9 ms·
> They focused on his tone deaf communication style and awkward demeanor. They spoke of behavior from decades ago and pointed out the fact that he had a mattres
by Barrin92 7y ago
> They focused on his tone deaf communication style and awkward demeanor. They spoke of behavior from decades ago and pointed out the fact that he had a mattress in his office.
It wasn't just awkward demeanor. He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again.
> He held his positions at MIT, GNU, and the FSF for over thirty years, and in that time nobody accused him of coercion, unwanted touching, or verbal harassment
Yes, because of people like you, Geoff. When people like Stallman behave like they do and say the things they say they don't have to face the consequences because people don't want to speak up, because they're afraid of being called liars or censors. That's how authority figures and popular individuals keep getting away with it.
The second paragraph of the post is irrelevant and further proves the point. Stallman's contributions to free software don't excuse his conduct.
- Aeolun 7y agoThen maybe we should have removed him for one of the previous instances of awkwardness, because the message I see here in no way justifies any of the things that subsequently happened. I would not call it anything less than a disgrace for anyone involved.
- coldtea 7y agoI hope people thinking like above, or sad finger-pointers like the ones writing the articles, are removed from the tech industry...
- lagadu 7y agoYes, I too would like everyone who I disagree with to be removed from my industry. That was sarcasm, because apparently in 2019 that's an acceptable thing to say with a straight face.
- coldtea 7y ago>Yes, I too would like everyone who I disagree with to be removed from my industry So, like those people you seem to applaud did to Stallman? >apparently in 2019 that's an acceptable thing to say with a straight face Oh, the irony...
- Chris2048 7y ago"lynch-mobbers" are not "everyone who I disagree with". Invoking <current year> isn't usually said with a straight face anymore.
- sergiosgc 7y ago> It wasn't just awkward demeanor. He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again. Every episode I read about fell into the category of "socially awkward adult male". If we can't, as a group, tolerate awkwardness, we are very much down the rabbit hole of mandatory social conformity. By all means, point me to a real abuse scenario by Stallman. I like being proven wrong.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIgnoring a legal age of consent, refusing to accept the accepted definitions of assault and rape, and claiming they were actually willing are emphatically not just "socially awkward".
- metiscus 7y agoCan you cite some specific evidence for your specific claims?
- spats1990 7y agoOn his website, for example, Stallman says that he "reject[s] the term sexual assault" completely.[1] ~edit: I have included the full quote below as I did not intend to twist/misrepresent in any way. Stallman writes: " The term is applied to a broad range of actions, ranging from stealing a kiss to rape, as well as other things in between. It acts as propaganda for treating them the same. There seems to be an exception for TSA agents, however. The term is further stretched to include sexual harassment, which is not a specific act, but rather a pattern of acts that amounts to a form of gender bias. Gender bias is rightly prohibited in certain situations for the sake of equal opportunity. I don't think that rape should be treated like stealing a kiss, so I reject the term "sexual assault" completely." [1]https://stallman.org/antiglossary.html#assult https://stallman.org/antiglossary.html#assult
- dpq 7y ago...and does a great job explaining his pov. It's not like he's saying that sexual assaults do not exist, and people should be able to rape / immodestly touch whoever they please with impunity. > Sexual assault: The term is applied to a broad range of actions, ranging from stealing a kiss to rape, as well as other things in between. It acts as propaganda for treating them the same.
- throw_xyzyz 7y ago>It wasn't just awkward demeanor. He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again. I've met Stallman. He made everyone feel uncomfortable because of the smell. He is mentally ill and incredibly talented. Should we drug him until he becomes acceptable to middle class women and in the process reduce him to the average drone programmer?
- missosoup 7y ago"actively made women feel unwelcome" therefore he should be internet lynch mobbed with the same fervor that's reserved for high profile criminals? Do I get my own internet lynch mob next time someone makes me feel unwelcome or acts unprofessionally?
- mieseratte 7y ago"Someone could have been theoretically, emotionally harmed, therefore I must cause real-world harm!"
- equalunique 7y ago>It wasn't just awkward demeanor. He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again. Can you please cite your sources for this claim?
- barry-cotter 7y agoHe’s autistic. He probably gives almost everyone he comes into contact with the creeps. Neurotypical people don’t like autistic people, and would prefer to avoid them to the greatest extent possible. I doubt Stallman was any more unpleasant to women than to men, or showed any greater or lesser social graces. He has never, ever held back about any of his opinions or actions. I’m sure you could get him to admit to things that would get almost anyone fired by most jobs in under ten minutes and he wouldn’t deny any of it afterwards. People like Stallman don’t do professional because he’s not a faker. He’s not trying to make money or buy prestige. He just wants free software.
- rimliu 7y agoI'd just awoid stinky people no mater their neural status.
- shademaan 7y ago>Neurotypical people don’t like autistic people, Oh this is hilarious. Do you realize how many people -- not just men -- in CS, physics, mathematics are autistic, especially in places like MIT? Places like that are teeming with autistic people who somehow manage not to make their students and colleagues uncomfortable. I'll even be so bold as to claim neurotypicals are actually a minority in some of those subjects. This is really strange atempt to spin his firing as some sort of evidence that autistic men are being oppressed in CS academia and tech. As anyone who's been in either of those environmets, that's clearly NOT the case.
- barry-cotter 7y agoI’m not saying he’s oppressed. He’s a super giant nerd and people don’t like nerds. Other nerds don’t like nerds. No one owes anyone else shit. Normal people don’t like fat or ugly people either, and avoid them too. The idea that autistic people do not make allistic people uncomfortable is completely at odds with my experience. The more obviously autistic someone is the less allistic people want to be near them. People who are crushing monomaniacal bores with poor social skills are tolerated if they have some valuable skills, keep to themselves, or parrot the party line. Autistic people can make allistic people uncomfortable by sitting quietly in the corner of a room. They look funny, they stim, they do that flappy thing with their hands, or rock. Stallman wasn’t oppressed. He was booted for being a huge outspoken driven asshole with no political nous, but he’s been a huge outspoken equal opportunity asshole for decades.
- rndgermandude 7y ago>He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again. Please elaborate?
- forgot_user1234 7y ago"He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again." You are making me feel unwelcome on this forum and your comment is unprofessional. > Yes, because of people like you, Geoff. When people like Stallm .... It's because of people like you that allegations ruin people's life. When there's nothing to prove, you are talking about what could have
- fugly_nerd 7y agoSeriously I feel so attacked right now. Barrin92 is saying it is a crime to be awkward and people are upvoting it to the top. I thought people stopped picking on nerds after high school. Makes me want to kill myself to not deal with the anxiety of trying to make people like me.
- Valmar 7y agoYou made a stupid comment. Own it. Don't play the victim. People aren't attacking you personally. Rather, people are criticizing your argument.
- lazyjones 7y agoIt's just a small, noisy, superficial and generally annoying minority with short attention span that goes on such lynch crusades.
- Chris2048 7y ago> because they're afraid of being called liars or censors lies where told. There are plenty people afraid of pointing this out, lest they be called an "apologist" for something. Is that because of "people like you, Barrin92"?
- verroq 7y ago> He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again. How do you know this? How do you know that he deliberately tries to make women uncomfortable? I don't think any women is comfortable near a fat, bearded virgin that eats things off his foot, but to accuse him of deliberately making women uncomfortable implies that he knows some of his actions are off limits and he's deliberately crossing the line. You're just attributing malice when there's a simple answer - he's socially awkward, he doesn't know what the limits are.
- minitech 7y ago> How do you know that he deliberately tries to make women uncomfortable? He doesn’t do it deliberately (probably). The accusations are only that he does it. > I don't think any women is comfortable near a fat, bearded virgin that eats things off his foot None of the things you just listed were part of the reasons they gave. > but to accuse him of deliberately making women uncomfortable Again – deliberate not necessary for this to be a bad thing. In case you haven’t seen it and/or for your browsing convenience, here’s a link to the main set of actual issues in question: https://medium.com/@selamjie/remove-richard-stallman-appendix-a-a7e41e784f88 https://medium.com/@selamjie/remove-richard-stallman-appendi... (the fact that I’m linking this doesn’t mean I agree with every word of it or take its truth as a given, by the way – just pointing out that you’re arguing against a non-position)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danillonunes 7y agoIgnorance is a bad excuse for undesired behavior. That's why when it comes to legal terms, you can't claim you didn't knew something was illegal and get away with it. There are good reasons to defend (some of) Stallman's behavior, saying he don't know better is not one of them. If anything, it only makes me feel better about his current situation: Oh, the whole problem is that he didn't knew what he was doing? Well, he's learning a hell of a lesson now.
- nabla9 7y agoI'm voting you down because you don't give specifics. If you have something to share, put the effort to be specific. Now you are just throwing general accusations.
- EmeraldMoon 7y ago> Yes, because of people like you, Geoff. I don't see why you have to attack the author here, but let me ask you this -- if I "feel" unwelcomed by your conduct, for whatever reason, on a "private" mailing list, then should you be forced to resign?
- meerita 7y agoHe made feel unwelcome both women and men. Not just women. It was part of his personality.
- znpy 7y ago> Yes, because of people like you, Geoff. When people like Stallman behave like they do and say the things they say they don't have to face the consequences because people don't want to speak up, because they're afraid of being called liars or censors. That's how authority figures and popular individuals keep getting away with it. On the other hand, so far, no one has come forward to denounce anything (harassment or similar) about Stallman. It seems to me that Stallman's lack of social adherence is the reason why he's being attacked. Not actual facts.
- virgilp 7y ago> He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again. All this is irrelevant to the quite real and undeniable truth that it's not because he "made women feel unwelcome in the workplace" that he was sacked. This is pure after-the-fact rationalization. He was sacked for having the wrong opinion and not knowing when to shut up.
- AsyncAwait 7y agoThe original Medium post was resting on equating Stallman saying that one of Epstein's victims may've been presented to Minsky as "entirely willing", as him saying that the girl in fact was "entirely willing". Such intentional smear campaign makes me seriously question the author of the piece, because if they had an obvious case of wrongdoing, no such intentional misquoting would indeed be necessary.
- domnomnom 7y agoHonestly I'm starting to feel that at this point we should just have businesses that are like sororities and fraternities because people can't seem to handle themselves or handle how others fail to handle themselves.
- bsder 7y ago> He actively made women feel unwelcome in the workplace and behaved unprofessionally over and over again. I'm 6 foot+ and 200 pounds+. I make certain women uncomfortable simply by existing. They will view every action I take through a lens of being frightened and intimidated. Do I deserve to get fired? Obviously not. I have also had different women ask me to join a meeting because the audience wasn't listening to them because they were so physically small. They needed someone with authority to say "shut up and listen". Those women have no issues with me whatsoever and enlist my assistance Clearly the problem isn't with me, should the women frightened of me get fired instead? Obviously not. Now what?