27 ms·
Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index
- celticninja 7y agoPersonally I prefer to use the CBECI https://www.cbeci.org/ https://www.cbeci.org/
- steve19 7y agoIt says a single transaction generates almost 300kg of CO2. Surely not. 95g of e-waste also seems incredible. And 600 kwh of energy per transaction? Really. Edit: based on a cost of electricity at $0.1/kwh, and assuming bitcoin operators break even and are rational, one transaction costs less than 3kw of energy: https://bitcoinfees.info https://bitcoinfees.info If it cost 600kwh, we would assume a transaction would cost at least $60. Electricity is probably a lot cheaper in China. If it was half as much we would be looking at under 6kwh of electricity at the most.
- Kinnard 7y agoDo you have some back of the napkin counter calculations? Or critiques of their methodology?
- VRay 7y agoI'm not sure if the article is right or wrong, but the commenter above you was probably getting at this: You can see how much money a block miner receives for a block of transactions, and given the money they received, and an estimate for the cost of power, you can estimate how much power they might have been willing to expend on it Going off the guy's link, I guess it's 24 cents to get into the next block, and a block has about 500,000 transactions, so whoever mines that block gets $125,000. Assuming 4 cents per kWh, the presence of only one miner, and no other operation costs, he'd still be breaking even if he expended (1 kwH/$0.04)*$125,000 =~ 2,500 kWh per block (and by the same napkin math, that's 6 kWh per transaction) What's weird is TFA seems to be using a similar methodology (but looking at total bitcoin mining revenue instead of an individual block), and yet they came out with a number 100x as large. I'm not sure why there's such a big discrepancy.
- laurentoget 7y ago625 kwH is microwave oven running continuously for about 3 weeks. This is a lot of energy.
- Reason077 7y agoIf 625 kWh per transaction is accurate, then 300kg CO2 is plausible depending on the grid. Many electric grids emit 500g CO2 per kWh or more. Others are much cleaner depending on the production mix. See: www.electricitymap.org
- cjbprime 7y agoI don't think most Bitcoin mining is powered by a grid at all. I think the reward would be less than the cost using grid power.
- xyzzyz 7y agoAn average block has something like 2500 transactions in it. It means that there is about 1-2 transactions per second. Bitcoin network is running at 100 million TH/s. Modern mining hardware does 10 GH/Joule = 10^10 H/J, so 100 million TH = 10^8 * 10^12 H = 10^20 H is 10^20/10^10 = 10^10 Joules. 1 kWh is 3.6 * 10^6 joules, so 10^10 Joules is something like 3 * 10^3 kWh, so 3 MWh. One ton of coal produces something like 2 MWh. So yeah, assuming some of the electricity is not coal, the numbers do add up.
- cjbprime 7y agoThey're missing that the reward has fallen below the cost of non-renewable energy, such that the only profitable way to mine Bitcoin now is with renewables. The only way to profitably mine Bitcoin with any country's electric grid would be if someone else is paying the electric bill for you. > Electricity is probably a lot cheaper in China. Specifically, miners in China are famous for colocating with overprovisioned excess hydroelectric power that is not transportable elsewhere via the grid.
- jron 7y agoEasy to miss the point that the power would be lost if it wasn't used.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI saw this a couple days ago when @arcticbull mentioned it here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21256112 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21256112 Jaw dropping. Converted to Telsa Model S miles as per https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Model_S https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Model_S Comes out to about 2000 miles or 3200 kilometers for one Bitcoin transaction. Astounding.
- arcticbull 7y agoI mentioned it in a couple of threads and people seemed surprised, so I figured it would be worth surfacing more broadly as its own post.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoDefinitely agree. I have some rather left-leaning friends, vegans and all, who recently mentioned they were going to take a punt on Bitcoin. Might have to show them this.
- reportgunner 7y agoIt does not really matter if it's 2 miles or 2 million miles per bitcoin transaction. You cannot stop bitcoin. Edit: You would end up burning even more if you tried to stop it.
- davidgerard 7y agonah, there's approaches. I meet with politicians and suggest a carbon tax on crypto exchange conversion to fiat - miners have to cash out, after all. You have to tax the clean coins too, otherwise buyers will just exchange dirtycoin for cleancoin before cashing out.
- lifty 7y agoWhy not tax or make all energy more expensive? That way all wasteful usage will be curtailed and only the valuable use cases will be left after a while. If we do what you proposed it sounds like we should start taxing other behavior on the internet based on its usefulness to society and electricity usage.
- lucisferre 7y agoThis seems completely outrageous to me. I had seen similar numbers thrown around casually in the past but still found it hard to believe to be true, (despite being pretty bearish on Bitcoin myself). This seems to provide some pretty detailed evidence, analysis and validation directly addressing criticisms. It seems pretty thorough. Is there any more to discuss on the topic of Bitcoin being outrageously wasteful? Or is this pretty much the final word? Is Bitcoin figuratively, and almost literally, a tire fire?
- elznebelyk 7y agoBitcoin Core is 100% a tire fire, Cryptocurrency, like Ethereum and Bitcoin Cash are on the other hand killing it.
- jxcl 7y ago(Edit2: I interpreted your use of "outrageous" to mean surprising or unbelievable. If instead you meant inciting to outrage, then I agree, it is.) My opinion is that if you find this outrageous then you don't understand the core principles of Bitcoin. The difficulty of mining a block on the network goes up with the amount of mining being done to maintain a constant block mining rate. There are massive bitcoin mining warehouses in China, and for each one that opens all of them are less effective at mining, but still consume the same amount of energy. So, yeah, it's pretty much a tire fire. Edit: to add to this, many industries can use technology to produce more value with less energy. Bitcoin is fundamentally unable to do this for the same reasons I mentioned above. When bitcoin specific mining hardware first came out, it briefly gave an advantage to the first people to have it, but then the advances were completely neglected when they became widespread.
- spookthesunset 7y agoTo summarize your excellent summary: bitcoin wastes energy by design. It cannot keep all the “features” it’s supporters value without wasting energy.
- baroffoos 7y ago
- floatingatoll 7y agoA footnote says: > The assumptions underlying this energy consumption estimate can be found here [1]. Criticism and potential validation of the estimate is discussed here [2]. [1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#assumptions https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#assumpti... [2] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#validation https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#validati...
- Analemma_ 7y agoFWIW, [2] doesn't seem to offer substantive criticism at all. It mentions a couple independent verifications of the numbers in [1], with one complaint (from a very biased party) whose claims are not sourced. This pretty much lines up with what I've seen in all Bitcoin energy use debaters: the evangelists insist the numbers are all wrong, but never really provide any evidence to that point.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- elznebelyk 7y agoBitcoin is artificially limited in capacity by people like Adam Back and his company Blockstream. The number of transactions is a simple limit set by whoever controls the Bitcoin GitHub Repo, thats it. Bitcoin Cash is much closer to the "Bitcoin" described by the inventor Satoshi Nakamoto.
- labster 7y agoBitcoin is an ongoing environmental disaster, profiting off of subsidized coal power in China and elsewhere in the world. Millions of people die every year from air pollution. But on the other side, hey blockchains are so cool they can do the same work as banks but six orders of magnitude less efficiently.
- ISL 7y agoBy that measure, the problem is the pricing of energy, not Bitcoin.
- spookthesunset 7y agoDoesn’t work that way. Bitcoin’s block reward system is designed so that the systems energy consumption costs are basically some percentage of the price of bitcoin. The higher the price, the more energy used. Drop the price of energy, and all rational miners will just buy more hardware. Why? If they don’t, their competitors will and the odds of them getting block rewards will go down.
- ISL 7y agoI'm arguing the opposite -- if energy cost more, less energy would be consumed by Bitcoin.
- lone_haxx0r 7y agoThat's not Bitcoin's fault though. Otherwise, we could also argue that iPhones are a humanitarian disaster.
- newguy1234 7y agoCryptocurrencies provide benefits that banks do not provide. That's why people use them in the first place.
- wiggler00m 7y agoCodswallop.
- reaperducer 7y agoI wonder how that compares to mining various precious metals.
- your-nanny 7y agoif true Bitcoin needs to die, and eventually will under its own weight.
- your-nanny 7y agoHere is the proposition: let's make an inherently deflationary currency suitable for black market transactions that will become even more polluting with every transaction. CryptoKidz: I'm in! But haters gonna hate, and downvoterz gonna downvote. what evs
- cwkoss 7y agoThe traditional financial system is the root cause a significantly greater amount of pollution.
- grapehut 7y agoPer transaction is intentionally a bit misleading, as the amount of power usage is proportional to how-much-power the block-reward can buy regardless of there being 1 or 1 million transactions. Not to mention, a single transaction can power an infinite amount of (wash) transactions thanks to 2nd layer stuff like the lightning network. So it'd be similarly misleading to try quote in terms of that. So the correct unit would be power usage, per block or time unit.
- mdavidn 7y agoThe average number of transactions per block is easy to measure historically. If each block takes 10 minutes, and the miner network indeed draws 73 TWh each year, then that works out to ~1.4 GWh per block.
- baroffoos 7y agoThe bitcoin network has a limited number of transactions per second that it can process (Limited by block size). Last time I checked the network was basically at the limit so per transaction is not an insane way of looking at it. I get what you mean, if you decide not to make a transaction, the energy still gets spent but the more you use bitcoin the more valuable it becomes which incentivizes miners to keep mining. Also someone elses transaction will just slot in to fill the gap left since there is a very limited amount of space for transactions which is always fully utilized.
- optimiz3 7y agoNowhere near the limit, and hasn't been for a while: https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#0,24h https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#0,24h
- jimmydorry 7y agoNot exactly. Second layer transactions sit on top, so the hard max of 4200 "settlements"[1] in a block does not necessarily mean 4200 transactions. With enough people using the second layer network, each "settlement" could mean finalising hundreds of transactions for thousands of people. This second layer network acts like a caching layer, and consolidates many transactions into a single transaction (put into very simple terms). [1] Combinations of inputs and outputs.
- gleglegle 7y agoOne could drive an electric car for nearly 2000 miles with that much energy.
- y3k 7y agoOne of the main reasons why I dropped BTC. "Getting rich" at cost of the environment (extremely high resource consumption)? No thanks, I'd rather leave that world for future generations.
- newnewpdro 7y agoI have similar feelings, but if you apply this attitude uniformly it's nearly impossible to participate in the economy at all, since it's mostly riding on fossil fuels in one way or another. At least with bitcoin you could theoretically throw up a pile of solar panels and directly convert that clean electricity into money.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoAt current difficulty rates, what is the profitability formula for cost of electricity versus hashrate? example: if you aren't getting X Mh/s @ $Y kw/h, it isn't profitable?
- y3k 7y agoI'm not "smart enough" to calculate that acurately, but if the "cost per transaction" is high enough to get a couple of articles written about it, I won't participate into that. I'm more worried about humanity having a future.
- iopq 7y agoDepends on the hardware, mining difficulty, block reward. Right now? Something like 0.15 per kw/h is the break-even point, and if you're not getting below 0.10 you won't get the cost of your hardware back fast enough In other words, you should mine if you're in China where you can get those rates
- paulmd 7y agoto add: china often pays zero, because they're bribing local officials to ignore their bitcoin farms
- Reason077 7y agoTo put this in perspective, Bitcoin's 73.12 TWh annual energy consumption is enough to power over 10 million electric cars each driving 100 km (61 miles) daily, every day of the year.
- ctdonath 7y agoDefine “transaction”.
- qwerty456127 7y agoIf only governments and corporations did not insist on limiting people's freedom to trade freely and anonymously we wouldn't need that. Just make trading and privacy fundamental human rights like air breathing is and huge amount of energy will be saved.
- iikoolpp 7y agoDidn't realise cash was suddenly outlawed
- qwerty456127 7y agoC'mon, it's 21-st century, we need electronic cash we can send to a person we don't know instantly with a press of a button without revealing ourselves. We could use more traditional banking if only anonymous accounts were legal and banks were banking secrecy was guaranteed. I've never bought anything illegal (but some weed perhaps) yet I feel very uncomfortable every time I have to share my personal details with any party. I also want anonymous P/O boxes. I just bloody don't want any party to track me nor tell me what I am and what I am not allowed to buy (unless it's a weapon of mass destruction or a human slave and there are other ways to bust people selling these).
- DethNinja 7y agoDon’t worry it won’t be suddenly outlawed but all the governments will gradually outlaw it as it directly threatens their power. I hope somebody manages to release a conscious AI before they manage to completely outlaw it, otherwise it will be very hard to fight against tyrannical governments.
- cwkoss 7y agoIndia suddenly demonetized a large portion of circulating cash without warning. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/nov/08/india-withdraws-500-1000-rupee-notes-fight-corruption https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/nov/08/india-withdraw...
- ur-whale 7y ago
- pembrook 7y ago>"Single transaction footprint: Equivalent to the carbon footprint of 742,348 VISA transactions" One thing is clear, no matter how far blockchain technology progresses, proof-of-work will never reach the efficiency of a trusted intermediary.
- eindiran 7y agoThe way the model works is very interesting: 1. Calculate total mining revenues, across all miners in the Bitcoin network. 2. Estimate that, on average, miners spend 60% of their revenues on electricity. (I believe the origin of this number are the calculations in this paper [0]). 3. Find out how much miners pay per kWh on average. 4. Convert the costs into a consumption. There is some discussion of the origin of the assumptions, and some criticism and validation here [1] and here [2] respectively. [0] https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(18)30177-6 https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(18)30177-6 Specifically, see the calculations using Antminer S9 in Table 2. [1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#assumptions https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#assumpti... [2] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#validation https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption#validati...
- kneel 7y agosmall price to pay to put the vampire squids out of business
- paulsutter 7y agoThe Bitcoin network has a fixed transaction capacity that has no relation to the amount of power expended to mine bitcoin. The amount of power used is proportional to the value of the reward for successfully mining a new block, which happens about every 10 minutes (12.5 BTC or about $100k). If the value of BTC goes up miners will increase their spend and more power will be consumed per block mined, and if the value goes down so to will the power used. Regardless of the power used for mining, there is a fixed transaction capacity in the network.
- spookthesunset 7y agoPower used can also be a function of energy costs. It costs go down by half, miners will be incentivized to increase mining capacity (else their competition will) and as a result presumably energy consumption will double.
- privateSFacct 7y agoOr $68/transaction supposedly if electricity cost at 11 cents per KwH is used. Actual transaction fees run around $0.20 for on-chain which implies either math is wrong or per block reward is sufficient still (total blocks I believe are fixed with increasing difficulty). Does this analysis take into account secondary network transactions? For example wire transfers are relatively expensive to process still, but are often used to settle huge volumes of things like ACH payments, nightly sweeps etc.
- arcticbull 7y agoTransaction costs are currently being socialized across all holders. The block reward is sold to pay the power bill creating downward pressure on price for everyone.
- DanielleMolloy 7y agoCan someone tell me whether this is ever going to change? When the last bitcoin is mined?
- Rebelgecko 7y agoNot even then, and that won't be for a while. Even though about 85% of all BTC have been mined, the process gets exponentially slower the closer you get to the final blocks. After the last BTC is mined, miners will still presumably be able to profit from block transaction fees. That might help power a little bit since they'll worry more about being efficient with which transactions go into a block.
- iopq 7y agoBlock reward halves in about seven months, if the price doesn't go up, miners will start turning their rigs off.
- sword_smith 7y agoThis does not seem to include transactions on the Bitcoin Lightning network which are transaction that are handled offchain so they are not included in blocks. I don't have the exact number of lightning transaction ocurring but it is the Bitcoin Core developers' plan that the scaling to thousand of transactions per second will and should take place on the lightning network (this is where they differ from their competitor Bitcoin Cash which is aiming for bigger blocks and onchain scaling). Bitcoin is still a technology in its infancy ten years after being started.
- iopq 7y agoBecause they basically don't exist. How many Lightning transactions are there per day?
- spookthesunset 7y ago> Bitcoin is still a technology in its infancy ten years after being started. Meanwhile Apple introduced the first version of the iPhone, completely transforming the mobile landscape. Meanwhile, Uber and lyft upended the taxi market completely. Meanwhile, we have private companies sending payloads to the space station Meanwhile, electric cars are increasingly becoming mainstream. In what possible way can you claim bitcoin is “in its infancy”?
- sword_smith 7y agoThe market cap of Bitcoin is above 120bn USD, less than Apple and Facebook but more than Netflix. But that is still only about 0.1 to 1 % of its potential. So, big but in its infancy.
- jacobush 7y agoBesides it being completely different in other ways, the market cap is not value. You couldn't realize a tiny fraction of that without tanking the market cap.
- 7y ago
- desc 7y agoBitcoin is another wonderful example of trying to solve a people problem with technology. A complete and utter waste of resources, which at best fills a gap while the actual problem remains unsolved.
- Temasik 7y ago>central bank energy consumption index
- rlt 7y agoThis is obviously a problem if you expect small or even medium-sized transactions to be recorded on the blockchain itself. It's less obviously a problem if the blockchain is able to function as a "trust anchor" for additional protocol "layers", e.x. Lightning Network. TBD whether that actually works in practice at scale, but I believe it's Bitcoin's only hope.
- Temasik 7y agoHN think segwit is BitCoin hahahaha BitCoin is a world computer
- danfo 7y agoShut it down. Can a couple of these people agree that a well-coordinated merge & release to sabotage proof of work is ethical. https://github.com/orgs/bitcoin/people https://github.com/orgs/bitcoin/people
- kinghajj 7y agoEven if you got a maintainer to commit and release code to disable PoW, you'd still have to get enough node operators to update, which... I doubt would happen.
- k-ian 7y agoThat would be difficult to pull off. bitcoin code merges are highly scrutinized, and disagreements in blockchain projects just result in forks and new networks. A better way would be a global ban coordinated among every nation, and even then that would be difficult to pull off.
- danfo 7y agoDifficult to pull off, but they could make it happen. The earned value would need to transition to the non-proof-of-work favoured network. Turmoil would take care of the $ value of the forks (crypto confidence is rattled enough as it is)
- myroon5 7y agoUnrelated to the content itself, I like the inclusion and format of the Recommended Reading section, especially "If you find an article missing from this list please report it here, and it will be added as soon as possible."
- fitzroy 7y agoNew Dark Forest theory: The universe is teeming with alien civilizations that have survived The Great Filter ...but they all built Dyson spheres around their respective stars to harness the maximum amount of energy for mining cryptocurrency. Now they pass the time counting their money until their stars burn out.
- jeremyw 7y agoThe contrarian take on Bitcoin and carbon is that Bitcoin chases the cheapest energy, and solar is quickly becoming the cheapest source. In some areas of the world it already is (various subsidized infra in China). See Ramez Naam (co-chair for energy and the environment at Singularity University) for more on this friendliness to proof-of-work. This is a good intro: https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2019/09/16/64-ramez-naam-on-renewable-energy-and-an-optimistic-future/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2019/09/16/64-r...
- Geee 7y agoThat's correct. Bitcoin actually accelerates the adoption of renewables because it provides an instant economic incentive to build e.g. solar in places where electricity demand doesn't provide high return on the investment.
- newguy1234 7y agoThe problem is bitcoin needs baseload power, not variable because the mining equipment is expensive. This is why bigger mining farms are located near large hydropower areas. BTC miners run their equipment 24/7/365.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoTo put this somewhat in perspective, we can look at Wh/$ From the article, Bitcoin used 73.12 * 10^12 Wh and generated $5,749,979,074 in mining revenue Googling shows that the US economy used 3.82 * 10^15 Wh and generated $ 19.39 * 10^12 in GDP So bitcoin uses 12,716 Wh of electricity for every $ of revenue, and the US economy uses 197 Wh of electricity for every $ of GDP.
- lukev 7y agoThe energy consumption of Bitcoin isn't new news. What continues to disappoint me, however, is how many people immediately jump to its defense with arguments based on the value it provides, as if that offset its cost. What gets neglected is that the Bitcoin algorithm is inherently wasteful. By its very design, it results in an insane amount of duplicated, pointless computation. The question isn't whether something like Bitcoin can provide any value. The question is whether we have better options. And the answer is: we do, by far. From proof-of-stake (like Ethereum is moving towards) or trust-based models (like Stellar), technologies exist that grant almost all the benefits of Bitcoin at tiny fraction of the environmental (and monetary!) cost. I give Bitcoin credit for being an interesting "first answer" to an extremely hard problem. But it is in no way something that we should be doubling down on.
- donatj 7y agoWith energy becoming more and more renewable, does it really matter if BTC uses a lot of it?
- viraptor 7y agoUntil most mining moves to renewables, yes it does.
- chroem- 7y agoIt already is due to energy being the biggest mining expense. Miners congregate around inexpensive sources of hydroelectric/wind/solar energy.
- viraptor 7y agoOk, I should be more clear. Until we have enough energy that we're all running on renewables and adding more bitcoin-related load uses up spare capacity rather than increase overall usage - it matters. I mean, unless it's a dedicated power generating station, you're still using renewable power which is not used by someone else and overall we're supplementing that with coal and others.
- jron 7y agoSome counter points to consider: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvFqEofdAZ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvFqEofdAZ0 More nuanced: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTelx_iGajE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTelx_iGajE
- hndamien 7y agoBitcoin appears to be highlighting the issue of how we price dirty energy vs clean energy. There is nothing Bitcoin miners would like more than for all energy have the correlated carbon tax associated with it in the price.
- DonHopkins 7y agoBitcoin is China's way of exporting subsidized coal via the atmosphere. https://www.buybitcoinworldwide.com/mining/china/#reason-2-excess-coal https://www.buybitcoinworldwide.com/mining/china/#reason-2-e... Reason #2: Excess Coal Coal is the cheapest power source but also the dirtiest. It’s well-known that China has comparatively lax environmental policies. Major cities like Beijing are notorious for their high levels of smog, produced mostly by burning coal. Energy producers can freely burn coal and use the energy for Bitcoin mining. Instead of physically transporting the coal, it’s easier and more cost-effective to establish a Bitcoin mining operation near a source of coal and convert carbon directly to crypto. #Bitcoin enables Chinese entrepreneurs to export coal by burning it and using the energy to mine. https://twitter.com/el33th4xor/status/623178828727361536 https://twitter.com/el33th4xor/status/623178828727361536 #Bitcoin enables Chinese entrepreneurs to export coal by burning it and using the energy to mine. — Emin Gün Sirer (@el33th4xor) July 20, 2015 FTA: Carbon footprint Bitcoin’s biggest problem is perhaps not even its massive energy consumption, but the fact most mining facilties in Bitcoin’s network are located in regions (primarily in China) that rely heavily on coal-based power (either directly or for the purpose of load balancing). To put it simply: “coal is fueling Bitcoin” (Stoll, 2019). https://www.wired.com/story/bitcoins-climate-impact-global-cures-local/ https://www.wired.com/story/bitcoins-climate-impact-global-c... Bitcoin's Climate Impact Is Global. The Cures Are Local. To measure bitcoin's contribution to global warming, you need to know where it is mined and where those computers get their electricity. ... Not so fast, said county officials. They pointed to a different culprit: a giant coal plant halfway across the state. If energy from the dam went to bitcoin mining, they said, the county as a whole would wind up using more coal. In April, officials required all future mines to build their own renewable power. Missoula County was on the right track, says Christian Stoll, an energy researcher at the Technical University of Munich. In a paper published Wednesday in the journal Joule, his team takes a closer look at the energy consumption of bitcoin mining, based on where miners are located and the types of machines they are using. “Coal is fueling Bitcoin,” he says. “The question is how to prevent it, and that’s up to local regulators.”
- lone_haxx0r 7y ago> convert carbon directly to crypto That's the coolest phrase I've read today. What would someone from before Bitcoin think about that?
- spyder 7y agoIceland using more electricity for bitcoin mining than for its households is interesting, but at least it's a greener energy: https://qz.com/1204840/iceland-will-use-more-electricity-mining-bitcoins-than-powering-homes/ https://qz.com/1204840/iceland-will-use-more-electricity-min... but reopening closed coal power plants for crypto mining is more worrying: https://qz.com/1250980/an-australian-coal-power-plant-will-reopen-to-help-mine-bitcoins/ https://qz.com/1250980/an-australian-coal-power-plant-will-r...
- exabrial 7y agoFor anyone that wants to promote a free-market cryptocurrency ecosystem, my suggestion is to look at the Stellar Foundation. Doesn't fill the earth with C02, and enables trades across borders
- aey 7y agohttps://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.13302.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.13302.pdf only 2 nodes away from failing :)
- exabrial 7y agoOne transaction of bitcoin: > Equivalent to the power consumption of an average U.S. household over 21.13 days.
- zallarak 7y agoClarifications (this website perpetuates some common misconceptions): - A single bitcoin "transaction" can actually have thousands of inputs and thousands of outputs. So energy "per transaction" or "transactions per second" is not analogous to a typical monetary transaction. - Bitcoin does not compete with literal credit card transactions (although some use it like that today). I'd compare Bitcoin on-chain transactions with how nation-states settle their central-bank ledgers with gold. Gold is the best comparison to Bitcoin because trading in hard gold is "final". Credit card transactions happen on a higher level in the financial stack. As does cash. As do bank transfers. All of these bubble down into interbank transfers that eventually settle on the base layer of central banks. So compared to shipping and securing gold, Bitcoin is quite cheap! - Adding to the above point; if Bitcoin succeeds in beind "adopted", it would not mean we no longer use credit cards. Credit cards would just port their underlying mechanism on top of Bitcoin instead of fiat moneys.
- blueprint 7y agoDon't know why you were downvoted. Excellent comment.
- sschueller 7y agoBecause many believe that Satoshi's vision was to do quick on chain transactions and be used like cash not like gold.
- fierarul 7y agoPerhaps the Satoshi group should have called their invention BitGold instead of BitCoin? Although it's normal to see tech guys bad at marketing/branding.
- nrp 7y agoThe linked website attempts to quantify the impact with some stated assumptions. You’ve stated some alternative assumptions, but haven’t quantified the conclusions to determine if they hold. I’ve been long on Bitcoin, but I am exiting my position over concerns about the environment impact. I don’t think it’s plausible that a proof-of-work based blockchain can be anywhere near as efficient as centralized ledgers are. If any of the proof-of-stake based solutions ever gain traction, maybe I’ll participate in those.
- dnprock 7y agoBitcoin has grown a complex mining ecosystem that is pretty difficult to understand. Bitcoin has high level of energy consumption because of its demand. If demand goes down, energy consumption will go down. From what I've seen in the market, Bitcoin works the best. Many coins attempt to tweak this Proof of Work model. The result is not wasted energy but wasted human effort. What we need is to go back and explore Bitcoin Proof of Work model. It's works and simplest to configure. I create Bitflate, a Bitcoin fork with constant inflation. I get to see a small-scale, simpler version of Bitcoin energy consumption. Currently, it costs me about $3/day to mine coins and verify transactions. I get about 12-14 TH/s. That is cheap for running a digital ledger system. It's cheaper than renting any server on AWS. I imagine, in the future, businesses can run private permissioned digital ledger system to verify their own transactions. A Proof of Work system like Bitcoin is not wasteful.
- me551ah 7y agoThe most powerful supercomputer in the world reaches 143 petaflops, bitcoin network in comparison reaches 80704290.84 Petaflops. Granted that a majority of this computing power is in the form of custom ASIC's, but the figure is really staggering. And all of the 80704290.84 Petaflops, consume 73.12 TWh to repeatedly calculate SHA256 ! What could be the world's most powerful network does absolutely nothing but crunch hashes billions of times to discard almost all of the results anyway. Sheer waste of computing power.
- foepys 7y agoThat's like saying a water bottle factory has only an output of N water bottles per day while the Three Gorges Dam can output N million liters of water a day with the difference that the Three Gorges Dam actually produces something useful, electricity, while doing so. Just because it's a higher number, it doesn't mean it's equally useful.
- arcticbull 7y agoIt's more like instead of using the Three Gorges Dam to generate power you use the giant flow of water to fill 7 water bottles per second and divert the rest to dry up in a nearby salt flat, citing the renewability of the solution.
- dx034 7y agoSo supercomputers produce nothing useful but the bitcoin network does? In the long term I'm not sure we gained anything so far by all the energy spent on bitcoins. Some people got richer, some got poorer but I've yet to see any benefits for society from bitcoin.
- antpls 7y agoMaybe there are more values in investing into SHA256 hardware other than Bitcoin. That's 80704290.84 petaflops dedicated to break the SHA256 algorithm (finding a duplicate). Finding such duplicate could advance knowledge, mathematics, cyber security, society, etc
- the_svd_doctor 7y ago
- MichaelMoser123 7y agoI read that some miners operate right next to hydro electric stations where electricity comes cheap, that would mean they are using excess energy that would have been lost in transit? https://news.bitcoin.com/how-big-hydro-power-partners-with-bitcoin-miners-to-prevent-energy-waste/ https://news.bitcoin.com/how-big-hydro-power-partners-with-b...
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoCannot the bitcoin developers put in a massive difficulty jump at this point? Just make mining useless. It won't solve the transaction cost, but I thought sharding was supposed to help that, although I never bothered to learn about lightning network.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y ago> Just make mining useless. This would make Bitcoin useless. > Cannot the bitcoin developers put in a massive difficulty jump at this point? No, because the miners will continue to run the useful version (for some definition of useful). Changing the algorithm would require a hard-fork and a hard-fork to turn down the network will result in the "new" branch of the fork ... turning down, while the old one continues.
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoWhy would people no longer mining make bitcoin useless? There's a supply of existing bitcoins that can be split to ludicrous degrees. Scarcity is already enforced by the difficulty, and a huge difficulty jump won't affect that. If bitcoin can't survive without mining (which IIRC isn't related to transactional processing or any actual use of bitcoins), then bitcoin has a guaranteed uselessness point when the difficulty jumps exceed, I dunno, the output of the sun? As for code changes, what is the lightning network about? Isn't that a code change? And if every major exchange enforced the switch, and miners kept mining coins that the exchanges didn't take, then those coins would be worth much less. I'm not saying the code change is easily done or even technically feasible. But it should be considered. Bitcoin is immoral in the age of human global warming.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y ago> Why would people no longer mining make bitcoin useless? Because mining is what secures the network. > which IIRC isn't related to transactional processing Transactions are confirmed by being included in mined blocks. The amount of compute power burned to mine that block, and the following blocks, is what prevents someone from pretending a different transaction (moving the money somewhere else - a double-spend) happened first. > what is the lightning network about? Isn't that a code change? Software running on top of the existing mining network, although downwards-compatible changes were made to enable it. The downwards-compatible is key here. > if every major exchange enforced the switch, and miners kept mining coins that the exchanges didn't take, Then someone would make an exchange that still trades "original Bitcoin" and get rich, and the exchanges would go bankrupt. More sensible and less controversial changes failed or resulted in splits (with the chain that remained downwards compatible being the most valuable one). (Downwards compatible is the easiest approximation I can come up with for the much more complicated reality.)
- kbody 7y agoQuite arguable numbers that seem to be used to drive traffic to this site rather than do a proper scientific report like done by the University of Cambridge https://cbeci.org/ https://cbeci.org/ The CO2 emissions heavily depend on the actual use of renewable which nobody can be sure about. In some cases like bitcoin mining using fuel that would otherwise cause CO2 emissions, you actual have a net gain. (See companies like https://www.upstreamdata.ca/ https://www.upstreamdata.ca/) So even by those arguable arguable CO2 emissions it's actually less than 0.1% of the world's total. I wish people that have knee-jerk reactions about this, actual think about the big picture and what actually causes high CO2 emissions and offer way fewer benefits than censorship-resistant money. The luxury fashion industry for example for a long time has had a big negative effect, from drying up whole lakes, to child labor to effectively destroying villages for what... anyhow.
- heimatau 7y agoThe idea that bitcoin is 'wasteful' is entirely missing the solution that bitcoin is. Byzantine Generals Problem. This network is unmatched in it's provability and security. There is a turing complete machine, operating that can be trusted. Seriously, the possibilities are limitless but guess what, they do have a cost. And there are too many con-artists around. But an industry that is changing the entire monetary policy around world is very impactful. It's changing it and you'll notice in the coming years how much monetary policy is going to change. The grand experiment is about to happen. Are we going back to gold? Are we going to innovate a replacement that's better than crypto? How is 'money' going to function in the 21st century? P.S. Proof of Stake is terrible in it's economics. If you think rent-seeking is good, then PoS is for you. It's not for me and I think it's terrible based on the game theory of it. Remember the 'We are the 99%' chants? Yeah, not going to go over well.
- Kbelicius 7y agoIf PoS is rent-seeking how come PoW isn't rent-seeking?
- heimatau 7y agoIn a PoW network (read Bitcoin), those that have the currency (satoshis/'sats') don't gain any more sats by just possessing them. The only way to gain more is from either those that have some or to mine more (until 2140). In a PoS network, those that have the currency can "stake" their possessions to gain more. They don't need to spend in hardware/electricity to mine more. There is a built in function to extract currency.
- btcd 7y agoAlthough interesting in its own right, Bitcoin's energy consumption is in no way a good basis on which to judge its social value. Bitcoin is fundamentally an asset. A useful analogy is to think of it as gold. Gold can be used to make payments, but it is not convenient. Same goes for Bitcoin. But they are both useful as a robust way of storing value. Maintaining the Bitcoin network costs energy, but almost nothing else. Given Bitcoin's price history, it's safe to assume that Bitcoin's total energy cost is a tiny fraction of its current market cap of around $150b. Now compare that to the social costs of protecting gold, which probably has an over $7 trillion market cap. Wars were fought and lives lost for its ownership. In conclusion: a large and liquid crypto asset like Bitcoin provides a much more advanced solution of value storage and transfer than traditional physical assets. Its net social benefits should be orders of magnitudes higher than its energy expenditure.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoAre the smooth raises and flat lines in the estimated values explained somewhere? Seems highly questionable if the hash rate is fluctuating.
- cryptica 7y agoIt's disturbing that people are still praising Bitcoin in spite of that fact that it can only handle at most 4 transactions per second and consumes as much energy as Austria. Same goes for Ethereum at 15 TPS... Ethereum is an over-engineered mess of technical debt. It's been stretched way past its original design goals. All these valuable cryptocurrencies are a symptom of a failing capitalist system. The only reason that they had value in the first place was because the rest of the economy was so inefficient and speculative that they started to look like a wise investment in comparison (especially as a hedge). The rise of useless jobs is real, this is especially true in the cryptocurrency industry. The amount of human effort and talent which has been wasted on Bitcoin, Ethereum and other overhyped, poorly engineered cryptocurrencies is staggering. Not only is it wasteful, but this industry is producing a new wave of engineers and scientists who are gullible (hype-driven), unskilled and complacent; a dangerous combination. Most cryptocurrency projects were created by juniors who had limited understanding of distributed systems and scalability at the time. If Vitalik Buterin had to start Ethereum from scratch today (knowing what he knows now), I think he would design it very differently. But instead, he is forced to support the existing network and protocol even though the only real way to fix the project is by starting from scratch with a new foundation. It's like if you start building a 1-storey apartment and after you finish, you realize that you actually needed a skyscraper; but instead of starting again from scratch, you decide to re-use the existing building foundation with the same investors, same architects, same engineers, same builders. You even allow the existing tenants continue to live inside the house while you continue building on top. It's probably not going to work because you don't have the right foundation, your team doesn't have experience building tall structures and you don't have any experience leading projects of such complexity - The fact is that your odds of success are extremely low; your foundation is probably not strong enough, your team is probably not smart enough and not adaptable enough and you, the leader, are probably not humble enough to accept reality; so you will fail to take the necessary steps to fix the problems.
- cortic 7y ago>energy consumption of VISA offices isn’t included
- bmking 7y agoA little late to the party, but here are my two cents. First of all I also want to mention "Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index" (https://www.cbeci.org https://www.cbeci.org). In my opinion it makes better comparisons (https://www.cbeci.org/comparisons/ https://www.cbeci.org/comparisons/). The strongest hypothetical argument against the consumption is that Bitcoin incentivizes green energy. The mining operation is mostly interested in one thing: access to the cheapest electricity possible. Currently China is still subsidizing electricity, which has attracted a lot of Chinese miners and apparently is tolerated by the state. But in the longer run I believe that Bitcoin will be the thing that will allow investments into green energy on a big scale. This is currently only happening by e.g. governments guaranteeing a minimum electricity price with other horrible consequences (see Germany: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.focus.de%2Fimmobilien%2Fenergiesparen%2Fregenerative_energie%2Fnegative-strompreise-deutschland-verschenkt-tausende-euro-ans-ausland-die-rechnung-zahlt-der-verbraucher_id_8309486.html https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...). Bitcoin however provides the incentive by itself to invest into green energy. This also is regardless of the fact that where there are optimal conditions for green energy often no infrastructure is available to add it to the grid. Bitcoin only needs an internet connection and consumes energy on-site. Regarding arguments that compare transactions with energy spent (comparing apples-to-banana...), I will make a counter-comparison: "The amount of electricity consumed every year by always-on but inactive home devices in the USA alone" spends three times the energy of the Bitcoin network (see "Fun Facts" at https://www.cbeci.org/comparison https://www.cbeci.org/comparison). Comparing the energy consumption of a transaction is meaningless, because this transaction may enable thousands of off-chain transactions (see Lightning network) and vary in actually block-spent-size depending on if it aggregates many actual transactions or not. It also shouldn't be a surprise that a lot of energy went into it in the first place, since otherwise the whole point of Bitcoin, namely being open, borderless, censorship-resistant and neutral, wouldn't be possible. It's like saying that all the many maintenance checks of airplanes (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft_maintenance_checks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft_maintenance_checks) wastes so and so many hours and energy of engineers' work-time, just because you don't see that they make air travel safer.
- hexo 7y agoI don't think this makes even sense to account. Try to look at internets energy consumption as a whole and how much of it "makes" sense and provides real value - tranferring memes, DDoSes, ADs and so. Look at all animated websites - how needed is this "feature", what value it provides (usability? haha) and how much total energy it consumes in sum across all devices. I really "love" that Belgium uses city night lights on their highways - this is total nonsense. Compared to these, Bitcoin energy consumption makes complete sense.
- Empact 7y agoIt makes no sense to me to put Bitcoin under different scrutiny than, say, Christmas lights, Netflix or the US Military. We need to decarbonize our energy sources, but Bitcoin or not is not the answer to how. https://bitcoinist.com/bitcoin-mining-energy-consumption-us-christmas-lights/ https://bitcoinist.com/bitcoin-mining-energy-consumption-us-... https://www.thesun.co.uk/tech/9062282/netflix-energy-crisis-fears/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/tech/9062282/netflix-energy-crisis-... http://theconversation.com/us-military-is-a-bigger-polluter-than-as-many-as-140-countries-shrinking-this-war-machine-is-a-must-119269 http://theconversation.com/us-military-is-a-bigger-polluter-...
- RichardHeart 7y agoI developed something that can help reduce some of these problems. The energy used to mine a resource trends towards the value of the resource. The resource in cryptocurrencies is the block reward + fees. One can reduces pollution by paying miners only transaction fees and not inflation. One further increase savings by utilizing an existing network, and employing time locks. More hashrate is not what matters most. Hashrate from honest, non cooperative parties is what makes the system censorship and collusion resistant. It's interesting to note that the people you "defend" yourself against in sha256 hashing are only the very same people you're paying, as only they have equipment relevant to attacking. On GPU and CPU mined algos, hash rate matters more as a larger set of humans can become attackers.
- H8crilA 7y agoHow much would an average BTC transaction cost with proper carbon emissions pricing? Carbon emissions are already priced in Europe.
- daniel_ameli 7y agoOne bitcoin transaction is not directly comparable to one transaction on other payment systems. One bitcoin transaction can represent thousands or millions of transactions. It isn't fair to say bitcoin requires this amount of electricity. Different people all over the world choose to spend electricity to try to find new bitcoin. The amount of new bitcoin is exponentially decaying to zero. It's like telling someone their gold jewelry uses up too much electricity because someone they don't know is spending electricity to mine gold. Some amount of mining is necessary for the security of the network. Most global endeavors use electricity, whether it is traditional finance or video games. Bitcoin mining believed to be one of the greenest industries (a very high percent of electricity comes from solar, wind, and hydrolelectric). This is due to some of the cheapest electricity in the world being from green energy in remote places (and bitcoin mining is extremely portable)
- zornado 7y agoBitcoin is good for the economy because it encourages spending. It's better than having a electricity as a resource and not using it. Miners buy equipment which is income to the producer. Also increases employment in the power plant and the factory producing the equipment.
- mcnichol 7y agoDo your research on the guy who writes these articles. Alex de Vries (blockchain hobbyist with no scientific / economics background who started digiconomist) https://hackernoon.com/the-reports-of-bitcoin-environmental-damage-are-garbage-5a93d32c2d7 https://hackernoon.com/the-reports-of-bitcoin-environmental-... Oh yeah, and he invented this energy consumption index...stop letting yourself get trolled.