21 ms·
The next big thing will start out looking like a toy (2010)
- ojbyrne 7y agoMods: Please put (2010) in the title.
- feross 7y agoFixed!
- wenbin 7y agoTen years later... it's still very true :)
- dwd 7y agoThere are some interesting user comments like one guy who talked up Google Search compared to Yahoo and AOL and how it gave you what you wanted and sent you on your way and didn't try to keep you on site indefinitely. How things change and end up repeating the same old mistakes.
- throwaway66920 7y ago> Disruptive technologies are dismissed as toys because when they are first launched they “undershoot” user needs. The first telephone could only carry voices a mile or two. The leading telco of the time, Western Union, passed on acquiring the phone because they didn’t see how it could possibly be useful to businesses and railroads – their primary customers. What they failed to anticipate was how rapidly telephone technology and infrastructure would improve (technology adoption is usually non-linear due to so-called complementary network effects). The same was true of how mainframe companies viewed the PC (microcomputer), and how modern telecom companies viewed Skype. (Christensen has many more examples in his books). Skype feels like a bad examples it was always fairly obvious video chat would be prevalent eventually. It was never obvious that Skype was the best answer, and there were Skype alternatives with similar offerings which have failed. Skype itself may not last the long run if it can’t keep up with zoom or whatnot.
- coldtea 7y ago>The reason big new things sneak by incumbents is that the next big thing always starts out being dismissed as a “toy.” This is one of the main insights of Clay Christensen’s “disruptive technology” theory. This theory starts with the observation that technologies tend to get better at a faster rate than users’ needs increase. Or perhaps new technologies are solutions in search of a problem, and without any concrete sense of self and hierarchy, user "needs" can get artificially inflated to infinity... Kind of how people "needed" cigarettes in 1950, and "needed" bell bottoms in the 70s, and "need" a good smartphone camera today (because of course they also "need" to broadcast to their friends and everybody else what they ate for dinner, their latest selfie, and their life 24/7) -- even if nobody on the receiving end really cares, except perhaps their parents and grandparents...
- appleshore 7y agoHere’s a more full account of the Western Union and Bell settlement on patent infringement- http://oldtelephones.com/blog/2012/04/25/bell-telephone--western-union-patent-agreement-of-1879/ http://oldtelephones.com/blog/2012/04/25/bell-telephone--wes... I’m also generally skeptical of revisionist narratives. People often say no one saw X coming, no one saw apps on a phone or a screen with buttons etc etc. But it seems hundreds or thousands of writers, designers, futurists, failed technologists and so on did predict these things. The hard part is building them and then creating a system (eg financed hardware) to create widespread adoption.
- jerf 7y agoThis went by on HN a week or so ago: https://www.gwern.net/Timing https://www.gwern.net/Timing I tend to agree, the problem isn't seeing what's coming exactly (though that is non-trivial). The problem is the timing.
- mywittyname 7y ago> People often say no one saw X coming, no one saw apps on a phone or a screen with buttons etc etc. But it seems hundreds or thousands of writers, designers, futurists, failed technologists and so on did predict these things. Often technologies are available long before they ever catch on with the mainstream. There were several PDAs sold in the 90s, and at least one had a built-in telephone. The Buick Reatta had a touch screen center stack in the late 1980s. Technology adoption is weird. There needs to be the perfect storm of integration, marketing, and (for lack of a better term) zeitgeist to really make something mainstream. And even with all those things, it still takes YEARS to really get there. Think about how long techies were downloading TV shows/movies before streaming really took off -- Windows Media Center came out in 2002! That's a full six years before Netflix started its streaming service, which itself took several years to take off.
- xitrium 7y agoThis did not hold up well, imo. Not sure how to count it but by some lists this is stuff like: Tencent, Alibaba, Amazon, Netflix, Priceline, Baidu, Salesforce.com, JD.com. Others would include Uber/Lyft, Airbnb, GitHub, ... There are only a few that would qualify that I can think of - Instagram, Snapchat, and WhatsApp. If folks here have other examples or thoughts on why this does or doesn't hold true would love to hear them.
- airocker 7y agoUber/Lyft/AirBnb were considered toys when they began. It may be that nowadays the transition from toy to big company is faster.
- playpause 7y agoI don't remember anyone saying Uber/Lyft/Airbnb were toys when they began. Some might have thought them unlikely to succeed, but that's not the same thing as being a toy.
- airocker 7y agoI do not think we are referring to Toy's literal meaning here. IMO, Toy here means something insignificant that a few people/small market uses.
- Impossible 7y agoExactly. Those of you that are hung up on toy meaning a literal toy or video game with no intrinsic value can replace the word toy with "gimmick" or "novelty" or even "a serious idea that won't scale" (http://paulgraham.com/ds.html http://paulgraham.com/ds.html). Early Air Bed and Breakfast charging people for couch surfing and selling Obama O's (https://www.airbnb.com/obamaos https://www.airbnb.com/obamaos) to fund their startup definitely feels toy like to me. I'd argue there are entire categories that are currently considered toys, but eventually with the right business model, tech improvements and cultural changes will make the serious billion dollar tech companies we have now look like toys.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- viach 7y agoImo if a statement about the future doesn't contain word "probably" - it is probably wrong.
- AznHisoka 7y agoprobably.. suppose... it seems to me.. I hate it when people try and hedge their opinions.
- viach 7y agoYou are right. I could re-phrase my comment - all statements about the future which don't contain notion of probability are pure gambling.
- AznHisoka 7y agoI totally agree. except "probably" contains a weak notion of probability . What does probably mean? 51% likely? 55% likely? 90% likely? If you're going to attach a probability to an opinion, use "most likely", or "almost certainly", or "unlikely". That to me, isn't hedging an opinion. That's attaching a real probability to the outcome.
- alecbenzer 7y agoWhy? Hedging is fine. I think it's important to accurately communicate how certain you are of a thing. Constant hedging is annoying, but so is stating everything as if it's a fact, despite how sure you really are. Communicating confidence is useful.
- AznHisoka 7y agoI totally agree. My beef was with people using vague words like "probably". What does probably mean? 51% likely? 55% likely? 90% likely? It contains no sense of probability, that can be agreed upon. If you're going to attach a probability to an opinion, use "most likely", or "almost certainly", or "unlikely".
- 7y ago
- dang 7y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1029069 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1029069
- onychomys 7y agoFun to see that a decade ago, people were convinced that AR was going to be the next big thing. I could see that exact same argument being made today, nearly ten years later!
- SandersAK 7y agohealthcare?
- smacktoward 7y agoPossibly the absolute last market sector where you want people thinking of their products as toys.
- guptaneil 7y agoWearables started off looking like toys, but are poised to drastically change how we think about health. The whole point of this argument is that the next big thing will come out of left field, not that you should build toys to try to solve a major problem.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoThis was the approach Anki (which recently shut down) took for robotics. I actually had a similar idea, but whenever I went to the drawing board to make robot toys I could never make anything that was both fun and affordable - using videogames as a benchmark it basically always lost. I think Anki did as close to an admirable job as you could at trying to sell robotic toys while developing more utilitarian robots (they were working on a chore bot but it was woefully inadequate), but they still failed pretty hard. I was always surprised by their ability to continue to raise large sums of money (they raised about a quarter billion in total). There is a similar approach being taken in the eVTOL space, with Kitty Hawk trying to develop their Heaviside as an obvious toy for the rich (single seater, short range, "quiet"). I think people will refuse to allow so much noise pollution in the skies, not to mention the inherent question of safety as all these designs make serious compromises to flight stability in order to make them so lightweight and take off vertically. There is merit to this approach though - you could certainly argue hypercars are toys for the super rich and eventually that technology trickles down to cheaper vehicles. But the economics around racing cars are much more complicated, including making an entire sport (and an extremely popular one at that) to justify the development costs. You could also argue Tesla did this, starting with the Roadster, then the Model S, and now the Model 3. Tesla's financials have been a source of great debate for a decade now though. Whatever the next big thing is, I bet the media hasn't caught onto it yet. I don't think it's VR, AR, self-driving cars, general AI, or anything else that has already been woefully overhyped. It'll be something nobody was looking for and the right person stumbles upon it at the right place and time.
- Ancalagon 7y agoI actually think AR could still be the next big thing, once the integration becomes seamless and the peripheral technology doesn't look ridiculous
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoI'd have to try it. The question is what's the killer app? VR essentially has 3 things going for it after becoming somewhat mature - Google Earth, Beat Saber, and porn. All are considered better in VR, but none are really "omg VR is the future!" level of amazing (to be fair I haven't tried the porn yet so maybe I don't realize how much I'm missing out). The notion of having a HUD for my eyes everywhere I go sounds neat at first, until I think about it a bit more and it just seems like sensory overload. I can always just pull out my phone if there's something I want to know, and that thing is already pretty invasive when it comes to my daily living - do I really need something more than that? When it happens, we'll know. The iPhone was famously expected to be such a failure that Verizon refused to be a carrier. Microsoft also joked about Apple being able to make a smart phone. Blackberry felt the same way. The only company that took them seriously was Google with Android. Out of curiosity, what is it you think AR will revolutionize? What do you consider the killer app?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ETHisso2017 7y agoTiktok comes to mind. Maybe drones as well
- peter998 7y agoAm I the only one thinking of WebAssembly? (e.g. https://wasmer.io https://wasmer.io )
- soperj 7y agoSurprised no one here has mentioned bitcoin.
- awicklander 7y agoThis makes me think of Fortnite. What if Fortnite, and the impact it's going to have on us, is yet but a tiny baby?
- kgwxd 7y agoYou must not have school-aged kids, Fortnite is already dead.
- jpindar 7y agoOf course I don't know what your kids are into, but Fortnite just started a whole new map, and there seem to be plenty of people playing.
- kevinventullo 7y agoYou sure about that? It currently has the second-highest viewership on Twitch, topped only by League of Legends (which is surprisingly almost a decade old).
- kgwxd 7y agoIt was mostly a joke for people with school-aged kids. At least in my kids school, and what r/memes seems to reflect around the world, is they all say it's "trash" and Minecraft is the thing again. I think they all still play it, it's just cool to say it's not cool. However, a lot of them seem to have stopped buying V-bucks, at least to get skins.
- nostrademons 7y agoWhat're kids into these days? I could believe it, but haven't seen anything else get hot recently.
- jpindar 7y agoHave you tried Fortnite Creative mode? It can be as much of a virtual world as a FPS game engine. People are building islands for other types of games, for socializing, and just as art for art's sake.
- aazaa 7y agoI think most participants in the Internet circa 1996 and personal computers in the early 1980s would understand this idea. The Internet was being widely written off as a toy that many couldn't ever imagine having practical applications. Case in point, this widely-cited piece from 1998: > The growth of the Internet will slow drastically, as the flaw in "Metcalfe's law"--which states that the number of potential connections in a network is proportional to the square of the number of participants--becomes apparent: most people have nothing to say to each other! By 2005 or so, it will become clear that the Internet's impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machine's. http://web.archive.org/web/19980610100009/www.redherring.com/mag/issue55/economics.html http://web.archive.org/web/19980610100009/www.redherring.com... Here are some fun things about this concept of toys turning into big things: 1. toys start out looking like toys, too 2. it's extremely difficult to distinguish the toys that will remain toys forever from those that will become "the next big thing." A useful approach to the problem posed by (2) is to look at things that appear to be toys but refuse to die despite every indication that they should have done so long ago. Toys that remain toys often have a trendiness and inelasticity to them that gives them naturally short lives. If you see a toy lingering long beyond the time it should have given up the ghost, you may be looking at the next big thing. The next problem is that it can take a very long time for a toy to turn into the next big thing.
- cookingrobot 7y agoBy this test, is Lego the next big thing?
- Tronno 7y agoLego has an annual revenue in the billions and has recently grown bigger than Mattel or Hasbro. So, yes
- swsieber 7y agoAlready was - spawned games, movies, theme-park rides, etc.
- jacobr1 7y agoMaybe? The definitions evolve and stretch. What if legos where made of smarter material or had more powerful components? 3D printing might actually be the right way to think about small-scale at-home manufacturing rather than per-brick components - but even then plenty of components (such as compute related) require different manufacturing methods - so standards based on something like lego might allow for interoperability. It's a toy ... until it is not.
- raymondsoldier 7y agobitcoin...
- grumpy8 7y agoI have a question for those who were there at the very beginning of the internet. I heard that many were skeptical about both personal computers and the internet.. did it feel the same as it does right now with crypto-currency/quantum-computing? I wasn't there, but on my side, it feels like people were able to use internet right from the beginning, whereas there's a bigger leap to using crypto/quantum. Is it just that the infrastructure isn't in place to allow normal people to do easy things?
- drblast 7y agoPersonal computing and the Internet were a much bigger deal than cryptocurrency. Each completely dominated the overall cultural dialogue for years at least in the U.S. If you ever watch "The Graduate" and the guy gives the college grad advice to go into "plastics" because it's the next big thing, that's computers in the 80's and the Internet in the 90's. People were quick to latch on to the web because it facilitated things they really wanted to do like keep in touch with friends and buy things easily. Cryptocurrency doesn't do that for most of the population. PC's were a hobbyist thing at home and more akin to cryptocurrency, but at the same time they were completely taking over how business operated. The web had a similar impact on small businesses too. Having a web presence exposed small companies to a much larger customer base than they could have ever hoped for before. Cryptocurrency doesn't really solve real-world problems like this. Most people are perfectly fine using traditional currency and wouldn't see any benefit to replacing that with Bitcoin, et al. Edit: I think the most recent change that you might have been around for was the introduction of the iPhone and the smart phones that followed. Huge paradigm shift for the general population.
- pavlov 7y agoI was there in early 1990s, and it was completely different. The immediate benefits of the Internet were obvious, and much more interesting than any theoretical "take over the world" growth story. People were willing to tackle slow connections, bad UIs and device configuration hell so that they could get chatting on IRC or posting on Usenet or downloading files from weird/shady FTP servers. With cryptocurrency, there's nothing new or interesting you can actually do, no meaningful human connections to be made. It's just speculating on a made-up growth story, like penny stocks you can trade 24/7 — but we already had penny stocks and boiler room scams.
- ctdonath 7y agoObservation: "comic book" movies today are largely not suitable for non-teenage children (practically all rated PG-13). What was literary version of "toy" is now 9-digit-budget blockbusters.
- aidenn0 7y agoFWIW, my son is in 3rd grade and most of his peer group (8-9yo) has seen at least some of the MCU movies.
- guptaneil 7y agoIf you're hung up on the word "toy," another way of phrasing this is the next big thing will look like just a hobby to most people. Looking forward, smart homes and 3D printing are 2 industries that fall in this bucket. Both feel like toys to the majority of the market right now, but have the potential to completely change how we live. 3D printing - low-cost manufacturing has completely revolutionized what's possible for startups, and developed a large hobbyist following, but we haven't scratched the surface of how they can change day-to-day life for everybody. Imagine what's possible once they support more material types (metal, electrical circuits, food, etc) and every home has one, like an oven. Smart homes - we just have fancy remote controls so far, but eventually we'll be living like Tony Stark with homes that constantly adapt to us without input. This is where we'll see the benefit of ambient computing present itself clearest. Imagine a home that helps you raise your child, keep your chores in order, or handle the repetitive tasks without requiring a primary care-taker to be responsible for keeping the home in order. disclaimer: I'm building Hiome (https://hiome.com https://hiome.com) to turn smart homes into more than just toys, so maybe I'm a little biased.
- starpilot 7y agoThe thing is a hobby isn't too different from a business. They can even be hard to distinguish: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/hobby-or-business-irs-offers-tips-to-decide https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/hobby-or-business-irs-offers-ti... The next big thing will start out looking like a business! Wahey!
- guptaneil 7y agoI think cpsmith said it well in another comment on this page that we're talking about technologies, not individual companies[0]. Would other people (mainstream users) say the tech is for hobbyists? The examples I cited (desktop 3D printers and smart homes) are definitely considered hobbies today, regardless of whether anyone would classify Hiome as a hobby. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21316776 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21316776
- bcrosby95 7y agoBefore smart homes are more than just a toy, they need to have functionality that is actually time saving. I've messed with smart home stuff and so far the only thing that has been useful beyond being a toy is our robot vacuum, which I'm not sure is really classified as a smart home thing. As someone that lives in California, something that could be an actual $$ and time saver rather than just a toy is if I could have a system that would open windows rather than turning on the AC when the outside temperature is low enough.
- myth_buster 7y agoThis was my thought regarding Google's Soli chip[0] when I saw comments talking about it's usability limited to cooking or other fringe cases. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21269877 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21269877
- oscargrouch 7y agoThe chip has potential to change the way we live, but this potential will only become reality when proper applications and bussiness models create really useful stuff around it. I think seeing this tech as disruptive somehow is kind of obvious, but to change our lifes upside down it needs much more. The same can be said about 3D printing. It has a lot of potential, but timing + the right ecosystem around it is also a big deal. Apple with Newton, MS and specially Palm were there first for the pocket computer + phone, but why only with the iPhone things started to really happen? The right bet + timing + ecosystem around it is also pretty important.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoI hope the next big thing will move atoms around. I think bits are very limiting. My Iphone, no matter how good the apps are, will never be able to get up and clean up the kitchen, or build me a house for that matter.
- schnevets 7y agoI'm trying to brainstorm what I think is a "toy" in today's tech market, and I can't think of much. Tech pundits who have seen 30 years of crazy endeavors are taking everything overly seriously. Companies have the resolve to invest billions in "jokes" (like Facebook Portal) stubbornly refusing to recognize a sunk-cost fallacy. Instagram is the most recent example of a revolutionary toy - when everyone thought social media was a puzzle solved by Facebook, Instagram cut the fat and became a more elegant tool to getting a message across (and making some money in the process). I could see Slack's fun approach to workflow automation and collaboration take off, but maybe I'm biased by what I'm investing my own time into learning.
- umeshunni 7y agoSome examples of 'toys' in today's market - AR/VR, Drones, Another factor is that investment in tech is dramatically higher today that it was 20 years ago (partly due to success that early investors had) and people are willing to invest in anything that looks like a 'toy' in the off chance it pays off.
- outworlder 7y agoAre drones still considered 'toys'? At least in photography, they have long ceased to be toys. Given that you have big companies working on them (like amazon for deliveries), I'm wondering if they are still in the 'toy' phase. VR is. The incremental changes are not yet enough to make them practical for non-gaming use (and even gaming, they are amazing, but cumbersome). AR is firmly still in the toy camp.
- iamwil 7y agoJust look at what's polarizing, what you might dismiss without looking deep into it. Cryptocurrencies is a good candidate. So is VR and AR.
- segmondy 7y agokubernetes didn't start out looking like a toy. nor did tensorflow or kafka nor ipod / iphone nor spacex nor tesla unless looks like a toy is relative to the incumbents, but not to the population at large.
- mch82 7y agoIn “Wonderland: How Play Made the Modern World” the toy as predictor concept is explored more deeply. The emphasis is less on the implementation of the toy than on the popularity of the style of play or human amusement that the toy enables. Then over time various technologies come along to implement the mode of play. Eventually someone says, wow that might help in serious adult activity X. And then disruption. Kubernetes, Tensorflow, Kafka, Falcon 9, iPhone, and Model S aren’t toys. Video game AI, model rockets, iPod (limited to music playback), and RC cars are toys that predicted these modern, serious adult innovations. The toy as predictor theory doesn’t require that all technologies begin as toys. So maybe Kubernetes & Kafka don’t fit (I can’t think of a relevant toy).
- k__ 7y agoPCs, Smartphones, the Web, JavaScript... All things that helped me making a good living.
- dredmorbius 7y agoOr weapons / military hardware.
- mch82 7y agoIf you’re excited by this concept I recommend the book “Wonderland: How Play Made the Modern World” by Steven Johnson. Fascinating stuff! Here’s a recorded talk and more info: http://longnow.org/seminars/02017/jan/04/wonderland-how-play-made-modern-world/ http://longnow.org/seminars/02017/jan/04/wonderland-how-play...
- mraudiobook_com 7y agoBitcoin?
- ianai 7y agoAren’t atomic bombs a counter example to this? Though maybe an example that proves the trend. There’s a strong connection between nuclear power failures and political push back.
- perl4ever 7y agoRemember 3D TV?
- aaron695 7y agoOnions (Tor) Darkmarkets which are Onions are a big thing which were just for LARPing in the past. But the next big thing 10 years ago was Uber which was not a toy. It didn't sneak. It smashed regulatory bodies and corrupt monopolies as people cheered. People really don't understand it's also changed the fabric of society. It's far easier to see in developing countries. What is the real insight we can use here? It's probably more, some toys will become big, but it's hard to think of examples. Bitcoin has only gone from a toy, to a toy people can see will leave the toy stage.
- rmason 7y agoRecently watched George Hotz on video announce his latest update for Comma.ai. To sign up for their optional prime(?) monthly subscription account you've got to give them your GitHub account. Gave a friend anxious to try self-driving a link. He then asks me what is GitHub? I explain it and he tells me, what is this some sort of tech toy? I could tell that he began to lose interest. I well remember talking to people about getting on the Internet in 1994 and as soon as they found out they'd have to install a tcp/ip stack on Windows 3.1 they too soon lost interest. I believe against all odds that Comma.ai just might be one of the eventual winners in the self driving market. Which is crazy because they're battling people who've invested billions of dollars. By coincidence the partner who brought Comma.ai to Andreesen Horowitz is Chris Dixon! Coincidence? Personally I'm just waiting for them to add support for Ford.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- anovikov 7y agoI can't see how Skype was different in 2010 vs 2003. I mean, it provided facility for perfect clarity voice calls over the Internet right away and that never changed (arguably, clarity of a Skype voice call is worse now than it used to be). And it perfectly worked over then-day Internet connections. I had a mediocre quality dial-up in 2003 which was already long in the past for most developed countries, and i used Skype a lot, it worked OK - and when i moved onto 112kbps dedicated line - also considered slowish by developed countries' standards of the day - and Skype calls were literally perfectly clear all the time, every time. Much better than over a landline phone, if you had a headset. So while agreeing with the rest of the article, Skype sounds like a wrong example. It was a total replacement for phone calls from day one. I never made, and maybe received only about 10, calls to/from my U.S. customers since getting on Skype, PSTN immediately lost me as a long-distance client.
- hyperpallium 7y agoMost toys remain toys... I really like Clay Christenen's ideas, but he dismissed the greatest recent disruption (smartphones) as "sustaining"... His theories are not predictive. What actual toys are there? Especially new ones. def toy: fun/enjoyable/popular but useless. video games (e.g. minecraft, pubg), social media (stackexchange, reddit, meme-makers), scooters, fidget spinners, drones, 3D printers, face swaps, shadertoy
- growlist 7y agoThis made me think of disparaging comments from ESA about SpaceX: 'Asked about how the Ariane 5 compares to lower-cost alternatives on the market today, such as SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket, Stefano Bianchi, Head of ESA Launchers Development Department, responded with a question of his own. “Are you buying a Mercedes because it is cheap?” Ranzo, sitting nearby, chimed in and referenced the India-based maker of the world’s least expensive car. As he put it, “We don’t sell a Tata.”'
- AstralStorm 7y agoBut whoever makes that Fiat Ducato or equivalent for space will make big bank. Different markets warrant different solutions, including custom.
- growlist 7y agoAgreed, but lower cost access to space could also change the game itself. If launch costs are 1/10 or 1/100 what they are now, your bespoke $100m absolutely-cannot-fail-at-all-costs satellite can similarly be blown away by satellites that can be built without the super-expensive verification required to make them infallible. Just build them cheap and good enough and if/when they fail, throw up another.
- sailpro 7y agoThats an interesting topic and an evergreen article as every few years we can try and observe the landscape of up and coming toys. Some candidates: Drones Bitcoin Electric Scooters VR AR Voice recognition (Alexa, Siri, OK Google) 3d printer Robotics what else?
- dawg- 7y agoVideo games will always show what's next. Gaming companies are developing the expertise at constructing virtual worlds, with rules that engage and immerse users, that will be essential to the popularization of VR. VR will go mainstream under the umbrella of gaming before it's used in any practical sense. It's the same way computers went mainstream, and I bet video games will spawn whatever comes after VR as well.