4 ms·
To the computer hackers who read these things: biology is a complex system. So complex that the most complicated system you have ever worked on seems very simp
by dekhn 7y ago
To the computer hackers who read these things: biology is a complex system. So complex that the most complicated system you have ever worked on seems very simple compared to it. WHen you read articles like this, be aware the scientists have extensive training in working with complex systems, and publish exciting sounding coherent narratives that are, at best, incorrect but useful working models (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong).
It's fun to speculate but to prove your case and make a real dent in human health problems is a lot harder than coming in late and saying "But wait, why don't you just..."
I heartily recommend going back to the great textbooks of these fields and reading them, rather than trying to understand things by dropping into the state of the art research (which is usually wrong, and hard to understand in detail).
Some books I recommend:
The Biology of Cancer (Weinberg). After you read this book you'll have a better understanding of why doctors and scientists cringe when people say "cure cancer".
Molecular Biology the Cell (Alberts, etc). After you read this book you'll have a much better understanding of the full complexity that scientists have to deal with in complex cellular systems.
Molecular Biology of the Gene (watson, etc). Can't say much about this book except that's it's a classic reference.
What makes these three books exception is that they support all their factual claims with direct links to the papers that established the facts. And they provide you with the skills to evaluate modern research. But nothing compares to actually going to grad school and participating in the research- once you see how the grants are made, the experiments are, and the papers are written, you'll understand why trying to understand biology by press release is like trying to understand assembly language by watching a Steve Jobs product announcement.
- cgiles 7y agoThis is not bad advice, especially for people lacking the fundamentals, but these books are often way out of date and only cover topics that have been solidly established 20 years ago. I would suggest, especially for people interested in a relatively niche field like aging, that a good compromise is to read review articles. You can go to PubMed and filter by review articles to find them. But I wholeheartedly concur that for non-experts to read primary research articles will cause much more confusion than clarity. And doubly so for press releases on those articles.
- dekhn 7y agoBiology of Cancer ed 2 is from 2013 and nothing has changed tremendously to the point where the book would be out of date. Molecular Biology of the Cell ed 6 is from 2014 Molecular Biology fo the Gene is a bit older and I would generally not recommend people read it, but the problem is (IMHO) the alternative, Genetics by Lewin, is genetics-oriented instead of molecular biology, and I find that most CS folks understand MB and find genetics confusing. Review articles are good, but I still recommend starting with textbooks before moving on to reviews.
- pgeorgi 7y agoThanks for providing well thought-through advice like that. Following your arguments it seems pretty clear to me that you put a lot of thought in that. If I may ask, what's your background that tells you things like "most CS folks understand MB and find genetics confusing"?
- dekhn 7y agoMy background is dual CS and MB. In particular, I got an undergraduate degree in Molecular Biology at UCSC and did my undergraduate thesis with David Haussler (CS professor who helped "save the human genome") on probabilistic graphical models of E.Coli genes. At that time I didn't really know much CS (just hacking), so I went into grad school (BIophysics PhD) but focused on computational chemistry, so got lots of fortran distributed computing programming experience. Based on that I was able to do a couple postdocs in bioinformatics, increasing my understanding of protein function and evolution, and then became a full-time scientist, however after several years of not being able to find funding, went to work at Google for a decade where I taught myself all the CS I didn't previously know and applied it to scientific computing. Now I work for a company that does machine learning for drug discovery. What I've learned over the years is that genetics is a field where people who excel in abstract thinking about blobby, messy, wet objects succeed and understand the paradigms. While CS people find molecular biology, with its concerete focus on molecular entities (agents) interacting is very easy to understand. After many years of trying to understand genetics I finally realized that many of the paradigms in genetics are just useful but wrong models that don't correspond to reality.
- aussieguy1234 7y agoAlso: The mouse operating system is quite different to the human operating system. Just because it works in a mouse, doesn't mean it will work in a human.
- breck 7y ago> To the computer hackers who read these things: biology is a complex system. So complex that the most complicated system you have ever worked on seems very simple compared to it. I had this exact experience, when I transitioned from working in big tech to working at a cancer research center. The scales are wildly different. In the time it’s taken me to write this comment, my body has generated nearly a billion new cells at 20GB of data per cell, or about 100 google web indexes worth of data. Very humbling. But also very fun!
- copperx 7y agoCould you explain how you made that transition? Or any advice for someone in tech interested in getting into working with cancer?
- breck 7y agoI was working at Azure and did some minor projects with the Microsoft Band. I decided I wanted to get into consumer bio tech. Then, the wife got a job in Hawaii and so we decided to move from Seattle for that. I expected there to be a lot of tech jobs in Hawaii, given its location in between Asia and North America. However, there are very few. Then I saw a post on Craigslist that the cancer center was looking to hire a software engineer. I had almost no biology experience but there are very few software engineers/data scientists here, so it ended up being a great fit. Took me about 9 months to be comfortable with the biology, and still am far from an expert, but have great team mates with that expertise. From what I hear, this is not too rare. There is a large shortage of good programmers in biotech. Probably because the pay is a lot worse than in the tech industry. I’d recommend new software engineers go work in tech and save money while the economy is hot, and then transition to bio tech when you are looking for some more challenging work and money isn’t as big a concern.
- breck 7y agop.s. - our lab is hiring folks without a bio background if they have a strong software engineering/deep learning skill set! Email me yunits@hawaii.edu for more info
- amelius 7y ago> To the computer hackers who read these things: biology is a complex system. Reminds me of: "Can a biologist fix a radio?", http://protein.bio.msu.ru/biokhimiya/contents/v69/pdf/bcm_1403.pdf http://protein.bio.msu.ru/biokhimiya/contents/v69/pdf/bcm_14...
- shmooth 7y agoThis strikes me as standard gatekeeping and anti-intellectualism. Probably 99.9% of great things ever discovered was by people saying, "Why don't you just..."
- 762236 7y agoI am a computer hacker that has dipped into physiology to perform at athletic extremes to good success. I always rely on data and evidence, and refuse to take advice on physiology from anyone (including doctors), because very few stick to evidence-based strategies (and doctors seem uninterested in sports physiology). Physiology is many orders of magnitude more complicated than any computer system I've worked on. It is easy to create abstractions that try to explain some of the data, but you must always be ready to have them proven wrong when you look at the next layer down. Evidence must rule.
- andy_ppp 7y agoI’d also thoroughly recommend Peter Attia’s podcast, it’s a really amazing in depth discussion into how the body works and it never anything but astonishing.
- bhouston 7y agoIn University I tried to transition into molecular neuroscience. It was very frustrating how slow porgress is and how little a single individual can impact it. Biology feels like a huge spaghetti code project with millions upon millions of lines and much of it interconnected. Basically biology feels like a working but horribly written program with secret gotchas everywhere. I left and went back to coding and mathematics. So easy to make progress. I can pretty much understand the whole system. Everyday I get something real done.