34 ms·
Attorney General will ask Zuckerberg to halt plans for end-to-end encryption
- cbeach 7y agoRemoving / banning encryption will hurt us all, including (I hope) the ignorant and authoritarian politicians responsible for eroding our privacy. I eagerly await the publication of these politicians’ private communications.
- ganitarashid 7y agoIn other words, these politicians are unelectable
- humble_engineer 7y agoI am a proponent for encryption but I don't think Facebook should be allowed to end to end encrypt all of their messaging platforms. You will have people messaging very young children offering them $ to do things and law enforcement should be able to retrieve that with ease. If they do this, there would be almost no liability for spamming millions of young girls or boys recruitment messages.
- HorizonXP 7y agoMETA: DAE get popups/hijack ads when the click anywhere on that article? I'm on macOS Safari, and I'm wondering if it's me, or the site.
- Alupis 7y agoDoes End-to-End Encryption mean anything here? What's stopping the government from just forcing Facebook to provide access to the servers directly, or through some sort of portal? This just means the government can't intercept them without Facebook cooperation... no?
- simonbw 7y agoI believe end-to-end means that the message is encrypted on the sender’s device, remains encrypted in transit and on Facebook servers, and is then only decrypted on the receiver’s device. Facebook themselves would not be able to read user’s messages.
- Alupis 7y agoAh, ya that makes more sense. Although I have a tough time believing Facebook would lock themselves out fully... they need all those data points for pushing ads...
- tempestn 7y agoThey get plenty of data from what people post to the facebook and instagram platforms. I can definitely see how business incentives could swing toward E2E encryption for messaging. (Not because most people will know the difference, but because people who influence tech trends will, and are privacy conscious.)
- alexnewman 7y agoThis is bs. Facebook can already push a bonked app to your phone which makes interdiction easy.
- alexnewman 7y agoWhy must I always get downvoted when I say anything slightly critical or anti big tech?
- yccheok 7y agoSo that FBI can have my cat pictures?
- zarro 7y agoI think its more about "We wont be able to collect data en masse as efficiently anymore" than it is about "National Security or prevention of sex trafficking".
- doggydogs94 7y agoGranting one government access to data is the same as granting access to every government.
- kitchenkarma 7y agoAssume these services are being tapped. If you want ultimate privacy exchange keys with your contacts offline and you PGP over any messaging service.
- gigatexal 7y agoPerhaps Zuck will make a deal with the Devil and go forward with this if he receives some agreement that they won’t break up FB into many companies and continue to allow the firm to do shady things with user data.
- slimginz 7y agoAgreements like that only work for the current administration in charge. Once Trump and crew is out of there that deal is dead. And since Trump hasn't indicated recently that he wants to break up Facebook, Zuck only has Warren to really worry about. If she wins, she's gonna do everything she can to break up that company regardless of previous deals with previous administrations.
- m0zg 7y agoRepublican administration will not break up FB. Elizabeth Warren could, which is why she won't win the election if she's nominated. Big Tech, which is in charge of what we see and don't see is directly threatened by her, so you can bet that "algorithms" will all of a sudden find it appropriate to de-rank her content.
- oconnor663 7y agoHow does the Attorney General feel about foreign governments making "lawful requests" for people's private Facebook messages? Does he believe America benefits from giving every government access, or does he believe that these systems would somehow serve America alone?
- choppaface 7y agoTime for Facebook to make like Google and say 'sorry but foregoing end-to-end encryption would lower the Barr' https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/googlers-say-f-you-to-nsa-company-encrypts-internal-network/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/googl... (Of course, this just prompted Google to serve more legal data requests, but better than letting the Justice Dept sweep everything for who knows what end)
- akersten 7y agoThey can ask all they want, the answer should always be "No."
- ZuckMuck 7y agoRight to privacy supersedes the AG's request.
- sroussey 7y agoFB has enough privacy problems, and now we supposedly want them to read and keep all private person to person messages? No thanks.
- saagarjha 7y ago> We are writing to request that Facebook does not proceed with its plan to implement end-to-end encryption across its messaging services without ensuring that there is no reduction to user safety. Oh, so you’re asking for more end-to-end encryption? > While the letter acknowledges that Facebook, which owns Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp, and Instagram, captures 99% of child exploitation and terrorism-related content through its own systems, it also notes that "mere numbers cannot capture the significance of the harm to children." This is such a lazy argument :/
- Kinnard 7y agoThe Second Great CryptoWar: https://reason.com/2013/03/12/the-second-great-crypto-war/ https://reason.com/2013/03/12/the-second-great-crypto-war/ > "The proponents of this process use fear tactics to win support, what the four cypherpunks dub "The Four Horsemen of the Info-pocalypse: child pornography, terrorism, money laundering, and the War on Some Drugs." In other words, laws passed to go after child pornographers, terrorists, money launderers, and drug dealers end up chipping away at everyone's privacy. The classic example is the PATRIOT Act, passed to prevent terrorism but soon used to expand wiretapping and National Security Letter powers in other contexts."
- radarsat1 7y agoWhat's the fourth horseman? edit: ok ok sorry I misread
- mr_overalls 7y ago1) child porn 2) terrorism 3) money laundering 3) war on [edit: some] drugs
- cowmoo728 7y agoIt was specifically "war on some drugs". Americans love drugs, and we even love dangerous or mind altering drugs. But some drugs, for various socioeconomic reasons, we have declared evil.
- OedipusRex 7y ago"We are writing to request that Facebook does not proceed with its plan to implement end-to-end encryption across its messaging services without ensuring that there is no reduction to user safety." Isn't the entire point of E2E Encryption for user safety, as in safety from the government reading your message?
- kamyarg 7y agoTrue E2E Encryption would also mean the platform(FB, Telegram, Google, Apple, etc.) also can not read the messages and thus the law enforcement can not force them to reveal what a user said because it would be impossible for them to know.
- snarf21 7y agoYou are partially right but the issue is that E2E isn't even enough. E2E doesn't matter if they force a patched binary that also sends the data to the government. This is EXACTLY what the Australian laws saws they must do, oh and it is a gag order so they can't disclose it. I'm starting to wonder if this is a smokescreen. Eventually give in to E2E because you know you have got app store signing keys for the apps so you can upload a patched one with backdoors.
- vageli 7y ago> You are partially right but the issue is that E2E isn't even enough. E2E doesn't matter if they force a patched binary that also sends the data to the government. This is EXACTLY what the Australian laws saws they must do, oh and it is a gag order so they can't disclose it. > I'm starting to wonder if this is a smokescreen. Eventually give in to E2E because you know you have got app store signing keys for the apps so you can upload a patched one with backdoors. Is there no way to prevent auto-updating of apps? If the app blocks access barring upgrade it may be suspicious. Though I guess the upgrade would probably be veiled in new features.
- colejohnson66 7y ago
- murat124 7y ago> to delay plans for end-to-end encryption across its messaging services until it can guarantee the added privacy does not reduce public safety. Eat a bag of dicks, Barr.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't do this here.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- surfsvammel 7y ago"We are writing to request that Facebook does not proceed with its plan to implement end-to-end encryption across its messaging services without ensuring that there is no reduction to user safety." I don’t get it. How could end-to-end encryption reduce user safety?
- fooey 7y agoThis is the authoritarian argument that it makes everyone less safe if they're not allowed to spy on everyone.
- adrianmonk 7y agoIt's even a poor version of that argument. The victims of whatever crimes this would allegedly prevent aren't necessarily users of the platform. In that type of scenario, the perpetrators are the users.
- univalent 7y agoWhy should Facebook guarantee that it won't lead to security concerns? That's not their job. Is the AG going to go around asking all companies not to do E2E encryption until they can each make that guarantee?
- ddoolin 7y ago> While the letter acknowledges that Facebook, which owns Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp, and Instagram, captures 99% of child exploitation and terrorism-related content through its own systems, it also notes that "mere numbers cannot capture the significance of the harm to children." Ah yes, "think of the children!" This is so tired, I'm (just a bit) surprised they fell into this argument.
- berdon 7y agoThe joke is on "them" in our current day and age. The overwhelming majority that care about children are far more interested in gun safety than backdoors for the NRA backing party.
- kazagistar 7y agoI will believe that anyone in politics gives a shit about children when the US stops bombing children in other countries.
- alkonaut 7y agoAlso: Kids being shot in schools: the price of freedom. Private communications means also criminals can communicate privately: outrage.
- Brushfire 7y agoIf they don't do E2E, users will abandon Facebook for platforms that do support it (and already are). And they aren't doing this to commit crimes, but to prevent advertisements from targeting every conversation they've ever had.
- dancemethis1 7y agoThey won't. People are not really giving a crap for their (and their peers') safety. Just look at how popular Discord is alongside FB.
- dylan604 7y agoPlease name these other platforms
- tempestn 7y agoSignal messenger
- sschueller 7y agoTelegram, threema, wire swiss, matrix, signal and many more.
- kitchenkarma 7y agoYou are unable to tell whether any service uses E2E. It is best to assume we don't have E2E services and adjust own opsec accordingly.
- saagarjha 7y agoI wonder how many WhatsApp users are aware that their messages are encrypted end-to-end.
- pilsetnieks 7y agoIt shows that in every message thread, so I'd say everyone; how many understand that and realize the consequences of having or not having E2E encryption is another matter.
- wonderwonder 7y agoSometimes I can understand the willingness to reduce the privacy of self and others in order to ensure that the law is able to prosecute those involved in heinous crimes. Our current political environment though involved a president openly calling on foreign governments to investigate his political opponents. What is to stop them from going after the private communications of those same opponents in the name of targeting "Corruption". Encrypt it, end to end, the government does not need to be able access all private communications of private citizens. There are other means of investigating potential crimes.
- snarf21 7y agoOn top of that, so these crimes didn't exist before mobile phones? They just want to sit in the ivory tower and see everything. I'll also agree to this the day after Barr hands me his unlocked personal phone. I promise not to disclose anything I find.
- brunoTbear 7y agoYou may be radically underestimating the degree to which the Internet has made it possible for people who abuse children to share content. In some cases, these crimes truly couldn't be perpetrated without the anonymity of the Internet, and the existence of these clustered communities of pedophiles encourages further abuse/exploitation. I love the Internet, and my career is in security. But we as a security/privacy/technology community truly need to look hard in the mirror about how we are allowing and perpetuating lifetime harms to children and women. Terrorism exceptions, like San Bernardino, don't ring with as much impact as the CEP argument.
- throw0101a 7y ago> terrorists, drug dealers, pedophiles, and organized crime * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalypse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalyp...
- autoexec 7y agoEncryption or not, if "bad" people can access illegal content "good" people can too. It might take actual work instead of passively reviewing the private communications of every person innocent or otherwise, but it's not made suddenly impossible.
- evilsnoopi3 7y agoI don't think this often, but, in this case, Facebook is doing the right thing both ethically and practically.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoFacebook isn't doing it because they believe in it. WhatsApp added E2EE after being acquired by Facebook but before FB fully took control, a parting gift of sorts.
- eloff 7y agoI hate these requests for government back doors into tech communication software in the name of "the children". Let the parents worry about and protect their own children. Let the government mind its own business and stay out of ours.
- robrenaud 7y agoAnd if the parents are the abusers, then it's okay? I am still pro E2E encryption, especially given the Snowden revelations (the US gov cannot be trusted to be responsible), but it does come at a high cost. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-abuse.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-...
- eloff 7y agoThat's a really horrible situation, but running an information drag net on the entire world is the wrong way to crack down on that kind of crime.
- heavyset_go 7y agoWe could solve a lot of those problems if we put a camera, or quartered a soldier, in every home.
- giggles_giggles 7y agoNot often I get to invoke the 3rd Amendment. Get out of here, you Loyalist!
- mlindner 7y agoThe thought that people can remove all crime or get anywhere near it is faulty from first axioms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer." If you start thinking that parents "can be" the criminals then you've decided that parents are automatically guilty and must be proved innocent. This goes against the very moral fiber of the entire western world theory of law, the presumption of innocence.
- s3r3nity 7y agoQuestion for those more knowledgeable than I in this space: a huge value prop for iMessage is E2E encryption, correct? Why hasn't that gotten similar response from the AG? (OR has it already, and I may have missed it?)
- mikhailt 7y agoThey did go after Apple, remember the FBI vs. Apple court cases about forcing Apple to backdoor the entire OS to get to the user's data: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI%E2%80%93Apple_encryption_dispute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI%E2%80%93Apple_encryption_d... As for Facebook, it is more likely because Facebook is in "progress" of enabling E2E and they have more users than Apple right now. It is easier to hit Facebook now than later unlike in the case of Apple that already implemented it from the start; it would go into court litigation for several years and most likely end up in Supreme Court. Barr is just assuming FB will cave in. PS: No, a huge value prop for iMessages is that it's built into iOS and any iPhone user can talk to another iPhone user, not because of E2E. Most users aren't aware of what E2E is.
- nuclear_eclipse 7y agoMost likely because a) it happened well before current administration and AG, and b) because Apple didn't saying anything until after it had already been done, rather than declaring intentions and giving the AG plenty of time to draft ridiculous letters.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Question for those more knowledgeable than I in this space: a huge value prop for iMessage is E2E encryption, correct? Why hasn't that gotten similar response from the AG? Because when Apple was preparing it, it wasn’t public about it, and the then-sitting AG wasn't looking to generate news articles with his name that weren't attached to his role in acts fueling an imminent Presidential impeachment, so no similar warning note.
- sigmar 7y agoI'd like to contrast with the other responses here by offering my suspicion that Apple is cooperating with governments to quietly swap out keys for users upon receiving a court order. It would explain why Skype was banned by China and iMessage was not.
- surfsvammel 7y agoSometimes I think that things like this is a problem related to age. Older people (often those is charge) is not any where near as tech-savvy as younger people. They just don’t understand. Ignorance. In time it will all be alright...
- authoritarian 7y agoAh yes, another case of "We must stop the pedophiles and terrorists, so please just allow us to monitor everything you do at all times"
- not_a_cop75 7y agoThis could probably be reworded better. "While the letter acknowledges that Facebook, which owns Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp, and Instagram, captures 99% of child exploitation and terrorism-related content through its own systems, it also notes that "mere numbers cannot capture the significance of the harm to children." "
- wongarsu 7y ago> Risks to public safety from Facebook’s proposals are exacerbated in the context of a single platform that would combine inaccessible messaging services with open profiles, providing unique routes for prospective offenders to identify and groom our children So the government not having access to private communication is a threat to public safety, and won't somebody think of the children!
- brunoTbear 7y agoThe claim of catching 99% of activity is really hard to justify. In many detection systems you cannot know your true number of false negatives. It's inherently unknowable in this case. A better metric would be mean time to detection for a given CEP sharer or perhaps a metric around how much CEP is shared before detection, or perhaps a metric for network size of CEP and how well FB can clean up an entire network at once. This NYTimes article https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-abuse.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-... is quite good. I don't want to punish FB for doing a good job of detection by turning around clutching my pearls at them. Stamos tweeted that every hosting platform has these challenges and I believe him. There has to be some nuance from the absolute privacy folks on this one. How do we balance the need to fight child abuse with privacy?
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoI mean, you could always do an audit and see what percent of a thing your automated system catches. That definitely doesn't seem inherently unknowable.
- salawat 7y agoYou're not quite getting it. You measure accuracy of detection via a training set of definitely known examples, and comparing it to the detections reported by your system. You can say with certainty that their system catches 99% of your training data set, but that doesn't mean it Will generalize to "all permutations of child abuse ever". That's two totally different things. In the end their use of that statistic illustrates an attempt to lie with statistics more than anything else.
- edmundsauto 7y agoBy this standard, no system could ever say that it generalizes to all permutations. Especially when the definition of the measurement outcome (child abuse) varies.
- 7y ago
- encoderer 7y agoZuck, the mat is calling.
- greencar 7y agoIs there an easy way for the people to make an open letter to Mr. Zuckerberg asking decline on Barrs request?
- gumby 7y ago> "We are writing to request that Facebook does not proceed with its plan to implement end-to-end encryption across its messaging services without ensuring that there is no reduction to user safety." Seems easy for FB to comply with this: they are adding encryption specifically to improve user safety.* The later extract in the article body talks about "public" safety, which is the classic false dichotomy that has been brought up by law agencies for the past 30 years. Much as it sticks in my craw to say something supportive of either of that meretricious duo Barr and Patel, I have to admit I am glad that they are using an open letter rather than trying for a backroom deal or quiet threats. Perhaps they tried those already and have been rebuffed. I have seen some friends of mine outraged by social media's inability to do wholesale censorship, spurred by some NYT articles on child abuse from last week. I wonder if that was coordinated? * OK, they are a corporation doing it to encourage people to use their service, but they are trying to accomplish that by improving user safety.
- quotemstr 7y agoIt's really amazing how often tyranny is justified on the basis of "safety". It's why the "trust and safety" team moniker ubiquitous in the tech industry sounds so Orwellian. I think tech companies would have a stronger basis for refusing to monitor and censor user traffic if they hadn't volunteered to monitor and censor some user traffic. Doing anything some of the time makes you vulnerable to pressure to do more of that thing. Carrying all legal content and refusing any cooperation with the government without a warrant is the only sustainable path.
- wcunning 7y agoThere was a discussion not long ago about brain privacy on the front page and this twitter thread was brought up in the comments: https://twitter.com/hashbreaker/status/709314886384427008 https://twitter.com/hashbreaker/status/709314886384427008 > Fun game to play: Take statements from Comey et al. Replace "smartphones" with "brains"/"memories"/"thoughts". Technology will get us there! Very on brand for the new versions of this request...
- hnspirit 7y agoTHANK OFF THA CHULDRUN!! (Lol)
- Johnny555 7y ago"We are writing to request that Facebook does not proceed with its plan to implement end-to-end encryption across its messaging services without ensuring that there is no reduction to user safety." I don't understand why they don't just ask for what they want, why say it's about "user safety" when it's not about that at all. Just say "As a matter of national security, the government needs to be able to read user messages (and we don't care if that opens up a hole that enables other governments to do it too)"
- leshow 7y ago> I don't understand why they don't just ask for what they want, why say it's about "user safety" when it's not about that at all. Because they don't care about an honest representation of their argument, they just want to have their will imposed. The best way to do that is to lie.
- mattnewton 7y agoBecause Americans would not make that trade, and that makes the government worker's job harder. So they spin it in a way that is more palatable so they can erode barriers to their job. They (government workers at the agency) have no real incentives to fight for privacy other than having to live with eroded privacy, which most people just don't think about as giving something up until it affects them anyways.
- inetknght 7y ago> I don't understand why they don't just ask for what they want, why say it's about "user safety" when it's not about that at all. Have you never heard someone lie through their teeth?
- smueller1234 7y agoQuite simply because this makes it hard for Facebook to fight back. If they do, they look like they're on the wrong side of morality. If the demand was phrased around security, it would be less emotionally laden (for most).
- buboard 7y ago
- jknz 7y agoDetecting child abuse pictures is not incompatible with end-to-end encryption if the detection is done locally. Facebook (or other messenger app owners) could train a good classification model to detect child abuse pictures on large servers and provide the model to smartphones locally. Before sending pictures, the app would run the trained model (which is cheap computationally). If if detects pictures of abuse with a certain accuracy, the app would block the transmission of the picture (possibly, explaining why to the user). If the detection of pictures of abuse happens again, the user could be banned from the app for 1 day, and if it happens more often the ban would become longer and longer. That way facebook can fight child abuse without ever having the pictures.
- jpadkins 7y agodon't trust the client. How easy it would be for a motivated community to create a binary patch that skipped the local abuse checks?
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoIf we're positing users clever enough to modify the client, then such users could also just modify the client to scramble all CP images so that they would not be detectable via fingerprinting and can only be descrambled by a patched client. People sending CP through whatsapp/FBM are not clever. If they were clever, they wouldn't be doing that. The justice department is not primarily interested in catching clever criminals, at least not via this particular mechanism.
- jknz 7y agoThere are ways to run trusted code on a client using remote enclaves (provided it is supported by the local CPU) https://signal.org/blog/private-contact-discovery/ https://signal.org/blog/private-contact-discovery/
- jandrese 7y agoHow are you going to get a pedo to setup a secure enclave on his box that you control? This is one of those technologies that are cool in theory but almost impossible to implement in practice on current hardware.
- rosybox 7y agoFor those of you opposed to this request from the government, what do you think the negative consequences are for end to end encryption? Do you think there are no negative consequences or are they just negligible? Just try and imagine what the cost might be, how broad the impact might be and who and how many would bear the brunt of those costs. Nobody really cares about your personal Facebook messages to your friends and family. You're not that important. But still considering what is being offered in payment for this privacy, it's still worth it to you? I'm not so sure it is, personally.
- kyboren 7y agoYou make the mistake of assuming the watchmen have and will always have noble intentions. Rather, you should assume that at some point, someone in power will have the most ignoble intentions. What do you think the negative consequences are for a government to have a permanent record of every private conversation made over the Internet? Bear in mind that the fraction of all private conversations which occur over the Internet is only increasing. You must assume that "exceptional access" really means "routine access". While the government claims it only wants access to some encrypted content, decryption leaves no trace. The NSA's collection posture is: "Sniff it All, Know it All, Collect it All, Process it All, Exploit it All, Partner it All." Does it sound to you like the NSA will sit on their hands while some other USG functionary has the Golden Key? > Nobody really cares about your personal Facebook messages to your friends and family. You're not that important. But still considering what is being offered in payment for this privacy, it's still worth it to you? Perhaps you're correct now. But imagine that a decade from now, you (or a friend or family member) become an activist or a political candidate. Now your incumbent political opponents have a wealth of sensitive private data to mine to find anything to imprison or discredit you. The argument extends further than your own direct interests: What happens to our political system when policymakers are completely transparent to the NSA and their political co-conspirators? Considering the very real risks of a totalitarian government ruling with an iron machine learning model, or a silent coup by military intelligence, is it still worth it to you?
- rosybox 7y agoYou didn't address my question though. You're just thinking about the cost to you personally if you don't have end to end encryption. I'm asking you to think about the cost of having it. What's the cost. Compare that probably real cost, a thing that is a real problem right now, with your own personal alarm at some future imagined problem.
- throwaway66666 7y agoThere are many forms of tyrants, but there are none so terrible as those stifling their own people in the name of freedom and safety.
- noonespecial 7y agoIn the current political environment, allowing the government (just about any nation's) in via eliminating end-to-end encryption is a reduction to user safety.
- aloukissas 7y agoWhat a great way to convince even more of my contacts to switch to Signal :)
- tracker1 7y agoF*ck AG Barr... they can subpoena their data requests like they should have already been doing.
- mprev 7y agoForgive the OT comment but in the UK we have a soft drinks manufacturer named AG Barr, most famous for Irn Bru. I spent a few moments trying to understand what had led to the manufacturer of Tizer, Irn Bru, and various other traditional British soft drinks getting involved in this. https://www.agbarr.co.uk/ https://www.agbarr.co.uk/
- sofaofthedamned 7y agoThat caught me too...
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoYou're not the only one. I was wondering what FB might have done to Irn Bru to provoke the response... :)
- dang 7y agoWow, that's quite a stretch for a title ambiguity: attorney general or soft drink? Submitted title was "AG Barr Will Ask Zuckerberg To Halt Plans For End-To-End Encryption".
- brianpgordon 7y agoI mean, I doubt that many UK natives know the name of the US Attorney General off the top of their heads. It seems like a reasonable mixup to me.
- atonse 7y agoReasonable to think that a soft drink provider would ask FB to not use end-to-end encryption? But I agree that AG should be expanded.
- brianpgordon 7y agoThey realized that something was off, obviously. They were just saying it was confusing at first because without the context of knowing who Barr is, "AG" is a nonsense word. The only remaining parse is a soft-drink company.
- danShumway 7y ago> mere numbers cannot capture the significance of the harm to children. Oh, bull crap. By this argument, literally no protection or liberty that allows even one child to be harmed could ever be tolerated. Why stop at vetting baby-sitters or teachers? We ought to require mandatory background checks for every person who ever visits a family or goes into a public space that might contain children. Law enforcement also ought to be able to track every underage child at all times, via mandatory GPS collars. At the risk of sounding callous, there are occasionally some situations where you really do need to shut up and multiply.
- cwkoss 7y agoI think 99% of arguments that claim to be in defense of children are disingenuous obfuscation of advocacy of censorship to enable fascism.
- umvi 7y ago> By this argument, literally no protection or liberty that allows even one child to be harmed could ever be tolerated It's an appeal to emotion and a commonly used tactic of politicians to get what they want (and to convince people it's what they want too). Used all the time in gun control debate.
- joe_the_user 7y agoBy this argument, literally no protection or liberty that allows even one child to be harmed could ever be tolerated. Well, I think the aim is to create (or in this case, maintain) a emotional button that when pressed, create such an extreme picture in the person's mind that they instantly respond with "your freedom? versus this?, yeah screw your freedom, we gotta stop this." The extreme the pictures shown on media, the more minachean the TV plot, etc, the stronger reaction.
- concordDance 7y agoSomething must be done, this is something, so it must be done. (Ignore the fact it won't really help)
- 7y ago
- benterris 7y agoI don't get it, hasn't E2E been already available for a long time in facebook messenger ?
- justapassenger 7y ago> mere numbers cannot capture the significance of the harm to children. So, when is ban on guns, cars and parents coming? Each of them killed countless kids.
- AlexCoventry 7y agoI guess FB could just respond by linking to this blog post: https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/05/end-to-end-encryption/ https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/05/end-to-end-encryption/
- diogenescynic 7y agoThe corrupt and criminal AG recruiting foreign governments to interfere in our elections? That one?
- carapace 7y agoThe problem is deeper than just protecting your data against the government: One of the products these guys sold to corrupt goverments was a tool to plant CP on people's computers. https://hacked.com/italian-hacking-team-hacked/ https://hacked.com/italian-hacking-team-hacked/ How do you like those apples? I can't think of a technical defense against a threat like that that doesn't involve disconnecting all the computers in my house and throwing them away.
- jMyles 7y ago> a tool to plant CP on people's computers. This tool is not described in the article you've linked. Do you have an additional link for those of us who want to read more about this?
- newguy1234 7y agoHere is another discussion on it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9836336 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9836336 It is true, there is a tool that was developed to basically plant evidence on a compromised machine. So the idea here being that the hired hackers would compromise the machine and then the government client would tell the hackers to put CP, incriminating evidence or other stuff on the machine before the police raided the house/building. The computers would be seized and then it would be used as evidence to prosecute the target. It is real. Also if you are interested, dark net diaries did an episode on this group called "hacking team". https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/38/ https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/38/
- kup0 7y agoAnother attack on privacy and liberty that cheaply hides behind "protecting children" as the reason.
- notyourday 7y agoWhile not being a fan of Zuck, I sincerely hope his reply to Barr is "Fuck off, clown"
- hashkb 7y agoRemember - we don't actually need social media. Encrypted email is enough to protect your actual private communication so you can revolt or share a little illegal material with a few friends. It's not fair to ignore the network effect here. And what do we, as a society, gain from social media? Nothing! It's addicting us, wearing down our critical thinking, and it's stopping you from going outside.
- justinclift 7y ago> ... without ensuring that there is no reduction to user safety. Australian here. Does "user safety" include journalists not being raided and/or prosecuted for publishing public interest material? For example, likely evidence of war crimes by some of our soldiers. As has begun happening here, after laws were introduced forcing our telco's to allow monitoring of anyone.
- jenkstom 7y agoWell, I guess we know now that law enforcement reads our messages whenever they want.
- sakisv 7y agoI, for one, love the sweet irony where the Attorney General is making Zuck and FB appear like the good guys. Also, should we read this request as "if you implement E2E encryption we will no longer have visibility over what FB users say"? If so, and because the connection between us and FB is over https, I assume there are deals in place where various 3-letter-agencies from these 5 countries are given (or they take themselves) the contents of our private messages? I wonder why they would be opposed to something like E2E then /s
- hinkley 7y agoIf Bill Barr asked to borrow my lighter right now I'd throw it on the ground and stomp it to oblivion while making intense eye contact. And it's a really nice lighter. I'm still waiting for the headline for disbarment proceedings against that sad sack. Fuck him, his requests, and everything he (fails to) stand for.
- zelly 7y agoJust light him on fire and keep the lighter.
- Havoc 7y agoZuck looking like the good guy in an exchange about privacy. Now that takes some doing...
- shmerl 7y agoLack of proper security (i.e. lack end to end encryption) always reduces public safety due to bad actors being able to snoop on the data. Not that anyone should trust Facebook to begin with for exactly the same reason.
- bpicolo 7y agoIf Facebook implements E2E encrypted chat, and they are able to catch 99% of those child exploitation cases today, are they going to be down to catching 0% of those cases with E2E in place?
- ghostly_s 7y agoKind of seems this news should be considered in context with the other Trump/Zuck news today that strangely hasn't been upvoted to the front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21152869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21152869
- Porthos9K 7y agoYou'd think that with all his billions, Zuckerberg would buy himself a spine and tell the AG to fuck off. We keep having this debate because law-enforcement types won't be happy until they can monitor your thoughts in real time. You expand their powers even a little, and the next day they're clamoring for more. And it's always the same excuses: preventing terrorism or protecting children. Well, I don't see the Feds cracking down hard enough on homegrown fascist groups, and I would be happy if Bob Barr's kids or grandkids were locked in a dungeon and made to sit in their own filth Omelas-style if it meant we'd have strong crypto for everyone.
- munk-a 7y agoInteresting side note, if the concern is that this end-to-end messaging is being made available through the same service that hosts social profiles - instead of asking the company to please-please-please include backdoors thank-you... maybe, just maybe, it's time to break up a vertically integrated monopoly - when your argument is that their vertical integration is literally a threat to public safety. This will, of course, never happen because breaking up businesses and consumer protection is verboten and anti-american, but I really wish someone with a big voice could stand up and make this point because it makes them look silly.
- ryeguy_24 7y agoAt the end of the day, Facebook isn’t the arbiter of whether bad actors can speak privately or not. Anyone can communicate privately using encryption tools. Do we shut down every website that offers to convert your message into cypher text? A scary world it would be if all communication was accessible by government. I liken this to stopping gun violence by pointing to mental disease. Is Facebook really the way to stop bad actors? What about the next communication device like cell phone transcripts? Is that fair game too because criminals communicate by phone?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- auslander 7y agoNo Libra? Eat this! I removed Moxie's E2E encryption from WhatsApp for you, I can put it back, you know.
- ineedasername 7y agoThe timing of this this seems suspicious. Combined with the ramp up of antitrust investigations, it almost comes across as a shakedown.
- eranima 7y agoWhat are Facebook's options?
- dehrmann 7y agoMy questions for Attorney General Barr would be after revelations about warrantless wiretapping, the FISA court, and National Security Letters, what did you think would happen, and given the US government's gripes with Huawei, isn't the only difference that this backdoor is for the Five (or Three) Eyes?
- oneplane 7y agoBut what if the rest of the world doesn't want the rules of the USA applied to them? Perhaps only do this to USA-users in the USA?
- agoodthrowaway 7y agoYet another reason not to have so much concentration in a single person. If we had smaller or more distributed social networks it would be impossible to control the spread of E2E encryption.
- amiune 7y ago"It seems to me, Golan, that the advance of civilization is nothing but an exercise in the limiting of privacy." -Isaac Asimov
- nutcracker46 7y agoEnd to end encryption is here to stay; it works! Anyone failing to use it to protect user privacy does not value user privacy. Go ahead, Zuck, and make your messaging product second-rate. See how far Facebook and WhatsApp fall behind...
- fnord77 7y agoHey Barr, if innocent people have nothing to hide, please set an example by releasing all your private communications to the public.
- lcfcjs 7y agoIsn't this a bit like saying we need to install government controlled cameras in everyones houses because people are selling drugs from within their living rooms?
- elif 7y agoMaybe what we need is an "encrypted messaging system" generator. If there is an infinite supply of encrypted channels, controlling them all becomes literally impossible.
- judge2020 7y agoI think you're describing PGP. Other than some platforms having character limits, you can run PGP over any text format as long as both clients (or humans) know what to do with the encrypted messages. A system that handled things like performing the encryption and decryption of messages over any platform would be interesting, the only pushback you would get from an authoritarian government is them telling providers to "block all pgp/encrypted comms on your platform" and/or the platform actively attempting to block your client's access to the API.
- elif 7y agoWhat I mean is not generating the encryption layer, but generating the transport layer. For instance, discovering and negotiating various publically available http or irc or jabber etc. nodes, and coordinating around their unavailability.
- stockkid 7y ago> prioritize public safety in designing its encryption by enabling law enforcement to gain access to illegal content I don't think it works that way. Serious criminals that we really want to catch are probably not coordinating their activities using unencrypted channels anyway.
- euske 7y agoIt is interesting that they chose to control Facebook instead of calling it a monopoly and splitting it into two, because it's their interest to have a choke point that they can conveniently go after. Apple is big and they provide e2e encryption, but they're not a choke point because not everyone uses Apple. On the other hand, everyone (except me) uses Facebook.
- drawkbox 7y agoIt is amazing to me that people that are supposedly "pro-business" and "pro-market" are against encryption. Mostly encryption protects privacy and business information. Corporate espionage is bigger than state espionage or terrorism my many multiples, and directly threatens national security as well as markets. Encryption is pro-business and pro-privacy for business and individuals. Without encryption or with backdoors you are trusting that bad actors don't get access to it, they will. Why have a world class security system, yet plenty of keys under rocks in the backyard? I wish encryption was framed like this: Going without encryption or including backdoors is another level of trust, like leaving your window open on vacation and putting a note that says, "Only Sally the neighbor can come in through the window, please" (Sally being the gov't). Guess what, Sally won't be the only one coming in. In that situation you may as well open the front door because that is the same as the backdoor or window, just less obscurity but more attractive to underground/opposition forces whether that is state, corporate, personal or more. Oversight and security has gotten lazy, two decades of surveillance based detective work without warrants over real detective work with warrants has made enforcement and security lazy and unable to operate without all the noise that comes with access to everyone's data. Initially it was about terrorism, but everyone knows it is about business information, personal information and other over steps like the drug wars or fights against sex workers or other wars on people that are low hanging fruit that are picked on constantly. Good detective and intel work needs to come back and less of the surveillance type.
- dclusin 7y agoPerhaps because it prevents them from forcing a moral code on others? Like SOPA/PIPA protected the children and also penalized those immoral women who trade sex for money.
- echelon 7y agoTerrorists can and will use steganography, which even the most advanced automated systems cannot detect. They want to surveil the public.
- ohazi 7y agoThey don't even need to... You can have a correct implementation of RSA in like 20 lines of code. The cat was out of the bag 20 years ago.
- JaRail 7y agoIf they're worried about kids, maybe they should have asked to not enable E2E for Messenger Kids. There's already a feature to let parents see their kids' messages. I'm pretty sure they have no plans of breaking that. Government should be providing their expertise to help FB train AIs to help alert parents to suspicious chats. There are lots of good ways to protect kids. This ain't it. Ask any woman/minority, domestic abuse victim, etc. They don't want people spying on their messages.
- realid 7y agoDidn't we already do the crypto wars? I guess we need to go through this again for those who missed it.
- no_opinions 7y agoI'm in favor of the government being capable of seeing and viewing 100% everything. 110%. The infrastructure should be there. If there's a court order or lawful authorization, info should be accessible without delay. But The way to do that would be more systems of review for when it's used, generally making the standards more strict, less ambiguous. But The problem is there are side effects to changing the law that can give away methods and also put convictions at risk. There's other ramifications we may not know about until it was put in effect, but they could be negative. I bet that's one reason there isn't as much movement in the area. There was an article in the news recently that right now in USA the case law considers unopened email to be discarded. GDPR went into effect in EU. That is another aspect that US doesn't a similar thing for (does it need one? I don't see people bringing it up often, convince me otherwise?) My point is, backdoors are more of a hypothetical thing. The legal framework around them and making them better is more productive use of your time. That would involve people coming together and nuancing what the types of privacy are and whether it involves US people, foreign countries, drug dealers, etc.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoNo one is physically raped, murdered, or even injured (beyond choosing to be offended by a certain combination of letters on a screen) in the electronic arena. All crimes they like to mention for the fear factor take place in meatspace and as such leave traces that can be followed by appropriately skilled investigators. Electronic surveillance is primarily used for reconstruction and back tracking after a significant crime has taken place. After the fact. Electronic surveillance is paying cheap lip service to a problem instead of paying the expensive price of doing it properly, in meatspace, with boots on the ground.
- dontbenebby 7y agoThe constitution does not specify that one's speech must be intelligible to the government. Governmental restrictions on strong encryption plainly violate the 1st amendment.
- eanzenberg 7y agoI’n extremely surprised that warrants haven’t been brought up yet here. A device cannot be unencrypted when a warrant is issued, so that evidence is lost, assuming the device itself is lost. Is this an ok course of action?
- unityByFreedom 7y agoI don't see the point in this request. We're going to have to figure out how to live with encrypted messaging regardless of whether Facebook implements it.
- jasonhansel 7y ago"...except for phone calls with the President of Ukraine. Those can stay secret."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bArray 7y ago> the letter raises concerns that Facebook’s plan to build > end-to-end encryption into its messaging apps will prevent > law enforcement agencies from finding illegal activity > conducted through Facebook, including child sexual > exploitation, terrorism, and election meddling. Not buying the case for the protection of children from the UK, after repeated failures to protect children despite mountains of evidence [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]. Finding pedophiles is relatively easy in the UK, they are one of the single most hated groups and often cited as the reason to bring back capital punishment. Terrorists are already using encrypted chat services such as Telegram to evade intelligence agencies. Encryption has no influence over election meddling. What this is really about is watching the general public. Facebook now blocks content even in private messages. The other day I wanted to share a free-documentary (i.e. fully legal) with a friend and so shared a page with a direct download and magnetic link, which in turn Facebook kindly blocked. Something that is pouted as "safety" is actually just about trying to line the pockets of the film/music industry. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotherham_child_sexual_exploitation_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotherham_child_sexual_exploit... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derby_child_sex_abuse_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derby_child_sex_abuse_ring [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huddersfield_grooming_gang https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huddersfield_grooming_gang [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Savile_sexual_abuse_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Savile_sexual_abuse_scan... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester_child_sex_abuse_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester_child_sex_abuse_rin... [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcastle_sex_abuse_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcastle_sex_abuse_ring [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Wales_child_abuse_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Wales_child_abuse_scanda... [8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oulu_child_sexual_exploitation_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oulu_child_sexual_exploitation... [9] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_child_sex_abuse_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_child_sex_abuse_ring [10] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rochdale_child_sex_abuse_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rochdale_child_sex_abuse_ring
- Snickelfritz72 7y agoI claim Citizen Privilege per the Constitution and the "... Supreme Court has found that the Constitution implicitly grants a right to privacy against governmental intrusion from the First Amendment, Third Amendment, Fourth Amendment, and the Fifth Amendment." Law enforcement rooted out criminals and organized crime before end-to-end encryption and you can do so now. YOU, a hypocrite who testified he was against law enforcement spying on Americans while investigating if a possible crime was occurring ... even if they have probable cause. Public Safety my Ass! https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Right_to_privacy https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Right_to_privacy
- tgb29 7y agoZuckerBerg was talking real tough when the opponent was Elizabeth Warren. Let’s see if he’ll go to the mat with this one.
- sedachv 7y agoThis is most likely motivated by the US government (current and past administration) efforts to suppress whistle-blowers: https://theintercept.com/2019/08/04/whistleblowers-surveillance-fbi-trump/ https://theintercept.com/2019/08/04/whistleblowers-surveilla...
- Snickelfritz72 7y agoA.G Barr, I claim Citizen Privilege as I am a PRIVATE citizen who is innocent and as you have testified to Congress, you believe SPYing on a person while being investigated for alleged crimes is not acceptable AND could be seen as an abuse of power PLUS I wouldn't want to be charged with Treason if I say, eh well I am sure you know what I am talking about. You have shown during your short time pretending to work for the People of the United States (again) and yet People were replaced with the president. you're a Hypocritical POS. You are supposed to be protecting my country. You should be respecting the 3 branches of government. If I cannot see documents of what my government has been doing because you other Trump bitches refuse to provide them, (no matter what it or who requests them), then I think you should not have any measures, whatsoever, with respect to Oversight in what I do, what I say, my friends are, who my relatives are, my subscriptions I have in Messenger or any other part of my life. Go babysit his children with private email accounts. Even non-Russia related requests are NOT provided to Congress. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/12/us/politics/house-afghanistan-zalmay-khalilzad.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/12/us/politics/house-afghani... "The committee had asked three times this year for Mr. Khalilzad to brief lawmakers on the administration’s plan to end to the 18-year war in Afghanistan, and each time the State Department declined." "....Eliot Engel, the committee’s chairman, in a statement. “It shouldn’t have taken a subpoena to get the State Department to work with this committee and allow us to perform our oversight duties.” House Foreign Affairs Panel Subpoenas Top Afghanistan Negotiator AND " ...Eliot Engel, the committee’s chairman, in a statement. “It shouldn’t have taken a subpoena to get the State Department to work with this committee and allow us to perform our oversight duties.” https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-afghanistan-khalilzad/us-house-committee-reaches-deal-for-testimony-by-trump-afghan-envoy-idUSKBN1W332O https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-afghanistan-khalilzad... https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United_S...
- NoblePublius 7y agoDo any police out there miss actually solving crimes as opposed to just sucking up all the cell phone data and Ring camera feeds?
- logfromblammo 7y agoDon't forget searching public DNA databases.
- zer0gravity 7y agoThe only thing I can say about this is that, once we'll have BMIs, the Government will want to tap into that as well, because you may have dangerous thoughts. If you see the insanity of this, you should see the insanity of the Government tapping into private messages.
- nichch 7y agoMakes me wonder what level of access the Five Eyes currently has if they're this afraid of losing it.
- ddmma 7y agoIf 99% then why not Facebooks systems include AI to catch bad guys before they act and imprison’em in a benevolent virtual reality using oculus. Classic Spielberg called ’Minority Report’ with underwater ‘precogs’
- JDEW 7y agoI find it strange that there isn't already some precedent from the supreme court on the right to encrypt under the second amendment. This isn't a new idea [1] and the debate about whether or not encryption is a fundamental right is already going on for ages... If Americans cared so much about their freedom to protect themselves from their government, rationally it would make far more sense to be up on the fence about encryption than about firearms. [1] https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/3696/is-the-right-to-keep-and-bear-crypto-protected-by-the-second-amendment https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/3696/is-the-right-to... [Edit] I don't want to start a flame war about guns, I'm genuinely curious about what the law would say about encryption under the second amendment.
- Calashle0202 7y agoBut what’s app already leaked the private keys and is owned by FB. Zuck doesn’t care either.
- radres 7y agoDo you really think the user cannot implement end-to-end encryption themselves?
- plmu 7y agoWhat happens if someone distributes an OSS toolkit that enables everyone to easily setup an encrypted ad-hoc peer to peer network? If you want to prevent criminals from communicating safely in the long run, you would have to prohibit open internet access and/or mathematics. Prohibiting platforms will lead to some delay at best. The collateral damage, taking away privacy from the population at large, is proably the real goal.
- tadasZ 7y agoI don't want to give up my privacy just because some bad actors are using (or will use) OTHER end to end encrypted messaging apps. Bans won't solve the problem of child abuse and etc., when i'll want to live in a dictatorship i'll move to china or some similar place.
- stefek99 7y ago> Our understanding is that much of this activity, which is critical to protecting children and fighting terrorism, will no longer be possible if Facebook implements its proposals as planned. Here is some legislation from 2000: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_of_Investigatory_Powers_Act_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_of_Investigatory_Po... > Critics claim that the spectres of terrorism, internet crime and paedophilia were used to push the act through and that there was little substantive debate in the House of Commons. 20 years in life of internet is a lot. Same arguments. Remarkable.
- ekianjo 7y agoThis predates the age of the Internet by millenia. Almost every politician in History appeals to children to drive their policies or block their opponents'.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoHow? Childhood is a rather modern concept and child labour exploitation peaked just a few centuries ago during the Industrial Revolution. What historical events and periods are you referring to in the past millenia?
- leetcrew 7y agocorrupting the youth was one of the charges against Socrates made by essentially political opponents.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoWhich, incidentally, he was undoubtedly guilty of. By putting all sorts of notions into their heads.
- leetcrew 7y agofrom the perspective of a contemporary Athenian, yes, he did say things that were incompatible with the state religion. I don't think a modern reader necessarily has to agree that that's "corrupting the youth". the Athenians also probably didn't care very much about this anyway. the charge was literally true, but it was also bullshit because none of the accusers actually cared about any of the offenses they were charging him with. what they actually cared about was that he had humiliated them in public on many occasions and his association with (though not outright involvement in) the reign of the thirty tyrants. so actually fairly analogous!
- ashelmire 7y agoThis is equivalent of asking for a ban of wax stamp seals in the age before the internet.
- gorgoiler 7y agoHow many crimes are solved through wiretapping or evidence gathered from Facebook servers? Facebook’s 99% figure needs more context — maybe that’s 99% of just 1% of all child abuse / sexual assault / terrorism crimes? Some more statistics would be useful to quantify the impact on criminal justice of losing either of those options. Otherwise the arguments just feel political or emotional. End-to-End won’t impact the major source of evidence in, say, sexual assaults where the victim unlocks their phone and submits a copy of their decrypted message threads to the police, though this is a controversial policing method, recently reported on in the UK: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/sep/21/people-report-rape-routine-demands-mobile-data https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/sep/21/people-repor...
- gorgoiler 7y ago2,500 prosecutions as a result of “the work we did with Facebook in the last year”, according to UK government (Brandon Lewis, a minister on Radio 4, October 4th.)
- velox_io 7y agoBanning encryption in one place will not change anything, it just means that those who want their actions hidden will go elsewhere or use tools such as VPNs, which seem fairly common these days, even amongst general users.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rpmisms 7y agoAnd this is why I enjoy politics from afar. If you're invested, all that's going to happen is that your otherwise good person you support will start pushing shit like this. Party doesn't matter: state power will always be the goal.
- srmatto 7y agoWe probably need a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the right to use encryption, otherwise this cat and mouse game will never end.
- neop1x 7y agoI thought there a backdoor already? Messenger and Whatsapp, all proprietary, can't be trusted anyway. :)
- PovilasID 7y ago"Think of the children" often covers a lazy powergrab. Now is full transparency bad or the role of privacy itself that is not a online comment battle conversation but this is just lazy.
- hansdieter1337 7y agomy (conspiracy) theory after watching some house of cards: No end2end encryption before the US election 2020 🇺🇸