17 ms·
U.N. postal union clinches deal to keep U.S. in
- spsrich2 7y agowhat a relief. of all the postal unions the USA could be in the global one is the best
- iagovar 7y agoSo, would this apply to Europe too? I mean, it's insane that it cost me more to send a package to France than Import it from China.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pkaye 7y agoI guess it would depend on the definition of "high-volume importers of mail and packages". I would assume the European countries had their own negotiators in the meetings.
- avocado4 7y agoIt applies to everyone starting 2021, and to large volume shippers starting July 2020.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoWorth noting that despite us not leaving the union, Trump is apparently getting what he wants. The union basically capitulated to his demands. At least that is my reading. To be clear, I'm not saying one way or another whether this is a good thing. It's just, I felt the title somewhat implied that the USG had given up on its intentions. Whereas actually what happened was the opposite. I meant only to point this out for others who might be likewise confused.
- cameronbrown 7y agoWalking away was just a bargaining chip. I never expected the US to leave.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoFundamentally, threatening to walk away only works if people believe you'll actually do it. (It's plausible Trump has additional influence here solely based on the fact him doing crazy %$&@ is considered "plausible".)
- jackvalentine 7y agoWhat would be the practical effect if the U.S. had left? Having to negotiate fees separately with every country?
- cameronbrown 7y agoI don't doubt they could do it if necessary. Disruption would probably be minimal. But like I said, I don't think it was ever on the table.
- jackvalentine 7y agoI’m genuinely asking, is that what you have to do if you’re not part of this postal union or is there some other state you find yourself in as an outsider? Do packages stop getting routed via your country? I don’t know!
- cc81 7y agoWhich is good. It has been discussed here in Sweden as well and it feels pretty odd that we would subsidize packages so they pay less sending something all the way from China than I would pay sending something to the next town. I get the history behind it but the world has changed since then.
- Scoundreller 7y agoTrump’e arguments weren’t wrong: it didn’t make sense for China to keep its below-average and below-cost fees for sending packages to the US. I just wish he could get the USPS to stop seeing outbound international mail as a profit centre. Plenty of Americans could be exporting a lot more internationally, but the USPS has chosen high prices and low volumes. As a Canadian that sometimes talks Americans into selling to me on Ebay, they find it a painful and costly experience compared to US sales.
- theflyinghorse 7y agoDoes this mean the field is leveled against Chinese shippers?
- pcdoodle 7y agoWondering the same thing here. I do like cheap gizmos off of ali express however I'm willing to pay fair shipping (We all pay in one way or another).
- oh_sigh 7y agoMaybe. Maybe China will start subsidizing their mail instead of having the US do it.
- microcolonel 7y agoIt is their prerogative, either way. I always assumed it was them paying the subsidies all along.
- kelnos 7y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted; that's a perfectly reasonable prediction. If shipping costs start reducing shipments of goods to the US by any appreciable amount, and the Chinese government wants to offset that, a subsidy is a reasonable way for them to do it. And I'd much rather the Chinese government subsidize their citizen's postage than the US government doing it for them.
- Danieru 7y agoChina would need to use their foreign reserve to do this subsidy. Ignoring belt and road all of China's internal industry subsidies use Yaun. Belt and Road use dollars but are "lent" thus in theory China is not reducing its foreign reserve. Problem for China as we see in their capital controls is maintaining wealth in Yaun. Any subsidy which requires using foreign dollars, as paying the US postal tarrif would, weakens the states stability.
- sct202 7y agoIf it is, they'll just move to doing Fulfillment by Amazon or the soon to come Fulfillment by Ebay.
- colechristensen 7y ago>The U.N. agency coordinating postal systems worldwide on Wednesday reached a compromise to reform its fee structure, proposed by the United States,
- freefal 7y agoNice to see this getting addressed. There's a great Planet Money episode explaining the brokenness of the existing system (https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/01/634737852/episode-857-the-postal-illuminati https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/01/634737852/epis...). NPR ends up substantiating the claim of an entrepreneur who says that it costs him more to send a package across the street than it costs someone in China to send a package to that same address.
- ikeboy 7y agoNo they don't. They repeat a false claim uncritically. If you look up the cheapest US shipping rates you'll find they're roughly the same range, and that almost all the comparisons purporting to show otherwise are cheating, typically by using retail pricing on a more expensive shipping option. >So he turns to his shipping guy. And he asks, how much would it cost for us just to ship this mug, like, not across the ocean, just across the street? >SMALDONE: He told me it's going to cost us about $6.30 to ship this item. Amazon page for mighty mug says it's 12.6 oz shipping weight. https://www.amazon.com/Might-Mug-1525-Mighty-Black/dp/B00FZDJHGK https://www.amazon.com/Might-Mug-1525-Mighty-Black/dp/B00FZD... Round up to 13 oz, then look up rates for the cheapest shipping option for packages under a pound "parcel select lightweight". See https://pe.usps.com/text/dmm300/Notice123.htm#_c139 https://pe.usps.com/text/dmm300/Notice123.htm#_c139 The cheapest rate is $2.02 for 13 oz. This rate applies when mail is injected at the closest mailing point (DDU), which "mailing across the street" corresponds to.
- gamblor956 7y agoNo, the claim is true. Under the UPU, the USPS is required to charge Chinese shippers a "terminal fee" for packages shipped from China. However, due to China being classified as a "transitional country" it had extremely low terminal fee rates. Combined with China subsidizing shipping for export-based businesses, it was generally cheaper for a business in Shenzen to ship small/light products by post than for an American business to ship an equivalent product by USPS across the street. The deal secured by the US allows the USPS to begin charging new terminal fee rates beginning next summer. Presumably the new rates will change the economics of this situation, but in the meantime Chinese shippers still have at least a year to continue these subsidized shenanigans.
- socalnate1 7y agoThis is one of those instances where playing chicken seems to have worked out (for the US). Good news on this issue; although I'd feel more comfortable if there were fewer geopolitical games of chicken going on; it just takes one crash to wipe away the wins.
- the_duke 7y agoThis was definitely a case of the US strong-arming the rest of the world, but in this case I think it was justified. I hope European countries follow suit and stop subsidizing foreign mail. It's absurd that we can order something on AliExpress, have it shipped halfway around the world, and pay 1 Dollar.
- mieseratte 7y ago> This was definitely a case of the US strong-arming the rest of the world, but in this case I think it was justified. What's the difference between "strong-arm" and "negotiating?"
- opportune 7y agoStrong arming is just negotiating with an advantage
- _delirium 7y agoEuropean countries mostly discourage this not through postal rates, but by applying VAT and customs charges even on small-scale individual importation. How uniformly this is done varies by country (some inspect and enforce more aggressively than others). In Denmark, for example, which is one of the more aggressive, you either need to have your package pre-cleared by arranging duties/VAT to be paid ahead of time, or the Danish post office will charge you a flat 160 DKK (about $23) for clearing it [1]. That makes it not cost-effective to order $20 items from China, even if the UPU rates are low. [1] https://www.postnord.dk/modtag/spoergsmaal-og-svar https://www.postnord.dk/modtag/spoergsmaal-og-svar
- 7y ago
- lettergram 7y agoGood. It was insane that we were subsidizing shipping from China. This, more than anything, will shift to a more balanced manufacturing model. It was more expensive to ship within the US and Canada than from China. Pretty much crushed the small retailers (I know I refused to spend $7 shipping for a $12 item). Now that that’s improved the rates should more normalize, because they won’t have to subsidize the loss on China shipping.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThis has been so frustrating. Last week I shipped a tightly packed t-shirt from Ontario to Oregon. $11.50. Months ago I bought replacement shelves for my fridge. Together about the size of two phone books stacked. Shelves were $40 and shipping was $40 from Illinois to Ontario. Life itself feels so frustrating when it's wildly cheaper just to buy more crap from China than to recycle stuff from within North America.
- mikepurvis 7y agoI've recently become exposed to the DIY electric skateboard scene, which has a fascinating dynamic going on where people in NA and Europe design parts (motor mounts, electronics modules, enclosures, etc) and then advertise them for sale to other forum participants. See: https://www.electric-skateboard.builders/c/electric-skateboard-parts-market/new-items-for-sale https://www.electric-skateboard.builders/c/electric-skateboa... What's interesting about it is that there are some users who order 50x of whatever the item is and then just sell them out of their garage, but there are others who have an arrangement with their contract manufacturer in China to actually do drop-shipping through eBay storefronts and similar. This latter group are obviously the more professionalized ones, but it's funny just to see a tiny microcosm of this issue, where the guys who are sending stuff within North America and Europe struggle to compete against dirt-cheap overseas shipping.
- rwmurrayVT 7y agoThis might be the wildest community I have stumbled on in a long time. Have you noticed particular pricing discrepancies between similar items sold different ways?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- megous 7y agoMore useful info here http://news.upu.int/no_cache/nd/frequently-asked-questions-third-extraordinary-congress/ http://news.upu.int/no_cache/nd/frequently-asked-questions-t...
- notyourday 7y agoBlast from the past: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20965145 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20965145 So can we get HN chicken littles that were predicting all this gloom and doom to admit that they don't actually understand how negotiations work? Edit: Embarrassing, isn't it?
- sunkenvicar 7y agoVery few people on HN have read The Art of The Deal.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoNot even Donald Trump has read it (or wrote it, to be factual.)
- sunkenvicar 7y agoAn irrelevant statement. The book explains his negotiating skills and strategies. I recommend reading it because it will help you understand his speech and actions.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoNo it will not. Donald Trump is not a good negotiator and he has no strategies aside from narcissism. The guy who wrote the book said himself he made it out of whole cloth without really any input from him. You're falling for a conman, dude. Choice quotes from the author: >"Trump's tweet that he has "written" bestselling books is one more deceit & delusion. He is incapable of reading a book, much less writing one." >Given the Times report on Trump’s staggering losses, I’d be fine if Random House simply took the book out of print. Or recategorized it as fiction. >“If I had to rename ‘The Art of the Deal’ I would call it ‘The Sociopath,’” “He has no conscience. He has no guilt.... He does not experience the world in the way an ordinary human being would.” >“I put lipstick on a pig. I feel a deep sense of remorse that I contributed to presenting Trump in a way that brought him wider attention and made him more appealing than he is.”
- TheSoftwareGuy 7y ago>Under the phased agreement, high-volume importers of mail and packages would be allowed to begin imposing “self-declared rates” for distributing foreign mail from January 2021. Does anybody have any idea what this means? Who is considered a "high-volume importer" and how do they set "self-declared rates"?
- markstos 7y agoI translated that the United States imports more mail then it exports. Backbone internet companies trade traffic with each other, but the trades aren't always equal so it makes sense for there to be money flowing more in one direction. The US is saying that the current relationship has costs that exceed the benefits, so the US is going to be declaring their own interpretation of a "fair market rate" to import mail from other countries that aren't receiving the same volume of US mail in return.
- mikepurvis 7y agoIf anyone else is interested in some of the history of how we got here, Wikipedia has a pretty decent summary: "The 1874 treaty provided for the originating country to keep all of the postage revenue, without compensating the destination country for delivery. The idea was that each letter would generate a reply, so the postal flows would be in balance. However, other classes of mail had imbalanced flows. In 1906, the Italian postal service was delivering 325,000 periodicals mailed from other countries to Italy, while Italian publishers were mailing no periodicals to other countries. [...] In 1969, the UPU introduced a system of terminal dues. When two countries had imbalanced mail flows, the country that sent more mail would have to pay a fee to the country that received more mail. The amount was based on the difference in the weight of mail sent and received." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Postal_Union#Terminal_dues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Postal_Union#Termina...
- tehjoker 7y agoThe reason rates are so cheap from China is because the system was intentionally designed to make it profitable to produce goods in China where labor is cheap. These kinds of attacks on the system are pretty interesting as they undermine the system the business community has loved since the 1990s. It's kind of amazing that Trump is actually attacking the system in order to feed his xenophobic platform. On the other hand, it's possible the business elite are suspicious of China's rising economic power and want to reduce dependence. In no scenario will ordinary people benefit so long as the elites are allowed to execute their plans as all roads lead to their own enrichment at our expense.
- droithomme 7y agoThis is reasonably good news. However I was kind of looking forward to the insanity that would follow from leaving this long term and fairly sensible pact! Change isn't always bad, sometimes change leads to new solutions. I personally enjoy the ability to buy NEW parts for my 1914 sewing machine and have them sent directly from some mom and pop family stall in a Chinese village for $0.15 with free shipping. But I also see the importance of encouraging American manufacturing, even though I also realize the long tail products I love so dearly and greatly appreciate the life support China's extended to them is valuable. I also benefit from the ability to manufacture prototype PCB boards in China for new products just by sending off a webform request and for around 1/50 the cost stateside. Losing that ability might be damaging to domestic productivity since we really can't meet those prices, which makes doing frequent bugfix revs, or a small production product, untenable. For those with access to those highly superior Chinese facilities at low cost and quick turnaround, they might have the long term advantage. On the other hand why can't we locally have very modern robotic pick and place machines that don't cost hardly anything and have Joe Bob's fabrication of Arkansas pivot from custom tractor parts to producing clean room spec proto boards. These shops in China doing this stuff a lot are in rural areas and are small outfits run by a few people. We can do the same and would be more interesting for a lot of americans than meth and opioid despair. And yes we can do it. Who knows though. What happens in the global economy and balance of tech is a delicate balancing game and difficult to predict long term outcomes past next year. I do think our present administration is quite good at this game of take it or leave it hardball. The present outcome is a reasonable compromise. And is the new solution we may or may not have gotten from actually leaving.
- kelnos 7y ago> I personally enjoy the ability to buy NEW parts for my 1914 sewing machine and have them sent directly from some mom and pop family stall in a Chinese village for $0.15 with free shipping. I do, too, but this just means that we're externalizing the cost of shipping and ignoring the fact that shipping things over such long distances is damaging to the environment, and damaging to the US's ability to have an independent, self-sustaining economy. (We'll never actually 100% get there in our globally-connected world, but getting closer when it makes sense for our interests is IMO a good thing.) > I do think our present administration is quite good at this game of take it or leave it hardball. I agree they're good at reaching for hardball at the slightest provocation, but I would not agree that they're good at it. This is one of the very very scant few situations where it's worked. It's the exception, not the norm.
- gpm 7y agoAlternative headline: "China gets deal to continue having America subsidize it's shipping for another 7 months"... I'm not impressed with the timeline associated with this deal. I'm also not impressed by how the US seems to have only solved the problem for the US. It seems like Canada and most of Europe are in a nearly identical situation.
- avocado4 7y ago7 months is very short when it comes to international agreements. Also it applies to every country from 2021, i.e. Canada and EU will be able to set their own rates as well.
- gpm 7y ago7 months is only fast when you ignore the 12 months leading up to this. > Also it applies to every country from 2021, i.e. Canada and EU will be able to set their own rates as well. Oh, I must have misread the article, that's good to hear.
- kelnos 7y ago19 months is still a pretty reasonable timeframe for modifying a huge international treaty that around 200 countries are party to. Regardless, I don't think it's fair to include the preceding 12 months; there was nothing actionable for any country to do to prepare for the changes until now. I would actually consider seven months to be impressively fast.
- mcv 7y agoYeah, I'm quite impressed by how fast and smoothly this happened. Considering practically every country in the world is party to this, and it's going to impact nearly all global mail traffic, I expected more talk and slower implementation.
- scarejunba 7y agoThat's a fantastic timeline, dude. You have to give people time to adjust. You know how we complain about products being sunset without sufficient headway. This is that headway.
- duxup 7y agoWhat are "self declared rates" and how does this exactly change things? I get the idea that international incoming shipments were subsidized but it's not clear what self declared rates really .. does?
- kelnos 7y agoI believe that the old rates were set by the UPU, and, in the case of China, were artificially low due to China's status as a developing nation. That status (conferred upon them 50+ years ago) has not been a reflection of reality for a long time. The new deal allows recipient countries to declare their own rates. The US will, almost certainly, declare a rate much higher than the current rate, such that the USPS will no longer be subsidizing shipments from China.
- duxup 7y agoOH, got it, the receiving nations declare it. It almost sounded like the sending were and of course they'd be all "oh yeah this is like a penny...".
- AimForTheBushes 7y agoGlad to see China backed the compromise. Definitely the best outcome.
- kelnos 7y agoI noticed this and found it interesting. I wonder what the motivation is here. Is the amount China stands to lose from this so low that it wasn't a hill they cared to die on? Will they use this in trade negotiations with Trump as a sign that they're being reasonable?
- ehvatum 7y agoTrump successfully telegraphed US intention to leave the IPU and impose punishing costs on delivery of Chinese parcels in the US, making acceptance of an equitable compromise the only palatable alternative for the Chinese. Incidentally, every Chinese person I know absolutely adores Donald Trump because he plays hard ball, whereas they didn't quite know what to think about Obama, who was totally inscrutable from the Chinese perspective. Trump lays out what he wants, and then he fights for it, and he usually gets it. As far as I can tell, people who grew up in China view that as the natural, normal, and proper way of conducting affairs.
- peteretep 7y ago> Chinese person I know absolutely adores Donald Trump because he plays hard ball, whereas they didn't quite know what to think about Obama, who was totally inscrutable from the Chinese perspective I have read countless well-written articles arguing exactly the opposite, so I find this interesting.
- ehvatum 7y agoThere is certainly no shortage of impeccably composed essays dumping on Trump and developing a galaxy of identity-political rationales for why various people ought to dislike him. The story on the ground is distinctly at odds with the impression I get from American media and the BBC. I'm sure they feel they are advocating for a good cause in a situation so dire that all other concerns are overridden.
- Animats 7y agoUPU terminal dues were up for renegotiation in 2018-2021 anyway.[1] That's done every 10 years. The end result of all the noise from the US seems to be the same thing as would have happened anyway - a rate change in 2021. The UPU classifies countries by level of development, and there's a price break for underdeveloped countries.[2] China is currently in group 3, along with Chile and Lebanon, and was probably going to move up to group 2 in the 2021 round anyway. So all this was mostly hype. [1] http://www.upu.int/en/activities/terminal-dues-and-transit-charges/2018-2021-cycle.html http://www.upu.int/en/activities/terminal-dues-and-transit-c... [2] https://www.uspsoig.gov/sites/default/files/document-library-files/2015/ms-wp-14-002_0.pdf https://www.uspsoig.gov/sites/default/files/document-library...
- defertoreptar 7y agoDidn't the terminal fee UPU agreement happen in 1969? China was considered a third world country back then and got favorable rates. Isn't all of this due to how in the last 50 years, the rates have not been updated to reflect how countries such as China have grown in the e-commerce era?
- s17n 7y agoIf I'm understanding the article correctly, the USPS can now unilaterally set its own rates, which is a pretty substantial change from the existing system where rates were determined by the decennial negotiations you're talking about.
- gumby 7y agoNot pointed out is that this works in the opposite direction as well, and it doesn't look like that part was fixed. For example Australia post operates a service when you can buy US goods, have them shipped to a US address, and then have the parcels shipped in aggregate to Australia for arbitrage on shipping and licensing costs: https://shopmate.auspost.com.au https://shopmate.auspost.com.au
- Leary 7y agoThe decision was reached unanimously by all 190 some countries. It's good to see countries working together to reach a compromise.
- paggle 7y agoThis is where Trump’s “give no quarter” tactics has really yielded fruit. I wish we could find a more normal and balanced guy who was still willing to throw around the weight and leverage of the US.
- m0zg 7y agoMore "normal" and "balanced" guy would be eaten alive by the establishment and mainstream press, and would achieve nothing at all.
- paggle 7y agoNot at all, Reagan was a guy who managed to proudly use the strength of the US without being a moral degenerate.
- m0zg 7y agoReagan too was called a total clown during his first election campaign and in his first term (he's in a good company, so was Lincoln). He was a much better public speaker, I'll give you that, but Trump is almost certainly a better negotiator, just from experience alone. I took some classes on negotiation, and did a bit of that myself, and I routinely see people misinterpret bog standard negotiation plays he does as his "missteps". Literally any book or course on negotiation will walk you through all of the techniques I've seen so far. It's getting tiresome. That's _the standard way_ of doing this shit, literally everyone who has successfully run any kind of business will see these tactics for what they are immediately. As to "degenerate", that's the label you use when you've lost the rational argument. All I see is a talented businessman with a bit of Aspergers, strong Twitter game, and a profound lack of public speaking skills. None of that disqualifies him from the job he was elected to do. http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2016/05/ronald-reagan-was-once-donald-trump.html?gtm=bottom http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2016/05/ronald-reagan-was-onc...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- m0zg 7y ago>> agreed to reform its fee structure And for decades before this moment it never occurred to any of the demagogues in chief to look into such mundane matters as trade imbalance, or subsidizing everybody in the world at the expense of our own businesses and manufacturing base, hollowing out large chunks of the country to make a quick buck. This shows the downsides of electing lawyers who never did anything of material consequence in the real world, and don't understand or care how the business side of things works.
- caf 7y agoI wonder whether, in practice, sellers will apply the higher rates only to US destinations - or whether they'll just spread it across all their customers, so that the situation changes to non-US customers subsidising the US ones?
- kevindong 7y agoA few years ago, as a joke, I bought the absolute cheapest phone case off of Aliexpress for a friend for $0.46 with free shipping. 1.5 months later, I did actually get it in the mail. It went from China, through several of the central Asian countries (the ones whose names end with "stan"), and was delivered to my mailbox. All for less than the cost of a first class postage stamp at the time ($0.47). It blows my mind that Aliexpress was willing to take my money and act as an intermediary between me and the retailer/factory as I cannot imagine they made a profit on this transaction given the fixed cost of accepting credit card payments (i.e. the "$0.30" part of 2.9% + "$0.30"). It further blows my mind that a retailer/factory can profitably send me the case at all, even if they were to receive the entire $0.46.
- Overtonwindow 7y agoExcellent! China has been abusing this system far too long.
- racino84 7y agoAnyone have a list of countries that do over 75,000 tonnes of imported mail a year?
- ummwhat 7y agoThis is weird because the postal union was the one wonky, deep in the weeds policy where even the globalist agreed with the populist that something needed to be done. Way I see it there were 3 options. 1. Use international institutions like the WTO and UN to affect a change or enact a legal, narrow set of tarifs on bad actors without putting the wider, generally beneficial system at risk. 2. Start subsidizing our own postal service. China does it because it's an economic multiplier that benefits a wide segment of society. Why not copy it. 3. Burn the postal union treaty to the ground. Trump picked 3 and has now pivoted to 1. I personally would have picked 2 but I don't think any of these options are crazy. 3 sucked but wasn't outrageous IMO.
- aivisol 7y agoSubsidizing own postal service would mean paying it with tax dollars. Why would those who never use this service should pay for those who use it more? Besides that (and its my own observation only) I have noticed that subsidies usually distort market and make service/product less sustainable and competitive.
- ummwhat 7y agoSame reason I'm ok with the government building a road even though I don't personally drive. It's an economic multiplier. It increases opportunity overall by facilitating more transactions than were previously possible, and the net economic growth can flow back to me even though I didn't directly use it. I'm not universally in favor of subsidies, just in certain specific instances where the economic multiplier is high and a large fraction of the public benefits directly (usually infrastructure).
- Spivak 7y agoWhich is why I'm so surprised that people dislike farm subsidies so much since every single person in the US benefits from cheap corn being available.
- Spivak 7y agoThey absolutely distort the market! That's the point if you're a government trying to affect your economy. The idea is that everyone collectively paying $X for cheap shipping to be available creates more than $X in economic value. Someone who doesn't actually take advantage of the cheap shipping directly is 100% benefiting from the businesses they frequent that do. An argument that might be more familiar in our industry: Why do we spend 10M on advertising when we could use that money to make our product cheaper? Because that 10M spent brings in 12M in revenue.
- mcv 7y agoGood. This might actually be the one good thing that Trump has accomplished. Or that would have been my reaction until I read the article: "Countries with more than 75,000 tonnes in post imported annually - mainly the United States - may apply their self-declared new rates from July 2020, UPU officials said." So does 'mainly the US' mean 'only the US'? I don't want an exception just for the US because they are too powerful to ignore, I want the same rule to hold for every EU country. Replacing a rule where rich countries subsidize long distance mail from (former) poor countries with a rule where only small rich countries have to pay for that subsidy is really not an improvement.
- TMWNN 7y agoTrump is president of the United States, not of the EU. It is the EU and its member states' onus to obtain similar changes, should they believe them desirable. That you begin with a snarky remark about Trump, and then go on to say that he is at fault for not helping Belgium or Austria win the kind of changes that the US needed to seriously threaten to leave the UPU for, says more about you than about the US or Trump.
- mcv 7y agoI'm not sure how you think the UPU works, but Trump does not set UPU rules on his own. 200 countries are involved in those negotiations. If the UPU rules are inconsistent, that's not just on Trump, but on the UPU and the many parties negotiating in it, including the EU. So I have no idea why you choose to read my complaint about the UPU negotiations as a complaint about Trump. I even started out by saying he is right in this one case. But this is an issue that's not unique to the US, but to all wealthy countries, and therefore should be handled evenly for all countries. That's what I pointed out in my comment. You're a bit too eager to read attacks where there are none. Had the UPU made just a single exception for the US because of the US's power, that would have been inconsistent and a mistake by the UPU. But as others have explained elsewhere, that's not what happened. The rule is for everybody, it just starts 6 months early for the US, which I guess is a minor gesture to appease Trump. I'm fine with that. Starting in 2021, the situation will be fixed for everybody.