16 ms·
Tree planting: Where can I do it and which type is best?
- luxuryballs 7y agofruit trees are great because you can eat the fruit
- stevespang 7y agoWhile tree planting is an admirable goal, if you don't get enough consistent rainfall all your trees die. Climate change already impacts rainfall distribution.
- tareqak 7y agoN.B. Crazy idea follows: I wonder if there would be a away for the government to allow people to purchase land at a reduced cost and tax-free (sales and property taxes) for the sole purpose of planting trees. Land purchased this way would be legally protected against the government's power of eminent domain/expropriation [0]. Sale of the said land would be restricted in the same way. If someone did want to develop the land, they would be allowed to do so only if they paid the difference that would have been accumulated over the years in taxes compounded with interest. The whole thing would sort of be like a U.S. 401k or Canadian RRSP, but for the environment. It would sort of like what this Brazilian politician asked for here except the ownership of the land would be transferred, so it wouldn't be a sort of one-sided, long-term extortion [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eminent_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eminent_domain [1] https://www.npr.org/2015/11/10/455432704/rich-nations-should-pay-to-preserve-amazon-rainforest-brazilian-politician-says https://www.npr.org/2015/11/10/455432704/rich-nations-should...
- mattkrause 7y agoA couple of similar mechanisms already exist. One way to do this is through a conservation easement, which essentially splits off the right to develop some land and sells/donates that right to a land trust or the government. You retain ownership of the land itself, but this restriction becomes part of the title, so it runs with the land and binds you and future owners to its terms. In exchange, the donation is tax deductible (or the sale nets you money) and the easement also reduces your property tax since the land is now worth less (30-60%). There are also less permanent versions where the owner agrees to manage the land in a particular way or according to a designated person’s advice (e.g., a forester). I think these are often for a fixed term (e.g., 10 or 25 years).
- avierax 7y agoWhat would be the advantage of making the land private compared to planting trees in public land?
- tareqak 7y agoIt’s so that a future government can’t sell that land to someone else to cut down the trees and develop it. That can still happen with private ownership, which is why I had the idea of giving concessions that would have to be paid back to deter it.
- arkades 7y agoI see repeated comments suggesting seaweed is superior to trees. Any guides on how to safely plant seaweed without disrupting the local biome?
- exabrial 7y agoPlease: native species to the location.
- aacook 7y agoPick natives and don't ask for permission! (https://www.reddit.com/r/gardening/comments/bwuxsf/guerrilla_planted_our_potted_christmas_tree_in https://www.reddit.com/r/gardening/comments/bwuxsf/guerrilla...)
- ulisesrmzroche 7y agoHow about like, urban farming? If I was to grow my own tomatoes and peppers and onions, like, to make a badass salsa, is that helping sequester carbon or no? I admit my front lawn is like...embarrasing. It's nothing but grass and one single tree. If I was to really go nuts on it, would that help? It wouldn't be such a bad future if everyone's lawns were required by law to have a few trees.
- hashgowda 7y agoAkira Miyawaki - proposed a methodology to grow forest faster and stronger. No maintenance required after 3years.
- feedbeef 7y agoTrees can be planted a lot easier than you probably think (e.g. cuttings from existing trees). Trees grow best in established forests or areas with shrubby growth, as this indicates the soil is generally more fungal than bacterial, which trees prefer. Check out the efforts of Akiva Silver and Geoff Lawton on YouTube. Also: http://www.woodlanders.com/episodes http://www.woodlanders.com/episodes
- hoseja 7y agoI don't understand this feel-good obsession with planting trees. They plant themselves! Just stop cutting grass and they will come and if they won't, planting them would probably not help anyway!
- yo1 7y agoMany of my 4 year old Spanish Cedar trees (cedros) are already 20cm (8") diameter at chest height and ~15m tall. Planting hardwood trees in the tropics is one of the best long term investments you can make, especially if you plan to have furniture etc made with the wood. Some types of trees are ready to harvest in 5 years, others in 10, others in 20, others in 40+ (for your kids) I've planted about 30 hectares so far, will do another 15ha this year. To keep maintenance costs down, you can plant them in contour rows along with closely spaced leguminous trees like inga edulus to shade out the weeds below. Selecting trees that are hardy against insects when they are young is a good way to go (cedros and mahogany are not, need spraying..) I'm not a fan of teak, eucalyptus or pine being planted in the Amazon, I think fast growing native species are best. If you do the math, the numbers are really good. And it's good for the animals. And climate.
- elliotcoad 7y agoIf you want to plant lots of trees cheaply, and watch your forest come to life we created a platform for exactly that. We don't take a cut of your money to pay ourselves either. We just want to let people achieve amazing things and grow billions of new trees. It's Offset Earth - https://offset.earth/ https://offset.earth/
- arethuza 7y agoThere is also Trees for Life in Scotland: https://treesforlife.org.uk/ https://treesforlife.org.uk/ You can volunteer for week long tree planting & conservation trips: https://treesforlife.org.uk/volunteer/conservation-weeks/ https://treesforlife.org.uk/volunteer/conservation-weeks/
- dleslie 7y agoGiven the amount of provisos, conditions, and regulators required to approve of planting, it sounds to me like it is better to beg forgiveness than ask permission.
- cschneid 7y agoThe rules presented in the article were just: "Don't mess anything up, and do it with permission by the land owner. If you plan to plant a ton, ask pros if that'll mess anything up."
- dleslie 7y agoThe rules require archeological, environmental, and civic planning assessments; as well as permission from the land owner.
- notatoad 7y agodid you read a different article? "In England, you would not need planning permission to plant less than two hectares (20,000 sq metres) in a low risk area, it said."
- dleslie 7y agoOf course I did. How do you expect one determines an area to be low-risk? To do so requires assessment from all stakeholders who could deem it not to be low-risk.
- stordoff 7y agoIf I understand it correctly, you can just look it up. Woodland Trust: > In England, planning permission isn’t needed if your project is under 2ha and in a low risk area. Check your area using the Forestry Commission land information search. https://www.woodlandtrust.org.uk/plant-trees/advice/where/ https://www.woodlandtrust.org.uk/plant-trees/advice/where/ Map browser: https://www.forestergis.com/Apps/MapBrowser/ https://www.forestergis.com/Apps/MapBrowser/ (via https://www.gov.uk/guidance/use-the-land-information-search https://www.gov.uk/guidance/use-the-land-information-search) Then enable the Forestry Commission > Targeting and Scoring > Low Risk Areas for Woodland Creation layer. At the very least, if your plan is to just beg forgiveness, it would give you a better argument that you thought it was acceptable and at least tried to comply.
- rebuilder 7y agoMy wife and I have a property with a good bit of forest. It's mostly fir trees and birch. Every now and then I wonder if there's some way to increase the co2 uptake of the forest, but the question appears surprisingly complicated, and so far my conclusion has been to just leave it be. Has anyone looked into this?
- pjkundert 7y agoHarvest it, and sell the wood to be converted into long-duration construction materials. The land will produce successive crops.
- dx87 7y agoThere was an article posted recently that said the best way to increase the co2 uptake is by cutting down the fully grown trees and planting new trees. Full grown trees don't absord as much co2 as a tree that is still growing, and the needles that some trees drop make the ground acidic, preventing new trees from growing. The problem is that you have to find something to do with all the wood so the captured co2 doesn't get released from the harvested trees.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoit's probably a 2 (or more) factor optimization problem. Because even if large trees don't absorb as much, they are still blocking sunlight and converting at least some (how much, I don't know) of the photons into photosynthesis instead of heat. The sweet spot would probably be a medium-size tree.
- jerkstate 7y agoI'm not sure if that's true. Based on what I've read, older trees sequester carbon at a higher rate, according to [1]. I would like to see the counter claim. https://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/Downloads/method-calculating-carbon-sequestration-trees-urban-and-suburban-settings.pdf https://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/Downloads/method-calculat... page 8
- 7y ago
- hangonhn 7y agoSlightly tangentially related, for those of us who are into gardening and coding, there is a plant monitor made by Xiaomi called Xiaomi Flower Care that will monitor moisture, light, temperature, and soil fertility. It works over Bluetooth and can be purchased on Amazon for as low as $8 per probe but the vendors will often charge around $25. You see a lot of rebranded ones but they're all the same from Xiaomi. It works with their iOS (and presumably Android) app. Someone has released a SDK for it: https://github.com/vrachieru/xiaomi-flower-care-api https://github.com/vrachieru/xiaomi-flower-care-api My plan is to use that and build a Raspberry Pi to monitor my plants. And later on maybe control the watering system. Anyways, it's a nice cheap plant monitoring option. It was really helpful when I was trying to figure out why my plants were turning yellow. People were mostly telling me that I was either over watering or under watering, etc. Then the probes all told me that my soil has no fertility left so I just added some organic 5-5-5 fertilizers and my plants are doing great again. The nerd in me love checking the data every day but would ideal build a Raspi server to sync and display some graphs some day (using a Prometheus endpoint perhaps?) If anyone has good advice on how to control a set of water valves using Raspberry Pi, please let me know! I know about GPIO but I would like to have a bus of some sort so I can add more valves in the future if needed. Maybe a USB solenoid?
- mikehotel 7y agoGood luck with your plans! Think about using a bell siphon [1]. Its typically used in aquaponics with a constant stream of water being pumped, but the pump can certainly be switched with a relay/pi/sensor setup to allow for intermittent dry spells (depending on what your growing). Water can be pumped from a nearby reservoir or tank. [1] https://worldwaterreserve.com/aquaponics/bell-siphon-for-aquaponics/ https://worldwaterreserve.com/aquaponics/bell-siphon-for-aqu...
- pardavis 7y agoWoah. This is awesome! I travel for work and keeping my plants happy has been vicious trial and error with passive auto watering stakes. I've been looking for a convenient sensor package so I don't have to muck around with wires. Jackpot! There are many raspberry pi projects on reddit for the "microgrowery" community... I recommend having a search. I plan to set up an indoor tomato and herb garden using these methods. For solenoids, I advise some methods like [1] so that you can connect a cheap and daisy-chainable relay board like [2] via SPI. Then you can control anything. If you don't want to get down into the 5v to 3.3v mumbo jumbo, it may be easiest to connect an arduino or clone via USB to the raspberry pi. There are bazillions of documented ways to drive relays with an arduino. [1]: https://www.tansi.org/rp/interfacing5v.html https://www.tansi.org/rp/interfacing5v.html [2]: https://www.ebay.com/itm/SPI-breakout-board-with-6-relays-for-AVR-arduino-PIC-Raspberry-Pi-/160927333012 https://www.ebay.com/itm/SPI-breakout-board-with-6-relays-fo...
- jerkstate 7y agoI did a rough spreadsheet some time back based on this 1998 EPA carbon sequestration worksheet [1] and found that an average person from a high carbon output country needs about 600-1000 trees to offset their carbon output. There are about 3 trillion trees for a population of 7 billion people for an average of 428 trees per person, so that means you have to make up the delta of about 172 to 572 trees over the course of your lifetime to erase your carbon footprint (of course, young trees don't sequester as much carbon, so your footprint will still be positive for much of your lifetime - but as the trees get older, they sequester at a higher rate per year, which eventually gives you a negative footprint). This projection was based on the CO2 sequestration per year and the average survival rate documented in [1]. [1] https://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/Downloads/method-calculating-carbon-sequestration-trees-urban-and-suburban-settings.pdf https://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/Downloads/method-calculat...
- IgorPartola 7y agoMy understanding was that trees are not the best way to go about this. Seaweed is best, followed by grass, then trees. To be fair, planting seaweed isn’t as satisfying.
- anthony_doan 7y agoGrass is so terrible. You need to maintain it and it requires so much chemicals especially from Monsanto. It's so much work and money just to maintain grass. I like alternatives like moss or clovers. Even cactus gardens seem better suited.
- IgorPartola 7y agoI am not talking about your lawn, but fields of wild grass.
- anthony_doan 7y agoOh wow I feel like an idiot. Thanks for the clarification, I some how thought grass was man made or domesticated/engineer like cows.
- crispsquirrel 7y agoI really want to start planting trees because this planet needs more trees, it's not a joke or some hippy movement, the consequences are real. I just feel like doing so in the UK is a bureaucratic nightmare. Plus buying trees to plant isn't cheap. I might just start saving up for land and planting trees there if I can.
- gantkimthis 7y agoSave up money to buy a farm and grow trees and other plants that you can farm and sell their produce.
- hanniabu 7y agoOr create a nursery so that others can buy trees from you and you help speed up the growing process and success rate.
- scrollaway 7y ago> I just feel like doing so in the UK is a bureaucratic nightmare. The way I see it, "making it easier to plant trees" is also an excellent action you can take, that can have even more of a positive impact than what a single person can achieve in terms of simply planting trees. So if it's hard to do in the UK, you may find your time to be better spent making it easier for others (and yourself) to plant trees. And if you're on HN, you are like to have an entrepreneurial spirit; maybe you'll be tempted to start a charity or startup in the space. Good luck :)
- ptah 7y agoa lot of plants can be propagated from twigs, you don't need to buy more
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cabaalis 7y ago"You should not plant trees on ... grassland that has never been ploughed..." Can anyone shed some light on the reason behind not planting in open grassland?
- Jolter 7y agoPresumably because the Trust are tasked with conservation of nature, they cannot recommend converting one land use to another, because that would run contrary to their task.
- carapace 7y agoThink about it, this is in Britain right? Grassland that has never been ploughed is going to be pretty rare, probably some kind of old ecology that shouldn't be converted to forest willy-nilly. That's my guess anyway.
- tastyfreeze 7y agoThe only problem I have with that is that many areas that are grassland in the UK now may have been heavily forested and were denuded of trees prior to or during Roman colonization. I found this video on Caledonian reforestation interesting: https://youtu.be/UDtsExXe93Q https://youtu.be/UDtsExXe93Q
- lucb1e 7y agoI recently looked into this as well. What I'm worried about (as opposed to a more expensive method like Climeworks offers) is what prevents people from ripping out those trees next year? The planting companies never seem to be the owner of the ground. They don't even guarantee a single year. Does anyone know how they handle this risk?
- gnode 7y agoIf the aim is to sequester carbon, then planting trees seems to be only half the solution. We also need to prevent the captured carbon reentering the atmosphere by combustion or decay. It seems to me that it would be beneficial to landfill as much wood as possible to capture the carbon underground and limit aerobic decay, and rather than recycling wood products, sustainably harvest as much new wood as possible. In this case, the best place to plant a tree would be where it could be most economically lumbered, and the best kind of tree would be that most useful for industry.
- londontrees 7y agoIn Lewisham there is a group of volunteers doing excellent work planting street trees (Street Trees for Living - https://brockleystreettrees.blogspot.com/p/welcome2.html https://brockleystreettrees.blogspot.com/p/welcome2.html) They work with the council and have organised the planting & maintenance of over 600 trees since 2012 (including the lovely Himalayan Birch outside my house which I sponsored last year). I have also helped out here and there and created a 'tree map' a few years ago which has information on all the publicly owned trees in the Borough - http://maps.catfordstreettrees.org.uk/ http://maps.catfordstreettrees.org.uk/ (I actually happen to currently be in the process of updating the map with new data)
- dobleboble 7y agoYou can sign up for a service that will plant trees on your behalf. Do your own research, but these ones seemed pretty good and plant 1 tree per $1. https://onetreeplanted.org/ https://onetreeplanted.org/ https://trees.org/ https://trees.org/
- captainmojo 7y agoI've been liking Eden Reforestation (https://edenprojects.org/ https://edenprojects.org/), which employs local populations to plant trees in deforested areas. Ecosia is listed on their Partner page, so I'd assumed that's how it works under the hood. I'm interested in hearing about other projects, too.
- tunesmith 7y agoI don't see how 1.5 billion trees is enough to offset the UK's carbon emission rate. If you go by a tree sequestering a ton of carbon over a 40 year lifetime, and the UK emitting 368 megatons per year... you're sequestering on average 37.5 million tons per year (less when they're young, more when they're old), which is only one tenth of what the UK emits in one year. Plant 15 billion trees and then you're carbon neutral, on average, for the 40 years, and carbon negative if they live longer. But isn't that like planting trees on half of the land of the UK?
- quixoticelixer- 7y agoPlanting trees can only ever be part of the solution, but it gives you time to greatly reduce net CO2 emissions while you figure out how to reduce gross CO2 emissions effectively. And out of all countries the UK is the one of the few that could actually plant half it's land area in trees.
- gnode 7y agoThe slow initial growth of trees makes me wonder whether we'd be better planting fast growing crops like bamboo and hemp which can be processed into long term materials like fibreboard and bioplastic or added to concrete.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoand seaweed near areas with ocean access. I wonder if you could have wastewater treatment plants that feed seaweed (in a large enclosure with seawater access, done responsibly), then harvest the seaweed, dry it, and send the carbon straight to mines for sequestration. More simply, perhaps farmers could be encouraged to sink waste carbon in the same way. Corn farmers could be encouraged to send the husks to sequestration instead of burning (I know they use the ashes as compost, so there are downsides). Or hemp, as you said, strip the leaves from the stems and send one or the other to a carbon sink.
- gnode 7y agoRather than immediately sequestering the carbon, it seems to me that it would make economic sense to use fibrous plant materials in products. By taxing competing non ecologically friendly alternatives like fossil oil-based plastics, and sending carbon-containing products to landfill, a greater financial incentive is created for growers, and carbon is sequestered from the atmosphere rapidly and long-term.
- carapace 7y agoAlso we should stop cutting down the existing forests. Brazil and Canada have both been in the news recently for clear cutting their rainforests (yes, CA has inland rainforest!)
- quixoticelixer- 7y agoCanada almost always replaces their forests. Brazil is different they are being cleared for agriculture but it is hard to tell them they can't clear forest to become rich when most of the rich world did that before them.
- __turbobrew__ 7y agoCanada replaces 500 year old rainforests with saprolings. We do a decend job rotating tree farms, but there isn't any way get back our ancient trees (besides waiting a few hundred years).
- quixoticelixer- 7y agoSaplings are better at sequestering carbon than old trees are.
- 23throwaway23 7y agoFunny, how come this topic isn't flagged, but one revealing new information (updates from interim IPCC models) has been flagged: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20574620 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20574620 As for tree planting - absolutely necessary, but without a political solution, it won't do much but buy a bit of time. And that is ONLY true if we stop ongoing, accelerating deforestation. A political solution would likely be better than individuals trying to plant a few trees.
- rohittidke 7y agoCould we plant trees in parking lots? A law must be made. In the US especially West Coast (Seattle) for example and also in Germany a lot of flat space has been taken by parking lots. Its actually crazy seeing these huge parking lots. Could we plant verticle wines and change the geometry (introducing gradients to add area for a tree - simple pythogoras concept) to add space for at least a tree per car slot or maybe at times even more.
- jws 7y agoMany places in the US having zoning codes requiring trees or other plantings in parking lots of certain sizes. Success is mixed. Where I live a big box store will typically be built with a bunch of small trees planted which don't have adequate area for water to reach their roots. They will die in a few years and maybe be replaced by more tiny trees which die. So, that zoning might want to be revisited. Writing laws to ensure outcomes with trees is hard. Our old suburban community, generally covered in mature trees, made rules that if a developer is going to tear down a house and build a new one the trees must all be inventoried, only a minimal number are allowed to be removed, the rest get fences around their drip lines for the duration of construction to protect their roots and at the end they are checked to make sure they weren't injured. Significant fines are involved for accidentally taking a tree… So now before a homeowner sells their property to a developer they "do a little landscaping" i.e. cut down all the trees except maybe some small ones on the lot lines. Problem solved!
- rohittidke 7y agoYup but its like a cat mouse game. There never will be no crime so the in the government laws must keep evolving, just as the thieves get more innovative. But the laws are needed. In Germany at least now they are taking climate change seriously. Munich has invested a lot in public Transport and by 2030 it would really at a good level. The parking lots Story I will make a Blog soon with preise carbon calculations so that its advantage us both for the Business and the climate.
- algaeontoast 7y agoI've started doing this as a hobby wherever I live after spending some time in the Bay Area and becoming obsessed with how cool huge redwoods are. Growing saplings is slow and sometimes difficult, but one of the coolest things I've ever done was taking saplings I grew and then heading out into a reserve with scientists to plant them. I feel like a huge understated challenge to these efforts is finding land that's protected / optimal for planting that will knowingly not be plowed or cleared within 60 years. Otherwise, it doesn't really matter how many trees you plant if they're all uprooted or killed before they even reach 6' in height...
- Merrill 7y agoWhere? Not where it will grow up into utility lines, or where it will fall into utilities or onto a structure. What type? Small and strong species that will not uproot, snap off or shed branches in a windstorm, and will tolerate heavy loads of ice and/or snow, depending on your climate.
- JudgeWapner 7y agotrees don't need to be in perfect shape to sequester carbon. breaking off branches is part of nature's process. and they can be trimmed to avoid powerlines since you have plenty of warning. I think the biggest concern is for those who live in deserts where water is scarce.
- gooseus 7y agoI've been wondering about various carbon sequestration methods myself and am glad to see these topics on HN since it is an opportunity to harvest relevant knowledge from the community. Apologies for tangential topic, but give me a sec and it'll try to tie it back to some other discussions happening here - has anyone here heard of "Cryo Carbon Capture"? https://sesinnovation.com/faq.html https://sesinnovation.com/faq.html This seems to involve feeding the exhaust of a power plant into a process which cools the exhaust to the point where CO2 dry ice (and other pollutants) desublimates out of the exhaust and is then extracted for various industrial/commercial applications. I am curious about this model if it feasible then couldn't this also be used on the exhaust stream of a heater for pyrolysis of fast growing trees, grasses, etc. creating biofuel and biochar? You can use biofuels to heat the pyrolysis and biochar to sequester carbon in the soil, while also improving it to grow more biomass for sequestration. The cryo-capture handles your CO2 waste streams and further captures carbon in a cold sink (also useful for refrigeration and can maybe act as a "battery" when combined with a Stirling engine?) which also produces CO2 which can be used to enrich biomass grown in greenhouses and has plenty of other commercial uses. If you add solar and other sustainable power inputs to the cryo-capture process then what you have is basically a farm which creates useful carbon-based products from the atmosphere using plants and basic chemistry... and here is where I hope someone with more knowledge will point out why this isn't already a thing, likely due to some serious inefficiency I'm overlooking.
- Skunkleton 7y ago> This seems to involve feeding the exhaust of a power plant into a process which cools the exhaust to the point where CO2 dry ice (and other pollutants) desublimates out of the exhaust and is then extracted for various industrial/commercial applications. Based on what you said, the dry ice would sublimate and just re-release the carbon into the atmosphere. Or did you have a different place for this carbon to go? If so, how are you planning to keep the dry ice cool, and how are you planning on producing it in the first place?
- gooseus 7y agoThe dry ice itself would be stored in well-insulated containers, and cold generated from these containers would be useful for refrigeration with the CO2 that does sublimate out as the containers heat up being feed-stock to enrich greenhouses, with the rest would being recycled into the pyrolysis exhaust, and thus back into the dry ice production. One of the things I'm curious about is the efficiency of the dry ice production at various CO2 levels and the physical quantities of material that would be expected from such these kinds of processes. The general idea is that you would be creating a system for accumulating/concentrating carbon as CO2 solid/gas, as well as in biomass, and at the same time creating two large energy differentials that could also be put to work. The major input to this system (assuming the numbers can work) would be photosynthetics and photovoltaics.
- hinkley 7y agoThere are a lot of people in this thread conflating 'mature' with 'in decline'. Remember that there are many, many species of tree with a natural lifespan in their preferred environment that can be measured in hundreds of years. That's a huge time period between full-sized and 'slowly falling apart'. A tree in decline may have heart rot. Every year its losing wood while making new. It's a fight against gravity and the elements. When the losses outpace the gains the tree loses integrity, major limbs start falling off, and eventually the trunk fails. If you told me this tree is carbon neutral, I'd have to take your word for it. But for the previous thirty years? That tree was socking away tons - literally - of carbon. There are "mature trees" in the world today that will outlive the children sitting beneath them.
- adrian_mrd 7y agoA lot of farm land seems ripe for planting trees. Does anyone know of any organisations who work with farmers in the USA, Europe, Oceania, Asia, Africa or the Americas to help reforest farmland?