25 ms·
US proposes barring tech companies from offering financial services
- blodovnik 7y agoSo then would financial services companies not be allowed to offer tech services? And what, precisely, is a tech company? How is that unambiguously defined?
- viraptor 7y agoThe proposed definition is in the article.
- klez 7y agoFrom TFA > The draft legislation, “Keep Big Tech Out Of Finance Act,” describes a large technology firm as a company mainly offering an online platform service with at least $25 billion in annual revenue.
- bilbo0s 7y agoLike Paypal?
- trevyn 7y agoPayPal’s revenue is ~$15B, but your point is sound.
- zeckalpha 7y agoOr any large member of the ACH network.
- Dirlewanger 7y agoIt's weird though, because something like ACH desperately needs to be replaced. It's slow, and compared to whatever they have in the EU, it's slow and embarrassing. Not saying it needs to be blockchain (I'd prefer it isn't), but taking lessons from it would be beneficial. In the past ~30 years, the American business ecosystem cares less and less about standards and more about pushing their own standards/formats and not giving a fuck about interoperability.
- 420codebro 7y agoCan you please elaborate on what ACH currently lacks? ACH is for low priority (and low value) stuff. Fedwire (an RTGS) is for high-priority / urgent transactions (securities and the like.
- wil421 7y agoSame day ACH is available if you have a bank that supports it. My small credit union has same day (and free) ACH if I get it in by noon.
- kalleboo 7y agoThe new EU SEPA system launched in 2017 has 10-second settlement and it's available 24/7. You're not going to compete with Venmo, PayPal and Libra with "same day if I get it in by noon"
- wil421 7y agoZelle has instant settlement for banks that use it, including two of the three banks I use. ACH goes through the FED before it is processed by the receiving bank. Is SEPA sent to the ECB before clearing? I’ve worked in Fintech for 6+ years. Banks are dinosaurs and the US banks are terrible at adopting new processes/tech. In the US we are in a standard war with ACH, Zelle, and other payment schemes fighting for market share.
- dhruvmittal 7y agoPaypal's revenue is more around 15B currently. So, not yet.
- awinder 7y agoThere isn't a definition provided for platform utility in this bills text, but the first mention I saw of the "platform utilities" term was from Warren, which was referring to select category of companies with this definition: Companies with an annual global revenue of $25 billion or more and that offer to the public an online marketplace, an exchange, or a platform for connecting third parties would be designated as "platform utilities." It looks like PayPal is at around 13B in yearly revenue so they would 100% not be included for revenue bar alone, but not completely sure how I would read if they fit into the category based on the rest of the definition.
- Robotbeat 7y agoA limit of $25 billion in global revenue? This reads like legislation drafted by large banks to secure their moat against newcomers with enough heft to actually make a dent in their market share. I don’t think this will facilitate competition or protect the consumer in any meaningful way.
- apocalyptic0n3 7y ago$25B is the point that Warren has been targeting for a few months now, not just for banking-related services. She says that at $25B, the company is sufficiently large that they control a significant portion of whatever industry they are as well as the economy and people's lives. The goal is to target companies with too much influence and reign them in with regulations and/or breakup. Again, this number is being used for any industry, not just banking and tech (though tech does seem to be the focus at the moment).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- beejiu 7y agoDon't banks themselves offer an "online platform service" - i.e. online banking, trading, etc?
- eCa 7y agoCan Apple be seen as a tech company by that definition?
- manicdee 7y agoThis legislation is clearly aimed at Apple. Today Apple Pay and a Goldman Sachs credit service. Tomorrow a credit card offering if their own to compete with other Eurocard/Visa/MasterCard services. There’s a lot of money on the line.
- klez 7y ago> This legislation is clearly aimed at Apple. Really? Because I was under the impression that they're more worried about companies minting "currency".
- manicdee 7y agoI guess it’s a bit hard to accurately target the legislative equivalent of a nuclear bomb.
- umeshunni 7y agoIt seems to be clearly aimed at Facebook.
- manicdee 7y agoFacebook is only establishing an alternative currency, which major banks will be participating in if it gets off the ground. Libra is not a threat as long as Facebook plays well with regulators and various nations’ tax offices. In addition, Libra will be run by a spin-off company, not directly by Facebook. Apple is potentially going to cut EMV out of the loop.
- bilbo0s 7y agoThe worst part is who cares anyway? Think about it, why are we targeting tech? If having tech mix with finance is bad, shouldn't we disallow finance companies from offering tech services? If it's not bad, then why are we doing it at all? This really sounds like these politicians are once again doing too much of something no one asked for, and nothing at all about what we did ask for, privacy protection. All they need to do is make a HIPAA like law that criminalizes any sharing of personal data at all for commercial purposes. With mandatory prison sentences for offenders. That's it. Do that and you stop all kinds of egregious privacy invasions in their tracks. That's a really simple ask, and yet they won't do it. It's starting to get a little infuriating. No one cares about whether paypal or ebay offer a prepaid debit card or whatever. Anymore than anyone cares about Walmart offering prepaid debit. We want to make it illegal for ANY of these companies to share information. Full stop. Why can't these people do such a simple thing that makes a whole lot of sense? The EU has protections. Even the AU has started drafting the privacy protections regs for their new zone. Why can't we in the US do that same, very simple, thing? Worst part is now instead of having to worry about what ebay, paypal, and amazon are doing with that data, I have to worry about what thousands of anonymous smaller vendors are doing with my data after they purchase it. In a very real way, these politicians are turning what was a 9mm round flying at me, into a shotgun blast... and then saying, "Hey don't thank us!!!" Don't worry I won't.
- thoughtfunction 7y agoThe politicians wont do it and the populace won't like it because tech companies have become a significant part of the economy and are a significant driver of economic/retirement account growth and international political power in the USA for the past 20 years.
- inlined 7y agoIf you’re in CA you could try to start a referendum.
- b_tterc_p 7y ago> “Such a sweeping proposal would likely spark opposition from Republican members of the house who are keen on innovation” Is this true? I would assume Republicans are more interested in protecting big bank interests
- delfinom 7y agoThey must feel heavily conflicted.
- bluGill 7y agoThere are a lot of republicans: don't paint them with a wide brush. Republicans are in favor of small government - (less so now that they have power). The large number who believe small government even when in power are not in favor of big banks which have mostly got by exploiting government regulations that republicans oppose. Remember though, the above is the generalization of one significant group of republicans. There are many different (overlapping) groups with different beliefs.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Republicans are in favor of small government “Small government” is rhetoric Republicans use when Democratic priorities for government (social services, etc.) are being discussed; it evaporated when Republican priorities for government (military, law enforcement, etc.) are discussed, and even when Republicans have full control of federal policy you don't get smaller government, so the idea that they are for it in any way other than as a occasionally-convenient rhetorical dodge around discussing particular issues is not well supported by evidence.
- wheelerwj 7y ago> There are a lot of republicans: don't paint them with a wide brush. I'm sorry, but no. Republicans are republicans the same as Democrats are Democrats. These parties have their own priorities and most votes fall along party lines anymore. you could switch out Republicans for the word Conservatives and it would be more accurate.
- viraptor 7y agoI'm curious where they draw the line for "company offering financial services". Even if Facebook falls into the big online tech bracket, they explicitly wanted Libra to be a separate entity. In the extreme case, they could hand over Libra completely to other companies and deeply integrate as a payment system/wallet for Libra that they have "no control" over.
- klez 7y agoFrom TFA “A large platform utility may not establish, maintain, or operate a digital asset that is intended to be widely used as medium of exchange, unit of account, store of value, or any other similar function, as defined by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System,” it proposes.
- Robotbeat 7y agoSo it’s specifically targeted against Libra.
- viraptor 7y agoI don't understand it this way. Facebook is the platform and it can organise Libra in a way that it doesn't actually operate or maintain the cryptocurrency itself. I'm assuming that implementing a wallet is not part of operating the currency.
- Mengkudulangsat 7y agoI wonder if Calibra is made into a non-custodial Bitcoin wallet and integrated into Whatsapp instead... does that count as "offering financial services"?
- alt_f4 7y agolet's keep financial services in the hands of Wall Street, where everyone is very reputable and well-intentioned
- raxxorrax 7y agoWall Street just takes advantage of any financial advantage they can get their fingers on no matter the casualties. Tech companies like Google or Facebook are actively trying to shape your opinion. Must have been an ingenious move they made to look worse than Wall Street in a few years. edit: The unpersoning they have committed isn't a viable strategy in the financial industry. Even if players like Mastercard have fallen into that trap. But I wouldn't trust them with a penny.
- jkilpatr 7y ago> "A large platform utility may not establish, maintain, or operate a digital asset that is intended to be widely used as medium of exchange, unit of account, store of value, or any other similar function, as defined by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System," Define large, platform, and utility please? They do define large as 25bil. This definition has serious issues if nothing else.
- krastanov 7y agoIsn't it normal to be vague when writing laws in a "common law" system like the US? I thought the practice was defended with the notion that judges will have to interpret the spirit of the law, having some flexibility with unforeseen cases. It has its pros and cons, but it seems to be an explicit design decision in the system of laws.
- cat199 7y agonot a lawyer, but there is 'vague allowing room for interpretation' and 'so vague it cant be interpreted'
- Qwertystop 7y agoWell, this isn't that. The interpretation may vary slightly, but there are definitely established meanings for "platform" and "utility" for a judge to work from (though "platform" might be only the plain-English meaning, "utilities" such as power and water companies are a regulated category which can be used for reference if nothing else).
- jbverschoor 7y agoSo you simply start a different company unrelated to the tech company. Similar to the tarrifs.. Apple gets an excempt because it cannot get their parts anywhere else; because they are Apple-specific parts, manufactured there. Governments need to take a look outside their bubble and see that they are loosing power to global companies.
- klez 7y ago> Governments need to take a look outside their bubble and see that they are loosing power to global companies. Look, I know Hanlon's razor and all, but thinking that there's no complicity between the US government and US companies (you say global, I say US because FAMGA, in this case) is wishful thinking.
- ptah 7y agonations are becoming obsolete. soon it will be a william gibson world
- 0xB31B1B 7y agoI understand the sentiment but have no idea how this could be carried out. What happens to gift cards? What happens to in game digital currencies, what happens to ad accounts, what happens to AWS credits.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI'm not an economist and really don't know how to articulate this well so forgive how dumb this might sound. I think the difference is if the financial component is the product. All of those things, Steam wallet, Ebay, etc. are all trying to use the money moving tools to sell products that aren't money. Your Steam wallet cannot be used to give someone $20USD who can then go spend it on Pop Rocks. Ultimately it all funnels into buying games. When your product is the money storage, transfer, removal services, that's when you become a "financial service."
- onetimemanytime 7y agoThey can fine tune the law as much as they want
- bilbo0s 7y agoIf they'd make a simple HIPAA-like law that just criminalizes outright the sharing of personal data for commercial purposes, we wouldn't have to worry about fine tuning to catch privacy corner cases. No one even tries to wiggle or weasel out of HIPAA violations because the law is simple and none of the big shot hospital CEO's want to spend any time in prison. All the hospital employees are well aware of what will happen if they violate a patient's privacy as well. We need that same thing for all personal data, not just our medical data. Perfect example of politicians giving us truckloads of junk we never asked for, like this "Keep Big Tech out of Toilet Paper Printing" or whatever, while at the same time giving us absolutely no part of what we do want, privacy protection.
- cmiles74 7y agoI do think part of the reason that health service companies and insurance companies adhere to HIPAA is because it helps them keep their customers "locked in" to their product. It is often used as an excuse to prevent the digital transmission of health care data from one provider to another ("they gave me a CD with my data to give to my new doctor") and to prevent people from leaving "the network". These are companies that have very real incentives to avoid sharing data with each other, indeed, the more data each holds hostage the more powerful it becomes (hence the consolidation in the field). That seems very different to me from how advertising companies function and make money.
- Mirioron 7y agoWould this also affect Visa and MasterCard?
- Robotbeat 7y agoIt seems very particularly targeted at Libra. I don’t think it’d effect either company.
- yohann305 7y agoI have met engineers from Visa and American Express and they are as knowledgable as their counterparts in the said "tech companies" and do work on bleeding edge tech. In other words, the proposition to bar tech companies from offering financial services is a joke. How can you tell what a tech company is? Every company uses tech in some way shape or form.
- liopleurodon 7y agoThis ^
- runeks 7y agoIsn’t a banking license mandatory for a company that offers financial services? And if so, why does it matter what else a company does as long as it lives up to regulations? If it’s problematic that a licensed tech company is offering financial services, isn’t there something wrong with the requirements for acquiring this license? Seems to me that if Facebook lives up to the regulations, it should be allowed to acquire a banking license. And if there’s something problematic about this, the requirements for acquiring a banking license should be changed, and applied to everyone.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Isn’t a banking license mandatory for a company that offers financial services? No, banking is a subset of financial services, and not all financial services firms are banks.
- wil421 7y agoPayPal is a good example of a financial service company that’s not a bank.
- runeks 7y agoBut they need a license, right?
- dragonwriter 7y agoPayPal is a money transmitter, which requires a different federal license than a state or federal banking license.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wheelerwj 7y agoThats not 100% true. Paypal may very well own a bank, or at the very least cooperates with a bank, to stay in compliance with some of the services its offers. Financial services companies are often a complex arrangement of licensed and/or white-labeled services that are necessary to maintain compliance with regulations in the multitude of jurisdictions in which they operate.
- wheelerwj 7y agoI work in FinTech and I love this idea. Banks and other Financial institutions have incredibly strict data compliance and personal privacy laws that preclude them from using customer data the same way the current large tech companies do (facebook and google specifically). The laws limit both the type of advertising including the language and representations/disclaimers, as well as the scope in which their "sales history" can be used or distributed to other vendors/firms/partners. This type of service flies directly in the face of the Google and Facebook's business models, there is absolutely a good reason to fear how these advertising giants will abuse customer financial data. These services MUST be kept separate for the health of society. On a personal note, Facebook was just used to overthrow the democratic process in the US and the UK, possibly in other nations as well. They certainly need to demonstrate the ability to control their existing products before they are given even greater responsibility. I love what David Marcus is doing and the idea of a crypto currency can do the world a lot of good. But not in Facebooks hands or in the hands of any other advertising giant.
- alienallys 7y agoNot long ago Facebook was praised especially in "White" countries media on how Facebook was helping establish "democracy" in "third-world" or "non-white" countries. Tired of this 'not in my backyard' mentality' of US polity.
- nwah1 7y agoYou're assuming that the same people are doing the praising and complaining. In my experience, the people who don't like Facebook, don't like what they are doing anywhere. The people who like Facebook, who I assume are mainly those with a financial interest, are pretty happy about Facebook in general.
- paulddraper 7y agoAh yes, as a longtime Wells Fargo customer, I am aware how great financial institutions are with their customers.
- aasasd 7y agoHuh? It seems every second company that has a website now tries to be a financial middleman, not even counting the cryptocoins. Open an account with McBank to pay for your burger! Oy, we now have a bazillion of customers' dollars on our hands, that we get to hold for five minutes each. Better invest them in the meantime, I guess. Anyway, the quotes in the articles are so vague that they have no chance or regulating anything.
- ativzzz 7y agoRetail has been doing this for a long time. Every single retail store seens to have their own credit card.
- fartzzz 7y agoit seems that the US financial regulations are 1 big mess of patches. (For an uninformed outsider like me). For example are onion futures are made illegal, The Pattern day trading rule seems strange, gift cards etc. it seems problematic that there is a need for creating very specific regulations when it’s about financial services. This seems way too specific to be able to uphold and cause uncertainty for startups. It is not possible to create a more broad regulations?
- sjg007 7y agoI wonder what the specific worry is? Anti-trust? How is this different than being a different payment network?
- ptah 7y agoquite a few large investment banks have the refrain that they are technology companies first. will this impact them?
- aj7 7y agoThe financial services industry sees an existential threat. So they respond with lobbyists.
- hanniabu 7y agoYup, I wonder how much of this has to do with the advancements and progression of blockchain technology.
- Shivetya 7y agofinancial services industry? try the governments of the world. a currency outside of their control that is supported by a well known agency, in this case its obviously facebook, would be just another nail in the coffin for them. look, government, namely the politicians, all truly upset that the facebooks, google, and more, of the world, give anyone the opportunity to get a message out. decades ago the politicians could reliably count on the press of their nations to always pony up. they have lost control of the message mostly, they are trying to claw it back under the guise of protecting privacy , elections, children, and puppies. they damn well will get in front of any attempt which could affect their control over any means of wealth transfer. even regulated and taxed they would lose manipulation of currency to implement policy.
- draw_down 7y agoDon't think that's it. If they were really so worried, they'd just buy whatever concerned them so much.
- todaysmistakes 7y agoI would be okay with them adding some oversight for online mortgage brokers. I was recently shopping to refi my home and it is dark and shady shopping for a mortgage online. Even the bigger name brokers like Loan Depot, Better, Amerisave, Rocket Mortgage were pushing documents through stages that they had no right to and were attempting to have me sign my wife's name. It wasn't just one-off, it seems to be the standard operating procedure for them.
- dean177 7y agoThe title is incorrect. “A large platform utility may not establish, maintain, or operate a digital asset that is intended to be widely used as medium of exchange, unit of account, store of value, or any other similar function, as defined by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System,” Its specifically targeted at currencies (libra and perhaps things like xbox points?). Not all financial services.
- paulddraper 7y agoA closer to correct tile would be "US proposes barring tech companies from offering currencies"
- conanbatt 7y agoI find these laws that make BS criteria like "Above X billing" to be a grotesque violation of the rule of law. Clearly they want to apply rules to a specific company, but it would be too crude to say "FANG" and create criteria that apply only to the "FANGS".
- buboard 7y agoAbsolutely. The US needs to protect the banks and Visa
- dooglius 7y agoI wish the Constitution prevented laws from discriminating on the basis of size or industry, the law should only be able to determine what conduct is or is not permitted.
- PorterDuff 7y agoHow would you deal with antitrust?
- dooglius 7y agoDon't require being a monopoly as a condition, just regulate anticompetitive behavior. For instance, I think it is a flaw that Microsoft is prevented from bundling a browser on Windows while Apple gets off Scott-free for much more egregious behavior on iOS.
- cameronbrown 7y agoThis makes so much sense if it's actually possible. It also means we can keep useful companies like Amazon around while keeping them in check.
- Communitivity 7y agoIn today's age, can we make the distinction between a tech company and a non-tech company? How many B2B digital services does JP Morgan Chase offer, how many consumer-facing digital services? Does that make them a tech company as well as a financial institution? I think this may be a knee-jerk reaction to the rise in crypto-currency adoption, and Facebook's launch of Libra. Rethinking it, this could also be taking aim at Amazon.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoAlso, it seems like this would make relatively sensible financial services from tech companies harder to get. Apple Pay/Google Pay, for example. A smartphone company is a perfectly logical choice to push for smartphone-based payments. I don't think that's the kind of thing we'd want to regulate away. Sometimes, vertical integration can be a good thing, because for some spaces the alternative requires so much coordination that it's awkward and clumsy. If you look at Tesla's supercharger network, for example. The very fact that there are no really serious competitors yet that are not tied to a specific brand of electric car demonstrates how lack of vertical integration can be a major impediment for chicken-and-egg-type problems. And while I'm sure there eventually will be, just having Tesla out there in the forefront is useful as a leading example.
- hedora 7y agoPresumably car manufacturers are also “tech companies”, along with online-only banks + lenders.
- Cuuugi 7y agoGoogle is a heavy investor in Credit Karma if memory serves.
- 0xDEFC0DE 7y agoIt's a pretty ridiculous solution for a real problem IMO. I'm leaning towards tinfoil-hat on this one. This proposal exists for some other nefarious reason.
- ticmasta 7y ago
- jdlyga 7y agoWhere does Bloomberg fall in this? They're a tech company, but they're also a financial company.
- brokensegue 7y agobut they aren't one of the evil ones, apparently
- umeshunni 7y agoBut their revenues are less than $25B, which is the arbitrary limit set in this proposal.
- deepakhj 7y agoSears, the original amazon, offered many financial services. Sears -> Discover (founded) H&R Block (located in stores) Dean Witter (acquired) Allstate (founded)
- monocularvision 7y agoIn the interest of discussing the actual proposal and not the headline of this article, here is a link to the draft: https://www.scribd.com/document/417056845/Keep-Big-Tech-out-of-Finance-Act-Discussion-Draft https://www.scribd.com/document/417056845/Keep-Big-Tech-out-...
- cheriot 7y agoBanks are going to love this. It's called regulatory capture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture Less threat of competition just means their margins get to stay high. I'd rather be looking for ways financial regulations can encourage more players to enter the market.
- OrgNet 7y agoThey would finally be able to take care of Paypal.
- mandelbrotwurst 7y agoWould $1M per day be a large enough penalty to discourage Facebook from pursuing Libra? For comparison, MasterCard's annual revenue is $12.5B.
- oarabbus_ 7y agoRobinhood is a tech company which offers financial services. What does this bill even mean?
- tracker1 7y agoWhile I don't want Libra at all... the framing of this is pretty absurd and overly broad, having not read the proposed legislation. That said, given the path that technology as a sector has taken to censor and deplatform people based on their political alignment, I'm not sure I'm really supportive of any potential currency exchange that does not stay out of any discussions of legally protected speech. I don't agree with most of those that would be cast out, but potentially not being able to pay for housing, utilities, bills, taxes or buy food is a pretty big deal.
- squirrelicus 7y agoIt's easy to ridicule this post, as this comment section demonstrates, but there's a point hidden behind the apparent ignorance insofar as cnbc has reported it. Startup culture has demonstrated that they are uninterested in following and very interested in subverting long standing regulations that exist for good reasons. It's not clear how to solve this problem, and there's a certain quasilibertarian bias that legitimizes it, as the federal register is incomprehensibly large, such that only long established networks of expensive lawyers can wrangle it, which stifles innovation. The difficult part, however, is making the case that innovation ought to happen in this space anyway.
- CryptoPunk 7y ago>>subverting long standing regulations that exist for good reasons. Do you have evidence that they exist for good reason? It seems to be central economic planning, based on the delusional idea that cookie-cutter rules designed to regiment every class of interactions will preempt misbehavior and promote socially beneficial behaviour. The opportunties for special interests to stifle competition with regulations are replete, so there are many explanations for regulations existing besides their being in the public interest.
- webninja 7y agoIf Facebook’s Libra is successful, it would benefit every American tremendously by strengthening the American Dollar. Up until now the USA’s main export has been the American Dollar.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoConsumers should decide whether they use the banking services of tech companies, not politicians or regulators.