10 ms·
Taking Virtual Reality for a Test Drive
- neonate 7y agohttp://archive.md/ud1fF http://archive.md/ud1fF
- canada_dry 7y agoI have a couple VR headsets and, like someone on reddit recently observed, they sit mostly gathering dust - but, when I do put one on, I will use it for hours. Most times it's such a totally immersive experience that I'm usually shocked to discover that I'm actually at home when I take off the helmet. IMHO VR (and AR) has moved on from being at a high risk of dying as an overhyped fad (e.g. 3D TV) to having enough niche utility that its uses will grow as people get exposed to it. Using VR is a fun regular diversion at the moment, but not a highly useful tool - but I'm hopeful that will change. I would love to be able to easily use a VR helmet in conjunction with a keyboard/mouse/hands vs. holding controllers to do more intensive computer tasks like programming.
- wlesieutre 7y agoFor what it's worth, gathering dust isn't universal. Pretty much every day mine gets fired up for half an hour of Pistol Whip or Beat Saber. Other games get longer sessions, like Shadow Point which I just started yesterday. Neat game so far, puzzles based on perspective, light/shadow, mirrors/reflections, that kind of thing. It reminds me of The Witness in a lot of ways. Also has some unusual spaces where rooms connect to each other or back to themselves in a ways that they shouldn't. Nothing new about that in games, but it's weirder to experience in VR than on a computer screen. My favorite trick so far has been where they'll make you lean in close to something, and then when you step back you find yourself in a totally different space. Nothing changes on screen, they just pull the whole environment out from under you while it's outside your field of view, leaving only the part you'd been looking at unchanged. Narration by Patrick Stewart is also great. A friend was telling me last week that a 3D space strategy game is what he was hoping to see in VR before he jumps on board. Then last night I stumbled on Eternal Starlight, which will be right up his alley: https://twitter.com/e_starlight_vr/status/1211646479884017664 https://twitter.com/e_starlight_vr/status/121164647988401766... It's still early days, but I think VR has a lot of room for different kinds of experiences for all sorts of demographics. Very excited to see what we can do with it in the next couple of years.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pharke 7y ago> I would love to be able to easily use a VR helmet in conjunction with a keyboard/mouse/hands vs. holding controllers to do more intensive computer tasks like programming. I'm looking forward to this with the Quest. I've tried out the hand tracking but there aren't many apps that support it yet. I haven't given bluetooth pairing a go yet but I'm itching to try out some kind of text editor with it when I have the time. I agree that they need to reduce the barrier to putting the headset on even more, I think that moment will come when the UI experience is as easy as opening a laptop which probably means reducing the weight further and having much better video pass through so you're not completely hoodwinked while using it (being able to easily drink a coffee while working in VR is a must). AR glasses would be ideal but seem like they're still pretty far off for reasons like battery life, screen resolution, opacity, and bulkiness. The interim solution will probably just be comfort and durability for VR to the point where you can put it on as easily as a hat and treat it with the same physicality as a tablet. Oculus' Half Dome 3 prototype[0] seems to be exactly this which is why I'm very excited to buy whatever iteration of it comes to market. [0] https://www.oculus.com/blog/half-dome-updates-frl-explores-more-comfortable-compact-vr-prototypes-for-work/?locale=en_US https://www.oculus.com/blog/half-dome-updates-frl-explores-m...
- whywhywhywhy 7y ago>I haven't given bluetooth pairing a go yet but I'm itching to try out some kind of text editor with it when I have the time. Seen a few people posting that Glitch's coding tools work in Firefox on the Quest with at bluetooth Keyboard. https://twitter.com/fernandojsg/status/1139570325312684032 https://twitter.com/fernandojsg/status/1139570325312684032
- dickjocke 7y agoI wonder if there is any application for VR as an IDE tool. From what I understand, today it is very hard to see text clearly and type, but I spend a lot of time sitting on my couch or laying on my back trying to code pretend I'm not creeping up on 30 and that I can sustain that kind of computer use. I think if I could wear a headset and sit on my couch or even lay on my back and code it would be heavenly.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoI've played around a bit with Virtual Desktop[1] on my Oculus Quest, and text is surprisingly legible, even over WiFi. I've seen some people on Reddit who claim they write code all day with a similar setup (often with 180° or more of monitors). It's not something I would want to do (esp. typing while using VR), but it's possible. [1]: https://www.vrdesktop.net/ https://www.vrdesktop.net/
- e12e 7y agoHave you tried the oculus dk2? As I recall text wasn't crisp enough to be usable - wondering if that's much better on the quest? You're using the quest as a vr headset for your computer? Running W10?
- Rebelgecko 7y agoYeah, I'm using it to display the monitors hooked up to a PC running Windows 10. I've tried the Oculus CV1 and various dev kits. I don't remember if I ever tried DK2, but I saw a few demos on the "1080 HD" dev kit which came between DK1 and DK2. For me, reading text on the Quest is MUCH easier. If I were using an IDE I'd probably bump the font size up to 14pt to make things a bit more comfortable but it's not awful with the default settings. For reference, when I view the new godawful Steam UI [1]on the Quest, the only text I have a hard time reading is the list of games on the left. In games that work with VR but aren't really designed it in mind (e.g. Euro and American truck simulator) it's can be harder to read some of the text, especially at oblique angles. I need to lean forward a bit to be able to read things like my fuel gauge. [1]: https://assets.vg247.com/current//2019/09/steam_library_overhaul_screen_3.jpg https://assets.vg247.com/current//2019/09/steam_library_over...
- jdietrich 7y ago>I have a couple VR headsets and, like someone on reddit recently observed, they sit mostly gathering dust - but, when I do put one on, I will use it for hours. That was one of the key factors that influenced the design of Oculus Quest. Carmack spoke often of minimising the "time-to-first-fun" in both hardware and software. A VR headset that you can just put on and start using is meaningfully different to a VR headset that requires even the most moderate amount of setup. > I would love to be able to easily use a VR helmet in conjunction with a keyboard/mouse/hands Oculus Quest already supports the Bluetooth pairing of keyboards and mice, which can then be used to wirelessly interact with a remote PC via Virtual Desktop. We don't yet have a mechanism for tracking the position of keyboards and mice, but it's pretty much trivial if there's a market for it - we just need keyboards and mice with embedded IR markers. Controllerless hand tracking is in beta on Quest and developers have access to the APIs; official support should be rolling out in the next couple of months. The resolution is still much lower than we'd like, but 1440 x 1600 per eye provides a marginally tolerable experience for desktop computing. The HP Reverb already provides 2160 x 2160 per eye, so we're very close to having headsets that can truly replace a conventional monitor.
- shafyy 7y agoGreat to see VR more frequently on the first page here.
- Causality1 7y agoMy issue with VR has always been UX. I purchased an Oculus Touch a couple of years ago. When it works and I'm in-game it's utterly transporting. Truly a next-gen feeling. Everything else about it is an absolute nightmare. The software insists the headset is working fine while the headset is blank and displays an amber warning light. It requires you to have a computer monitor facing your VR area, which for me involves twisting my desktop screen completely around backwards. The slightest vibration throws the tracking cameras off forcing me to set up the entire play area again. Game downloads refuse to start for unknown reasons. Games designed for use with a traditional gamepad won't work with the Touch controllers and my gamepad won't work unless I pull the batteries from my Touch controllers and unpair them from my Rift. Oh, and my new glasses don't fit in the headset and they don't sell wider adapters. VR is the future but its present will make you want to beat its developers with a tire iron.
- wlesieutre 7y agoGive the Quest a shot. No setup besides putting it on your head and tracing out the guardian area. Controller tracking is nearly flawless, with some limitations like not being able to hold a controller behind your back or hidden behind your other arm, but I don't run into those limits in practice. Probably won't help your glasses though. That's one of the Quest's bigger design oversights IMO, that wearing glasses can scratch the headset lenses even with the glasses spacer installed. There are 3d printed lens rim bumpers that will keep glasses from touching the headset lenses, but if your glasses don't physically fit that just trades smushing them into the headset lenses for smushing them into your face.
- mdre 7y agoBuy some VR Lens protectors. I got some for my vive, there were some special dedicated ones but I just got a pair of smart watch protectors that were recommended on Reddit.
- wlesieutre 7y agoI printed a set of the bumpers, I think they're protective enough for me while not having any impact on the optical quality like a stick-on protector would
- wildermuthn 7y agoVR hardware, with the wireless Quest and its eventual successors, is ready for the mainstream. VR software is not. What drives an industry is value, whether business or recreational. While VR software has typically focused on entertainment value (and there is a lot there), business-driven VR software hasn’t received as much attention as it deserves. But thus far no killer-app of VR has been made. There is no excel, no word, no browser. But there could be, if more people thought about and identified what VR hardware can do that no other platform can. Moreover, its value needs to be a 10x moment. Minor improvements will not cause mass adoption. So what can VR provide that other platforms can’t? 1) 3D Space This is the first thing people think of, but is the least important. There are few business tasks that can’t be done on a 2D plane, and the value of going 3D (such as in industrial design) is not a 10x improvement over real-life prototyping. 2) Unlimited space This also provides less value than it seems. A human can only be in one place, and our vision can only encompass so much area. There is a low upper-bound on how much space a human being can use. 3) Presence The feeling of “being there” is something VR does 10x better than other platforms. This has been leveraged by entertainment software to good effect. However, the nature of recreational user experience — gameplay experience — doesn’t hinge upon presence in a location. VR games can induce strong presence while still not providing value with strong gameplay experience. 4) Social Presence This is where VR hardware has the greatest possible leverage and impact. When you play poker in VR, you see this most clearly — people spend more time interacting with one another than actually playing poker. Even with cartoonish avatars, the feeling of being in the presence of another person is practically the same as being in the same room with them. There is large room for growth in improving social presence, but even the early state of VR software is 10x better than what exists elsewhere. If there is to be a killer business app for VR, it will be akin to excel. But instead of transforming numbers and formulas, it will transform communication and relationships. Whatever replaces Facebook, video chat, JIRA, Reddit, Tinder, or even email will be done on VR/AR. The gold is there waiting to be picked up. It’s just up to some great company to do it.
- pmoriarty 7y agoVR hardware is awful. It's bulky, uncomfortable, and annoying. Until VR headsets are as light and unobtrusive as a pair of ordinary glasses, VR will never become mainstream. Even ordinary glasses are unacceptable to many people for aesthetic reasons, despite being much lighter, less obtrusive, more comfortable, and more convenient than VR headsets, which look even geekier than glasses.
- japhyr 7y agoWe just got our 8yo son a Nintendo Labo kit to go with his Switch. I was skeptical about it, because anything with VR or AI or ML in the promotional material has the potential to be mostly hype. But I was amazed watching him build and use the kits. If you're not familiar with it, the Labo is a series of cardboard devices that you build, which hold your switch and controllers and turn them into a VR setup. For example, you build a blaster and play a VR game where you shoot aliens from a few different virtual worlds. Or you build a bird with wings that flap, and then you fly around with other birds looking for eggs to hatch. Along with that, you build a foot pedal that makes you fly faster, which also fans you so you feel more air rushing by your face as you fly faster. The first time I tried it, I spent about 5 minutes shooting at aliens all around me. I was laughing and jumping when the boss alien leaped into the air and came down over my head. When I took the headset away from my face, I was amazed to find myself back in my own house. It's amazing to me that people at Nintendo built a VR kit around a device that, as far as I know, was never intended to be a VR device. It's been really satisfying watching our son build his own setups, rather than just using a manufactured plastic device. He's having so much fun with it, and he's learning so much from it as well. He sees what the screen looks like in VR mode when it's out of the VR kit, which has led to interesting conversations around concepts like raytracing. If you're not ready to jump into an Oculus setup and you already have a switch around, I highly recommend trying out one of the Labo kits.
- shafyy 7y agoWhile the Labo is great, we should avoid describing it as VR. The same is true for Google Cardboard. The experience in a "true" VR headset that offers 6 DoF and hands, such as the Oculus Quest, is just something completely different.
- kkarakk 7y agoIt's functionally VR and is most current gen folk's/kids first experience with VR. There is no point gatekeeping it Unless you think ~20 million headset VR users is somehow a large number of people in a world saturated with smartphones
- kfarr 7y agoAgree with all of the comments here which can be basically boiled down to: the hardware, especially the Quest, is great and "ready" for prime time. However the software is not. Yes, agreed 100%. As a hobbyist web vr developer I'd say one of the most difficult (and also exciting) things about the industry is that there are very few agreed upon conventions. As a developer you are faced with recreating the wheel for each and every experience. Imagine if as a web developer you had to literally recreate pixel for pixel a web form, checkbox, etc. and all its behavior. It would take forever to just get a basic application working. That's where VR is at. It's coming, just slowly.
- jotm 7y agoI only have an Oculus Go, which I decided to get as a test drive. It's... fun, but the graphics quality is lacking. Some people say they stop noticing the screen door effect, but I never do. Plus I do notice the limited FOV. Watching movies in a virtual theater is pretty bad, and I can't even smile or laugh because then everything goes out of focus, or have a snack, obviously. I did love the various travel videos on Oculus Video, 360 VR makes it a whole new experience. If there were any VR MMO's I'd try them (Zenith had some hype a while ago). It's a real pain, but you can use the Go + a PS4/Xbox controller to play games on a big screen, and indeed it's a nice experience even if it's not VR/3D. Still prefer a projector for anything 2D.
- Phillips126 7y agoI was intrigued by VR so I picked up the Oculus Go. It was interesting, but felt lacking. I wasn't disappointed but the whole experience felt pretty meh. For Christmas I thought I'd test the upgrade and purchased an Oculus Quest. Wow, this thing blew me away. The experience is night and day different, so much so that I stuck my Go in the closet and may be selling it down the road. Having two controllers, hand tracking, Oculus Link if you have a gaming PC, overall improvements to display and battery, and of course 6 DOF. I've never been more excited about VR. The Quest really is an incredible unit. I've so far been able to: - Play "native" Quest games which have been very fun - Play PCVR (SteamVR) games using ALVR[0] over 5ghz WiFi with great performance - Sideloaded RetroArch[1] to play N64, SNES, Gameboy and GameCube games with a bluetooth controller - Watching full length movies in a cinema-like experience - Enjoying many 360 videos on YouTube I'm contemplating doing some game development in VR again. I tried to build some applications on my Go but the single controller and weak specs really hindered my creativity. I implore you to test out the Quest if you found the Go experience lacking as I did, it's really more than a minor upgrade. [0] https://github.com/polygraphene/ALVR https://github.com/polygraphene/ALVR [1] https://www.retroarch.com/ https://www.retroarch.com/
- alasdair_ 7y agoHow does oculus link on the quest compare to the latest-gen rift? Is there any reason to buy the rift any more?
- buboard 7y agowith prices of huge tv screens dropping , what about 3d projection rooms like this? https://prodisplay.com/wp-content/uploads/cave-projection-screens-600x400.jpg https://prodisplay.com/wp-content/uploads/cave-projection-sc...
- criddell 7y agoThat's the tech that I want to see grow. I have no interest in wearing a headset for long periods of time but a holodeck-like room would be amazing.
- saberdancer 7y agoYou don't get 3d with that kind of setup. It can work for seated experiences like driving or flying sims but for any kind of game where you interact with the environment it doesn't work. Holodeck is effectively VR, not walls with projections on them.
- criddell 7y agoRight. I'm saying I want to see that tech developed. There used to be ad kiosks in grocery stores that had a 3d display without glasses. This was about 10 years ago and I don't really know how it worked (holograms maybe?). Make an entire room out of that stuff.
- saberdancer 7y agoHow can you drive adoption with that kind of setup. Most people do not have a spare room just for some kind of 3D setup, even if you could develop a technology to turn your walls into 3D images, you still cannot interact with the environment as you cannot project the image in the "air". You cannot grab things or turn things around as you can in VR. Given that your perspective should change depending on your head positioning, this kind of system should reproject everything as you move your head (even turning of your head should affect it). There are a lot of issues with this kind of tech, at least for the mass market. For niche uses like driving simulators it can work, and I am sure with enough cash you could set it up. Even VR has issues, data collected by SteamVR and Oculus shows that most people have very small playspaces, this means that roomscale experiences are much harder to pull off. Right now, the main problem is barriers to adoption, having a headset that you can just put on your head like you turn on your gaming console, that is what is needed. Needing to take 5 minutes to start everything up, or half an hour to setup your tracking cameras is not acceptable for average consumer. Oculus Quest works great in this department and is the way VR will go forward.