10 ms·
The Advertising Industry Has a Problem: People Hate Ads
- neonate 7y agohttp://archive.is/IhDHL http://archive.is/IhDHL
- ratsmack 7y agoThere is only so much people will put up with, and it seems that we're inundated with advertising from all sides. When most ads were in print, it was easy to avoid them, but now they are forced into every electronic media stream available. On the web, I have never used an ad blocker and have just closed the page if the advertising gets to be too much in my face. It seems that it is getting worse all the time, because it is a war between the advertisers and ad blockers and people like me are stuck in the middle. And then YouTube is showing longer ads every day, with many in the 5 minute range. And when you're trying to watch a video that is only 3 minutes long, why would you watch a 5 minute advertisement?... it doesn't make any sense.
- dazc 7y agoAttribution is the problem. Lots of ad spend is a waste of money and, despite the advent of various tracking technologies, advertisers still don't seem to know which ads are actually bringing in the sales. This, of course, isn't a problem for the third-parties providing all this tracking because they get their slice regardless.
- buboard 7y agoThis is the gist of the issue. Ad companies sell advertisers tracking and reporting, not real return of investment. I bet an ad agency could beat google by throwing up vast dashboards with tons of nonsense graphs.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThe easiest and arguably best way to do that is coupon or promo codes per advertiser but that involves taking a haircut to the profit per item on top of the nominal ad expenses.
- dazc 7y ago...and a fee for the 99% of sales you already had in the bag before your customer launched his search for a coupon code.
- visarga 7y agoFor Youtube it makes sense to pay. I did the jump and it was worth it - no ads, play music with locked screen on the phone.
- TheCapeGreek 7y agoFirefox on Android + "Video Background Play Fix" addon already bypass the locked screen/app not in focus "feature".
- maest 7y agoOr NewPipe (https://f-droid.org/packages/org.schabi.newpipe/ https://f-droid.org/packages/org.schabi.newpipe/), but it does require you to have FDroid (which is not a bad thing in itself, just adds a bit more friction)
- rumori 7y agoIt almost looks like Youtube intentionally raised the number and length of ads before and after videos while heavily pushing Youtube premium alerts to make people sign up for their subscription. No matter what you do, they win.
- catalogia 7y ago> "No matter what you do, they win." What if what you do is use youtube-dl?
- kds3 7y agoThey can just suspend your account. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21247759 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21247759
- catalogia 7y agoThey theoretically could, but there is no real reason to think it actually happened to that guy. His story is full of holes, and furthermore tons of people use youtube-dl daily while only this single guy claims to have been banned.
- cyborgx7 7y ago>On the web, I have never used an ad blocker Why? My recommendation to every single person is to install an adblocker right now and never ever turn it off again. It's such an easy thing to do which immediately significantly improves your quality of life.
- cameronbrown 7y agoPersonally? I'm willing to watch or see an advert for a newspaper, YouTuber (especially this!) or small blogger. Usually I use my adblocker's counter as a measure of how awful a page is and if it's reasonable I'll turn it off.
- pmoriarty 7y agoMalware is frequently delivered by advertising, so there's good reason to keep your ad blocker on even on sites that you want to support. Tracking is yet another thing you can avoid to some degree by using an ad blocker (and, better yet, by disabling javascript). Finally, the best reason to use an ad blocker is to opt-out of the advertising ecosystem to make it less viable. We have to find a more ethical way to fund media than supporting this manipulative, privacy-invading industry.
- gwd 7y ago> Why? My recommendation to every single person is to install an adblocker right now and never ever turn it off again. It's such an easy thing to do which immediately significantly improves your quality of life. The same reason that if I go into a cafe to sit down for a while, I'll buy a drink even if I'm not particularly thirsty. The cost of having a table in a downtown location for you to sit at is far higher than the cost of the beans and water; a drink for a place to sit is part of the "implicit deal". Websites cost money to run, so I think it's only fair to accept a reasonable amount of advertising. But I don't think being silently tracked for just happening upon your website is fair, so I block trackers. If your advertising works without trackers, I'll see it just fine.
- cyborgx7 7y ago
- opencl 7y agoEven the print ads seem to have gotten way more intrusive over the past few years. Amazon puts ads on their shipping boxes. I got a fortune cookie in a restaurant the other day with an ad printed on the back of the fortune!
- kyle-rb 7y ago>And then YouTube is showing longer ads every day, with many in the 5 minute range. Uhhh, can't you can press 'skip' after 5 seconds? I've never seen an unskippable YouTube ad longer than 30 seconds. Although yes, they are upping amount of ads: a couple months ago they started doing two back to back pre-roll ads every once in a while.
- malux85 7y agoI hate ads because they are so, totally, unbelievably irrelevant to me. I’m a daily YouTube user, I have a rich watch history of (probably) 10,000s of videos. Then it serves me an ad for beer with a bunch of beautiful woman, at a loud party, drinking with men. I’m a non-drinking, introverted, gay, who hates loud parties. The advertisement couldn’t have been more irrelevant if it tried.
- jasonlfunk 7y agoPeople complain (not that OP is complaining per se) because the ads are irrelevant, but also object to tracking and profiling. You can't have targeted ads AND be anonymous to the ad companies.
- malux85 7y agoI didn’t complain about tracking. I’d gladly, willingly put my demographic data into a platform that gave me interesting ads
- amelius 7y agoWe should of course consider the possibility that some of us are outliers.
- denton-scratch 7y agoI assume I am an outlier; it must be the case that advertising works on most people, otherwise merchants wouldn't pay for it. But it's interesting that most people commenting here seem to loathe advertising. Can we really all be outliers?
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> Can we really all be outliers? Yes, absolutely. People who have something to complain about will often do that waaaaaay in excess of people who don’t. Compounded by HN tending to attract people who enjoy a text-only interface.
- tyfon 7y agoI've often tried to explain to marketeers at work that marketing to the wrong people will create negative sentiment and lower sales, but I can never get them to do any tests of it. It's all about having the maximum number of people to spam. Personally I'm trying to avoid products where the ads manage to penetrate my "firewall" either by breaking the law (DMs even if I am registered not to accept those), public space advertisement or email spam where I didn't sign up for it. Both the email spam and DMs are illegal to do here if you don't sign up for it so I report them all to the local authorities.
- LaundroMat 7y agoI am rooting for someone to find a way of making ad aversion measurable so that marketeers can finally take it into account.
- tyfon 7y agoI often get the feeling that they don't want to know this because it invalidates large parts of their work.
- Nasrudith 7y agoYeah - people look at me like I am crazy when I mention it but the marketing of the /advertiser/ is actually more relevant than the actual conversion rate given fuzzy attribution.
- bertil 7y agoFacebook and Google do that and try to limit showing ads to people who will care enough there’s a chance they’ll click it. Both have x-out options on every ad: feel free to use it, it helps training aversion models.
- tyfon 7y agoThey never have the reason I want, "I hate ads" ;) Maybe they changed that but I gave up on that strategy quite fast.
- catalogia 7y agoMost people don't categorically hate ads. They hate some ads, and really like other ads. Here is an ad, a movie trailer, that has 232 million views: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZfuNTqbHE8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZfuNTqbHE8 People voluntarily seek out some forms of advertisement and jump through hoops to avoid other forms of advertisement. The nature of the ad in question is a huge factor. If the ad industry has a problem, it's being bad at their jobs.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoAnother problem: GDPR more or less prevents tracking by requiring informed consent by the users.
- goatinaboat 7y agoHow is that a problem?
- bayesian_horse 7y agoFor the advertisers and those that rely on that revenue, this is definitely a problem. Without gathering information about users, targeting is a lot worse and ad revenue will generally decrease. I'm not saying I'm opposed, just stating this observation!
- dr_dshiv 7y agoWhy don't "they" ever ask what ads I want to see?
- cyborgx7 7y agoBecause the ads someone wants to see, like movie trailers or new products of interest to them, you go looking for yourself. The big tech and media conferences are viewed by a ton of people completely voluntarialy. The "value" of advertising next to things you are seeking out, is showing you things you don't have an active interest in seeing.
- criddell 7y agoAre there actually ads you want to see though? I guess around SuperBowl time there are some funny ads, but that's about it for me.
- sunstone 7y agoI don't hate ads. What I hate is when ads track everything I do and everywhere I go and then keep a running dossier of all that and sell that information to third parties. It's a complete breakdown of trust between a seller and a buyer.
- _ph_ 7y agoI don't hate ads. I hate to be tracked, I hate to be harrassed (blinking, flashing ads, inappropriate ads), I hate to be exposed by malware. There were times, when I actually liked ads - when they appeared in reputable magazines for specific topics, be they hifi, sports I have interes in or the national geographic magazine. They all were tasteful and actually interesting, as they were targetted. But not targetted by the stories some cookies seem to tell, but by the topic of the magazine. Much higher chance to show me something which actually interests me. The cardinal mistake was selling off add space to networks which would decide which ads to place instead of traditional add placement. And to be too greedy and overdo ads until they couldn't be tolerated any more. Bonus points in the almost globalized age: show me ads for things not available in my region.
- kop316 7y agoHear hear. I don't mind ads as a concept. I sign up for several email newsletters because I like seeing the ads and knowing what's going on. I have a Nintendo Switch, and I go to their "News" section to look at what new games are coming out. I hate that giving an inch for ads means tracking, malware, harassment, etc. I hate that I have to be skeptical to give any personal information to any company/institution, as 999/1000 its sold and used for ads. I hate that this is a wealth of information for people to steal and use for nefarious purposes.
- denton-scratch 7y agoI get that the capitalist system needs advertising, so that merchants can draw the public's attention to the existence of their product. But it's not acceptable for dozens of dodgy ads per page to crash my browser (so I use an ad-blocker). And it's not acceptable for fraudulent email spam to take up more space in my inbox than messages from friends and relatives: I've spent a lot of time over the last 20 years fine-tuning spam filters. Most of the phone calls I get seem to be from criminals, telling me that ISP X is about to close my account, when my provider is ISP Y. I haven't found a solution to that. Youtube ads seem to have become more frequent and longer in just the last few months. My response: avoid Youtube. TV ads: I pre-record and fast-forward. I don't understand why merchants and advertisers seem to think it helps their pitch to infuriate people. Perhaps if the advertising industry would get together to drive out these crooks, fraudsters and scammers, and perhaps not treat everything on the face of the earth as an advertising medium, the honest merchants might get a clearer run at their consumers. As far as I'm concerned, they missed the boat a long time ago - if you advertise at me without my permission, then I will remember your name and NEVER consider buying your product.
- rabidrat 7y ago> if you advertise at me without my permission, then I will remember your name and NEVER consider buying your product. Unfortunately it seems that their tactics work, because we subconsciously remember their name but then lose track of whether it was a positive or negative association. Plus when "everyone does it", it becomes impossible when actually shopping to reward those who don't do it, because they are indistinguishable from a fly-by-night/fraudulent brand. So everyone continues to advertise in the most obnoxious way possible and the noise floor is permanently raised.
- denton-scratch 7y agoWell, brands came about because merchants were adulterating everything - brick-dust in flour, that kind of nonsense. It was a lemon market - you had to adulterate to compete. A well-known brand was an assurance that "our stuff is OK". So you have to make your brand well-known, otherwise branding doesn't help. I get it. But covering everything in shouty ads isn't that - it's trying to manipulate people. If everyone would adopt my "NEVER consider" policy, the problem would be gone in six months.
- WilTimSon 7y agoFor me, the problem is that there are just a few categories of ads, each with their own problems. Video or audio ads (YouTube, popups, Spotify, etc.) - usually way too loud or too long (hey, listening to Judas Priest? Now check out 30 seconds of Ed Sheeran's new song), and seemingly totally random. Sidebar ads - usually something completely useless at best or outright spammy sometimes ("You're our 5000th customer, click to win!") Feed ads - Twitter, Instagram, other social media. These actually manage to offer things that I care about because they probably have good tracking algorithms. I've found that the few cases where I've actually paid attention to an ad or even, gasp, clicked on it were the feed ads. So, yeah, I hate the first two categories. Of course I do, they're absolutely useless and the first type is also intrusive. The catch is... I dislike the third kind as well. Because it leeches off of my privacy. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
- simplicio 7y agoI dunno. I'm indifferent to mildly annoyed by ads themselves. On the other hand, over my lifetime, I've probably consumed tens of thousands of hours of content and made use of countless services paid for by advertising that I'd be hard pressed to afford if I had to pay directly. So I guess I'm pretty strongly pro-ad, even if they're occasionally annoying. Plus I've gotten a decent chuckle out of some of those Geico ads.
- ololobus 7y agoIf we abstract away and understand that we are not representative here, then we realize that people actually love ads in general. Just take a look on some Instagram star profile with thousands of active followers, it is full of integrated ads and sponsored content. Then check some general/tech news, non-professional one, sponsored content sometimes is more than half of the whole website. So actually people hate those old-fashioned ad banners and pop-ups, but currently the advertising industry is more about integrating hidden ads everywhere and personalizing it as much as possible. That speaking, if you are not deeply into privacy and anonymity or just turn off you ads/track blocking stuff, then you will see how personal ads could be. They are not entirely correct, but more and more often I found them horrifyingly personal and targeted.
- m4r35n357 7y agoAt last, the truth emerges ;)
- AegirLeet 7y agoI do hate ads, but I don't hate them because they're irrelevant, not personalized enough, too silly, too frequent or anything like that. I hate advertising as a concept and nothing is going to change that. I don't care how much the advertising industry tries to adapt, it's not going to help. I just want that entire industry to stop existing and I know many people (especially young-ish people like me) who share that view.
- artsyca 7y agoThe worst is when an ASMR video lulls you into a sense of relaxation and vulnerability and a loud obnoxious ad suddenly obliterates you and sends your heart racing
- rolltiide 7y agoI like influencer marketing where people just do things because someone they are entertained by does it I was surprised at how effective that is for conversions Its been hilarious to watch grifters think they could do it just by having followers
- buboard 7y agoThe NYtimes may feel immune to advertising woes because they have a paywall now (even though they still make tons off advertising), but what is the paywall other than an obnoxious, loud, obstructive full page ad? I 'm glad to see they are tackling advertising itself though, rather than fabricating stories about social platforms. The ad industry seems to be very much lacking in real metrics, and seems to be particularly dumb in innovating, holding up appropriate standards and protecting their art.
- SaturateDK 7y agoI really do hate ads, and I've even worked doing ads both for web and TV. I want to pay for my services, and would like real micro transactions, maybe I read an article i really enjoyed - I want to be able to pay for this, as a donation. I'm pretty sure we need to look beyond ads for funding services and websites. I'd much rather pay, and while I know not everyone wants to pay... if we could push this behavior, it would really make the web better. Personally, I have adblockers, privacy badger and even AdGuard/PiHole on my network. So to all creators, let me pay you, even a tiny amount. I'm aware that transaction fees are en enemy here, so maybe that's a problem to fix?
- mschuster91 7y ago> So to all creators, let me pay you, even a tiny amount. I'm aware that transaction fees are en enemy here, so maybe that's a problem to fix? There are models for this (e.g. Blendle), however they suffer from the same problem as Spotify did and Netflix does: the content creators (newspapers, studios, labels) lose the direct connection to their audience and cannot upsell them any more or gather data about them. This is why newspapers employ massive amounts of trackers and why studios build their own crappy streaming service instead of licensing to Netflix. The only idea I see to fix this is regulatory: require rightholders to license their content under FRAND terms to aggregators. Otherwise the negative incentives of modern capitalism will block a user-friendly solution.
- werm82 7y agoI'm generally for heavier regulation vs. rampant capitalism, but regulating what media companies can & can't do with their content isn't the answer. That feels like it'd be heading down the path to a state run media.
- tzs 7y ago> So to all creators, let me pay you, even a tiny amount. I'm aware that transaction fees are en enemy here, so maybe that's a problem to fix? The bigger problem is taxes. A website getting paid directly by its viewers is selling something to each of those viewers, and has to worry about sales tax or VAT in every place those viewers reside. A website getting paid by selling ad space to ad networks generally only has to worry about taxes in the country it is in. The latter is orders of magnitude less of a pain than the former.
- novaRom 7y agoGoogle Business Model: "Get dominance on the market, establish a Monopoly" 1) Invest long-term, offer free attractive services, don't expect any profit during first several years 2) Implement locked-in methods 3) Wait until monopolic position secured and majority is locked into your free service 4) Start monetization and track feedback. Optimize to find perfect tolerance with long-term profit maximization as objective. 5) Enjoy! You are Monopoly.
- rchaud 7y agoThere should be a Step 0 to indicate that every product idea lives or dies on the degree to which it can be tied back into Google Ads.
- bump64 7y agoThis article has 5 ads on it, from the top and then every 3 paragraphs. The irony...
- SeanMacConMara 7y agoi hate ads i cant avoid seeing because my agency to do that has been subverted. i will attempt to acquire tools to avoid that in future. i dislike ads as 99.??% are effectively automated insults. "buy this or you are lessened" over my lifetime the ad industry has offered insult to me perhaps 100s of 1000s of times.
- the_snooze 7y agoI generally dislike online ads and block them aggressively, but there is one case where I tolerate (and even enjoy) them: podcast ads. Among the podcasts I listen to, their ads fit the context of the show, and the producers sometimes add their own entertaining twists to them (see: Reply All). This effort and editorial control make me feel respected as a consumer. The advertisers and producers have skin in the game in terms of their reputation. It’s also nice that this format doesn’t really allow for individual behavioral tracking.
- pontifier 7y agoThe problem is that ads are the reccomendation system for products and services, but the reccomendation algorithm is biased toward whoever pays the most to have their ad shown, not what might be the most most useful product or service for the person to see. This is fundamentally broken.
- ddingus 7y agoI will, on occasion, see an AD that runs on something of value, or that engages in some common sense advocacy. If you can figure out how to do either one better, faster, whatever, I do not mind those. And I remember who took the time to be considerate enough to create them too. Got nothing else. Hate inane ADS right along with everyone else.