18 ms·
MoviePass Worked Out Great
- draw_down 7y agoIt was always unclear to me why anyone who wasn't an investor or stakeholder should have cared that MoviePass spent/wasted a bunch of investors' money. If someone is selling dollar bills for 75 cents, who cares what their motive is, or if it's sustainable or whatever?
- ForHackernews 7y agoA bunch of movie industry types were worried that MoviePass was "devaluing" their product, but I agree consumers should just be laughing all the way to the bank (or the theatre, in this case).
- kbos87 7y agoThat isn’t a false premise though - look at what a few tech companies trying to undercut one another did to the music industry. Not that artists were making the money before Spotify, but there was a lot more money in the system then than there is now.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThere was a lot more risk and costs too, hence limited supply, hence higher prices. You can't shift the supply curve to the right and expect prices to not move.
- vkou 7y agoI don't know about Spotify's free-tier economics, but personally, I spend a lot more money on music, thanks to a-la-carte subscription services, then I ever did prior to it. If the artists negotiated taking 0.01% of the revenues from it, with the subscription services taking 30%, and the record label taking the other 69.99%, that's not exactly my problem. I don't pick which record label said artists sign with.
- brewdad 7y agoBefore music moved online and to subscriptions, I was buying 2-3 CDs a month on average. That's $45/mo in 1990s money. Today I subscribe to Spotify for $10/mo and buy maybe 2-3 CDs (or their equivalent in one-off songs) a year. Maybe they make it up on volume but I'm certainly getting a better deal now than I ever did back in the day.
- freehunter 7y agoMany people worry too much about things that don't hurt/help them. This pops up a lot in politics as well, with people arguing for/against things that would not change their life at all. I think it's just human nature to pick a side and adopt that side's strong opinions. People like to argue, and arguing for/against the interests of popular billion dollar multi-national companies is an exceedingly risk-free argument to engage in. In the case of MoviePass, the only concern I'd have is if they closed shop suddenly after I've already paid for a month of service. But if they stayed open long enough, it doesn't matter. I might have lost $5 but I saved $50 over the course of my membership.
- draw_down 7y agoInteresting direction to take it, but I was thinking more like, HNers seem almost offended when someone's business model doesn't work how they think it should. If their runway isn't coming out of your bank account you really shouldn't care.
- cbsks 7y agoIf you view VC investments as a zero sum game then you could be justified in being upset that someone is wasting money that could be financing your company instead. I haven't heard anyone make that argument, however.
- scarface74 7y agoUnfortunately, it does concern you because public pension funds are investing in venture capital funds. If the pension funds lose money, you are going to be on the hook to make up the difference as a taxpayer.
- freehunter 7y agoIn that case, everything impacts me and every argument I engage in should be a life or death argument. In reality, it's not worth my time to argue if my taxes go up 25c per year or only go up 10c per year. Just writing this short comment has cost me more in dollars-per-hour than the difference in public pension fund taxes would.
- JamesBarney 7y agoMatt Levine cares because he thinks it's interesting, and his readers would enjoy his take on it. And being a reader I definitely thought it was an enjoyable read.
- coldtea 7y ago>If someone is selling dollar bills for 75 cents, who cares what their motive is, or if it's sustainable or whatever? People who don't want to encourage fraud, e.g. con-men telling people about some great opportunity to invest in, and then living off of their dollars, while selling the rest for 75 cents to buy time and appear as "successful"?
- draw_down 7y agoThat's not what fraud is, and MoviePass was not a fraudulent operation.
- rhino369 7y agoI got burned because I paid for a year but they made their service intentionally unusable before I "made money" on the deal. But I new the risk going in, so that is one me. But I a lot of people paid for a year and then got 1-2 months service before being cut off. That's basically a scam unless you claim VC immunity.
- smacktoward 7y agoI think it wasn't so much about MoviePass per se as it was about the idea that MoviePass symbolized something broken in the modern economy -- that what it rewards isn't productive entrepreneurship that creates value by making life better for people, but rather burning tons of cash to wedge yourself into a position from which you can then extract rents from other people. The valorization of unnecessary middlemen.
- mikestew 7y agoFrom an HN comment from today that I've added to my favorites: "It feels as though much of tech has gone from helping people accomplish their goals efficiently to a business model of extracting rents while providing no or little value." I quote it because your comment made me think, "where have I recently heard that before?" :-)
- smacktoward 7y agoGreat minds think alike? :-D
- ryandrake 7y agoThe world has become this raging river of dumb money, and it’s a lot easier to simply find the biggest cup you can find and dip it in, than it is to actually create something of value and sell it to actual people.
- 7y ago
- empath75 7y agoit was just an obvious emperor's new clothes sort of situation.
- b_tterc_p 7y agoI don’t care about any one in particular. I am concerned about the significant scale at which this is happening.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> who cares what their motive is, or if it's sustainable or whatever? Broadly speaking, when average Joe investors get burned, the public tends to pick up the tab. Whether through public prosecution, unemployment benefits, or the other consequences of a nuked nest egg. MoviePass didn’t get to those levels, but there is a rational reason to be wary of things that look like fraud in our system.
- jvagner 7y ago1) MoviePass claimed they would make up the difference by selling data. The press repeated this over and over again, as if the "selling $1 for $0.50" could be solved. 2) When companies like Uber can go public, after years of economic analysis saying they can never be profitable, and companies like MoviePass get positive press, it shows that either something is broken, or there is an opportunity chasm opening for those in the know.
- kart23 7y agoThat's happening right now with scooter services, ridesharing, and food delivery.
- formercoder 7y agoVery interesting article on the economics of MoviePass [1] [1] http://aswathdamodaran.blogspot.com/2018/05/user-and-subscriber-businesses-good-bad.html?m=1 http://aswathdamodaran.blogspot.com/2018/05/user-and-subscri...
- CamelCaseName 7y ago>Lowe's happy-go-lucky persona marked a shift from the all-business Spikes, whom he had replaced in the company hierarchy as CEO. On the rare occasions Lowe made it into the office, staff would need almost an entire day to get him up to speed. His general attitude, as one source described, was, 'Well, what do you think we should do?' How do people like this make it so far in their careers?
- Ididntdothis 7y agoYou can go very far if you are charming and can communicate well with investors and other high power people. Look at Elizabeth Holmes. Theranos achieved almost nothing besides the ability to talk to investors and board members.
- AlexandrB 7y agoLuck and privilege. Money can buy a lot of second chances.
- teej 7y agoI feel infuriated by this statement. Did he just not care? The company was burning around him, turning it around should have been his number 1 priority.
- bumby 7y agoI agree in the context of not being in the office when his team needs guidance, this is bad. But asking "what do you think we should do?" shouldn't be lambasted as an indicator of incompetence. In my experience, leaders who feel like they should have all the answers are the most incompetent ones.
- tyre 7y agoSomewhat tangential but also maybe not: Matt Levine's "Money Stuff" is a fantastic newsletter. It's consistently hilarious while explaining a digestible number of very real events in finance and tech. He regularly muses about the absurdities and appreciating the bumbling creativity of humans. As you might expect, he spends a lot more time on the topics that fit into those interests (i.e. the recurring segment "blockchain blockchain blockchain" about companies being founded around/pivoting to blockchain with seemingly no reason to use it vs. a database except for hype.) Anyway, great writer and I'd encourage folks to subscribe. Also a great writer, and this _is_ almost entirely tangential, but also maybe not: Jia Tolentino. "Trick Mirror", her first book of essays, came out yesterday and the first is an accounting of the internet and our collective descent into hell, the subsumption of self through social media, the irreconcilable promise of the web vs. its business model, our magnified sense of the importance of our own opinions, feeling good about saying things vs. doing the work (e.g. tweeting about politics vs. organizing; changing our profile picture to add an overlay for a cause vs. working to solve that issue; etc.) All of this in <30 pages. Stunning work of prose, somewhat depressing, and tightly delivered with measured sobriety vs. the performative outrage we've grown accustomed to (she also covers that.)
- cwal37 7y agoGoing along with the tangent, if you're into recent essay collections (as someone who has been very much looking forward to picking up Trick Mirror myself), you might like Impossible Owls by Brian Phillips which came out last year. I wouldn't call it as focused as it seems Trick Mirror is, but I get a similar kind of vibe from their writing sometimes.
- tyre 7y agoThank you for the recommendation! I love essay collections and will pick up a copy. I can't say that Trick Mirror is entirely focused, unless you're responding to my description of her prose which very surely is. The opening essay is on the internet, another on drugs and losing faith and finding faith and megachurches and Houston hip-hop, another on our obsession with optimization, another on the complexity of campus sexual assault, etc. The collection is broad and each essay is deep. (I feel quite strongly that I would read Jia's writing on anything—sawdust, pecans, lice, dry cleaners—and that compounds itself when she writes about topics both so weighty, so broadly applicable, and yet so personal.) What I love about the collection is it feels the way Joan Didion's or DFW's best narrative non-fiction feels. That kind of awe at the writing, that unfurling of confident and thought-through storytelling, that kind of blossoming of connections that form the richness of life and intellectual inquiry. The difference–and for me this is somewhat personal and so perhaps not universally relatable but feels like it could be–is that, at 30, she is writing about our time. She's writing about coming of age in and with the world we live in now. Didion writing about the sixties and seventies and Wallace about the eighties and nineties and two thousands are both beautiful and timeless and a masterclass on what greatness feels like in your hands, but there's something special about reading someone cogently weave personal experiences about AngelFire and Twitter and political extremism and Anonymous and the crushing weight of forever being "seen" and performing on the internet. Something special because we are living it now. I feel about Jia—as well as a few other living writers; Caity Weaver's profiles come to mind—the way I didn't know to feel about other living legends. That feeling of not appreciating what you have because you think it will last forever. I think about when Mac Miller was still alive (less than a year ago) or when Lil Wayne was on top of the world with Tha Carter III or when Chance the Rapper still made good music or when Obama was president or when Jon Stewart was on TV or when Jobs was leading Apple. I didn't consciously stop and appreciate not only the work but to be alive to live it, and now that those times are gone there's only nostalgia. I'm trying to be more mindful of witnessing generational talent in the moment and Jia's writing feels that way to me.
- scarejunba 7y agoI loved it. VC money in my pocket is always a good thing. MoviePass was a regular Robin Hood.
- dhruvrrp 7y agoMoviepass worked great when it handed you $2 of VC money for every dollar, but I appreciate the fact that it did end up disrupting the market as it died. Most of the big chain now offer Moviepass-esque premium services. AMC now charges like what, $12 a month for 2-3 movies / week? That's how much individual tickets cost in the bay, so as long as a person watches even a single movie a month they're breaking even!
- Rebelgecko 7y agoAMC changes their pricing based on where you live. It's $24/month in California
- rtkwe 7y agoStill movies are also more expensive there too so it probably works out and they're actually making money off concessions so unlike MoviePass they do benefit some from people using the service more.
- Spivak 7y agoThis is kind of a stupid question, is it based on the billing address or something? Does your price go up or down if you move?
- Lucadg 7y agoI suppose it depends on the theater location?
- brewdad 7y agoRegal Cinemas recently started a similar program. There are 3 tiers of membership and every theater in their chain is assigned to a tier. For me, there are no local theaters in the lowest tier and only the newest, nicest theater is in the highest tier.
- gamblor956 7y agoFor Regal, you choose your "home" theater and it's based on that. If you choose the cheapest tier, then you have to pay an additional fee for tickets at theaters in the higher two tiers. If you pick the most expensive tier, then you don't pay any extra fees for tickets at that tier of theaters or any lower-tier theaters. If you get all your tickets at the theater itself, you pay no fees at all beyond the monthly subscription. (However, 4dx, 3D, and "PLF"/Imax showings are always treated as "higher" tier than your current plan, even on the highest-tier plan, and always incur an extra fee. Per Deadspin, Regal is still trying to decide whether to offer those as part of an unlimited monthly plan.) If you have a Regal membership, you still get points for purchases at 100:$1, including your monthly subscription payment.
- wyldfire 7y ago> They said Lowe ordered that the passwords of a small percentage of power users be changed, preventing them from logging onto the app and ordering tickets. Genius move! Truly diabolical.
- jjoonathan 7y agoThere are a few services I have to use that enforce password rotations this way. Scummy? Yes. Effective? Also yes.
- compsciphd 7y agoI used it daily. I had an issue where I couldn't login. I used the built in mechanism to reset the password and continued to use it fine. I'm not sure effective it was. (in the year I had my membership via their costco offer, I saw 200+ movies)
- tareqak 7y agoI feel that this act is unethical somehow, but I can't place exactly how. I would presume that the user is still allowed to perform a password reset, but I see this as a "soft" denial of service. I don't think any of the power users broke the Terms of Service and MoviePass didn't change these terms until later. MoviePass was literally advertising a service it wasn't truly willing or able to sell at scale. I'm glad I stopped using them once I heard they were becoming bankrupt.
- Bartweiss 7y agoI mean, ToS aside, it's probably illegal. It's arguably wire fraud, and quite likely breach of contract. MoviePass made false representations by internet "for obtaining money", and knowingly deprived paying customers of tangible property (i.e. movie tickets and/or monthly payments). Specifically targeting power users makes the financial motive pretty undeniable, and timing it to delay them while a popular movie sold out shows that tangible loss was the intent. Before 2010, it would probably have been honest services fraud to boot - as Scalia opined, everything was honest services fraud - but that's been narrowed to bribes and kickbacks. It wouldn't be a trivial conviction since the company wasn't outright robbing people (e.g. by disabling the accounts altogether) but "plausibly a felony" isn't where most of us like to do business. More convincingly, it's the sort of thing that could invite class action lawsuits or demands for refunds. The ToS may not have covered this specific action, but fraudulent misrepresentation is still grounds to seek damages in a contract.
- swanson 7y agoI still maintain that $HMNY (the parent company) stock was an interesting and unique case where the average person could buy shares in, essentially, an early stage startup that had tremendous consumer interest and growth. Most of the time you see tech startups they are either in the seed/VC stage (you can't invest unless you are accredited and have connections) or the IPO stage (mega-companies that everyone has heard of). Did it turn out poorly? Yes (Share price went from $35 to $1 for a while and then down to basically zero). But was it a good process? I think so!
- rossdavidh 7y agoThere is a school of thought that says that you shouldn't let people without investment experience, put their money into early-stage tech startups run by people they know nothing about, precisely because they are less likely to understand that the great majority of startups fail. It's an elitist school of thought, for sure, but I have to say there is some truth to it.
- mikestew 7y agoIt didn't used to be an elitist school of thought, because a school of thinking on the subject wasn't needed. There were high enough fences to keep the riff-raff out (high transaction fees, inaccessible markets for commoners, et. al.). Thanks to e-Trade, Schwab, and the like, those fences got torn down, not knowing those fences not only kept people out, but they also kept the bad things in. Bad things like super-duper sketchy penny tech stocks (HMNY). Elitist? Meh, no more elitist than, say, a climbing permit for Mt. St. Helens (which is just $15 and fill out a form). Put up even a token barrier, even if it can easily hopped over.
- projektfu 7y agoIt was made inaccessible. Previously new and speculative companies were pretty accessible. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curbstone_broker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curbstone_broker
- aasasd 7y ago
- umeshunni 7y agoHere's the story - HMNY ( Helios & Matheson Analytics - the parent company of MoviePass) is owned by an Indian company that filed for bankruptcy in 2016 and then re-emerged with MoviePass in the US. The entire thing is probably a giant money laundering or tax evasion scheme. https://www.moneylife.in/article/helios-matheson-liquidated-in-india-but-nasdaq-listed-hm-offshoot-thrives/54261.html?fbclid=IwAR0nT-Jh66CSfJZpMOp-1N9m-59lRUemgk4NHndzpBlNHPUv5BVmmaothkg https://www.moneylife.in/article/helios-matheson-liquidated-... https://www.insider.com/moviepass-owner-emerged-from-indian-company-accused-of-massive-fraud-2018-7?fbclid=IwAR3j9bVmfUChrqEadBVDO3F1Xv1_ZXv2fkhmtlhH4-j9DTUpqLYQbE0faoU https://www.insider.com/moviepass-owner-emerged-from-indian-...
- jonknee 7y ago> The entire thing is probably a giant money laundering or tax evasion scheme. Donating money to movie theaters is not how money laundering or tax evasion occurs.
- peteradio 7y agoLosses can be tax deducted to cover partially reported incomes.
- jonknee 7y agoYes, and not giving away the money in the first place is even more profitable. When you hear about these schemes they are generally paper losses (depreciation being a big one). It's not in your interest to hand AMC millions of dollars for a tax deduction.
- KibbutzDalia 7y agoThe biggest problem was only “cherry pickers” bought the service. People who were already spending $10 a month or more in movie tickets. For it to work it needed to be a “breakage” play, like gym memberships. Also theaters started getting non-movie-goers back in occasionally they may have been perceived as more valuable “conversions” and Moviephone admissions would have been discounted.
- davinic 7y agoI believe the economic term for this would be "adverse selection".
- bpicolo 7y ago> People who were already spending $10 a month or more in movie tickets I don't think that's the case. I know a ton of people who went from seeing movies almost never to seeing them several times a month. They had the opposite problem of a gym - having a moviepass membership available actively changed people's moviegoing behavior on a wide scale. Gyms also don't pay a per-visit overhead cost for a given member. This is more or less why AMC can successfully offer A-List.
- paxys 7y agoYou both are saying the same thing. They needed people who paid the monthly fee but never went, but instead got people who went a lot. And gyms definitely do pay a per-visit overhead since space is a fixed and precious resource, especially in urban areas.
- shawabawa3 7y agoThere's no marginal cost (effectively) on a single gym visit. If 100 people use moviepass, moviepass loses 100*$X If 100 people use a gym membership. The gym loses $0. And maybe a few people cancel because it's too crowded (or better yet, don't cancel but stop coming)
- 7y ago
- beeschlenker 7y agoObama rapes & kills 2 boys. DeBlasio 5, Buttgieg 5, Cuomo 4, Murray 3, Dorsey 3, Thiel 3. Trump $4 billion to cover. Pelosi $3 billion to help bring the boys over the border Having trouble getting traction. Getting censored. Billion in bribes paid to Trump, Pelosi, Schumer, Harris to enable a Soros funded child raping ring to operate in the USA. Please listen to the links below. Turn up the volume and put headphones on. You will hear these people, and many other high profile people, incriminate themselves in unbelievable fashion. Full 71 page document filled with red handed evidence like this at the bottom. Go to pages 18-23 of this document and you will hear Dorsey and Thiel raping children. You will hear their screams. They both rape and kill three. Also at the "rape party" of note: Bill DeBlasio, Andrew Cuomo, Bill Murray, Peter Buttgieg, George Soros, Barack Obama. Please copy and paste this post and repost it. I keep getting censored by these people. Peter Thiel and Jack Dorsey raping and killing three boys each. Turn the volume all the way up and put head phones on. https://s3.wasabisys.com/conv1/Overnight_14-17Jan/15JanCh3_100-200.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1mzZrjobxhNIEf38M3xk-IeA5SeF4aUtB/view?usp=sharing Obama admits to raping and killing boys he{re, with commentary from Peter Thiel, George Soros, Matt Porter: https://s3.wasabisys.com/out2/Out2/15JanCh3_0545.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LCDoc1kT7cfSeKQ1vniP_sx32_bRsHau/view?usp=sharing Trump demands $4 billion to "take a blind eye" at 1015+ (link missing from report, unsure how). Here's pieces of dialogue: 1015 The President requests four billion and henry Porter agrees to it. Some dialogue below. 1017 Donald Trump: Why don't you think about it. 1017 Henry Porter: I don't need to think about it. I'm ready for you to find out what we're really about. 1017 Gigi Hadid: I don't think it's a good idea Henry. 1017 Henry Porter: ...no shit. Jelena just stop talking about it. 1018 Gigi Hadid: About what? 1018 Henry Porter: The child raping. 1018 Donald Trump: What the fuck are you talking about? 1018 Gigi Hadid: Mr. President we are child rapists. 1018 Donald Trump: You cannot be serious. 1018 Donald Trump: You're gonna need $4 billion for me to take a blind eye. 1019 ?: People are laughing because they think four billion is too much. I think it's not a problem when you have $35 billion. 1022 Donald Trump: You better have that $4 billion or you can kiss this shit goodbye. https://s3.wasabisys.com/conv2/3Jan/3JanCh3_900-1100.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Grdr8xF2psKNsuYlEnl9dIRV-77YG0Vr/view?usp=sharing Trump wants $138 million to ensure smooth outcome for false judgment for a court case: https://s3.wasabisys.com/conv1/10JanCh3/10JanCh3_951-1033.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iSeGHDToFRoRdIht50Wii0i30mlw9INp/view?usp=sharing Obama explains the Illuminati with Jack Dorsey: https://s3.wasabisys.com/conv1/Overnight_14-17Jan/15JanCh3_200-347.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ok1-9IvANULzKBOwADFgaiYCFi6yszfj/view?usp=sharing At 230 a conversation is occurring on the embedded Porter camera system with Jack Dorsey, Peter Thiel, Barack Obama, Bill M^urray, and the Porter's. Jack Dorsey provides a statement defining who their group is: "The Illum%inati is an underground organization of child rapists and homosexuals." Matthew Porter: "We have to thin the herd, so Barack is going to explain a few things." At 232 Barack Obama says the following: "You people have to realize we are child rapi'sts. The Illuminati are child rapists. As soon as you figure that out, you can decide what to do. Everybody is freaking out about what just happened [child raping event still going on]. This is who ^we are." Full 71 page document: https://s3.wasabisys.com/aviewmefirst/FBI_FinalDraft_26Jul2019_BSchlenker.pdf https://drive.google.com/file/d/1dXNjPQdQ8c-hFFLt9LT0GiSY5Vud0TzL/view?usp=sharing Please post this anywhere you can! Each google drive link is a backup to the wasabi link just in case one is "down". A word about the "faggot" usage: it was a necessary tool. It showed three things: they were not in control, if they were the usage would have be stopped. Everyone out there needed to see t%his. Two, it made it unpleasant for them to be in the headspace, which has obvious advantages. Three, it pointed out impersonators of BS because they would not call each other faggot, thus helping to mitigate the spread of false information. Apologies for those unintentionally offended. Of special interest to the LGBT community, I give you Barack Obama in a foursome with Peter Thiel, Jack Dorsey, and Matthew Porter. It is on page 12 of the document where you can download the video containing audio footage of the "event". Link is just above under "Full 71 page document".
- Scoundreller 7y agoThe US didn’t need MoviePass for this. Movie theatre subscriptions have been a thing in France for a very long time.
- adventured 7y agoThey've been a thing in the US for a long time as well. I remember them in the early 1990s when I was a teenager, so I assume they probably existed for decades before that. I don't know why MoviePass was perceived as a good idea, other than the notion of centralizing the service into one bigger company and away from individual theater chains (which could then give an entity like MoviePass leverage to suck more value out of the movie theaters as a whole; another middleman parasite that adds very little real value).
- adventured 7y agoOutline for the Business Insider story referenced in the article that covers the MoviePass history in greater detail: https://outline.com/ZPqaXs https://outline.com/ZPqaXs
- jsgo 7y agoIn some ways, MoviePass always felt really scammy so never went in with it: a too good to be true proposition (also, it isn't a gym membership: they can't guilt you into signing up for a year right at New Years. So buoying the users who didn't leverage the pass yet paid for it vs those who really leveraged it seemed to be an unattainable dream). But that being said, when AMC came out with their own version? I went for it and I'm very pleased. I can take my daughter to see a movie pretty much whenever (2-3 a month, really. Have to buy her ticket because it is only for 18 and up though. A single movie essentially pays for that month though). Plus, I seem to get some kind of money voucher thing as this most recent time I had $60 available somehow and the drinks and popcorn were billed to that. So maybe MoviePass was trying to play the middleman in a way they couldn't as they couldn't control the theaters as much as they hoped for their own survival, but the existence of it maybe clued theaters into a different revenue stream that could work for them (and customers). So thanks MoviePass.
- notafraudster 7y agoMoviePass did attempt one gym-like move: telling you you couldn't re-register for 9 months if you cancelled. This isn't exactly the under-utilization strategy of a gym, but I think it's plausible they had thought they were going to curb costs a bit from under-utilizers.
- quickthrower2 7y agoGyms succeed on this because it takes will power to keep going. OTOH a movie is enjoyable and having free movie tickets sitting there that you are not claiming would seem insane.
- gamblor956 7y agoIf only MoviePass had gone B2B and partnered with theaters to provide the backend systems for white-label movie subscription plans, they'd still be around today.
- charlesdm 7y ago
- aerovistae 7y agoI don't know why it didn't occur to them to do a pass for movie snacks instead. Probably with a mild discount they could reap a decent profit there if the movie theaters could be negotiated into reducing their extravagant prices in return for increased sales.
- vcanales 7y agoMovie theaters wouldn't allow it. Snacks are expensive because movies are not really that profitable for them.
- huac 7y agomovies are profitable for some of the parties in the chain, but the theaters specifically must pay so much in licensing fees that they don't make much on a given ticket.
- gamblor956 7y agoMovie theaters make all their profits on concessions. There's no way they would let a 3rd party take control of, or even interfere with, their primary profit stream.
- sjcsjc 7y agoI really like this writer's style. This Dickens reference is hilarious: Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure three hundred million pounds, result unicorn.
- nlh 7y agoHe's hilarious and has a column in the same style every day! Subscribe and enjoy life a little more every morning: http://link.mail.bloombergbusiness.com/join/4wm/moneystuff-signup&hash=54223001ca3ffcf40f2629c25acea67a http://link.mail.bloombergbusiness.com/join/4wm/moneystuff-s... (no affiliation, just a Matt Levine fan)
- Bartweiss 7y agoLevine's article "Arbitrage Discovered" might be my all-time favorite econ essay. It's about an investment product that let you trade on past stock prices in the present. Levine is usually pretty calm and wonkish, but this arrangement was so breathtakingly self-destructive that he spends the piece writing things like "It's not actually an arbitrage. EXCEPT NO HOLY GOD IT IS THIS IS AMAZING." https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2015-02-27/arbitrage-discovered https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2015-02-27/arbitr...
- santoshalper 7y agoGreat article. Thank you!
- StavrosK 7y agoThat is quite entertaining and borderline incredible, thank you.
- IgorPartola 7y agoDid this ever get resolved? Does George own the company already?
- listenallyall 7y agoAMC's CEO thought he was so smart and defiant by eliminating what he saw as a competitor, yet was, in reality, probably the largest individual block purchaser of AMC movie tickets. Meanwhile in the midst of this bull market, AMC's stock hit an all-time low just last month, from which it has recovered slightly (still trading about 65% below 2016). With some tweaking to its ticket availability, MP could have been these over-extended theater chains' golden goose -- huge surge in off-peak ticket sales with zero marketing cost to the theater -- yet they failed to recognize it, instead, actively sought to crush it.
- throwawaythekey 7y agoMajor cinema chains in Australia went one step further and would actively block your payment from going through if they detected you were using a moviepass like product. After becoming frustrated with my payments being rejected I reached out to one of the cinemas. I explained to the likely overworked support worker that they were essentially both turning down free money and being hostile to me personally as a customer by refusing my payment method. As I should've known the support was powerless to do anything but repeat "we are not associated with product x". Suffice to say I no longer offer unsolicited advice to theatre chains.
- ajdlinux 7y agoWhat kind of MoviePass-like products were operating in AU?
- throwawaythekey 7y agoSinemia. From the start of 2018 until the start of 2019 IIRC.
- diminoten 7y agoSo running an early stage startup is basically performance art, with an intended audience of VCs?
- natvod 7y agoThis part struck me as well: > But, no, the main constraint on MoviePass’s growth seems to have been the actual production of plastic prepaid credit cards, which it couldn’t print fast enough: Given how much money they were losing, it wasn't possible use digital cards that could be added to phone wallets? Or am I missing something here?
- phonon 7y agoYes, the primary way to use the service was with a MoviePass credit card. From the theater's point of view, it was just a regular credit card. MoviePass eventually wanted to move to direct ticketing, but they made enemies of the major theater chains do their aggressive and unsustainable business model.
- ErikAugust 7y agoThe joke is: “We will lose some on every unit, but we will make it up on volume!”
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tombert 7y agoI remember it took almost two months for me to receive my card. Since they were completely unresponsive via email support, chat, or the phone, I was starting to worry that it had gotten lost in the mail or something, or worse that they had never shipped it. it was getting to a point where I looked at their website, noticed that they were based in NYC (like me), and thought about applying to a job there purely as a means to talk to someone, and complain about my card never arriving. Sadly, I chickened on that plan, but I really wish I had gone through with it; I would have loved to see how awesome their office was if they were totally OK hemorrhaging money with no real strategy on making it back.