40 ms·
My company sold for $100M and I got zilch – how can that be?
- xingped 7y agoIs there any good book for explaining all of these startup evaluation, fundraising, etc. terms, how they work, what to ask about, etc.?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIn no particular order: https://www.holloway.com/g/equity-compensation https://www.holloway.com/g/equity-compensation (The Holloway Guide to Equity Compensation) https://gist.github.com/jdmaturen/5830b83c1425c4767f7e1bd4c9561718 https://gist.github.com/jdmaturen/5830b83c1425c4767f7e1bd4c9... (Who pays when startup employees keep their equity?) https://gist.github.com/yossorion/4965df74fd6da6cdc280ec57e83a202d https://gist.github.com/yossorion/4965df74fd6da6cdc280ec57e8... (What I Wish I'd Known About Equity Before Joining A Unicorn) https://gigaom.com/2011/06/05/5-mistakes-you-cant-afford-to-make-with-stock-options/ https://gigaom.com/2011/06/05/5-mistakes-you-cant-afford-to-... (5 Mistakes You Can’t Afford to Make with Stock Options) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2623777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2623777 (Bookmarked comment by /u/grellas about above article/thread) https://web.mit.edu/tytso/www/OPTIONS-HOWTO/OPTIONS-HOWTO.html https://web.mit.edu/tytso/www/OPTIONS-HOWTO/OPTIONS-HOWTO.ht... (Startup Stock Options Tax How To) https://smile.amazon.com/Venture-Deals-Smarter-Lawyer-Capitalist/dp/1119594820/ https://smile.amazon.com/Venture-Deals-Smarter-Lawyer-Capita... (Venture Deals: Be Smarter Than Your Lawyer and Venture Capitalist)
- SparksZilla 7y agoAndy from Holloway here. Our equity comp. guide is 100% free. We also have a Guide on Raising Venture Capital (340 pages). We made sure to include an entire chapter on "Assessing Whether to Raise," which includes sections on alternatives to VC and how VCs can control your company. If anyone on here wants to buy it, you can get a 25% discount on it using this link: https://www.holloway.com/rvc?vip_code=VIP25 https://www.holloway.com/rvc?vip_code=VIP25
- seeadot 7y agoQuick thanks for making the equity comp guide free! It's come at the perfect time for me. I'm also on the wait list for the tech recruiting guide and will be happily purchasing it when it's available. Great stuff you guys are doing!
- SparksZilla 7y agoYou heard it first here: Technical Recruiting and Hiring is coming out November 19th =)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tych0 7y agoDan Luu has a pretty good writeup on the various ways you can get screwed :) https://danluu.com/startup-options/ https://danluu.com/startup-options/
- x0x0 7y agoVery briefly: for employees to have a good outcome, the company must be a success relative to the funding. I'd love to say that founders are in the same boat as employees, but it's not true. Unethical founders can engineer situations where they alone get millions of dollars and no other employees do. That can be somewhat justifiable (eg taking $1m or something off the table in a round B for a company that eventually fails), or it can be poisonous (Adam from wework getting north of a billion in cash for a company that will probably go bankrupt). With respect to the article: $100m exit on $10m funding? Employees should do well. $100m exit on $110m funding? You can't expect a good outcome for the employees in that case. They may get some sort of retention bonus in an acquisition, but that's about it. Another thing all employees should know is that, as a rule of thumb, you need to triple your valuation between funding rounds. That is not as true late, ie when you have enormous $100m + rounds that are raised in lieu of going public with more of a debt structure than an investment structure. You should be skeptical of companies that have raised too much money. Eg if a company raises a $100m round B, they are basically saying their metrics have to justify a multibillion dollar valuation. Anyway, there's a bunch of good links, but (and I'm a company founder), I'd tell you to keep a couple crucial things in mind: First, don't work for dodgy founders. I understand that's not easy for you to evaluate, but there are ways you can figure out. eg have the founders hired lots of people they're previously worked with? That's a good sign. Second, if you want a good outcome, the company must be growing. At a startup, you are comped on growth. You should be unafraid to fire founders and execs (by quitting) that are unable to grow the company. That's not to say quit at the first rough patch, but every year when you are deciding if you re-up for another year or not, you should evaluate the metrics over the last year. Third, understand the runway and the metrics that get you the next round or an exit. Be unafraid to demand to know all the above, and expect positive performance on all those things.
- thekingofh 7y ago"they're previously worked with? That's a good sign." As in good, or bad?
- code_duck 7y agoI think the intent to say is that if people they previously worked with are willing to work with them again, that is positive because it shows that previous employees/partners haven't been screwed over.
- gk1 7y agoI found Consider Your Options (by Kaye A. Thomas) helpful and easy to understand.
- floatrock 7y agoA few years ago I made a visualization of vc math: http://dlopuch.github.io/venture-dealr http://dlopuch.github.io/venture-dealr Predates KISS's and SAFE's and the round sizes are a bit out of date, but the you-get-nothing scenarios like liquidation preferences and down rounds are still the same.
- badrequest 7y agoAs a normal individual contributor not at the C-level or even management level, I just assume the value of any options/shares I receive is zero unless an accountant or the IRS tells me I should believe otherwise. Too many goofy fine-print shenanigans like this to keep track of.
- ng12 7y ago> the IRS tells me I should believe otherwise If you have NSOs (or pay AMT) the IRS will happily lie to you about the true value of your options.
- x0x0 7y agoThis doesn't sound like shenanigans. Reading between the lines: > While it hasn’t ended up becoming the unicorn I was hoping for it sounds like the company wasn't a success. It could be the preference overhang, or it could be a difficult acquisition. Fundamentally, if the company isn't a success relative to the funding, employees aren't going to get paid. Employees can get paid quite well on a $100m exit if eg the funding structure was correct for the exit size.
- pc86 7y agoUnicorn refers only to a billion dollar startup, and they sold it for 1/10 of that.
- x0x0 7y agoRight, but my guess is people start talking about being a unicorn probably means they did a unicorn-sized funding round. So total raised is comfortably north of $0.1B.
- badrequest 7y agoI don't mean shenanigans as a cutesy word for fraud (and to be completely fair, the author touched on how this is something the industry needs to improve at), but I merely mean that the explanation provided to most workers is "you own X number of shares in the company that are currently valued at Y", and anything missing from that summary that makes it untrue is, well, shenanigans to me.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fqw3b58w4n6 7y agoI understood none of those words.
- loblollyboy 7y agoThat's the point
- cj 7y agoLiquidation Preference. In very simple terms: "Liquidation Preference" is an agreement between a company and an investor that when the company is acquired or IPOs, the company will pay the investor some specific amount of money BEFORE any other shareholders get paid. If the company negotiated the funding well, the liquidation preference might be 1x (basically saying the company promises to pay back, in full, the investor's original investment if the company is ever sold) Things get scary when the liquidation preference creeps up to 2x, 3x, or higher. It's possible to raise $5mm with a 3x liquidation preference... which means that the investor will get $15mm payout BEFORE any other shareholders in the event of an exit (which means that, after raising that $5mm, the company can not have an exit less than $15mm without 100% all the proceeds going to the original investors). Raising $5mm with a 3x liquidation preference, then selling your company for $15mm, is an easy example of how (even founders) can walk away with $0 after a $15mm sale.
- ethanjinsen 7y agoSo in your example, the investors are basically getting a 300% return if the company sells for 15M or more?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jusben1369 7y agoYep. They're locking in their upside to offset for the risk they see in putting in $5 million. 3x preferred is either a weak founder with a good company or more likely an ok founder desperate for funding and therefore pretty high risk for the investor.
- bdcravens 7y agoYes.
- aetherson 7y agoIn my opinion: Liquidation preference of 1x (or lower) is just sensible alignment of investor and founder incentives. The investor wants to make sure that if they buy 20% of the company for $5M, the founders aren't now incented to take advantage of them (in an extreme example: the day after the fundraising, liquidating the company for its assets, taking home $4M themselves and handing the investor back $1M. In a less extreme example, selling the company (in toto) for $10M a year or two later). Liquidation preference of higher than 1x is a whole different thing. It's, at its most benign, something kind of like a financial instrument a little more like debt than stock, trading a more-guaranteed return for a lower price, or at its most pernicious, basically an attempt to create false impressions of a company's value. If you sell stock with a x3 liquidation preference, that is deeply different, and conveys considerably less investor confidence, than selling the same stock at the same price with x1 liquidation preference, but the press releases get to not mention the preference.
- jpeg_hero 7y agoYeah, if your company raises $200m and your sell for $100m you don’t make any money.
- jammygit 7y agoI feel like legal manipulation is very bad for the startup ecosystem. Even here, at the YC forums, people assume their startup equity is worth $0 and advise you to go with a FAANG (or day that they broke even with friends at faangs after their exits). How is a legitimate startup supposed to recruit the best people under these conditions?
- paulgb 7y agoBy being transparent and giving all the numbers needed for the employee to make a good decision. For what it's worth, I've always valued options at private companies as zero in making career decisions and looking back I don't think that heuristic ever steered me wrong (even at a company that is now a "unicorn")
- foobiekr 7y agofrom experience: I am very big on transparency and honesty and while that feels good and no one ends up surprised, the problem you run into is that other companies are not particularly honest or transparent. I would not change what we did (which was basically full disclosure) but it was challenging to deal with.
- microtherion 7y agoWould a sensible compromise be to disclose anything that you would have to disclose if you were a public company instead of a private one?
- ElKrist 7y agoThe legal complexity of all the equity structures possible seems way too daunting anyway. Passionate young programmers who want to work for a startup don't have the background to understand it, even if the raw information is given when signing up. Plus, you have no idea what the next round of funding will do to the equity structure... Isn't it time for regulation to limit this complexity?
- landryraccoon 7y ago
- gshakir 7y agoMy former company got acquired for $150 million after raising $87 million. I am not expecting anything. If at all I can expect a tax write off for the shares that I bought
- nostrademons 7y agoThis matters more now that the current crop of tech companies have taken so much money. In the old days, when software companies sold software rather than traditional services enhanced by software, it was common to get to profitability around the B round and then never take any more investment after that. Google took $25-35M and then nothing until IPO, running the company from 2001-2004 off cashflow. Microsoft took nothing except a small mezzanine round (to align incentives with the I-bankers) right before IPO. Github took a $50M Series A on a valuation of $500M; VCs owned 10% of the company, and the 3 founders + employees split the remaining 90% of its $7.5B acquisition. Indeed took a Series A and is profitable. Atlassian took a $60M Series A 8 years after starting the company, when it was already profitable. PlentyOfFish, HotOrNot, Reddit, Wufoo all raised either nothing or just angel money before being acquired. When you're capital efficient, you get to keep the majority of any sale price. The current crop of unicorns like Uber, Lyft, WeWork, Postmates, DoorDash, Instacart, AirBnB, and Stripe have all taken massive amounts of capital though, sometimes in the multi billions of dollars. That has to be returned to the investors before the common shares (founders & employees) make anything. If they hit on hard times before a liquidity event, there's a good chance that the common will be wiped out, and investors effectively own the company. Why shouldn't they, when they put up all the money that the company's been burning?
- a13n 7y agoIt's also interesting to consider the role SoftBank has played in this shift. Whoever takes SoftBank money will have the deepest pockets and will be able to play hard against competition. This means you're pretty much forced to either take SoftBank's money, or compete against someone else with SoftBank's money. They don't care much who takes their money, because either way they have the most funded pony in the race.
- cortesoft 7y agoIn certain fields, sure... but even SoftBank isn't investing in EVERY market. Not everyone has a SoftBank funded competitor.
- 7y ago
- deogeo 7y agoA lot of words to say something very simple - information asymmetry via contractual complexity is being abused to profit those writing the contracts.
- harryh 7y agoWhat information asymmetry? Liquidation preferences are perfectly fair, and not at all a mystery. Especially in the year 2019 when there has been an enormous amount written about them on the internet.
- deogeo 7y agoThe parasites writing these contracts are counting on people not taking the time to become experts in shady startup contracts. As evidenced by this article, it's working.
- harryh 7y agoThe contracts in question aren't shady in the majority of cases. Again, liquidation preferences are perfectly fair.
- ElKrist 7y agoHonest question here: as an employee (non-founder) do you have a say in liquidation preferences of future rounds of investment?
- harryh 7y agoIt depends on whether your role in the company means that you are part of negotiating the deal. If you are the CEO: then probably yes. If you're an IC engineer: then probably not. Relatedly, most of these deal terms are pretty standardized. In the vast majority of cases there aren't a lot of negotiations around liquidation preferences, only negotiations around valuations. The exceptions to the rule tend to happen for very large or late stage fundraises.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- a13n 7y agoBecause your company raised money from VCs. This will never happen at a bootstrapped company.
- drtillberg 7y agoFrom a 40,000 foot view, it's odd that employees who are investing their professional effort are relegated to a lower equity tier. I think the person asking the question in the article makes a valid point: why is it fair for human capital to be devalued in this way?
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoBecause that is how investing and capitalism works. The man who has the capital, wins. Always.
- harryh 7y agoIt's not odd at all. If you start a company and you turn $200 million of investment into an exit of $100 million dollars you haven't done anything valuable. Why would you expect your stock to be worth anything?
- lostdog 7y agoWhy should investors expect their full investment back when they did a bad job choosing who to invest in? I don't think it's reasonable to pretend that the current system exists because it's the fairest. Investors exert more negotiating power than employees, and that's the reason they get better terms.
- harryh 7y agoIf my example (turning $200 million into $100 million) the investors don't get their full investment back. They lose half of it. But I get your point. And yes, it has something to do with leverage. But I also assert that the current system is better for common shareholders as well. The idea that we could have a slightly different world in which investors acted exactly as they did today, but bought common shares instead of preferred shares is clearly wrong. If they're buying common instead of preferred then valuations would drop significantly. Probably by over 50%. This means that either companies would be giving away much larger %s of themselves when fundraising or they would be raising much less capital (which is of course used to pay the salaries of all those common shareholders). Both are probably bad for common stockholders in most cases. Which is why we see very few companies ever do this.
- tempsy 7y agoEven as a very early employee (say number 20) of a unicorn probably will not make that much...you'd be lucky to get $2M if it sold for $1B... Most people are better off just working at a big company if they want to build wealth.
- notimetorelax 7y agoThat’s what I thought. The OP was hoping to receive 1mm for 4 years of work. VP role will give that easy in any sizable company.
- nikanj 7y agoMuch easier to become a senior programmer at a 3-person startup than a VP at a sizable company.
- charwalker 7y agoWhich is partially why the VP makes several times more at a stable firm vs options/stock/equity that are a lottery ticket, more or less. The VP won't get paid if the company sells but they can by a new car each year.
- alecbenzer 7y ago$1M over 4 years is L4 at Google. https://www.levels.fyi/salary/Google/SE/L4/ https://www.levels.fyi/salary/Google/SE/L4/ edit: Oh, well I guess that's not counting the startup's salary. If they were getting paid $200k/yr, that's L6 at Google https://www.levels.fyi/salary/Google/SE/L6/ https://www.levels.fyi/salary/Google/SE/L6/. Less easy, but not as hard as getting to VP.
- vonseel 7y agoThere should be a simpler way. All this crap is too complicated. Even if you manage to somehow do the research and understand it well at some point, unless your working with options grants on a regular basis, you'll probably forget it all before you ever leave the company. People don't have time to do all this stuff and not get fucked over.
- harryh 7y agoIt's not that complicated. If a company exists for less money than the amount invested in the company then common stock is worth nothing. If it exists for more than the amount invested then common stock will (almost always) be worth something. If you exit for 3X the amount invested you've done allright and will generally see a modest return on your stock. If you exit for 10X the amount invested you've done real good and will generally see a pretty good return on your stock. If you're smart enough to learn how to code, you're smart enough to understand this stuff. I promise.
- ElKrist 7y agoAgreed. Even if you get all the information when signing up at an early-stage startup, you have no idea what the founders will negotiate in future rounds
- Florin_Andrei 7y ago> All this crap is too complicated. If it was simpler, regular folks would figure out it's just a scam. You're naive if you think there's any other reason for all this.
- mark-r 7y agoOne thing to remember is that the acquirer has probably done this before while the acquiree is a first-timer. The details are almost certainly going to favor the party with the most experience. I once worked for a company that was acquired. At the first all-hands meeting after the acquisition closing, the CEO was practically gloating about how cheaply he was able to get us. All because he knew how to structure the deal in a way that wasn't transparent to our company owner.
- buzzdenver 7y agoYour company should have retained investment bankers. Just like you get a lawyer to represent you in court.
- jacquesm 7y agoProbably not a company with any professional investors on board.
- mark-r 7y agoCorrect. The founder probably retained 90% or more of the stock, its growth was completely organic. I was very lucky to be part of it.
- jacquesm 7y agoIf there is one way a small shareholder can ensure that they are going to be treated well it is to see to it that they hold the exact same kind of stock as a much larger shareholder. That way a bigger fish will fight for your rights with a lot more power than you ever could do by yourself. There are then still quite a few ways in which you could be screwed but far fewer than without that precaution.
- einarvollset 7y agoIndeed. This is also why you should make sure any equity you get in the acquirer as part of the deal is as high up the preference stack as possible.
- altmind 7y agoI highly recommend reading Venture Deals by Brad Feld - this book alone lays out perfectly how minuscule are your chances of getting rich, working for a startup. The areas to lose money are: liquidation preferences, insuficient voting rights, dilution, different stock classes, general benefits to investor's equity compared to staff equity, investor drag-along, 409A valuation, options expiration or company staying private forever.
- Balgair 7y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Venture-Deals-Smarter-Lawyer-Capitalist/dp/1119594820 https://www.amazon.com/Venture-Deals-Smarter-Lawyer-Capitali... Book is here
- qaq 7y agoBasically if you are working at startup value your options at 0 and you will be right 99% of the time.
- harryh 7y agoIf anyone reading this is working at a startup and values their options at zero please get in contact with me (contact info in my profile) and we'll find a way for you to sell me your equity for $1.
- mamon 7y agoAnd if the seller in turn uses your $1 to buy a lottery ticket you both would have roughly equal chance of getting rich :)
- harryh 7y agoI think that you are wrong and am demonstrating that with my willingness to put my money where my mouth is.
- qaq 7y agoA person working at startup will take a fairly decent haircut for those options. You valuing it $1 pretty much proves my point :).
- Canada 7y agoAre you really putting your money where your mouth is? Even if I have shares I think are worthless, your offer to buy them is also worthless, so why bother? Actually, your offer is worse than nothing, as I would spend hours dealing with the share purchase agreement without assurance you will follow through and it would send a clear signal to the company that pays me that I believe it's worthless.
- Aloha 7y agoThis is why I've been saying for years that stock grants/options/RSUs are like playing the lotto, and salary/benefits are more important. Particularly when dealing with privately held firms where you have no ability to sell on the open market. They're also a tool to keep people in roles they no longer want, because of a promise of a great payoff someday.
- CalChris 7y agoHeidi Roizen, VC, most definitely does not feel Former Millionaire's pain. Yes, liquidation preference overhang is the mechanism. However, the company got sold for $100M. Who sold the company? The founders + the VCs and they got theirs. They could have structured the deal to give the employees something. They didn't. The advice here is simple. Walk. Former Millionaire owes absolutely nothing to the new company. Staying rewards this screwjob. If the founders + VCs want this Engineering VP to stay then they have to pay the VP to stay. This could have been handled better if the founders and VCs had left something on the table for the workers. That was a choice they made.
- jariel 7y agoBetter yet: get everyone to walk. Forget unions - just say: "We get a payout or we're all leaving and your $100M investment is immediately worthless". If it fails and they call your bluff, of course you're going to have a hard time getting a job elsewhere unfortunately. I wonder the best way to mitigate such situations without simply having to rely on VC/Founder goodwill. YC was a leader in their 'clean terms SAFE' which really helped set a 'good standard' for all parties that was a win-win all around, I wonder if there's such a policy framework that could facilitate the same in these situations. YC's concerns in their 'SAFE' situation was balancing VC<->Founder, not employees, that said, Sam Altman has always talked about sharing more equity with other team members.
- nostrademons 7y agoShe mentions this in the article - most deals are structured with carve-outs so that specifically those employees you want to stay get multi-million payouts (over multiple years) as long as they stay with the employer. If there was no such carve-out for the VP, it means the acquirer doesn't want them. The answer is still "walk", but the acquirer is not going to care. The reason to walk is that there's no sense staying in a job where your employer doesn't want you and isn't going to reward you. It's for your own self-respect, not to stick it to the man.
- CalChris 7y agoI'm going to plead guilty to giving up after I saw the preference overhang thrust of the article. She in fact gives a good outline of the issues involved. Maybe I had Travis Kalanick and Adam Neumann in the back of my mind. Still the element of unfairness about is that Certain key employees were incentivized with a “ carve-out “ in order to stay through the transaction and make sure it would happen. Using the example, four years is a long time to be rewarded with squat. However, Roizen also points out that common stock is priced lower than preferred. Usually someone like an engineering VP or a senior contributor will figure things out well before that and bail. The idea that this was somehow a surprise is difficult to accept. Yes, it is definitely for your own self respect.
- antiviral 7y agoI have found that in job negotiations, many startup founders are highly reluctant to discuss what the value of their stock option grant is worth, much less what other conditions may impact the payout. Has anyone else had this experience and what do they advise others to do when faced with the dilemma of turning down an offer due to a lack of transparency into the option grant?
- sjg007 7y agoYep very little transparency. Ask these questions!! Don’t take the job? Take another job? Hope that the company will IPO? Or that an IPO is the path?
- antiviral 7y agoGood advice. However, from a negotiation POV, it’s difficult since there are so many alternative people who only ask how many shares they will get, and think that more shares is better than less, rather than what they are worth. It’s comical. This makes it easy to just pick one of those people and skip the few who know what’s going on. For a founder or VC, this is like free money, since you can promise whatever you want ( 100 zillion shares) and pay them whatever is convenient. Eventually, this will erode the trust needed for Silicon Valley to work.
- harryh 7y agoThis is actually a great heuristic. Good founders (and companies) will be very transparent about how all this stuff works. Bad founders (and companies) will not. If a company that is trying to recruit you is squirrely about this stuff, it's definitely a vote in the direction of walking away.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThere's no dilemma. Just do it. The best way to get information about this is to ask you question and then shut up. You'll get a BS answer first. Just sit there and don't say anything. Most people break down after 30 seconds and give up more information. The longer you keep your mouth shut the more you receive. It's totally OK to say 'this doesn't seem like such a great deal.' Don't answer questions about what you want - just reply that you don't know enough about their financials to know what they could agree to, only what you can agree to. If it starts going round in circles, think of it as a preview of future experience and decide whether you want to be in that position.
- tibbon 7y agoWhat questions (specifically) should have this person asked upfront when having their options offer prior to employment? What should have they asked long the way to check on when there were fundraising rounds?
- qroshan 7y agoYou'll almost never get preferred shares unless you at C-level or put your own money. The only thing you negotiate is more salary in cash and assume your options are just lottery tickets with very high odds
- denton-scratch 7y agoI feel for you. I don't know how old you are, but my guess is that you are young, and you get another shot. Don't be dismayed. Try again. $100M is an awful lot of money - I'd consider $1M to be a lot. I I understand that you got zilch, and if I were you, I'd be angry too. But you seem to be clever - get over it, and have another go. /me just another employee. Never been an entrepreneur. Not smart enough.
- tabtab 7y agoIs there a benefit in asking to get "paid" in both preferred stock and regular stock to spread the risk out? It seems "preferred" stock is really "preferred but with lots of dangerous caveats" stock.
- jacquesm 7y agoThat's a nice answer but the question really needed a lot more information for it to be the right answer. There are quite a few ways in which small shareholders can get screwed, this article illustrates just one of them and quite possibly not the one that bit the questioner.
- appleiigs 7y agoThis is exactly my thought. The author is just guessing. There are 95 comments here, and they are just guessing too. The real reason of why the employee got zilch would be found by just reading the documentation - the legal agreements awarding the stock options, the purchase and sale agreements, incorporation docs...
- jacquesm 7y agoThere is some chance that the questioner doesn't even exist and that question was just written to be able to write the article in response to it.
- harryh 7y agoI very strongly believe this to be the case. The details don't feel right. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21359698 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21359698
- qroshan 7y agoThe author who has probably done these deals probably knows the most common occurrence and went with it?
- testfoobar 7y agoAs a former founder, I am often surprised by the incredible spend at some startups I've visited. The biggest is headcount - so many fluff jobs. How many designers does an early stage startup really need? 1, 2, 10, 20, 50? How many SREs do you need when your site is just a handful of AWS instances? How many sales people do you need when your product isn't ready for sale yet? Each employee fully loaded in the bay area is what like $150-$300K? 20 people like that will chew through your Series A before you know what happened. Bad (for startups) deals get done when you start running out of runway. Once you're out of runway, you'll sign a 4x liquidation preference at a low valuation because it gets you an infusion of cash now. Now the VCs own you.
- dmix 7y agoInstagram had what, 12 employees when it got bought for 1 billion? I worked for a small company that fired half the employees (10->5, mostly marketing/sales execs) and absolutely nothing changed. Our revenue actually increased over the next year, not to mention gross sales not paying those salaries. We were originally going to replace them but decided to wait it out for a full year because we realized we didn't need them. They were all expert busy-workers, who used to try hard when they first joined but got lazy about 2yrs in and started phoning it in. Startups and small businesses have no time for those types of people. The other massive expense VC-backed companies waste money on are high-paid consultants (and lawyers) from the big business corporatey world.
- draw_down 7y ago> Instagram had what, 12 employees when it got bought for 1 billion? Which was really a pittance. I acknowledge hindsight is 20/20, but it's interesting to see posts here lamenting that startups hire too many people, when selling for much too little is surely a more grievous financial mistake. Or to put it another way, if they had 75 engineers when they sold for a billion, the tragedy would still not be that they had too many engineers.
- farrarstan 7y agoYeah that is really too bad.
- z3t4 7y agoCheck what the owners got, and if they got any payout with the 50% dilution event. If the owners also got nothing, then the investors took it all. But if the owners got say $50 from the deal and you got nothing for your 2% you got screwed.
- kovek 7y agoWhy is it that the common shares holders are not properly informed that a certain investment round basically reduced their cash-out to 0? The incentives to invest more time into the company is greatly reduced. The person affected who is asking to Heidi said that they were working very hard, considering that they owned 1% of the shares of the company.
- jdjjdflknfjj 7y agoIt sounds like an easy way to screw holders of common stock out of their money. Don't they have any protection at all? Like at least, does the agreement for "liquidation preference" have to be reasonable (like, they could go to court and challenge it, and the company would have to prove that it was a necessary deal)?
- qroshan 7y agoEmployees that are paid common stock didn't put any money. They are also paid decent salary. It is like playing a lottery, but only with opportunity cost. Not sure what needs to be protected here.
- alecbenzer 7y ago> Employees that are paid common stock didn't put any money. > It is like playing a lottery, but only with opportunity cost. So, they did put in money. It's "opportunity cost" money as opposed to literal cash, but logically it's still value being invested in the company (the company has $X more in the bank because the employee was willing to take a $X pay cut). Compared to VCs, engineers are making a lot more of an investment in terms of % of their potential value for a less favorable return. I think VCs get better terms because A) they control an amount of capital that's rarer and have more leverage, B) they do this professionally and are better at negotiating things. But probably mostly A?
- campfireveteran 7y agoThis is why founders and employees should form worked-owned co-ops rather than be slaves to investors. If they absolutely need funding, look for angels, loans, convertible notes or ways to build slowly without giving away control to vampires.
- jdjjdflknfjj 7y agoI'm not convinced that is true. If they accepted a lower salary with the promise of stock options, they paid money. I thought it was common for startups to pay employees in stocks rather than money.
- bitL 7y agoFor anyone thinking about working for startups: - don't treat verbal agreements seriously - common stock is 99.9% worthless, you want preferred stock - liquidation preference is important, if company doesn't want to tell you, insist on market-rate salary - if a company tries to switch from an LLC to C-Corp and move you from being a minority owner of LLC (0.1-3%) into a common-stock owner of a C-Corp with the same %, block/sue them; you were working for thieves
- theNJR 7y agoIn what universe is an employee getting preferred? Or do you mean, be an investor instead of an employee?
- bitL 7y agoSome companies tend to "promise" that. Then of course "rescind the offer".
- brownkonas 7y agoIt's fine to want preferred stock, but it's pretty rare for employees to ever receive it (unless they put up cash) -- it's reserved for investors to avoid a sandbagging + abscond with the money raised scenario.
- Conan_Kudo 7y agoAnd employees deserve to be sandbagged? That seems monumentally unfair...
- bitL 7y agoHe who has the money sets the rules(tm) :shrug:
- mlyle 7y agoPreferred stock (and specifically, liquidity preferences-- the common 1x, nonparticipating term) exists to ensure that if investors put in $10M for 20% of a company, you don't immediately sell the company for $10M and give them $2M back, and split $8M among yourselves. The deal is structured so that the investors have their option of either getting their original money returned or their share of the proportional share of the returns.
- rb808 7y agoblah blah options blah preferred blah series A/B/C blah blah The real reason they got shafted is that they weren't important enough or they didnt follow what is going on. If you have a $1m asset you shouldn't be hoping its OK when there are so many sharks in the building. Yeah it would be nice if you could trust management and VCs but you can't.
- hogFeast 7y agoThis is going to happen more and more often. Companies chased jazzy valuations, they made crazy deals, and now values are starting to drop (and stuff like liquidation preferences come into play). I know of a company that was sold for $1bn+ and common equity got almost zero. It happens, it is a very silly thing to angry about though (because the valuation was never $1bn+).
- harel 7y agoThis is why, for me, VC money is a last resort and an admission of defeat of sorts. If my business cannot be a business, i.e., an entity that earn's it's keep and makes profit, then maybe it's not meant to be. VC money might prolong it's life, but at that point, they are the real owners of this "entity".
- charwalker 7y agoWith that, the founders/core group can deploy VC cash injections to stay paid and in charge vs closing shop. Quitting can be really hard for highly driven people or those thinking their idea is going to work even when the numbers say it isn't making money. There's an incentive mismatch then for them to pursue VC funding and keep going while employees with stock won't notice their probably worthless options becoming definitely worthless options or at best a bonus when all is sold. Like my own performance/holiday bonus at a stable firm, options are nice and possibly count toward total compensation but aren't hard cash and should not be relied upon as an investment or in your budget. Bird in hand and all that.
- harel 7y agoI decline any offer that puts equity instead of pay. Options, equity etc. is worthless. The only way it's statistically worth anything is if it's your business. On a side note, I wish Pud would revive fuckedcompany.com (with the last snapshot of the db before it went down). It's still relevant.
- harryh 7y agoFWIW, I kind of don't believe that this question is real. Questioner clams that he is a VP but also: > He has no idea how liquidation preferences work > He was "told" that the company was being acquired (instead of being involved in the sale) > No one at the company walked him through how his stock was valued, even after the acquisition. To the point that he thinks he needs to hire a lawyer. It's a fine question to use as a lead in to explaining how stock options work, and that's a fine thing to write about. But I'd bet money that the author made up the question.
- kevinskii 7y agoIt could be. But small companies often give their employees inflated titles, where a "VP" is actually a small team lead with no executive responsibilities.
- IggleSniggle 7y agoExactly. The entirety of the company roster could easily be 5 people and still have someone with a title like that.
- xpWr7r1ZeX 7y agoTitles are usually based on area of responsibility, at a small company you may have a small number people or no people but still have the responsibility... it's just enough for one person to handle. So it's not bad to have a VP of Engineering only manage 4 ppl.... but if everyone things a VP of Engineering is the same at small or large companies that's uninformed of reality. Title inflation helps recruit... so add that on to this as well and it's confusing. Not saying it's right, but that's how it is. Actually, there is immense title inflation at large companies as well, just depends which company and field. Have you seen the number of VPs in the Finance industry in NYC?
- blihp 7y agoThe title is not a meaningful gauge of a person's knowledge or experience. It wouldn't be unheard of for a VP at a company with 50 employees to have similar responsibilities as a manager at a company with 1000 employees. They could also be VP of Engineering/Customer Service/etc. which would typically not be expected to have much, if any, legal or finance knowledge.
- persistent 7y agoThis is why you should get a proper salary even if you are working at a "hot startup". Were you expecting a $1m gross payout from owning 1% of a $100m company? That's the kind of gross income you'd get every 2 years of working at Googbookagramazon. Consider opportunity costs carefully.
- librish 7y agoThis article is really weird, because the person in Dogpatch says they were granted OPTIONS not stock. So it's possible that this doesn't even touch on liquidation preferences and the strike price was just higher than the sale price. But if we assume that this was RSUs, or that the strike price was just a fraction of the sale price, I still think the common advice of "consider start-up equity to be worthless" is a little overzealous. Unless the founders accepted some outrageous terms it's probably the case that your options are worth a lot in a company that's doing well. If the company stops growing or takes a down round that's when you should start thinking of your shares as useless.
- waynecochran 7y agoThis is the sentence that is the core reason: "if you raised more than your company is now being sold for, you will get nothing"
- pgrote 7y agoHow does owning the 1% stock that doesn't get a pay out when the purchase occurs affect taxes? Do you have to pay taxes on the perceived value of the 1%? Can you consider it a loss?
- harryh 7y agoQuestioner probably owned options for which he paid no money. Therefore there is no loss. Nor is there a gain on which they owe taxes.
- dgudkov 7y agoOK, what I understood from the article is that the guy owned 1% not of the company's acquisition price (as he thought), but 1% from (price - X) where X was unknown and turned out to be greater or equal to the price. The fact that he didn't realize it until the very end makes the author's advise very correct - "make sure you understand exactly what you own".
- peterlk 7y agoI have had this conversation with so many people now. If your (private) company has taken VC money, options are toilet paper. Treat them as valueless scraps. Now, maybe you'll get lucky, and make something off of them, but that should be a pleasant surprise, not an expectation. Cash is king. If you're in it for the money, go work at MegaCorp, and take a sizeable, steady paycheck.
- joekrill 7y ago> Again, let me emphasize, this is not inherently unfair. I guess our definitions of what is "unfair" are quite different. I think a better term here would be "illegal". It's most certainly not illegal - but I definitely would not consider it fair. Companies throw options at employees - or potential employees - like candy. They imply, explicitly or not, that when the company gets big and successful, these options are going to be worth tons of money. Most of us here know they're probably worthless. But executives/entrepreneurs/whoever most definitely suggest otherwise. So it's more like false advertising. Now is that "fair"? I don't personally think so. I think it's pretty dishonest. I think when sale time comes around, they most certainly realize that these employees think they're finally going to cash in, and they are more than happy to let them think, even though they know otherwise. Obviously there are exceptions. There are occasions where they actually do end up being worth something. Or where the seniors folks are very clear about how worthless these things actually are. But, in my opinion at least, those are most definitely the exception to the rule. I'm also pretty cynical for the most part, too. So there's that.
- alteria 7y agoWhen I received my most recent startup offer, I was handed a spreadsheet that outlined the size of my option, and what they would be worth under multiple hypothetical scenarios, including highly-optimistic >400M and >3B valuations. While it was nice for them to do the math for me, I do think that the scenarios presented were misleading and only represent the case where everything goes exceptionally well. Now they did caveat that these were based off of assumptions, and that I should consult my own professional advisers etc etc. But, they didn't name any of the factors that could significantly impact returns (liquidation preference, participation, caps, etc.).
- RandallBrown 7y agoI received something similar with my last offer, but it also included the caveat that the shares are currently completely worthless unless we have some sort of exit, which probably wouldn't be happening in the short term. It was pretty refreshing.
- 7y ago
- heyflyguy 7y agoI just love reading this on the day I signed my options package.
- randyrand 7y agorenegotiate. “though I’ve signed my offer I’m having second thoughts about joining” If they want you, they’ll talk.
- moron4hire 7y agoThe comment on "founders getting offended when asked about the preferred overhang" is a point I think that is getting missed. Yes, there is the whole "caveat emptor" of being an equity employee, but there is clearly a culture of hiding all of the necessary information for making an informed decision. In a lot of ways, I think the over-emphasis on "startups change the world" has been a contribution to this. There is a greater supply of people who "want to work in a startup" (or rather, think they like the whatever idea they have in their head of what a startup means) than there is demand for early stage employees. So any founders who might have something to hide will have their pick of people to fleece. They can easily pass on anyone who asks the the probing questions about the real value of the company and just wait for a shmuck to come along who doesn't ask. What can we do to educate the general populace enough to dry up that pool of shmucks? In the long run, the way things are has to be terrible for investors, too. They put their money into founders who aren't being up front with their employees, and probably not getting the best employees because of it.
- riazrizvi 7y agoSimply, the 1% ‘shares’ were actually shares in a company that only begins existing if the company you worked for surpasses some value $X. Example, if the company is sold for $X + $50 million then you have 1% of $50mm. The con with these agreements is that you, the little-person-with-no-leverage, you are not told the X while you are working there. Ask your CFO, they will say in a practiced tone, “We don’t give out that information”. IMO the best way to tell if the company is a winner, is to see big growth in sales/market size, especially after funding rounds. If the company is on its third funding round with no revenue and no clients then it’s one of these weird VC zombie dogs that manage to get funding because of spectacular bullshit artistry by the CEO (likely with a sales background). In which case your shares are worthless but the pay/gig might be interesting.
- Cherian 7y agoSomeone should make a tshirt “Liquidation Pref: the most dangerous word”
- readhn 7y ago2 start ups behind, shares worth 0. both companies took on half a billion (!!!) in funding combined - from VCs, gov etc. Revenue = close to nothing. I feel that start ups mostly are cash burn machines built to pay cushy salaries to C-level execs and build "impressive" resumes again for the execs. For most other folks, they are a just stepping stone to a "real" world job in a stable corporation. assume, your shares are worthless, basically a lottery ticket! In both companies i knew that some people put in real money to buy out options, 100s thousands of dollars amounts. Now they are sitting on a bunch of 0s. Learn from others mistakes! They are free!
- bbulkow 7y agoWe usually called it the liquidation stack. Because of different trigger points, whether different investors are participating or non participating, you needed a spreadsheet to figure out what common gets, for each potential outcome. There is no way to have a conversation with a potential employee about the liquidation stack, it is usually far too complex. More insideously, the buyer can change the rules. As long as the sellers vote for it, you can do things like wash out common, recap common, give new grants that are incentive grants with a one year cliff. Option holders don't vote, so you won't even see what they are voting on. That kind of stuff invites shareholder lawsuits, but it is ill advised to sue because then you are a trouble maker. Otoh, not suing means you are a pushover. An example of a shareholder wash out was when jobs took over pixar, so i was told by a friend who had shares.
- guelo 7y agoInvestor are short-sighted when they steal all the money from startup employees. Equity used to be the one way that startups could compete for talent but the more the word gets out that it's a scam the less that startups are able to compete.
- ry454 7y agoThe funny thing that all this might be funded by the big corps who don't really need any startups and competitors around: it's easier to invest 20-30 billions into destroying the reputation of the startup concept, than to continue buying them at 1-15 billions each.
- sabujp 7y agoIt's stupid that startups don't tell people going in what the overhang is, or that you won't get called back or get weird looks. Everyone is looking out for their bottom line, wtf would a startup expect any less from an employee that's about to spend 60+ hours a week toiling on the product? In any case, this is good info and I'll pass it onto my kids if they ever decide to join or build a startup. Hopefully they decide to be their own founders. I'll supply the garage :) .
- dudul 7y agoBased on my XP, getting details about options is real difficult. HR and hiring managers are used to people who barely understand the vesting schedule, so when you start asking about percentage, strike price, etc etc it's kind of unusual. And yeah, companies tend to not be transparent simply because they play on people's ignorance to make attract them with options while in 99% of cases you will never see a penny from these.
- dudul 7y agoI had never heard of this "carved-out" money. Is anyone familiar with this? It sounds a little like retention bonus based on the provided example.
- rozhok 7y agoJust in case anyone wants to visualize all the things in the article here's the good tool for it: https://dlopuch.github.io/venture-dealr/ https://dlopuch.github.io/venture-dealr/
- awinder 7y ago“In fact, one of my kids was recently interviewing at a startup and I told her to ask about the preferred overhang — she said the interviewer looked at her like she was asking about his sex life! She didn’t get a call-back.” I’ll do you one better. This is like asking someone you’re about to have sex with if they have an STD and then having them act indignant and not answer. And you should do the same thing in both cases and run away.
- gnicholas 7y agoIt’s also not the most polite/politic way to ask about it. A neutral way to get the same information is to ask about the cap table and then go from there if needed.
- H8crilA 7y agoSalary negotiation (which is what this is) is not the time to be super polite and dance around important topics.
- gnicholas 7y agoActually, it wasn't salary negotiation because it was pre-offer. It was during an interview, and the author lamented that "She didn’t get a call-back". I agree that during salary negotiations it is less important to tiptoe around things. Perhaps it was a bit premature to have even inquired about the cap table in any way during an interview, unless the interviewer had just mentioned how many options would be offered to a selected candidate (which would be oddly specific, pre-offer).
- H8crilA 7y agoDiscussing your stock/option grant is salary negotiation, even if it happens out of the standard order :)
- chii 7y agoit is understandable that this info is private (after all, you don't want this info leaked to your competitors). But if you are trying to lure candidates, this info is critical for them to evaluate their offer (esp. if the offer consists of large amounts of stock/options etc). There's no reason this info should be kept secret from them, except when there's foul play on the part of the employer! If the employer is concerned about the data leaking if the candidate rejects the offer, make them sign an NDA before telling them!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- WheelsAtLarge 7y ago"It's all in the fine print," and the fine print can say anything. I would say that this is a learning lesson for all who think options will make them rich. If you're at a company make sure you get paid what you're worth in money. Don't count on options as part of your compensation. You are unlikely to get rich because of them. As we have seen over and over again.
- habnds 7y agoin a perfect world options would (literally) be a bonus. In the real world people are playing stock market with their careers.
- geggam 7y agoWelcome to common stock
- justapassenger 7y agoIf you work in startup business, you should really take some finance classes to learn how it works. Your chances of getting any money out of the equity are basically 0%, no matter if company succeeds or not
- campfireveteran 7y agoObscene liquidation preferences for investors?
- aSplash0fDerp 7y agoThe comments were a very informative read! I'm sure they'll explain it to their kids as a ponzi scheme with a paycheck.
- code4tee 7y agoOptions holders are not shareholders. Options holders are not owners of the company. Options holders are not investors in the company. Too many forget these things and are shocked when then find out some event doesn’t treat them like one of the above.
- farrarstan 7y agoHonestly the only business I would be comfortable accepting options or even stock in lieu of adequate compensation is the guillotine factory.
- fisherjeff 7y agoUnless your options or equity are publicly traded, chances are you’re probably going to get screwed. I much prefer the 37signals approach: https://signalvnoise.com/posts/2987-an-alternative-to-employee-optionsequity-grants https://signalvnoise.com/posts/2987-an-alternative-to-employ...
- carlallison 7y agoIt's not uncommon employees got nothing. Some even need to pay tax when exercising the options. Remember Good Technology? https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/technology/when-a-unicorn-start-up-stumbles-its-employees-get-hurt.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/technology/when-a-unicorn...
- fogetti 7y agoI find it "funny" that the whole sharing and startup economy is basically built on top of something that resembles a Ponzi-scheme (not in terms of the actual operation of the scheme, but in the way how unfair the scheme is for different people in different roles). And the fact that the software industry happily embraces this modus operandi is simply mind boggling. As far as I am concerned this scheme with the stock options (some people call them opportunity or investment) never should be substitute to social contracts, like a monthly pay check. I find it especially nefarious the fact that people who invest time are penalized over people who invest money. This is especially true when the 4-5 year long time investment of a developer today can be easily worth millions. And a dozen developers' time investment can easily reach tens of millions.
- thatthatis 7y agoI’m of the opinion that the scariest words to a startup founder/employee should be “exit below the liquidity preference”