4 ms·
Google Cloud's run rate is now over $8B
- frostyj 7y agoAt the mean time, there are 7 GCP services currently under outage. --A frustrated engineer
- swuecho 7y agoI feel better, because I have only one. wonder why gcloud is so bad? not even as good as digital ocean from a user perspective.
- singron 7y agoDigital ocean has ~300 employees (circa 2017 according to wikipedia). Google has far more than that working on Cloud. Google Cloud is also largely layered on top of their existing internal infrastructure. Google cloud also has more services, more regions, and more zones. My opinion is that there is just way more that can go wrong.
- verdverm 7y agoI move people from AWS to GCP for cost, simplicity, and developer experience. What do you find so bad about GCP?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- verdverm 7y agoTo be fair, these were not outages, rather degraded services where a feature or two was not working. None of my applications had any errors, nor were my users impacted. You can find the details here: https://status.cloud.google.com/ https://status.cloud.google.com/
- broth 7y agoYou also have to account for the incidents that customers face that don't show up in the status dashboard until a certain influx of support tickets raise the flag. For example, right now we're facing an issue where one of our GCP HTTPS load balancers is suddenly failing to connect to any backend service for reasons unknown. Not sure if there was any correlation to the eight reported service disruptions on the status dashboard.
- verdverm 7y agoYeah, there are still per customer issues that don't make the status page. GCP does a good job with their RCAs, in-depth with future mitigation strategies. They are also really good about keeping the status updated. I had an experience on both GCP and AWS of disks failing. For AWS we had to manually reset the machine, for GCP, I only know because I looked at the audit logs. GCP auto-migrates on hardware issues.
- FrankPetrilli 7y agoSounds like something GCP support would love to help you troubleshoot. The disruptions I'm aware of have no correlation to load balancer traffic paths. What's the actual reason listed for the 502s in Stackdriver? That's a great first step.
- broth 7y agoAll Stackdriver logs for the load balancer have the following for each request as the status details: failed_to_connect_to_backend We've tried the following with no luck: - Restarted GCE instances in backend service - Recreated the backend service - Recreated the HTTPS load balancer - Switched the balancing mode of the backend service to rate instead of utilization since monitoring was stating the backend service CPU utilization was 500% (another red flag) We are, however, able to directly connect to the GCE instances within the backend service via external IP. Have not heard much back from Google support.
- broth 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 7y agoGoogle includes GSuite revenue, which not long ago, was half of all "Google Cloud Revenue". I also assume a large portion of Azure revenue is O365. So Amazon's lead is a bit more impressive than it might seem at first.
- knorker 7y agoIt is, but considering the estimated $1T market and all players having some exponential growth-looking curves (IIRC) the difference is pretty insignificant. I'll hold on to my stock in all these companies for a bit longer. I don't think there'll be any losers in this race.
- pmart123 7y agoBut startups use Oracle according to Oracle...
- scarface74 7y agoSounds like every deck pitch from a non profitable startup trying to get another round of funding... “The market we are in is projected to be worth X. If we only get Y percent our revenues will be Z”...
- knorker 7y agoIt would, except the tapped market is 30+11+8 billion dollars today, and honestly do you doubt that the market is anything less than hundreds of billions? There are a lot of companies out there who should focus on their business model and not be in the DC-running-business. Also, Google, Amazon and Microsoft don't need your funding, thank you. They're very profitable already.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m not talking about funding, I’m more referring to just because the market is big, doesn’t mean that GCP can take advantage of it. Amazon has first mover advantage and Microsoft is entrenched in the Enterprise. Just going by the old adage of “No one ever got fired for buying IBM”, AWS is the safe reputations choice because “everyone” uses AWS and Azure is safe because enterprise companies have decades of trusting Microsoft.
- DevKoala 7y agoGCP Cloud Composer (Airflow) has been a nightmare. I cannot recommend it. BQ is great.
- verdverm 7y agoGKE is amazing too, none of the other major clouds even come close.
- reilly3000 7y agoI found Airflow for a small to medium project to be a nightmare on its own; I'm sure its a powerful framework, but plain Python ended up meeting our needs more than adequately. I was self-hosting it while kicking the tires and found it to be a lot to admin. I always thought I would look at Cloud Composer if I wanted to revisit Airflow. Were your issues with Airflow or Cloud Composer? Agreed BQ IS great.
- DevKoala 7y agoMy issues have been with cloud-composer. I like Airflow.
- chimerasaurus 7y agoWould love to know the pain points so we can make it better - Composer, Airflow, or both.
- DevKoala 7y agoTriggering a DAG externally fails consistently for 1% of requests, and 100% of the time when the web server API goes down, which is too often (502). I understand that in the realm of Airflow, triggering a DAG externally is perhaps a bit of an anti-pattern, but it should not have been documented then: https://cloud.google.com/composer/docs/how-to/using/triggering-with-gcf https://cloud.google.com/composer/docs/how-to/using/triggeri... I have cases open with the composer team, and I am upgrading the cluster again this weekend, but I have lost hope at this point; I am designing a solution to stop using external triggers.
- antiviral 7y agoThe AWS and Azure numbers are actual revenue, but the Google cloud number is a ‘run rate’, meaning, pick a particular high point, call that steady-state, and multiply accordingly to get an annual rate. I am not doubting Google’s success with GCP. However, they should provide the actual revenue, in addition to the run-rate or whatever other vanity metric they want. Not doing so just makes me wonder about their lack of candor.
- eitally 7y agoI think it's more complicated than that (for all three vendors) because customer contracting can involve all sorts of convoluted terms, especially mega-deals. Using ARR makes more logical sense because it provides a less messy way of accounting for things like guaranteed future consumption commits.
- bogomipz 7y agoInteresting, so it's really just a means of smoothing then? Do all three use run rate as their key metric then?
- techslave 7y agoAs a public company you wouldn’t exaggerate it that way. An $8bn run rate means $2bn last quarter. We often look at annual numbers so reporting a run rate makes sense. It’s not meant as a deception. Anyway run rate doesn’t project growth so if anything, it’s understating the numbers.
- antiviral 7y agoThat sounds great- congrats on the impressive growth last quarter. However, it would be more insightful if the earnings report made it clear that the revenue was actually $ 2 BB last quarter in addition to giving a 'run rate.' We would then be able to apply an apples-to-apples comparison with AWS, which made $8.4 BB last quarter, growing 37% from the quarter last year, with a 'steady-state run rate'(no growth) of $33B. That seems straightforward, don't you think? Giving partial info when compared to your peers will only encourage deeper scrutiny. As for the point about ARR in the other comment, it would be good to see how much of the revenue is due to pre-existing commitments vs. on-demand use, but you won't get that just by using a single 'run-rate' number.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI've been in the cloud space for a relatively long time, worked at AWS 2008-2014, and have followed all three big cloud providers since inception. My personal view is that both Azure and GCP boost their "cloud" revenues by 50-60% - e.g. GSuite is included in GCP, some various Office and Enterprise software products by Microsoft are included in Azure. They do this primarily to convince corporate customers that they've closed the gap with AWS, and their service is now comparable. From a technical standpoint, and still IMHO, Google has fewer products, but several of the ones already available are usually quite superior to AWS. AWS has of course the broadest set of services. Azure is still quite a mess, but that doesn't prevent a thriving ecosystem, an easier integration, etc, to convince many customers to use Azure. It's going to be a long battle, for a huge and growing market. And unfortunately for their customers, it means that lock-in, FUD, and other nefarious practices will be common.
- lumost 7y agoYou could flip that and say that AWS under-performs in straight SaaS like github, gsuite etc.
- panpanna 7y agoEven if your numbers are correct, it is still most relevant to customers that azure can scale up to <some big number>. That part of that big number is used internally is not an issue, dogfooding is a good thing and further demonstrates that cloud is a real priority for Microsoft.
- yyyk 7y agoSo what? Had gsuite/office been made by a 3rd party company, you would have counted them in, right? And had Google/MS not have a cloud presence so these products would have been hosted in a different cloud, they would have been counted in your estimation as well, right? This case is technically no different than the others. It is a fact Office/GSuite are rather reliable and fast. It's a credit to their respective clouds, and obviously propels them forwards in their competition with AWS. The respective companies are right to include these in total revenue/marketshare, and it is good to see that they eat their own dogfood. We could have flipped that around and ask why Amazon doesn't trust AWS, but I recall that Amazon does have a few things there too...
- nstart 7y agoI wonder how much Google's deeper integration with kubernetes and the influence of pushing the industry towards using k8s is going to help them in the long run. Could be pocket change at this point but as newer customers come onboard it would be interesting to see if this helps their numbers more.
- writepub 7y agoGoogle's strategy of standardizing microservice infrastructure around kubernetes is likely to benefit them greatly in the long run. Any large company wants to avoid vendor lock-in, and [kubernetes + containers] offers a compelling alternative
- IshKebab 7y agoDisingenuous mix of per-quarter and per-year figures.
- jfengel 7y agoTIL: The "run rate" is extrapolating a year's revenue from some shorter period. So the headline means, "Google Cloud earned $2 billion last quarter, which will be $8 billion a year if we can keep it up." So it makes the numbers more comparable with "per year" as the standard rate, but with all the obvious hazards of extrapolation.