8 ms·
I have so many questions about China. 1) What does this mean for Xi's leadership and the CCP? Will this threaten their power? 2) Does this cement the US as th
by echelon 7y ago
I have so many questions about China.
1) What does this mean for Xi's leadership and the CCP? Will this threaten their power?
2) Does this cement the US as the leading economy for the next quarter century?
3) What does this mean for up and coming rivals, such as India and Vietnam?
4) How will this effect China's middle class?
5) Will we see an increase in Chinese expats?
- mc32 7y agoIt depends on how they respond. It would threaten their power if it enters a deep, extended recession. How it affects VN and IN depends on how long the trade tiff lasts. If it’s prolonged it will benefit them as companies are encouraged to transition. The middle class in cities of course will see a crunch if this continues —they have a lot tied up in real estate.
- Supermancho 7y agoHow does this story engender these questions? 1. Nothing. No. The CCP retains power without challenge under far more volatile conditions. Xi is the head of the CCP and he is not about to let go. 2. No. Nothing cements the future. 3. Nothing. Their growth is not China's growth. 4. It will continue to grow. 5. No. This "slowdown" has nothing to do with expats. Financial tools being taxed, has curbed Chinese investment outside of China. Anchor babies will continue to be popular. This announcement, means very little in the long term, imo.
- wendyshu 7y agoGreat questions but I doubt the experts who could answer them will comment here.
- jacquesm 7y agoAt least one expert has already chimed in.
- billfruit 7y agoIndia is in a slump of their own, and the recent government measures there including the effective suppression of the right of habeas corpus, the most fundamental of rights is severely unbecoming of a parliamentary democracy.
- youeseh 7y agoI think you're talking about Kashmir. I wish you'd provide more context for what you just said. I think it'd be better to start a separate thread than to take this one off-topic.
- mayankkaizen 7y agoYour comment is vague but I guess you were talking about Kashmir issue. Don't want to start a flamewar, I'll just say Kashmir issue is far more complex than you can imagine and talk of fundamental rights suppression is utterly nonsense. But let's not discuss it on HN. In the context of this thread and topic, Kashmir doesn't play any significant role in India's economy or growth story. Secondly, the troubled area is quite a small part of Jammu Kashmir state.
- puranjay 7y agoRegardless of Kashmir, India's current slowdown appears to be unprecedented. My architect brother contends that the slump in real estate is worse than it was after Demonetization and 2008
- baybal2 7y ago> What does this mean for Xi's leadership and the CCP? Few days of bad mood > Will this threaten their power? Who will threaten his power? Han Zheng is the last Jiang loyalist in party's higher tiers, he is under extreme pressure for his handling of HK now. I bet Xi will come out of that even more powerful, by dumping blame on whomever may oppose him. > Does this cement the US as the leading economy for the next quarter century? Leading economy != leading country. The negative feedback on currency will just roll Chinese companies back few years in their market outlook. Companies that were previously aiming for selling to developed economies will thing of places like South Asia, Africa, Eastern Europe and such. > What does this mean for up and coming rivals, such as India and Vietnam? Not much for India. India just like Russia doesn't really want joining the global economy, and the impediment comes from within. For Vietnam... good times to come. And for whomever will be working as fixers, bringing Western companies there. But there is a big BUT. The moment Vietnam will get up on the economic ladder, there is a certain chance US or somebody else will try to pull the same tariff hike on them. > How will this effect China's middle class? Chinese middle class largely works in service sector, and that depends near solely on internal demand. > Will we see an increase in Chinese expats? Sure, there is always a knee jerk reaction among Chinese rich to any new wave of doomsayers. When I was living in Vancouver I met quite a few rich Chinese. One of whom was an owner of the 4th largest scrap metal company in China. He sold his business at an insane 60% discount, and ran to Canada the moment he read "Chinese steel bubble is about to pop" in an "esteemed Western publication" in 2010. The last time I checked on him, he was still living a nice rentier life with 3 houses in Vancouver, but was super cringy about him selling so low, and trusting random rags for making a once in a lifetime decision. Near same was the case with 3 factory owners. Two had electronic factories, and one did clothing. You can still argue about one with clothing business making a correct decision closing the shop, but for two electronics factory owner, the decision to close their businesses made zero sense. I asked them separately why they exchanged life in Canada for untold millions to come. None was able to give an answer, saying simply they don't understand their own rationale back then. To them, people of peasant background, life in the West looked as something near mythical. They grew up thinking that "getting to the West" was something like a once in a lifetime chance, something what exceeds just anything on the list of ones personal achievements. To such people, parting with a few million buck a year business for a house in Vancouver and steady life genuinely looks like a good deal. The new generation of entrepreneurs of course don't hold the West in such esteem, and some actually thing of it with some degree of contempt.
- AFascistWorld 7y ago1) What does this mean for Xi's leadership and the CCP? Will this threaten their power? No, only had you experienced the level and depth of China's indoctrination, can you understand how profoundly it affects the people, I still recall now and then the red songs I was taught and sang. Your whole world view is shaped by the regime to ensure their best interest, you think in their ways even if you are a rebel. BTW they now teach "politics" in primary schools. The Youth are extremely patriotic and loyal to the party, they are impatient to even let you start your different opinions. There will be discontent, but the power and reach of the tools the party has built is simply unprecedented in human history. 4) How will this effect China's middle class? If the condo market collapses, most of them probably will go bankrupt and be in huge debts for a long time, being taught bubble economics the hard way, but the market probably can bounce back since it's CCP monopoly. Worst case senario the party can print money nonstop to keep the prices from crashing.
- kiliantics 7y agoMuch of this description applies pretty well to western countries, especially the US.
- Quarrel 7y agoNot in the same way. The US has had credit collapses before, and has relatively robust institutions to deal with it. Robustness that has developed through major crashes. This is largely true of most developed economies as well. China's credit bust will be epic - epicly bad, both for China and the rest of the world, but mostly for the Chinese people.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoNo no no, in which American city does the condo prices wthin it's urban area are no less than 1 million dollars? In Beijing you have it, it's a city full of (multi) million-dollar-property owners, and the majority of them love the CCP dearly for a reason.
- tmh79 7y ago
- 99_00 7y ago1) His leadership is always under threat form opposing factions.
- andrekandre 7y agowhich ones?
- kayaeb 7y ago1) It's not great, however it's not Xi's main point, wealth was Deng Xoaping's promise to China, respect is Xi's promise. Xi is actively expending wealth in trade for respect (military, belt and road, space program, etc.). This was foundational in Xi's being chosen as leader, he cut his chops preparing Beijing for the olympics 2008 international show -- a respect event, not an economic one. 2) No. USA is the leading economy not because of economy but because of dollar hegemony, which insulates it from shocks that the RMB is subjected to. If belt-and-road nations start using RMB as reserve currency (and non-swift banking systems), regardless of economic power, that would challenge USA as leading economy. This is being attempted, but not covered much, for example the sino-russian deal to trade oil and gold in RMB instead of using the OPEC petro-dollar. 3) India is a more socially volatile than China, considering regions like Kashmir and social discord like lower-castes. If India were the #2 or #1 it would suddenly have these situations magnified the way China's situations are scrutinized on the world stage, leading to more aggressive challenges. India currently gets a free pass on inequality and climate etc. because it's a 'democracy.' Vietnam doesn't have the framework to challenge either effectively. 4) Not super, but again not terrible. The main thing is income distribution, not GDP. It may mean less iphones but doesn't necessarily mean less Huaweis, inside the mainland a Huawei is only about 60% the price you see in USA and doesn't represent a major drop in quality of life. 5) This is more a function of capital control I feel. They are a long long way from panic-flight ala Venezuela. Expats at this point are more luxury expats. Lots of other asians immigrate into China for a better life. Regardless, the China diaspora is already huge, and largely welcome in every country the immigrate to.
- lacampbell 7y agoPeople here are very dismissive of 1, but IMO they are being short sighted. Dictatorships are brittle, their power is extremely secure, up until it isn't. When the communist party rule does end, I think it will happen quicker than people think and catch a lot of people by surprise. Not willing to stick my neck out with a prediction though. For 2), I think the answer is yes. Chinas rapid transition from a low to a middle income country was remarkable, but I think the zeitgeist got a bit too excited about it (just as they did with Japan 30 years ago). I don't see any contenders to US economic power in the near future - China will be competing with India, not the US.