8 ms·
Climate change now detectable from any single day of weather at global scale
- supercall 7y agoPeople's financial incentives are not aligned with the climate's necessary modifications. The two won't be aligned until climate passes over its tipping point and enters an irreversible feedback loop.
- loopz 7y agoCurrency can be printed electronically these days. Beings can't eat currency or shelter in currency. xkcd climate timeline: https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/ I know there's a huge difference in data resolution, but worth pondering about nonetheless.
- pjc50 7y ago"When the last tree has been cut down, the last fish caught, the last river poisoned, only then will we realize that one cannot eat money." -- popular quote of unclear but probably native American origin in the 70s: https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/10/20/last-tree-cut/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/10/20/last-tree-cut/
- bureaucrat 7y agoDuh. Science will figure it out and 'the last tree' will never be cut down. Science along with capital is un-poisoning rivers, making fishing sustainable, and greenifing forests while eco-attention freaks do nothing but protest.
- acqq 7y agoAnd, if anybody doubts, it's sure that we are losing forests as we speak: "World losing area of forest the size of the UK each year, report finds Chance of ending deforestation by 2030 seems lower than when pledge was made five years ago" Guardian, Sep 2019: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/sep/12/deforestation-world-losing-area-forest-size-of-uk-each-year-report-finds https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/sep/12/deforest...
- kzrdude 7y agoWhen will incentives ever be aligned with one's own long term interests? There is reason for despair, that competition to survive the day to day - everyone needs to get through their week, month and year - will always detract from the larger concerns about long term sustainability of our civilization and prosperity.
- igorkraw 7y ago> When will incentives ever be aligned with one's own long term interests? Once we've installed a good global governance system (imo some form of confederation of confederation ala Switzerland) that democratically aggregates preferences and can align the incentives. People like to act like competition is inevitable, forgetting that the main hegemon of the last 50 years has competition as a large part of it's ideology (and all the runner ups are not democratically legitimised in the sense people in Europe or the US would consider enough). It's not a law of physics, it's part of a system that can be changed. So I'd disagree. The time for despair is when you are dead, or can no longer try to improve things. Now there's work to do
- Fjolsvith 7y ago> Once we've installed a good global governance system (imo some form of confederation of confederation ala Switzerland) that democratically aggregates preferences and can align the incentives. This is wishful thinking with more than half the world not involved in democratic governance. But be of good cheer. There's profit to be made where there's crisis.
- CalRobert 7y agoI worry that we have removed people's moral agency by normalizing huge debts for life's necessities. We have the technology to make housing and education cheap and plentiful, but instead create scarcities and credit to have leverage over the workforce and keep them working in ways they'd prefer not to. I mean, every day I think "but guys seriously shouldn't we use all these computers to work on the metaphorical asteroid heading for Earth??? guys??" But we don't, myself included, because bills.
- yokaze 7y agoOr laws/taxes are passed, which incorporate the externalities, and subventions for detrimental efforts are cut. That is "just" a matter of political will.
- Consultant32452 7y agoHow much war are you willing to wage to force other countries to do the same? I think that's really the only question that matters when it comes to the "everybody pass laws" plan.
- blackflame 7y agoYou can never know when the tipping point is because either you haven't yet hit it, or you already have but don't know at which point in the past the death spiral could have been prevented, if at all.
- windexh8er 7y agoThis is an ineffective approach. No country can assume any other will fall in line to "do the same". This creates a do nothing approach because it turns doing the right thing, by taking the first steps, into a game of finger pointing. War is definitely not the answer and is 100% counterproductive to the end goal. If all countries, that are supposedly interested in being the best climate change affectors, all competed to truly be the best - we'd be in a far better spot. The war you allude to is not international in nature. It's national. If the US, for example, actually removed campaign contributions and lobbying allowances from organizations responsible for a majority of annual pollution we'd already be down the road. But instead it is national politics, and those legislators, that are the real roadblock to starting the snowball move towards clean technology.
- Consultant32452 7y agoThe problem with this approach, which I was trying to highlight, is that as long as "doing better by climate change" implies "economic disadvantage" there will be major polluters who do not get on board. What will you do with them? If you really believe this is an existential crisis for humanity, you must be willing to destroy these countries. Choose your poison: bomb them to oblivion or sanction/starve them to death. That is why this is a failed approach.
- pluc 7y agoGood. Something smarter than humans might come along next.
- dang 7y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- surfsvammel 7y agoWe have in fact already passed a couple of those tipping points, unfortunately. But we can still make a big difference by getting our act together. But, some of those are already locked in, we might not see the effect for 1000 or even 10000 years, but still.
- CalRobert 7y agoOr until we discover how many fewer billions Earth can support at +4C
- PeterStuer 7y agoThing is the world's climate will not fail us gradually. Past the 'tipping point' the 'Geo-engineers' will be let out of the asylum and get to deploy their crackpot hail-Mary schemes playing fast and loose with a runaway high dimensional complex feedback system they (or we) barely are beginning to understand. There is no 'backup' on this planet. There is no 'safety net'. There is no 'oh shit, abort!' button. An optimist would say we are just going to make sure to speed up the inevitable.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- amiga_500 7y agoBecause laissez-faire economics doesn't converge automagically on the best path. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1993/12/how-the-world-works/305854/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1993/12/how-the...
- ixtli 7y agoCorrect. I'd add that I don't think anyone worth listening to has ever really thought this to be true: rather, it is convenient for those with the majority of private capital for everyone to believe it is true so that they don't have to account for how they spend their money.
- ykevinator 7y agoNot on fox News
- skilled 7y agoLiving in Eastern Europe right now. It's +6 Celsius for the last week. Earth hasn't frozen yet, so if any snow falls it melts in a few hours. In comparison, when I was growing up here in the 90s; we had solid -30 Celsius winters for several months. You had to prepare opposed to nowadays, where buying a winter jacket comes down to preference. Cold or not cold... But climate change is a hoax, right?
- haunter 7y agoI mean I live in Eastern Europe too, Hungary and it's -7c now. No snow but everything is frozen. I don't think our local experiences are a good indicator. >we had solid -30 Celsius winters for several months I'm curious, do you have any data source about that? -30c for several months sounds really extreme
- skilled 7y agoWhy would you ask me for data when you can look that up for yourself? I speak from experience.
- exdsq 7y agoMaybe in Siberia? I can’t find anything for, say, Ukraine to suggest it averaged -30 for months
- bureaucrat 7y ago>I was growing up here in the 90s; we had solid -30 Celsius winters for several months. Where? In your imagination? https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148642/1990/Historical-Weather-during-1990-at-Kyiv-Zhuliany-International-Airport-Ukraine https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148642/1990/Historical-Weather-... https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148509/1990/Historical-Weather-during-1990-at-Ellinik%C3%B3n-Airport-Greece https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148509/1990/Historical-Weather-... https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148455/1990/Historical-Weather-during-1990-at-Belgrade-Nikola-Tesla-Airport-Serbia https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148455/1990/Historical-Weather-... https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148594/1990/Historical-Weather-during-1990-at-Loshitsa-Minsk-International-1-Belarus https://weatherspark.com/h/y/148594/1990/Historical-Weather-...
- Taniwha 7y agoAustralia is burning, its government doesn't seem to think anything is wrong, they just want to dig more coal
- mikro2nd 7y agoThey might not get the chance: latest news[1] this morning is that some of the coal seams have caught fire underground! This is catastrophic. Underground coal (and oil) fires are near-impossible to put out and are generally just left alone to burn, usually for decades before/if they run out of fuel. [1] https://twitter.com/maetl/status/1213420680579964929?s=20 https://twitter.com/maetl/status/1213420680579964929?s=20
- selimthegrim 7y agoIs there a source for this assertion?
- scrollaway 7y agoIt's a decently well-known phenomenon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal-seam_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal-seam_fire For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia_mine_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia_mine_fire -- Started burning in 1962. Still burning today and on track to burn for another 250 years.
- selimthegrim 7y agoI meant the news item, but thank you.
- pnako 7y agoThe oldest one is about 6,000 years old https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burning_Mountain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burning_Mountain
- squarefoot 7y agoIf that's the case then it's truly catastrophic. As an example, the Centralia (USA) mine coal-seam fire started in 1962 is extimated to last for about 250 more years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia_mine_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia_mine_fire Assuming we have the technology, removing underground oxygen might help to put out the underground fires, though I can't imagine any process not involving either pumping sea water down there which would make the land sterile for vegetation, or slowly replacing oxygen with CO2 which would be even worse.
- beefield 7y agoI'm quite tired of the framing of the climate change discussion, whether it exists or not. It is like you pondering whether your house is going to actually burn next year or not when you think about purchasing insurance. Completely idiotic question. What you are thinking is the risk (i.e probability times loss) of your house burning. So no, I am not going to tell you that the climate catastrophe is going to happen. What I do say is that even if after reframing the discussion from dichotomy to probability discussion, if you really think that the probability of the scientists being collectively wrong is so small that the science can be ignored, in my books you are so f$&king stupid[1] that you should give up your voting rights. [1] pardon, I think my french is a bit rusty here.
- chewbacha 7y agoI don't think that's a very apt analogy because it still frames the question as to whether something is _going_ to happen. It's more like you contemplating whether your house is going to burn next year while a fire fighter is telling you it's on fire right now.
- scrollaway 7y agoYes well, those so-called "firefighters", what do they know about fire anyway. I see no evidence that my house is burning, and all the fire coming out of it is due to its natural warming cycle.
- brobdingnagians 7y agoIt is important to distinguish the basis of the change. Whether anthropogenic or of other causes (or, likely, a mix of causes). The same change in weather could have different responses based on the cause. It is also important to talk about what to change. Some governmental/industrial changes could cause the deaths of millions or billions of people (doing absolutely nothing might do the same), it is important to have a civil conversation where the ideas and rights of all are respected, understood, and considered. Oversimplifying is not useful. I'm not arguing for any specific reason or changes, only for civility and all around thoughtfulness. It is a very complex issue that may impact a huge number of factors in society. Great caution, civility, and thought should be given. Even to those who disagree with some conclusions. Advocating for the removal of voting rights for those who disagree so that we can arrange their future for them may be counterproductive.
- SimplePotato 7y agoYes everything is completely messed up. Flowers blooming at wrong times of the year, animals are confused, crops are being beaten up by the biggest hail, Winds are getting stronger and this and that etc. Mother earth didn't even show the real teeth yet. When one of the the super Vulcanos wakes up we'll see the real hell on the earth. There is also super hostile environment outside earth but this is for some other space debate.
- buboard 7y agoit would be naive/foolish to expect that the enormous technological progress and overpopulation by humans would not affect the environment. The question is how fast can people and ecosystems adapt. This is not the first nor the biggest change the earth has seen by far. It's also naive to think that politics is going to reverse that change - it's a technological problem.
- kmlx 7y agothe overpopulation mantra has been debunked so many times already. edit: since i'm getting downvoted for pointing out the obvious, here's links pointing out that overpopulation is a myth, even a racist one in some circumstances: wapo: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-the-worlds-population/2011/10/26/gIQArjSWmM_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-the... https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/fee.org/articles/the-myth-that-the-world-is-facing-a-population-crisis//amp https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/fee.org/articles/the-myth-tha... https://www.pop.org/debunking-the-myth-of-overpopulation/ https://www.pop.org/debunking-the-myth-of-overpopulation/ https://www.globaljustice.org.uk/blog/2019/mar/9/how-racist-myths-built-population-growth-bogey-man https://www.globaljustice.org.uk/blog/2019/mar/9/how-racist-... kurzgesagt: https://youtu.be/QsBT5EQt348 https://youtu.be/QsBT5EQt348 the guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/mar/19/overpopulation-cities-environment-developing-world-racist-paul-ehrlich https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/mar/19/overpopulatio... nytimes: https://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/14/opinion/overpopulation-is-not-the-problem.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/14/opinion/overpopulation-is... https://wattsupwiththat.com/2019/05/25/overpopulation-the-deadly-myth-behind-the-other-modern-myths/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2019/05/25/overpopulation-the-de...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- K0SM0S 7y agoIndeed, if we only think in terms of thermodynamics, the Earth could sustain trillions of people with ample private room (orders of magnitude more than our current average home+office size). And if you trickle down to implementation problems (agriculture, logistics, etc) and take mega-structures of the 25th century out from the equation (so, immediate future, 21st century) you still get a max figure north of 10 times the current pop. The problem is one of contrast: e.g. there's nobody in deserts but people die everyday in overcrowded train stations in India. That's why people perceive "overpopulation" as a problem, but it has more to do with human inefficiency than the physics of our planet. However GP's point about adaptation speed of our civilization to the changing ecosystem stands. I sometimes wonder, between utopia and horror, how many people will have to die in the name of climate catastrophes for a global "survival instinct" to kick in at the highest level — like stability is a thing for the finance world, the military world, because we're so aware of how much these things may destroy or kill when derailed. I'm pretty much convinced it's generational — boomers will never get to it, not enough of them; half of gen Xers might sway; but millenials (born 1982 and on) will enact the tipping point, politically and sociologically. So, that's 2030-2040 mechanically for that gen to become the dominant one (by then aged 50-60). My question is, how many will climate kill or hurt deeply until then? Could the tipping point happen sooner due to catastrophes? I don't know what's a reasonable fair estimate, here. Are we talking millions? tens, hundreds? a billion? How dire is the situation, really?
- bbeckerman 7y agoPublicly funded and supported climate change detection method that is essential to communicate to the public...behind a paywall. Disappointing at least.
- conistonwater 7y agohttps://sci-hub.se/https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-019-0666-7 https://sci-hub.se/https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-019-0666-7
- aldoushuxley001 7y agoSeems fake
- jokoon 7y agoThe only way to get out of this situation is a green dictatorship. It's the least painful solution. Democracy and freedom are great things, but consumerism abused them, and it's leading everyone to their own destruction. I'm tired to end discussions with "but you cannot confiscate things from people, it's against basic human rights". Ignorance and failure to listen to reason are very dangerous. I want to hope people will adjust deliberately, but advertising has too much power over people. I cannot let myself gamble with the idea that humanity will be courageous enough to avoid destruction of this scale. The stakes are too high. History always worked like this. It's a collection of new lessons that adjust the collective consciousness. The future will progressively look like some Hollywood dystopia, until something will break politically, but it will be too late. Don't forget that the new deadline is the melting permafrost, which will snowball climate change into something that will make temperature rise much faster.
- CM30 7y agoIf you really want to kick off another civil war/world war, something like this seems like the perfect way to do so. If people tried to enforce environmentalism via a dictatorship, the rest of the population would like fight back hard, and they'd end up in a very awkward situation very quickly. Remember, the people who would want to limit other people's consumption for environmentalism sakes are significantly outnumbered and outgunned by those who don't. It would also likely inspire an awful lot of anti intellectualism and anti 'ivory tower' resentment, which could have terrible consequences for the future. Basically, any attempt would go about as well as someone walking into the middle east and trying to set up a secular dictatorship in the style of the USSR. Of course, a cynic may say that's the only way to deal with climate change and they may be right. It's just that trying to fix things via force would probably go even more poorly than trying to persuade people to live less comfortably would. Unfortunately, the most likely fixes right now are probably: A: Some sort of miraculous new technology is invented that can cheaply do carbon capture and provide enough clean energy that fossil fuels are made completely obsolete. B: Somehow, a huge push is made for mastering space travel, and people are incentivised to leave Earth. A sentient species with an advanced civilisation may simply be incompatible with other life on a planet. C: Society gets wrecked enough that humanity somehow ends back in a pre industrial revolution state, perhaps due to the side effects of climate change. D: Humanity simply decides they can't fix Earth, doesn't try and edits themselves/civilisation to deal with rampant temperature increases/disasters/whatever.
- manigandham 7y agoDoes anyone have a link to the paper? Also climate change is undeniable. At the risk of stirring the controversy, the real questions have always been: how much of it is because of human activity? and if that's significant, how much power do we have to change it further? Based on the evidence so far, I personally think modern civilization has triggered initial conditions for the warming cycle but is no longer the majority force for the continued change.
- rfrey 7y agoWhat do you base that opinion on?
- manigandham 7y agoFeedback cycles and runaway change wouldn't be an issue otherwise. Things like melting permafrost [1] releasing methane would be an example of something we triggered and now has taken over as a majority contributor in those regions. 1. https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2785/unexpected-future-boost-of-methane-possible-from-arctic-permafrost/ https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2785/unexpected-future-boost-o...
- dmd 7y agoYou can "personally think" whatever you want. You can "personally think" that 0 is 1, that frogs are a kind of cat, that the moon is made of cheese. Just please don't make decisions that affect other people based on what you "personally think", when it's about facts that have actual truth values.
- manigandham 7y agoWhat is the fact around the exact impact that humanity has had vs natural conditions, and what is the derivative of that impact as the climate has changed? For there to be a runaway effect means that humanity is no longer the significant factor so how is this calculated? I've never found this explicitly stated anywhere. By the way, every human makes decisions based on what they "personally think". Please share the "actual truth values" if you have them.
- yalogin 7y agoOn this issue the anti science republicans have been wildly successful in convincing people about their claims than the other side has been. At this point climate change denial has been adopted into their core political platform and they just blindly reject and rally against any issue that has the word climate, sustainable or any similar words. This is a huge failure of humanity in general.
- bamboozled 7y agoIt’s likely to kill everyone of us. From the rich to the poor, strong to the weak, through famine, war and drought. Natural disaster after natural disaster. Horror after horror. Tragedy after tragedy. Yet we’re all in state of paralysis, watching our impending doom draw closer and fates unfold. Entrusting those who will do nothing about it. Half of us are still in denial. I really wonder if we possess the survival instincts we think we do. Do we really have the drive to go on ? Were humans just lucky to be installed on this beautiful blue spaceship. Do we deserve any merit for our past success? We are just limp and powerless to do anything about it all it seems. Such a strange time to be alive, what a peculiar situation we’re in. Quite the nightmare indeed.
- hsavit1 7y ago500 million animals wiped out in the blink of an eye and we look the other way. When humans start dying, I think we will continue to look the other way.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bamboozled 7y agoHardly a whimper for them.
- mistermann 7y ago> Half of us are still in denial. One half is in denial about climate change itself, and the other half is in denial about the solution to the problem. Almost everyone is guilty.
- K0SM0S 7y agoI think it's generational, and it will get better in the 2030-2040s at the latest, when millennials become the dominant generation. The ethos of climate awareness is simply not present enough in previous generations, the seeds were simply too few, too weak, too late. They quite literally were not born in a world where 'it' was a thing. Here's my other comment below for details.[1] This is compoundd by the fact that "professional politicians" feel compelled/incentivized to lie over and over again in their career, and it becomes easier and easier to lie as you do it — kind of a psychological response to cognitive dissonance, a defense mechanism. Survival instinct, at this level, is definitely individual, internal, and may completely shut down or even oppose the survival of the country, civilization, species. You just lie your way out to save yourself and your family and friends, and to hell with everyone and everything else because you're not super(wo)man. So human. The kind of collective instinct for survival (what Jung would probably have called a collective form of consciousness, that is opened to others, bigger-than-each-of-us) that is required for such higher-level evolution (civ, species) is more generational, imho. This is all mostly deduced/hypothesized from sociology and political science studies, with a tad of psychology etc. I mean, I haven't found much contradictory arguments to these apparent "truths", however unable we feel to explain them. It takes generations to meaningfully evolve civilizational paradigms, there's just no speeding up history in that regard. We merely leap forward big time when conditions are ripe and a particularly exceptional figure (or group thereof) manages to steer things "the right way" — one of these. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21955196 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21955196
- cannabis_sam 7y agoEconomics is a morally bankrupt pseudoscience, that’s literally killing our planet. Anyone looking for an answer to the fermi paradox, I think we’ve got something here!
- cannabis_sam 7y agoI would appreciate a counterargument..