4 ms·
According to that chart, it’s too late to do anything now. (Arguably, it’s always been too late. There is nothing we could’ve done even starting in 1990 that wo
by rayiner 7y ago
According to that chart, it’s too late to do anything now. (Arguably, it’s always been too late. There is nothing we could’ve done even starting in 1990 that would avert climate change while accommodating the industrialization or China, India, and Africa.)
If you turn off the natural gas plants now, the economy shuts down whenever the wind stops blowing or the sun stops shining. The alternative energy storage you need to back up renewables simply doesn’t exist yet.
Yes, we needed to use nuclear back in the 1970s. We would be much better positioned today if we had done it. But the same type of environmentalists that want to ban fracking today are the folks who stymied nuclear uptake. We shouldn’t listen to them this time.
- cagenut 7y agoWhat part of that report, the linked graph, or my comment said anything about turning off the natural gas plants now? Why is it so impossible for anyone to read and understand a graph without engaging in such wantonly shitty logic. That graph says we should stop building NEW gas (and coal and oil) infrastructure. Typical plants and projects are scoped in the 10 - 30 year time range, that graph is a 30 year time range. All that has to happen is we shift what we purchase and invest in going forward. Its such an underwhelmingly simple answer that people seem to miss it in their yearning for a fight.
- bpodgursky 7y agoFracking in the US is very low-infrastructure. It's not like the 10-30 years it takes to spin up a deep-sea drill rig. It's literally a month or two and a couple million dollars. Here are some actual numbers: https://www.roseassoc.com/the-current-costs-for-drilling-a-shale-well/ https://www.roseassoc.com/the-current-costs-for-drilling-a-s... That's the whole reason it has taken off -- you turn it on when prices are high, you turn it off when prices are low. We aren't committing to 30 years of energy policy by fracking in the US. You're committing a to maybe a couple years to pay off the investment.
- rayiner 7y agoThis part? > The remaining available carbon budget does not afford for a two-step transition. All investment in carbon emission producing generation needs to be replaced with investment in non-carbon-emitting generation, starting "in 2020" but honestly that's just politician talk. The real deadline is "fucking yesterday". First, this is a response to someone who suggested we ban fracking. We will need fracking for the foreseeable future to power natural gas peaker plants. So your response to me doesn’t really make sense in context if you’re not actually supporting a fracking ban. Second, until we have replacement technology, we need to replace retiring coal plants with natural gas even as we invest in renewables. Renewables are, at this stage, not stand alone power. More renewables means we need more peaker plants capacity to balance it out. That means fracking will have to continue and even increase over the next 20-30 years as we shift to more renewables.
- sitkack 7y agoThe problem isn't really that hard, we need to have vast far reaching austerity measures be put into place immediately or the human race AND human civilization will cease to exist. People that make arguments like yours beg the question as to economic progress and standards of living. Standards of living should drop overall, but should normalize across the population. A smooth transition is not possible.
- javagram 7y agoAFAIK the extreme, apocalyptic statements you are making are not supported by the science such as the IPCC. 3-4 degrees C of warming by 2100 will not make the human race or civilization cease to exist. There are also technological options available to us to cool the planet such as seeding the upper atmosphere with dust, which we have not yet used and could provide some additional time to switch to sustainable energy production means. In any case, a non-smooth transition is not possible right now. Look at France which was paralyzed by “yellow vest” protests for a fuel tax increase until it was rolled back - the needed carbon taxes are far higher than that small tax increase. Right now the best scenario is to continue R&D and target promotion of sustainable energy, not attempt to reduce people’s standard of living which a democratic society will refuse to accept.
- petre 7y agoIt's not too late to bootstrap more nuclear, but big nuclear plants don't make less sense economically nowadays. SMRs on the other hand do. NuScale's design is very interesting.
- cagenut 7y agoIt is specifically, exactly, too late to wait for that. Did you not look at the graph? I'm all for continued and increased R&D funding, but the best case scenario for SMRs is they help us with the back half of the transition (2035 - 2050) not the front half (2020 - 2035). Anything more optimist than that is simply denying the science (see ipcc report again).
- petre 7y agoI did look at the graph and 2035-2050 is a better scenario than never.
- cagenut 7y agoIt is an utterly lost cause to discuss things with people on the internet. I specifically said "wait for" and somehow you turned that into "never". Seriously someone just ban me from this dumb site, no one can read.