16 ms·
What to Do When You Get Sherlocked by Apple
- api 7y agoOne of the first examples of being Sherlocked was done by Microsoft when they basically killed Netscape by adding Internet Explorer to Windows.
- remote_phone 7y agoAn earlier one is in MS-DOS when they added Doublespace disk compression which killed Stacker.
- oceanghost 7y agoNo finer way was there to lose data.
- blueboo 7y agoThe finest way is to run Catalina on a $5000 iMac Pro.
- auggierose 7y agoTry running it on a $10000 iMac Pro. No data loss yet ;-)
- remote_phone 7y agoIf your business can be replaced so easily, then unfortunately what you have built is a feature, not a product.
- rubbingalcohol 7y agoRTFA
- oldmanhorton 7y agoLarge tech companies have the resources to clone any single piece of software engineering or hardware engineering. The marginal cost of developing a new "feature" of their existing "product" is so small in the grand scheme of things. As long as you have software engineers, money, and an idea, you can make something like sidecar real; this company needed to create all three from scratch, Apple has oodles of the first two and can easily steal ideas for the third. With that being said, if the only definition of a product is something that Apple can't replicate, then I'm afraid we are damn near out of products. (Again, this applies to every large tech company, not just apple)
- lonelappde 7y agoYou can make something that the big co doesn't want to make, like something user customizable.
- toyg 7y agoWhich is effectively what OP says in the blogpost: they will go on by offering more advanced features in the product that was more customizable.
- tjalfi 7y agoLarge tech companies can replicate anything but it doesn't make sense for them to clone products sold in a small market. Legal operations software, for example, is about a 1 billion market[0]. Your startup can compete in this space but it's too small to be worth pursing for Microsoft. [0] https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2019/07/05/1878916/0/en/Global-Legal-Operations-Software-Market-Worth-Reach-USD-3-565-Million-By-2027-Zion-Market-Research.html https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2019/07/05/187891...
- threeseed 7y agoCompanies can clone features not products. And they will only do so in a market that is core to them.
- 7y ago
- theferalrobot 7y agoThat seems unnecessarily cheeky. If you can make money on it, its a product, if someone builds it in to their product line, perhaps they did it better (though not always).
- prepend 7y agoYou can make money off many things that aren’t products. Pedantically we might be right that anything revenue is product, but I think it’s the difference between a real product and an add on that people only buy because hey are buying something else. The advice is useful because if I’m building a feature I will either be purchased by a product or eventually be added into a product.
- theferalrobot 7y agoI can see what you are saying. Perhaps a third option of advice is being suggested here which is diversify your feature to make it better than a built in solution or diversify your business to make it resilient to these types of loss.
- prepend 7y agoI think that’s a good strategy. As long as I’ve paid attention (85+) there have been “feature” companies selling addons and stuff on top of windows, Mac, Oracle, etc. I think the risk is thinking you are a product company when actually a feature company and then not diversifying.
- dahart 7y agoIf what you have is a business that pays the teams salaries, then what you built is by definition a product, not a feature.
- AndrewKemendo 7y ago"Easily" in this case is a trillion dollar company throwing multiples of what you could without really blinking. Spending $10M worth of resources on a project within Apple is not even notable, meanwhile that's a healthy series A for a startup.
- mthoms 7y agoYou're using this trope entirely out of context. There are only handful of companies (Google and FB come to mind) that make products for Apple's platform that Apple can't easily replicate itself.
- damnyou 7y agoMaybe the government should get in the way then.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoIt's probably too early to know if astropad can actually survive this, or if it can create a sustainable business so this article is premature. My company was Sherlocked in 2017 when Apple released ARKit and our flagship product, an AR SDK with SLAM was made obsolete overnight. We knew it was coming, but didn't know when, so we diversified into mobile-web computer vision products before it happened. Didn't matter though, the third party mobile AR tool landscape isn't robust enough to sustain more than a handful of content companies. All the hard tech in AR is being done by FB, Goog and Apple so we were dead in the long run anyway. We were lucky though that a niche market for our mobile web product was desirable enough for an acquisition and we found that offramp. I don't think most companies can survive a sherlocking.
- tpmx 7y ago> For our team of just 13 people In the 1990s, 2000s, or heck even early 2010s this would have been an open source utility that someone had spent a few months building as a passion project. And then 5-10 people from around the world would have pitched in a work week here and there to make it work really well and lots of people using it would be really happy from using it. Now, because everything that possibly can be monetized needs to be monetized.. it has to be monetized. And everything needs to be made into a company, with programmers, product management, marketing, HR, legal etc etc. I hate to defend Apple here, because I think they are beginning to halt progress rather than bring it forward, but.. meh. It's just a goddamn feature. You can't call dibs on obvious features. (And in terms of obviousness, I think this one is a lot more obvious than Sherlock.)
- otterley 7y agoOn the "obviousness" judgment - maybe, maybe not. A lot of people claim post-hoc that something was "obvious" but it's usually Monday-morning quarterbacking. If something was so "obvious" then why wasn't it done before? Food for thought. What I will say is that I think - despite the harm to the specific developer of the competing product - that adding new features to the OS for free is a net positive for consumers. It's one less thing they have to pay for out of their own pockets, and enhances the overall value of the product and its ecosystem.
- scarface74 7y agoStep 1: Allow iOS apps to use AirPlay to create a separate display from an iOS device. Step 2: Allow Macs to use AirPlay to create a separate display from a Mac. Step 3: “We have this nice beatific light display call the iPad and we already have the capability of low latency AirPlay”..... Is that not obviously the next step?
- otterley 7y agoIt wasn’t to me. Was it to you? Even if it was, how would you prove such a thing?
- mondoshawan 7y agoUsually I root for the underdog, but in this case, it was almost inevitable. I have both Astropad and a iPad Pro, and I have to say that they priced themselves out of the market straight out of the gate by using a high cost subscription (~$20/mo) plus ~$20 for the hardware dongle. At these prices, professionally it's actually cheaper to just go buy an Intuos because it will perform better in every way and doesn't cost you over time. TBH, I'm actually surprised this didn't happen sooner -- it's the obvious solution to a lagging Adobe Photoshop and pro tools that immediately give the iPad strong value and staying power.
- dahart 7y agoMaybe this is also the obvious outcome of Apple refusing to put a touchscreen on the laptops, fearing cross-cutting of iPad sales. It’s a surprise though that Apple is making some moves that appear to cater to pro users, since the overwhelming sentiment seems to be that Apple has completely abandoned the pro market. I loved my mac laptop, but it’s becoming very clear I can’t stay on the platform. I work with a lot of CG film companies and everyone I know feels the same way, that Apple no longer has any interest in customers doing high end design. I suddenly don’t know anybody who’s not migrating away from macOS.
- pram 7y agoYou believe this, despite them just announcing a tower Mac Pro. I'd say the very fact that they are even producing it precludes that they have 'abandoned' the pro market and customers doing high end design. If they had truly abandoned the segment they wouldn't bother.
- sfgweilr4f 7y agoI've talked to multiple audio / graphics studios and they are actively planning/executing their Apple exit strategy. Phasing out over several years. Started about 2-3 years go for most of them. Apple don't care about them because they can't even see them on their bottom line.
- dahart 7y agoI was surprised by how positive and constructive this article is considering the circumstances. Say what you want about whether it was foreseeable, being blindsided by your platform is not fun. I’m sure there were some swear words used the first couple of days, but some companies in the same situation have just closed up shop, so putting it behind you and moving on with hope and positivity, recognizing that there are still options, and noting that one of them is to stay there and compete with Apple, that’s commendable.
- saagarjha 7y agoGenerally, writing whining hit pieces doesn’t get you the kind of sympathy or support you’d want. Plus it just makes you look bad.
- PeterStuer 7y agoThis is what worked in a 'Sherlocked' case I was involved with: (1) Take a deep breath, don't pretend nothing happened (2) Don't just compete, look at how you can provide additional value to those customers that will also use the incumbent's offering (3) Get on with your roadmap on improving value for and delighting all your customers When Microsoft announced Teams [1], we thought our own team collaboration product [2] would be severely impacted. Not that we were surprised that Microsoft came out with this product after having lauded ours in the past. Team collaboration was always on their radar, and had been declared strategic for years. But I will not deny that it still makes you feel as if the ground beneath your feet is rumbling. We knew from past experiences, and our contacts, that Microsoft would push this product hard into their ecosystem. So we had to keep in mind that most of our customers would be aware of it if not already, soon, and at least there would be questions of whether they should consider going with Microsoft or not. But we also had been competing successfully for years as a 'small indie' shop against outfits that were swimming in VC money, so stiff competition was not a 'new' experience. However, Microsoft being the gorilla in the room stapling in their offering into O365 might be a different beast altogether. So what to do? First we acknowledged that going forward many of our customers would also have Teams, by choice or by company policy. So we looked at how our customers might benefit from having both. I think this is a key question you should ask. Not just 'how is my offer better than theirs', but how are both together better than just the competing offer from the behemoth? In our case this meant two things - making sure that you play nice with the new app, in a way that the experience of using both is seamless. - find specific scenarios where the users of the incumbent app benefit from having yours as well We developed an integration with Teams[3] that covered these points. We also doubled down on our roadmap, making sure that both standalone and dual app users receive increased value over time. Dual might be a bit of a misnomer since nearly 100% of our customer base even before Teams touched collaboration across different applications and services, Outlook and SharePoint being the most prominent. I'm not saying this is a recipe that will lead to guaranteed success in every case. It worked for us and we kept growing both our customer base and revenue all through the advent of Teams and thereafter. Of course I can not compare this to a world where Teams was never introduced. I remain however convinced that where possible, the strategy of not just competing but also adding value to those customers that chose or were forced onto the platform provider's own offer is far preferable to one were you just go head-to-head. Always offer the best product, but also offer the better-together experience. [1] https://products.office.com/en-us/microsoft-teams https://products.office.com/en-us/microsoft-teams [2] https://tasksinabox.com/apps https://tasksinabox.com/apps [3] https://tasksinabox.com/integrations/microsoft-teams-integration https://tasksinabox.com/integrations/microsoft-teams-integra...
- giancarlostoro 7y ago> We admittedly got swept up in a false romance with Apple. Over the past few years, Apple routinely invited us to demo our products at their headquarters, and offered to help us out with whatever business and engineering challenges we faced. They also ordered thousands of dollars’ worth of our hardware, and we naively thought it was because they were interested in our product. It turns out that they were… just not in the way we were thinking. Holy crap they got (HBO) Silicon Valley "Brain Raped."[0] What sickens me is that Apple wouldnt just outright buy them out instead. If you are designing something like this... Make sure you patent as much as possible. That would of guaranteed a buyout. Course not sure how patentable that idea would of been by now if they had other competitors. [0]: https://youtube.com/watch?v=JlwwVuSUUfc https://youtube.com/watch?v=JlwwVuSUUfc
- tpmx 7y agoAgain, I hate to defend such a fxxedxp company as Apple, but... Unless they divulged some really clever low-latency video compression optimizations during these meetings (I bet making the mouse cursor move with low latency was the #1 priority - everything else is boring plumbing)... I'm filing this under the "CEO's slightly dramatically exaggerated regrets", maybe for the benefits of his investors.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoExaggerated how? Not sure how the investors benefit. I am going to assume good intent from the author to just reflect on things. Hes not focused on his other projects. But he does have the right to link to them since they are relevant.
- tpmx 7y agoThat would be irresponsible speculation on my part, so no thanks.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoAgain how do investors benefit? There is usually motive behind ill intent, I am not seeing it. I have had moments similar but not quite as impacting as an entire OS adopting my ideas and I reflect from time to time on those moments. I have nothing to gain from sharing them though nor will anybody near me.
- pier25 7y agoApple reminds me of Amazon knowing which products are popular in its store and replicating them with its own brand.
- edent 7y agoI've read the whole article and I've literally no idea what either product does. I use a Mac for work - and most of user that I know don't slavishly follow the glorified press conference that Apple holds. I dare say most users don't know about most of the new features in the utility laptop they buy or are forced to use at work.
- egypturnash 7y agoThese are both tools for professional artists. Astropad lets you use your iPad as a second display for your Mac, with an emphasis on functioning as a tool for artists. It used to support multiple iPad styluses but moved to only supporting the Apple Pencil. Sidecar lets you use your iOS13 iPad as a second display for your Catalina Mac, with an emphasis on functioning as a tool for artists. I have not used it but I am pretty sure it only supports the Apple Pencil. Both of these are sort of functioning as an alternative to buying an external monitor with pressure-sensitive stylus support, which is generally going to be more expensive than a tablet - Wacom's Cintiq line, for instance, runs from $700 for a 13-inch screen to $3300 for a 32-inch screen. They are also in competition with the growing power of tablet apps; there's a lot of former Photoshop painters who have switched to Procreate or the tablet version of Manga Studio to get their work done.
- edent 7y agoThanks!
- coredog64 7y agoSidecar only works with very recent Macs. Any MBP with a functional keyboard isn’t on the list.
- crooked-v 7y ago> I have not used it but I am pretty sure it only supports the Apple Pencil. It works fine with touch. The Pencil just allows for more precision and easier secondary actions.
- 7y ago
- pcr910303 7y agoI'm sorry for Astropad as they have made such a good product, but to be honest, this doesn't feel like Astropad being sherlocked; I'm pretty sure Apple was experimenting with this from the very first iPad Pro. The idea to connect the iPad to use as a second display isn't that unique, there's Duet Display (founded by an ex Apple engineer), Astropad, and I think I've seen a couple of more apps. Watson was a pretty unique product; that's why people recognized Sherlock as a copy of Watson... but this feels like a company that developed a Voice Memo app for macOS complaining that macOS Mojave 'sherlocked' them by including Voice Memo by default.
- rolltiide 7y agoDoes anyone have an app that lets me draw on the ipad and show it live on my laptop? Is that what astropad and now Sidecar does? I resorted to joining Zoom meetings twice and sharing the screen with my ipad session as host and drawing in the Notes App
- glennpratt 7y agoThat's more of the inverse. I think an AirPlay receiver on your Mac might work, but I'm not sure. Sidecar, Duet Display and Astropad let you draw on your iPad as a secondary display for your Mac, using Mac apps.
- pixelmonkey 7y agoThat's a use case that the app Reflector 3 handles. It's sort of the inverse of Sidecar. Lets your Mac display you iPad, iPhone, or Android device live in OSX over WiFi, by implementing a desktop receiver for the Apple AirPlay and Google Cast protocols. https://www.airsquirrels.com/reflector https://www.airsquirrels.com/reflector
- fitzroy 7y agoThat's a pretty funny/clever hack (took me a minute to figure out you're Zooming with yourself). You can also try AirServer (similar to Reflector). There's a free trial. https://www.airserver.com https://www.airserver.com I use it mainly for audio streaming from my phone to my MacMini / Stereo, and sometimes to play Alto's Adventure on a projector. Or, if your Mac is compatible, just try Sidecar. There's a hack to make it work on older Macs, but I think officially it's tied to the ones that have hardware HEVC/h.265 support. http://osxdaily.com/2019/10/11/sidecar-compatible-mac-ipad-list/ http://osxdaily.com/2019/10/11/sidecar-compatible-mac-ipad-l...
- bhauer 7y agoI'm not in the Apple ecosystem so I've not previously heard of this product, nor Sidecar or the amusing verb "sherlocked." I don't have a lot to add except to say that the blog entry was substantially more insightful, honest, introspective, and valuable to the reader than I would have expected given the circumstances. The author and the company deserve a lot of credit for dealing with setbacks so graciously. Meanwhile, Apple deserves another helping of skepticism. I look forward to seeing what kinds of creative display tricks Astropad comes up with in their multi-platform adventures on Rust.
- ecmascript 7y agoI think the author is missing the most vital point and that is why you should develop web applications and not native applications, if possible. With native, you have big companies that is in control of the platform and can easily make it hard for you any time. Besides, with a web app, you can reach customers on many different platforms making it harder for one company to kill your business. The web on the other hand is open and no single company can just change it in a whim. Always believe in the web.
- igammarays 7y agoEverything can't be a web app. This is a good example of one.
- ecmascript 7y agoSure, but a lot of native apps could be web apps. What I wrote was a general rule and I added "if possible". For example, their graphical editor could perhaps be a web app instead of relying on big bad Apple.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- agota 7y agoThat was my takeaway from the article - web apps over native apps.
- ecmascript 7y agoYeah and here come the fanboys with their downvotes.. jeez.
- briandear 7y agoWeb apps are good for CRUD but little else. What film editor is going to edit a movie using a web browser? What kind of powerful image editing can you do on a web app? Who is going to use ForeFlight in a cockpit over the web? Who wants to play Call of Duty in a browser. The web is good for displaying information, but it’s not a 1-1 replacement for native.
- linuxftw 7y agoHow to have this not happen to you: 1) Have your work patented. 2) Be acquired by a larger firm that can enforce your patents. If you don't have a patent, then anyone can copy anything you create, and economies of scale are going to catch up to you and force you out of business. I personally don't believe in patents, but it's the only way to operate today.
- cycloptic 7y ago>Be acquired by a larger firm that can enforce your patents. You mean like Apple? What other firm is going to acquire a startup with products like this, which are so tightly tied into MacOS/iOS?
- briandear 7y agoWacom. Avid. Adobe. There are a lot of companies that would buy tech like Astropad. Adobe could have integrated it into CS for instance and it would have been a value-add for that audience.
- cycloptic 7y agoEven if the software itself ticks a nice box as a feature add to some other product, the patents wouldn't have fit into the portfolios of any of those companies. To make it a profitable investment they would have had to pre-meditate a licensing deal... with Apple.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deltron3030 7y agoProvide remote iPad features for Windows and Linux users!
- NelsonMinar 7y agoSeriously! The way to avoid Apple out-competing you on their own platform is to stop locking yourself in to Apple's ecosystem.
- zapzupnz 7y agoSeveral products already exist for this purpose, including Duet Display, one of the Splashtop products (can't remember which). I'm sure there are others. It made reading this article a bit off-putting because they seem to imagine they were the sole bearers of such a product; they were not and never have been.
- scarface74 7y agoThis has been possible since 2012. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/138762-how-to-use-your-ios-device-as-your-pc-second-display https://www.extremetech.com/computing/138762-how-to-use-your... You’ve also been able to hack stuff like this together using VNC.
- chrischen 7y agoI also used a VNC client to turn my iPhone into a trackpad my mac... slightly unrelated but no notable latency and similar tech used.
- xwdv 7y agoWhat people seem to forget is that this is nothing personal, only business. A company has the right to compete with your product, and you are not entitled to any sort of market share. That’s just the way capitalism works, and the consumers are better off because of it.
- deltron3030 7y agoSure, but don't expect that devs are loyal to you and your ecosystem. Think different is dead!
- xwdv 7y agoIn a few words: Fuck them.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoThis happened to me, in the early 1990s. I spent months writing a very capable MIDI driver. In those days, writing a MIDI driver was a truly non-trivial exercise, as you had to have a MIDI adapter that fed back a 1MHz clock, which you would then program their UART to clock down. That UART was also a pretty hairy bit of hardware. You had to program it with ASM, and the chip was set up so that a 16-bit address range corresponded to various control states. Setting control states for the chip meant a LOT of homework. MIDI drivers basically were about as difficult as you could get, as you needed to step down an external clock, and set up things like ring buffers that were large enough to not trip over their own feet during an intense session. Anyhoo, after a couple of months of working on the driver (and buying a DX-7 as a test bed), I was just about to announce it, when Apple came up with a package of OS utilities that included...a MIDI driver. I don't think that theirs was as good as mine, but that was beside the point. I open-sourced the driver, but the OS community wasn't particularly well-established back then, and I believe that it's lost in the sands of time.
- crtlaltdel 7y agoThe linked article states that Apple actively researched their products. Is this what happened with your MIDI driver?
- scarface74 7y agoDo you really think that Apple couldn’t come up with the idea for SideCar without Luna? You could already use AirPlay to create a second monitor from your Mac and use AirPlay as a second display from iOS. It was completely logical that the next step is to send video from your Mac to your iPad as a second display.
- seandougall 7y agoIndeed, Apple had already implemented something similar with Target Display Mode on the iMac back in 2009, so it's hardly a stretch to figure they've been planning something like this for essentially as long as iPads have been around.
- archiepeach 7y agoIsn’t this quite similar to what happens when a supermarket creates their own brand version of a product, and places it alongside the copies product, albeit with a much cheaper price? I felt quite bad for Spotify and Flux when Apple Music and Night shift came out, but I guess this is a risk when you use any type of platform to reach customers. Diversification is a good idea, I’m impressed was impressed with the response in the article.
- underwater 7y agoA supermarket still charges for the own brand product. Apple's own-brand product is effectively free to the consumer. This poisons the well for an entire genre of productivity apps.
- dehrmann 7y agoSupermarkets rarely "create their own brand version of a product." They usually contact a a vendor to have them make the product with the house brand's labels. Trader Joe's does this, and some googling will tell you who really makes some of their products. Costco is known for rebranding some impressively good single malt scotches and selling them cheap.
- tyiz 7y agoMaxiVista was first with using a computer as a 2nd screen. Loooong ago in 2003. later there also was an iOS App.
- schappim 7y agoWhen Apple Sherlocks you, you Moriarty them in return. Hear: Make your product better and more feature rich, focusing on a narrow segment of the mass market Apple is trying to serve.
- EricE 7y agoExactly - I'll still us my Luna Display because it has features Sidecar doesn't.
- buserror 7y agoI also got sherlocked around 15 years ago. At the time I was working for a music company, and I was in very close loop with apple CoreAudio and CoreMIDI guys. I had (still have) a whole bunch of apple employees or ex- as friends. Rather enthusiastically I was advocating, and filing bugs to allow me to ship a side project I had been working on for quite a while: A way to network MIDI devices on OSX. Multicast, very low latency, auto-discovery etc. I basically entirely trusted them with all the ideas, thinking it wasn't something they would need, or care, to ship in OSX at any time in the future because it was so niche. I was wrong, next major OSX version, they had it -- in a more primitive way than my product -- but they had it. I that point I had been a mac developer, one of the old school, since 1985 or so. And I literally dropped tools and decided to do something else entirely. Now I still use a Hackintosh mostly for a few programs I still cary on using, but my work has entirely shifted away from Apple.
- ricardobeat 7y ago> that closely copied our product lines Interesting comment by a company whose apps replicate what has been available for almost a decade. I remember using software to turn my 1st generation iPad into a second screen, back in 2010. Have been through at least three variants of the same app since. I'm not happy with platform owners eating more and more of their own market, and think some of the anti-competitive clauses of app stores should be illegal, but there is no high horse to stand on here.
- orasis 7y agoApple got an Emmy for our tech that they copied. Don't show big companies shit.
- Trias11 7y agoPatenting, Trademarking and Copyrighting would be a good way to protect your IP from few sides.
- bredren 7y agoI remember during the early facebook app dev days, there was a very popular Independent ncaa tourney bracket app. Then fb partnered w some big name to do another app that copied the functionality very poorly, but fb promoted it far and above the other all, effectively killing it.
- hartator 7y agohttps://lunadisplay.com/pages/luna-and-mac-mini https://lunadisplay.com/pages/luna-and-mac-mini Can’t you do that with SideCar as well? I was thinking doing this instead of buying a new Apple Tv. Like having an iPad driving a Mac Mini via SideCar but also connected to a regular tv.
- flurdy 7y agoSo... Don't be a one-trick pony? Duh, quite obvious, diversification is what all companies desire, but most just try and milk the golden goose for as long as possible. Until it is too late. It does astonish me though when every year I walk through the booths at AWS Summit (poor man's Re:Invent) and see all these companies that are a feature-announcement-in-one-tiny-paragraph-in-an-AWS-blog-post away from going out of business. But I guess it pays the mortgage bills for a lot of people until those blog posts.
- tekromancr 7y agoAlternative term: getting f.luxed over
- robert_edwards 7y agoI think item 6 is key: Lesson #6: Lean into your competitive advantages by showing off what differentiates you from Apple. This is exactly why I continue to pay for an Alfred license over just using basic spotlight search.
- claudeganon 7y agoI honestly have zero sympathy for them. I have an older Mac as my daily driver and was bummed to learn it was excluded from the Sidecar functionality. As a daily Wacom user, I’ve really wanted this feature. So, I went and looked at Astropad and learned that their pricing is based around a ludicrous subscription model and they lock basic functionality behind it (like shortcuts). They obviously don’t understand their market because Adobe is near reviled by digital artists nowadays for these kind of tactics. If they had at all been reasonable in their to pricing, they would have been fine. Most artists I know hold onto their hardware for a long time and would’ve payed (reasonably) for support/their feature set. But because they got greedy, people will just wait and upgrade to the built-in support on newer devices.
- travisgriggs 7y agoThe add on/enhancement business is always risky. As the author says,oin one hand it's kinda validating when it happens, otoh it obviously means you're going to have to find a new "got to have tool" to hawk. There will never be a "sit back and watch the dollars roll in" in this space. Either the platform/ecosystem/standard offering eats you up OR everyone else smells the cash and moves in and the race to the bottom of profitablity begins. As an oldie, who remembers the kinds of money that was being made in the late 80s early 90s in software development tools? Cool languages. Powerful compilers. CASE tools. Libraries. Innovative IDEs. I worked in that space (Smalltalk VisualWorks). Businesses paid good money to fund those efforts, to try and have competitive advantage to develop better solutions than the competition. But in a similar vein, the OS vendors (as well as free open source) moved into this space, and then there was very little money to be made in 3rd party software development tools. So I feel these guys pain. But the expansion transcends the particular type of add in they're making money in.
- chrischen 7y agoPrior to using Sidecar I was using Duet Display, which is a software solution to the Luna hardware module. I can't see any benefits of using Luna over the Duet App, and most of the Pros/Cons on the Luna website are outdated as of Duet 2. If Sidecar didn't kill Luna, Duet would have.
- dr_j_ 7y agoI use a non-airplay compatible MacBook Pro from mid 2010 and I am rather disappointed at the overall product offering for these slightly older machines. While I find you can mirror the display to an iPad, it seems impossible to use one as genuine secondary display (such that it could be used for extra screen real estate). I paid for several products over the last few months only to be disappointed in this way. Perhaps therefore a niche could be to support older machines like my mid 2010 MacBook pro?
- shiftpgdn 7y agoI don't think a decade old laptop is slightly older. That's amazing that it's still running.
- thumbsdownnow 7y agoAll my apps wait 2 month verification time ??
- musicale 7y agoSidecar is an obvious OS feature that I've wanted since the original iPad, and the third-party attempts/solutions from VNC to Remote Desktop to Air Display to AstroPad to Duet to Luna were not great and some of them added very annoying bits like subscription pricing (seriously?) or clunky/expensive hardware adapters. I also considered how easy it is to have your iPhone screen show up as an video source in QuickTime Player, just by plugging in a lightning cable... I'm deleting basically all of them (possibly excepting VNC, which has a few different use cases) and switching to Sidecar.