9 ms·
Here are some wild predictions I'm making + Many (or potentially all of the backers except Facebook) will withdraw from the alliance. + Facebook/Zuckerberg wi
by csomar 7y ago
Here are some wild predictions I'm making
+ Many (or potentially all of the backers except Facebook) will withdraw from the alliance.
+ Facebook/Zuckerberg will defy the gov.s and launch Libra.
+ Libra might not dominate the world, but it'll be a success (at least a niche success) and it'll eat up some of the marketshare of these financial institutions.
I think Zuckerberg has come (or already know) to the realization that these institutions "added value" is navigating the regulations/laws of the different countries. They are a kind of monopoly. Sending money across "borders" is hard only because governments made it so. If Libra ignored these rules, they'll put these guys (or at least a part of their offerings) out of business. Why would anybody use Western Union if they can send money through their Facebook for less or no fees? It's easier and more convenient too.
- colechristensen 7y ago+1 for the first and second points, but I think it will play out much differently. Facebook will try to defy regulators, but I think the SEC will stomp on them, hard. It will end up a hybrid battle in the courts and Congress between libertarians, a few flavors of privacy advocates, US regulatory concerns, and ultimately land on US power projection concerns. I think the US will eventually shape the law and regulatory environment to prevent the existence of any cryptocurrency with its own valuation - distributed ledgers denominated in central bank currencies will be all that is allowed at the end. The US financial system is a core pillar of US world power and Congress isn't going to give that power away to Facebook. It will be a complex road because the issues are difficult to grok.
- wmf 7y agoI think the US will eventually shape the law and regulatory environment to prevent the existence of any cryptocurrency with its own valuation - distributed ledgers denominated in central bank currencies will be all that is allowed at the end. Existing SEC/CFTC/FinCen rulings seem to point in a very different direction. They've had many opportunities to shut down Bitcoin and have not done it.
- colechristensen 7y agoNobody actually uses bitcoin in the US for anything besides investment speculation and really rare toy applications. It isn't being seen as a threat to anybody's central bank, because for all its enthusiasts and speculators, it hasn't developed into any sort of competition for the existing financial system unless you are doing something really illicit.
- foobarian 7y ago> unless you are doing something really illicit. Actually I wonder if the intelligence agencies of the world like the cryptocurrencies because it lets them find illicit activity more easily.
- colechristensen 7y agoNothing like an indestructible globally replicated register of your transactions to help make yourself discoverable
- alwillis 7y agoWasabi and other modern bitcoin wallets run over Tor and have built-in features (like CoinJoin, coin control, etc.) to defeat blockchain analysis companies: https://docs.wasabiwallet.io/why-wasabi/ https://docs.wasabiwallet.io/why-wasabi/ There are also decentralized, Tor-encrypted exchanges to buy and sell bitcoin like Bisq: https://bisq.network/ https://bisq.network/.
- colechristensen 7y agoEither it works and you'll find it impossible to defend legalizing cryptocurrencies with money-laundering-as-a-service in front of Congress, or it doesn't work and prosecutors will slap money laundering charges on top of any crime that matters and you'll have a lot more difficult time defending yourself and your intent when you go to such lengths to hide your financial transactions.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> the SEC will stomp on them The SEC is a civil agency. Launching something like this naked would garner state and federal prosecutors’ interests.
- oceanplexian 7y agoSure Crypto backed by a particular company might not happen, but I don’t see BTC and similar P2P blockchain currencies going anywhere. It’s about as easy to stop as digital piracy, which is to say in other words physically impossible to regulate.
- ineedasername 7y agoThe US has a tremendous amount of power in the world financial system. If they want to inhibit crypto currencies, they can make it illegal to use credit cards to buy them, illegal for US banks to transfer to or from an exchange, and illegal for US banks to deal with any bank in any country that allows such activity, or any bank that deals with another bank that allows it.
- scottmcf 7y agoIt was illegal to privately own actual gold anywhere in the world as a US citizen between 1933 and 1975. That's absolutely an approach they could take.
- ineedasername 7y agoWell, that depends. You could have gold teeth, and jewelry, so if you were really determined... though having all your teeth hollowed out and filled with gold doesn't strike me at scalable strategy, at least not unless you have a lot of kids. But all that was also only because we were on the gold standard. Which, contrary to gold-bug belief, wasn't immune from currency manipulation. The US government arbitrarily increased the value from about $20/ounce to about $30/ounce at on point, making the government suddenly richer in a way not much different than printing more money in today's fiat system.
- ENGNR 7y agoThey can't make it illegal to work for cryptocurrencies. Or to spend them for digital services like content, anonymous server hosting, or paying people for work. It's just not possible without destroying cryptography itself
- 8ytecoder 7y agoA good number of countries will outright ban it for fear of the US governments control (warranted or not).
- amluto 7y ago> Congress isn't going to give that power away to Facebook I would say that Congress shouldn’t give that power to Facebook. Congress isn’t very good at doing anything lately.
- dgzl 7y agoLately?
- vinniejames 7y agoI tend to agree, the biggest concern here is the goverment will create overly broad legislation with the only purpose of leveraging it against truly decentralized cryptocurrencies
- colechristensen 7y agoCryptocurrency enthusiasts (and... Facebook) are actively inviting legislative overreaction with their actions. Don't poke the bear.
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoMuch.
- ilaksh 7y agoThe goal of Libra was not really to compete with Western Union. It was more to compete with real cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum, Monero, etc. and it wasn't just Facebook's idea. PayPal, Visa etc. know that real cryptocurrencies are eventually going to put them out of business. That's why they joined in on this fake cryptocurrency. The reason companies are pulling out is probably just because it looks like it's not going to succeed. Another theory is that it is just too obvious when you have those payment company's names attached. Too easy for people like me to say "why do you think Visa and MasterCard would back a 'cryptocurrency'"? It's quite possible that the people with real power in government will figure out that this is not a real cryptocurrency and in fact is the best defense the government has against real cryptocurrency which they can't track or interfere with. Because Facebook will give them total access for surveillance and control over transactions.
- chank 7y agoIt's way more complex than that. Pretty much everyone in government and the crypto space doesn't want Libra to succeed under it's current stewardship. The implications are very far reaching. Also, there isn't a single cryptocurrency today that can't be tracked, even ones like Monero.
- worik 7y agoAlso, there isn't a single cryptocurrency today that can't be tracked, even ones like Monero. Really?
- chank 7y agoCan be, yes. Through combining network and non-network meta-data. If anyone actually has the desire to do so is another question entirely, but I wouldn't be surprised if certain state-level agencies have already begun to compile such data.
- LMYahooTFY 7y ago>Also, there isn't a single cryptocurrency today that can't be tracked, even ones like Monero. Sure, and the cost of doing so compared to some guy typing queries into their indexed list of every financial transaction in the United States (at minimum) is probably at least one or two orders of magnitude. If you are someone or know someone to grant you some basic technical knowledge then certainly one or two orders of magnitude higher cost, unless you're a designated terrorist, or someone elected officials talk about executing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- FillardMillmore 7y agoOne of the drivers for the regulation is simply that the government is concerned about getting their piece of the pie. The regulatory fight will be interesting to watch, but I'm more interested in how Libra is going to affect the field of cryptocurrencies as a whole.
- ineedasername 7y ago">If Libra ignored these rules..." This isn't like Uber silently encroaching on a city's taxi medallion laws with grey-area definitions of "taxi" and "employee". Facebook cannot do something like this without attracting scrutiny at every stage, and as we saw with Robinhood, the financial regulation systems are relatively quick to act. Especially if they "defy govs", then those government's will have every reason to come down hard. This is one area where Facebook will need to finesse their way through-- moving fast and breaking things is not a winning strategy.
- K0SM0S 7y agoHonestly from an industrial / historical perspective, they are trying to enter a game of a whole other level than anything social-media or ad-related can ever touch. I don't know how they can win using the same strategy (disingenuosity, cheeky attitude, etc) than they used so far. It just won't fly in that space. Even bitcoin et al. look more serious by comparison, by a mile, and that's saying a lot. Not sure if serious or delusional, actually. Over-hyped by their own kool-aid, you know. It tends to happen to surprisingly large groups in the Valley. Time will tell, but if they don't have a special sauce kinda joker to play, I just don't see it. Defying states never worked well unless said states are basically non-existent.
- greggman2 7y agoI don't know what Libra's plans are but couldn't Facebook make their own Paypal? What would really be the difference? I can hold a balance at Paypal. I can pay others and others can pay me. The "crypto" part seems like an implementation detail but otherwise irrelevant. Note: I'm not saying Facebook should be allowed to make their own Paypal. I'm just curious other than "Facebook scary because big" what other reason would prevent Facebook from making a Paypal clone. Google has Google Pay, Apple has Apple Pay, why can't Facebook have Facebook Pay. What would really be the difference? Just the part about currency conversion to their own units and back? Is that different from certain game virtual currencies?
- Qworg 7y agoNothing prevents them from building PayPal, except the regulatory regime they don't want to ascribe to. Also, the currency conversion to their own units and back relates to the taxability of said currency and the inability to use WoW gold to buy Starbucks. It is a matter of degrees - Facebook could seriously destabilize monetary policy for certain countries and subvert currency controls.
- wahern 7y ago> Why would anybody use Western Union if they can send money through their Facebook for less or no fees? Because Western Union accepts and delivers cash. Western Union exists for the much the same reason payday lenders exist--to service the cash economy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- yellow_postit 7y agoThere's so many ways beyond Western Union already to avoid exorbitant fees, one example is TransferWise. While a very broad use case I'm not sold given the existing competition that FB has anything super unique or compelling when just restricted to the cross border money transfer space.
- jcampbell1 7y agoLibra is meant to be the m-pesa of the world. It is funny that the US government and CIA haven’t figured out how much Libra will offer US hegemony. At some point Sandberg will explain it to the political dopes and Libra will happen. That day is not today. I don’t have time to explain this comment, but I am probably missing something in my thinking.
- SomeOldThrow 7y ago> Libra might not dominate the world, but it'll be a success (at least a niche success) and it'll eat up some of the marketshare of these financial institutions. This relies on people consciously choosing to give money to libra rather than transferring directly. Why would anyone do this rather than use apple pay/cash/venmo/zelle with USD?
- Iv 7y agoEither Zuckberg has a geeky naive understanding of financial institutions to think this will go easily, or he is ready to use blackmail material. Libra is something I wish we fight to the death.
- Mengkudulangsat 7y agoWhat is so hateful about Libra when compared with the People Bank of China's digital currency project? When that is launched, any non-chinese can hold digital yuan without a bank account. Wouldn't the west want something equivalent for geopolitical reasons?
- asjw 7y agoBank of China is not a private company it's run by the Chinese government. Facebook is not the US government.
- sweeneyrod 7y agoI don't trust Facebook, but the Chinese government aren't exactly a shining paragon of virtue either.
- pyrale 7y agoAs a "westerner" please explain me why I would want a private american company that has been known to neglect their responsibilities to wield geopolitical power?
- JohnStrangeII 7y agoI don't think any of this is desirable. For me, it's similar to digital voting, I have strong technical concerns with crypto currencies. The cryptography behind them or the implementations will be broken. People claim that it's different now than it used to be. Every cryptographic system of the past has been broken, but now we have the computing power to make them future proof. There are no mathematical proofs for this assertion and there is no reason to believe it when you take into account the history of cryptography. Moreover, for some reasons the security margins in public cryptography tend to be far too low. I'd be surprised if many existing crypto currencies are even "quantum proof" yet - but attacks with quantum computers will likely be feasible in 10 - 20 years, if they aren't already for some state actors. All it takes is one weakness in a protocol or one mathematical breakthrough in cryptanalysis, and the whole economy of a country could become vulnerable to attack and break down.
- chris_wot 7y agoThe U.S. government will be very pleased that Facebook have circumvented all their anti-money laundering safeguards. So will entire nation states. Nothing could possibly go wrong.
- plmu 7y agoIf that happens, facebook will be attacked from all sides (including states) and loose.
- goatinaboat 7y agoit'll be a success Imagine being unable to buy food because an algorithm determined that “you violated our community standards” and there’s no way to contact them. One or two stories like that will kill Libra stone dead. If Libra ignored these rules, they'll put these guys (or at least a part of their offerings) out of business This is called money laundering, people go to jail for it.
- dvdbloc 7y agoIt’s all speculation but I wouldn’t be so sure about some negative press killing Libra. Thinking of another large platform where an algorithm determined a driver safe and then they perform a sexual assault on one of their passengers, it gets tons of press, still has millions of users... Example: https://money.cnn.com/2018/04/30/technology/uber-driver-sexual-assault/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2018/04/30/technology/uber-driver-sexu...
- theK 7y agoVery correct, bad results or user experience would unfortunately not have any effect if it is not a systemic problem that the great mass of users experiences. Google services also are still successful and used by billions even though google has a track record of terminating accounts at random...
- louhike 7y agoYou're comparing oranges to apples here. I really don't see how Facebook potentially refusing access to their platforms for obscures reasons can be compared to an employee of a platform committing sexual assault.
- alt_f4 7y ago> Imagine being unable to buy food because an algorithm determined that “you violated our community standards” and there’s no way to contact them. One or two stories like that will kill Libra stone This already exists. If your bank's AML algorithm flags certain transactions, your account will be frozen, with no explanation (they legally can't tell you why they did it, it is an offense). You will be asked to produce some documents whilst they and potentially law enforcement investigate. Again, you won't be told why or how long it will take. Usually, if you haven't done anything wrong, you'll have no access to your money for 1-2 months. Now, here's the kicker. Those flagging algorithms aren't very good. They don't work on any sophisticated social graphs. They're based on a bunch of simple rules -- maybe you made a large cash deposit, or wired more money than usual, or received a bunch of small transactions (maybe you're selling drugs?). The flag is raised, the account is frozen and you're shit out of luck trying to get an explanation or buying things for a few months. Given we still use banks, I'm sure "you violated our community standards" won't be the straw that broke the camel's back.
- speedplane 7y ago> Why would anybody use Western Union if they can send money through their Facebook for less or no fees? It's easier and more convenient too. So if I'm in the United States, and want to send some of my paycheck back to my family in Sudan so they could buy stuff, how could I do that with Libra?
- southerndrift 7y agoI would assume that there will be a neighbor who offers a money service to the village. He will have a Libra account. No need to drive to the next big city. Your family can go to that person who they trust and he will hand out the money. And if it is not Facebook, it will be WeChat. Then you first have to send your Libra coins to a suitable exchange that will wire it to that neighbor. Actually, many African countries have mobile money, so you won't wire it to a WeChat exchange but to a mobile money exchange [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_MobileMoney https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_MobileMoney
- grecy 7y ago> So if I'm in the United States, and want to send some of my paycheck back to my family in Sudan so they could buy stuff, how could I do that with Libra? Well, you can't. Sudan blocks access to Facebook (I was just there). A VPN mostly worked, but it was painful. Sudan is also cut off from the international money markets because they are on the list of 5 "bad" countries according to the US. No foreign bank cards function at all. Extremely nice and welcoming people. Friendliest I have ever met on the entire planet, hands down.
- Smithalicious 7y agoNormally I'd say that "[thing] but with no regard for the law" isn't a viable business model, but several startups have already proved me wrong.
- tnolet 7y agoNegative press hurt Facebook only slightly and mostly in the west. In Asia and Africa Facebook is still the internet.
- tjpnz 7y ago>+ Facebook/Zuckerberg will defy the gov.s and launch Libra. They could try but they'll be doing so in the face of laws designed to combat money laundering and funding of terrorist organisations. This isn't remotely on the same level as what AirBnB were doing when they decided to flout local laws around rental properties. >I think Zuckerberg has come (or already know) to the realization that these institutions "added value" is navigating the regulations/laws of the different countries. That's what will likely make Libra a non-starter in most countries. Financial institutions have already invested significantly to ensure their business practices are compliant with both local and international law. They won't allow Facebook to start undermining that.
- skywhopper 7y ago> Sending money across "borders" is hard only because governments made it so On the contrary, it's much easier than it has ever been in human history to send money across borders, mostly due to government regulation of international finance. For the absurdly wealthy, such regulation is a major pain of course. But the thing about the absurdly wealthy is... they can afford to deal with major pains. For the rest of the human race, the real question to ask about these non-governmental currencies is: would you rather have your money be regulated by your local government and the governments of those you wish to trade with, or would you rather have your money be regulated by Facebook? I find this a very easy question to answer, personally.
- jMyles 7y ago> would you rather have your money be regulated by your local government and the governments of those you wish to trade with, or would you rather have your money be regulated by Facebook? This is a false dichotomy: blockchain tech makes it clear that a third possibility is emerging - one which relies on no central authority at all, be it state or corporate.
- hakfoo 7y agoThe third option, despite not having a "central authority" seems to have been widely hijacked. What we know about economics seems to fly in the face of design decisions repeated again and again by cryptocurrency originators. The popularity of deflationary economics (maximum coin counts, diminishing mining rewards) incentivizes economic rictus-- eternal hoarding and austerity-- when basically every central bank on Earth recognizes that a modest, predictable inflation rate helps to spur consumer demand and actual economic activity. This is not some conspiracy to undermine your gold sovereigns and silver dollars, it's a century of data in action. Then you've got the tendency to stick to unsavoury communities. While some of this may be because they're the funding method of last resort for businesses that can't touch conventional payment systems (criminal or just radioactively controversial), there does seem to be an active prioritization of privacy, unreversibility, and immunity from regulation features, over features non-enthusiast consumers want like "easy cashin/out to fiat" and "fraud protection". If you said "here's a shiny happy new tech product. It's not designed as a treatise on the gold standard, to spar with governments, or create some speculative investment. It's just about using 21st century technology to undercut the high margins of Visa, Mastercard, and Western Union", that would hit real needs. But it would be 1) hard to bootstrap because there would be no philosophically or investment motivated enthusiasts to evangelize for it and 2) likely very different in structure and operation than today's cryptocurrency products. It might not even be a blockchain-crypto product, and it might even be outright ran by a state agency.
- koboll 7y agoI wonder why they chose to trumpet Libra with a big announcement and all this rhetoric implying it would be a major competitor to fiat currency. Surely that wasn't necessary to popularize it. It could have been launched quietly and promoted in-app to the target audiences, and the furor from the press and various governments could have been largely avoided. Was there a benefit gained that outweighed that cost? Or does Facebook drink its own kool aid so thoroughly that they simply didn't realize people would push back?
- mattrp 7y agoI think the partners are all realizing the last thing they want to be involved in is a project with banking regulations / consequences and a partner that so far has thumbed its nose at government oversight.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 7y agoTransferring money across borders has already been mostly disrupted by Tansferwise. Fees for that are about 10% of what WU charges. Granted there is still some room for improvement there since 1. Transferwise uses ACH so it takes a couple days and 2. Not everyone in poorer counties has easy access to a bank account or even a bank (with WU you can literally set up a stall on the side of the road and people can send and receive money). I think 1 and 2 could still be solved with traditional fiat since there’s not a hard requirement that ACH needs to be used. The fees are low enough with Transferwise that it’s probably not too much of a blocker for people to pay them.
- freetanga 7y agoLet me add: + Big act of terrorism found to be financed through siphoning funds via Libra, sidestepping worldwide regulatory frameworks. Bot Zuck Mark V walks into Congress, says he will look into it, nothing happens as said Congressmen used Libra to shift funds offshore to Panamá accounts...