29 ms·
That doesn't make any sense. The market is the most efficient capital allocator because shareholders are the market, not companies. Companies are giving their
by crazygringo 7y ago
That doesn't make any sense. The market is the most efficient capital allocator because shareholders are the market, not companies.
Companies are giving their cash back to shareholders because each individual company thinks their shareholders can better allocate the cash, rather than the companies themselves. This is equally true for both buybacks and dividends.
This is because most companies have no wish to operate like broad VC firms or investment firms. While plenty of shareholders do.
The government has all the infinite "dibs" it wants, they're called taxes. If the government wants to tax buybacks further it doesn't need any particular logic of "dibs" to do so. And right now buybacks are taxed in exactly the same way as capital gains, which is the same way qualified dividends are taxed too. And corporate profits are already taxed too.
- tw04 7y agoThe point is both the companies in question and the ultra-wealthy that are the beneficiaries of the vast majority of these buybacks AREN'T paying taxes, so it's another way for the government to at least attempt to capture the $$ that should already be going into the treasury instead of offshore accounts/subsidiaries/whatever double dutch triple lux tax evasion scheme of the month they're using.
- mrep 7y agoHow are they not paying taxes? The people selling their stock to the company in the buyback have to pay taxes on any gains and the people holding onto the stock long term will eventually have to pay taxes on any gains when they finally do sell (they're not going to hold onto a stock until the heat death of the universe so they are going to realize their gains and pay taxes on them at some point).
- jf22 7y agoI believe your comment is referencing normal people paying taxes, where the comment you are replying too is referencing the ultra-wealthy and corporations paying taxes. The ultra-wealthy and big corporations take advantage of schemes to lower their taxes.
- tw04 7y agoIf you have enough money, there are limitless ways to avoid paying taxes that range from illegal to legal but extremely questionable. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers
- pwinnski 7y agoThat's a great question with a complicated answer. Here's a start: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/12/rich-people-are-getting-away-not-paying-their-taxes/577798/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/12/rich-pe...
- xt00 7y agoThe companies are in many cases doing things like this: 1) their revenue they classify is centered in a different country like Ireland 2) they setup a massive line of credit with an international bank 3) they take out massive loans against the money they have “overseas” that is not taxed 4) they then pay the buybacks and other things to their investors with that loaned money in US 5) they then pay back the bank at their international site 6) the bank then borrows more money from federal reserve at nearly zero interest rate Rinse and repeat.. tons of companies have done this. So sure some investors will eventually cash out but companies should also be taxed if they derive some benefit from the country they are from or selling products. I would argue those taxes should be low but allowing companies to totally dodge them seems like a bad setup long term.
- ivalm 7y agoSure, when a company BUYS stock someone SELLS it to then. The selling party incurs capital gains and pays taxes on it.
- refurb 7y agoOK, but that has nothing to do with whether or not the people selling their stock back pay taxes on it.
- xt00 7y agoWouldn't it be hilarious if the bank prior to the buyback bought a bunch of the stock (I don't know if this is true, but seems plausible). Then in that case the company would literally be taking out a loan from the bank in order to buy the stock from the bank. So then the question is if its possible for the bank to claim some sort of thing where when they sell the stock to the actual company that it is some special type of transaction and maybe gets favorable tax treatment? Wow I want to look into that.. sounds interesting / shady if thats possible to do..
- bsanr2 7y agoWhat I don't understand about this is... Why can't I partake? If my employer is based out of these havens for tax purposes, why can't they pay "me" by paying into the bank account of the foreign on-paper-only company I own, whose line of credit with a foreign bank I then use for my own expenses? I feel like this must be against the law somehow, but I don't quite understand where the line is.
- CuriouslyC 7y agoYou can borrow against the stock, and defer gains basically forever as long as it appreciates more quickly than the interest rate of your loan.
- vasco 7y agoThe beneficiaries of these buybacks are the general public, these are public companies. They are your pension funds, your rainy day funds, they are government healthcare programs, Norway's Oil fund... They are everyone. The reason they aren't paying taxes on buybacks is because they haven't actually made any money until someone sells stock.
- crazygringo 7y agoThe largest beneficiary of buybacks isn't the ultra-wealthy. It's retirees. It's grandma: "Of the $22.8 trillion in stock outstanding... retirement accounts owned roughly 37%, the most of any type of holder." [1] [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/who-actually-owns-the-stock-market-2016-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/who-actually-owns-the-stock-...
- cpwright 7y agoRetirees are also going to be selling down their portfolio as they age for living expenses. The ultra-wealthy are probably not systemically selling out of the equity market.
- take_a_breath 7y agoYour data does not say what you are claiming it says. It is possible (or even probable) for the ultra-wealthy to have retirement accounts. Once we admit that, then the obvious question becomes: Who do you think owns most of the money in those retirement accounts, the rich or the poor?
- crazygringo 7y agoBy definition not the rich, since retirement accounts are capped by law to relatively low yearly contributions. Sure the ultra-wealthy can have their retirement accounts too (if they even bother), but they can't be any larger than anyone else's. Just a tiny tiny tiny sliver for them, really.
- take_a_breath 7y agoUnless there might be loopholes in those annual caps that the wealthy use to their tax advantage. Found one: ==The GAO report shows that the top 1% have saved $1 trillion in their IRAs, 22% of the total.== https://www.marketwatch.com/story/how-to-shelter-hundreds-of-millions-in-an-ira-account-2014-09-19 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/how-to-shelter-hundreds-of...
- hippich 7y ago
- rayiner 7y agoCorporations are paying taxes. US corporate tax receipts as a percentage of GDP are a tick higher than the OECD average. Also, it’s not the “ultra wealthy” primarily benefitting from these buybacks. Most corporate equity is owned by the bottom 99% and pension funds.[1] (Someone with a $5 million retirement account may be very comfortable, but they’re not hiding their money in offshore accounts.) [1] Most corporate equities are held by retirement plans or foreigners. Just 25% are held in taxable account. Of those, the bulk is owned by people outside the top 0.1%.
- bsanr2 7y agoWhat's the rate of pension funds that have actually paid out their initial promise? How many have ceased to exist?
- jeiei0ndjd 7y agoThat’s the problem though. Equity is an entirely imaginary value store. What’s the point of the majority holding all the corporate equity when it goes poof constantly? 80% of last generations Fortune 500s are gone. Retirees and the public were left holding the bag. Meanwhile, the aristocracy retains generational control of all real assets. This is another emotional boondoggle, wrapped in numbers to provide some sort of concretized framework. It’s the same old scam: Load the public up on ownership/stewardship of ephemeral nonsense (previously religion) insulate the most pious/rich. The bottom will fall out on the value of the equity, they can buy up more of the real property cheap. Rinse. Repeat.
- JackFr 7y agoNonsense from a throwaway account. Sign your name if you really feel that way.
- mpalczewski 7y ago>> Equity is an entirely imaginary value store. So is money. >> 80% of last generations Fortune 500s are gone. Good it's called capitalism. We need creative destruction to move forward. >> Retirees and the public were left holding the bag. This! Largely because the finance industry(or perhaps the world) is run by sales people. Don't be a sucker, if you don't understand your financial assets in detail(e.g. if you are buying an index fund, understand why, not just based on past performance, go deep, what's the weighting?(currently float weighted which makes it easiest to sell to you, but the worst possible weighting makes it buy high and sell low). Fuck that's a shit fuck ton of work for just a surface level analysis. But you should do much more research into your mutual funds/stocks than you do your next car purchase. So yeah, it's not that they were left holding the bag, it's that they were sold free money that turned out to be not so free. Imagine that.
- JackFr 7y ago> the ultra-wealthy that are the beneficiaries of the vast majority of these buybacks The S&P 500 is > 80% owned by institutions. That is mutual funds, pension funds and insurance companies. The main beneficiaries arent fat cats, but rather anyone with a 401k.
- streb-lo 7y agoAre you claiming that a mutual funds' performance evenly benefits anyone with a 401k? In the last 40 years 0.00025% of Americans have tripled their share of the wealth. Of course everyone with a 401k has benefited but they are nowhere close to the main beneficiaries of capital gains.
- JackFr 7y agoNo. The share of wealth of the top 0.00025% has tripled. The pool of people people in that quantile is dynamic. In 1980, that was about 600 people. In 1980 the richest person in the United States was J. Paul Getty. I imagine most of those people are no longer alive. In 1980, Jeff Bezos was 15, Bill Gates was 24, Larry and Sergey were 6, and Sergey had been living in the United States for 1 year. It's likely that the effect you're seeing is an artifact of the role technology plays in the economy rather than exploitation or rent seeking.
- s_r_n 7y agoTo add to this, the ultra-wealthy, university funds, funds-of-funds, etc. are interested in capital preservation, according to the article. This means they likely will not reinvest their profits into companies that will grow; they're more likely to reinvest into other companies that will do buybacks.
- jonathankoren 7y ago> Companies are giving their cash back to shareholders because each individual company thinks their shareholders can better allocate the cash, rather than the companies themselves. This is very strange explaination. As stated it sounds like stock buybacks are some sort of altruistic endeavor resulting from some kind of collective shrug. This couldn’t be further from truth. Buybacks are the result of executive incentives to hit a certain stock valuation. You can either do this the intended way by growing the company’s value by making competing in the marketplace, or you can do it the lazy underhanded way by manipulating the stock market by creating an artificial scarcity. You don’t get chalk this up to a faceless emergent phenomena when there are a very short list of people on FTC documents who made the decision at each and every one of the these companies.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>This couldn’t be further from truth. Buybacks are the result of executive incentives to hit a certain stock valuation. Why do you ignore the people who choose to sell their shares to the company? Stock buybacks move cash from the company's coffers into the hands of selling shareholders, period. Whether it's good or bad to do so at any specific time is certainly debatable, but the idea that it "manipulates" the share price is wrong, both in theory and practice.
- r_luna 7y agoAs a shareholder I want my money to be managed in a way that maximizes my investment. When executives incentives are paid by the value of the stock at a particular frozen moment in time, I get cheated. I get cheated because a buy back at the moment that the CEO and the board grade themselves is not in best long term interest of my wealth. I don't have time to be buying a selling stock everyday, they're fucking me by playing games. Money should be spent on research and development. That way GM and IBM dont become kodak, Walmart doesnt become Sears, and the great GE doesn't become...well GE is already there. Established american companies will grow from buy backs and mergers until they get disrupted because they didn't invest.
- jonathankoren 7y ago
- aczerepinski 7y agoBuying back stock only creates value for shareholders if the stock is trading for less than its intrinsic value. Above that price buybacks destroy shareholder value. Executives are doing this to meet performance targets and get bonuses. Not to allocate capital efficiently.
- jcfrei 7y agoI don't think I can follow your argument. What's intrinsic value? The market is supposed to arrive at a fair value for a stock (and there's no reason to assume it doesn't because that would create arbitrage opportunities). If you buyback at the fair value no shareholder value is created or destroyed, the only change is in the ownership of the assets and future dividends.
- voxic11 7y agoDon't stock buybacks basically transfer wealth from the company to the shareholders? The major advantage this has over other means of transferring wealth is that shareholders get to realize their gains with only capital gains tax applied, rather then the much higher dividend tax rate.
- JackFr 7y ago> Don't stock buybacks basically transfer wealth from the company to the shareholders? That is to say from the shareholders to themselves.
- csomar 7y agoPlus they might chose not to get taxed by holding the stock.
- jdsully 7y agoNo the shareholders own the company so they “own” the cash either way. Buybacks and dividends return control of the cash back to shareholders so they can allocate it elsewhere.
- code_sloth 7y ago> Companies are giving their cash back to shareholders because each individual company thinks their shareholders can better allocate the cash, rather than the companies themselves. _This_ doesn't make any sense. Companies don't think. They're legal entities that are controlled by a small group of people. This group of people can decide that they would prefer to do share buybacks to meet their own performance targets.
- derefr 7y agoFive facts, and one generally-held assumption: Fact 1. Companies’ brains (for this level of executive decision-making) are their boards of directors. Fact 2. Boards of directors are made up of people elected by shareholders. Fact 3. “Making the shareholders money” (either through dividends or equity) is the most obvious “platform” on which to get elected to this position; and “not making the shareholders money” is usually a quick way to get replaced. Fact 4. Unlike government elections in America—but like elections in Commonwealth nations—corporate “snap elections” can be triggered at any time from a shareholder vote. This means that a board-member can be removed pretty much instantly if they start to look like they’re not serving the shareholders’ interests. Fact 5. Members of the board usually want to stay on the board, because it confers advantages. Even if there are no explicit advantages to being on the board, they get the ability to vote in ways that work toward their own personal interests, perhaps even getting themselves sweetheart deals. Even if they don’t go for these, there might be “lobbyists” (internal to the company, from industry-organizational bodies, etc.) that are willing to bribe them to vote certain ways. And now, the assumption, that tends to hold in cases of publicly-traded companies: shareholders in the company are, by majority, pure investors that want their share value to increase, with some making short-term plays and others going long, but neither all that interested in the company outside of its portfolio value. Putting the facts and the assumption together, you can derive that the board is structured in such a way, and members of the board are incentivized in such a way, that their behaviour is extremely predictable, operating almost according to an algorithm, rather than acting like a “group of people” with human whims. This emergent behavior of the group, and the clear algorithmic model that can be used to predict it, are what people mean when they talk about “what corporations want.” It’s very similar to how a person can want things that are at odds with the “wants” of the cells that compose them (such as doing things like drinking that damage those cells, despite each cell embodying an algorithm that steers toward that cell’s own survival.)
- cryptica 7y agoShareholders and companies are equally inefficient at allocating capital. If not for buybacks, the company would probably have wasted the money on creating more useless jobs which would add no value to the company. Instead, the company prefers to give the money back to shareholders in the form of capital appreciation so that they will either hold it or sell some of it and use the proceeds to buy shares of another equally wasteful corporation. Eventually these corporate stock buybacks will lead to grotesque wealth inequality and if we're lucky, complete collapse of the international fiat monetary system which facilitates such atrocities.
- solatic 7y agoIf the purpose of equity buyback is to more efficiently allocate capital, then individual companies executing equity buyback are doing so because can no longer make efficient use of capital by using it to fuel additional growth and higher returns. If that's the case, then equity buyback is tantamount to admitting that the company has no future potential for growth. As a company's stock price reflects expected value from future growth, a buyback should therefore trigger a drop in the stock price. But it usually doesn't, usually buybacks trigger increases in the stock price as fewer shares remain in circulation in the public market and the company improves executive flexibility by consolidating control, and as investors expect to be paid a premium over market price through the buyback program. Why? Because private players don't care about macro performance metrics. Buybacks have nothing to do with what may or may not be the best allocation of capital in the market.
- bluecalm 7y agoThe stock price doesn't reflect growth at least not directly. The price reflects expectation of future earnings. If the company is never going to grow but makes stable 1M per year in profit then that company is worth something. Let's say it's worth around 16M as that's around the break even point at which people prefer to have cash over company stock. If now that company uses 1M in yearly profit to buy back shares it's still worth 16M but every individual outstanding share is worth more as it now represents bigger part of the same pie. Therefore after the buyback the share price should increase. We can also say by exactly how much (barring any other new information). This is finance 101 really. Buybacks are just more tax efficient because they are not taxed at the time of the buyback but at the time the stock holders sell.
- tboyd47 7y ago> Companies are giving their cash back to shareholders because each individual company thinks their shareholders can better allocate the cash, rather than the companies themselves. I thought the reason for a stock buyback was that the board believes the stock is undervalued. I can't imagine investing in a company that borrows loads of money from the government just to hand it back to shareholders. That sounds like a total scam to me and a terrible investment. I wouldn't accept stock in a company like that even for free. But what do I know. I'm not a CEO.
- throwaway2048 7y agoUnfortunately, its also a very easy signal for flailing companies to convince investors that their stock is undervalued.
- neffy 7y agoMarkets can be gamed just like anything else. In this case, companies are exploiting a short term feedback loop around taxation and share price, to funnel money into the executives and primary share owners. In the long term -- the next crash will be a doozy.
- fredophile 7y agoAren't these already taxed? If the company is buying that implies that someone is selling and would be taxed on that sale.