32 ms·
Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
- baroffoos 7y agoWhat does he actually do at the gnu project? It was my understanding that RMS doesn't program anymore.
- webkike 7y agoHe makes decisions about software. It’s the same position as Linus or Rossum.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- canarypilot 7y agoName some impactful decisions he has made recently. Your comment does an immense disservice to Linus and Rossum.
- rdc12 7y agoA while back he was blocking things like, a package manager for emacs (that does exist now) and making GCC able to export an AST for external tools to manipulate (in particular for emacs to do semantic editing of code). In both cases since it would make it easier for closed source software to make use of GPL software.
- pygy_ 7y agoAdding Rust as a first class citizen to GCC.
- earenndil 7y agoLinus and Guido actively write code and merge patches for their respective patches.
- _ph_ 7y agoHe still might make decisions, but I doubt he has many technical contributions of his. And quite a few of his decisions can be discussed very controversial.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- earenndil 7y agoHe would do well to acknowledge the controversy surrounding his recent exits--the people saying his resignations were a leap forward for tech. To ignore them lends them credence.
- t0astbread 7y agoHe did post an apology on his personal website but it wasn't particularly strong I guess
- papermachete 7y agoIt wasn't an apology, but regret.
- sprash 7y agoWhy should anyone apologize for being a victim of a coordinated character assasination campaign?
- KaiserPro 7y agowhy should anyone apologise for anything?
- domnomnom 7y agoTime to donate to gnu!
- soulofmischief 7y agoIt leaves a bad taste in my mouth how quickly people will let one bad cluster of comments negate a man's entire life work. I have already outlined my opinions on this matter elsewhere but I still hope this incident doesn't ruin RMS.
- stOneskull 7y agoYep. Damn thought police.
- wiz21c 7y agoYep, spot on. And as I said earlier, RMS's crime is that he doesn't condemn unequivocally and totally, (i.e. without judgment), what is perceived as unacceptable by the society. RMS loves freedom more than many of us, that's why "consent" is so important to him (I guess).
- legulere 7y agoFreedom ends where it restricts other people’s freedom and freedom doesn’t mean that there are no consequences. If you question that child rape should be punished, you have to live with the consequences.
- mantoto 7y agoBut it wasn't the only comment right?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- godzillabrennus 7y agohttp://techrights.org/2019/09/15/media-attention-has-been-shifted/ http://techrights.org/2019/09/15/media-attention-has-been-sh...
- 7y ago
- scarejunba 7y agoI don't get it. Did he just proclaim this to the world without provocation just after lunch? Also, Chief Gnuisance gives me all these feelings of nostalgia for my teenage years spent learning to compile the Unichrome Linux driver to play Unreal Tournament on a Via VT8378. All that silly nonsense about GNU's Not Unix. I'm glad the right culture for software was set up back then. It could have gone so many other ways.
- drevil-v2 7y agoGood for him. In this day and age I support any fightback against deplatforming. I hate that it has come down to this, where you have to take a stand just on principles. I don't know if Stallman is really a "creepy old man" who hits on his female co-workers but any chance of a fair enquiry in an appropriate manner is near zero. The mass hysteria and instant justice demands of the twitter outrage mob has killed nuance or shades of grey from public discourse. I really really hate that anything in the center is taboo. I lay the blame squarely on the far-left for this state of affairs. They started this war and this trend. God knows where it will end.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- smolder 7y agoThe thing you're describing where people latch on to outrage in the social media age isn't an effect exclusive to the left. I think that human tribalism and group think in a huge instant forum like the modern internet inevitably lead to some bad conclusions and disproportionate outcomes. I think we have to find a way to give deeply considered and measured commentary the share of our collective attention it deserves. Upvotes and downvotes and likes and shares don't serve that purpose well enough.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoI agree with you for the most part, but I disagree about the characterization of the phenomenon as "far-left." It's driven by middle-class conformists, in my humble opinion.
- specialist 7y agoNow that's an interesting idea. I'm very political and some of my peeps (on the left) exhaust me. I disregard anyone telling someone else how they should be living; remove the log from your own eye first and so forth. Left, right, up, down -- they're all the same. I call them scolds. I'll now have to consider your thesis (about scolds being a flavor of conformists).
- webkike 7y agoFrankly, it’s his code. Whatever. It just makes me want to fork his code and make it better
- hobofan 7y agoJust make sure to properly freely distribute any changes you made ;)
- eukgoekoko 7y agoToo bad you will never actually do this.
- floatboth 7y agoHe hasn't been very involved with code for the last N years, and how many GNU projects do you use anyway? GCC and coreutils? meh. Thankfully, LLVM has killed GCC's dominance.
- webkike 7y agoI use Emacs daily, and he is in full control of that project.
- bscphil 7y agoI think everyone should be able to agree that the situation, as it stands, is pretty unfortunate. Stallman has pretty clearly lost (or never had) the trust of many members of the community, and it seems unlikely that he will be an effective leader and public face for GNU, as a result. I don't think anyone reasonable is trying to prevent him from airing his personal opinions (contra what many people are claiming in this thread), and there are indeed many people who are open to listening to those opinions -- but whether you think he ought to leave GNU or not, it's unfortunate that he triggers such strong negative reactions from many people. Some pretty responsible and knowledgeable people such as the EFF's head of cybersecurity have described him as a "creep". [1] While I believe that what he said[2] is so far beyond the pale of responsible discourse that removing him from his positions, as two organizations have done, was the right decision[3], I also believe that that's not really relevant for this particular thread. He founded GNU. He runs GNU. He probably can't be forced by anyone to leave GNU. None of that changes the fact that he will probably not be a very effective leader of GNU, even if he was before. [1] https://twitter.com/evacide/status/1172287971220848640 https://twitter.com/evacide/status/1172287971220848640 [2] He said that an underage sex trafficking victim's "plausible" apparent consent means that the people who raped her did not commit sexual assault. [3] Even putting aside the forum in which he made these comments, and the things he has said and done at other times.
- nieksand 7y agoCan you provide an actual link for [2]? It's a very serious allegation.
- bscphil 7y agoYes. This article[1], so far as I can tell, contains the full nuance of the story. He claimed (or very strongly insinuated) that if a minor sex trafficking victim presented herself as "entirely willing", then a man who had sex with her is not guilty of sexual assault. I believe that's what I said in my comment. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2019/09/17/computer-scientist-richard-stallman-resigns-mit-after-comments-about-epstein-scandal/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2019/09/17/computer...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mongol 7y agoI thought contributions to GNU requires copyright reassignment to FSF.. in that case, is not a weak position to lead the GNU project from, if he has no role within FSF?
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoFSF only needs copyright so they can relicense at will. That is of little impact to GNU.
- onlydeadheroes 7y agoI guess we can soon expect them to relicense it all to free the world from the viral nature of the GPL.
- josefx 7y agoThe GPL is published by the FSF, so they could just publish a GPLv4 that declares all the code property of Alphabet Inc. and the "or later" clause would take care of the rest.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 7y agoThey actually did something like that with GFDL, they added a special exemption, just for Wikipedia[1]. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Free_Documentation_License#Compatibility_with_Creative_Commons_licensing_terms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Free_Documentation_License...
- anoncake 7y agoThat's a very different case. The point of licensing a work under the GFDL version n or higher is that the FSF can relicense it under a different copyleft license – like CC-BY-SA. Of course CC-BY-SA and GFDL aren't identical but neither are different versions of the GFDL.
- 7y ago
- samstave 7y agoThis is what I think killed Aaron - that he broke in to gain CP evidence... He got it and they suicided him.
- Viker 7y agoProbbably this is what killed Seth Rich too.
- jlgaddis 7y agoAlso, Jimmy Hoffa was his partner in these deeds. "They" don't want you to find out about that either. sigh
- samstave 7y agoEpstein funds mit media lab RMS defends Epstein, posts many nasty things about pedophilia Other rumors about pedophilia and cp at mit Rms resigns Aaron was going after specific things, but they claim all he took was JSTOR fIles He commits suicide the same way epstein, and many others have. Sure, maybe it’s all innocent - but there are a lot of very similar patterns here. So take your smarmy comment and get out.
- DanBC 7y ago> but there are a lot of very similar patterns here. Suicide is a leading cause of death, especially in men.
- Santosh83 7y agoStallman has been a 'creep' for decades is all I keep hearing from people in these threads. So why is it that all his victims from decades of his 'creepy' behaviour do not come forward and LEGALLY take action against him? Is the USA not one of the most empowered countries for women? If not in the USA then where? Repeated accusations on the Internet don't count. This is just digital version of character assassination. A lot of people seem to have hated and resented him for various reasons (something that all long-standing leaders accumulate), and they seem to have seized on a suitable 'faux-pas' to whip up as much frenzy as they can and do maximum possible social damage to him. And not one will pursue credible, legal redressal. To an outsider with no skin anywhere in this, it is just shameful how this has played out.
- zby 7y agoI think the root of the this was misinterpretations of 'creep' - publicly eating something from your foot might be called creepy - but there is no law against it and it is not against women in any way.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- x220 7y agoCreep is a useless term. You can say that anything is creepy.
- imtringued 7y agoBut it's always better if something isn't creepy, right? So if we remove all the creepy things everything will be better!
- dependenttypes 7y agoCreepiness is in the eye of the beholder, considering that one of the ways to get rid of it is to remove the people who think that a certain action is creepy for example. Reality is more complex than that though - just like it would be a net-negative to remove a victim of constant harassment in order to reduce creepiness it would also be a net-negative if we removed someone who asked someone else once on a date because someone found it creepy.
- moonbug 7y agoI guess the abortion "joke" will be staying then.
- samstave 7y agoHere is the quote in question: The nominee is quoted as saying that if the choice of a sexual partner were protected by the Constitution, "prostitution, adultery, necrophilia, bestiality, possession of child pornography, and even incest and pedophilia" also would be. He is probably mistaken, legally--but that is unfortunate. All of these acts should be legal as long as no one is coerced. They are illegal only because of prejudice and narrowmindedness. Some rules might be called for when these acts directly affect other people's interests. For incest, contraception could be mandatory to avoid risk of inbreeding. For prostitution, a license should be required to ensure prostitutes get regular medical check-ups, and they should have training and support in insisting on use of condoms. This will be an advance in public health, compared with the situation today. For necrophilia, it might be necessary to ask the next of kin for permission if the decedent's will did not authorize it. Necrophilia would be my second choice for what should be done with my corpse, the first being scientific or medical use. Once my dead body is no longer of any use to me, it may as well be of some use to someone. Besides, I often enjoy rhinophytonecrophilia (nasal sex with dead plants).
- buboard 7y agoObviously
- gexla 7y agoRMS was sitting in a hot seat when public scrutiny flooded in. With bullets whizzing past his head, he chose to post this language into the public sphere. Bad decision. You're fired. This is like being in a room with people who may be known to possess drugs and then running your mouth when the cops bust in. "Maybe cocaine isn't so bad!" Just shut up. Plead the 5th. "Talk to my lawyer, representative or whatever." Take your right to remain silent because any stupid sh you say can and will be used against you. Stay in your lane, especially as a representative of others. If you're going to run your mouth, then at least wait until you get home and do it on your own equipment using personal channels. And even then you still might be representing others. Opinions aren't cheap. They have a real cost. You should be well aware of what those costs might be and the risks you are facing. Then go ahead and give your opinion if you're willing to pay those costs. This is a skill everyone needs to have, but many don't. Even if he did the calcs and decided the cost was worth it, he still did so as a rep of an org which didn't share his values. Gnu must be a different situation and a different culture. I assume he would have already been forced out if it were possible. Maybe they have an air-gapped room in the basement with a desk and a red stapler.
- virgilp 7y ago> Opinions aren't cheap. They have a real cost. I.e. "before trying to form your own opinions, make sure you can afford to". Nice world we live in. I don't disagree with you wrt the current state of affairs, I just find it rather sad.
- gexla 7y ago> I.e. "before trying to form your own opinions, make sure you can afford to". Nice world we live in. Feature, not a bug. Having a real cost means it could also have real value. When someone has taken a great risk to do something, then it carries more weight to take it seriously. Don't be using fighting words unless you're ready to fight. ;) And we already know how to do this with our daily actions. It just seems we're too quick to give the mouth a free pass to get loose. RMS believed in free software and much the reason why he has fans is because he backs his words up with his actions. He has worked his tail off over the years and he gives up the convenience that non-free software provides. When he talks about free software, he backs that up with a massive lifetime workload dedicated to the subject. Why risk that to talk about something which he has no clue about, especially when the heat is bashing the door in. He's representing other people and he's in a public position. The leader in the room is that guy who tells everyone to shut up, flush your contraband down the toilet, don't talk to anyone and look like you did nothing wrong. He failed in that, and he's not the sort of guy I would want in my car if we got pulled over. If he wants to try something different, may I suggest Legos? Puzzles? If you take up explosives as a hobby, then don't be surprised if you get your leg blown off. Unless Dave Chappele is your press secretary, stay away from any subjects which might be tagged as "sexual assuault" "underage girls" "age of consent". I got anxiety just typing all that. He's nuts.
- thinkingemote 7y agoIf I can be forgiven for an interesting meta observation, I think the time of day and the tone of some comments makes a big difference depending on the topic. For example Snowdon topics posted during the European morning and then later on American users share their thoughts and comments. And then later on as Silicon Valley comes online. same with RMS and other cultural issues, when just looking at the comments it's clear that there's differences in opinion due to different cultures. I have not really observed these differences in pure tech stories though.
- Throw_Away_9472 7y agoWhat are these cultural differences in the Stallman issue? European users are more supportive of him I guess, right?
- ourlordcaffeine 7y agoThe one thing I hope for in this whole situation is that the F/OSS movement keeps going, and the quality of code and diversity of free software stays high, because I'm pretty sure there are individuals and companies who want F/OSS to end, and may see this as an opportunity to try to stoke further controversy and infighting to splinter and destroy the movement.
- bitL 7y agoIsn't RMS homeless now? I was told he lived in his MIT office; now that he is no longer there...?
- pseudalopex 7y agoHe moved out around 1998.[1] [1] https://stallman.org/rms-lifestyle.html https://stallman.org/rms-lifestyle.html
- bitL 7y agoHe might be homeless now actually: https://stallman.org/seeking-housing.html https://stallman.org/seeking-housing.html
- wruza 7y agoI found this comment in a similar local discussion, and it seemed to gain some traction instantly. Idk personally if its right or wrong, tbh, but maybe it is worth discussing in the light of recent events. “”” It is hard to choose to which comment to reply, so I’ll leave a general message to anyone who thinks that RMS resignation is good for a reason that was used for it and that one-sided mob rule is above all. His comments were formally correct. You cannot beat logic. You can scream and jump through as many hysterical hoops as you want, stigmatize the dead, but you will not get any respect from a majority of thinking population. You will never win this war by shutting throats. It is a war on logic. You will be disliked on a basis of being a noisy moron. All you do now is to train more and more people’s habit to cover real intents and reimplement them in politically correct ways against you, as there is no more place to speak without your picky attention. This virtual noose you invented will finally tighten around your own neck.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoThe founding fathers saw this in their time in their countries. They knew the Bill of Rights was of the utmost importance and wrote those things which were necessary for freedom. I dont think that Bill of Rights should change or we will go back to tyrannical governments.
- rrss 7y agoThe objectionable bits of his most recent comments were primarily opinion, so I don't know what "formally correct" means. "Even if it would have been legally rape, it shouldn't be called 'assault' because it would just have been statutory rape, and really we should consider whether statutory rape is morally wrong." I don't believe there is any formal logic to prove whether it is or isn't appropriate to call something assault. Goodbye.
- wruza 7y agoMy guess is that "formally correct" here means statements are logically connected into conclusions or potential suggestions. That's how I understood it at least. >I don't believe there is any formal logic to prove whether it is or isn't appropriate to call something assault. Iow, you believe that there is no proofs for harm of statutory rape. Why? (I don't understand your goodbye either.)
- mikeash 7y agoHere’s what I don’t get: why are you all so concerned about what happens to this guy? He didn’t get lynched. He’s not going to prison. He had a comfortable life and he will continue to have a comfortable life. Why does this asshole deserve so much of your time and energy?
- rowanG077 7y agoBecause of something called justice? It was really ridiculous how he was treated while he didn't do anything wrong. Uninformed masses will still see this guy as a bad person for years to come for no other reason that the media is lying to them.
- PaulRobinson 7y agoHe has done lots wrong over many years to many people. The incident that caused the furor was the last straw because it was tone-deaf to the context. Nobody wishes him ill, but he has no place as a leader in the free software movement if it is to flourish. Of course, he can participate, and as president of GNU that might be an OK level of participation. Do not expect us to believe he has been treated unfairly, however: he has been treated the same way any other employee at MIT would be treated, and as the FSF has seen fit given its organisational goals.
- diffeomorphism 7y ago> He has done lots wrong over many years to many people. [citation needed] and distraction. So what if he didn't do anything of what he is currently accused of, I am sure he has done lots of wrong before (of which I am going to list exactly nothing)? > he has been treated the same way any other employee at MIT would be treated. He has resigned to shield MIT from public pressure after lots of lies have appeared about things he hasn't said.
- rowanG077 7y agoWhat has he done wrong over the years? I keep seeing people say this in this thread without any reference or anything concrete.
- sanj 7y agoHow many honorary doctorates add up to calling yourself “Dr.”?
- cujo 7y agoOh good. Now the community here will bend over backwards defending him again. It's tiresome and misguided. 1. He said controversial stuff. 2. He's a representative of organizations that don't want him to say controversial stuff. 3. He got kicked around for it. Quit defending his behavior. It's not a good look. It doesn't matter if you think he's "technically correct" (which is highly debatable, anyway). You're enabling bad behavior if you think this should go on without any kind of blowback. This is the tech version of "locker room talk". It's all good so long as you're on the same team, right?
- dexen 7y ago>the community here will bend over backwards defending him >organizations that don't want him to say controversial stuff Quite a paradoxical situation: the organizations in question are no longer fitting - neither the community, nor the leaders. Stallman co-created and led a community. There were various organizations established to help the community and to benefit from it. Somehow the organizations became detached from both the community and one of the most prominent leaders, to the point of taking a stand against both. Here's to hoping one day the free software community's voice can reach Free Software Foundation better than the Twitter outrage mob.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- InTheArena 7y agoI know people are decrying the sudden exposure of years of actual issues (including warnings/remedial/probation), as well as skepticism about rumors that are floating around. None of this is new knowledge. I heard rumors about RMS floating back at Berkeley around 1999-2003. So let's look at the worst case possible circumstance - that a man who repeatedly makes comments that are interpreted as pro-pedophilia and has a history of inappropriate conduct with young (albiet legal) women might actually act in ways that he has publicly justified. In that circumstance, no one can say that the warning signals were not there. That would be on all of us, and leaving him in a position of power would continue the possibility of abuse. For the FSF and GNU to have a future (as opposed to "open source"), they need to evolve beyond Stallman one way or other. Associating these institutions with Stallman going forward exposed them to the risk (worst case) of being the catholic church at Stallman's alter. At best, they are fighting a fight that has nothing to do with their primary mission.