17 ms·
This can be summed up pretty easily. The TI graphing calculator has no internet access and no ability to store notes. Neither ability can be easily added. As
by jedberg 7y ago
This can be summed up pretty easily. The TI graphing calculator has no internet access and no ability to store notes. Neither ability can be easily added.
As long as that is the case, they will win, because the test companies don't want to deal with people having internet access and notes.
Now if Apple/Android made a simple way for a test proctor to put your phone into a single app only that you couldn't easily break out of, maybe things will change.
But until then, they're going to require devices without internet and note taking.
Edit: Since everyone is replying "you can store notes!", yes, you can, but most test proctors know about the programs and make you clear your memory before a test.
- soperj 7y agoTI-83's had a restore function, where you could just restore all deleted programs. Not that we had to use them... to quote my gr.12 math teacher - "You're not allowed to have programs on your graphing calculator, but they're not going to check, so you might as well." He wouldn't allow us to use the graphing calculator for his exams though, only the final.
- eurleif 7y ago> no ability to store notes What? It can run custom programs. Of course it can store notes.
- jedberg 7y agoThat's why I said "easily". Yeah you can store programs, but they're really hard to write, and most test proctors know how to clear the memory on a TI calculator, which they require you to do before a test.
- melq 7y agoAnecdotal, and I have been out of school for 5 years or so, but I never once had a teacher or proctor clear the memory on my calculator. Also, storing notes on a TI calc is trivial, you don't need any programming knowledge to do so.
- octorian 7y agoSame here. I feel like I went to school just before teachers caught on to the issue. Either that, or I just got lucky.
- michaelmior 7y agoIs the program required to be syntactically valid? I assume not in which case you can just type your notes into the program editor.
- mattbreeden 7y agoNo, it's not. This is exactly how I used mine. They weren't hard to write at all because they were just direct notes. It wouldn't run as a program but I didn't need/want it to, I'd just 'edit' the program again to see my notes.
- fwip 7y agoYour program doesn't have to be valid BASIC. It can just be a text document, open it up with the editor.
- lozaning 7y agoHell I had a buddy in high school that went through and wrote a custom program that's only function was to perfectly 'emulate' the entire calculators menu system, so that when asked to demonstrate that he had no notes or programs, he could go through the entire process of showing nothing being archived and then wiping the memory. Dude wound up in the Stanford CS program after high school, so clearly he learned something.
- jedberg 7y agoI did that too.
- pixelbath 7y agoI wonder how many individual variations on this specific functionality have existed or currently exist on TI calculators in the wild. It's common enough that I see it mentioned every time TI calculators are brought up. When I got my TI-85 (one of the earliest ones), I was one of two kids (the other kid had some $500 HP monstrosity) who had a full-on graphing calculator so "clearing the memory" wasn't even on the teachers' radar. I remember my calculus teacher being impressed that I could simply enter the terms of a binomial equation and it would just spit the answers out. A few years later, TI-83s were simply the required calculator for those classes.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoA week or two before the AP calculus exam, my calculus teacher had us all line up to install special software for solving exam problems, and then taught us how to use it. This wasn't really necessary, as I had enough time remaining to redo the whole test without the programs, and then a third run without the calculator.
- ChicagoBoy11 7y agoHa! I literally just wrote a reply saying that exact same thing. Crazy to realize how so many kids did this... there should be a club or something. I wonder how good a predictor of doing this in school is of certain lifetime outcome variables...
- egdod 7y ago>no ability to store notes You can still type in programs, right? I remember kids storing a bunch of notes that way.
- jedberg 7y agoYes, but most test proctors make you clear the memory before the test. In fact, one of the programs my friends and I wrote was one that faked the memory clearing process. This worked because at the time the test proctors didn't really know how the calculator worked so our fake was good enough.
- egdod 7y agoHa, that’s pretty good. Back when I was in school a million years ago, nobody thought to make us clear the memory before exams. So people just got away with it, as far as I know.
- toast0 7y agoYou know. When I was in high school, some of the other students would ask History or English teachers if they could use their calculators on the test. The responses were usually "I don't know why you would want to, but fine with me."
- wjmao88 7y agoirrc you can have a program that stubs the clearing of memory. it displays the message but doesn't actually do it.
- vorpalhex 7y agoYou can trivially store notes on the TI graphic calculator using it's built in programming function. This is not a new trick to any student. Common test setup is to have each student reset their calculator to factory settings to account for this. Internet access is possible but significantly non-trivial on most models.
- jmcphers 7y agoYou can easily store notes on a TI calculator. I had a TI-85 in college, and was occasionally guilty of writing TI-BASIC programs to make tests easier (for example, I had one which computed Euler's method).
- jedberg 7y agoMost test proctors make you clear your memory before a test in high school. In college they don't care as much because they are used to making "open book tests".
- bsamuels 7y agoThe trick with those is you can make a TI-BASIC program that will make it look like you cleared the memory - fake empty "programs" list and all. There were a few tiny details you couldn't replicate like the highlighting animation, but they never noticed when I did it.
- jedberg 7y agoI in fact did this in high school. But now that the current high school teachers are people my age who actually grew up using the calculators, they are wise to that ploy. :)
- JohnBooty 7y agoI went to high school in the early 90s, at the dawn of graphing calculators but before teachers were wise to the "notes" trick. One time before a calc test I dropped my graphing calculator. The battery door popped off and the batteries popped out. The unit was otherwise unharmed... but my cheat sheet in the notes app was gone! I nearly crapped my pants. Luckily though... as most cheaters know... to make a decent cheat sheet you actually have to comprehend the material first. Half the time you wind up not even using your cheat sheet. Luckily for me that was the case. I still did well on the test.
- 7y ago
- copperx 7y ago> no ability to store notes I thought that storing notes was the selling point of the TI-93. You can easily add an app that does just that.
- avhon1 7y agoThe TI-93 is typically not required for high-school or undergraduate math classes, and is often not allowed on standardized tests.
- thayne 7y agoThat is an argument against allowing phone apps. But doesn't excuse requiring students to pay $100+ for antiquated technology.
- ineedasername 7y ago> doesn't excuse..." At least for widespread standardized tests that allow or require a calculator, the obvious solution would seem to be providing students with one at the beginning of the exam. In addition to preventing cheating with unauthorized programs when students bring their own, it ensures there's a level playing field for poorer students who might not be able to afford one. Add an extra $1 to the cost of the test if need be-- the calculators should last at least 100 tests or so, and they could probably get a volume discount anyway.
- mandevil 7y agoThe SAT II Math exam is administered 6 times during the 2019-2020 school year. To be used 100 times, it would have to last over 15 years. For IB/AP Calc it's even worse, that is literally given on one day to the entire country (modulo a very small number of makeup exams), so would get two days of use per year (one for AP, one for IB). If you used the same set of calculators for both, we're talking about the hardware lasting at least 12 years on average, ignoring storage and transportation costs. Oh, and then you expose yourself to "the calculator was broken, that's why I failed" when right now they have the excellent defense of "well, you brought it."
- ineedasername 7y agoYou're neither adding all of the College Board tests that use a calculator nor accounting for the discounted wholesale price (or maybe better considering the volume) that would be paid. The SAT II Math isn't the only test. The normal SAT math component also allows calculators and is generally administered on different dates. The SAT is offered on 21 dates in 2019, so that's a total of 27 tests. Even at a full ~$100 per calculator, charging an extra $1 per test would still cover the cost in a little more than 3 years. AP Exams: Unlike the SAT which has regional test locations, AP exams are generally administered in the school you attend, and the school should provide a calculator. For that matter, the whole issue could be solved if schools issued them as standard equipment that same way they do textbooks. Finally, the whole point of these tests is to establish the level of knowledge a student has. That hasn't really been done if the test takers aren't on the same level playing field. All else being equal, the same score for a test taker with a calculator compared to one without would mean very different things. It's supposed to be a standardized test. All students should have the same equipment.
- tzs 7y ago> This can be summed up pretty easily. The TI graphing calculator has no internet access and no ability to store notes. Neither ability can be easily added. There was a similar concern with typewriters when I wanted to type rather than hand write exams in law school in the '90s. By then most typewriters included some memory and some kind of display, with a delay between your typing and putting the characters on the paper so that you could correct recent errors without needing white-out. Some typewriters were essentially dedicated word processors that could hold one or more pages in memory, sometimes even in non-volatile memory. To prevent cheating via typewriter, my school only allowed typewriters that had at most two lines of memory. I remember that I had a hard time finding a typewriter that was sufficiently limited.
- zerocrates 7y agoThe law schools and bar exams have now settled on software that reboots a computer into a limited environment just for testing, where the administrators get to configure what kinds of features like copy and paste or spell-check are available (and of course, no stored memory from beforehand, or web access). The DC bar had just moved from typewriters (with the same "lines of memory" restriction you mentioned) to computers for its essay portions when I took the exam only a handful of years ago.
- massysett 7y agoWhen I was in law school this was called ExamSoft. Inevitably it would screw up someone’s computer before the exam, holding everything up. In my last semester the school stopper using it. We could type exams in Word and we were told simply that under the honor code we couldn’t cheat. Reminds me of a “Leave It to Beaver” when Wally cheated (or tried to) by going to the bathroom and getting paper towels with the answers. It’s ridiculous to spend resources to lock down computers when there are much simpler ways to cheat.
- asperous 7y ago> Now if Apple/Android made a simple way for a test proctor to put your phone into a single app only that you couldn't easily break out of, maybe things will change. Apple actually supports this: "When you give a test to your students, you can lock their iPad in to an assessment app and turn off features that you don't want them to use." https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204775 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204775 I tried it just now with desmos testing app. It starts when you click "start test" and ends after 8 hours or when you click "complete". Teachers just verify that the start time and duration looks right before they click complete test and disable the mode. During that time you can't switch apps, look at notifications, etc.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThis works if the device is supplied by the school, but you can't lock a student's personal device.
- asperous 7y agoI just tried it on mine and it worked fine.
- dTal 7y agoYes, it worked for you - but surely in an adversarial context, there's absolutely no way to trust a previously untrusted device. In the extreme case, the entire interface might simply be a simulacrum app designed to feign success at locking.
- csande17 7y agoYup, a student could easily write an app that fakes the Desmos Test Mode confirmation screen, just like how a student could write a TI-BASIC program that displays "MEMORY CLEARED" on the screen. What's old is new again...
- lonelappde 7y ago
- naikrovek 7y agoThe HP Prime calc has these features, has been out for years, is FAR, FAR more powerful than any TI calc I know of, including the newer CAS models, has top-facing LEDs so the teacher can know that you're in test mode at a glance, costs (and is worth) $125 or so, and has never taken off at all.
- duskwuff 7y ago> and has never taken off at all. Nor have any of TI's attempts at replacing the TI-83 series, like the TI-Nspire. (Which even had a TI-83 emulation mode!)
- selimthegrim 7y agoIt even had Dropbox integration and Lua scripting!
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 7y agoThe Android/Apple device has internet access and ability to store notes. Neither ability can be easily taken away. Yeah, it's true if you emphasize "easily".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Eridrus 7y agoEven if TI cannot be displaced, the amount of money they're extracting could be drastically reduced. The only time these calculators are actually needed is in exams - it should be pretty straightforward to let students use a TI clone app on their phones for regular study, and give them real ones only during exam time. This reduces the need from 1 per student, to 1 per students concurrently taking an exam.
- jacobolus 7y agoThis is already the case, and has been for decades. It is entirely possible to get through high school and undergraduate math/science education without ever owning a handheld graphing calculator, just borrowing one for the 1–2 exams which require them. A “scientific calculator” (or for that matter a slide rule) is pretty much always sufficient in class, and a computer with a full keyboard and proper programming language (this could be a chromebook with a web browser, or a Raspberry Pi or used iPad with an external keyboard) is a better homework tool.
- scythe 7y agoYou don’t need a graphing calculator for tests. You can handle it with a scientific calculator that has expressions. The students could just use a graphing app on their phones for class/homework and a cheaper calculator for tests.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoWhy does it have to support expressions? A basic scientific accumulator-based calculator is enough for numerical computation without resorting to a slide rule.
- TomJansen 7y ago>no ability to store notes You can store notes on the TI-84! With the program called TI NoteFolio. This can be disabled in at least The Netherlands with the so-called "Examenstand"[0] (Exam mode). [0] https://education.ti.com/nl/resources/examenstand-84 https://education.ti.com/nl/resources/examenstand-84
- homero 7y agoYeah i used to store all kinds of notes and even functions
- narrator 7y ago>Now if Apple/Android made a simple way for a test proctor to put your phone into a single app only that you couldn't easily break out of, maybe things will change Exam4 and other software is built so closed book exams can be taken on normal computers. This is a pretty well understood problem.
- saghm 7y ago> This can be summed up pretty easily. The TI graphing calculator has no internet access and no ability to store notes. Neither ability can be easily added. Does this really need to cost $100, though?
- morpheuskafka 7y agoOn the SAT you can use programs and notes (obviously you are not supposed to share test content, but there is no specific prohibited on the notes feature. I think the ACT says you are not supposed to somewhere in the instructions but they do not clear the calculators. Only time I've had them clear the calculators was for some state-mandated EOGs that you could do with your eyes closed. And it can't be that hard to build a modified logic board that includes an LTE modem or WiFi chip and fits inside the case of a TI-84. If you're just going to copy the answers you wouldn't even need to bother cloning all the math features, just the very basics. The test proctors barely glance at the calculators as they hand out the test books, no one would notice minor changes in the look of the screen or case.
- fragmede 7y agoThe TI-84 has a USB port, so a backpack case could easily enable Internet access to the phone, though having the TI-84 taking advantage of this access would be a bit harder.
- swiley 7y ago> On the SAT you can use programs and notes That is definitely a new thing. I wasn't allowed to use a calculator at all when I took the test 4 years ago.
- morpheuskafka 7y agoYou may well be right--the test was given a top-to-bottom redesign in 2016, so you would have been just before that. Nowadays there is a calc active and calc inactive section, whereas the current ACT has one math section, all calc active.
- michaelmrose 7y agoThe only way to have a way for OEMs to provide a proctor mode in the context of the test is to take away your personal freedom to use your device in all contexts. The cure is vastly worse than the disease. It would on the other hand be trivial to provide a device owned by the school that Only runs calculator software without admin access. It would also probably cost at least a $100 per unit and be less familiar to students. On the other hand it could be trivially used to say read electronic books/videos when not in use during tests.
- naikrovek 7y agoThe HP Prime calculator has these features. Non-destructive but restrictive test mode, and the teacher/instructor or whomever can see if you've escaped test mode thanks to status LEDs on the device. They thought of those things and implemented a good system.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIf you really controlled the calculator you could tell the light to lie. Then again you probably don't care because it's a calculator. The original thought expressed was >Now if Apple/Android made a simple way for a test proctor to put your phone into a single app only that you couldn't easily break out of, maybe things will change. This expresses the idea of Apple/Google granting a third party control of your machine to render it suitable for use during the test. This restriction must happen at a level that is superior to the user on a device with a lot of personal information. This is hard to implement and terrible for the users right to con their own device and their privacy. The same restrictions on a school owned device not used for personal communication would be easier to implement and less worrisome.
- grawprog 7y agoEvery test I took in school, including university, forbid graphing calculators during tests, except for any that were about actual graphing. During those, as you said they went around and cleared the memory on everyone's calculator.
- tbrock 7y agoHah, oh yes. But most proctors also don’t know about the program that makes it just look like you cleared your programs but actually is showing an image of a cleared calculator’s program menu.
- DEADBEEFC0FFEE 7y agoCan you say more about this please? What is a proctor, and why don't they like notes?
- saagarjha 7y agoA proctor is someone who administers exams. Allowing people to keep notes lets them cheat, basically.
- arkades 7y agoApple already has this. Every med school has apps for administering exams on iOS and windows - partly relying on the use of Guided Access.
- caconym_ 7y agoI haven't been in school for ten years, but if I recall correctly the stipulation was not "it cannot connect to the internet and/or store notes". It was, invariably, some version of "it must start with 'TI-' and be followed by one of these accepted integers". So, whether it was a result of TI's lobbying or whatever else, the fact was and I assume still is that competing w/TI with a similarly capable, reasonably priced device is impossible because such a device cant pretend to be a TI-84, or whatever. Simply having the same capabilities and restrictions is not enough.
- enjoyyourlife 7y agoClass Calc (https://classcalc.com/ https://classcalc.com/) is trying to do just that
- m0zg 7y agoIMO notes should be allowed in all exams. That's just how people work. Moreover I'd argue working with notes is a more critical skill than rote memorization. Exams without notes is like coding on the whiteboard: sheer idiocy which has nothing in common with real-world skills, unless you're hiring/testing specifically for memorization skills or whiteboard penmanship.
- Gaelan 7y agoInterestingly, the SAT doesn’t bother with clearing calculators. I guess they don’t think it’s that big of an advantage.
- fourier_mode 7y agoFor me, you missed the most interesting parts of the article which were the TI's lobbying efforts.
- j45 7y agoTi calculators very easily store notes. You save the name of the program in a certain format and it becomes an invisible file. Add to this building your own apps to calculate common algebra, chemistry, etc. My high school allowed apps as long as we wrote it from scratch and were willing to risk our grades on it.
- phreack 7y agoI sort of get banning internet access but I've always been baffled at exams not allowing notes. At least in engineering, we should encourage students to be able to solve difficult problems with notes rather than solve minimal ones with barely memorized formulas and phrases.
- dredmorbius 7y agoAnswer keys, among other elements. Contrast a single A-4 / US Letter, or 3x5 or 4x6 index card.
- ekianjo 7y ago> As long as that is the case, they will win, because the test companies don't want to deal with people having internet access and notes. They are not winning because they have no competition. You don't win when you are alone on a market. As the article shows they have also massively lobbied to make sure textbooks make TI specific exercises which is just mindboggling.
- on_and_off 7y agohmm The big question will be whether the phones are rooted/jailbroken. That would open the door to pretty much anything. Otherwise, with enterprise mode, it sounds pretty easy to block the access to all apps except for one.
- greggman2 7y agoGoing to be interesting in 50 years when the computers are implanted early in life
- rcarmo 7y agoDesmos has a separate “test mode” app.
- pvorb 7y agoWhen I had my final math exam in 2008, all calculators used in the exam were reset by the teachers before the exam started.
- Aeolun 7y agoClear your memory? No way. There’s hundreds of hours of work in those programs. Anyway, I think my school figured that if you were smart enough to write those programs you would be smart enough to figure out the solution.
- ChicagoBoy11 7y agoBring good memories of trying to get around that during HS. At first people would store notes and things in programs, so teachers wisened up that you had to clear your memory. But there was a way you could archive programs, so then they figured out how to make sure you hadn't done that, either. But they never foiled the genius plan a friend of mine and I concocted to write a program that would simulate all of the screens involved in the "check" that teachers did to make sure you had cleared your memory correctly. What we were most proud of was the fact that after it was all 'done', you could even enter basic calculations in the calculator and it would behave as expected, making you none the wiser that you were actually running a program of ours all along. We also never used it for cheating. There was just something beautiful about knowing that we could, plus we had so many other games and things that it was always a pain to have to reinstall things after an assessment. Ohh the memories!
- anotheryou 7y agothere is also 2 memories: one for your work, one for "apps" or even like a repository for dormant apps to be installed. You can move your stuff to the frozen app part, do the default reset and than moe them back. Not that I ever did this in biology class, but you could, even with images. I also never used it as a chat with my neighbour.
- rolltiide 7y ago12 years ago I put a TI-84 emulator on my Nintendo DS and used that instead. It was novel at the time and professors enjoyed it but it was short-lived as they soon mandated that calculators cant have an internet connection so that students couldn't cheat on tests. I’m sure if I was in college now I would learn or create other tricks.