8 ms·
America’s DIY Phone Farmers
- iddqa 7y agoLooks like it's more profitable than altcoin mining!
- amelius 7y agoYes, but what is the break-even point, considering that each phone costs at least $50?
- Moru 7y agoDoubt they use new phones, used can be gotten a lot cheaper
- phonebanshee 7y agoAnd used with broken screens are cheaper yet.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI think they would aim for $10-$15 per unit. These buyers probably set a price floor for the lowest end of the market, between barely usable and the shredder. They probably get some bulk deals from recyclers for the Grade D units. Might even be able to make some Grade A or B units for resale if they have lots of parts.
- rubbercasing 7y agosurreal to think a simple tasks can end up with individuals making over 2,000 USD on the side by phone farming.
- wingerlang 7y agoDoesn't seem all that simple. Quite a lot of knowledge is needed and a lot up continuous upkeep. The whole article is also more or less about how it doesn't really work all that well anymore.
- Scoundreller 7y agoWas probably a fun hobby that also earned money. They probably learned a lot in the process about how things work. There’s a lot of transferable skills gained, but it can be hard to sell it to most employers. Nobody cared about my hundreds of EBay sales on my resume in my late teens, but it taught me a lot: Working with customers, how to sell and differentiate your product, managing money, managing inventory, getting cut out by Chinese competition with pricing you couldn’t possibly match...
- jdnenej 7y agoWould it be possible to just run 100 instances of an android emulator?
- avip 7y agoEmulators would be immediately identifiable. This method can only work if the fraudstee has no fraud detection mechanism at all.
- one2zero 7y agoHow though? With Bluestacks you can emulate a few different types of phones including Google Pixels.
- chmod775 7y agoI don't know. But I spent the better part of a day trying to prevent a game from detecting I was using an emulator. Bluestacks in different configurations was among the things I tried. Lost interest and decided the developers just don't want me as a potential customer.
- avip 7y agoFor native apps blacklist default emulator MSIN and similar attributes (and let the cat and mouse game begin). For mobile web various fingerprinting techniques are available. As a fun (and quite irrelevant) example, you can immediately tell chrome, safari, firefox and node apart just with: atob('Ψ') x
- Scoundreller 7y agoDepends what you’re emulating. Instead of emulating the OS, you could emulate app by simulating the I/O network traffic. PayTV pirates did this with smart cards: just replaced the entire thing with a chip that knew what to respond for each challenge/demand.
- avip 7y agoEverything is possible, and every measure has its counter. “Just replace the device with a chip that” is not in the same ballpark as “just use an emulator”.
- nothrabannosir 7y ago3 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20589870 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20589870
- rwmj 7y agoSorry about that - I thought HN automatically deduped submissions.
- Jaruzel 7y agoIt does, but only if the URL is the same. Original URL: https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/d3naek/how-to-make-a-phone-farm https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/d3naek/how-to-make-a-phon... Your submitted URL: https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/d3naek/how-to-make-a-phone-farm https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/d3naek/how-to-make-a-phon...
- nothrabannosir 7y agoDoesn’t matter, it should and if it doesn’t it’s not your fault. Never blame the user ;)
- dang 7y agoJust out of curiosity, how would you write software to catch that those two URLs pointed to the same thing?
- krapp 7y agoI have an idea: Crawl the page, create similarity hashes of the text and image contents, and keep track of the metadata and outbound links, which will probably match or mostly match between page versions, and related pages (particularly if they contain social media tags, or author and publisher, etc.) If any two submissions match text and images within some margin, or share the same links, consider one a possible dupe and ask the user if they want to post it or just vote up what seems to be the existing article (this will allow user curation to reduce false positives.) Also, automatically flag reposts for mod review later.
- chenlianmt 7y agoPhone farming is actually easy to be banned if the investors apply appropriate fraud detection strategies such as IP/device ID collection or user behavior classification. I wouldn't think phone farming is as profitable as it used to be.
- userbinator 7y agoThe idea of "watching" ads for profit has always amused me a little --- what if your mind is somewhere else or you're not looking at the screen? I suspect that those who don't all-out farm but still do such things are not really paying attention anyway. Of the people I know, no one actually pays any attention to ads even if they don't block them. Also, when profits decline, you can still use the phones to host an Android app-testing service...
- _def 7y agoAt least nobody thinks that he's not paying attention. Aren't video ads all about subconscious tactics? For instance, it seems to me that some ads on YouTube, which are skippable after 5 seconds, really try to hook you to watch the rest. Really annoying.
- jordache 7y agosame goes for commercials on tv, radio, etc... same business model.
- gregmac 7y agoThe demographic seems off to me for this: How much revenue is there to make from a customer that willingly spends their time watching ads? Is that the person you want to invest in? What's the ROI of paying people to watch your ads?
- whatshisface 7y agoIt's a form of ad fraud. P&G isn't paying ad farms intentionally.
- frankydp 7y agoThis is a strangely framed/toned article given the subject is run of the mill Fraud and not entrepreneurship as implied.
- J-dawg 7y agoI know the term "fraud" is used throughout the article, but is this actually fraud in the legal sense? (I assume not). I certainly don't see it as anything approaching fraud in the ethical sense. Advertisers are paying for clicks / "views", and that's what they're getting. If people want to game that system I see that as entirely fair game.
- shkkmo 7y agoThe article is fairly careful not to call phone farming of inctivized add apps "fraud" directly (except for the first line). I'm not sure I would include the behavior discussed in the article under "Ad Fraud". Usually "Ad Fraud" refers schemes where someone hosts an Ad and then fraudulently delivers fake traffic/clicks to that Ad to get paid. My guess is that the real money and real players in this space are not running incentivized ad apps, but being paid to generate traffic for REAL Ad Fraud.
- jordache 7y agothis is not fraud
- nradov 7y agoIt would be wonderful if clever scammers could figure out a way to wreck the entire Internet advertising economy. Burn the whole thing down.
- jdavis703 7y agoIt would be wonderful if clever mortgage fraudsters could figure out a way to wreck the entire housing economy. Burn the whole thing down. It will make housing more affordable. Actually that happened in 2008 and caused a terrible recession that effected more than just bankers. Perhaps introducing regulation would be a better way of dealing with unscrupulous ad firms.
- FussyZeus 7y agoWhat regulations would you propose? Ad-tech is doing what advertising does, only better. They've taken the industry to its logical conclusions; a catastrophic surveillance system deployed to sell you shit. The problem isn't ad-tech, it's not the surveillance, it's not even the data leaks or viruses; advertising itself is the problem. There's no amount of regulation that is going to make it "good," at best, it will remain a tumor on our free market system until it is excised once and for all. That is, assuming it doesn't kill it outright in its seemingly endless race to the bottom.
- whatshisface 7y agoBanning advertising would be the greatest imaginable victory for big brands and the end of small B2C business. The advertising that has already happened would get culturally locked in forever (would anybody forget Coca Cola?) and it would be illegal for new market entrants to change it.
- FussyZeus 7y agoI mean, this is just the logical conclusion of capitalism. A few monstrous companies dominating industry. It was held back from eating itself some time ago when a bunch of massive corps were broken up, but that doesn't happen anymore. Ironically, big business propaganda about how great big business is has swayed the public so far away from regulating it that there's now nothing standing in the way of capitalists destroying the capitalist system.