23 ms·
FTC Brings First Case Against Developers of “Stalking” Apps
- detcader 7y agoI've never heard of these apps and it's really alarming and at the same time not surprising at all. I can only imagine how widespread this is... I'm tempted to print out flyers with that NNEDV graphic to put up in public
- techntoke 7y agoThese apps are against the law, but you can still implement the built-in location tracking and activity history of the devices? Seems weird to me. They probably forgot to pay the lobbyists in the industry.
- relaunched 7y agoThink of it this way, chefs knives are legal. Murder is not. If you work in my restaurant, you can use the chefs knives to make food. You can't use them to kill people. If you do, you will be prosecuted.
- techntoke 7y agoI don't see how this analogy is relevant. They aren't accused of killing people. They are accused of having apps that are used to monitor devices (as they said was for work and kids). Google does this as well as many other apps on the Play Store. Just because someone uses the app by to stalk someone by getting access and installing it on a user's device, won't prevent them from using another feature that already exists to do the same thing.
- bendbro 7y agoIn your world: Chef knife :: the app Chef knife mfg :: the app developer Murder :: stalking Cooking :: legal tracking The law prosecutes app developers and makes illegal apps that allow for stalking. :: The law prosecutes chef knife mfgs and makes illegal chef knifes that can be used for murder. This is not you have stated. Your example world does not map to the real world, as it is a paradox to think a "murdering chef knife" can be discriminated from a "cooking chef knife" when the manufacturer creates it. And that is the point of the parent commenter. A tracking app can be used for both legal tracking and stalking, but it is absurd to think the developer will know which it is.
- ergothus 7y ago> it is a paradox to think a "murdering chef knife" can be discriminated from a "cooking chef knife" when the manufacturer creates it. You can certainly market your knives with an intention. You can study which knives "murder" best, and not study which knives are best for cooking. I agree that this should be a harder bar to prove, but I don't think it's paradoxical to say it can be done. > it is absurd to think the developer will know which it is. True, the developer won't "know" for any given instance. But it is NOT absurd to think the developer will be trying for one or the other, perfecting it for that purpose (with intent), and marketing it for that purpose, nor is it absurd that such an intent could be reasonably proven. (Not ABSOLUTELY proven, but reasonably)
- grawprog 7y ago>You can certainly market your knives with an intention. You can study which knives "murder" best, and not study which knives are best for cooking. But there's also no law against selling knives designed for murdering people in many places. I mean I can walk into a store and walk out with a katana or a long sword or something. You're not supposed to use them for killing people, but that's literally the reason why they were invented. I don't want to say for sure, but I pretty sure the katana manufacturer is still not going to be liable if I go and hack someone up with my katana.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI'd be willing to bet that an overwhelming majority of swords produced today are intended for display or ceremonial purposes. This is likely to lend render the manufacturer immune to any legal action.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoA katana can be (and usually is) used as a display piece. The FCC is saying (not unreasonably) that these apps aren't really suited for anything but illegally stalking people. They claim to be for legitimate tracking, but they made design decisions that clearly disagree with that. There's not really a direct analogy there (an...invisible katana?), but I think the difference is clear.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI don't understand why people insist on making these analogies when it's quite clear and simple what the issues are / can be with the sorts of apps under discussion here today.
- frandroid 7y agoI agree. Those making analogies are trying to obfuscate the issue, that's the problem...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- relaunched 7y ago>>>The FTC alleges that Retina-X and Johns developed three mobile device apps that allowed purchasers to monitor the mobile devices on which they were installed, without the knowledge or permission of the device’s user. They are being accused of taking no precautions to make sure their app was being used in a legal way (employees and children), as well as violating child privacy laws and deliquent security practices. To your other point, selling a legal service that can be used in an illegal way often has legal reprecussions, especially when you ignore compliance w/ applicable laws.
- trhway 7y agoI wonder whether these apps are used by police, cool TV FBI agents and the likes, and whether their ability to fight terrorism, drug and human trafficking, etc would get negatively impacted by limiting of those apps.
- inetknght 7y ago> whether their ability to fight terrorism, drug and human trafficking, etc would get negatively impacted by limiting of those apps. I seriously doubt it. First that I strongly disagree with the war on drugs. Second because, while human trafficking is certainly a problem, I think the scope of the problem is made out to be far larger than it is in actuality; it's often hand-waived for more security, more laws... but what are the actual yearly numbers of people trafficked? If the FBI gets a warrant to find you using your phone, they don't need to install an app for that. If they want to see what's on the phone then surreptitiously installing an app isn't going to guarantee that either.
- kevingadd 7y agoEven if these apps are used by the police etc, that's typically only allowed if they make sure to only sell to cops. Of course, that's usually not actually enforced, but services like GPS tracking arbitrary phones or cracking iPhone passcode security are usually limited in this fashion.
- _underfl0w_ 7y agoLaw enforcement wouldn't need a 3rd party app on the phone when they have 3rd party products like GrayKey boxes.
- mindgam3 7y agoGood. The stalkerware problem is bigger than most people realize. Teens whose parents use Life360 to stalk them are already well aware of the issue. http://www.wired.com/story/life360-location-tracking-families/ http://www.wired.com/story/life360-location-tracking-familie...
- droithomme 7y ago> Teens whose parents use... The FTC order allows them to do so. The problem was the apps are marketed to monitor employees and minors of which the installer is the legal guardian, both which are completely legal. But it was being used in some cases by customers to monitor other adults, which is not legal without consent. The company agreed to get the users to check a box saying it was being used for minors or employees, both which remain legal uses of the apps.
- mindgam3 7y agoMy point is: using these apps to monitor people without legal consent is super not cool, obviously, but there’s an even bigger problem which is parents relying on legal-but-shady stalking apps. Parents and kids need to be able to trust each other. Surveilling your kids is not the answer. Full stop.
- droithomme 7y agoIn my opinion, parents have more of a right to closely monitor and track their minor children than does Google, the US government, the child's school, the company supplying the child's school's tech for free, Facebook, Apple, etc. All those, by strangers, are being done as we speak with little complaint but here we have the parent monitoring their child argued as some massive privacy invasion. Yet if the parent fails to closely monitor the child and something happens to the child the parent is charged with neglect and abuse, CPS gets involved, and the child is whisked away to foster care.
- justtopostthis3 7y ago
- 3wolf 7y agoThis is small potatoes compared to the number of apps out there periodically harvesting a users' locations to be aggregated and sold to some quant fund.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoYours is a legitimate concern, but a separate issue. Stalking can present real, immediate, and severe consequences to the target(s).
- everlastingfan 7y agoRight, don't talk about advanced persistent threats here.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI don't understand this comment. What do you mean to imply?
- _jal 7y agoI do not think that means what you think it means. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_persistent_threat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_persistent_threat
- everlastingfan 7y agoI know what the words mean. Go meditate if you have trouble understanding.
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoQuants all went to the same 5 schools that control the global shadow government. They are untouchable, and you will not speak of this again.
- vkou 7y agoReally? I don't give a damn that my data is anonymized, aggregated, and sold to some asshole on Wall Street, who uses it to make a stock trade. Even if it's not anonymized well, this is not a physical threat to my safety, because the people buying the data don't care about me. I'm not special. And they don't care about hurting me - they just want to make stock trades. I mean, I care about this sort of thing - but I care only a little. I sure as hell care that someone might be using the information on my phone to physically stalk me, in particular. The latter is an active threat to my life and limb.
- geoffreyhale 7y agoWhat's the problem here? I don't see it. I see family opt-in location sharing.
- LeonB 7y agoFor example, abusive partners can use it to track their partner and continue to track them when they (hopefully) become ex partners.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoAnd some times kill the ex partner sadly in some cases. Back when I worked for a large telco we had a training film about why you should never look up data on our systems for a "friend" and there was a real case of this happening.
- somejerk123 7y agoOnce upon a time, I found this company's software on an employee's work laptop, installed by a jealous ex-boyfriend. I called the company, and they refused to remove our data or even help with uninstalling the software without a court order. The software helpfully logged the URL when it saved screenshots to S3, which it did every few seconds. The S3 bucket was fully public, listable, readable, writable. It also contained keylogging and other data. Not just from our employee. From everyone.
- nkrisc 7y agoDid the data spontaneously delete itself?
- matheusmoreira 7y agoDid you get a court order?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- koolba 7y agoCould you overwrite the existing data?
- derefr 7y agoPerhaps you should have just sent the link to the S3 bucket to a news organization. Things would have handled themselves from there.
- somejerk123 7y agoBetween the red text on all their sites and this settlement, I'd say things did handle themselves. The employee and jealous ex even made up, got married, and have children now. Everybody lived happily ever after.
- heavenlyblue 7y ago>> The employee and jealous ex even made up, got married, and have children now. /s if not for the app, that ex would never be able to get over their jealousy
- Jerry2 7y agoFrom the article: >Retina-X and Johns marketed one of the apps, called MobileSpy, to monitor employees and children. Retina-X promoted two other apps, called PhoneSheriff and TeenShield, to monitor mobile devices used by children. Retina-X sold more than 15,000 subscriptions to all three stalking apps before the company stopped selling them in 2018. MobileSpy's website [1] is still up but they now have an "apology" for getting hacked from 2018: >Regrettably Retina-X Studios, which offers cutting edge technology that helps parents and employers gather important information on devices they own, has been the victim of sophisticated and repeated illegal hackings. Over the past year, Retina-X Studios has begun to implement steps designed to enhance our security measures which had the positive outcome of restricting data obtained by the hackers in the most recent intrusion. No personal data was accessed, but some photographic material of TeenShield and PhoneSheriff customers has been exposed. These apps also appear to be Android only. I don't see how they could run something like this without a jailbreak. [1] https://www.mobile-spy.com/ https://www.mobile-spy.com/
- kizer 7y agoHoly shit... what?! People have been stalking their partners using hidden apps? Is jealousy this powerful? WTF - that legitimately sounds crazy to me.
- SmallDeadGuy 7y ago> Each of the apps provided purchasers with instructions on how to remove the app’s icon from appearing on the mobile device’s screen so that the device’s user would not know the app was installed on the device, according to the complaint. For the legitimate uses of this app, there should be absolutely no need to remove the app icon from the home screen and there should be a regular/persistent notification of when monitoring is in effect. I can't believe that the company would even think this is a good idea for their intended use, let alone ignoring how it enables malicious behaviour.