to the JR attendant and explained what happened, and in no time at all she had the other station attendant on the line who confirmed they found my bag. Just as easy as that. Then I proceeded to lose my wallet and passport in a taxi, which we recovered just as easily! Japan is a great country to visit, if while abroad you displace the part of your brain that keeps track of things...
- harikb 7y agoIs it possible the social support structure, education, etc are creating a society where unfortunate people don't have to steal/pawn to make a living?
- peterhadlaw 7y agoI think the point is that it's a cultural thing, regardless of how fortunate or unfortunate someone is.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoI'm sure it plays a role, but there are countries with similar wealth and support systems, but so many things (like the lost property example) are unique to Japan.
- rsmckinney 7y agoIt’s more to do with the purity of their culture resulting from low immigration which fosters a high level of mutual trust. Invariably immigration corrupts the hosting nation’s culture with trust absorbing the initial impact.
- sanitycheck 7y agoI think part of this is that a far greater proportion of "lost" valuables in Japan are _really_ lost than in other countries, street crime being pretty rare. But still, that 6% figure for New York! Can it be true? Is it really normal to steal other people's shit if they leave it behind?
- haskellandchill 7y agoYes.
- sct202 7y agoA youtuber did a similar test (but probably a lot less controlled) and it wasn't that bad (4/10 for NYC). Result spreadsheet: https://www.dropbox.com/s/m2ahob0949mmj3s/Wallet%20Data%20Aggragate.xlsx?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/m2ahob0949mmj3s/Wallet%20Data%20Ag...
- jotm 7y agoMan, I was living in the UK. A kid on a skateboard dropped his phone, didn't notice. Less than a minute later, a guy (gardener or construction worker by the looks of it) picks it off the ground and gets in his van. Bye bye phone. Another time, found a wallet and returned it, the woman said it's unbelievable, no one else would do that. Gave me 10 pounds, too, heh (there was way more in the wallet, plus cards and ID, it's how I found her). I'd be very happy if someone did that for me. But yeah, usually "finders keepers" holds true :/ I like these kind of stories from Japan, makes it seem like people do respect each other. Shame not everything is that good over there.
- progman32 7y agoWhat would a better response be to a dropped phone? From the story as told the guy may well have tried to find the phone's owner when he got a free minute.
- jotm 7y agoCatch up to the kids and return it? They were down the street within view. Tbf, I'm not one to judge, I just watched, so...
- pzumk 7y ago> In a study comparing dropped phones and wallets in New York and Tokyo, 88% of phones “lost” by the researchers were handed into the police by Tokyo residents, compared to 6% of the ones “lost” in New York. Likewise, 80% of Tokyo wallets were handed in compared to 10% in New York. Wow!
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI remember forgetting an umbrella in a restaurant in Tokyo, and being chased down in the street by someone returning it. It was pretty amazing.
- virtuous_signal 7y agoThis smells like a lot of post-hoc rationalization. Collectivism? What about China, which did terribly on this kind of test. Shintoism? Only 3-4% of the population follows that. See https://www.latimes.com/science/la-sci-people-are-honest-lost-wallets-experiment-20190620-story.html https://www.latimes.com/science/la-sci-people-are-honest-los... where the graphic in the middle of the page compares countries. It appears that Scandinavian countries fare best followed by Eastern European. I would be happy to hear what people at HN think are the real reasons. For what it's worth, as a scatterbrained person, I think it would be great living in a country with so much trust that I could expect my lost things not to be stolen.
- nwienert 7y agoHomogenous, nationalistic, small country with high IQ, good education system, high GDP, low levels of immigration, and a culture that emphasizes community. Oh, and lower levels of inequality, relatively, and a more aligned politics/media system that doesn’t foment distrust.
- jessriedel 7y agoI mostly agree, but note that Japan has 126M people, so it's quite large.
- JakeTheAndroid 7y agoYeah, but when you compare 126m to 1.3b I feel like you'd expect to see drift between the results. That's 10x the amount of people. If only 1 in every 10 people in each country is willing to break the social norms and ignores social pressures, then China will have 10x the amount of these infractions compared to Japan. But yes, Japan is not a small country even if it is a relatively small landmass.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThe infractions are per capita. If a country has ten times the population and the same percentage of honest people, then it will have ten times the number of people breaking the social norms.
- ookblah 7y agoI found this similar mentality in Korea where you can leave your laptop, phone, etc. at a cafe completely exposed on a table while you go to the restroom or even out to lunch. When you come back your stuff will still be there. As I live in NYC, this completely blew my mind and I still felt that anxiety and awkwardness just leaving my stuff to go use the restroom. Near guaranteed theft in NYC lol. --- And to add another story. A friend and I were traveling in Japan a few years ago. My friend had the lucky privilege of forgetting his backpack (with laptop, passport, all the not-fun-stuff to lose items) not once, but twice during the trip. The first time, he forgot it on the train ride to Osaka (left it on the rack above the seats). The bag went all the way to the end of the line. 4 hour round trip to get it back, but we were super surprised. Second time was the day we were to fly back. He left it on the train platform bench (!!!) for that non-stop ride to Narita. That feeling of dread when we started moving and he realized he had to wait at least an hour before he could contact anybody about it. Long story short, he took the 1 hour train back and it was still sitting there. Missed the flight, but got everything back safely. Amazing.
- jessriedel 7y agoI worked in NYC coffee shops on a daily basis for 2 years (and Toronto and SF for more years). Whenever I went to the bathroom, I just asked a random person nearby if they would make sure no one walked off with my stuff. I never had anything stolen, and the people I ask don't seem bothered in the slightest. It's a very small burden, and I think there's something pleasant about having someone put their trust in you.
- mcast 7y agoThis is the standard I've encountered at coffee shops and school libraries, no one seems to mind. However, it would be easy to build an app that alarms when the battery becomes disconnected (i.e. someone walks away with your stuff).
- reroute1 7y ago> It would be easy to build an app that alarms when the battery becomes disconnected (i.e. someone walks away with your stuff). Wait what? How does this work?
- supernova87a 7y agoThere are both amazingly good and amazingly bad things about Japanese culture. The shame of being seen to be not honest or respecting people's property leads to amazing responsibility and kindness. But it also leads to people being depressed and feeling constrained not to be able to break out of societal expectations. The very things that make us love Japan, would make you go crazy to live there. So enjoy the privilege of being able to visit and experience the benefits, while not having to deal with the downsides. And maybe it causes you to reflect that, in the US -- the very personal freedoms (i.e. lack of guilt on being disobedient or trying new things) leads to a society where it's more likely you're not getting your wallet back if you leave it somewhere...
- generaljelly 7y agoThis is a good assessment. I believe Japan generally only works for people that already fall in line with societal norms to some extent. I do wish to believe that a personal freedom society and a society that takes your wallet don't have to be tightly coupled... Although I will say the public shame of Japan is stronger than the private shame of the US.
- duxup 7y agoThere was a good blog post about a guy living in Japan. Here he was in this clean and crime free place, but his bicycle kept getting trashed overnight. Just his bike parked in a sea of other bikes. He thought it was because he was a foreigner, but finally after he reported it to the police numerous times someone explained the phrase "The nail that sticks out gets knocked down." and pointed out the bikes he was buying were from China. His bike looked similar to everyone else's bike in the area, but it was made by a Chinese company and there had been news stories about how these bikes were faulty / dangerous / bad (the information apparently was somewhat questionable). So he bought a proper Japanese bike that looked like the other bikes, and it never happened again. The contrast of a clean and orderly society with very targeted pressure by random members of society not to do something like buy the wrong bike ... is quite striking.
- drdeadringer 7y ago
- zebnyc 7y agoHonest question: Do folks feel warm fuzzies when they do something "good / +ve"? Frankly unless I went out of my way to do something significant, I don't feel anything. Asking as there might be some of that going on here. For e.g., around Christmas here in SF, I was a at a shopping mall parking lot waiting for my wife to return. I noticed a man counting a few bills of cash. He counted and then turned to head to his car. As he turned he dropped a couple of bills. I just shouted out to him to bring it to my attention so he could get it. I don't feel anything about the incident and would be hard pressed to use it as a barometer of my character.
- minaa-chan 7y agoI don't. I do "good" things because that's the way I was raised. I actually dislike getting thanked or anything that draws attention to the "good" thing I did because it seems so needless. Occasionally I'll feel a twinge of guilt if I could've helped out and didn't but usually I do it out of habit.
- sethammons 7y agoLikely a few dollars means nothing to you so the act of pointing the nearly lost dollars is a similar small task (not withstanding the possibility the act could have a profound effect on the recipient depending on their situation). When I was younger and we were struggling hard, we found a wallet in a store loaded with green bills. That money would have had immediate, real, positive impact for us, like gas money and food that we did not have. We turned in the wallet and did not bother counting the bills. The cashier might have pocketed the money, who knows. But hopefully the owner of the wallet got their stuff back. I think that act does cast a barometer on my and my wife's character. We did what was "right" -- the property was not ours and not ours to take. Did we feel good about it? Nope! It was just doing the right thing even though there was a touch of pain to it.
- FriendlyNormie 7y agoWhy did you give the wallet to a random person you had no reason to trust when you could have looked at the address on the ID in the wallet and taken it there yourself?
- throwaheyy 7y agoBecause they care about others
- tyfon 7y agoIt's not quite at the level of Japan, but Aftenposten, which is a newspaper in Norway, conducted a test [1] (translation [2]) in Oslo where they "lost" 20 wallets. 15 eventually returned. Personally I've lost my wallet twice and it has been returned both times. It is nice to be able to trust your fellow citisens somewhat :) [1] https://www.aftenposten.no/okonomi/i/zlOb/slik-gikk-det-da-aftenposten-mistet-20-lommeboeker https://www.aftenposten.no/okonomi/i/zlOb/slik-gikk-det-da-a... [2] https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.aftenposten.no%2Fokonomi%2Fi%2FzlOb%2Fslik-gikk-det-da-aftenposten-mistet-20-lommeboeker https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...
- retrac 7y agoThe Toronto Star tried the same thing in Toronto. 15 of 20 were returned. (One minus the cash.) https://www.thestar.com/life/2009/04/25/we_left_20_wallets_around_the_gta_most_came_back.html https://www.thestar.com/life/2009/04/25/we_left_20_wallets_a...
- kyuudou 7y agoAnother study was done with multiple countries and 17,000 wallets with some interesting results https://www.boredpanda.com/social-experiment-lost-found-wallet-returned-countries/ https://www.boredpanda.com/social-experiment-lost-found-wall...
- verisimilidude 7y agoThe abundance of "police boxes" in Japan, small satellite police stations, probably helps a lot. While living in Japan, I found a lost wallet on the street, in the gutter. That wallet was sitting just down the street from the police. Line-of-sight. Picking up the wallet and taking it to the station was immediately obvious and convenient.
- viburnum 7y agoI love the police boxes. When I was in Japan the officers helped me a lot with directions and reading maps.
- magduf 7y agoThat's totally different from America, where police will get pissed and yell at you to get lost if you ask them for directions. (Speaking from personal experience)
- viburnum 7y agoI know! I didn’t even have to ask for help in Japan. I think seeing a tourist holding a map is all they need to spring into action. Gotta keep those tourists out of trouble. I like how police officers in other countries look like normal humans and not stormtroopers. Makes me feel safe.
- magduf 7y ago>I like how police officers in other countries look like normal humans and not stormtroopers. Makes me feel safe. Yep, I feel exactly the same. The police in Japan look very professional, and not at all like stormtroopers; the shirt and tie they wear just isn't something you'd wear into combat. See: https://www.irishtimes.com/polopoly_fs/1.3451993.1523010914!/image/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/box_620_330/image.jpg https://www.irishtimes.com/polopoly_fs/1.3451993.1523010914!... Versus: https://www.wsj.com/articles/americans-respect-for-police-reaches-highest-level-since-1967-poll-finds-1477344780 https://www.wsj.com/articles/americans-respect-for-police-re... It also helps that police in other countries don't just shoot first and ask questions later, like American police: https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-asia-pacific-38534288/wrapping-people-in-futons-how-the-japanese-police-confront-violence https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-asia-pacific-38534288/wrap...
- NotASithLord 7y agoMy phone slipped out of my pocket on the subway on my last night in Tokyo. Realized 20 minutes later, talked to some employees and described what kind of phone it was (a cheap Samsung, really not a big deal), gone as can be. Flew back home to Miami. Received my phone back in the mail a month later. A friend of mine there kept checking with the employees and it eventually showed up in lost and found. Refused to allow me to pay for the international shipping.
- kibwen 7y agoLittle-known tip: in the US, if you happen to find a lost wallet that contains an ID, you can just drop it in the nearest postbox and the USPS has the duty to attempt to return it to its rightful owner. Here's the relevant page of the postal code: https://pe.usps.com/text/dmm300/507.htm https://pe.usps.com/text/dmm300/507.htm
- Hydraulix989 7y agoGiven what I've seen and also have personally experienced with postal employees, I wouldn't place much trust in it, for example: "USPS loses about $1800 of packages from store.rossmanngroup.com :(" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G4CCuMg6jXI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G4CCuMg6jXI
- laurieg 7y agoFunny this story should come up now. Two days ago I was on my regular running route and I saw a wallet on the ground. It had 5000 yen (around 50 USD) sticking out of it. The weather was a bit damp and it was far from a police box so I didn't want to risk getting randomly stopped and searched on my way to hand it in so I just put it on a fence post and went on my way. I run the same route everyday, so when I ran the next day lo and behold, the wallet was still there, complete with 5000 yen note sticking out. I'm curious if it will still be there on today's run.
- asdff 7y agoIs getting randomly stopped and searched a concern?
- laurieg 7y agoIt doesn't happen that often but it does happen. Foreign residents are required to carry a resident card at all times and the police are allowed to check for it. This can come with a search. Japanese nationals don't need to carry any form of ID by law, so you can see that how the police choose who to stop might be somewhat problematic.
- innocentoldguy 7y agoI lived in Japan for over 3 years and I was never stopped. It can happen, technically, but I don't think it happens all that often.
- tmm84 7y agoPersonally I have never experienced a random stop here in Japan. None of my friends here have worried about such either.
- acidtoyman 7y agoIt depends on where you live. There are areas where you never hear of it, and others where being carded once or twice a year is the norm.
- thbr99 7y agoBritain is bad at returning stolen property. Eg Kohinoor
- mmhsieh 7y agoi lost a phone in shinjuku station and located with the help of the station employees within 30 minutes. somehow they did this location act in the busiest subway junction in the world, with just a few phone calls.
- grillvogel 7y agoits funny that this article is part of a japan 2020 olympics feature, when there will surely be an increase in crime and bad behavior due to all the 2020 visitors.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoMy first day in Japan I fell asleep on the train. I woke up to a train employee telling me to leave the train. I grabbed my bag and left in a daze, only to realize too late that I left my duffle bag on the top shelf. I reported it and was assured that it would be found. 2 weeks later they still hadn't found my bag but kindly told me that it must have been a Korean. Um. Well, that was 20 years ago. I'm sure things are different now.
- dba7dba 7y agoI loled at that `must have been a Korean` comment. History of Koreans in Japan has a complicated story. But basically ethnic Koreans are treated as a second class citizen in Japan. A Korean-American friend told me this story. He worked with a Britain/Ireland born coworker who was working in US at the time. Blond, European. He traveled fair bit to Japan. He knew this guy was Korean-American and in a conversation he asked the Korean-American why Japanese didn't like Koreans. The EU guy said when he visited Japan in 2000, Japanese told him they didn't like Koreans. And than in 2005 or so, he heard from Japanese that they liked Koreans. In what context the Japanese told a blond European guy why they liked or didn't like Koreans is unknown. This EU born coworker was confused what changed in that 5 year period.
- yongjik 7y ago> This EU born coworker was confused what changed in that 5 year period. Could be this guy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bae_Yong-joon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bae_Yong-joon Or more seriously, a series of Korean dramas that somehow gained immense popularity in Japan. Bae, nicknamed Yon-sama, became so popular that Japanese prime minister (Junichiro Koizumi) joked that he wanted to be like Yon-sama.
- dba7dba 7y agoYup, I looked up and sure enough 'Winter Sonata' TV series was shown in Japan in 2003. Irony is that of the 10 richest peeps in Japan, 2 are Korean descent. One owns big chain of pachinko. https://www.businessinsider.com/what-is-pachinko-gambling-japan-2018-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/what-is-pachinko-gambling-ja... The other is Masayoshi Son Both were denied the path to a stable salary career life time job at a big firm and so they went on their own way.
- enahs-sf 7y agoAnecdotal evidence here: Went to Japan, was out in a crowded area after dinner. A woman's wallet fell out of her pocket as she walked along. Literally a crowd of people rushed to pick it up and give it back to her. Never seen anything like that. One of many strange phenomena observed on the streets of Tokyo at night.
- eruditegamer420 7y agoIt's because there aren't any niggers there. Hope this helps.
- NalNezumi 7y agoI don't think you can point the reason for this on one specific cause, and better bundle it up as "culture". I've wonder if this is also the cause for the low appreciation for privacy in the Japanese society. I've noticed that the Japanese seems to be more "ok" with the idea of Google/Facebook/Line/big company snooping around and collecting your data, even engineers. It is also culturally more accepted to point out physical feature and ask private questions in this country. "you've become fat!", "Why don't you have a girlfriend/boyfriend?", "you speak/walk/do something very weird" is comments you can get from both relatives, co-workers and not-so-close friends. The typical "mind your own business" attitude you expect in the west seems to not be as prevalent here, and the "If you have nothing to hide, you don't need anonymity and privacy" is an argument most people consider to be valid here.
- hoi 7y agoWhen I was living in Japan, i once lost my wallet on a bicycle ride. It must have fallen out of my pocket somewhere on the route i was taking. I didn't notice it was missing until I got home, got my keys out to open the door and realised the wallet was missing. I went back out on the bike and retraced my route but couldnt see the wallet annoyed that I would have to cancel cards, get a new ID card. After I got home again, i was procrastinating about cancelling the cards for about 30mins and then decided to crack on. After I picked up the phone to start, the front door bell rang, I opened the door and there were 2 ladies with my wallet, they handed me my wallet, asked me to check everything was there and then apologized for taking so long to return my wallet. Apparently they found my wallet, went to an address I had left in there, but I had recently moved apartments, so they went to the Koban, Police officer told them my address based off my ID card and then they came to my address.
- scarejunba 7y agoWell, would you look at that privacy leakage there.
- spicyramen 7y agoI was in Japan in 2008 and we didn't have an umbrella, when someone from a store gave it to us I felt so happy and thankful from the store how come a random person be so nice, couldn't believe how they went from Naijinh to Pokemon in one generation
- bamboozled 7y agoI love Japan and the mystery continues with its fascinating culture.
- turingbook 7y agoYes, it is very impressive. I lost my prepaid card (Suica card? withou name or password stuff) with tens of thousands of Yen in Tokyo's Disneyland train in last year. After half an hour, a sweating Metro staff found it and returned to me.
- Gatsky 7y agoI notice that this story and the story about Carlos Ghosn's escape from Japan are both on the front page of HN. Lucky for Ghosn, the rest of the world is less successful at returning Japan's lost property.
- jhanschoo 7y agoThe article attributes this characteristic with Buddhism and collectivism without much comparative evaluation, and I find the explanation utterly unconvincing. For if it is Buddhism and communalism that led to such societal behavior, why is it that its neighboring largely Buddhist and largely collectivist East Asian and South-East Asian neighbors don't exhibit such characteristics? A proper argument in terms of "cultural history" needs to account for comparative evidence. Interestingly when I encounter this kind of sloppy "cultural history" reasoning it is from a BBC article.
- Data_Junkie 7y agoProves that honesty is really about being well trained. Which in America at least is the backbone of many, many unsolved problems . A entire culture based upon education and training only going to who is approved by the State and Capital, instead of training young people because they are young, and people.