10 ms·
Americans' fear of losing their jobs grows
- intopieces 7y agoMy fear never went away. As someone who graduated at the very beginning of the Great Recession, I have a constant feeling that this cannot be forever.
- jurassic 7y agoI'm right there with you. I rode out the recession in graduate school and I've been waiting for the sky to fall pretty much since the time I got my first good tech job in 2014.
- aswanson 7y agoYup, it will. It is only a matter of time. Have to expect as much and plan accordingly. That's reality in this day and age.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- commandlinefan 7y agoI graduated in 1995, at the peak of the dot-com boom. I'm still pretty much always in fear of losing my job: there's always somebody willing to do it for less.
- mywittyname 7y agoEspecially now with the record enrollment in CS/CE programs over the past 5-10 years. The industry has been awash with fresh talent for the past few years and I don't see it slowing down.
- bonoboTP 7y agoMaybe it's different in the US but in Europe companies still struggle to find good job candidates. They get tons of applications of course but they aren't good/experienced enough. Basically many companies' bottleneck is hiring.
- mywittyname 7y agoThe past two companies I've worked for had nearly as many interns as FTEs on some teams. My current company has about 1/8th of the building dedicated to engineering intern cubes, and they are packed in like sardines too. When speaking with former colleagues, the topic of interns often comes up. I had drinks with some last week who mentioned her team had so many interns that some FTEs needed to double-up to manage them all. It could be regional. When I was coming up, internships were rarely a thing. I was never one and hadn't even seen an CS intern until a few years back. Seeing companies go from 0% to 40% of engineering staff as interns over the course of four years is pretty striking.
- Ancalagon 7y agoThat sounds like disaster waiting to happen. Just thinking about my skills as an intern vs. my skills now: good luck to that employer when, 3 years down the line, most of the interns and current FTE's have left and the code is unreadable.
- rubicon33 7y agoDude. I beg of you, to stop repeating the propaganda that big tech so desperately wants you, and everyone else to believe. There is NOT a shortage in developers. There NEVER WAS. Big Tech simply couldn't stomach the rise in salaries that we saw between 2005 and 2017/2018. This all comes down to cost. There's plenty of talent not just in the US, but abroad. But big tech continues to see a need to drive prices down, and profits up. The best way to do that? Pay employees less. Trust me when I say that programming is a blue collar job in 10 years. Big tech has done a phenomenal job convincing even engineers, that the pool of talent is "so small" that their job couldn't possibly be at risk if everyone and their mother gets a CS degree. Good luck to you, if that's your mindset.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoI don’t think 1995 was the peak of the dot-com boom. It was just starting out then, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dot-com_bubble https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dot-com_bubble The peak came in 2000, just before the bust (gradual rise, hard fall). I went to grad school after graduating in 1998, I was lucky enough to miss both recessions (I was in China in 2008). Now I’m jobless during a boom :). But I guess, as always, the best way to protect yourself is to be at the top of the tech curve (this is a double edge sword if you specialize in something that isn’t currently hot).
- scruple 7y agoEven prior to that, many of us watched our parents _very unceremoniously_ lose their "job for life" jobs in the 80s and 90s. The illusion of loyalty to an employer and job security went up in smoke with those layoffs, for me personally.
- foenix 7y agoAnd statistics don't apply to the individual. I'm a 3rd generation programmer and watched my own father get the boot by his company just because they wanted to "restructure to Chicago". 27 years at that job -- it defined where we put our roots down. I really enjoy the people I work with, but I never take stability for granted. Ensuring I'm always updating my resume and taking a couple interviews a year is part of my professional ritual. If it were feasible, we'd move elsewhere, but we both have good social networks and roots here -- which is arguably more "expensive" to a working couple in their early thirties than gold.
- noneeeed 7y agoSimilar experience here. 25 years at a "job for life" and he got a carriage clock. A couple of years later we move to the other side of the UK. A couple of years later they shut down that office making dad redundant. I am under no illusions about any company I might work for, no matter what size or how much I like the individuals I work with or for.
- intopieces 7y ago>it defined where we put our roots down. Sadly, I don't feel like I will ever put my roots down in a place. I'm of the mind that I always have to ready to pack up and move to the new office if means I can keep my job and lifestyle.
- cylinder 7y agoraised by immigrant parents who were self-employed I was always scared away from the corporate world for this reason. They were constantly talking about how people can get laid off very quickly. They tried to steer me into medicine for this reason (recession proof. Didn't take). I'm now in a corporate setting and aim to be self-employed again soon enough.
- manfredo 7y agoI graduated later, when unemployment rates were dropping continuously. I still have this fear, even though the justification for it is not well founded (I've been able to get internships for all of summers, and had full time offer in hand before the start of my senior year). It seems much more likely to me that this is an instinctual fear. Our jobs are our primary mechanism by which we get the resources we need to survive. Of course we'd worry about losing that, even when times are doing well. The cavemen that didn't have this fear probably starved at higher rates.
- tathougies 7y agoThat is a good feeling to have because it cannot and will not. It has been the same for every generation whether they felt it or not
- simplecomplex 7y agoDo you have savings? If you had enough saved to spend a year looking for another job, would you still live in fear?
- WorldMaker 7y agoStatistically "everyone" who graduated in the Great Recession is still a year or two at least (and in some cases far more) from paying off student loans. Statistically we're a generation of nothing but debt with no savings to fallback on because we've never had a long enough "peace time" of growth to pay back our creditors. It's wonderful to imagine some hypothetical reality where you had enough saved to survive an entire year looking for a job. What privilege you would have! Presumably you have no health problems because CORBA is broken again and the current administration crippled HCA guarantees because who needs affordable health care when you don't have a current employer. It feels like you might as well wish for a Pegasus to fly you to all your job interviews while you are at it. We've all earned our cynical stripes here, but thanks for offering a lovely fantasy.
- simplecomplex 7y agoYou’re not responsible for your generation, just yourself. You didn’t answer my question about savings. Are you saving? If not you can and you should. If you don’t have savings the first step is to come up with a budget. Send me an email if you need help it’s in my profile.
- threwawasy1228 7y agoCan't budget very well, or save at all if you make exactly how much your base-level living expenses are bud. I'm still eating ramen at the end of the month. What am I supposed to be budgeting here? Count out my bowtie pasta pieces more precisely to budget them? My generation simply can't live like this, it isn't sustainable, and isn't realistic to expect professionals to live in poverty. I barely have enough business casual clothes to make it through a single week cycle and buying more is a huge expense to me. Something bigger is going to have give, maybe a recession is what is needed to show people how unrealistic this is.
- botwriter 7y agoHow much of this is the mainstream media and left-wing politicians trying to put doubts on the economy? That way the US can have a recession so the left can get rid of trump.
- spamizbad 7y agoIs the US economy so fragile that it can be thought-crimed into a recession? This fear has nothing to do with any politician or political party and everything to do with the trauma from ‘08
- ScalaFan 7y agoThere are some people with trauma from 2000/2001.
- 40acres 7y agoAll economies are subject to this because markets are based on trust and faith. If enough doubt is generated then the markets will reflect that in a downturn.
- spamizbad 7y agoIsn't there a pretty big gulf between losing faith in a market and thinking there's a recession around the corner? A breakdown in trust in a market would more closely resemble an economic collapse rather than a a few quarters of contraction, wouldn't it?
- jp555 7y agoI think you're underestimating the amount of randomness at play in complex interconnected systems like markets.
- rifung 7y ago> Is the US economy so fragile that it can be thought-crimed into a recession? I think those in Behavioral Finance would argue yes, at least to a certain extent. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/07/shiller-self-fulfilling-prophecy-of-recession-could-ruin-bull-run.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/07/shiller-self-fulfilling-prop...
- VonGuard 7y agoThe United States is weird in that you are defined, here, by your job or profession. TV shows put your job title under your name when you appear on them. People's first question is always "What do you do?" at parties and at events. In other countries, this isn't always the case. When I'm in Europe, people ask where you're from, what's for dinner, and what's happening? The question of your job is rarely asked up front, I find. It's how Americans define themselves, which, in the end, generally comes down to how the US doesn't value human life, only the potential earnings thereof.
- dominotw 7y ago> When I'm in Europe, people ask where you're from, what's for dinner, and what's happening? The question of your job is rarely asked up front, I find. Meh, I don't agree with this observation. This is true in america too. > US doesn't value human life It does. US is the biggest aid provider in the world. You can put a cynical spin on the motivations behind that but even a regular US citizen gives more to chairty than anywhere else in the world. US is also the biggest pharma innovator in the world. Since we are throwing out wild theories. here is mine. Software kinds in europe are jealous of high wages in USA and try to justify their pitiful pay by attributing themselves with some sort of moral superiority. " I might be poor but atleaest I have a good heart"
- Ididntdothis 7y ago" It's how Americans define themselves, which, in the end, generally comes down to how the US doesn't value human life, only the potential earnings thereof." I agree with your observations but this conclusion goes way too far.
- Miner49er 7y agoMaybe from that one data point. But in general, it's very clear that the U.S. favors GDP over human life. There's plenty of data and examples to prove it. The price of medication, the cost of healthcare, homelessness, the people we kill in the Middle East, etc.
- deleted 7y ago
- mitchus 7y agoInteresting that the two data sources used concern housing and consumer credit, not employment.
- Someone1234 7y agoEmployment figures don't tell you much about consumer confidence. Decreased employment would be an indicator of an actual economic downturn, this is focused on people fearing an economic downturn which is very different.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Circuits 7y agoIs this any wonder with how incredibly expensive things are getting? In a year, in my state, I make 2x as much as the average single person and I am struggling to save money. These other single persons must be living in complete squalor. Most of my extra money goes to student loans but even without them I wouldn't exactly be raking in the $. I would probably only be saving around 18k per year. I have no debt outside of student loan debt and I live with roommates. I honestly don't understand how they are surviving.
- matz1 7y agoThat's why we need universal basic income
- Someone1234 7y agoUBI is an interest concept but it wouldn't solve this. If you go from e.g. $5K/month (job) to $1K/month (UBI) you'd still have to adjust your living standards (and if people expect to lose their jobs, even with UBI, they'd still make more cautious decisions which would still trigger the same indicators). UBI and other social safety nets are "good ideas." But they aren't a one size fits all solution to every problem. It won't restore consumer confidence.
- matz1 7y agoStill better than going from $5k/month to $0k/month. No solution are one size fit all solution to every problem. What is your point?
- Someone1234 7y agoThat with UBI we'd still be in exactly the same position as now? Your point was that UBI would somehow play a relevant role in low consumer confidence. I am pointing out that may not be the case.
- matz1 7y agoHow is exactly the same? $1k>$0k. With basic income, I for example for sure will be less anxious if i know that if I lose my job now, I still have some income.
- dragontamer 7y agoUS Workers have unemployment checks, food stamps, and Medicaid. No one is hitting $0 / month unless you're out of a job for over 6-months (when some unemployment benefits run out). If a lot of people are unemployed for over 6 months unemployment benefits can often be extended by the legislature.
- glitchc 7y agoI think this reflects a general erosion of trust between employers and employees, which I blame Corporate America for. It used to be a tacit agreement in the workforce that if you worked hard, the boss and the company would take care of you. This illusion has been shattered first by the employers (outsourcing, at-will employment, gig economy), and now the employees (ghosting, switching firms without notice). The lack of trust on both sides engenders the feeling that any promotion is unlikely and every position uncertain, so folks always have one foot out the door. Once the trust is gone, it takes a long time to rebuild, so even if corporations changed tack now, it's likely that employees will continue to distrust them for the foreseeable future. Edit: Clarity.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe employees also chose to patronize businesses that outsourced and offered lower prices. Other than forcing Americans to buy products made with American labor, what options are there?
- bluntfang 7y agoChoice is a really funny word when it comes to employees. Most employees don't have a "choice" if you look a little further beyond the surface.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoBy employees, I’m referring to American customers, who opted for the low prices at Walmart versus their local store. My point is employers didn’t have a choice either, if they wanted to stay in business. This is the end result of arbitrage opportunities due to differences in nations’ wealth.
- bluntfang 7y agoPoor people don't choose to not support their communities. They've been put in a position to be forced to "choose" between supporting their local store vs having a warm, safe(ish) place to sleep for their families.
- pysxul 7y ago> Americans' fear of losing their jobs Unemployment rate in the US is only 3.7% (July 2019) Employee fears that they are replaceable and the truth is that most of them are. So they are working hard, they perform, they are productive and economy is better than it has ever been! I am french and where I worked it is nearly impossible to fire a long-term contract employes (CDI). Most of them do less than the bare minimum at work. Then entire company is taking a hit. So IMO the fear to loose their job is a great boost!
- SnarkAsh 7y agoUnemployment rate is an essentially-fraudlent statistic. Changes in the labour force participation rate are more revealing: https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000
- bzbarsky 7y agoZooming that graph out to start in 1980 shows that there is a trend there that did not start in 2009 but closer to 2000. Also, that specific graph is of limited utility because it is the over-16 labor force participation rate, not the prime-age one. Which means that as the age distribution skews more toward post-retirement-age people it will automatically drop. Which is exactly what's been happening, by the way, as the baby boomers have started retiring. This rate will also drop as more people go to college instead of starting work immediately after high school. https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2017/employment-population-ratio-and-labor-force-participation-rate-by-age.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2017/employment-population-rati... has a chart that lets you see a breakdown by age group, sort of, for 2007-2017. Note the huge differences in the rate between the age buckets and where the overall rate falls compared to the 25-54 rate.
- fdavison 7y agoBecause we are near full employment and they now have jobs to lose? From this morning's Washington Post: "For the first time, most new working-age hires in the U.S. are people of color" https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/for-the-first-time-ever-most-new-working-age-hires-in-the-us-are-people-of-color/2019/09/09/8edc48a2-bd10-11e9-b873-63ace636af08_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/for-the-firs...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tempsy 7y agoI don't think I've ever felt scared about losing a job, though I think it has always been a part of my personality to reject being slotted into some corporate machine and have always had one foot out the door of a job, so to speak.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThe September who is hiring thread is much smaller than last year’s. Employers are cutting back.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cubano 7y agoI've stopped fearing losing a job because, frankly, it happens so often as a remote webdev I basically never stop looking. In fact, I am currently unemployed after I rather unwisely completed a 20-week job in 11, and I was literally given no notice and a week's pay. So now its back to the Upwork slog and trying to convince someone (again) that yes, since I have been a professional programmer for 25 years I can for sure fix those database issues and add those rather pedantic features to your app or website. Like I often want to shout..."Do you think I'm lying when you read the years and years of experience on my CV that literally lay out me fixing the same issues that you have, and much much more complex ones as well?" Trying to pin the "blame" (whatever that even means) will get you nowhere...it's like blaming the "wind" when a hurricane comes and blows off you roof. Yes, the "wind" did cause your roof to fly away, but it was simply the endpoint for a huge number of directly connected and unconnected forcess, too many to measure, that were in place for that bit of wind to do its dirty work. I feel the only sane way to look at work nowadays is to always have an eye out for opportunities that may work career-wise, and get better at interviewing. [edits]
- wccrawford 7y ago"Do you think I'm lying when you read the years and years of experience on my CV ..." Yes, they do. Because so many people do lie on their resume and hiring a liar is a very costly mistake. It doesn't matter that most people tell the truth... The ones that lie are just too much of a risk. When my father was looking for a new job, he would walk into the interview and tell them all the problems they were having. When they asked how he could possibly know that with so little information, he would tell them it was because everyone who was hiring him had those same issues. This helped reinforce that he understood the issues and had fixed them in the past. Perhaps some similar prescience on your part could help you answer their questions quicker and easier? It's almost a party trick, but it really did seem to be effective for him.
- partyboat1586 7y agoWhy don't you contract days for bigger companies? Day rates are very high for someone with your experience. Also you can usually negotiate to be on site only some days of the week or even month
- outside1234 7y agoThe recession is coming - save some money for the winter...
- readhn 7y agoWell, we had amazing 10 year bull market run so far. just look at your 401Ks performance from 2009 to 2019! 1-2-3 year shake down / or a mini recession would be technically completely normal and totally expected. at least by me. get your things/portfolios in order fellas ;)
- tathougies 7y agoGiven how low unemployment is, it makes sense there are more people who fear job loss. In the past, more people were unemployed and thus could not feel afraid of losing something they didn't have.
- la12 7y agoMeh, America could solve its jobs problem in five minutes. Simply limit the labor supply but that's not what capitalists and the popular political establishment (read democrats) wants. I guess this clear opinion might not even be popular on HN, so I find it hard to sympathize with all these people who are now scared of losing their jobs and they turn around and keep voting for implicitly increasing labor supply. Remember, the bigger pool of labor, the lesser pay and more desperate people will be but it will certainly help the politicians win elections easier because of lock-down on voting patterns from newly arrived low skilled immigrants.
- simplecomplex 7y agoSave some money, then you don’t need to fear losing your job. Fear of losing your job is a result of poor personal finances. There’s no need to fear if you have your personal finances in order.
- 033803throwaway 7y agoThis is great advice in general, but FU money gets tricky when you have negative interest rates on deck. We are one stock market pull back away from catastrophe even for wealthy boomers. Interesting times.
- H1Supreme 7y agoApparently you've never lived "paycheck to paycheck" before. I can remember a time in my life where I would be so happy just to have an extra $100 at the end of the month. This was living with roommates, never going out, and bringing my lunch everyday. No frivolous spending at all. God forbid you have to fix your car, or some other unexpected expense. That $1,000 it took you 6 months to save is gone in an instant. While I'm much better off these days, lots of Americans live the way I just described. You can't save what you don't have.
- simplecomplex 7y agoI have. If someone can’t save a few hundred bucks a month something is wrong. Let’s use Dallas TX for example, even just waiting on tables you can make at least twice rent. Forgo a car and you’d be able to pocket $500 / mo or more if one was frugal. It’s even more critical to save when at the bottom of the economic ladder, because it allows one freedom to pursue or invest in other opportunities (paying for school, moving, weathering unemployment, etc.)
- threwawasy1228 7y agoThis is an absolutely incorrect and unrealistic estimation for the majority of the people waiting tables. I started writing up a long thing calculating this out and stopped myself. I am going to assume you are commenting in good faith, so I'll just state the correct information would be extremely quick for you to research with a few google searches..
- newnewpdro 7y agoWe live in a disposable world now, that extends to both employees and corporations/employers. Everything's far more ephemeral than it used to be.
- ramphastidae 7y agoI always thought job loss was something that happens to other people until I got laid off despite being an ‘A player.’ Now I assume it is just a matter of time no matter the role. This is the reality for everyone under at-will employment. Even if you are the best at your job, outside circumstances like changes in strategy, funding and leadership can make you a target for ‘managed offboarding.’
- mikelyons 7y agoWhat other types of employment are there?
- ramphastidae 7y agoContract employment? Unions?
- mikelyons 7y agoCan't contracts always be terminated or union workers laid off?
- ramphastidae 7y agoIt depends on the specifics of the contract and the union's collective bargaining agreement, but plenty of these types of agreements exist where employment is not considered at-will.