14 ms·
Venice Battles Flooding Amid Highest Tide in 50 Years
- m4r35n357 7y agoWhat - the beach?
- orky56 7y agoFlooding and other symptoms of climate change are externalities that countries & corporations are not acknowledging let alone paying for. Who's responsible for compensating the businesses of Venice who are effected? Is it the government of Venice? Italy? If history has taught us anything, these entities are on their own.
- parliament32 7y agoInsurance, just like any other weather-caused damage.
- stevenwoo 7y agoIn the USA the national flood insurance program has distorted the market in an incredible way by incentivizing building and constant rebuilding in flood prone areas.
- munk-a 7y agoI think it's a bi of a reach to say that it incentivizes building in flood prone areas - there isn't, as far as I'm aware, any active reward for such actions - but it certainly doesn't appropriately punish such stupidity. I'd love it if everyone who was hit by a hurricane was given money to rebuild somewhere safer, but just once.
- magduf 7y agoI'm not sure about the US's national flood insurance, but for other things, it doesn't always enable stupidity. If there's private insurance companies involved, they usually won't insure abject stupidity. Even government insurance has its limits. As an example, Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf Coast back in 2005, and it was a total disaster. Flooding, of course, was not covered by private insurance (it's been like this for a very long time), only wind, so there was a lot of arguing over whether insurance companies had to cover losses because the storm surge was actually caused by wind, and a lot of damage was solely caused by the hurricane-force Category 5 winds. I'm probably leaving some important details out... Anyway, the aftermath was that private insurance companies in that area refused to insure wind damage to buildings. It just wasn't worth the risk. So the state (Mississippi) came up with something called the "wind pool" which was government-provided insurance for wind damage. The problem was, it was really expensive. So a lot of people never did rebuild, a lot of people left (or moved farther inland, where the insurance was cheaper), etc. The bottom line is that enabling stupidity as far as building location only works long-term if it's being subsidized. If insurance reflects the true risk of building in a certain place, then it really limits that kind of activity.
- stevenwoo 7y agoThere is no private insurance available for people in certain flood vulnerable areas in the USA - the NFIP is the only insurer available. When Congress attempted to make the premiums more reflective of the risk most recently, they rolled them back immediately when voters complained.
- michaelmrose 7y ago
- munk-a 7y agoWhether that cost is paid unexpectedly after a disaster or in installments leading up to a disaster really dodges the question - also, offering any sort of long term weather related insurance seems pretty risky right now and I wouldn't really trust any such insurance. The party offering it might just get overwhelmed and declare bankruptcy. No matter which approach to ameliorate the cost is taken, I think it's quite valid to be concerned that this cost won't be levied on those that have contributed to the damage.
- safsafsa 7y agoInsurance doesn't work that way. Insurance works by the insurer selling a bet that an event wont happen so that the buyer is covered if it does. The insured doesn't mind paying for a (negative expected value) policy because the peace of mind is worth much more than the premium. The insurer doesn't mind because they're making many bets across many flood plains. The insurer is basically making money by charging a small premium to coordinate and ensure different people help each other out when they get unlucky. As soon as flooding is guaranteed, there is no point of insurance since the premium is equal to the coverage provided.
- stevenwoo 7y agoEven when there is someone responsible like the USA government for the nuclear waste close to sea level at the Marshall Islands, it’s hard to get accountability after the early years. https://www.latimes.com/projects/marshall-islands-nuclear-testing-sea-level-rise/ https://www.latimes.com/projects/marshall-islands-nuclear-te...
- the-dude 7y agoAre you stating that any flooding and other symptoms of climate change are externalities of countries and corporations? Would the earth be static if there were no countries or corporations?
- wjnc 7y agoUhm, I would answer that as a Yes (but I think you would disagree). It'd be a subsistence level of existence for the several (tens of) millions of humans in existence in that scenario, but one with hardly any human impact on the global climate. The thought would be that massive specialisation led to our current level of (material) wealth and that both countries and corporations are signals of cooperation and thus facilite specialisation. Even if I think of something like a Nozickian world as a starter, with exchangeable money as a transaction facility for transferring information, I immediately think we would see the roaming "tribes" as something akin to corporations.
- the-dude 7y agoSea level has been rising thousands, ten thousands of years : 6-8k yrs ago, I would be able to walk to the UK from NL. The North Sea was inhatibed : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doggerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doggerland
- eyko 7y agoThe rate at which the sea levels rose was much slower and much of that water was frozen in the arctic. The past couple of centuries are exceptionally different.
- kibwen 7y agoTo that end, here's one of my favorite XKCDs ever, which is a long-form chart of Earth's average temperature for the past 22,000 years, including notes about the advancing and receding of ice and sea levels: https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/ It does a fabulous job of driving home the rate at which the current pace of warming exceeds geological norms.
- rootusrootus 7y agoThe city has been sinking for quite a long time, are any businesses surprised when the floods come?
- sbov 7y agoYeah, most of Venice's problems are due to pumping water from the aquifer under the city.
- Lucadg 7y agonot really, source please
- safsafsa 7y agohttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272771413004629 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S027277141... It really doesn't need a source. If Venice takes too much water from an aquifer then subsidence is unavoidable. The city is sitting on top of a sponge, after all. This is true for any city that's not built on bedrock (which I believe includes half of Manhattan and Miami. NYC of course draws from the Hudson) Anyway, as the paper states the subsidence exasperates rising sea levels.
- jcranmer 7y agoNYC's primary water supply comes from the Catskills, not from local aquifers or local riverine supplies (the Hudson River is too salty around Manhattan to draw from).
- gattilorenz 7y ago> It really doesn't need a source. If the claim is that it is the main problem, I think it does need a source, and by reading the abstract it doesn't seem like yours is one.
- fooblitzky 7y agoVenice should sue the fossil fuel companies for damages, like Hawaii: https://www.civilbeat.org/2019/11/honolulu-to-fossil-fuel-companies-pay-our-climate-change-damages/ https://www.civilbeat.org/2019/11/honolulu-to-fossil-fuel-co...
- Yeroc 7y agoI visited Amsterdam recently and noticed in conversation with a number of people that both the citizens and governments are very aware and concerned about climate change since they're in a particularly vulnerable position to rising ocean levels.
- the-dude 7y agoWe are already below sea level, and experts claim we can handle an additional multiple meters of sea level rise : https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2019/10/04/we-kunnen-meters-zeespiegelstijging-aan-a3975698 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2019/10/04/we-kunnen-meters-zeespi... ( Dutch ) We will be fine and there are no worries in NL except from climate alarmists.
- baq 7y agoNL dikes can handle that but wouldn't you be flooded from behind via Germany and France?
- the-dude 7y agoWell, in Europe rivers flow from high terrain to the sea ( low terrain ). We are at sea. Rivers come from central Europe. As I said, nobody worries except climate alarmist and poorly educated people.
- advanceduser 7y agoYou know tides are not caused by climate, right?
- JshWright 7y agoTides are deviation from mean sea level caused by gravitational interactions with the Moon (primarily). "Climate" doesn't impact gravity. It absolutely does impact the baseline sea level (a higher sea level means higher tides).
- advanceduser 7y agoVenice would be flooded every 24 hours if this were a result of baseline sea level increase.
- JshWright 7y agoThat's not even remotely how tides work... For starters, tides in the Mediterranean sea are semidiurnal, so it would be flooded every 12 hours, not every 24. In reality though, tides vary significantly, in a periodic fashion, based on various cyclic factors. The Moon is not a fixed distance from the Earth, and the gravity of the Sun (and how it aligns with the Moon's gravity) plays a role as well. The level of "high tide" changes over the course of decades as those cycles overlap and diverge (like constructive and destructive wave interference). I'm also not suggesting that climate change is the primary driver of the worsening flooding in Venice (geologic subsidence is major culprit there... the city is literally sinking). I was just pointing out that it's silly to claim that climate doesn't influence tides.
- fungicide 7y agoThe tide was higher 50 years ago, before the effects of climate change started? But the mayor says its climate change. Is the mayor an authority on climate science?
- namirez 7y agoIt happened only once in 1966, but that's for the most part irrelevant. The frequency of high tides is increasing at an alarming rate. Source: https://www.comune.venezia.it/it/content/distribuzione-annuale-delle-alte-maree-110-cm https://www.comune.venezia.it/it/content/distribuzione-annua...
- throwaway5752 7y agoHe knows enough. Higher tides are predicted and have been observed worldwide because of icepack melting and thermal expansion of water. So, whether or not the mayor has scientific qualifications, he is correct.
- xvx 7y agoMaybe don't build a city on 118 small islands and expect the water levels to never ever change? Seems more like a failure to plan for the future.
- dang 7y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- xvx 7y agoKarma Police... arrest this man!
- SeanLuke 7y agoI imagine this was said in jest. But it's worth mentioning that Venice has sunk almost 10 inches in the last century. Even if water levels hadn't changed -- and of course they have -- Venice would still be facing serious problems.
- jandrese 7y agoIt would be more accurate to say "Don't build your city on a river delta or flood plain", but that's where the good soil is. It's also hard to go back in time hundreds of years to yell at your ancestors.
- safsafsa 7y agoNor would a city not built in the delta be Venice. Venice is Venice because it was built where it wasn't supposed to be!
- ravenstine 7y agoI don't think it's in jest, and I actually agree with that statement to an extent. If humans weren't polluting the atmosphere, the climate would still be changing. The only difference is time scale and possibly the temperature delta. This is why building cities right up against the shoreline isn't a very good idea in the long term. And, no, you can have ports without building metropolises right next to the water. Someone's going to say that I'm a "climate denier" which is totally false because I believe in anthropogenic global warming.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hanoz 7y agoWhy has the title been changed from "Venice Battles Flooding Amid Highest Tide in 50 Years" to "Venice Floods Because of Highest Tide in 50 Years"? It hasn't flooded because of the record tide. I thought for a moment this meant that the barrage had been completed but was today overwhelmed.
- carapace 7y agoMiami in 10 years, San Francisco in 25.
- rm_-rf_slash 7y agoNot entirely. Miami was built on porous limestone. The water comes up from the bottom, not the sides. SF is mountainous. Some parts may go under but most of SF will remain dry.
- maximell 7y agoMiami in 10 I can see - but San Fran? Seems like it has enough elevation to weather sea level rise of a few meters.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoHave you looked at San Francisco’s topography? It isn’t flat....all of the west coast cities are pretty safe.
- namirez 7y agoTopography?
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoFixed, thanks.
- wahern 7y agoMission Bay, South Beach and parts of SOMA, and most of the Financial District, not to mention the waterfront, are threatened by sea level rise. That's why the city has been [endlessly] debating plans for reinforcing and expanding the sea walls. Newer developments, like in Mission Bay, have been required to elevate the grade, AFAIU.
- carapace 7y agoYeah, I live here. :-) You're right that most of the city is at a pretty good elevation and won't be directly affected in the sense of getting flooded. But if the Embarcadero floods that's billions of dollars worth of damage right there. Same for China Basin / Mission Bay area around Mission Creek. That's got a baseball stadium, the major train depot for the city (CalTrain terminus), and a bunch of new multi-story condos and UC Mission Bay they just finished. It's going to suck if that area gets flooded, the sidewalks around the new condos are already cracking due to subsidence. ( https://www.sfgate.com/local/article/sidewalk-sinking-mission-bay-why-soil-earthquake-13578335.php https://www.sfgate.com/local/article/sidewalk-sinking-missio... )
- GnarfGnarf 7y agoVenice is doomed. A beautiful civilization, the Atlantis of the Twenty-First century.
- Hoasi 7y agoAnd no, we won't be able to 3D-print it back to life, but ultimately that is what time does, erasing civilizations.
- keiferski 7y agoHaving been to Venice multiple times, I have somewhat of a contrarian view: even if the entire city were underwater, it wouldn’t really change much. Venice as an actual place to live died decades ago. It’s nothing more than Disneyland at this point. If it found itself under the Adriatic in 50 years, I imagine it would simply become an underwater Disneyland. The architecture might actually be better preserved for future generations; for example, had Venice sunk prior to the mid-80’s, there wouldn’t be a McDonald’s there (yup, there’s a McDonald’s in Venice.)
- Lucadg 7y agoVenice is actually a great place to live if you don't prioritize for comfort but appreciate other aspects of life. I guess it really depends on each person but not having cars really makes up for many other disadvantages. Which makes you think how bad cars in the city are in general. You don't really appreciate this until they are gone.
- keiferski 7y agoOh I think the idea of Venice is brilliant. Historically it must have been incredible, when the palaces were actually in use and not simply museums. But at this point the entire economy of the city is based on tourism. Any trace of authentic life sunk a long time ago.
- Lucadg 7y agoI can understand it feels like this, but I assure real people live and work there, and there is a real local culture and authentic life. I lived there and I lived in many other cities like Paris, London, Munich, Krakow, Bangkok and Bali. Venice is one of the most authentic cities of them all. The language is alive and evolving. It's a bit like the fight club, real locals recognize each others, while the tourists think it's just a Disneyland. Quite fascinating!
- rayiner 7y agoPeoples' "authentic life" is finding a job, finding housing, finding a school for the kids, interacting with neighbors, dealing with trash pickup and water bills, etc. A tourist can never experience that. Even if you experience the flooding with real Venetians, you're not going to deal with the water damage for weeks afterward, or attempting to get insurance claims paid. But that's "authentic life." Charming restaurants, quirky bookshops, etc., that's not "authentic life." That's frivolity. Sharing frivolities with the locals doesn't give you any insight into their "authentic life." Tourism is always Disneyland. It's always fake. It's just different versions of Disneyland for people of different temperaments. (It's funny you mention Bangkok. I was born in Bangkok. What exactly is less "authentic" about it than Venice? How can a city even be less "authentic" than another city?)
- Lucadg 7y agoI hate sharing FB but this is where we can see some recent pics and videos as posted by Venitians today https://www.facebook.com/1292366660/posts/10215308807895434/ https://www.facebook.com/1292366660/posts/10215308807895434/
- personlurking 7y agoAnd here [1] you can see what the region would look like with rising coastlines, based on a Climate Central interactive map (which can be used for any global coastal city). 1 - https://ss2.climatecentral.org/index.html#8/44.984/11.272 https://ss2.climatecentral.org/index.html#8/44.984/11.272
- Udik 7y agoInteresting, but a bit deceiving. When selecting "current coast" it shows the current coastlines, but selecting even a single foot of sea level rise it draws the new coast respecting the actual elevation. The problem with this is that in several places, for example around Venice and in the Netherlands, the land is already below the sea level, so they appear to flood even with a single inch of water. Which is not the case.
- 40acres 7y agoI was a dinner party when the topic of vacation homes comes came up. We were all young professionals in tech so a vacation home in middle age was not out of the question. When I mentioned my reluctance to invest in beach front property everyone seemed confused -- I don't own a home yet but it makes me wonder, how much is climate change being considered as a factor for family real estate? I'm sure commercial developers are taking these things into account but are normal people?
- jbob2000 7y agoShoreline erosion is already concern for any waterfront property, and there are already devastating hurricanes and weather events they have to prepare for. From what I've seen, the owners of these properties are up to speed on the challenges the properties face. If there's damage, they repair it, it's just the cost of living next to the water.
- aphextim 7y agoIn Florida, the entire first floor cannot be covered by flood insurance. Most homes do not have basements as you cannot dig down to create one. Most 1st floors of nicer homes are essentially a finished basement and posts to support the rest of the building and the main floor starts on the 2nd level. During a hurricane, you assume everything on the first floor to be a loss so usually people may have their pools, have granite/tile flooring and do not have carpet etc so that way after a flood/hurricane it's easy to clean/fix up.
- journalctl 7y agoAlternatively, don’t live in Florida.
- aphextim 7y agoAlso this only applied in an area along the Gulf Coast, if you live further inland you may be able to get insurance that covers the first floor, but I have no idea. I do agree though, I like to visit Florida here and there but I would never want to live there permanently.
- Jakawao 7y agoCan we please keep these political hit job pieces off of HN? /s
- mirkonasato 7y agoThe MOSE project is supposed to protect Venice from high tides, with mobile barriers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOSE_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOSE_Project Unfortunately it's been under planning first and then construction for decades, mired by corruption scandals, delays, and billions of Euros in cost overruns. It's currently scheduled to be delivered by the end of 2021, having first been put out to tender in 1975.
- fwip 7y agoI hear some people saying that by the time it's built, rising sea levels may have already obsoleted it.
- mirkonasato 7y agoThe fear is that the gates will need to be closed too often and for too long, damaging the lagoon’s ecosystem: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07372-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07372-3
- droithomme 7y agoVenice was built on marshy landfill in a lagoon and has sunk 23cm in the last century. This is the main problem here. It will continue sinking and there's no way to make that stop as you can't build stable foundations under an entire stone city built in the actual sea on top of mushy mud and not anything stable. Venice is and always has been inevitably doomed due to poor engineering choices made centuries ago. Same goes for much of New Orleans.
- abainbridge 7y agoInteresting. It looks like the sea level has also risen by about 17.5cm in the last century - https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indicators-sea-level https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indica...
- grzte 7y agoWell, it's Italy.
- riccardomc 7y agoMaybe it's because I am Italian, but I am honestly shocked by the lack of empathy and blatant superficiality of some of the comments, especially given the usual insightfulness of HN. There's the guy who's been to Venice "multiple times" who's explaining why it would be better if it sank. Another one had a conversation at a "dinner party about vacation homes" and how are a bad investment. The other: "Venice is Atlantis of the 21th century", and finally "they shouldn't have built Venice on 118 islands in the first place". Venice is a real city, home to thousands of people that are currently struggling with the damage that all of this caused. Their businesses are threatened. An entire city and region is on its knees. It is a site of undescribable historical and artistic beauty, a treasure that belongs to all mankind. Seriously, some of you might have been too deep into your ARR and TSLA and lost the ability to empathize. Maybe this news doesn't belong on HN at all.
- volune 7y agoAmerican here, and we say this about our own cities, an example of which is New Orleans. While I understand your emotional plea, the vast majority of people who do not own homes on a disaster zone do not wish to subsidize those who do. Not everyone is keen to throw endless money down a golden toilet.
- riccardomc 7y agoI disagree, that might be true for USA, but there are many other examples where the vast majority of the population does in fact subsidize intervention in less fortunate areas. Take the Netherlands for example, the struggle against water has been a collective, charitable effort for centuries, and finally harmonized at the state level: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directorate-General_for_Public_Works_and_Water_Management https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directorate-General_for_Publ... Not everything needs to be done in the name of individual profit. As a side note, using the term "golden toilet" for New Orleans, or Venice, or pretty much any other City in a difficult situation, doesn't certainly convey empathy as my initial comment wanted to point out. So to each his own I guess.
- kbos87 7y ago
- dr_dshiv 7y agoCould Venice be raised, as Chicago once was? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raising_of_Chicago https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raising_of_Chicago
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoIt might be feasible, but I doubt the Italian government has the organizational ability to rally scientists and engineers around it. (I'm Italian, it's IMHO, but I speak with some past experience).
- teslaberry 7y agothe irony is that the more people talk about it sinking, the more tourists go to spend money there, prolonging the sinking more. i live in manhattan/new york and this reminds me of the pattern of antique/collectible stores that always advertise they are going out of business and prices are 80% off. i believe venice is sinking when its all underwater. i've been to venice. it's great. it's NOT sinking. total bullshit.