12 ms·
> Sick of round-the-clock work emails and Slack messages? Here’s some hope. This is exactly why articles about 4-day workweeks, 5-hour workdays, and the idea t
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
> Sick of round-the-clock work emails and Slack messages? Here’s some hope.
This is exactly why articles about 4-day workweeks, 5-hour workdays, and the idea that productivity is inversely correlated to hours worked are so popular; Many of us are buried under expectations of around-the-clock availability and commitment to our jobs.
One of my employers made an official policy banning vacation statuses in Slack because, in their words, it implied that people were off the hook from responding to Slack messages. I was threatened with demotion for taking a 2-day weekend backpacking vacation out of cell phone range once (not an on call job). My management team just couldn't tolerate the idea that one of their employees was out of their control.
At this point, I'd gladly take strict 8-hour workdays, 5 days a week. These articles about 5-hour days or 32-hour workweeks feel like a pipedream.
- koonsolo 7y agoI don't get this. I'm a software developer in Belgium, and basically all cards are in our hands over here. There is a huge shortage of software developers. If I quit, I can get a job within a month which gives the same or better pay. From the company view, they need to spend several months trying to find a new employee, and then give full pay while that person is still learning the codebase, and other employees wast time getting him/her up to speed. It takes another few months before this person is 100% productive. So as an employer, you are basically pulling on the shorter end of the string. So my question: why is it so much different in the US?
- unclesams-uncle 7y agoI'm an American who lived in Belgium for 15 years, first to study then for work. I always told people that the difference between the US and Belgium is that you "live to work" in the former and "work to live" in the latter. Belgian labor laws are much more enforced than they are in the US. The unions in Belgium have a lot of sway in big companies and employers tend to respond positively to work-life balance. In the US, there's the expectation that if you're hired for a role, you should be able to onboard as quickly as possible. There's no 6 month trial period or even the concept of an indefinite contract (CDI in French, I forgot the acronym in Dutch) (EDIT: in the private sector). Likewise, an American employer can get rid of an employee (and likewise hire one) in less time and with less cost than a Belgian one. That flexibility drives a lot of the business decisions in a way that would never translate in Belgium (or much of Western Europe, for that matter). On the other hand, if you're in a situation where your employer goes over the line (like the person at the top of the thread describes), you can generally just walk away from the job. There's no 6-week notice. There's for sure a lot more to it, but that's mainly where I see the difference between the two countries.
- DJHenk 7y ago> On the other hand, if you're in a situation where your employer goes over the line (like the person at the top of the thread describes), you can generally just walk away from the job I think this is exactly what was meant by op. Why is there so much complaining? If it sucks, just walk away. It should even be easier in the US than in Western Europe.
- kamarg 7y agoLegally it's easy to walk away. Just stop showing. You'll probably get a few phone calls wanting to know where you are before they terminate you as an employee in a few days. Realistically, in the US so much of your financial health is tied to your employer that the advice to "just walk away" is only safe if you're already financially secure and don't need a job. Aside from the steady paycheck you're likely to lose: medical insurance, dental insurance, tax free retirement savings, and the unvested portion of your stock/retirement savings at a minimum. If you're in a position that tends to pay a yearly or even quarterly bonus, you're walking away from that too. You're also going to lose a number of smaller items that can be expensive. Does your employer pay for the tools you use to be productive? How much does a JetBrains subscription cost these days? Or an MSDN license? How about all those AWS instances you use for sharpening your skills? Time to start ponying up or doing without. This doesn't even count the other perks and benefits that companies are throwing at employees for highly competitive positions. Enjoying that free gym membership? Not anymore. How about the free snacks and lunches? That's another expense you can add back in now that you don't have any income. Free coffee in the break room? Time to find out just how cheap you're willing to get with your daily dose of caffeine. Now factor in that for many being unemployed for extended periods of time can lead to severe depression and a lack of self-worth. Don't forget to also factor in that 22% of divorces in the US are because of "money issues" which can usually be translated to "lack of money". Taking the above into account I would likely put up with some pretty awful employment practices while looking for a new job rather than just walking away.
- unclesams-uncle 7y agoIn Belgium, you can't just stop showing up without consequences. You need to give 6 weeks notice, otherwise, they can take legal action against you, along with firing you, which means you lose any claim to unemployment benefits. Likewise, if you quit voluntarily, you aren't entitled to unemployment right away. But I agree, you'd most likely want to have your next job lined up before putting in your notice.
- filoleg 7y agoUS is so big, there are absolutely parts of it where it isn't much different. If you are a decent engineer in any tech hub like Bay Area or Seattle, you can absolutely walk out of your job and get a ton of interviews scheduled by the end of the week and have at least a few offers by the end of the following one. And hiring is just as costly and difficult for employers as you described. A lot of times, we have to go through so many candidates just to fill one position, and it isn't just for something ultra-specialized like an AI researcher or a kernel dev, we are talking your run-off-the-mill solid software generalist. The estimates easily go to above 30 candidates interviewed per position filled.
- overcast 7y agoI've had the luxury of a 36.5 hour work week, with no on call for about 18 years. It exists, but don't expect $300,000 salaries with it. You want to be rich, or do you want to live a rich life?
- mdszy 7y agoNobody mentioned salary amounts until you did.
- overcast 7y agoAstute observation. I thought it was worth mentioning in the context of what I was talking about.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI think you'll find people on the lower end of the pay scale get the most abuse.
- mattmar96 7y agoId disagree here. Rarely will a $300K employee be the one on call.
- yabadabadoes 7y agoNot technically on call, yet it takes about 20 minutes to get through the corporate officer titles on an enterprise bridge, making it hard to complete the reboot sequence within the Platinum response time.
- dshuang 7y agoIf your manager demands you be available over the weekend, you are on-call and should be compensated.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoMay I add, if your manager demands you're available anytime outside of business hours and you're not compensated for that time, you should immediately be looking for your next job. Unemployment has never been lower in 40+ years (in the US). You're likely to get a pay bump moving. Always Be Interviewing. No one is going to look out for your comp and work/life balance except you.
- ticmasta 7y agoWell, most jobs are salary so there's no notion of compensation per unit of time. I rarely expect overtime but sometimes I need help outside of regular work hours; I also don't make you get HR approval and book off time to go to the dentist or pick up your kid. It seems like the same people who complain about a lack of employer care & "greedy corporations" are also the same people counseling "always be interviewing" and the only priority is #1. It must be exhausting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- yardie 7y ago> most jobs are salary so there's no notion of compensation per unit of time. Most jobs are wage and it's perfectly normal to be salary and non-exempt. Unless you are a founder or management if an employer is trying to classify you as exempt to avoid paying overtime they are breaking the law.
- opencl 7y agoHow would anyone in the software dev industry not fall under the "computer professional" exemption?
- searine 7y ago> I was threatened with demotion for taking a 2-day weekend backpacking vacation out of cell phone range once (not an on call job). No amount of money would ever make me put up with this. I would rather work retail, because at least there I know I am not valued as an employee.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoYour experience sounds unacceptable. My best work experience was in Germany with a strict 35 hour week. Overtime was difficult to get approved and also required 1.5x pay. You got to the office and actually worked until you went home. Nobody had time to sit in endless meetings or to be indecisive. It was very productive and you actually had a life during the week.
- kilroy123 7y agoI had a job once where we worked 35 hours a week. I agree, you had little time to mess around. Yet, I felt like I managed to get everything done on time.
- komali2 7y agoThe least productive places I've worked had the longest hours - companies in Japan and Taiwan. Lots of time fuckin around on phones, and the obligatory period from 5pm - 8pm to "wait for the boss to go home" was almost entirely filled with Candy Crush. Stupid.
- VRay 7y agohaha, yeah, I've never seen anyone so unproductive as a Japanese or Chinese engineer putting in 72 hours a week I think this whole system of paying people an hourly wage or a salary is toxic when it comes to knowledge work. I'm pretty confident that today I could do something in a day that would have taken me a month when I started out 10 years ago. (And I can do stuff that would have been inconceivable when I was at the college student/new hire level) But I'm only making about 2-3x as much as a new hire at my current company. I wish the whole system were a lot more freeform and mercenary.. I'd love to roll in and spend a few months building some GPU firmware or debugging camera latency issues, collect $100k at the end, and then spend a few months backpacking or whatever. I guess that only a tiny fraction of the people I've met would be OK with that sort of existence, though..
- __s 7y agoSounds like too many places are willing to pay young developers too much. Why pay a third what they pay you for an order of magnitude less value?
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoQuit. You’re worth better than this.
- commandlinefan 7y agoMeet the new boss, same as the old boss. Plus, you're now the guy who quit rather than being a "team player".
- eagsalazar2 7y agoAre we hearing "Quit" from people in the Bay Area and other hot tech spots where employees are in very high demand and everyone else with a more pessimistic view is in regions where there is a surplus of devs?? If you experience that type of treatment in Seattle, NYC, SF, etc you should quit immediately. That is not the norm and you don't have to put up with it. For everyone else, maybe remote gigs? People are killing each other for great devs in the biggest tech markets and most companies know they have to take care of employee happiness and culture to be competitive in hiring.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> People are killing each other for great devs Well, if that’s true, there’s only one conclusion that the abused/unappreciated can draw: they (we) must not be that great.
- imesh 7y agoIt's a hard thing to admit on an anonymous forum but I have never been a great dev. Just good enough to never get fired. Over half the developers I have worked with are more capable than me. The trick is to get them to think I'm a great dev during the interview stage.
- wnkrshm 7y agoHow did you pull that off?
- sloopy543 7y agoIf you provide value and they really need you, they won't treat you this way. Find a way to become more valuable and competitive in the marketplace demanding your skill. Save your money so you can say goodbye to micromanagers. Nobody with valuable skills should put up with crap like that
- papito 7y agoThey have no right to do that, at ALL. Legally, an employer can give you zero paid vacation, but if they require you to be reachable during YOUR weekend, it's their f---ing problem that they can't structure the team to have no fallbacks. In the least, have a rotation plan.
- handoflixue 7y agoLegally they can do whatever they want - you're salaried, so it's not "your" weekend. It's a red flag and you should definitely start job hunting, but I'm not aware of anything that stops them from imposing this requirement.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoIs this like an American thing? You don't own people just because you pay them a salary. In UK you cannot force someone to work overtime more than 48 hours, averaged over 17 weeks. If they require you to be available over weekend, they would probably have to count it towards overtime. I would find it unconscionable to be available 24/7, how are you meant to go along your daily life? What's the purpose of that anyway, you are not working as a paramedic??
- jay_kyburz 7y agoI don't even have slack open during the day at work. I open it 2-3 times like email to see what's going on.
- hinkley 7y agoYour bosses are acting like feudal lords. I dunno about you but I still live in a democracy. Speak truth to power when you can get away with it. And get away when you can’t.
- mc3 7y agoWhen the rules are stupid, play by the rules. Set up a PC at home, logged into slack that keeps the status as available. They didn't say anything about actually responding to messages, right? Alternatively I'm sure there is a law they are breaking, so let them know about it. But more simply - any company that comes up with such a rule has got things backwards and doesn't understand how to manage people, and probably doesn't understand tech. They probably love emergencies where "the team comes together" and hate spending extra time on ensuring quality and paying down tech debt. Leaving becomes a sensible option. They are shortsighted and I am guessing they don't make a lot of profit. Is my tea reading right?
- cwkoss 7y agoEmployer expecting you to be available 24-7 on a 40 hr workweek contract sounds like the sort of thing I'd talk to an employment lawyer about: seems like they are not paying for 128 hours/wk of 'engaged to wait' time.
- VRay 7y agoAh, they're posting on HackerNews.. He/she can just spend a few months grinding on those stupid coding challenge sites and then snag a cushy job at one of the tech megacorps. Or dig up the last "Who's Hiring" thread on this site and find a nice gig at a smaller company
- cwkoss 7y agoCan be prudent to wait until after a new job is lined up to before litigating wage theft
- FussyZeus 7y agoLook I'm not trying to defend what your manager did, but holy lack of backbone, batman. Why on Earth would you degrade yourself so much as to go along with this?!