5 ms·
Vermont Bill Proposes Ban on Cellphone Use for Anyone Under 21
- kbd 7y agoWhat on earth is their justification? You can drive a car, vote, and go to war at 18 but not use a cell phone? What politician would put their name behind this?
- squegles 7y ago> "I have no delusions that it's going to pass," he told reporter Eric Blaisdell. "I wouldn't probably vote for it myself." Did you read the article?
- kbd 7y agoSo it's purely a bill to spawn discussion... again 18 year olds are old enough to join the military but "it is clear that persons under 21 years of age are not developmentally mature enough to safely possess [cell phones]", the bill reads." Waste of everyone's time.
- gbear605 7y agoThe discussion is exactly about that. It’s a response to Vermont raising the age for gun ownership and tobacco usage to 21. So it’s the exact same logic. You agree with the bill’s author.
- Dylan16807 7y ago> You agree with the bill's author. I'm skeptical of that, considering how horribly broken the bill's analogy is. "Cell phones have often been used by mass shooters of younger ages for research on previous shootings." is so much of a strawman that it's a bale of hay.
- scottlocklin 7y ago"Rodgers writes within the proposal that cellphones are a large factor in teenage driving deaths and can lead to bullying and radicalization. "In light of the dangerous and life-threatening consequences of cellphone use by young people, it is clear that persons under 21 years of age are not developmentally mature enough to safely possess them," the bill reads. "just as the General Assembly has concluded that persons under 21 years of age are not mature enough to possess firearms, smoke cigarettes or consume alcohol.""
- munk-a 7y agoGosh yea, other than this specific proposal all laws in the US make sense - I sure am glad you can drink when you're 18 and no states have stupid religious laws limiting sales on Sundays to tiny bottles.
- theltrj 7y agoNot sure, but there is an argument out there that a cell phone + social media is as addictive as a slot machine, read some of Georgetown's Comp Sci Professor, Cal Newport: https://www.gq.com/story/cal-newport-digital-minimalism https://www.gq.com/story/cal-newport-digital-minimalism
- oneplane 7y agoDoes anyone have an alternate link? "Sorry, this content is not available in your region."
- usr1106 7y agoMaybe you are not 21 yet :) Seriously, I guess it's one of that web sites blocked for EU readers because of fear of GDPR. Well, I guess I can survive without that article.
- favorited 7y ago"I have no delusions that it's going to pass... I wouldn't probably vote for it myself." Well, at least he's not totally out to lunch.
- majos 7y ago> "I have no delusions that it's going to pass," [the state senator who introduced the bill] told reporter Eric Blaisdell. "I wouldn't probably vote for it myself." So it's not a serious bill. But I don't get what conversation the guy's trying to start. The full bill -- under two pages of generously spaced text [1] -- cites four justifications, conveniently arranged by decreasing plausibility: > (1) The use of cell phones while driving is one of the leading killers of teenagers in the United States... (2) Young people frequently use cell phones to bully and threaten other young people, activities that have been linked to many suicides. (3) The Internet and social media, accessed primarily through cell phones, are used to radicalize and recruit terrorists, fascists, and other extremists. (4) Cell phones have often been used by mass shooters of younger ages for research on previous shootings. And then it proposes prison sentences up to a year just for possession? Yeah, weird. My best guess is it's a publicity-seeking protest against Vermont's recent decisions to raise the tobacco [2] and firearm [3] purchasing ages to 21. The last bit of the cell phone bill suggests this. > (5) In light of the dangerous and life-threatening consequences of cell phone use by young people, it is clear that persons under 21 years of age are not developmentally mature enough to safely possess them, just as the General Assembly has concluded that persons under 21 years of age are not mature enough to possess firearms, smoke cigarettes, or consume alcohol. [1] https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2020/Docs/BILLS/S-0212/S-0212%20As%20Introduced.pdf https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2020/Docs/BILLS/S-... [2] https://liquorcontrol.vermont.gov/Tobacco21 https://liquorcontrol.vermont.gov/Tobacco21 [3] https://dps.vermont.gov/content/new-vermont-gun-laws-faqs https://dps.vermont.gov/content/new-vermont-gun-laws-faqs
- catalogia 7y agoHe's probably doing it for the "boomer memes", I'm sure a large part of his constituency thinks this is the funniest thing ever. You probably know the sort; those who laugh at those comics where the kid says "Dad, this iPad is broken." and the old wise boomer says "Son, that's a magazine." Side splitting stuff.
- hanniabu 7y agoGood ol' America, where you can enlist at 17, but can't drink, smoke, or own a firearm until 21. Also where it's illegal to pay somebody to have sex, unless you're filming it.
- neiman 7y ago"Sorry, this content is not available in your region." Second time today in HN while reading from the EU.
- welder 7y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200109230545/https://www.mynbc5.com/article/vermont-bill-would-ban-cellphone-use-for-anyone-under-21/30456265 https://web.archive.org/web/20200109230545/https://www.mynbc...
- tw04 7y agoMost small news organizations can't risk violating GDPR and don't have the technical staff in place to ensure compliance. It's a LOT easier to just block * traffic from Europe. Not saying it's fair or right, but it's reality. Really? I explained why he couldn't get to the site, and I get downvoted? OK
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIt shouldn’t be really surprising at this point: the website probably makes no money on people from the EU via advertising (their advertisers won’t pay for EU clicks), and there is a non trivial overhead in complying with extraterritorial EU laws, so blocking is a cheap solution. Reminds me of how Swiss banks won’t let Americans open bank accounts.
- dpflan 7y agoOK, if we explore this idea, I think there is a valid question of what are the effects of prolonged cellphone/laptop/screen on development. There could be negative consequence to individuals (micro-level) and society (macro-level).
- dang 7y agoBill proposals are rarely on topic for HN. Most bills never go anywhere. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20bills&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- RickJWagner 7y agoWe only gave our kids cell phones when they were old enough to be out without parents (so they could call home if needed.) I wouldn't like not being able to do that.
- duelingjello 7y agoInsane and stupid histrionic clickbait.