14 ms·
Why Japan lost its comparative advantage in producing electronic parts
- MobileVet 7y agoI visited Hamamatsu Co in a professional setting in 2004 and was very impressed. Their attention to detail was second to none and what we needed at the time. We were building brand new optical sensors for robots and they had lots of experience in the area. They walked through our specs and needs and found the right part and helped us integrated. It was white glove service all the way. That definitely comes at a cost. When you are prototyping, that cost is expected. If you cross into the millions of units, I can understand how their approach and offering doesn't scale well. Hard to match the other Asian mfgs when numbers are huge.
- Fronzie 7y agoHamamatsu is still around and still excellent at the design and prototype stage of optical sensors. They seems to have a company culture of very open technical discussions on pros and cons which I'm not so sure is common in other Japanese companies.
- dfox 7y agoWhat probably helps is that only real competition for Hamamatsu are people peddling cold war era new old stock (usually Soviet made) military grade parts.
- pkaye 7y agoI used to be an applications engineer for a company that developed electronic parts. So many times I would interact with engineers at various companies around the world. The Japanese engineers always stood out in how they evaluated your product. They would always do rigorous testing of your products. They don't just trust your specs like most other places. Sometimes they built custom test fixtures to test things even we didn't have the bandwidth to perform. I felt that is why they always have high reliability cars and stuff.
- peterwwillis 7y agoThey have high reliability cars from continuous improvement practices to increase quality and reduce waste: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Production_System https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Production_System
- klenwell 7y agoA favorite quote of mine from Donald G Reinertsen's Principles of Product Development Flow: I used to think that sensible and compelling new ideas would be adopted quickly. Today, I believe this view is hopelessly naive. After all, it took 40 years before we recognized the power of the Toyota Production System.
- Gibbon1 7y agoIn the US if you want to fix that you have to outlaw MBA programs. Because business schools are behind a lot of the decline in US Industry.
- williamDafoe 7y agoWhat? How can optimizing the most important criteria to the company (MBA salaries) - done scientifically by the MBAs - not lead to more success which is measured (or at least validated) by the number of MBAs hired in the next year?
- corodra 7y agoI'll say I do detest those with MBAs, mostly due to my bias since I didn't go to college. But even I'm going to say you're making a rather absurd statement that's filled with delusional correlation. MBA programs aren't the "cause" of US Industry decline. I don't even know where to begin with unpacking that they are the cause, because of the absurdity. MBA like programs (specialized business teachings to an advance level) have existed since the days of enterprise. The only difference between now and antiquity is the fact we've standardized the model and the naming conventions. Don't forget too it's the consumer's dollar that ultimately has the "real vote" in where production happens. That's why the past two decades, small farms are more and more... viable is a strong word. But they're more popular and there are plenty that do well. Because certain consumers do vote "Yes, I think that a heritage chicken that's cage free and free range is worth the extra money compared to the commercial broiler breeds." But it's a real difficult sell on someone to tell them, "Hey, you can go into an industry where there's money being thrown around or you can try raising a dying industry from scratch and hope it works out for you before the end of your lifetime." It's the same reason we tell kids you should go into STEM classes and not basket weaving. If consumers already have a history in paying for something, why should someone go into something where there's a history of consumers NOT paying for something?
- JRKrause 7y agoA critical element of the product my current employer sells comes from a Japanese owned manufacturer. Their quality and consistency is remarkable but it's like pulling teeth trying to get them to loosen quality controls to drive out cost. Even when we would make up the loss of reliability in our own integration they remain resistant to this change.
- stareatgoats 7y agoKudos to them then!
- dwoozle 7y agoNot really, overengineering is bad engineering.
- perl4ever 7y agoI was looking for replacement lightswitches; the old ones are probably 25 years old, some are broken. I got a new one that looked more or less the same, but I got home and realized it doesn't have the same feel as the old switch. And it isn't symmetric - it has a different click "on" vs "off". Here's the thing - if you take your comment to the logical limit, the only engineering requirement of a product is to make the sale. With this switch, I took it home and installed it, and probably will not return it, so even if I decide to throw it in the trash, it wasn't "underengineered". But everything is becoming like this, and so people and companies that "irrationally" overengineer stuff are becoming more valuable, as are their brands. Even if you don't care about what I care about, there are too many factors in any product for either of us to track. So there is always incredible value in someone that pays attention to the aspects we are not paying attention to. But that is overengineering. There is no alarm bell that tells you you have crossed over from optimizing what your customer cares about to screwing them over with a piece of crap. Assuming anyone cared. If you optimize everything, you destroy your brand.
- dwoozle 7y ago
- AFascistWorld 7y agoThe electronics market right now is like fast fashion, people use a thing for 2 years then there are better and shinier things to buy, TVs now come with built-in low-end SoCs that will become obsolete and laggy before long, then hey time to throw it out! When I was working in a Japanese-owned PCB factory in China, faking/modifing records on the production lines was common as water, to think that this was probably one of the best ones in China or even the world, which supplied for Japanese TVs, DSLRs and iPhones, was eye-opening and somewhat chilling. I don't know if it was the same in Japan tho, people who went there to study said it was awesome and they produced better products using old equipment. And I just read a story about how testing contractors in Apple's iWatch factories pass basically anything given after the stringen and supervised first batch. Breaking down just after warranty is perfectly acceptable now, so I guess noboby buys craftsmanship.
- detaro 7y ago> so I guess noboby buys craftsmanship. Part of the problem is: how do identify it, if even premium brands don't reliably maintain their standards?
- Brakenshire 7y agoIt has to be done at a government level. Requiring the cost of disposal to be put into the initial purchase price, for instance, or mandatory warranty periods.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y agoYes, but companies can eat these costs relatively easily, or they harm the consumer. These costs should really be baked in at manufacturing time. RoHS is a good example, but China somehow turned it into a competitive advantage.
- Gibbon1 7y ago> mandatory warranty periods I've wondered what the effect would be if the dump could force manufacturers to buy back broken appliances that are still under mandatory warranty.
- williamDafoe 7y agoMy friend ran an LED manufacturer in Taiwan. They were destroyed by China's federal government policy which basically subsidized (free housing) all the Chinese LEDs until all the Taiwan companies were dead.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoLED is especially brutal, there are few that produce chips but everybody can do the assembly. You can buy a 3W bulb plus shipping for 1 RMB at anytime, including big brands, 1 RMB, that's $0.1399.
- baybal2 7y agoLol, most LEDs in China are in fact from Taiwanese wafers, and some are from direct competitors.
- coughcough 7y agoThe world has tolerated Chinese thuggish behavior for too long. It's high time we in the West give considerations to certain radical measures
- scarface74 7y agoYou have been keeping up with the news in regards to American politics haven’t you?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JJMcJ 7y agoDuring late 80s/early 90s when Japanese memory chips were eating the world, one reason was their yields were much higher, so they could sell cheaper. Friends in semi industry said one major reason, cleanliness standards in Japanese fab lines were much higher than American.
- patfla 7y agoMaybe but the Japanese capture of the memory market was just as much about low costs of capital. Semiconductor manufacturing is about as capital intensive an industry as exists. I'd note that the Koreans now own this market. Same strategy. Commoditized industry thus barriers to technological entry are not high - and low costs of capital. I lived and worked in Japan for 6 years as a software engineer and left speaking and reading Japanese well. However I was in a joint venture quantitative investment mgmt firm and not manufacturing. Finance has its own particular views over, actually, all industries. You'll note that an important measure in the paper is stock prices. I might add to the author's analysis: with all these countries (Japan, Taiwan, Korea and China) you have to watch the demographic curve and in particular see just how many new university graduates arrive in the economy each yr. That curve is now declining for all them - but did it start declining for Japan earlier than Taiwan and Korea? Or is the time frame involved (since the GFC) too short? Traditional economics saw inputs as: land, labor and capital. Current understanding is more nuanced but that doesn't invalidate l, l and c. Less labor, less growth.
- JJMcJ 7y agoYields are a closely guarded secret for semi companies, since that determines the lowest price a company can sell at and still make some money. High interest during the 80s really hurt a lot of US companies, though. One example is Caterpillar vs. Komatsu for construction equipment. Cat had a price premium in early 80s, then interest rates were super high, the dollar popped, and that created a window for Komatsu to grab market share.
- Merrill 7y agoFujitsu, Toshiba, Panasonic and Sony are among the largest outsourcers of manufacturing, with many factories outside of Japan and sourcing many components from non-Japanese vendors. So Japan has been going down the same path as the US, just not so far yet.
- MR4D 7y agoThere more than one instance of this, including the 2008 financial crisis, but the first one is this: As the yen appreciated by 60% following the 1985 Plaza Accord, Japanese companies lost competitiveness in final electronics goods In other words, if your currency appreciates, you’re doomed.
- nine_k 7y agoNot doomed, but your market narrows down. You better produce and sell something really special. Switzerland is an example of it: its currency, and thus work of its people, is expensive. Their exports are things like high-end mechanical watches, and other low-volume high-precision machines.
- K0SM0S 7y agoIn addition, I would think the relative safety and attractivity of finance in Switzerland is also key to making sure said currency doesn't become irrelevant. For a small country, they command impressive power in the financial space, however privately so.
- MR4D 7y agoSwitzerland is an example, but at less than 10 million people, it doesn’t compare well to many other economies like Japan, Korea, Germany, Russia, China, etc. Pivoting is much easier at small scale.
- hliyan 7y agoI constantly hear this argument about inflation being good for exports, but I cannot help but wonder that in the final analysis, it is just a mechanism by which wealth is shifted from those with savings, into the hands of exporters. Isn't this propping up exports that would otherwise have not been naturally competitive?
- gniv 7y agoThere are areas where Japan manufacturing is still above and beyond. I remember reading a few years ago about Canon Tokki, which at the time was the only manufacturer of OLED production lines. It was in the news since Apple could not get their hands on them fast enough for the iPhone.
- ksec 7y agoPure and Simple, They are the most Stubborn people on the planet. But I dont mean that is a bad way, even with all its downside, I still view it as a good thing. It is their stubbornness to not give in to crap and sloppiness. Always over engineering it, and made it uncompetitive again all other product in pricing. Not willing to adopt to market situation, as they believe in their design and system being better or "right". Most of the Japanese companies manage to remain competitive only after they moved the production out of Japan. But while they say they have the same QA in place, in reality none of the product make outside of Japan of the same brand are anywhere as good as if they were Made in Japan.
- swagasaurus-rex 7y agoWouldn't this idea support the idea that the appreciation of the yen made these industries uncompetitive in the global market? Foreign production would be more likely dealing in foreign currency, shielding them from shocks to the yen.
- amayne 7y agoCould the argument be made that the drop also correlates with the advent of smartphones like the iPhone and Android? The most expensive components in these were microprocessors – which outside embedded systems were never Japan’s strong point.
- wahern 7y ago> By finding niches where they have market power, firms can reduce their exposure to safe haven capital inflows and volatile exchange rates. But that would also exacerbate the flux of capital. That Japan has a large number of Murata Manufacturing-like producers is exactly why the Yen appreciated so sharply. That strategy makes sense for each corporation, but on a national scale it's a great way to find yourself overly specialized and with a diminished safety margin for even your niche, up-market products. So the paper's advice is also part of the reason for the dilemma. The paper's first bit of advice was to save during profitable periods and spend during downturns. But there's a cooperation problem in that the first companies to apply the aforementioned advice won't have to be as skillful at navigating the swings, so the tendency will be for every company to pursue that strategy even though only a few will succeed while the others are merely hastening their demise. Seems to me there need to be some institutional mechanisms in place to maximize long-term profitability and stability. I suppose the Keiretsu provided a mechanism like this--a self-interest in investing in diverse sectors, even during downturns. But they're diminishing as Japanese industrial practices increasingly mirror those in America and Europe.
- Scapeghost 7y agoEven in the Middle Eastern'ish backwater that I grew up in, "Made in Japan" was colloquially synonymous with quality and class during the 1980s and 90s. People prided themselves on owning Japanese TVs, radios, VCRs, sound systems, ACs, flashlights, water dispensers, beauty products and of course, cars and wristwatches. Now the whole region is inundated with Chinese knockoffs for everything, and people understand they're not as reliable, but they're good enough for the average person and cheap, and that's what matters to the importers and buyers in the end. Flimsy enclosures whose screws get permanently dislodged if knocked around in the slightest. Rechargeable lamps that dim after a month of regular use. Power strip sockets and power plug prongs of various devices have mismatching dimensions so they wobble all the time, often cutting power. Nothing is properly grounded so you often get static shocks. The same manufacturer making the same products with slight variations under dozens of brand names. There's no way of getting official support for any product, and forget about warranties or refunds. There are astonishingly identical replicas of all major Japanese and Western products, even the latest iPhones, Apple Watch and game consoles, but of course they don't have the same specs or software when you turn them on (which is usually something like "500 games in 1!" kind of emulator menus.) But more people can own them and many will never know what they're missing.
- known 7y agoJapan's methods of promoting exports has taken two paths. The first was to develop world-class industries that can initially substitute for imports and then compete in international markets. The second was to provide incentives for firms to export. The 1970s and 1980s saw the emergence of policies to restrain exports in certain industries. The great success of some Japanese export industries created a backlash in other countries, either because of their success per se or because of allegations of unfair competitive practices. Under General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) guidelines, nations have been reluctant to raise tariffs or impose import quotas. Quotas violate the guidelines, and raising tariffs goes against the general trend among industrial nations. Instead, they have resorted to convincing the exporting country to "voluntarily" restrain exports of the offending product. In the 1980s, Japan was quite willing to carry out such export restraints. Among Japan's exports to the United States, steel, color television sets, and automobiles all were subject to such restraints at various times. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_policy_of_Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_policy_of_Japan
- H8crilA 7y agoIsn't this the Triffin Dilemma? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triffin_dilemma https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triffin_dilemma