13 ms·
Blue light may not be as disruptive to sleep patterns as thought: mouse study
- StuffedParrot 7y agoI’m curious if they tested the wavelengths that wood fires give off as well as moonlight—this would most closely match “natural” light exposure post twilight.
- georgebarnett 7y agoA few weeks ago I was advised by a lighting specialist that there’s a lot of ongoing disagreement regarding the best approach for reducing how light affects sleep. I was aware that there has been limited research and many of the solutions to this point have been basically “copy flux”. Thanks for posting this. Very interesting read and has made me change my buying behaviour.
- 34234lr 7y agoIs there disagreement also regarding the lighting level? I have dimmable lights and I like how I feel when I gradually dim them to darkness before going to sleep.
- georgebarnett 7y agoI don't know; I was particularly looking at color shifting devices and the recommendation was to hold off on the purchase for a few years until the science had a change to settle.
- chadlavi 7y agoAre mice a good analogue for human circadian rhythms?
- coldtea 7y agoBetter than ad-hoc hand waving, as is the "theory" most "blue light prevention" products are sold by...
- OGWhales 7y agoLooking at this image: https://i.imgur.com/NRvV0Kn.jpg https://i.imgur.com/NRvV0Kn.jpg [0] It seems like they are significantly more awake during the day. I only did minimal research, so be weary to trust me. But regardless, I would find this study to be essentially useless in determining how blue light affects the sleep of humans. [0] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnsys.2019.00051/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnsys.2019.0005...
- mgraczyk 7y agoAnecdotally, I can pretty reliably trigger a migraine by staying up 2-3 hours later than normal staring at a normal LCD screen. With flux/redshift on, that doesn't happen. Blue light may not be keeping me up, but it definitely fucks my brain up in some complicated way.
- rosstex 7y agoSame, my eyes completely stopped hurting at night when I switched to flux, permanently.
- thrownblown 7y agosimilarly, after switching my tv,gaming rig,work laptop,phone to twilight/flux/redshift/night mode for several months, I find going without at night to be uncomfortable almost to the point of pain. my ex-wife found them to be too dark and painful to her eyes.
- shrimp_emoji 7y agoI've found no difference after ~2 years of going (pretty deeply) red on all my devices and suddenly going back to filterless every now and again. I can't believe how blue it looks, but then I adjust. I continue to redfilter out of neurotic superstition. Like maybe we'll all have a macular degeneratory epidemic in the future because blue light was our generation's asbestos or cigarettes. Have you seen the new Blade Runner? They have yellow lights everywhere. Pretty sus, imo.
- DenisM 7y agoDid you adjust for brightness?
- slavik81 7y agoI only turn on night mode when the brightness on my Pixel is already at its minimum. It would be nice if I could turn the backlight even lower instead. In complete darkness, even the dimmest setting is unnecessarily bright. It seems like the ability to further reduce all light (including blue) would be a clear improvement, but I assume there's a reason why the minimum is what it is. Is there some sort of hardware limitation on the minimum brightness of the backlight?
- nixpulvis 7y agoI wonder how a human raised in a home with incandescent vs fluorescent vs other colors of light bulb would react. I have to assume this is at least partially a learned response.
- m104 7y agoThey only tested on mice. Mice are nocturnal.
- quotemstr 7y agoThe number of high profile research reversals over the past decade or so has been extraordinary. At this point, I'm forced to regard most published findings as simply false unless strongly supported by intuition and repeated studies. More and more, I feel like the process of science has decided all the "signal" the natural world is giving us and that now we're just interpreting noise, at least as it pertains to studies on people.
- thrower123 7y agoThere's an astounding amount of nonsense popularized in mass media where they take the results of these studies and promote it as the gospel truth, without noting the caveats - tiny sample size, only studied in mice, effect sizes, etc, etc. By the time the game of telephone has relayed the story to the public via the local TV news puff piece, it has been distorted so heavily that it becomes complete nonsense.
- kev009 7y agoNot sure how much conditioning this is but I tend to be more focused and task oriented in >4000K color temperature. I can't really stand residential settings >2700K (unless it's some isolated work room like a garage, laundry etc). So the people that work on that lighting design stuff seem to know what they are doing, at least for me. It doesn't help with the desire to actually go to bed, but another anecdote is the darker the room the better the sleep. Most window dressings are decorative and designed to be somewhat translucent. Add a blackout cellular shade or curtain. Eliminate any displays, cover power LEDs etc.
- Ericson2314 7y agoOK intuitively there is indirect and direct sunlight. Based on my highly unscientific personal experience I'd guess the body can tell between direct daylight and sunset spectra (both warm) and indirect daylight and twilight spectra (both cool). Electronic blue lights after lots of f.lux seem quite annoying, so I'd guess they are more like daylight. Relatedly it always bugged me when I was little that blue lights seemed "white in the middle with turquoise then finally blue exterior". Blue lights just couldn't be both bright and saturated very easily. I wouldn't be surprised this is related to the daylight-ness vs twilight-ness.
- 34234lr 7y agoDirect/indirect daylight is not warm, is cold: > Daylight has a spectrum similar to that of a black body with a correlated color temperature of 6500 K https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_temperature#The_Sun https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_temperature#The_Sun
- Ericson2314 7y agoAh, all the better. So the day is neutral/cool or quite cool (direct or indirect) and the evening is warm or that twilight blue which https://www.flickr.com/photos/bob_81667/25663810348 https://www.flickr.com/photos/bob_81667/25663810348 is just the same indirect thing but darker? Would seem like coolish is any time of day depending on brightness, but warm is definitely evening.
- nightfriendly 7y agoWhen the sun goes down, colour temperature is determined by the alternative light source. For most of the past 100,000 years, life on our rotating planet has relied on moonlight (cold) or firelight (warm) to see at night. Incandescent lights (Edison light bulbs) are a bit cooler than the candles and (most of the) oil lamps they replaced. Bright cold (high Kelvin rating) lighting at night is a very modern invention: Temperature (K) Source 1,700 Match flame 1,850 Candle flame, sunset/sunrise 2,700–3,300 Incandescent lamps 3,000 Soft White compact fluorescent lamps 4,100–4,150 Moonlight,[2] xenon arc lamp 5,000 Horizon daylight 5,000 tubular fluorescent lamps or Cool White/Daylight compact fluorescent lamps (CFL) 5,500–6,000 Vertical daylight, electronic flash 6,500 Daylight, overcast 6,500–9,300 LCD or CRT screen 15,000–27,000 Clear blue northern sky
- thdrdt 7y agoHere in the Netherlands the use of green light (540nm) is becomming popular for night lights. It doesn't disrupt sleep patterns of humans, animals and plants and your eyes can see quite well using less brighter lights (saves energy). And green LEDs are relatively cheap. In studies both green and blue light showed to be the least disruptive (but green is better for night sight). I thought this was strange since it was always believed that blue light is bad. But it appears this article agrees. Edit: a lot of plants and corals are grown under red light. So maybe red could be more harmful for your sleep if it triggers growth.
- ghostbrainalpha 7y agoGreen light is also being studied for chronic pain management. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/12/15/787138928/researchers-explore-a-drug-free-idea-to-relieve-chronic-pain-green-light https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/12/15/7871389... I struggle with migraines and am going to do a big Green Light experiment in my house for 2020.
- im3w1l 7y agoUnlike plants, we don't use chlorophyll (which doesn't work with green light) to harvest light.
- tsimionescu 7y agoPlants need both blue and red light to grow. Also, plants and animals are so fundamentally different biologically that very few things which affect one have any direct reason to have similar effects on the other.
- pilif 7y agoFor the last 3 years, the most reliable way for me to fall asleep quickly has been watching youtube videos on my phone. Night-shift is off too. Seeing how differing everybody's experiences seem to be, maybe this is one thing where people are just different from each other.
- papito 7y agoYou don't have to watch them. Just the blinking of TV will distract your brain from racing. That's how I do it. In my case, I rewatch something that I already know by heart - Seinfeld, futurama, etc. If I know the plot, I don't get into it enough to be awake.
- quickthrower2 7y agoA drama with a complicated enough plot but generally quiet ie mostly talking no action does it for me. But I need to be sleepy in the first place, such that I could probably just go to bed without tv and also sleep!
- Lammy 7y agoForensic Files is the best for this if you aren't negatively affected by the content. Peter Thomas had an incredible voice.
- hanniabu 7y agoHow It Works and Ancient Aliens do the job for me. If I watch either of those after I've just had dinner I don't stand a chance. I'm knocked out by the end of the episode.
- thrownblown 7y agoI use the trashy aliens docs on amazon prime. the "customers also watched" has been great for discovering all sorts of wackado theories on human origins.
- decebalus1 7y agoThe title should probably be edited to include 'in mice'. If it's editorialized, it should be done right. Mice sleep during the day, they are nocturnal. I would trust sleep studies on mice way less for extrapolating to humans... I mean, it's great that this is studied. But they should probably use apes. Also, waiting for all the anecdotal comments 'Yeah, it makes sense. Best sleep I get is after I use my devices without f.lux' to flow.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kerkeslager 7y agoOne possibility is that some people are more reactive to blue light than others. For me, the blue light versus non-blue light difference is really striking. Another issue is that, as others have noted, a lot of people's experiences are with Flux, but Flux is an incomplete solution to the blue light problem. I use a Macbook Air: Flux changes the color temperature of my screen, but directly below my screen is a backlit keyboard which is very, very blue. It was a big turning point for my sleep health when I got a pair of blue light blocking glasses which handled this in addition to the screen blue light.
- soapboxrocket 7y agoDid you get the glasses because you believed they would help your sleep, or for other reasons? One solution to why so many people talk about the improvements with Flux or glasses could be a simple placebo affect.
- kerkeslager 7y agoI got the glasses because I hoped they would help my sleep--I'm not sure I would say I believed they would. I totally agree that it may be the placebo effect. However, I feel that it's important to note in discussions of the placebo effect that it's fairly irrelevant whether an intervention works because of the placebo effect or some other reason--what matters is whether the intervention works. And this one does, at least for me.
- tsimionescu 7y agoIf an intervention only 'works' because of the placebo effect, than that intervention doesn't actually work and there is no reason for someone else to use it. If my sleep is improved by listening to death metal with the volume set to high, then good for me and I can continue doing it, but you probably shouldn't copy me, and may explain to people that they probably shouldn't buy my 10$ death metal sleeping app. Note: I'm not accusing you of trying to sell something, I hope my comment doesn't come up that way.
- macinjosh 7y agoI use blue filters more for comfort reasons than for health reasons. For me it is less harsh looking and it just let's me work for longer.
- OGWhales 7y agoThis is a study on mice, which from my minimal research appear to be more wakeful at night. I wouldn't consider this study useful at all in determining how blue light affects humans' sleep.
- m11a 7y agoIt isn't meant to be conclusive. These kinds of studies usually are for indicating whether a certain idea is worth pursuing. It takes more money and time to do conclusive studies on humans with larger sample sizes. I wouldn't be immediately dismissive just because it was on mice. It shouldn't be used to definitively argue either way.
- OGWhales 7y agoGood point. I agree. I just felt the headline felt leading compared to the actual intention of the study.
- ping_pong 7y agoThe original study on blue lights was on a small number of humans, and the delta in sleep was less than 20 mins per night. So if this isn't a useful study, I would hardly consider the original blue light study useful or conclusive either. The only reason why you heard about the original study was because it made the headlines.
- OGWhales 7y agoNo arguments there.
- art4ur 7y agoThe red light doesn't seem to travel as far. It's less likely to wake your partner when you peek at your device in the middle of the night.
- internet_user 7y agothat has to do with two things: 1) our photoreceptors in retina have highest sensitivity to blue 2) blue photons are higher in energy than red (1.5x to 2x, depending on specific frequencies/color temps)
- tengbretson 7y agoPerforming this study on humans seems like it would be incredibly easy. Why even bother with mice?
- tabtab 7y agoBlue light is the new caffeine: 2010: Study says caffeine is unhealthful 2011: Study refutes 2010 caffeine study 2012: New study says caffeine is unhealthful 2013: New study says caffeine is safe 2014: Etc.
- lonesword 7y ago"Unhealthful". TIL that it's an actual word.
- tabtab 7y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/unhealthful https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/unhealthful "Harmful" is probably a better choice, now that I think about it.
- Izkata 7y agoYou got me curious: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/unharmful https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/unharmful
- mgazzer 7y agoHmm this makes me wonder what did our previous generation of computer people do that had all this evil blue light blasted into their brains? I feel like this is the new "wellness" science that sounds good in practice, but lacks evidenced based studies.
- lonesword 7y agoMy guesses: 1. The previous generation did not have laptops. 2. The previous generation did not nearly have as many programmer/hackers/<late-night-computer-user-moniker> as we have today 3. Because of #2, nobody cared if a really small percentage of the population lost sleep due to blue light?
- djmips 7y agoI feel you've forgotten phones. A majority of people have a phone that they can stick in their face in bed.
- Cougher 7y ago"Hmm this makes me wonder what did our previous generation of computer people do that had all this evil blue light blasted into their brains?" They created things like Google/SEO, affiliate linking, facebook, twitter, pop-up ads, malware . . .
- herf 7y agoMichael from f.lux: This research is from a very talented group of researchers, but it is unclear if it will translate from nocturnal mice to humans (as others have said). The evidence in humans is mixed, but it either shows no effect or a tendency in the other direction. There is a study in the same issue (Spitschan) that says there is no effect in humans. 1. First, the study does not question the contribution of melanopsin (the blue-cyan opsin that got everyone talking about "blue light") - it asks a more subtle question: when you hold melanopsin stimulation constant, what does the remaining light do and why? Here they are finding whether the cones oppose or boost melanopsin based on color signals. But regardless of how this works in humans, we should still expect bright-enough blue light at night to be stimulating, because of the response due to melanopsin. 2. Holding the melanopic portion of a light constant is not something we usually do. For most lights we have today, the "blue" lights would be considerably dimmer than the "yellow/red" ones if we did this. When we compare lights of equal visible brightness, the yellow ones are known to have less effect on human melatonin suppression [Chellappa 2011]. 3. The evidence in humans is mixed, but it actually goes the other direction (saying blue is more stimulating), or there is no clear effect. In the same issue, a study on humans by Spitschan found a negative result on whether or not S-cone contrast has an effect: https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(19)31501-5 https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(19)... 3b. Other research (in monochromatic and polychromatic light) finds that humans are more sensitive to blue light than melanopsin would suggest. See a list below. 4. We're all still trying to explain how the transition to dusk is blue/purple, while our own lighting doesn't do that. We have built our lighting to be relatively bright, but warm. It is not "natural" to extend the day like we do, but it likely would not help anything to make the lights more blue, unless they were quite a lot dimmer, or used very novel spectra. Here is a list of references for the evidence +/- blue sensitivity (not melanopsin) in humans: 1. The Thapan study from 2001 indicates extra blue-light sensitivity in addition to melanopsin. Lights are seen for a half hour at night. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7793.2001.t01-1-00261.x https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7793.2001.t01-1-00261.x 2. The Spitschan study from this same issue of Current Biology says there is no effect in either direction when comparing 83x S-cone contrast. The lights here are "pink" (which has a lot of blue) and "orange" which has very little. https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(19)31501-5 https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(19)... 3. The Brainard 2015 study compares 4000k to 17000k lights: at the same "melanopic" level the 17000k lights do a lot more melatonin suppression: https://jdc.jefferson.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1081&context=neurologyfp https://jdc.jefferson.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1081&c... 4. There is one important study in humans (Gooley 2010) that says we can be more sensitive to 555nm light after two days in dim light, so that mirrors this study. But this is not exactly comparable to the study cited here due to sensitization: it stands on its own due to the duration of the experiment. It would be interesting if we could find some "truth" to the idea that twilight colors affect human circadian entrainment - it has been a recurrent idea for many years. We finally have the technology to target melanopsin separately from the S-cone (see Spitschan's work for an example). For the press these results get, you'd be surprised that there has been extremely little research funding for most of these things in the last ten years. In a way, I hope that mixed results like these might help! How light affects us at lower levels, and how different we are from each other is not "solved" at all, so there is still a lot of work to do.
- Waterluvian 7y agoLots of good comments on the quality or compatibility of these results for humans. But I'll add: I don't care. Even the placebo effect of the night time mode on my screens has a calming effect and signals the day is winding down.
- Semaphor 7y agoI agree, blue light, close by (so my monitor more than the TV) does make me feel more awake. Could be placebo, could be trained behavior (as in red light makes my body think sleep), could be that this study is not transferable to humans. Or any combination of these :) I'll happily stay with f.lux :)
- zarkov99 7y agoAnecdotally, it is definitely highly disruptive to me. I have red light shifting in all my devices and I bout some blue light filtering glasses and that does make a difference in how quickly I fall asleep.
- princekolt 7y ago...in mice. But sure, let's drop this tiny snippet of information, after all it will drive clicks, am I right??
- 384028345 7y agoOFFTOPIC: Isn't blue light still best to be avoided as much as possible, as it damages cells in the eye, causing macula degeneration. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
- theothermkn 7y agohttps://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/will-blue-light-from-electronic-devices-increase-my-risk-of-macular-degeneration-and-blindness-2019040816365 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/will-blue-light-from-ele... This is widely debunked. The above is but one of many such counterpoints.
- n1vz3r 7y agoIt may be "not as disruptive" for sure, but since I began to use night light mode both on my phone and laptop, I began to fall asleep in 10-15 minutes after going to bed. Also I use warm light LEDs intstead of cold ones.
- pdimitar 7y agoAnecdata: The night modes of my displays (iMac, MacBook Pro, iPhone, iPad) definitely help me be a bit more relaxed compared to staring at them in their normal mode, especially during the nights. That being said, reduction of blue light does not help that much either. I found that a much stronger contributor to my staying awake is the light of the screen itself. I found that if I am in the mood to nap during the afternoon, the smaller difference between the my phone's display light and the ambient light helps me fall asleep much, much quicker compared to when I am staring at my phone with all lights turned off. The difference is much more pronounced and obstructs my brain's desire to doze off. So IMO the reduced blue light has an effect. But it might not be that big indeed.
- theatraine 7y agoTangentially related: I've been experimenting with very bright lights from when I wake up to sunset. In my bedroom/home office I have a couple 6000k LED lights at 8100 lumens making the room almost as bright as noon outdoors. Post-sunset I use dim red lights. I was inspired by SAD lights but didn't like any of the ones I tried so went with high-powered "corn" LED lights in normal fixtures. I've noticed that I tend to get sleepier at night which is great as before I would have to force myself to go to sleep (I'm a natural night person.) I've also noticed a small increase in my distance visual acuity (subjectively measured by me using an eye chart so not the most accurate.) I have read that intense outdoor light protects against myopia (see https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK470669/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK470669/) so I suspect this is related.
- sharedfrog 7y agoDid you see this link, posted here a month ago? Opens a whole new world where 30,000 lumens per room is a reasonable option. https://www.benkuhn.net/lux https://www.benkuhn.net/lux
- scotty79 7y agoI made a lamp that does 25k lumens (and about 20k lux at 1 meter) but when I use it to light my room from the ceiling the light is bright enough to be unpleasent. Like going out during sunny day. I'll experiment with spreading lights a bit more.
- theatraine 7y agoI didn't see this, thanks for posting it! My thought process was really similar to the author's actually and I've been happy with the results so far. I've distributed the lights around my room with shades to mitigate the unpleasantness factor as opposed to going with the "megabulb".
- jiggawatts 7y agoI wonder why there's only engineering and so little science in the design of modern dwellings! A lot of our constraints, such as maximum illumination lux have gone away thanks to new technology, but the "wellness science" hasn't been applied. It's not even an established scientific discipline, which is why I'm struggling to come up with a name for it. I haven't heard of any large construction company or architect firm focusing on human-centric attributes such as: * Minimising the levels of O3, CO2 and CO * Fine particulate filtering * Daylight-equivalent illumination * Red-shifting illumation to simulate dusk * Noise insulation such as double-glazed glass or weighted foam partitioning walls * Etc... In principle, living and working indoors could be much better for us, but nobody seems to be spending real effort in achieving this. Instead, everyone is dead set on optimising for square-footage or workers-per-floor, completely disregarding basic humans needs. For example, the office of a large government agency where I'm contracting has atrocious air-conditioning in their main city office building. The temperatures are over 26C (79F) most of the time, and I get blinding headaches from the CO2 buildup after a day of bad ventilation. After about 2pm I'm basically a zombie and can't concentrate. Noone has bothered to do anything about this for literally years. (This is not my imagination: Their own staff work in air quality monitoring, so for laughs they used one of their probes in the middle of our floor and it basically read "off scale high" on nearly every metric.) Meanwhile, another building around the corner has floor-to-ceiling glass windows letting in a lot of light and nice cool refreshing air-conditioning. There, I can work until 6:30pm regularly without feeling run down.
- rationalfaith 7y agoAnecdotal experience and of many others, go against this "experts". As all things, it's a spectrum but the press has to be sensationalist about it.
- moron4hire 7y agoAs a society, we like to focus on presumed "easy" fixes. It's not the sedentary lifestyle, chronic sleep deprivation, and massive amounts of caffeine we drink that disrupts our sleep, no, it's the color of light. Never mind that the effect is apparently so small that science has yet to prove conclusively that it even exists, this is the thing that is killing everyone.
- xchip 7y agoTL;DR: “Our findings suggest that using dim, cooler, lights in the evening and bright warmer lights in the day may be more beneficial.“
- davidmurdoch 7y agoI reliably get restless leg syndrome when there is a blue LED left on in an adjacent room with its light leaking in to my bedroom. Other triggers: too much caffeine late in the day and dehydration. The yellow LEDs in the room don't bother me when I forget to turn the device off. And the red clock projected onto my ceiling doesn't bother me either. I used to sleep fine with blue LEDs though, so maybe it's just different for different people, ages, environments, and/or other factors.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bookAlot 7y agoThe discussion in blue light is about a light that has radioactivity, the bluer one is usually gained from gamma. What then this may mean is that blue light, the color blue, in gamma, may not be as destructive as we have been led to believe, to sleep patterns. You WILL feel rested to enjoy the morning stretch. But what is wrong in it is that blue light is a color that dyes up into the eyeball and then we have less of the actual light to use in our thought process, so we may just be using blue there as we would use something else in the process of breathing. We may be making it difficult to realize a thing in the dark instead of messing with our rest, as the language of our bodies is not to ignore, it is to discuss. We may be missing some amount of that same metaphor's existing incidence in the detailing of what might be happening during a blue light. And metaphors are indeed and in fact all we are allowed to use in science. We can render a detail of a result in English only AFTER. To be discussed to, not to affirm. That is in the purchase.
- vlunkr 7y agoHowever the science turns out, I still recommend flux/redshift just for the reduced eye strain. I don't even bother with scheduling it to shift throughout the day, since I've never noticed any impact on my sleep.
- tingletech 7y agoMy eye doctor told me to use a blue cutting program all day long (not just at night) to save my eyesight
- bluegreyred 7y agoMy eye doctor told me that it's all made up by the optometric industry and there's no meaningful evidence. (I still use night mode and calibrate my screens for low temperatures because even if it is just a placebo, it works for my comfort)
- Albertchrist 7y agobut this photo pigment is sensitive to the blue light then who we can say it will not have any effect on sleep cycle.Because same kind researches state that blue light has effect on sleep patterns.
- aszantu 7y agoDo mice eben see blue? They only see greyscale, or am I wrong?
- squarefoot 7y agoIt may not be disruptive to our sleep patterns, but surely I find extremely annoying if abused like it is today. At over 50 I have no sleeping problem, at least not more than I had before the digital age; blue light just make me nervous, and I recall hating blue leds thrown in every appliances just because they're dirt cheap long before people started talking about any potential harm.