8 ms·
Homelessness rises in U.S., driven by California housing crisis
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mberning 7y ago"The bottom line: Per the Washington Post, California's homeless issue is related to soaring housing costs, mental health and substance abuse issues and "legal hurdles to getting people off the streets — all issues that could complicate federal officials’ ideas to stage an intervention." It would seem that in many cases mental health and substance abuse problems are a more significant factor. People of sound mind typically do not find themselves out on the streets long term because their rent went up.
- KirinDave 7y agoI'm not sure that's clear from the data, but even if it is true the problems remain related. Families cannot afford to house relatives who might not be able to support themselves. Ignoring that, many folks of sound mind and body are homeless. They live in cars and borrowed spaces, and suffer greatly for it. All because Californians refuse to build adequate housing.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoThere's a certain amount of self reinforcement in this. Once a person become homeless, it taxes them psychologically, leading to further issues with mental health and substance abuse. There are success stories of the chronic homeless being able to overcome their situation but for the most part the earlier an intervention happens, the greater the chance of success. The truly difficult part in all of this is that we are an individualistic nation that puts high value on freedom, including the freedom to enter into a downward spiral of self destruction. Freedom of movement also complicates things as those jurisdictions that offer the most (productive or not) are often swamped by those who became homeless elsewhere. We hear a lot about cities dumping their homeless on each other but Megabus can be as cheap as $1.50. The freedom of movement and the low cost of it does more to move the homeless around than any "clean the streets" initiative a city engages in. Homelessness will never be solved at the local level. Though local services can help address the symptoms of homelessness, no local entity has the power to address the root causes nationally.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoExcept, how long will they remain of sound mind and without substance abuse once they're out on the street? It's not destiny, of course, but it'd be naive to assume that becoming homeless won't change the odds of someone developing a mental illness, or a drug habit to attempt to cope.
- chaostheory 7y agoBased on past data, our current homelessness programs are working for people without mental or drug abuse issues. 80% of the homeless tend to recover within several months, while only about 20% are chronically homeless. IMO the current homeless problem stems from the shutdown of old mental institutions by the Kennedy’s. There were good reasons for their crusade, such as problems with abuse and neglect. The issue is that no solution or alternative was given for shutting down the asylums which leads us to our current predicament
- diogenescynic 7y agoAnyone think it’s not just the cost of housing driving this but largely driven by meth and heroin and mental illness? The visibly homeless people I see on the sides of the road in tents in California aren’t just becoming homeless due to a rent increase—-their drug addiction and lack of treatment for mental illness are the bigger issues. Lack of universal healthcare means if you’re poor and mentally ill, you can easily end up on the street if you don’t have family to care for you. Since Prop 47 passed, heroin and meth are basically decriminalized and openly used on the streets in front of police. Likewise, Prop 57 decriminalized theft up to $950/day so now we have an epidemic of car break ins and theft from stores and no real police response. So I think the people we see on the streets would have been in prison before prop 47 and 57 passed. We definitely need more public housing and to build more houses, but I truly think meth and heroin are the elephant in the room that we aren’t addressing. We just keep giving out needles and don’t even arrest the dealers. It’s insanity.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m torn about this. While nothing good ever came out of drug abuse, even less good comes out of giving the government more power and the “War on Drugs”. I’m okay with decriminalizing drug use but not property crime.
- epistasis 7y agoIt's a mistake to conflate the highly visible homeless with unhoused people in general. For every highly visible homeless person there are probably a dozen that try to keep out of sight. And I would also point out that it's far far easier to fall into drug addiction, and for mental health issues to take over, when somebody doesn't have housing or their basic needs met. When you lose your apartment because you can't pay rent and an unexpected expense has tapped all your money, you look to all the resources you can to survive. Maybe you start couch surfing, but eventually you exhaust all your friends. Then when you're on the street, and it's clear that you're unsafe, maybe you look to new groups to hell get by. In that setting, starting down the pa Th if heroin is far easier than when you're working long hours and struggling to make rent. The path from working a job to ending up in a tent in a visible area doesn't happen overnight. It's a long path. And there's a huge amount of flus of people I to and out of homelessness. The counts they do are a point in time, and don't count the much larger number of people that become homeless then figure out how to get out or get assistance.
- seriesf 7y agoThis is a problem of supply. “An unprecedented $1 billion” will buy you at most three thousand new dwellings, probably fewer given high cost and inefficiency of housing construction in California. California has been under-building housing for decades, to the extent that people will call this current activity a housing “boom” even though it’s only slightly above historic lows.
- KirinDave 7y ago> inefficiency of housing construction in California. California housing isn't "inefficient." The housing codes are made with the idea of keeping houses up through natural disasters and serviceable for a long time. We might modify that last provision (as Tokyo does, for example) but it comes with it's own problems. The idea that somehow housing regulation increasing costs is the core or even a major contributor to the problem is one that requires substantial evidence. Unless you're referring to "Californian contractors are overpaid," which seems more like a reflection of the expensive cost of living here than "inefficiency."
- seriesf 7y agoWell you are very wrong there. The inefficiency is in the permit process. In San Francisco it takes years to get your project approved, and that time is money. Many projects also just don’t get approved, and the carrying costs and fees of those failures don’t even get added to the average cost per dwelling that eventually gets reported. In many jurisdictions permitting and planning consume a full third of the cost and take years.
- KirinDave 7y ago> Well you are very wrong there. The inefficiency is in the permit process. In San Francisco it takes years to get your project approved, and that time is money. There is no denying that California refuses to build housing. This does raise the cost of Californian housing. However, this is characterized distinctly from efficiency of the housing regulations and building codes in most conversations specifically to avoid the dodge many developers present, "Housing codes are too strict, it's inefficient to build homes in California." If I ended up misreading your post as a result of context, I apologize for doing so. I did not mean to put words into your mouth. But please consider that many other people may read this and read the same intent because of specific phrasing you're using.
- scurvy 7y agoThis article is rather thin on facts connecting the rise of California real estate to homelessness. There's a passing mention of a WaPo article that mostly lists addiction and legal hurdles as the reason for homelessness. How did this reach the top posting while being...so thin?
- ailideex 7y ago> How did this reach the top posting while being...so thin? people upvoted it.
- scurvy 7y agoWithout actually reading anything more than the headline Edit: Sans real data, this article just fuels anecdata based political pissing matches. This article is flotsam.
- chrisseaton 7y agoNewspaper and magazine articles like this never have the kind of statistical analysis and tests that you're asking for. It'd be nice, but it's not a realistic expectation.
- KirinDave 7y agoThis is clearly not a flag-able story, so perhaps shrugging and moving on about your day is the best call. I see things here all the time that I think are light on details or outright lies (usually thinly veiled cryptocurrency ad copy). There are many readers of HN these days and you just gotta accept that and move on.
- xwdv 7y agoPeople don’t need to read the article to upvote what they already know. This morning I stood on the balcony of my San Francisco apartment on a very high floor, but not high enough where I could not see and hear the homeless people croak. Someone has to do something.
- ilaksh 7y agoI suspect that housing is available, just too expensive.
- seriesf 7y agoWhy? Vacancy rates are near all-time lows in California’s major cities. Most cities are around 2-4% vacancy whereas you need about 10% vacancy to operate a healthy market.
- Vaslo 7y agoIf that were the case, shouldn’t supply/demand fix it? That is, available housing would get cheaper if not being utilized, right?
- anoxor 7y agoUnless rent control happens and only a tiny fraction of the apartments are at market rate. If that's the case the messed up portion of the market will just keep exploding.
- takeda 7y agoWho said that those units aren't used? It's just that they cost is so high, that bigger and bigger portion of the population can't afford it anymore. It doesn't help that foreign investors also purchase the property and either don't rent it (afraid it will reduce its value) or use it for AirB&B. That causes the supply to go even lower and prices go higher.
- KirinDave 7y agoHousing is too expensive because not enough is available.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoThat's essentially the same thing. Not enough housing supply will have the predictable effect of increased rents that will price some out of the market.
- boyadjian 7y ago
- ravenstine 7y ago[redacted because what I wrote was stupid]
- KirinDave 7y agoYou're getting a terribly skewed sample if you're only informing yourself based off homeless people who are visible on the street, in front of you.
- ravenstine 7y agoSure, there are also homeless people who live in cars and vans, motels, shelters. More than most realize. There's families, veterans, etc. But they don't make up the majority of people experiencing chronic homelessness.
- SerLava 7y ago>But there's a large segment of homeless people who choose to be homeless or So people sitting in $900,000 homes are saying you know what? I'm gonna live in a tent under a bridge. Is that what they are doing
- i_am_nomad 7y agoThese articles keep claiming that high rents, mental illness and substance abuse are the causes of the homelessness surge. But rarely, if ever, are any statistics cited. The HUD report referenced by the article does not discuss causes either. I can tell you from my experience working in homeless encampments in Oakland that most of the people living there are neither mentally ill, nor abusing drugs. Most of them are people who would ordinarily work on the very bottom rung of the employment ladder, in jobs that 20 years ago would be a good fit for someone undermotivated, or quirky, or otherwise unfit for a more “responsible” job. But there’s no place for them anymore; automation has replaced some of those jobs, and a combination of plunging wages and a more ruthless Amazon-style workplace has made many of the jobs that are left intolerable. People are choosing a tent in the park in Oakland over working three part-time jobs and being micromanaged by an AI just to barely afford 1/7th of an apartment. And, we have imported tens of millions of unskilled, mostly unauthorized immigrants who are happy to take those jobs - another thing you won’t hear discussed in these articles.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> And, we have imported tens of millions of unskilled, mostly unauthorized immigrants who are happy to take those jobs - another thing you won’t hear discussed in these articles. I'm not sure that's relevant. Based on your anecdote, the people in question in tent camps wouldn't be taking the jobs regardless of the immigration situation.
- i_am_nomad 7y agoI'm saying that because we have so much unskilled labor supply in the country, businesses can make those jobs horrible if it improves their bottom line - that's just the nature of supply and demand.
- irrational 7y ago>And, we have imported tens of millions of unskilled, mostly unauthorized immigrants who are happy to take those jobs - another thing you won’t hear discussed in these articles. It sounds like Survival of the Fittest. Only we aren't as willing to let our fellow humans just die from not being fit enough like our ancestors would have.
- jph 7y agoHomelessness in California is one of the volunteer topics at Hack For LA (https://hackforla.org https://hackforla.org) and Code For America (https://www.codeforamerica.org https://www.codeforamerica.org). The purpose of the code is to assist social services case managers, who match people at risk with potential resources such as shared housing placements. If you're interested in volunteering, feel free to message me. If you're interested in donating, see https://donorbox.org/hackforla https://donorbox.org/hackforla
- i_am_nomad 7y agoWe have to treat the causes of homelessness. And I don’t think the cause is “not enough software.”
- tempsy 7y agoStrange when I see HN diverge from “tech twitter” in this situation. Why are so many on here skeptical of the legitimacy of the housing crisis in California? Maybe it’s that this website draws a broader audience, but it’s a fairly accepted fact among people that live in CA, including myself, that it is indeed a crisis. And no, not everyone who is homeless is a meth head.
- baby 7y agoI suspect a lot of people here own housing in the bay and are trying to spread FUD and blame current issues on mental health.
- friedman23 7y agoEveryone is only willing to believe the facts that support their own interest. California home owners will deny housing is the cause of homelessness similar to how Texas oil barons will deny climate change even exists.
- hellisothers 7y agoThis is a poor comparison because nobody is claiming homeless doesn’t exist. If you had said “as oil barons will claim oil isn’t the cause of the climate crisis” that would be better. It’s also better because like fossil fuel burning literally damages the environment, lack of affordable homes in an area is literally the cause of homelessness. But that is a useless point, of course more homes would fix the issue but to what end, are you going to build enough homes so everybody who wants to live in the Bay Area can? Obviously not, so there will still be homelessness. “Just build more houses!” Not being an actual answer is the point
- friedman23 7y ago> are you going to build enough homes so everybody who wants to live in the Bay Area can? Obviously not, so there will still be homelessness. “Just build more houses!” Not being an actual answer is the point This is a strawman argument. There will always be homelessness because there will always be people that prefer to be homeless. Building more homes will reduce a significant amount of homelessness that exists due to structural reasons.
- boyadjian 7y agoThis is not a housing crisis, there is enough houses built in California. This is an overpopulation crisis : Simply too many people searching for a house. Don't take the problem the reverse way.
- bbddg 7y agoIf there are enough houses how is it "overpopulation". It's clearly a failing of the housing market. It's not able to efficiently allocate houses to people that need them, it's designed to allocate houses only to people who can maximize profit for land owners.
- anoxor 7y agoRent control means there isn't a true housing market when only a tiny fraction of apartments are at market rate.
- baby 7y agoI live in SF and there is def. a lack of housing.
- someguydave 7y agoWho gets to decide how many people is too many?
- ravenstine 7y agoWho decides how much water can fit in a glass?
- defterGoose 7y agoWell that's a terrible analogy.
- ravenstine 7y agoCan you be a little more constructive than that? If you think it's terrible, maybe you can explain why you think it's terrible?
- genzoman 7y agoIMO at least some of the problem is the historical laxness with which California has approached drugs. You have decades and decades of drug use being de facto legal to the point where now you will not be arrested for shooting heroin in front of a police officer. You could tax all the billionaires out of the state and they still not afford the rehab expense for all of the addicts in California. How many chances do you get at success? Why not just start taking heroin so you get a free stay indoors, with free food at a rehab resort?
- adamsea 7y agoNo disrespect but that’s pretty far removed from pretty much any set of facts you can dredge up. And “rehab resort” is the biggest pile of BS I’ve read in a while.
- trophycase 7y agoWhy not do it then? And write a blog post and tell us all about how it goes.
- trimmedarticle 7y agoNo JavaScript - reduces page load by 99% from original size of 4.14 MB to 24.3 kB: https://beta.trimread.com/articles/1170 https://beta.trimread.com/articles/1170
- sysbin 7y agoThe United States is barbaric when it comes to social support systems. I used to live in the States and I'm happy to now be in Canada for moral reasons. I can only speculate from my experience (when I went through hard times as a student working on my CS degree with unsupportive family "me being lgbt and they being religious conservatives") and trying to navigate what was available in my area while living in the USA. I've come to the conclusion that religious ideology is to blame, as similar to rising cost of homes & tuition, and not enough jobs for everyone (when you consider most people have low skillsets); while considering not everyone can become a programmer or whatever in-demand profession because most people just don't have what it takes with age making it increasingly difficult to get into a skilled field with health factoring into the equation. I think homelessness is rarely the outcome of drug abuse. People aren't going to drugs in a great life for no particular reason. In any case deciding to do drugs with life then spiralling downhill to where they're homeless is just ridiculous to assume is the cause. The idea that people do it to themselves is nonsensical. We're living in a harder time than the 90s, 80s, 70s, for the less privileged and the system needs to be revamped to get people into homes that don't cost them anything if they cannot pay for it.
- doublement 7y agoI agree with much of what you said but the religious ideology attribution is a non-sequitur. The Bay Area and Los Angeles are pretty much the opposite of hotbeds for piety, yet they have the most severe homelessness problems.
- sysbin 7y agoI'm not from California but a lot of homeless people navigate to California from elsewhere. Homelessness is on the rise in general. Religious ideology creates thinking patterns of the blame is on the victim and not from the system they reside in being unfavourable with the person's genetics & environmental upbringing.
- petethepig 7y ago> a lot of homeless people navigate to California from elsewhere That’s a common misconception. According to this study [0] 70% of people who were homeless in SF in 2019 lived in the city before they became homeless. [0] http://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/FINAL-PIT-Report-2019-San-Francisco.pdf http://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/FINAL-PIT-Report-201...
- sundeepprikar 7y agoIt’s ok, the other guy said We’ve just had the best decade in human history
- kelp 7y agoThis is one of the rare cases where I agree with the Trump administration. California does deserve all this criticism for years of policies that over-regulated housing, leading to a severe shortage. And the California solution continues to be stricter tenant protections and more housing subsidies. But the subsidies are nowhere near enough. This article suggests it would cost $12B for the Bay Area alone. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/10/cost-to-end-san-francisco-bay-area-homelessness-would-be-12point7-billion-report.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/10/cost-to-end-san-francisco-ba... And when polled, 57% of Californians continue to blame the wrong causes: https://extras.mercurynews.com/blame/ https://extras.mercurynews.com/blame/ Blaming developers, rather than the local governments that restrict supply. I’ve been following these issues closely for years, and have been active in advocacy around them. I’m now convinced it won’t get substantially better without federal involvement.
- Trias11 7y agoAnyone mentions liberal policies wasting millions of dollar of taxpayers money and not bringing any solutions? Let's downvotes begin...
- dang 7y agoPlease don't use HN for ideological battle. It's tedious and not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jokesnotfunny 7y agoWe need to ask if homlessness is really that bad? These people can surely move to some cheaper locations but they choose not to. That means assumed opportunity cost is bigger for them if they make a move to cheaper location. If you go 4 months homless and the manage to find some benevolent company owner, who hired you and you get paid good salary, then you end up staying in same well off area with added benefit that now you aren't homless anymore.
- paul7986 7y agoAre some of the reasons its increasing there is because its always warm and it offers the most money/help to the homeless? A good amount there want to offer a universal basic income of what 1k to every person. I guess you can live off of 1k a month in CA?