9 ms·
The U1 chip in the iPhone 11 is the beginning of an Ultra Wideband revolution?
- yodon 7y agoIt will be interesting to see how the U1 chip fits into Apple's widely expected 2020 AR glasses rollout
- caseyf7 7y agoI really hope Apple can show enough restraint to not make these glasses cameras or video recorders like Google glass.
- kgwxd 7y agoHow would they augment reality without a camera?
- selectodude 7y agoMake the screens transparent.
- wongarsu 7y agoEverybody has transparent screens on their AR googles, but how do you overlay information over real objects if the device has no clue what real objects exist and where they are? Without cameras you are restricted to being essentially another screen for your smartphone.
- swebs 7y ago>the device has no clue what real objects exist and where they are The technology in the article solves that
- umeshunni 7y agoEh, no. UWB solves the problem of locating yourself in relation to other UWB devices. It doesn't help you identify non-UWB devices (like a wall) that AR glasses might want to know about.
- caseyf7 7y agoThere’s a big difference between a camera used in real-time for AR vs a camera recording everything to disk and sending it to the cloud for analysis and data mining.
- judge2020 7y agoMy only guess is the glasses screen not relying on a camera and something like soli would be used instead of a camera for detecting air interactions. https://atap.google.com/soli/ https://atap.google.com/soli/
- wongarsu 7y agoIt pretty much has to have cameras for working AR. The MS Hololens has 6 cameras. Any solutions have to be software-side, like an external indicator light when images are saved in some form. I think Google Glass attempted that too.
- rowanG077 7y agoThis is a technical impossibility right now. Any inside out tracking will need at least one camera, multiple if you want it to be good.
- goodcjw2 7y agoI think the interesting question to follow up is: "why not camera"? Is it intuitively bad? How bad? When weighing against the benefits, is camera still worth it? I'm not 100% sure, just a couple random points: 1/ The first concern pops into my head is having a recording device nearly always on. In reality, there is no way you can prevent people to take photos and/or videos using smartphone when something interesting is happening in the public. It takes less than 5 seconds for people to take the phone out of their pockets and start recording. Then what's the real difference between camera on the face or camera in the pocket? 2/ The Glass-Hole issue. People always blame the camera as the ultimate evil. I'm not that sure. Remember, the original Google Glass was basically a piece of not-that-useful-to-put-it-nicely gadget that costs $1500. Honestly, back then, I thought whoever is buying those stuff that just overpaid nerdy douchebags (I'm thinking that way mainly because I cannot afford it). I'm not sure having a camera is the biggest issue; but having a camera is probably the biggest issue that you can publicly talk about. 3/ Trust issue, i.e. whether Google/Apple/FB are secretively collecting those video feed. Or even worse: what if the business model of future AR products depending on collecting those video feed.
- mewse 7y agoWhen someone is holding up their phone or actual camera to take a photo, that’s very visible and obvious to everyone in the area what they’re doing, and social feedback can be delivered if the usage is inappropriate. That’s very different from an accessory like glasses, which are typically on somebody’s face all the time, whether or not they’re being used for photo functionality, with a hidden camera constantly pointed at whoever they’re talking to or whatever they’re looking at. You may never know that a photo or video or other recordings of you, of your property, of your company secrets, of national security, etc are imminent or already taking place. “What’s the real difference” is kind of absurdly obvious, yes?
- goodcjw2 7y agoApologize if I didn't make my idea clear enough. Seems there are two topics here: 1. being able to use a camera & 2. being able to conceal a camera. My originally argument is focusing on point 1: people can already _use_ smartphones to take pictures and to record videos as easily/convenient as using a wearable camera. On the point 2. I totally agree with you, wearables will make it easier to conceal the camera and that is a bad thing. I guess the takeaway here is that the camera isn't the problem, the problem is being able to conceal the camera.
- john_minsk 7y agoI really hope they can figure out how to get camera record full day without recharge...
- tobsmagoats 7y agoThe tracking tags are still pretty interesting, could see apple succeeding with a "tile" like device.
- macintux 7y agoMy Tile died but I’m waiting for Apple’s solution. Hopefully for Christmas.
- itgoon 7y agoIf they put the tech into a keyfob, as suggested by the article, does that mean I would never lose my keys again?
- dpkonofa 7y agoI think that's exactly what this means, friend. /me cackles loudly
- judge2020 7y agoI guess it depends on if UWB devices can detect the location of beacon devices regardless of whether or not they specifically integrate with the "finder device"'s manufacturer. IE would Toyota and others have to add some code to work with Apple's chip, or can every device find other devices in beacon mode? (Another hurdle is if Apple limits what you can do with the chip as a developer, since they've done this for their NFC tech)
- bluedino 7y agoHopefully manufacturers can take advantage of it faster than they have adopted CarPlay...
- ehsankia 7y agoYou can already get a Tile and attach it to your keyfob, but yeah this would bring higher precision.
- gruez 7y agoTile does it, but it's essentially an active beacon, which isn't really privacy friendly as it allows your movements to be tracked. Apple's innovation here seems to be doing it in a privacy friendly way https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20129942 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20129942
- crooked-v 7y agoApple leaks and patents suggest that they're even aiming to have distributed location recovery, e.g., you lose your keys in a store and turn on 'find my keys', some random person's iPhone detects them and pings Apple, and Apple pings you with the location.
- tlb 7y agoUWB is essential for secure vehicle unlocking. Bluetooth isn't, because it can be relayed. It'll give Apple a nice integration point with your new car. For scooter rental, it'll be way smoother than opening an app and scanning a QR code. You can just step on the scooter and go. (My wife hates the QR-code scooter app experience so much that I generally unlock both scooters under my own ID when we're going around together. Fun fact: there are geocoded low-speed zones in Paris, where it limits the scooter to 10 kph in some crowded pedestrian areas. Fine. But when you unlock two scooters with the same phone, it uses the GPS location of the phone to decide when to limit or un-limit the speed. And a lost Bluetooth connection can leave it stuck at low speed. But I digress.) UWB will also improve the ergonomics of contactless payment. With the current system, you have to hold your phone really close to the reader for a few seconds. UWB could allow an instant gesture. EDIT: removed fatuous intro
- Nextgrid 7y agoCan't the relay problem be solved by having time of flight measurements as any relay attempt would inherently take more time than what a direct communication would? I'm pretty sure that's what they're doing with the macOS Apple Watch unlock.
- tlb 7y agoYes, time of flight is what UWB measures. But Bluetooth isn't suitable for measuring TOF to a useful accuracy. (I'm not sure what the Watch unlock feature is using.)
- icanhackit 7y agoIt feels like this is the key to unlocking useful AR [1] for low powered, lightweight headsets. If the heavy lifting for locating and interacting with objects in 4D space is done with UWB, you don't need to do too much computational heavy-lifting - reducing bulk, increasing available space for batteries and reducing battery draw. [1] Right now I can't really see a killer app for AR, something that would make you super-human enough to want a layer of abstraction between you and the real world. However if I could remotely interact with objects through walls, like turning off a lamp in a bedroom or seeing where my wife is and opening up a audio chat with her so that we're not yelling to hear each other, all of a sudden the trade off of having to charge and wear another device seems less annoying. All of a sudden you have powers not unlike a sorcerer.
- ctdonath 7y agoKiller app: ambient information, especially face recognition. Think "thought bubble" information appearing over anything you might want to know about. I'm lousy with names, would be nice to see names over everyone I should know.
- crooked-v 7y agoOne line of thought I've pondered here for scifi settings is people being able to share their currently playing music that way, like a tiny virtual radio station.
- mastazi 7y ago> UWB can also determine the angle of arrival of the radio signals by measuring the phase shift this reminds me a bit of how VORs work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VHF_omnidirectional_range https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VHF_omnidirectional_range
- willshepherdson 7y agoI expect indoor navigation to be a very powerful, especially the U1 chip is combined with the existing Indoor Maps functionality in Apple Maps: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/maps/overview/indoor-maps/ https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline...
- nickysielicki 7y agoHow does this deal with multipath? This article is all hype and no explanation.
- neaanopri 7y agoUWB deals with multipath by having very short pulses. The direct path is always faster, so the "true" pulse is the one which arrives first.
- Gibbon1 7y agoIt's been 10 years since I think the last attempt at UWB failed to gain traction. But I think you can use a rake receiver with UWB to combine the multipath components.
- zaeem 7y agoThis is perhaps a more detailed answer - https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-new-Apple-U1-chip-and-why-is-it-important/answer/Brian-Roemmele?ch=10&share=7e467f08&srid=Pi3 https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-new-Apple-U1-chip-and-why-...
- offmycloud 7y agoCould someone who understands the radio technology please explain why using time-of-arrival and phase tricks with existing WiFi and Bluetooth signals is "wide-banded" in any way?
- varenc 7y agoWiFi channel width is 20 MHz or 40 MHz. UWB has 500MHz channels. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_UWB_channels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_UWB_channels
- jsjohnst 7y agoWiFi channels can also be 80MHz (which my laptop is currently connected at) and 160MHz (which is still a bit rarely supported), but your point still stands.
- Throw7634959 7y agoThe wider the bandwidth the faster the rise time of each 'pulse'. The UWB standard allows for a known preamble sequence upon which a particular symbol is designated the ranging pulse. By each pulse having a rise time in the picoseconds it allows for an exact time of arrival to be measured. Exact timestamps can be recorded on each side of the transmission giving the final bit of information needed to calculate tof. edit: clarity of last sentence
- DrTung 7y agoDoes this mean Bluetooth is dead, if UWB can do all the stuff that Bluetooth did?
- gilgoomesh 7y agoI have no idea if this could replace Bluetooth but even if it did, Bluetooth would not be "dead". Bluetooth has enough inertia that it will be supported for the next decade.
- ohnope 7y agoMy theory on why they didn't elaborate on U1 / announce the (rumored) object tracking tags: they need better U1 chip penetration geographically before making any promises. Once a bunch of iPhone 11's are out there, they can further test the new product in a more realistic setting, and make adjustments if necessary. There could be some critical flaw that may need reengineering and they won't want a repeat of AirPower. For instance, if they released the new object tracking tag with iPhone 11's, it would be a bad user experience because U1 is not spread out. Better to wait until the U1 geographically saturates to their standards before releasing it. They can still talk about U1 in regards to e.g. new AirDrop capabilities, and in other marketing-level generalities.
- csande17 7y agoThere's an even more compelling reason why Apple's waiting a while before announcing the tracking tags: crowdsourcing. At WWDC this year, Apple announced that all iOS devices would begin reporting nearby devices' locations back to Apple. U1 probably only works at relatively close range, so they want to wait until their "crowdsourcing network" includes enough devices for long-range tracking to work. (IIRC they aren't going to let users prevent their devices from contributing to the network, so it's just a matter of waiting until everyone has the latest iOS update.)
- madeofpalk 7y ago> all iOS devices would begin reporting nearby devices' locations back to Apple Just to clarify for others - its not that all iOS devices will report the location of all other devices, but rather "lost" devices will emit a (BLE?) signal, which nearby Apple devices will report its location back to Apple.
- ejstronge 7y ago> Just to clarify for others - its not that all iOS devices will report the location of all other devices, but rather "lost" devices will emit a (BLE?) signal, which nearby Apple devices will report its location back to Apple. How would a lost device know it was lost? The Wired piece on this suggests that all devices are always broadcasting their location: https://www.wired.com/story/apple-find-my-cryptography-bluetooth/ https://www.wired.com/story/apple-find-my-cryptography-bluet...
- Zenst 7y agoUWB may well end up the USB of wireless for tech as it has many uses.
- kccqzy 7y agoI haven't really been this exciting for a new technology on my phone for a while. Am I just drinking the UWB hype kool-aid it is this actually revolutionary? So far it is difficult to tell but I guess we'll see.
- patsplat 7y agoUWB scales poorly. There's a limited number of channels. Ad hoc range finding requires a call and response. However. The range finding is accurate. So long as one is dealing with a few devices, it is incredibly effective. It's not going to be GPS for the house, but it does make proximity triggers reliable.
- colordrops 7y agoWhat's the upper limit though? Wouldn't a half dozen devices placed at known coordinates around the house be enough to do indoor GPS?
- patsplat 7y agoThere's 6 channels, and I think a high / low setting to get a total of 12. With indoor positioning, the anchors aren't positioned as precisely as GPS satellites, nor do they have the same quality clocks. Thus time of flight is done with a call and response per device. It was hard to setup positioning for more than 1x device... remember that 1x device is range finding to 4x anchors. Am sure these problems can be solved, but in the near term think this is more about precise distance rather than position.
- randyrand 7y agoyou’d think hundred of devices could share a same channel though. duty cycle is really small.
- TheAceOfHearts 7y agoCould you give some rough numbers? The definition of "a few" varies heavily depending on the context.
- dillondoyle 7y agoCan someone explain the privacy implications? Is this part of the new always on Find Phone network? Does apple respond requests from LE to 'find person x'? Is there similar random UUID protections built in (e.g. change MAC address frequency)?
- jdnenej 7y agoNo need to worry. Apple told us they won't track us.
- rahuldottech 7y agoI get that Apple has a better rep than most other companies when it comes to user privacy, but that still doesn't mean that we should take everything that they say at face value. As users, it is up to us to stay vigilant and ensure that Apple is doing as promised.
- jdnenej 7y agoMy comment was satire about how apples proprietary systems offer us no more than some PR persons comment saying it's all ok.
- justinclift 7y agoSure. They might not track people, but if they ever share the user data with external places it's a moot question.
- m463 7y agoI would hope for (but probably will not get) a switch to turn this off. The problem is that apple is playing both sides. It wants things to be attractive and convenient for both users and businesses. For example, although they are a privacy company, they don't advertise bluetooth beacons and deep linking to their users.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoI don't know, the Decawave DW1000[1] has been out for a couple of years now and the revolution hasn't happened. Perhaps there is another missing piece to the puzzle. [1] https://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/decawave-limited/DW1000-I-TR13/1479-1001-1-ND/4499860 https://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/decawave-limited/D...
- function_seven 7y agoFrom the article: > Imagine a whole-home audio system moving music playback through multiple rooms based on the location of an individual listener. Hell, why stop there? Imagine that same audio system not only activating different rooms as you move through them, but also adding the appropriate delays to each audio channel to make sure they arrive at your ears in sync. That'd be pretty neat.
- Whinner 7y agoBill Gates had the room activating thing back in the 90s. He talked about it in his book The Road Ahead. https://www.digitaltrends.com/home/the-awesome-technology-inside-bill-gates-mansion/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/home/the-awesome-technology-in...
- cheschire 7y agoI can imagine Tim Robbins describing this tech as “primitive.”
- alt_f4 7y agoImagine this, now substitute "audio system" with "hellfire missile-equipped drone"
- divan 7y agoNot sure if UWB-enabled devices are also capable of sensing spatial position of other devices (i.e. phone A is on the left of the phone B), but I'm already envision how this can be used to create screen-to-screen file moving feature – some sort of Avatar-like UX: https://imgur.com/8O89CXK https://imgur.com/8O89CXK
- yoz-y 7y agoAccording to their ad copy it should be able to do it. To quote from the iPhone 11 page: > The new Apple‑designed U1 chip uses Ultra Wideband technology for spatial awareness — allowing iPhone 11 to understand its precise location relative to other nearby U1‑equipped Apple devices.
- cstross 7y agoShort-term and small scale, Apple really needs to add UWB tracking, at least a beacon you can locate, to the next generation of AirPods. (Signed: someone whose spouse "can't find my airpods, I was sure they were in this bag …") Thereafter: full inventory control and location of all your e-waste-to-be?
- zeristor 7y agoOr finding them on the train tracks of the New York subway: https://www.macrumors.com/2019/09/03/lost-airpods-nyc-subway-train-tracks/ https://www.macrumors.com/2019/09/03/lost-airpods-nyc-subway...
- georgedotin 7y agoThis will really help a a lot in tracking things real time for AR apps
- Myraly 7y agoA rotating scheme that makes it impossible for the wrong actors to track you.