18 ms·
Supercentenarians are concentrated into regions with no birth certificates
- howard941 7y agoDid anyone pull the full study? Does it come out and take the supercentenarian-ship claimants to task for lack of probity?
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoThere is a 'full text' tab in the linked article.
- crazygringo 7y agoIt explicitly mentions pension fraud -- who wouldn't want to retire a little earlier? > The hypothesis that these relatively low literacy rates and incomes are generating age-reporting errors and pension fraud, and therefore remarkable age records, seems overlooked. ... > This issue presents a substantial problem for remarkable-age databases, embodied in a deliberately provocative, if seemingly absurd, hypothesis: > Every ‘supercentenarian’ is an accidental or intentional identity thief, who owns real and validated 110+ year-old documents, and is passably good at their job.
- simias 7y agoInterestingly the holder of the record for oldest human being remains Jeanne Calment and there's a lot of evidence for her record. Wikipedia mentions a theory that her daughter might have assumed her identity in the 1930's[1] but it doesn't appear very credible. So I guess it is possible to live that old, just extremely unlikely. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment#Scepticism_regarding_age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment#Scepticism_rega...
- gamblor956 7y agoThere's a very detailed analysis of Calment showing that it is most likely that the daughter replaced the mother, since the facial features of Jeanne Calment as a middle-aged or elderly woman don't match her earlier photos at all...but are a splitting image of her daughter's facial features. Also, a lot of her photos feature her wearing clothes that were not in style at the ages she appears to be in the photos--but would have been right for her daughter. And there's the bit where she keeps calling her putative husband her father... And finally it's just plain weird that her son-in-law (i.e., her daughter's husband) moved in with her after her daughter's supposed death and lived with her in a common-law relationship for decades. But it makes perfect sense if it was actually just the daughter assuming her mom's identity for tax evasion purposes.
- simias 7y agoI replied to this in a similar comment above, I disagree that this analysis is very detailed, or at least that it's more detailed than the evidence in favor of Jeanne being who she claims to be. I looked at the picture comparisons, it's not like they had 20Megapixel HDR cameras back then, the quality is not great. Besides only a handful of pictures exist, with a lot of variations in lighting and exposition. It's possible that it's true, but it's not exactly overwhelming evidence in my opinion. >And finally it's just plain weird that her son-in-law (i.e., her daughter's husband) moved in with her after her daughter's supposed death and lived with her in a common-law relationship for decades. Wikipedia says: "By the 1954 census, she was still registered in the same apartment, together with her son-in-law, retired Colonel Billot, Yvonne's widower; the census documents list Jeanne as "mother" in 1954 and "widow" in 1962. Frédéric Billot lived next door with his wife Renée." Doesn't make it sound quite as weird as you make it out to be.
- gamblor956 7y agoWikipedia says: "By the 1954 census, she was still registered in the same apartment, together with her son-in-law, retired Colonel Billot, Yvonne's widower; the census documents list Jeanne as "mother" in 1954 and "widow" in 1962. Frédéric Billot lived next door with his wife Renée." Doesn't make it sound quite as weird as you make it out to be. That is extremely weird, and the simplest and most logical explanation is that Yvonne was committing estate tax fraud to avoid a ruinous tax on her inheritance of the family store. Besides only a handful of pictures exist, with a lot of variations in lighting and exposition. It's possible that it's true, but it's not exactly overwhelming evidence in my opinion. Yes, but pictures of the two of them are available and the older pictures of Jeanne clearly match the younger pictures of Yvonne. Jeanne would have needed to have had face surgery or some serious facial structural changes to have the face she did in her old age. The simplest explanation, again, is that Jeanne died young(ish) and Yvonne pretended to be her. And again, this also explains why for decades, despite otherwise being sound of mind and coherent, she kept referring to her husband as her father in casual conversation.
- benj111 7y agoI wonder if you get the opposite in regions with relatively better child benefits? Child benefits lead to shorter lifespans...
- ipsi 7y agoA little bit? It does say that many _could_ be committing, e.g., pension fraud, but that the primary issue is with the data, and the reliance on documents as the "source of truth" of these claims, and this seems to accurately sum it up: > This issue presents a substantial problem for remarkable-age databases, embodied in a deliberately provocative, if seemingly absurd, hypothesis: "Every ‘supercentenarian’ is an accidental or intentional identity thief, who owns real and validated 110+ year-old documents, and is passably good at their job." > This hypothesis cannot be invalidated by the further scrutiny of documents, or by models calibrated using document-informed ages. Rather, invalidating this hypothesis requires a fundamental shift: it requires the measurement of biological ages from fundamental physical properties, such as amino acid chirality or isotopic decay. > Until such document-independent validation of remarkable ages occurs, the type I error rate of remarkable human age samples will remain unknown, and the validity of ‘supercentenarian’ data in question.
- sebringj 7y agoElephant in the room...no birth certificates.
- dvduval 7y agoI also have been thinking of ways that I can extend my life. I'm not sure this is what I'm looking for. Perhaps a therapy animal such as a dog or a cat... It seems like the probability of an accident occurring with an elephant in the room would be very high, and only a small percentage of people would live past a hundred.
- wnevets 7y agoI guess that means the secret to a long life is the lack of government paperwork.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoBet they claimed there benefits nudge nudge wink Sorry to be cynical.
- supernova87a 7y agoHomer: "Oh Lisa! There's no record of a hurricane ever hitting Springfield." Lisa: "Yes, but the records only go back to 1978 when the Hall of Records was mysteriously blown away!"
- trumbitta2 7y agoI live in Sardinia. We have both birth certificates and supercentenarians.
- tyre 7y agoFrom the first paragraph of the abstract: > In Italy, which has more uniform vital registration, remarkable longevity is instead predicted by low per capita incomes and a short life expectancy. > Finally, the designated ‘blue zones’ of Sardinia, Okinawa, and Ikaria corresponded to regions with low incomes, low literacy, high crime rate and short life expectancy relative to their national average.
- trumbitta2 7y agoThe crime rate is low, the literacy level medium-high. I wonder if any of the authors ever came to Sardinia.
- tyre 7y agoDo you have citations for this? They are specifically pointing out the "blue zones" where a high percentage of supercentenarians live. It's possible that the average literacy of Sardinia is separate from these pockets. I mean I'm guessing the authors didn't just sit around and say, "hmm, I wonder what the literacy rates are in Sardinia? Let's say low." I guess it's possible though.
- gpderetta 7y agoThe article does not provide citation for Sardinian literally rates either (they make a claim only for some of the Japanese numbers). For Sardinia they only claim poverty (with a qualitative, non quantitative claim) and life expectancy which, if I'm reading the ISTAT tables correctly, they got spectacularly wrong. Also there are no blue zones within Sardinia. The demographic data is the for the all the provinces of the island.
- JPLeRouzic 7y ago
- brzezmac 7y agoso it's time for Carbon-14 then ...
- jerf 7y agoCarbon-14 datings works because once an organism dies, it stops exchanging carbon with its environment, so C14 stops coming in. Carbon dating any living organism will come back with "it died 0 years ago/hasn't died yet", give or take whatever details make it more complicated in reality than it is in theory, as it always is.
- iguy 7y agoIs there any dead carbon, like perhaps in the teeth? Have never heard of it being done, but would be neat.
- hobofan 7y agoTeeth mostly consist of hydroxyapatite, which doesn't contain any carbon. Not 100% sure, but for someone that just died, you might be able to do it with their brain, as brain cells are hardly ever renewed. For a living human I don't think there is any way that's non-invasive.
- garmaine 7y agoThat thing about brain cells not regenerating is a myth, btw.
- hobofan 7y agoCould you provide a source for that? I recently tried to read up on the topic and everything I found stated that brain/nervous cells are generally barely regenerated and can stay with you your whole life. Granted, most articles trace back to this source[0] from 1967, but if newer information exists, they've done a really bad job at spreading it. [0]: https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/bionumber.aspx?&id=101940 https://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/bionumber.aspx?&id=101940
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoBoy this may change some recommendations about the “blue zone” diets and lifestyles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Zone
- hombre_fatal 7y agoI doubt that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Zone#Characteristics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Zone#Characteristics Pretty standard, unanimous lifestyle advice. Stay social, stay active, not too much alcohol, lots of plants, avoid stress, don't smoke.
- graeme 7y agoDid anyone investigate if these traits differed from other regions in japan, italy, costa rica and greece? In particular back in 2005?
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoHow much of those are based on erroneous correlations based on blue zone data though? >In his book, Buettner provides a list of nine lessons, covering the lifestyle of blue zones people:[13] >Moderate, regular physical activity. >Life purpose. >Stress reduction. >Moderate caloric intake. >Plant-based diet. >Moderate alcohol intake, especially wine. >Engagement in spirituality or religion. >Engagement in family life. >Engagement in social life. We don't know which ones of those are real and which signify you live in a zone which has bad records for birth certificates.
- simonsarris 7y agoAlso what does "high vegetable intake" or "Plant-based diet" mean? These can mean wildly different things to different people. For example, how many people over 100 are lifelong vegetarians? Vegans? I bet the number is extremely small (or zero in the case of vegans, a term coined in 1944), but that's what many people think of when one says "plant-based diet".
- kranner 7y agoWhen the grandmother of, let’s say a friend, passed away at 96, I was surprised to note the local newspaper mention her age as 106, no doubt due to the political influence of said friend’s relatives. I didn’t realise at the time that this is a sort of thing people like to brag about.
- jfk13 7y agoYou don't think it was simply an arithmetic mistake by the editor of the local deaths column? Given a birth date of 19xx and a death date of 20xx, an off-by-10 error doesn't sound too far-fetched.
- kranner 7y agoThe family didn’t know her date of birth. They had an estimate of her year of birth because she’d said she was x years old when her first child was born.
- pieter_mj 7y agoI guess i'm gonna start planning moving to a no-birth-certificate region. Hoping the somewhat late move will still have a positive effect on my life- and healthspan.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoEasiest way to live past 100? Just say you did. 2nd easiest: use your grandfather's birth certificate.
- wavefunction 7y agoDealing with my somewhat prematurely elderly father of 73 and his issues (my gps all lived relatively heartily into their 80 and 90s) I have to conclude my options in a few decades will be self-limited to driving my car off a cliff if I can't upload myself into a robot husk. What I'm saying is that supercentenarianism seems heavily overrated.
- futureastronaut 7y agoWhy are those your options?
- BuildTheRobots 7y agoIn a lot of places around the world, assisted suicide isn't an option. Not the op, but after watching nearly all of my relatives loose their minds to dementia, altimeters (edit: mood swings can be a...) or something else in later life, the idea of being trapped in that state for any amount of time is terrifying. I know it sounds trite, but having a fast motorbike squirrelled away (even if it's entirely unrealistic in actuality, for a number of reasons) is surprisingly soporific.
- futureastronaut 7y agoAltimeters: Not even once.
- BuildTheRobots 7y agoI either need to stop using spellcheck when distracted or start wondering how early onset this might actually be o.0
- lostapathy 7y agoMaybe not a bad idea, though. Buddy of mine plans to take up skydiving when he retires so he can pack his parachute wrong when the time comes.
- 7y ago
- mktmkr 7y agoThere is also the reverse process: people who are older than officially recorded. When my in-laws came to the USA from Vietnam after the war they wanted to be able to work for a long time before anyone forced the to retire, so they just said they were 25 years old, an understatement of quite a number of years. Upheaval and displacement tend to wipe out government records.
- o09rdk 7y agoI kinda wondered that looking at the paper. It's hard to know from eyeballing such low numbers relatively speaking, but it seems like there's not only a large peak in supercentenarians born shortly before the introduction of records (suggesting erroneously reported very old age), but maybe also a smaller peak after the records. With name databases, there seems to have been a phenomenon where people retroactively created records when they were introduced (e.g., people registered for SSNs after the fact). Maybe there's something similar going on: people are overreporting their age when born with no records, but also are overreporting their age when they registered their birth after the fact. It's a bit hard to explain in terms of underreporting age, and the trends are such that I think they still largely support the authors' hypotheses in terms of relative overreporting and underreporting. But I agree there's probably more fuzziness here. The bigger issue for me that this raises are the perils of making inferences on outliers of any distribution. The further out you go on any characteristic, the more likely you are going to run into similar problems with errors, fraud, or unusual circumstances.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dev_dull 7y ago> When my in-laws came to the USA from Vietnam after the war they wanted to be able to work for a long time before anyone forced the to retire, so they just said they were 25 years old God bless your parents. I don’t care much for the immigration debate in our country, but we should be actively recruiting people like this.
- hollander 7y ago
- Finnucane 7y agoMan, I must be old--the first thing to come to mind was the Dannon yogurt ads from the 1970s with the old people of Soviet Georgia. And, at the time, Dannon actually caught some flack because there was no documentation of how old these people really were.
- lucas_membrane 7y agoDo not condemn those people as liars or frauds. They did what any sensible person would have done, avoided death by conscription during the Great War by assuming the identities of their older cousins, brothers, uncles and fathers.
- Finnucane 7y agoProbably some of them didn’t really know for sure.
- opportune 7y agoNote that the introduction of birth certificates in the US only reduced supercentarians, it didn’t eliminate them. I would be willing to accept that most are frauds, but I do think it is possible for someone to live to be a supercentarian. I have met a couple people who are around 100 who seemed healthy and had it all together mentally. I’m sure some decent percent of people in that position have the ability to live for another 10 years
- ajcodez 7y agoMy great-grandmother died a month before her 100th birthday. Born in California with valid records and survived her husband by decades. She was pretty active and alert considering her age well into her 90s. We would walk together on the grounds of her retirement home (she needed a walker) until the last year or so.
- svachalek 7y agoAbsolutely. My grandmother lived to 104. She had my mother when she was 45 and was still doing push-ups to stay in shape in her 80s. At her 100th birthday party, she blew out 100 candles in one breath. It's not hard to believe that at least a few people out of a billion could go well past that.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoOf course, but that isn't what this study is about or why it (and other's like it) are important. Researchers have spent tons of time trying to discover why certain areas are ripe with supercentenarians - what is it about their diet or environment or genetics or social structure. As a random person in the US, I have particularly heard about Okinawa in this regard. This study is strongly implying that the only thing special about those areas is their ability and desire to commit fraud.
- sandworm101 7y agoThe lawyer in me suggests removing that comment asap. Lying on immigration forms, no matter the reason or timeline, can be a big deal. The US recently setup a "denaturalization task force" to look for technical reasons to deny/deport and generally be evil towards immigrants who have done things like lie on immigration forms. But maybe you really hate your in-laws. "A United States Citizenship and Immigration Services team in Los Angeles has been reviewing more than 2,500 naturalization files for possible denaturalization, focusing on identity fraud and willful misrepresentation. More than 100 cases have been referred to the Department of Justice for possible action." (2018) https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-denaturalization-20180812-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-denaturali...
- marpstar 7y agoI see your point, but are there records to verify his claim? If not, what's the government going to do?
- BuildTheRobots 7y agoThe worry would be them saying "we have evidence of your x-in-law stating you lied. Prove otherwise."
- _jal 7y agoOh, I dunno, lock people up and/or deport them anyway? https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-citizens-ice-20180427-htmlstory.html https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-citizens-ice-20180...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- burkaman 7y agoWhatever they want to do. There is zero penalty or downside for them to falsely imprison someone for months or years.
- btilly 7y agoI am reminded of https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/study-questions-age-worlds-oldest-woman-180971153/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/study-questions-ag... which lays out the case that the oldest woman on record, Jeanne Calment, was actually her daughter Yvonne who substituted herself for her mother in 1934 to avoid inheritance taxes.
- gwern 7y agoYes, there's an interesting philosophical question here about burdens of proof and Humean 'extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence'. Calment's claim is to be the oldest person out of billions of people, and she is the oldest by a truly extraordinary margin - no one has even come close to reaching her record before or since. So, which is more likely: that her claim however improbable (someone has to win the lottery) is completely correct (and she simply had some unique luck or mutation enabling her excess longevity), or that some highly unusual (but still more likely than '1 in tens of billions') circumstance (such as a complicated tax & insurance fraud) has led to a mistake? Indeed, how would one ever be sure of such a claim, short of the isotopic testing advocated in OP - which will, incidentally, stop working in the future? (This is a general problem of priors and evidence and model uncertainty I think about occasionally: https://www.gwern.net/Modus https://www.gwern.net/Modus https://www.gwern.net/Littlewood https://www.gwern.net/Littlewood https://www.gwern.net/Mail-delivery#on-model-uncertainty https://www.gwern.net/Mail-delivery#on-model-uncertainty https://www.gwern.net/Research-criticism https://www.gwern.net/Research-criticism https://www.gwern.net/Everything https://www.gwern.net/Everything https://www.gwern.net/Turing-complete#on-seeing-through-and-unseeing https://www.gwern.net/Turing-complete#on-seeing-through-and-... )
- CommieBobDole 7y agoI really wouldn't say "nobody has come close" - she was 3 years older (122 vs 119) than the next oldest verified person, and around five years from most of the next top ten - most of them died at 117. If she was, say, 132, I'd be more suspicious, but 122 sounds more reasonable for statistical outliers in an incredibly complex process.
- crimsonalucard 7y ago>Instead of prompting skepticism, under the relatively safe assumption that smoking, drinking, poverty, and illiteracy should not enrich for remarkable longevity records, these contra-indications of survival are routinely ignored. In contrast, it could be suggested that the abundance of supercentenarians in these regions reflect high rates of undetected error. One bluezone is loma linda, california. Why was this not factored in this study. I find this study to be quite biased as well.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoI've wondered about this for a long time. Finally somebody investigated, and lo and behold, a good chunk of this phenomenon is simply the result of lying.
- thaumasiotes 7y agohttps://dilbert.com/strip/2013-03-07 https://dilbert.com/strip/2013-03-07
- tracker1 7y agoI would guess the biggest factors are very limited consumption of heavily refined foods (in particular sugar and refined grains) as well as some access to modern medicine (antibiotics, hospital births). edit: And, of course, there's a lot of fraud cases.
- golemotron 7y ago> Finally, the designated ‘blue zones’ of Sardinia, Okinawa, and Ikaria corresponded to regions with low incomes, low literacy, high crime rate and short life expectancy relative to their national average. As such, relative poverty and short lifespan constitute unexpected predictors of centenarian and supercentenarian status, and support a primary role of fraud and error in generating remarkable human age records. Or, bureaucracy kills.
- raverbashing 7y agoInteresting enough, the article doesn't mention that in a lot of places (and possibly a bit too long ago for any of those to be affected), baptismal certificates substituted for birth certificates Sure, there might have been some time difference between date of birth from date of baptism, but it was usually short enough (even if it might have been a couple of years)
- jobigoud 7y agoBut surely you are baptised after you are born so it would skew the data in the other direction.
- Animats 7y agoA few years ago, the government of Japan decided to have people visit everyone over the age of 100, to see how they were getting along and what they were doing right.[1] They found 231 cases where pensions were being paid out but the person could not be found. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/15/world/asia/15japan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/15/world/asia/15japan.html
- mikekchar 7y agoThanks for finding that link! I saw this on the news at the time and I've never been able to find something in English to talk about it. One of things that shook out from this is that they redid the longevity studies in Okinawa and discovered that people in Okinawa have the same life expectancy as everyone else in Japan (which is not much different than the rest of the world). All of those nutrition studies in the 70's were based on government census data -- which turned out to be massive pension fraud.
- wirrbel 7y ago> relative poverty and short lifespan constitute unexpected predictors of centenarian and supercentenarian status, and support a primary role of fraud and error in generating remarkable human age records So I think for lack of birth certificates I can imagine the underlying process of unregistered people not being aware about their true age. The claim that high poverty and crime rates produce such fraud feels prejudiced. also why would Sardinia be different in that regard compared to Sicily or poor regions on the Italian mainland? Also I would be interested in how many hypothesis these researches tested on the data set and on whether they performed proper adjustments of thresholds (bonferroni correction)
- rconti 7y agoAs far as I know, all of these records are maintained at the comune[1] level in Italy, so high crime/corruption in one comume might manifest itself differently from how it does in another comune. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comune https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comune
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> The claim that high poverty and crime rates produce such fraud feels prejudiced. I disagree. And note the claim was about "relative poverty and short lifespan". Seems very straightforward reasoning that those in relative poverty with shorter lifespans have much more incentive to falsify their age to be older than they actually are.
- chewz 7y ago> Thousands of Japanese centenarians may have died decades ago > The justice ministry said the survey found that more than 77,000 people listed as still alive in local government records would have to be aged at least 120, and 884 would be 150 or older. > The nationwide survey was launched in August after police discovered the mummified corpse of Sogen Kato, who at 111 was listed as Tokyo's oldest man, in his family home 32 years after his death. > Kato's granddaughter has been arrested on suspicion of abandoning his body and receiving millions of yen in pension payments after his unreported death. > Soon after came the discovery that a 113-year-old woman listed as Tokyo's oldest resident had not been seen by her family for more than 20 years. Welfare officials have yet to locate Fusa Furuya, who was last seen in about 1986. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20627021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20627021
- glandium 7y ago> 884 would be 150 or older. It is kind of disturbing that these people are officially thought to be that age, but that nobody had been looking them up before despite them literally, albeit theoretically, being the oldest people alive on Earth!
- aitchnyu 7y agoWinston Churchill had special shipments of cigars from India with associated paperwork. The paperwork persisted a few decades after Indian independence and his death. Depending on data keeping, it will take a crackdown to find suspicious pensioners.
- Merrill 7y agoOdd, since a birth certificate is not actually a valid proof of identity. There is no biometric associated with a birth certificate created in year X that can be used to prove that the baby named in it has grown up to become the person claiming that identity in year Y. An actual background check has to establish a chain of evidence linking the birth to the person being checked. This requires interviewing relatives, friends and acquaintances, collecting school and business records, drivers license records and any other public or private records.
- gvx 7y agoWhile true, doing such background checks gets a lot easier with documentation like birth certificates. I assume a large fraction of people who have considered committing this kind of fraud, have decided against it because they realised it would be relatively easy to investigate. (And I expect that places with birth certificates also tend to have a more consistent presence of other kinds of records, and a higher law enforcement budget for investigating possible instances of fraud, when compared to places without birth certificates.)
- Muromec 7y agoYou don’t really need a better budget if you have vital records of sufficient quality — just a routine procedure to cross-reference them when issuing identity documents. Ex-soviet countries would be fine example for that.
- Muromec 7y agoThe thing with birth certificates — it’s pretty difficult to backdate them or retroactively issue legitimate ones without rising red flags in process that would trigger some background checks. So you need to assume identity of real person living or dead, which is more an effort than flat out bullshiting about your age. And if you are assuming identity of other person, you cant simply snatch birth certificate and issue new id, but with your photo — if such id was issued before, it would be routine check to match photos. Alltogether it greatly limits, but not entirely eliminates this kind of identity thieft. It is however other story to assume same identity (name, dob) but different parents (altought with same names) for inheritance or immigration fraud. That is pretty much undetectable in some circumstances.
- mcculley 7y agoI found suspicious data when looking at voter records: https://enki.org/2018/12/07/finding-unusual-voters/ https://enki.org/2018/12/07/finding-unusual-voters/ https://quark.cards/voters/Florida/oldest https://quark.cards/voters/Florida/oldest
- dwd 7y agoI think the point is that any dietary or lifestyle recommendations to achieve a long life need to be reassessed. Do recommendations to reduce intake or intermittent fasting rely on unverified population ages? My personal take on living long is to get regular health checkups and seek medical care early if there are any issues. What do people like Queen Elizabeth, Warren Buffett, Rupert Murdoch do to remain healthy and still working at their age?
- aaron695 7y agoThis fact about Blue Zones and the fact it only just got pointed out shows an incredibly broken system. In both science and general information flow Something so simple should have been checked or questioned on the internet, and it should then have risen to the top as a concern. Not sure where it's broken. Real information doesn't float to the top on HN, but equally I've never seen this at all on HN. I think PG was wrong here, I never understood this comment fully https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4692598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4692598
- mandelbrotwurst 7y agoProof that bureaucracy kills!
- SomewhatLikely 7y agoAnother explanation could be that all the young people have moved away from the poorest areas and older people stayed and kept getting older. It depends if they are dividing supercentenarian population by today's population or by the area's population when they were born.
- rumcajz 7y agoOne thing I heard (not sure whether it's true) is that in Ottoman empire, when I child died, parents often used the his or her birth certificate for the next child. That way they could avoid all the associated paperwork.
- gpderetta 7y agoWhile I've also congettured in the past that at least a good chunk of extreme supercentenarians are due to anagraphical errors if not outright fraud, I do not think that the paper support the thesis well. For starter they do not have a global model, it seems that they handpicked different statistics for different areas that support their thesis (they do not even show anything concrete for Japan). Regarding Sardinia, their numbers seem actually wrong: looking at the raw Istat data the numbers for 55 year life expectancy for the Sardinian provinces seem in line with the rest of Italy (95-96%) putting Sardinia somewhere in the middle of the (quite tight) Italian distribution. It is possible that the researcher averaged the data over a longer period of time that I bothered to look is possible, but the paper doesn't discuss the methodology. Their fitting, p value not withstanding, also seem a bit adventurous; the fact that all and almost only Sardinian provinces are extrme outliers shoud have been a tell. The rest of the Italian bprovinces are in a tight uniform cluster. Sardinia, except for a very brief period in the mid 2010s,has only 4 provinces, so it is possible that messed up their data extraction (they show 8 provinces). Also Sardinia is not particularly poorer than the rest of Southern Italy and actually has a lower crime rate (which they suggest but not outright state is a factor). A better paper would probably try to build a single model for Japan, Italy and US using actual mortality, crime and poverty rates.