6 ms·
> the U.S. has a much wider range of students taking most tests. Citation? All countries have a mix of wealthy, educated students, working class students, stu
by gumby 7y ago
> the U.S. has a much wider range of students taking most tests.
Citation? All countries have a mix of wealthy, educated students, working class students, students whose parents are drug addicts, immigrants who don't speak the local language, etc. In my experience the US isn't that different from other wealthy countries I've lived in.
SAT isn't really used for international comparison; a system like PISA does cross-sectional studies of countries, not elites. The results are not encouraging for the USA:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programme_for_International_Student_Assessment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programme_for_International_St...
https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/pisa/ https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/pisa/
http://www.oecd.org/pisa/ http://www.oecd.org/pisa/
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoWasn’t Shanghai famous for getting really good PISA scores, that being the richest city in China?
- gumby 7y agoThe Shanghai results are quite controversial, not only in terms of accuracy but whether they might skew Chinese results significantly. Not being in the field (and not really caring much about it TBH) I don't know how to evaluate the controversy or even its legitimacy.
- mieseratte 7y ago> Citation? All countries have a mix of wealthy, educated students, working class students, students whose parents are drug addicts, immigrants who don't speak the local language, etc. In my experience the US isn't that different from other wealthy countries I've lived in. Yes, but many European countries engage in so-called tracking of students, putting them in separate tracks for tradeswork, skilled labor, and university such that the "dumb" ones aren't taking university entrance exams. In the US this has become increasingly frowned upon by (perhaps) well-meaning administrators who feel that to do this is unconscionable. In my freshman year of high-school they had advanced academic and standard groupings in the same school, but removed this my sophmore year. They re-branded all the base-level courses as "College Prep," with "Honors" being the former advanced-track classes, AP and IB courses already being branded as such. Of course, if you were in the advanced group the counselors and teachers would all push you into AP and IB courses but they also encouraged everyone to take the SAT and ACT tests, to apply to university, and discouraged enrolling in the trades program that the county offered (half-day academic, half-day trades classes). This type of "everyone goes to college" mentality is why the SAT is a poor academic bellwether.
- eeZah7Ux 7y ago> Yes, but many European countries engage in so-called tracking of students, putting them in separate tracks for tradeswork, skilled labor, and university such that the "dumb" ones aren't taking university entrance exams. Not at all, this is largely false.
- eeZah7Ux 7y agoInstead of downvoting, provide evidence to the contrary. In various countries in Europe where I lived there are no laws preventing people from taking university entrance exams.
- zmk_ 7y agoBut in Europe this often goes hand-in-hand with mandatory schooling while in US people sort themselves by dropping out.
- mieseratte 7y agoIn my home state, one cannot drop-out until 16 which is well past when one would be traditionally tracked.
- dogma1138 7y agoMandatory schooling in most of Europe is up to the age of 15-16 and you can do w/e you want after that not unlike the US... https://os.unil.cloud.switch.ch/tind-customer-edudoc/aa7b2aa4-cfe2-4f45-a924-46bfe179e3da?response-content-disposition=attachment%3B%20filename%2A%3DUTF-8%27%27compulsory_education_2018_19.pdf&response-content-type=application%2Fpdf&AWSAccessKeyId=1e2525c929074b90b98e19eb95e6256c&Expires=1569518355&Signature=iy%2BwCYz0cHkACt8CYRFZaD0ELjs%3D https://os.unil.cloud.switch.ch/tind-customer-edudoc/aa7b2aa...
- SomeOldThrow 7y ago> Yes, but many European countries engage in so-called tracking of students, putting them in separate tracks for tradeswork, skilled labor, and university such that the "dumb" ones aren't taking university entrance exams. Err, this is a positive thing? Personally I found the AP classes and SATs to be pretty useless beyond getting into college. We should just admit anyone who wants to to. If the point of this is to justify high international test scores, there’s a much better argument there to test either nobody or everyone.
- barry-cotter 7y agoThe US has far more ethnic diversity than any country that’s at a remotely similar level economically. If you compare the average scores for Americans by race to countries where that race is the majority the US looks pretty great considering it’s 1/20 of humanity, less than ten countries do better at educating White or Asian populations, one does better with Hispanics and US Blacks outscore the only majority Black country that takes part in PISA by a small amount. You see the same dynamic in the US by state. http://www.unz.com/isteve/2015-pisa-mean-scores-in-perspective/ http://www.unz.com/isteve/2015-pisa-mean-scores-in-perspecti...
- BeetleB 7y ago>The US has far more ethnic diversity than any country that’s at a remotely similar level economically. That sounds like a cherry picked criterion to make a point. In any case, looking at GDP per capita, Singapore is similar to the US, and also similar in terms of racial/ethnic diversity. Yet Singapore (as a whole) tops your rankings, and the US as a whole is way down in the list.
- swebs 7y ago>The same census also reports that about 74.1% of residents were of Chinese descent, 13.4% of Malay descent, 9.2% of Indian descent, and 3.3% of other (including Eurasian) descent That's extremely different than the US.
- BeetleB 7y agoDifferent in terms of the ethnicities involved, but not in terms of the distribution: 72.4% White, 16.3% Hispanic, 12.6% African American, 4.8% Asian
- esyir 7y agoHonestly, I'd say that a good chunk of that is culture. Singapore has an insane focus of education, with enormous amounts of spending on supplementary education and such. In the US, the Asian "tiger mom" is seen as an odd peculiarity. That alone speaks volumes.
- tombert 7y ago> Citation? All countries have a mix of wealthy, educated students, working class students, students whose parents are drug addicts, immigrants who don't speak the local language, etc. In my experience the US isn't that different from other wealthy countries I've lived in. If you look at [0], It looks like the parent is right. > However, the PISA’s results are drastically over simplified. For instance, as noted in a report by Dr. Martin Carnoy of Stanford and Richard Rothstein of the Economic Policy Institute, American students actually perform better than the much higher ranked Finland in algebra in general, but worse in fractions. More importantly, when you normalize the results between the countries, adjusting for the relative poverty of the students taking the PISA tests, the U.S performs significantly better, ranking 6th in reading and 13th in mathematics, a drastic jump in both categories. > Dr. Carnoy and Rothstein further note in their report What Do International Tests Really Show About U.S. Student Performance? that when you divide the kids based on family wealth, the actual gap in performance isn’t so stark between any country, with a not insignificant portion of the ultimate ranking of each nation being based on how many impoverished vs. middle class vs. wealthy students are taking the tests. [0] http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2015/01/kids-get-summer-school/ http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2015/01/kids-get-sum...
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> when you normalize the results between the countries, adjusting for the relative poverty of the students taking the PISA tests, the U.S performs significantly better, ranking 6th in reading and 13th in mathematics, a drastic jump in both categories. We're doing better than that. When you break the results down by race, the US generally ranks second or first. (US whites do better than whites in Europe; US asians do better than asians in Asia, US blacks do better than blacks in the few countries with a large black population that aren't afraid to take these tests in the first place...)
- tombert 7y agoWould you mind providing a citation for that? I've genuinely never heard that.
- Spooky23 7y agoThe US has a caste-like professional class and an underclass. You can pretty easily observe the difference by looking at school performance in the x largest suburban districts in your state and comparing it to the x largest urban districts.
- zarkov99 7y agoLike it or not, different racial groups have significantly differential SAT mean scores. And the US has a growing number of minorities that do not do well on said tests.