10 ms·
America is going to pay for the cronyism that merged every airplane manufacturer into one and eliminated internal competition. If you don't have internal compet
by whatshisface 7y ago
America is going to pay for the cronyism that merged every airplane manufacturer into one and eliminated internal competition. If you don't have internal competition, you'll collapse in the face of external competition. There is no way to get away from Boeing without getting away from the American aerospace industry entirely, a problem that didn't exist back when McDonnell Douglas was around.
- trimbo 7y agoWhy would Airbus be different?
- whatshisface 7y agoIt's not, and it could easily have gone the other way. By not having any competition or diversification, countries expose themselves to tremendous risk: the balance of the aerospace industry rested on a coin flip and the US bet tails. Without the cronyism, we could have had many separate raffle tickets against Europe's one.
- ahartmetz 7y agoIt seems like Airbus currently is different. Maybe the friction from it being very multinational prevented it from becoming like Boeing, maybe it will have its own big scandal in a month. Who knows. But currently, Airbus does look better.
- rsynnott 7y agoI mean, it wasn’t a safety scandal, but the A380 was a huge disaster for the company. I’d be more comfortable getting on a notional A360 than a notional 797, but both companies have self-harmed recently.
- CydeWeys 7y agoIt lost them money but it didn't hurt their brand. Those are great planes to fly in as a passenger, they're just not profitable in the end for Airbus. Boeing can't even keep its newest plane in the skies, and may have killed off the 737 line for good. Think another revision after the MAX is ever going to be approved?
- rsynnott 7y agoI think a more modest re-engine of the 737 would absolutely be approved. They’d have to sell it at a discount vs the a32x, obviously.
- cameldrv 7y agoI think that the MAX was about as modest as they could make it. That was really the point of the whole exercise. A more modern engine core with a smaller fan wouldn't have moved the fuel economy needle enough to justify a new model I don't think, and Boeing would have lost a lot of orders to the A320neo. Everything would have been fine except there was so much pressure to make every change as modest as possible that it didn't quite all work. They needed to either make significant changes to the landing gear or significant changes to the flight control computer and they chose neither.
- joking 7y agothe a400m plane has been a brand failure, it's military and on a different league than civilian planes however.
- throw0101a 7y agoAnd how has the KC-46 done compared to the A330 MRTT?
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoPer a quick check of Wikipedia it seems like they're about equal. The KC46 is being fielded by the US and a few nations that the US traditionally use the same arms. The A330 is fielded by the UK, a couple commonwealth nations and KSA Total number built is in the 30s for both.
- alexis_fr 7y agoAirbus scandal won’t come “in a month”: Boeing’s problems became public in 2013 and it is the same problem over and over. - The Ducommon airframes in 2013, problem is FAA delegated certification to Boeing, - The batteries, albeit smaller, - The MAX, 2 crashes due to oversight and to the FAA delegating certification to Boeing. Boeing’s problem didn’t come in a day, but in 20 years since the merge with MD, who had the same lose and fast culture. Airbus is safe for the time being, even if risks always exist, political instability for example. Not the case for the moment.
- ahartmetz 7y agoWell, for Airbus there is this where it looks like problems were swept under the rug https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_296 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_296 ... though from the same era, there is this for Boeing which seems much worse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_737_rudder_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_737_rudder_issues
- pdonis 7y ago> for Airbus there is this where it looks like problems were swept under the rug Or this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qantas_Flight_72 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qantas_Flight_72 This is the same basic design flaw that Boeing's MCAS has (allowing a single AoA sensor failure to cause the airplane to do unexpected and dangerous things), but unlike MCAS, it wasn't an ad hoc addition to deal with an issue in a redesign of an old airplane, it was designed into all Airbus fly-by-wire aircraft from the start.
- slavak 7y agoYou keep posting this, but it's simply not true- Qantas flight 72 did not experience an AoA sensor failure, and even if it had, the A330 uses all 3 independent AoA sensors and all 3 independent air data inertial reference units to command control movements. The issue was caused by one of the ADIRU CPUs corrupting valid sensor data to produce a series of very specific spikes, hitting a specific edge case in the AoA cross-check logic that made the flight computer behave as if the erroneous data it was seeing was valid. It's undoubtedly a serious design flaw, but it's not even remotely in the same ballpark as the Max's flagrant disregard for all process and well known design standards. http://code7700.com/accident_qantas_72.htm http://code7700.com/accident_qantas_72.htm
- socialdemocrat 7y agoBecause Europe has not legalized corruption to the same degree as the US. Massive campaign contributions is not as common in Europe, hence large European multi-nationals likely don't have the same opportunity to change regulations to serve them. Of course they can still influence politicians by talking about all the jobs they will provide etc. Also power in Europe is not centralized the same way as it is in the US. In the US you can lobby Washington DC. American lobbyist companies started swarming Brüssels as soon as the EU started gaining more power over national legislation. So there is potential for the EU to head in the US direction, but it isn't quite there yet.
- isostatic 7y ago> Massive campaign contributions is not as common in Europe Also far more complex - the political groupings in europe (EPP, ALDE, etc) are far looser organizations than the US parties, and power is spread in lots of different levels. Most Euro countries are coalitions of smaller parties too, defence in depth. The US and UK suffer from having just two parties that from time to time get all the power. Infiltrate one party and your time will come. Infiltrate both and you're safe.
- hnarn 7y ago> Brüssels Please stop that. Brussels is the English name for the city and clearly that letter does not exist in English. Alternatives are "Brussel" (Dutch) and "Bruxelles" (French). The closest to what you wrote is the German "Brüssel" (no S).
- tomp 7y agoAirbus isn't focused on profit (cutting corners), it's focused on politics (i.e. providing jobs in different countries). Hopefully that would make (local) engineers more powerful...
- bluedino 7y agoAerospace has the same level of politics when it comes to jobs in the USA.
- ailideex 7y ago> Airbus isn't focused on profit Why would you say that? > profit (cutting corners) Is profit the same as cutting corners?
- bhtru 7y agoThe context of the reply is why Airbus would not encounter the same organizational faults as Boeing. The general consensus is that Boeing pursued profit over safety with respect to the MAX. & they did so by cutting corners.
- ailideex 7y agoI think it is fair to say that Boeing cut some corners which resulted in the current situation - but even Airbus surely only prioritises safety over profit to a point - and I'm also sure Airbus cuts some corners. And this is also not really clarifying why Airbus, a publicly listed company with shareholders, is not focused on profits. I think what is being missed here is nuance - I don't think air-travel with 0 risk is possible - most things come with risk and if we are not willing to consider anything else nothing will ever get done.
- ailideex 7y agoYou really think Airbus will never prioritise profit over increasing safety? And if so do you think that Airbus planes are 100% safe?
- formercoder 7y ago
- larksimian 7y agoMy suspicion: the whole world lets the FAA validate airplanes and then sort of rubber stamps. Boeing was able to capture the FAA, but Airbus wasn't(since it's a foreign company). As such Airbus is still working with a proper adversarial regulator, whereas Boeing can get away with more cut corners. Eventually that screwed them. The EUs move for greater local safety review, ironically, might make Airbus less safe, since they might be able to capture the EU regulators. [edit] to emphasize: it's not market competition or the EU being better than the USA that's different. It's just the quasi-monopoly the FAA has on global aviation safety checks and the effect it has on foreign versus local companies. In fairness, if there were multiple US aircraft manufacturers, they might battle each other for FAA regulatory capture and prevent either of them from achieving it. [double edit] For the reverse of this see Dieselgate: discovered by some random American(named of all things John German) and pushed into the limelight by the EPA or whatever. It's not a perfect metaphor since he worked for an NGO, but arguably even civil society faces a sort of funder capture. Would German environmental NGOs have blown the whistle on something like this? Maybe?
- gamblor956 7y agoLet's not forget that until the two MAX crashes, Boeing had an overall safer record for its 7x7 line than Airbus did with its equivalent passenger jets. So the EU's "vaunted" adversarial regulator actually was doing a much worse job than the FAA.
- matthewmacleod 7y agoI think you have both misunderstood the argument being made, and misrepresented the relative safety of Airbus and Boeing passenger jets – which, by my understanding, is broadly comparable.
- larksimian 7y agoMy point was that the adversarial regulator for Airbus is the American FAA, not whatever EU institution is their equivalent.
- pdonis 7y ago
- atoav 7y agoAs somebody who lives close to the Hamburg Airbus Factory and read a lot about the Boeing story: the regulators are more strict within the EU, and my feeling is the biggest mistake in the whole Boeing saga was to have them regulate themselves. While there might be a economic benefit to not having to go the extra mile to get a regulators aproval, this can bite you really badly if you cannot uphold quality yourself any longer. And the interviews I heard wirh Boeing personel is nothing I ever heard even in personal exchanges with Airbus people. They surely also have their issues, bur to me it feels like a few magnitudes difference in severity. So in short: underfunding the FAA isn’t doing you airplane manufacturers a favour in the long term. I know in the US people are usually anxious to give any job to the state, but regulating is actually one of the things they should do, and should do well
- rsynnott 7y agoI mean, one option is to break up Boeing (and Airbus). They’re far too vertically integrated.
- wbl 7y agoVertical integration means fewer middlemen driving up the margin on each part.
- whatshisface 7y agoEfficient market theory would suggest that there is no margin in equilibrium, and what looks like margin is actually the cost of capital (which all companies, big and small, have to pay).
- theli0nheart 7y agoEconomics is laughably bad at predicting real-world economic behavior.
- whatshisface 7y agoThat's too broad a statement. There are some theories in economics that work very well, like supply and demand, or arbitrage theory. The idea of the cost of capital is also a fairly well-trodden one, it is taught in business courses, used on wallstreet, and seems to work in practice.
- theli0nheart 7y agoI can't think of a single broad economic axiom or theory that doesn't depend—wholly or in-part—on the principle of ceteris paribus, which excludes their practical application to essentially everything in real life. In a few cases, economic theories do a passable job of roughly mirroring real-world behavior, but that's the exception and not the rule.
- thrillgore 7y agoYou also literally just described how Airbus also came into existence.
- nutjob2 7y agoAirbus and Boeing are widely considered to be the one of most competitive and efficient duopolies on the planet. That might have a lot to do with the fact that they are based in two different large economies and cultures. The nature of their products and customers, and the scale needed, may not lend itself to having a lot of smaller competitors. Where are the economies of scale (or other efficiencies) going to come from? This may already be reasonably optimal for large aircraft.
- landcoctos 7y agoNearly 50% of part content of Airbus planes are American made.
- yyhhsj0521 7y agoDo you know how is the situation in reverse?
- landcoctos 7y agoSome Airbuses might be more American than Boeing (such as the 787)
- snarf21 7y agoWe pay for this all over the place and not just in planes. Look at it in communications, entertainment, social media. Stock price is valued as more important than choice for the consumer.
- yonaguska 7y agoIf you have cash to speculate, liquidate now- American market is going to take a dip in January with Boeing, which will be a good opportunity to re-invest.
- iguy 7y agoAnd in things without a stock price, like the MTA. Isn't the second avenue subway exactly what you get when there's exactly one player in the game?
- hanniabu 7y agoNot sure why you're downvoted. MTA basically has a license to print money. Their expenses keep growing while the service keeps deteriorating and fares increasing. They are very poorly managed and awarded the contract with no competition. The MTA has become too big to fail.
- kevinqiu1 7y agoI think the MTAs woes are unique to the MTA/management of the MTA and not lack of competition. Paris and Madrid have no problem building and operating trains at reasonable costs even though they also operate with no competition.
- iguy 7y agoI'd argue the problem is endemic to large stationary organizations, but some do a better job than others at keeping it at bay. It's interesting to wonder why. I think one aspect is the degree to which politically powerful are willing to fight it. Famously Stalin actually cared that the Moscow metro worked well, and it did, in a country otherwise crippled by complacent behemoths. Perhaps the Parisian elite likewise take more pride in having a metro which works OK, are willing to spend more political capital fighting for it. They feel some obligation to keep up with Brussels & Berlin, perhaps that substitutes for competition?
- soapboxrocket 7y agoIt's not just the airframe OEMs, but the entire supply base of aerospace manufactures has been going through a consolidation. Look at Rockwell Collins and Safran. But it's not all bad, most of this consolidation will lead to new opportunities for new suppliers.
- costcopizza 7y agoYup. I really hope these guys don't get bought up if their supersonic plane comes to fruition. https://boomsupersonic.com/ https://boomsupersonic.com/
- ajross 7y ago> America is going to pay for the cronyism that merged every airplane manufacturer into one and eliminated internal competition. This is true, but the counterpoint is: America isn't going to pay very much for accidentally killing its last airliner manufacturer. Airliners are a very mature market, with little incentive to innovate and minimal gains when you do. It's literally cheaper to operate 20 year old vehicles than replace them with the best available new ones! In how many other industries is that true? And airliners are small: Airbus revenue is like $60B, Boeing (which also sees a lot of defense spending to pad the number) is $100B. No one else is even on the map. This is a tiny market, in a global sense. We're just stuck on the idea of it being important because of history: Airliners "feel like" a high tech growth industry of the future. They aren't. They're trains, basically. The core devil's advocate position here is: so what? Boeing failed. Let them die (or rather, shrivel into the defense-only core of the company). Let the rest of the world fight over this tiny market with its shrinking margins. Nations that truly want to invent new things and grow in new ways[1] have better things to do and more important problems to worry about. [1] Whether the USA still qualifies is sort of an open question, but for a different thread.
- AWildC182 7y agoTheir defense side is also seriously suffering. They've lost the vast majority of contracts in recent history and their main combat jet, the Super Hornet, was inherited in the McDonnell Douglas merger and continues to suffer under their management.
- qaq 7y agoSo why Europe is not paying for merging everything into Airbus
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoHmm, not so sure, it a global habit and for each country that does it, then it goes international. Lots of other countries merge their major manufacturers, or allow them to, then - being 5x larger - find themselves powerless to avoid being bought out by their American cousins. Has happened to countless engineering, manufacturing, chemical and tech here in Europe. I suspect it would already have happened with most of the last remaining defence players were they not defence players. We're starting to see similar now China has risen as far as they have. Real competition is really, really unpopular in today's world.
- Aloha 7y agoThis has very little to do with that. McDonnel Douglass had no equivalent to the 757 really either. (The MD-11 was a suitable replacement for the 767, if you wanted a 3-hole aircraft) I'm absolutely certain that if Boeing was making a 757NG like aircraft, United would have bought those. When it comes down to it, Boeing has no direct replacement for the 757. Airbus does, so United bought airbus.
- gumby 7y agoBut I feel the consolidation, and the overweight in the result of military purchases, led to Boeing permitting such a hole in their commercial lineup.
- Aloha 7y agoI dont think thats really rational either. Look at the sales figured for the 757 - sales were either flat or very slow from 2001 onward. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_757#Orders_and_deliveries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_757#Orders_and_deliveri... Boeing stopped making the plane because the situations that led to its existence evaporated, and it looked as if there would never be more demand again, and the world seemed to be trending to 737 size aircraft in ever increasing numbers.
- pdx_flyer 7y agoIf Boeing had wanted to play ball on an NMA aircraft, United definitely would have purchased them. Instead they abandoned their smaller 787 variant and didn't pursue NMA at all, leaving the door wide open for Airbus.
- starfallg 7y agoA large part of the problem with Boeing is McDonnell Douglas. After the merger, the corporate culture of McDonnell Douglas was transplanted into Boeing. Their HQ was moved from Seattle to Chicago and money was spent on buying back stock instead of long-term R&D.
- bilbo0s 7y agoAssembly facilities being moved to the south because "it's cheaper" didn't help either. Engineers and technicians are not really just cogs in a wheel where you can replace one with another and get the same results. You lose a lot in the way of "informal knowledge base" when you do that.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 7y agoFollow the money. The lowest common denominator. The shareholders won then.
- pdonis 7y agoI don't think cronyism is any less of a problem for Airbus than it is for Boeing. Boeing happens to have had a recent bad incident that got it a lot of negative PR. But Airbus has had past incidents due to design flaws that are just as shocking.
- pinkfoot 7y agoBy the same logic, surely Airbus should also be collapsing in the absence of European competition? Something is missing from your argument.