25 ms·
Sundar will be the CEO of both Google and Alphabet
- frakkingcylons 7y agoTitle should just be Larry Page stepping down from Alphabet, Sundar Pichai to become new CEO.
- jmmcd 7y agoPlease please please, just keep telling Sundar and everyone, "don't be evil".
- drran 7y agodon't be evil
- 1000units 7y agoIn a world where "telling" people is enough, there is no evil.
- skratchpixels 7y ago[deleted]
- ollerac 7y agoFor anyone who doesn't know, it's currently in the Code of Conduct, at the very bottom: > And remember… don’t be evil, and if you see something that you think isn’t right – speak up!
- skratchpixels 7y agoThank you for the information. I didn't know it was added on.
- drran 7y agoIt doesn't carry same meaning as "Don't be evil."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoI like the idea of the "don't be evil" rule, but it always seemed overly naive / simplistic to me. Even without factoring in self-justifying rationalizations, people can have significantly different ideas of what counts as evil.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIt's an easier ethos to hold when a company is small. When a company is large, it bumps up against the problem that humanity as a whole has a difference in definitions on the subject.
- bogwog 7y ago"Don't be evil" is perfect because of how simple it is. It's supposed to be common sense. > people can have significantly different ideas of what counts as evil. And those people, who need someone to explain to them what is or isn't evil, aren't welcome. That's why I personally loved that motto. Too bad that whole ethos got dropped like it was a recently-launched product.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoThis topic fascinates me, but I haven't found a way to productively discuss it on HN. If you too find it interesting, you may enjoy doing a literature search on the topic.
- saalweachter 7y agoI personally like the semantic distinction between "don't be evil" and the way it is often misremembered on HN, "do no evil". Do no evil seems stricter than don't be evil. How much evil can you do before you are evil? Or can you be evil while doing no evil?
- sbuccini 7y agoCongrats to Sundar. Well deserved and I wish him the best of luck in his new role.
- andihow 7y agobootlicker
- ggm 7y agoAbsolutely nothing about the structural discontent emerging in staff. And nothing about the increasing sense of a loss of claimed ethical stance. I stress claimed, because the lack of concern at the top at its obvious demise makes it less likely it was actually held as a core belief.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lacker 7y agoAs a former Googler who stays in touch, there doesn't seem to be structural discontent emerging in staff. There were a few news stories about people complaining, but Google employs about 100,000 people, so any news story involving less than 1000 of them being unhappy can't really count as "structural discontent".
- notJim 7y agoOkay, what about 20,000 of them? https://www.vox.com/2019/4/23/18512542/google-employee-walkout-organizers-claim-retaliation https://www.vox.com/2019/4/23/18512542/google-employee-walko...
- lacker 7y agoThe walkout referred to was over a year ago, so I wouldn't call that discontent "emerging". If anything, that demonstrates that discontent is diminishing, because there hasn't been another similar walkout.
- sildur 7y agoYeah, in the same vein the discontent in Venezuela must be diminishing, as there is been quite some time from the last big demonstrations.
- ericol 7y agoI think they made every effort possible to cut this at the root, and even retaliate. the fact that 4 out of 7 of the organizers of the walkout left the company[1], some with more than 10 years working for Google, is rather telling. I don't think your comment holds water. [1] https://www.wired.com/story/most-google-walkout-organizers-left-company/ https://www.wired.com/story/most-google-walkout-organizers-l...
- mathattack 7y agoWow - big news! It seems better to have a CEO who is “All in” rather than one who is and one who isn’t. This is more work Sundar. I hope he has a strong bench.
- rosybox 7y agoAlphabet and Google being a separate company makes even less sense now.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIt's a line-item hack, the way that Hollywood studios structure films to be separate sub-corporations with their own fixed budgets. So if a film crew, say, accidentally blows up a small town somehow, there's a firewall between the assets that were dedicated to making that one film and the entirety of, for example, Sony Pictures net worth and capital. I'm not sure that firewall is well-tested in American law, but it's a well-used approach and I've always assumed the Google / Alphabet arrangement was for similar reasons (so that worst-case scenario on any 'bet is always "Alphabet cuts bait and shuts it down, liquidates it, and debtors go after the assets of the 'bet" without risking the performance numbers of the Google cash cow directly).
- throwaway0237 7y agoIt's a line-item hack but I believe it's for a different purpose: investors are asking for more details on revenue and expenses of the various units. Splitting the monolith Google into Alphabet + stuff provides line-items along "objective" lines that are still chosen by the company. One of the things people were anxious to see was the financials of YouTube. Guess who's not a separate "bet"?
- nostrademons 7y agoAlso allows the other Alphabet companies to have independent investors who may not want to invest in "Google" itself. Niantic is the prototype for this: it's success with Pokemon Go couldn't have happened without the partnership with, and investment by, Nintendo. It's doubtful that Nintendo would've wanted to invest directly in Google, though, and Niantic's $3B in lifetime revenue would be rounding error for Google as a whole but is still a very substantial return on Nintendo's $30M investment.
- notatoad 7y agoIsn't it the opposite of a line-item hack? Instead of being able to hide the losses of their other bets in the profits of their ad division, the alphabet structure gives their investors visibility into exactly how much money the non-google parts of the company are losing.
- nserrino 7y agoI wonder if this means that Google Cloud will be more likely to be split out as its own company?
- radiusvector 7y agoWow, Sundar is truly phenomenal.
- andihow 7y agobootlicker
- ciustuc 7y ago"We could not have imagined, back in 1998 when we moved our servers from a dorm room to a garage, the journey that would follow."
- totalthrowaway 7y agoc.f. https://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ https://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/
- xvx 7y agoRemember when the ‘Don’t Be Evil’ sign was taken down and thrown in the trash? I do.
- Starkus 7y agoGoogle's political censorship is outrageous and dangerous.
- reubensutton 7y agoWhat’s the relevance of that to this post?
- andrewstuart 7y agoGoogle needs to fix its reputation for killing products. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/04/googles-constant-product-shutdowns-are-damaging-its-brand/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/04/googles-constant-pro...
- michaelhoffman 7y agoGoogle had that reputation wayyyyyy before Sundar was CEO.
- TurkishPoptart 7y agoSundar became CEO in 2004. Google didn't start becoming evil in, I would say, 2008 or 2009.
- the_watcher 7y agoSundar joined Google in 2004. He didn't become CEO until 2015, when Eric Schmidt stepped down.
- enitihas 7y agoEric Schmidt had step down long before that, and Larry Page was the CEO. In 2015, Alphabet was formed and Page became the CEO of Alphabet, leaving Sundar as the CEO of Google.
- the_watcher 7y agoYou're right, I forgot about that.
- nemothekid 7y agoSundar became CEO in 2015.
- morei 7y agoDid you mean to say 2015? (Sundar become CEO about October 2015)
- cmiles74 7y agoTLDR: We are just as awesome and virtuous today as we were 21 years ago. Such self congratulatory nonsense.
- drcode 7y agoThe fact that a layer of management can be eliminated with everyone remaining on amicable terms seems like almost uniformly positive news for google.
- orky56 7y agoHow do you know everyone is on amicable terms? A press release is definitely not the place to determine the reality of the situation.
- lacker 7y agoI think this is good news. Google has sometimes felt like it was pulled in two different directions - making the core business successful, and providing spinoff cash for the crazy projects. Having the same person run both of them seems like it will make management more efficient. It probably means that a number of Larry and Sergey "pet projects" will become deprioritized. Good. Self-driving cars seem like they have great potential. I think that technology has the potential to make the entire Alphabet structure worthwhile. But it also seems like it should no longer need the Alphabet structure to protect itself.
- matthewfcarlson 7y agoWhat are some Larry and Sergey pet project? Genuinely curious.
- bduerst 7y agoSupposedly Google-X and Glass was Sergei's billionaire playground, with Waymo being Larry's pet project.
- avocado4 7y agoI think a lot of "bets" are going to be canned after this. A lot of them were just toys for Larry & Sergey.
- aazaa 7y agoBuried in a paragraph 2/3 of the way down: > ... Going forward, Sundar will be the CEO of both Google and Alphabet. ... Not knowing the internals of Google, it seems as if this is the announcement that Page and Brin are stepping down. Is this correct? If so, what an incredibly subtle way to announce a high-profile pair of resignations.
- lacker 7y agoYes, this is the announcement that Page and Brin are stepping down. I wouldn't really call it "incredibly subtle" - most similar announcements are wrapped in a bunch of corporate language as well. This is a pretty standard way to announce this sort of thing.
- im3w1l 7y agoDo you know what they will be doing next?
- givinguflac 7y agoDistancing themselves as much as possible to avoid legal trouble I'm sure .
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- darksaints 7y agoCashing out before the antitrust suits start to hit.
- Frost1x 7y agoI'm not sure how long these sort of antitrust cases take to litigate (I was young during Microsoft's high profile case), but I'd say this is one of the most rational explanations as to why, seemingly out of nowhere, they'd parachute away together. It looks like an attempt to try to distance themselves, their personal images, and their assets before it gets too ugly. I would certainly do so unless my personal financial analysts told me otherwise.
- ixtli 7y ago> Nonetheless, Google’s core service—providing unbiased, accurate, and free access to information—remains at the heart of the company. How is it ok to just say clear lies like this?! Without making any value judgements at all this is blatantly false. The ranking algorithms specifically encode a bias into search results. This is actually explicitly what users want, too! To be clear this is distressing to me because very powerful people can throw around words uncritically in this way for niche political points without being challenged. EDIT: It seems people are taking this comment in a way I didn't intend for it to be taken. Another example is that they are applying biases by sorting and displaying results on news.google.com. Personally I really like how this is done, but I think we need to be honest that it is a bias so that we can move on to a more productive conversation about what is or isn't a good bias.
- pknopf 7y agoThe difference is between personal bias and relevant search results. He meant to say "personal bias."
- ixtli 7y agoI would have accepted this, yeah. The difference is important because there is a relevancy calculation that determines what's on top of news.google.com at any given time and that encodes types of bias. Personally, in fact, I believe they're mostly good sorts of biases in that they wont generally show you InfoWars or something like that, for example. But we need to be honest when we talk about this stuff.
- mirekrusin 7y agoI think "I'm feeling lucky" button on the home page is unbiased.
- savanaly 7y agoDon't be too pedantic. By your definition, what even is unbiased? A list of all the sites on the web, A to Z? Words are what we make of them, and there's clearly some distinction between Google and, say, Baidu that is entirely appropriate to capture with the word "unbiased".
- nvrspyx 7y agoI see a few comments praising Sundar. As someone who doesn’t follow closely, but feels that Google has deteriorated dramatically under his watch, does someone mind explaining the reasoning for said praise?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Ididntdothis 7y agoGoogle has matured into a regular big corporation. By that standard they are doing well with revenues and earnings growing.
- lacker 7y agoGoogle's market cap has approximately doubled while Sundar has been the CEO. That's the simplest reason. Personally I think a lot of their products have gotten better recently, like the experience of using voice-controlled Google Maps in my car, and Google Cloud is superior to AWS in many ways, but the company really offers so many different product lines that it's hard for personal experience to be a great representation.
- nemothekid 7y ago> Google's market cap has approximately doubled while Sundar has been the CEO. It’s hard for me to say that this is because of Sundar and not just because the whole market has grown size and google already had a massive moat to capture it. Apple, MS, Facebook, Amazon all have grown massively in the past 5 years. However Google seems to continue to be a one trick pony - GCP lags behind the competition despite the fact that Google invented cloud computing. Even Apple is weaning off its iPhone revenue with its fast growing services division.
- GauntletWizard 7y agoI see this meme all the time. What does GCP lag on? What is it missing? I see a proliferation of AWS services, yes, but many seem to be replicating things that GCP has had since the start, in multiple different formats without clear direction. Bigquery covers most of the use cases of Redshift, Kineseis, Athena, EMR, and others. It is at once decoupled from and well integrated with their object storage, allowing reads and writes with clear translation when necessary. I find myself reaching for Bigquery like semantics all the time and having to cobble two or more AWS tools to get similar. I see the same pattern repeated constantly - If I click "ECS" in the Amazon Console, it wants to sell me ECS, ECR, Fargate, and EKS - All of which overlap in non-obvious ways. Disclaimer: I'm Ex-google, and was a poweruser of dremel
- throwwwawayyy 7y agoPosting this as throwaway because, well, obvious. The heat is on Google and its founders. It goes beyond anything that’s in the press right now. The real question is if regulators and others will allow Sundar to take the heat for everything and keep Larry and Sergey from the “hassle” of having to testify about anti-competitive practices and a whole range of other issues. And then there are the “hobbies” of the early Google crew and founders which are a problem in the #metoo era... There is way more to this than a retirement goodbye.
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoYeah it also seemed like an Irish exit to me. Especially with all the scrutiny over data collection policies and other political issues happening internally.
- Rapzid 7y agoWhen you say "hobbies" are you alluding to sex tourism and Casa De Epstein type stuff?
- throwwwawayyy 7y agoThe answer isn’t no.
- v64 7y agoDoes there exist evidence of these alleged transgressions?
- pier25 7y agoWhat are those "hobbies" you talk about?
- Rebelgecko 7y agoIIRC there was a book that claimed one of the founders took liberties with the massage room and some of the staff edit: i think it was this https://www.businessinsider.com/google-sergey-brin-employees-masseuse-room-2018-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/google-sergey-brin-employees...
- el_cujo 7y agoI wonder if this will result in any big changes at Google or is just codifying the way things have been run for a while.
- FpUser 7y agoTranslation: we've become a cancer like disease that have spread so wide and deep that cutting it out will severely wound the host.
- Rapzid 7y agoThe whole thing reads like it was written by a PR person.
- TurkishPoptart 7y agoWell...this is a corporate announcement, so it was likely at least approved by a PR/legal blob.
- xwowsersx 7y agoBecause it was lol.
- el_cujo 7y agoThis is exactly the type of thing you have PR people on staff to write though?
- rvz 7y agoWell it isn't everyday you hear the original CEOs of FAANG companies stepping down these days. First you heard Gates, then Jobs (Twice) and now Page and Brin. We'll see if whether if Pichai can continue this now that he has been crowned King of Alphabet and Google.
- arrrg 7y agoIt is literally the job of PR people to write things like these. I’m confused by your statement. This is effectively a press release, of course it was written by a PR person.
- ummonk 7y agoI recommend changing the title to “Sundar will be the CEO of both Google and Alphabet” (which I’ve quoted from the article).
- dang 7y agoOk, changed.
- enitihas 7y agoTLDR version: Sundar is now the CEO of both Google and Alphabet, and Larry and Sergey have taken a seat on the backbench.
- Wonnk13 7y agoThis has to be a green light for TK to take Cloud and really run with it. There's no way Sundar can give as much attention to Google and all the other bets simultaneously. Curious what side projects of Larry and Sergey get turned down now.
- suyash 7y agoHowever neither TK nor Sundar are of Satya Nadella's caliber. Let's see how things turn out in few years with this change at Google.
- hyperdo 7y agoSuper curious why you think this -- what about Satya Nadella makes him so much "better" than Kurian or Pichai?
- joemi 7y agoWho or what is TK? It's proving hard to google decisively for a relevant meaning.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- techntoke 7y agoGoogle has done some things well, but some things very poorly. First, fire whoever decided to prevent syncing Google Photos to Drive and not having a compatible Photos API for syncing original backups. Next, invest in and add features to Google Music or stop charging for it. Last, Google News sucks. No matter how much I dislike content it keeps showing me more of the same. Reminds me of YouTube. People should get heated on Google curating propaganda.
- markmm 7y agoLarry and Sergey are cutting the cord. They gave birth to a star company and it now owns most of the Internet's information. We are already seeing a backlash against the major internet juggernauts like Facebook, Google and Twitter and it will only continue as their dubious behaviours are unearthed.
- pizzaparty2 7y agoAlphabet. Alpha bet. Ohh!
- utopcell 7y ago:'(
- footpath 7y agohttps://abc.xyz/investor/news/releases/2019/1203/ https://abc.xyz/investor/news/releases/2019/1203/ Slightly more organized info in the intro bullets. Larry Page and Sergey Brin, the CEO and President, respectively, of Alphabet, have decided to leave these roles. They will continue their involvement as co-founders, shareholders and members of Alphabet’s Board of Directors.
- nostromo 7y agoI'm curious what their continued involvement will look like. For a while after Bill Gates stepped down as CEO, there was this awkward tension where Steve Balmer was CEO, but people still treated Bill like he was the one in control -- because he was.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lonelappde 7y agoPage and Brin have been out of the big picture for a long time.
- steve76 7y agoAwkward tension? WTF is this middle school? Money goes up. Hell flows down. No need to complicate business.
- binary_vitamin 7y ago> For a while after Bill Gates stepped down as CEO, there was this awkward tension where Steve Balmer was CEO Bill was simply playing politics.
- grappler 7y ago“cofounder” isn't “what you're doing now”; it's “what you did 20 years ago” but it's important because people put weight on what the founders say and think. “[large] shareholder” is sort of a role, and often goes together with “member of the board”. Bill Gates is probably a good example to look to. He also stayed on the board (as chair) and remained a large shareholder, and was looked up to as the cofounder. So I'd imagine “like Bill Gates but with less active interest and involvement”.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoI wish both Larry and Sergey well in their future endeavors. It is clear that the mess that Google is in, the investigations, the internal revolts, the general slide from being "good guys" to "bad guys" weighs on those who are nominally tasked with addressing those issues. By stepping out now they have no doubt made their lives easier but it puts Sundar in an fairly challenging place. I hope he is up for it.
- viburnum 7y agoThese guys have all the money and power in the world, and they've used it to turn an excellent service into a sleazy ad machine. They have $50 billion each. What would it have cost them to run Google without making it trashy? Would they have even noticed if they only had $5 billion each?
- Skunkleton 7y agoDon't blame them, blame corporate capitalism. This is where all publicly traded american businesses end up.
- throwGuardian 7y agoThis is probably an admission that bets outside core Google [YouTube, Maps, Photos, cloud] & Android haven't paid off. Time to run alphabet in a more disciplined, less "risky" manner? I'm expecting cuts to come in Alphabets' "bets"
- somerandomness 7y agoIt'll be interesting to see how they use their preferred shares voting power (which still give them effective control of the company).
- beaner 7y agoOne thing I really like about Larry Page is that it's obvious he never really wanted to be a manager. He's a real nerd at heart who likes technology. But he also realized the value of what he created and acted as a good steward for 20 years. He took the reigns when he needed to, and let others take over when the time was right. He's still one of the people I look up to most.
- JohnFen 7y ago> He's still one of the people I look up to most. I don't. He's allowed Google to become many of the things he's long stated he was opposed to. Either he never had his stated values in the first place, or he's turned his back on them in later years.
- smt88 7y ago> He took the reigns when he needed to I strongly disagree. Alphabet is an unfocused company which seems to treat product releases as experiments that can be killed at any time without warning. There's a culture that incentivizes more experiments rather than better products. The aimlessness is obvious in the frequent and baffling product renaming, reorganizations (like Nest joining Google), duplicated/overlapping products, and killing of acquired products. A smart CEO knows how to focus, build on early success (rather than abandon), and tell a coherent brand story.
- m0zg 7y agoOne of the first initiatives Larry undertook when he became a CEO is to "put more wood behind fewer arrows" by canceling a ton of bullshit projects that _haven't_ yet been released to the public, and some that have, as well. So if you're going to blame Larry for anything, this is not it.
- smt88 7y agoI'm sure his intentions were good. It doesn't mean he followed through or succeeded. If they canceled a "ton of bullshit projects" and still ended up with a time when Hangouts, Hangouts Chat, Hangouts Meet, Allo, Duo, Messages, and Voice are all actively used but somehow still missing important fixes/features, then he utterly failed. No one gets credit for the things they didn't release when the things they did release are still baffling and often result in a betrayal of their loyal users.
- sys_64738 7y agoAn ad company has a new CEO. Why is this news?
- lucb1e 7y agoI'm also not sure what the news is. The (in 2014) new CEO of Microsoft apparently got rid of an entire management layer, that seems like news. Without an intention like that being announced, this is celeb news for nerds and really only tells me it'll be new face same story -- at least until we know more.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoWeirdly this feels like a non-issue. Google has not felt like it has a "personality" for some time - maybe it's a function of hitting mega-corporate size, but it also feels a bit like when Microsoft (a Computer on every Desktop) essentially achieved its goal, it then spent a decade in "goalless and soulless exploitation" mode - something that one suspects is the next step for the worlds largest personality-free platform. If the two of them leave (have fun sipping pina coladas on the beach!) I am not sure (from the outside) what difference will be made. This may sound like great corporate succession planning - but I feel without a goal there will be little to stop business plans that boil down to "squeeze every dollar from everyone everywhere" (Was there a glimmer of light in "unbiased free information to all" - is that a mission for the new decade?) Edit: Just to emphasise - I hope they have fun spending their billions.
- hnzix 7y ago> is that a mission for the new decade? It would be nice to see a focused mission from El Goog. From the outside it feels like they incubate a bunch of random semi-competing products which are arbitrarily terminated or boosted. There's a lot of talent that could be marshaled.
- droopyEyelids 7y agoThey have a mission, to control the interface between consumers and digital business. All their 'random' stuff makes sense in that context.
- usrusr 7y agoNot just digital. In the analog age, all those little "yellow pages" publishers around the world were in a similar position and got quite fat from it as well. Now that entire market is concentrated, with enormous automation benefits, at a single address in Mountain View. Injecting Google intro the interface for brick and mortar businesses is why Maps and Android exist.
- RivieraKid 7y ago
- bedhead 7y agoIt is clear that Sergey and Larry (and Eric) have been asleep at the switch in shaping Google's culture, which now looks like the campus of Evergreen State College. Both he and Sergey have seemed checked out for years. Being the CEO of this company, especially given everything they've accomplished, doesn't seem very fun. I couldn't tell you what Sergey's been doing there or if he even works at all. This company's culture is trending towards being toxic but that they invented the world's greatest money-making machine has been able to paper over a lot of the rot.
- tomrod 7y agoI am out of the loop. What does this mean? > It is clear that Sergey and Larry (and Eric) have been asleep at the switch in shaping Google's culture, which now looks like the campus of Evergreen State College.
- rabidrat 7y agoEvergreen State College is (in)famous for its lack of traditional grades and curricula: "non-traditional undergraduate curriculum in which students design their own paths of study...Faculty write narrative evaluations of students' work in place of issuing grades."
- telotortium 7y agoAnd also infamous for its student activism, some would argue past the point of all sense (see: Bret Weinstein).
- nafizh 7y agoSundar Pichai is the Steve Ballmer of Google. Google has lost a lot of street cred under him, and it seems they are happy with long may it continue.
- leowoo91 7y agoTIL that is a valid url: http://google/ http://google/
- smlacy 7y agoI wonder if this is actually: "Larry and Sergey resign over cancellation of TGIF"?
- kccqzy 7y agoSeems unlikely. Larry Sergey previously attended all TGIFs. Then after a series of pointed questions at TGIF, they no longer decided to attend TGIFs.
- emrehan 7y agoDear Larry and Sergey, Thank you for creating Google. Nobody could prove that without it the web would have been a better place. You couldn’t have known what’s to come when you were raising hundreds of thousands of dollars as two students in 1998. Maybe your leadership has been one of the least evil among the possibilities in the evil world we live in. However, we know what is it like to lose control of your company, and how it could inspire dystopian novels under your leadership now. There’re many lessons for all the entrepreneurs to take from your story. I sincerely hope that you would prioritize the greater benefit rather than the Google’s benefit as years pass. Sincerely, A Non-Googler, one of the 7.7 billion
- xtracto 7y agoThat is something that I kind of admire about Bill Gates: As Microsoft's boss he was ruthless, and even anti-competitive, all to benefit his own company. But somehow, he is one of the "best type of person" that could become the richest man in our world. There are so many rich people that just look to be buried with their millions or pass it to their family. Hopefully Sergei and Larry will try to get the same type of legacy.
- hangonhn 7y agoSo Gates is not alone. Buffet and Ellison have both pledged the vast majority of their wealth to the Gates Foundation. Somewhat unique to the US, our billionaires tends to be fairly philanthropic.
- rosege 7y agoDidn't Page and Brin pledge their fortunes to Musk?
- Lerc 7y agoI believe one of them said they were more likely to give their fortune to someone like Musk over a traditional charitable venture. I feel that was expressing a desire for more transformative change over fixing the individual problems we have now. Change the world so much that the problems are no longer an issue.
- ageofwant 7y agoA VP of customer service, and 'not shutting shit down today, perhaps' would have been nice.
- throwaway9381 7y agoHm, a high profile resignation. I've heard that there's been many high profile resignations in the last year or two across many Fortune 500 companies, I can't confirm this myself though. I've heard conspiracy theorists say it's cause the deep state is being flushed out. Personally I think there is more than meets the eye with this resignation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- summerlight 7y agoThere are some ongoing theory-crafting in this thread, but the real reason seems pretty simple; Larry and Sergey obviously don't want to deal with all the management and operational stuffs, but only "moonshots" like autonomous vehicles or quantum computing. Yeah, this was the whole purpose of establishing a holding company, but Alphabet has grown by 2 times (both in employee count and revenue) and probably they're now facing the similar amount of bureaucratic workload again. Personally, I think Sundar has been a pretty good CEO and probably a better businessman for this size of organization but I'm still not sure whether this leadership change will work better for Google though. Due to Alphabet's structure, Larry and Sergey will keep majority voting stocks but they will be away from most of the details in the company. Can they still make good business decisions without such details?
- bb88 7y agoI'm not sure that Sundar has been a good CEO. The constant shutdown of google services that people rely on has been troubling. The management troubles over employees lately has been troubling as well. They still own the search market, but would you worry about the lifespan of the google products you're thinking of buying? I still have a Sony Google TV, it works great as a TV but the android OS is no longer supported, so there are no more OTA updates. It's a shame because it seems like if they had thought about it they might have wondered what happens when they no longer support the product. There was a time when Google questioned the value of managers and managers had to prove their value to the engineers. Maybe it's time to question their value again.
- KaoruAoiShiho 7y agoIsn't the constant shutdown a google thing before Sundar? I doubt it's an imposition from him.
- summerlight 7y agoYes, Google has a chaotic culture of project incubation, which leads to over-promotion of product launches and their eventual deprecation. And this predates Sundar's tenure on CEO. I think Sundar is trying to reduce a frequency of product launches, but there's already a crazy number of product in flight or development so deprecation of certain products are inevitable IMO.
- gorgoiler 7y agoGoogle! What a thing to have created in this world. Hats off to Page and Brin. After the dotcom crash, and I don’t know if there’s any real analysis to be had around this or if it’s just sentimentality, but personally there was always a sense of hope attached to Google as they brought excitement back into bleak times in the industry. Facebook was a sort of cheerleader in that way as well, during the 2008 credit crisis, way before the world turned sour towards the Facebook brand. Who will be the great business to drag us out of the next financial / tech-industry crisis?
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoIncredible way to paper over the likely source: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/06/alphabet-board-investigating-inappropriate-relationships-by-execs.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/06/alphabet-board-investigating... Sergey Brin and Larry Page were terrible to women. They engaged in, promoted, and paid for sexual harassment. Shortly after the Alphabet board is investigating misconduct, Larry and Page are "retiring". And of course, they're still worth billions.
- cromwellian 7y agoThis article says David Drummond was involved in an extramarital affair with an employee, it doesn’t say that Page or Brin are being investigated for sexual misconduct. Where’s your evidence that they’re stepping down over some personal scandal? This seems like a rather bold claim.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoStories about Sergey and Brin are longstanding and easily researchable. And Larry Page is who paid Rubin $90 million without approval before it got out why Rubin was leaving. But here's an example for Sergey as well: https://www.businessinsider.com/google-sergey-brin-employees-masseuse-room-2018-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/google-sergey-brin-employees... > Ayers said in the excerpt that when the company's human-resources department raised eyebrows at Brin's behavior, Brin suggested he was entitled to engage with his employees in whatever manner he saw fit. > "HR told me that Sergey's response to it was, 'Why not? They're my employees,'" Ayers said. "But you don't have employees for f---ing! That's not what the job is." The boys club at the Alphabet C-level goes to the very, very top, and it would be impossible to address Drummond without addressing Page and Brin.
- cromwellian 7y ago> Stories about Sergey and Brin are longstanding and easily researchable And all happened a long time ago, e.g. Brin's dalliance with Hugo Barra's girlfriend, so why would he resign years after this happened? > And Larry Page is who paid Rubin $90 million Again, Page didn't personally pay Rubin, this was part of Rubin's exit-contract, approved by the board, and why would this cause Page to resign specifically, and not Sundar? > The boys club at the Alphabet C-level goes to the very, very top, and it would be impossible to address Drummond without addressing Page and Brin. Pretty much the "boys club" extends everywhere in corporate America (and politics), pretty much anytime men get a lot of money or power, they tend go off looking for lots of sex. But you're alleging that they are both resigning simultaneously because of some scandal that's about to be unearthed related to sexual harassment. Everything you've brought up have been known for years and are not revelations and so are already 'priced in' to the board reputation. Most Googlers know and have felt that Larry and Sergey have been 'checked out' for years and are no longer interested in the day to day direction of Alphabet as a business. They barely ever attend company events. So what's more likely: a) They're rich and bored and want to go off and do other things or b) they's suddenly resigning for behavior that was documented years ago (Brin's affair while married, Page dating Marissa, etc, or paying off C-suite execs). In fact, rank-and-file Googlers didn't even demand their resignation when the Rubin $90 million exit happened. There's no pressure on them to resign over that. or c) some secret scandalous sexual escapade that happens to involve both of them is about to be unearthed but yet is unsupported by anything you've linked. I think you have to admit that your claims are both salacious and exceedingly unlikely, and this is very likely a bunch of multibillionaires long bored with management. You've made very specific claims that their resignations are being driven by some sexual harassment claim. This claim is baseless until you present evidence.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ddp26 7y agoLarry and Sergey, thank you for the incredible gift that you gave the world. You will be deeply missed at Google.
- claudeganon 7y agoSeems like “interesting“ timing given that the Alphabet board just recently stated they’re investigating the handling of sexual misconduct by executives: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/06/technology/google-sexual-harassment-lawsuits.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/06/technology/google-sexual-... And relatedly: > Charlie Ayers: Sergey’s the Google playboy. He was known for getting his fingers caught in the cookie jar with employees that worked for the company in the masseuse room. He got around. Heather Cairns: And we didn’t have locks, so you can’t help it if you walk in on people if there’s no lock. Remember, we’re a bunch of twentysomethings except for me—ancient at 35, so there’s some hormones and they’re raging. Charlie Ayers: H.R. told me that Sergey’s response to it was, “Why not? They’re my employees.” But you don’t have employees for fucking! That’s not what the job is. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/07/valley-of-genius-excerpt-google https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/07/valley-of-genius-exc...
- dgacmu 7y agoIt's hard to have the moral authority on that with Sergey still running things: https://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2017/11/30/google-employees-say-shadow-of-office-romances.html https://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2017/11/30/google-e... If your theory is correct, we should see Drummond retire soon as well. I expect it...
- luxuryballs 7y agoI was thinking “interesting timing” given we are coming up on 2020 elections and Twitter CEO Jack announced he would be living in Africa for a portion of the year... they are washing their hands of whatever shenanigans that Google and Twitter will be up to during this election cycle.
- lonelappde 7y agoThat's years old news.
- claudeganon 7y agoThe investigation of executives to fend off shareholder lawsuits is less than a month old...
- lawrenceyan 7y agoA well deserved congratulations to Sundar's promotion! Larry and Sergey have spent the majority of their time on Other Bets for quite some time now, and it's good to see that this is finally being solidified / recognized within Alphabet's management structure.
- option 7y agoCan someone please explain why it is well deserved? For example, when I was at MSFT it was very clear why Satya deserved to be the next CEO - for leading and growing the cloud business from irrelevance to a major pillar of MSFT. What about Sundar? Is this all because he led Chrome?
- coffee12345 7y agohe just released stadia, the greatest gaming console of all time
- DevKoala 7y agoIt is way too early to measure the success or failure of Stadia.
- xzel 7y agoHe's being sarcastic (I hope).
- aaronharder 7y agoEither way, too early.
- Jamwinner 7y agoThe amount of advertising (every single youtube video for the last 3 months), and lack of any excitement amoung gamers, hardcore or casual, does seem damning.
- m23khan 7y agogoogle has been making lots of typical corporate moves lately.
- Starkus 7y agoI find it amusing that, if you comment on a thread on Hacker News, about Google's censorship, relevant to the posted article that states google is 'unbiased'...you're...censored
- mandeepj 7y agoShared are up. So, market has approved the move
- luxuryballs 7y agoJust in time for some plausible deniability when Google goes hard on manipulating the 2020 elections next year.
- nfRfqX5n 7y agois dual CEO'ship going to become a thing now?
- perseusprime11 7y agoThis is a very well deserved promotiom for the hard working Sundar. He is likely to reign in moonshots and other bets that are unlikely to succeed.
- rickncliff 7y agoI don't much care about throwing the codeword "unbiased" in there, it's just pandering to critics and their nonsense talking points.
- bfrog 7y agoSundar seems set on track to cause a large part of the google workforce to question the ethics of their work, unless I've mis-read the headlines (entirely possible) since he's taken the reigns.
- mikl 7y agoKinda make that whole restructuring dance they did when creating Alphabet pointless. The CEO of Google is once again in charge of all the things.
- anonytrary 7y agoI'm sure the legal implications of this so-called "restructuring dance" remain and are certainly not rendered pointless because of these title changes.
- mmmeff 7y agoOkay Google.
- Avamander 7y agoFunnily (or sadly) enough, saying "Ok boomer" triggers the hotword detection.
- tus88 7y agoHow is this not a quasi-merger of the two then?
- iandanforth 7y agohttps://www.wired.com/story/wired-25-sundar-pichai-china-censored-search-engine/ https://www.wired.com/story/wired-25-sundar-pichai-china-cen... Having Pichai in charge is deeply disturbing to me. If he has had a public moment that demonstrated deep moral convictions that were put before the obvious market benefit of the company I haven't heard about it. (But feel free to provide links)
- jariel 7y agoLeaving just when there are the first real signs of existential trouble for Google ... Google was fairly succesfull right from the start, they deserve a lot of credit for that, but anyone with experience knows how different the climate is when things are up vs. down; When things are up, everything is easy, when things are down, everything is hard. As much as I kind of loathe Ellison ... at least he's there 'in the control room' the whole time.
- cutenewt 7y agoJohn Legere is stepping down from T-Mobile. Perhaps he might be asked to step in for Sundar if Sundar can't turn it around in the next 18 months.
- sidcool 7y agoGoogle should buy a hardware company and a carrier company to have a big impact on hardware business
- fireattack 7y agoWho will be the new President of Alphabet?
- dznodes 7y agoCould Larry and Sergey start a new business? I bet they would enjoy that and likely succeed again.
- williesleg 7y agoWho the fuck is Sundar? No last name? Just do the needful. Sucks to be Google, a shell of what it once was. So evil now.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fjrufjfjfu 7y agoThis is amazing. What happened to those guys?
- gigatexal 7y agoCongrats to Sundar! He and Nadella need a movie about how they came in and ran things.
- mtgx 7y agoSundar has basically destroyed what was left of Google's "soul" in the never-ending search for high quarterly profits. In his time you started seeing Google give up on the "don't be evil mantra" both officially and unofficially. It has started tracking users much more shamelessly, it has started working with the government on AI assassination projects, wanted to go back to China with a much more censorship-friendly version of the search engine, more protests erupted from its workers, Google's phones have become much more expensive, and so on. I "can't wait" to see what terrible and irreparable damage Sundar will do to Google/Alphabet over the next 10 years.
- airnomad 7y agoProblem with google is that they are losing data game. They own the web but meanwhile web became only one medium among many and a lot of companies build their own "web" Instagram app is essentially a browser to use IG's private "web" of content google has no access to. Same goes for twitter, even Snapchat. So attention wise, google is loosing dominance as other companies are building their own protocols on top of web. Speaking of data,they own search intent (via Google) and web content (via Google analytics). However I'd say Facebook is ingesting way more data on non-content usage. They made much easier for advertisers to connect into FBs audience graphs and cross reference and retarget based on first-party visitor profiles.
- xz0r 7y ago> Instagram app is essentially a browser to use IG's private "web" of content google has no access to. Search engines are meant to index the open web. IG's public profiles are still being indexed by Google. Google is winning the data game from an ad-tech point of view but not loosing it.
- hobofan 7y agoIf you go with that kind of thinking, then I would say that they also mostly own location data. I'm more and more regularly seeing ads on my Google Maps, so it seems they are gearing up on monetizing that too. Even with being locked out of that silos, I wouldn't be too worried about Google, as it seems that it barely hurt their income streams.
- bborud 7y agoSomehow it feels like Google’s soul died years ago, but was hooked up to life-support. Reading that Larry leaves Alphabet would be the equivalent of just unplugging the life support on Google’s soul. And to be frank: this scares me.
- slowenough 7y agoPossibly off-topic but who will be Sundar's successor? Who is likely?
- TrickyRick 7y agoAm I the only one who recoils when hearing "Nonetheless, Google’s core service—providing unbiased, accurate, and free access to information—remains at the heart of the company.". This is more or less the complete opposite of how I view Google (Apart from accurate maybe). Google delivers results which are highly biased based on what they think you will like and what they will make the most money from and you pay a high price for it, giving up all your personal integrity.
- mrobot 7y agoNationalize Google.
- lanevorockz 7y agoUnbiased ? LoL, things are so absurd these days. Google gives Search Optimised results aimed at Ads. It was never about unbiased and it is a very silly and unnecessary point to be added there.
- m712 7y ago>Nonetheless, Google's core service--providing unbiased, accurate, and free access to information--remains at the heart of the company. Hah!
- mr_woozy 7y agoI hate google and you should too.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
- steveloco1999 7y agoBest run Page and Brin. When the hammer falls on political interference you want to be in another solar system. Google is the greatest criminal enterprise to ever walk the face of the earth.
- sharadov 7y agoSergei and Larry don't want to go before Congress and testify, Sundar will do that for them.
- williamDafoe 7y agoThat's right, give him credit for Ruth's budget cuts and he is very good at squelching employee will and silencing freedom of speech at Google.
- jiveturkey 7y agoWow, people are taking a press release at face value. Not just any press release (all are PR garbage) but one from Google, a master at corporate doublespeak. This is an ouster at worst, a forced resignation at best. Were I to guess, the politics-at-work thing as gotten out of hand. Larry and Sergey built the company in their image, in that specific way. One can easily imagine them bristling at the notion of having to take away employee freedoms. Because they are not willing to do what needs to be done to quell the uprising, rather than see their company spiral down to darkness, they are stepping aside so that others may do what needs to be done.