21 ms·
Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
- dvt 7y ago> “Doing business in China, it’s been easier to ignore the authoritarianism of the government because they were asking us to do things like remove a skeleton [from a game],” he said. It looks like China learned nothing from the USSR (or from their own Great Leap Forward, for that matter). Escalation is not going to go their way. Hawkish members of the CCP are going to blow the whole thing up. This is much bigger than Activision-Blizzard and it's clear that Western companies are going to have to pick a side soon. There's a very salient conflict between Wall Street and the Classical Liberal underpinnings of our modern democracies. As it stands right now, this is going to get worse before it gets better. Is anyone worried about the HKD/USD peg falling?
- munk-a 7y agoI don't think it's Western companies as much as Western society putting pressure on all companies in general - and that'll bump up really hard against neo-liberalism and especially the libretarian segments of society. Ideally we'll see political support shifting away from neo-liberalism and toward more pro-democracy ideologies.
- dvt 7y agoTheoretically, at least, I think that the two are inextricably linked. I don't think you can have neo-liberalism (an actually free free market) unless your markets live in a democratic law-abiding state.
- ep103 7y agotrue, but I don't think you can have neo-liberalism, and do anything other than move away from a democratic law-abiding state, and towards a more authoritarian most-state-capitalist society
- munk-a 7y agoThe golden goose of neo-liberalism has always been local free-democracy and political protections while offshoring the uglier parts of the free-market economy to regions where the local political system can't resist the pressures being imposed by corporations. Within the west the idea is that corporations (mostly) play nice and respect democracy while exploiting that abroad - I think that may have lasted for a month or so and then folks realized they could double dip and have been eroding political institution for the benefit of corporations both locally and abroad.
- dmix 7y agoYep, almost all of the economically free countries are liberal democracies with strong independent courts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_of_Economic_Freedom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_of_Economic_Freedom There's a strong correlation between economic and social liberty, as well as with the average wealth, quality of life, and happiness of the general population. The fact Taiwan and HK are right next to China with ethnically and culturally similar people and were both way ahead of China economically and socially is no surprise. I often wonder how much more advanced the entire world would be if China didn't waste 50yrs trying their failed experiment and had skyrocketed to success like Japan, South Korea, HK, and Taiwan did long ago.
- maximente 7y agoone of the reasons Japan/Taiwan/SK's economies are so strong is because - you guessed it - China is a major importer of their produced goods. without disposable income they have gained from something over the last few decades, they aren't importing massive amounts of goods from their neighbors.
- dmix 7y agoNow imagine if China opened up their market earlier and had fair independent courts and political systems where they could attract other country's companies, talent, and money 10x easier without fear of it being stolen or squeezed out. They'd all be doing even better.
- duxup 7y agoYeah strong / independent courts and laws are absolutely required... for a lot of things really.
- CamperBob2 7y agoWall Street has nothing to do with it. https://www.pcgamer.com/every-game-company-that-tencent-has-invested-in/ https://www.pcgamer.com/every-game-company-that-tencent-has-...
- dvt 7y agoI'm not sure if I agree. "Expansion in Chinese markets" seems to be a staple of quarterly earnings reports.
- CamperBob2 7y agoDo you see companies that aren't partially owned by Chinese interests doing things like this? Admittedly I'm not fully up to speed on the situation, but I doubt Blizzard would have taken this action without considering Tencent's influence.
- tomnipotent 7y ago> without considering Tencent's influence At 5% ownership, Tencent doesn't have the muscle to force Blizzard to do anything it wouldn't have already done of its own volition.
- oarsinsync 7y agoActivist investors often have less than 10% stakes in the companies they’re trying to institute changes in. 5% is not a meaningless amount to hold.
- tomnipotent 7y agoI hadn't thought about the parallel to activist investors, that's a very good point. I've seen the hell raised by folks like Carl Icahn...
- morningseagulls 7y agoAgreed, but Epic Games, which is 40% owned by Tencent, is now claiming it won't do what Blizzard did: https://www.insider.com/epic-unlike-blizzard-wont-ban-players-talking-politics-hong-kong-2019-10 https://www.insider.com/epic-unlike-blizzard-wont-ban-player...
- jorblumesea 7y ago> China learned nothing from the USSR On the contrary, they learned that USSR's self imposed isolation was fundamentally flawed and largely stagnated the Soviet economy. It also put them behind the Western world in terms of R&D. China is attempting to put those lessons to use and attempting to have an "Western opened" totalitarian regime. So far, it seems to be working. Accepting Western capital and tech, stealing everything they can find, and suppressing anything that's a threat to their system while requesting their system become normalized. Whereas we used to shut out the Soviet Union, we welcome China. +1 on taking the side, it's hard to see China as anything less than hostile to Western democracy.
- jdashg 7y agoI believe it's also a play similar to Embrace Extend Extinguish: - Embrace investment globally - Extend markets and improve industries - Exert political pressure in exchange for access to now-crucial markets/industries
- tossAfterUsing 7y ago> Is anyone worried about the HKD/USD peg falling? I just hope it fails before China fully takes over HK's banks
- mortenjorck 7y ago> This is much bigger than Activision-Blizzard and it's clear that Western companies are going to have to pick a side soon. I would imagine there are thousands of businesses with varying degrees of exposure to the Chinese market whose executives are on pins and needles right now, desperately hoping no circumstance arises that will require them to publicly take a side on this issue. Businesses with less exposure or fewer ambitions in China might have a lower barrier to standing firm if pushed, but those with the most to lose in the Chinese market are staring down a very real, very imminent choice between taking a major hit to either their revenues or their ethical credibility.
- finnjohnsen2 7y agoI just got some faith back in Blizzard. It was lost.
- xvector 7y agoDecisions like these are usually not the fault of the employees. I sympathize with them. It’s more management and PR.
- munk-a 7y agoAmerican labour organization pretty much no longer exists which is quite convenient for this sort of thing - it's quite likely this went across a few folks' desks who bowed their heads because they thought they'd be singled out for objecting. I praise the employees that are walking out today - but a number of them were involved in this happening and didn't feel empowered to speak out and oppose this before the poo hit the windmill. That tends to be par for the course in modern america (keep your head down because anyone who objects is fired) and while it has some short term benefits for upper management they end up wholly owning their problems and nobody is going to call out a big mistake like this one before it goes public. Lastly having worked in the gaming industry the turnover is quite high, I don't know if Blizzard is better about retaining senior folks, but it might be that everyone who would have the confidence to stop this before it exploded was long ago canned because their salary grew out of the range where Blizzard wanted to keep them on.
- jeron 7y agoimportant to recognize that like a country's citizens may not agree with what a country does, a company's employees may not agree with what the company does
- wffurr 7y agoI don't know why "a small group of Activision Blizzard employees" would do anything to change your "faith" in the company as a whole. Wake me up when their C-suite staff and board of directors "walk out" or make a meaningful public statement.
- undefined3840 7y agoBy far the most egregious example of western firms working with China are management consulting companies like McKinsey that work directly with governments on expensive contracts, including of course China. I mean, in those cases they are often writing the playbook for the government when it comes to implementing certain policies. Crazy that is even legal for a western firm.
- mrosett 7y agoThat's a really good point and not one I had considered in the context of everything that's happened recently. McKinsey has been involved with a lot of bad stuff internationally over the last decade or two. Monitor's work with Gaddafi was also really gross. There's an odd dichotomy though - the ex-McKinsey employees I know personally and work closely with are all very thoughtful, ethical people.
- SkyBelow 7y agoYou can create an interesting modified trolley problem if you replace the trolley with a person. Assuming you don't have recourse to stop them in any way, but you can help them make a less destructive (but still awful/harmful choice), do you? Much as the trolley is going to hit some group, and you have the option to reduce it from a larger group to a smaller group, except this time instead of a large metal contraption under the influence of gravity and/or steam, you have a bag of flesh and bone working using the power of glucose. Does this change the parameters of the trolley problem at all? Honestly, until now I've never thought about it. Might be an interesting thought experiment.
- prepend 7y agoMonitor was bought by Deloitte.
- undefined3840 7y agoA lot of good, decent human beings justify doing awful things in their day job. Wasn’t there just a post on here a few days ago about someone who worked at Capital One writing about how everyone working there justified getting poor people deeper in debt?
- jrockway 7y agoThe Internet's reaction to this has warmed my heart a little. Overwatch and Hearthstone are among my favorite computer games. I've certainly played more Overwatch than any other game. I have made real-world and online friends in Overwatch. I met my girlfriend in Overwatch. It made me sad to have to throw all that away yesterday. But the conversations we're having as a result of this is great. The mainstream media is talking about it. Congress is talking about it. We're going to have to ask ourselves: can we really let China have this much influence? Is it really worth it? (Remember: this is what Europe is asking about Silicon Valley with things like GDPR, and it's working out quite well for them.) Banning someone from Hearthstone GM doesn't matter. But we are heading down a path where we decide what our values are, and they're looking pretty good.
- seph-reed 7y agoIf anyone knows how to fill out a list of companies to boycott in relation to HK, please see this link: https://github.com/hongkonggong/beyond-lennon-walls/issues/24 https://github.com/hongkonggong/beyond-lennon-walls/issues/2...
- jasonlotito 7y agoIt's interesting to see people give up Blizzard games, but still continue supporting companies like Apple that do far worse, like effectively giving the keys to iCloud to China. I think the conversation is great, and maybe now we'll actually reconsider what the TPP's goal was. But in the end, the people picked money first, so it shouldn't be a surprise when businesses do this as well.
- ddtaylor 7y agoAs much as I want to think change will happen, it's much more likely this will be a few weeks of PR and ultimately nothing will change. For something to change people have to vote with their wallets. In this context that means cancelling subscriptions or dropping games they are already playing in favor for ones by competitors with better integrity, and I don't see that happening. Diablo players could go to Path of Exile, its closest competitor, but that game is massively invested into China as well and partially owned by Tencent. Warcraft RTS players represent a small market right now with almost no microtransactions or ongoing revenue. WoW players have alternatives, but not many I am aware of that aren't heavily Chinese based as the MMORPG category is dominated by Chinese companies like Perfect World. Starcraft players don't have a lot of alternatives as SC has dominated the esports and highly polished RTS category for over 5 years with the same game. The closest competitor would be Age of Empires or Warhammer, I'm not sure how much influence China has over them, but they are different types of RTS games. Heroes of the Storm players can go to Dota or LoL. LoL being owned by China and Dota being owned by Valve with strong Chinese market involvement. More alternatives are needed IMO.
- minimaxir 7y agoA common albeit reductive meme around the entire controversy is that Blizzard games were already declining in popularity (especially Starcraft and HotS) so it's easy to boycott them. Path of Exile is an interesting case as I know a lot of Diablo players went there since Diablo III is effectively on life support (including myself), but the resurfacing of the Tencent ownership news is causing ethical complications: https://www.reddit.com/r/pathofexile/comments/df5zx7/anyone_else_suddenly_worried_about_ggg_censoring/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pathofexile/comments/df5zx7/anyone_...
- my_usernam3 7y agoOn the contrary, wow classic was setting twitch records just a month ago. Obviously that spike in popularity will not be sustained, but still worth noting and shows the size of Blizzard as a brand.
- jiggawatts 7y ago
- dmix 7y ago> Protesting Blizzard employees from multiple departments gathered at an iconic statue of an Orc warrior charging into battle in the center of the company’s main campus in Irvine, California The link says the statue that was made in China, heh.
- mantap 7y agoIf Hong Kong becomes a Palestine-style cause celebre it will be bad for China. China is trapped. They are stuck with this democratic appendix attached to a communist body. China can't keep Hong Kong under a democratic system as they have zero understanding of democracy. But if they try to repress it they risk endangering China's relationships with the rest of the world. They made a mistake thinking they could transform a democratic territory into a communist one without any consequences.
- ahbyb 7y ago>If Hong Kong becomes a Palestine-style cause celebre it will be bad for China. Will it? Because nobody gives a fuck about Palestine, and Israel is not suffering much (or at all) because of what they did and do.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIf nobody gave a fuck about Palestine, people wouldn't be so bent out of shape over Representative Omar's comments on the topic.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> If nobody gave a fuck about Palestine, people wouldn't be so bent out of shape over Representative Omar's comments on the topic. Nearly nobody (outside of Palestine, and weighted by political power) has a positive concern for the Palestinians, but lots of people (particularly in the US and Israel) have an interest in assuring that anyone who shows any sign of such a positive concern be punished to pressure them to recant and, even if that fails, to discourage others.
- chronic71819 7y ago> Will it? Because nobody gives a fuck about Palestine, and Israel is not suffering much (or at all) because of what they did and do. Unfortunately I agree with you. Very few people in the US even care about Israel/Palestine. I don't know how the sentiment is in Europe, though.
- 7y ago
- lambdasquirrel 7y agoThis is probably not going to be a popular opinion here, but I wonder if any folks have considered what it looks like on the China side? Specifically, you are in China, and the HK protestors want what to happen to China? You have HK protesters waving American and British flags. These are the countries that have started wars all over, in the last 70 years since the end of WWII, ostensibly to promote democracy, and everywhere this happens there is chaos and destruction. Add to that, China's cultural history of being invaded and exploited by various foreigners whenever it was weak or divided, and what happened to Russia in the 90s after democracy and neo-liberal capitalism were introduced, and you don't really have a good story here. So, imagine then, you are in China, and the HK protestors sound like they want what for China? The popular notion is that China would become a place friendly to Western ideals if it became successful. But even here, the West – and in particular, the US/UK – doesn't "get" China. Whatever is said here, China will bypass the US/UK, for practical purposes. But in any case, it is not as if they are representative of the West as a whole, nor can they claim to have a better human rights record – or equality record – or a fairer society.
- JakeTheAndroid 7y agoI'm not sure I understand your opinion at all here. The protesters don't want to impact Mainland Chinese citizens lives whatsoever. The demands are pretty clear and not at all an attempt to become the US/UK or fundamentally change Chinese culture. HK already views itself as culturally, economically, and politically separate from China. There is an agreement between HK and Mainland China to allow them to function independently for 50 years and that is not being upheld, or at least that is what is perceived by people in HK. The rest of the stuff you are saying is moot once you recognize those key factors. They don't want anything for China, they want HK to be allowed to do what it's supposed to be allowed to do; govern itself without interference, which was agreed to by both parties.
- umvi 7y ago> There is an agreement between HK and Mainland China to allow them to function independently for 50 years and that is not being upheld, or at least that is what is perceived by people in HK. Yeah because if you wait 50 years, HK isn't going to want to be a part of a dictatorship communist regime when they've been democratic for the past hundred years. China needs to ignore the agreement and ratchet down hard now if they hope to keep HK.
- sgt101 7y agoWOW classic is ramped in English realms tonight - coincidence ? much!
- _bxg1 7y agoAnd still no (American) statement from Blizzard. Whoever runs their PR team is getting fired, if they haven't been already.
- shadowgovt 7y ago... or is currently being held in check by management, who has absolutely no idea how to spin this yet. Can't march with no marching orders.
- _bxg1 7y agoGenerally it's the PR department that figures out how to spin things
- bduerst 7y agoTrue, but Execs will gatekeep the final review and approval for larger responses and campaigns.
- alkonaut 7y agoThis shouldn’t be hard though. Execs shouldn’t think “we should maximize shareholder value while following the law”. Execs should think “what will I wish I had done when I’m 90”. Does it really hurt that much to tell your shareholders “we think it’s the right thing to stand up for democracy and human rights even if it means we are bennes from China and our profits are halved”.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> Execs should think “what will I wish I had done when I’m 90” Probably "made enough money so I'm not tucked away in this low-rent retirement home with Nurse Ratched beating me when I don't eat my soup." ;)
- themacguffinman 7y agoAs much as I'd like execs to do that, I think it is actually hard. The board, made up of investors and other stakeholders, have a lot of power too. Execs can tell shareholders that they want to stand up for human rights, but shareholders can also tell execs to stand up for human rights somewhere else (ie. they get fired; execs can be fired too).
- jcims 7y agoI know it's the original but this title is turrible. 'Staged' - usually means faked 'Protest Banned Pro-Hong King Gamer' reads like they are protesting the gamer
- dvtrn 7y agoSynonyms and context clues exist, you know.
- chrisweekly 7y ago(replying on behalf of gp) Of course such clues exist; it's unlikely s/he was personally confused. Which has zero bearing on the quality of the title. The fact that it _requires_ parsing and reliance on clues indicates poor word choice. Synonyms abound, and better ones would have made for a much better title.
- dvtrn 7y ago"Staging a walkout" seems like a phrase that, unless one is an ESL speaker or otherwise don’t speak the language you'd have to be actively and conscientiously misinterpreting when reading the title in whole. But point taken...I suppose.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jcims 7y agoSure but what's wrong with something like: Blizzard Employees Protest Banning of Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
- dvtrn 7y agoNothing unless, as I said in another comment one is either just not a native English speaker or is deliberately trying to misconstrue the words used in a vacuum of context. But I fear we’re quibbling the point now and getting pretty far off topic. So I’ll desist.
- mrybczyn 7y agoI cancelled my blizzard account as soon as I heard this news. I doubt I'll renew - since the root cause is unlikely to be fixed with any PR expedient move at this point. They have shown the world where their true nature lies - and it ain't good. Cancel yours if you have them...
- atarian 7y ago>The demonstration’s numbers fluctuated throughout the day, the two employees said, ranging from a dozen to 30, and the protesters departed sometime in the late afternoon. So less than 1% of the company? Not trying to minimize the issue here but let's also not make events sound bigger than they really are.
- master-litty 7y agoEven at the size they are, that's still enough people to make a scene -- Enough to bubble upward and ask for a disciplinary decision, I'd think.
- beirut_bootleg 7y agoIn the same vein, let's say there are only 400k people online showing outrage at this. That's less than 0.01% of the world's population. Now weigh this ratio against the violation of human rights, police violence, ethnic cleansing and organ harvesting, and ask your question again. Thinking that numbers is all that matters is the same as valuing $$$ over morals, which is what this is all about.
- atarian 7y agoYou're making a strawman argument about morals, which is not in the same vein as what I said. My point was this piece was sensationalized.
- Quanttek 7y agoNow, a protest by "a dozen to 30" employees is unlikely to change Blizzard policy, even with the public backlash. While employees staging walkouts could actually hamper Blizzard's ability to make money, when each employee is individually up to the whims of the larger company, they may face negative repercussions and many, out of fear of reprisals, don't protest in the first place. That's why we need unions in the software industry. Via collectivized action, the power differential between employer and employees is leveled. This is not only about collective bargaining, being able to enforce adequate labor standards (e.g. no/less/compensated "crunch" time), but also about being able to force company policy. If the majority of employees would strike/walk out and any negative repercussions against individuals would be met with more strikes, Blizzard would very quickly change.
- cwkoss 7y agoSounds like a great time to 'accidentally' break production
- joshschreuder 7y agoSounds like a great time to 'deliberately' get fired
- cwkoss 7y agoJust need to be sure they can't prove it was malicious in court
- anon1m0us 7y agoI figured it out! Why are we so up in arms about this? Why not before this? Well, because we were insulated from China's behavior. Their heavy handed approach only affected their own citizens. They jailed their own citizens, but not Americans, not other people. We got our supply chain from them and they gave us what we wanted, so we're good. However! Now China's tyranny is leaking out of China. It's getting into arenas where we are. You could have been playing that game. You could have said something that offended China -- maybe without even knowing it. Plus, they are in our IoT devices, our iphones, our cameras. China is watching and controlling us now. They are restricting our access to games -- not just their own people. The culture and rules of countries don't exist solely within the borders of that country. This is new for Americans. It's not new for the rest of the world. What USA wanted, USA got. Now, what China wants, China gets -- even if it's not what we want.
- mmazing 7y agoNow here's a thought ... could video games and entertainment be tools for generating change in countries? Could every game developer and internet service pulling their services from China completely compel the population to try to change their regime? I know if suddenly my entertainment was taken away I would flip my shit if it was my government that was responsible. Edit : To offset potential cost to companies, could this behavior be subsidized by our government?
- anon1m0us 7y agoInteresting! It's certainly subsidized by China, so yes. Continuing your thought. In the past, wars were fought physically by damaging the opponent. We are at a place in history where we can fight not with fists and bullets, but with entertainment. Like national rap battles. Wars were fought over resources: water, oil, food. Now they are fought over games, movies, ... products. Instead of war winners being those who can inflict the most harm on the opponent, maybe now we can shift that into the winner being the most entertaining. This could be a good thing.
- morningseagulls 7y ago
- lsniddy 7y agoFree Tibet never seemed to be controversial here in the US, makes me wonder why supporting Hong Kong is.
- TDL 7y agoRichard Gere says that it's affected his career. https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2017/04/richard-gere-hollywood-china https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2017/04/richard-gere-ho...
- madez 7y agoThe Chinese government thinks it could lose the power struggle over Hong Kong, while it was confident about the Chinese invasion and assimilation of Tibet. Hong Kong is a real threat to the Chinese regime.
- ahaferburg 7y agoBecause it started in the eighties and we didn't have Reddit to make shitposts about it: https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/dfmgst/oc_a_quick_look_at_todays_reddit_storm/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/dfmgst/oc_... I remember it being mentioned in the "Work rules" book by that Google guy. They had a desert in their canteen called "Free Tibet Goji-Chocolate Creme Pie..." in the canteen. They said "well, the food is free, and the berries come from Tibet, so ..." Trying to be cheeky. But several people threatened to quit over this, and they had a huge discussion on the internal mailing list with over 1300 replies. The chef who created it got suspended, and then people got worried because of the chilling effect that this would have on free speech. Eventually the suspension was reversed. Very dramatic.
- gtirloni 7y agoBoycotting Blizzard is easy and achieves almost nothing. Boycotting Chinese products on the other hand...
- cwkoss 7y agoIs there a website that helps consumers identify brands that do not have Chinese investors and don't use Chinese manufacturing in their supply chain?
- gtirloni 7y agoNot that I know of. Doing this at the consumer level requires a lot of convincing, grassroots movements, etc. It's messy and ends up creating xenophobic groups. IMHO, it's more efficient done at the government level where it can impact big state-owned companies. Reading what I just wrote, it may sound like I support Trump's tax war, which is not true at all. He's not doing that to forward an agenda of human rights, which I think it's the point of this whole discussion.
- Can_Not 7y agoI thought buycott would have this as a trending campaign but I couldn't find it.
- prepend 7y agoBlizzard survives on monthly recurring revenue streams. Boycotting disrupts this stream in a very consistent manner. 1M boycotters mean $10M lost per month plus all the addition revenue from lost streamers and watchers. Blizzard made $1.4B last quarter [0]. It doesn’t bankrupt them but losing 2.5% of earnings sucks. [0] https://investor.activision.com/news-releases/news-release-details/activision-blizzard-announces-second-quarter-2019-financial https://investor.activision.com/news-releases/news-release-d...
- gtirloni 7y agoI thought the point was to affect China's policy, not to bankrupt companies we don't like.
- cwkoss 7y agoSomewhat tangential: Is there a website that tracks companies which do not have Chinese investors and does not use Chinese manufacturing in their supply chain? I'd like to try to avoid giving money to China, but they are so ingrained into the American economy I'm not sure how to do this in practice.
- nsporillo 7y agoYeah I'm in the market for a new memory foam mattress and being made in China is non starter. I'd also love to see a website like this.
- ganitarashid 7y agoFreedom is always more important than money. Shame on these greedy companies
- nyxyn 7y agoSo, basically, 3 people walked out? If they're anything like most corporations the majority of their workers are contractors.
- icu 7y agoI can't verify this but a video game YouTube channel I subscribe to has reported that the following statement was released on Chinese social media by Blizzard representatives: "We are very angered and disappointed at what happened at the event and do not condone it in any way. We also highly object the spreading of personal political beliefs in this manner. Effective immediately we've banned the contestant from events and terminated work with the broadcasters. We will always respect and defend the pride of our country." If true, the Chinese side of Blizzard is anti-Western values and the US corporate side is ultimately responsible for allowing the situation to happen. As the US/China trade war drags on, as the HK protests continue, I think US corporations will have to choose between profits or values. Some brands and reputations will be reinforced, others--like Blizzard--will take a massive hit.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nec4b 7y agoWhere are all the Hollywood stars, NBA players and silicon valley software engineers fighting for SJW causes, bravely protesting Trump, cheering for other people to loose jobs. Oh, right this is now about their money and their livelihood. I guess not so brave after all.