17 ms·
Many Americans who live paycheck to paycheck blame debt
- ponzifighter483 7y agoLiving paycheck to paycheck? 1. Downgrade everything you own. Car and house are the main things. You don’t need that BMW. Get a shitty Toyota. 2. Sell the house and move back in with your parents. If you have too much pride, then downgrade to a smaller place. Pocket the savings. 3. Pay off all your debt and student loans if you have any. Ask your parents to help you out. Swallow your pride. 4. Work towards a better job. Go back to school if necessary. For example, you could get an MBA. Laziness is your enemy. Take advantage of your resources and network. If I can do it, so can you.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> Go back to school if necessary. Does anybody ever need to take on copious amounts of student debt? I feel like I have some friends who have bachelors and were able to do it debt/scot free, and then I have friends who have $80k in debt with little to show for it because that's what they chose.
- Avamander 7y agoIt depends on the country, quite a few countries offer re-education for people when they're jobless.
- nexuist 7y ago>Get a shitty Toyota What if I have a shitty Toyota? >Sell the house As if I could afford a house, lol... >Pay off all your debt and student loans if you have any "Why are you so depressed? Just don't be sad, idiot!" >Ask your parents to help you out What if my parents are as broke as I am? >Go back to school if necessary And take on more debt that I'm supposed to pay off? >Laziness is your enemy My enemy is a system hijacked by the rich to smash and grab as many systems and institutions that are supposed to help poor people as possible. >Take advantage of your resources and network I have no money. All my friends are poor. If I didn't go to college, where am I supposed to find these rich friends to get me job references? If I can't afford to go to a bar or a simple restaurant, how am I supposed to spend time with anyone who could help me out? - I'm not actually the person above. But you must understand why people do not like these common tips you give. It is not because they are lazy, but because they do not have the escape hatches you have/had. They are angry that you think everyone has the luxury of getting a personal bailout from your family members, or that everyone owns a car like a BMW. I say this as someone in your own position. I have a good car, good apartment, parents who helped pay my student loans, and they even covered my lawyer fees when I tried to start my first LLC. I am in a luxurious position that millions of my fellow citizens would envy. Yes, of course my parents worked hard, they came to this country in 1999 with $0 in their pockets and worked their way up to managerial positions eventually being able to buy a house in a wonderful neighborhood with three (three!) non-beater cars. I like to think that I work hard. But the opportunities given to me by having good parents, a strong financial background, being in a calm, safe neighborhood, and especially having a pass-me-down car? Those were free. I didn't work for those. It was complete luck that I ended up with parents who gave me these things. Luck, not work. That's privilege.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> I didn't work for those But your parents did. > What if my parents are as broke as I am? Sounds like they didn't work as hard/get as lucky as your parents?
- zbentley 7y agoWhat is your point exactly? My initial interpretation is that you're saying the equivalent of "tough shit, sucks for you", which ignores the negative impact of poverty on the rest of society at best, and is actively inhumane/callous at worst.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoHow did your parents start with $0 but get "lucky" enough to work their way up some kind of occupational ladder to the point where they could live in a home and have 3 cars? Why aren't those same opportunities available for everybody in your opinion? They were available for your parents.
- gridlockd 7y ago> Pay off all your debt and student loans if you have any. Paying back student loans seems like a bad idea, what if the Democrats win and forgive student loan debt? You'll be left holding the bag. > For example, you could get an MBA. With another student loan? > If I can do it, so can you. Perhaps, but if I was living paycheck to paycheck, I'd be in "good company" with the federal government, local governments, corporate America and the majority of the general population. That's a pretty big interest group. I have a feeling there's a big debt jubilee coming up...
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> I have a feeling there's a big debt jubilee coming up... I would recommend not living as if you expect that to happen...
- gridlockd 7y agoPerhaps, but I would also recommend not living as if you expect that it won't happen.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>Paying back student loans seems like a bad idea, what if the Democrats win and forgive student loan debt? You'll be left holding the bag.... This is an extremely bad way to think about handling your financial future. I feel like too many people engage in these risky bets not only with student loans, but also with investments. But consider, what if student loans are not forgiven? Here you would sit at, what? 40, or 45, not having paid anything on your loans. That's a horrible idea. With all gambles like that, what's foremost in your mind should be: "The market can stay irrational much longer than you can stay solvent."
- sokoloff 7y agoAt this point, I think the risk that the student loan giveaway will happen is quite low. Nevertheless, if my kids were older and in or done with college, I’d counsel them to pay the minimum on student loans and save the rest that they might otherwise pay in a taxable account just on the small chance the student loan forgiveness actually happens. There’s nothing inherently better about paying down student debt if the alternative is investing in a broad based equity fund (VTSAX, VTI, etc). There is something better about paying down debt if the alternative is consumption with that money.
- bluedino 7y agoTitle appears to be “Many Americans who live paycheck to paycheck blame debt”
- dang 7y agoChanged now. The submitted title was "Here's why so many Americans can't handle a $400 unexpected expense", which is in the URL. URLs are often a source of better titles but in this case I'd say it was baitier.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoI think there is an order of "debt" that is acceptable: 1. Unless you go out and buy a house way out of your budget, or you buy a house that was in your budget then lose some/all of the income you previously had, being in debt to a mortgage really shouldn't cripple you under normal circumstances. 1. Having a car payment is pretty socially acceptable. Some people get the latest and greatest every 2-3 years either through leasing or trading in. Hopefully, there are not tons of people in crippling debt because they want the latest and greatest $40k-$60k SUV. I'm sure there are plenty of people in the "I have crippling debt" group who couldn't even afford a car payment. 1. Medical bills. I'd imagine nobody is going to criticize you if you are genuinely in debt because you had to pay to stay alive/keep a sane quality of life that is free from disease/ailment. 1. Student loans. You don't have to go take out $60k-$80k in loans to get a degree to get a job, but a lot of people do. Some people take out loans, then go spend the money on Amazon/vacations/cars. They get to cry they have student loan debt, but did they do the most efficient things possible with the money? 1. Credit card debt. On one hand, you have people who need to protect themselves from financial ruin. With inadequate savings, they turned to their line of credit. That's fine. Emergencies happen. But... what percentage of credit card debt holders (which I'd imagine is one of the most popular/crippling forms of debt in America) are solely in credit card debt because they only used it in an emergency? How many of those people are making day to day sacrifices to try to "get back above water"? How many people are in debt because... they just enjoy being a consumer and spending money.
- war1025 7y agoOut of curiosity the other day, I picked up a magazine that said "How to get out of debt". But the entire contents were basically what you just wrote. Seems like a defeatist bate-and-switch to sell a magazine specifically on how to get out of debt and then have it actually say, "just kidding. you'll be in debt forever. There is no escape"
- Edmond 7y agoOne perhaps not so hidden cost of American life that I wish someone prominent would seriously investigate is the cost associated with car ownership. I suspect over the course of a lifetime car ownership could easily be the most ruinous financial baggage that a lot of people incur.
- diminoten 7y agoWhat makes you think this? There are lots of sites/people who do "total cost to own" and the numbers they come up with aren't ruinous amounts as far as I can tell.
- Edmond 7y agoI have owned cars for over 20 yrs so I have a pretty good sense of just what a hole in my pocket the whole thing is :) There are all sorts of costs associated with car ownership beyond mere purchase cost and repairs...things like fines associated with cars that fall more heavily on poorer people...there is just A LOT of cost associated with cars.
- hhs 7y agoYou write: "There are all sorts of costs associated with car ownership beyond mere purchase cost and repairs". Service and maintenance is another one. I have colleagues who, overall, like the Uber and Lyft lifestyle, even when facing the occasional cancellations. I'm curious if there are empirical studies done on the overall benefits and costs of owning vs leasing vs ridesharing?
- diminoten 7y agoI don't... understand what you're talking about. Sure there are additional costs to owning a car, but you're not really explaining how they're so commonly ruinous to a person's financial well being. So far all you've given me is a few worst case scenarios, but what about the average scenario? What's the normal car ownership process like in your mind, and how does that average situation teeter so close to the edge of ruin, as you say?
- mdorazio 7y agoLooks like this article is trying to reconcile the multiple conflicting studies on this topic, especially around some of the wording of the questions. Here's the key takeaway: "Many of the people who have $400 or more available to them likely have already earmarked that money for another obligation (and so, in other words, the cash isn’t really available to them)." So if you're not in a good position, what little money you have in savings is already going to go somewhere else by the end of the month, and adding an expense on top of that would require an additional debt of some kind. It's still not clear to me, though, how credit cards factor into this since many people put any significant expense on their credit card rather than writing checks/handing over cash.
- TomMckenny 7y agoThe article repeatedly mentions credit cards as debit but not mortgages (or rental expense). But it seems unlikely that credit cards are the biggest debt/financial-obligations people hold.
- whatshisface 7y agoMortgages tend to be equal to rent in the long run due to efficient market reasons. Credit card debt is especially ruinous because unlike mortgages and car loans, there's no asset for the bank to go after if you default. As a result the interest rates are naturally higher because the people who roll over their balance month to month have to pay for the people who go bankrupt at a casino.
- TomMckenny 7y agoI do not claim credit card debt is smarter than a mortgage. I claim it is a far smaller percentage of personal debt. For example, reducing housing cost by a few percent would have a vastly greater effect than reducing any other source of debt by the same percent. If a person is in debt, it's not primarily because they bought a latte, it's because housing cost are high. So if we're looking at debt per se, then it's housing we should be looking look at.
- gridlockd 7y ago> Mortgages tend to be equal to rent in the long run due to efficient market reasons. Not really, the property price and mortgage rate you pay is what you individually agreed to, not whatever the "efficient market" says it may be on average "in the long run". There's tons of macro factors that are currently driving real estate prices well beyond what's justified by potential rent income. You're most likely better off renting.
- 11thEarlOfMar 7y agoFor some reason, I am reminded of the paradox of more hard disc space. Or more lanes on the highway. Any time to capacity is increased, it seems to get consumed and before long, you're out of space again. This presents a difficulty that perhaps researchers and pollsters can tease out: How many of these cash-poor people genuinely are earning enough to live comfortably vs. don't know enough or don't care enough to build savings, and instead, spend up to their income? Increase their income and they'll just increase their spending and be back where they started. It seems likely that we could take these numbers down substantially by improving financial management education. Or, simply accept that a large percentage of Americans want to live their life to the fullest that their income can allow.
- Retric 7y agoMore HDD space did eventually solve the problem for most people most of the time. Which I think is telling. People don’t need unlimited road capacity, but they do want more than a few minor improvements.
- marcosdumay 7y agoA thousand times that... But the matter with roads is different, because we will not see orders of magnitude improvement on road capacity, ever. What we need is completely different solutions, but it would be great if people pushing for city mobility weren't pushing against the one form of mobility that actually works most of the time.
- clairity 7y ago> "...roads [are] different, because we will not see orders of magnitude improvement on road capacity, ever." you don't need an orders of magnitude increase in capacity. doubling it is probably enough. you can do that by putting roads underground, right under existing roads. it's expensive, but we have concentrated and idle wealth that could be unleashed on it. let rich people who really want less congestion pay for it. people in LA willingly pay $20+ for one single-occupancy trip in the toll lanes.
- 7y ago
- tracer4201 7y agoI posted in a different thread on a similar topic the other day about how recent tax policy shifts helped me increase savings and pay less than 10% effective tax last year. My post was downvoted and flagged. If you already have wealth, the economy is working pretty well for you. If you’re in a low paying job, often times with irregular schedules and less than even 20 hours a week, you’re in a world of pain. I’m not sure what the solution to the problem is. Just discussing it at all has become so controversial.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> If you’re in a low paying job, often times with irregular schedules and less than even 20 hours a week, you’re in a world of pain. Who is to blame if you are only working a low paying job only 20 hours a week? By all means, it's not an easy world out there. But... wealth + opportunity isn't going to just fall from the sky? Maybe I am guilty of looking at things the wrong way? Curious to hear your thoughts. Hope I don't get downvoted... :/
- bilbo0s 7y ago>Who is to blame if you are only working a low paying job only 20 hours a week?... Without more information, we don't know? Does the company even offer low ranking employees more hours than that? Etc etc etc.
- zbentley 7y ago> Who is to blame if you are only working a low paying job I'd argue that it doesn't matter. Whether you take the position that it's the fault of parents/colleges/the education system/predatory lenders/politicians, or the position that it's primarily the fault of the individual, the reality remains that most people are staggeringly unable to change their circumstances. In general, income/class mobility in the US remains extremely low, especially when someone's first jobs are low income and they have no secondary assets. This is a life-long condition for many (and, arguably, often a multi-generational condition). Anecdotes to the contrary are a favorite conversation topic, but the lack of mobility remains. What (precious little) applicable information is present in up-by-your-bootstraps stories is either not actionable or not acted upon. I'd argue that "what if someone is to blame for their circumstances?" and "if I/$self_made_person_of_the_week got out of poverty, why can't you?" are both pointless questions. They attempt to find root causes for a symptom which, when addressed, makes discovery of the root cause a moot endeavor. People overwhelmingly don't get out of poverty. With a very few ascetic exceptions, there is not an affirmative choice being made to be poor--even in the most conservative interpretation, people are "irresponsible" rather than pro-poverty. Poverty causes suffering (to poor people and to many other layers of the social fabric, including non-poor people). Alleviating or removing suffering is within the power of the state and affluent people as a whole (from donations to social welfare/education programs to moonshots like UBI and a million other proven or plausible strategies). Who is culpable is not pertinent to the removal of the proximate suffering of poverty, and I suspect that after removing that proximate suffering, the culpability question would no longer be as relevant/interesting (historically/sociologically, maybe, but not as an answer to a widespread social need). To be clear, mobility (and the severity of poverty) used to be much, much worse in the US (and is still quite bad in many places). But the suffering remains. "You make your own problems" is as useless to point out to financially suffering people as "you just eat too much" is to point out to someone who has been 100kg overweight for 30 years. Solving the immediate suffering has an effect.
- sneak 7y agoMany millionaires I know would struggle to come up with $400, too, if I passed them through a strong magnetic field outside of business hours.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoCould you elaborate?
- sneak 7y agoOur society is becoming increasingly cashless and even wealthy people for the most part seem to regard contingency plans as unimportant. It’s a bit of a tangent, but still related in an emergency planning sort of way. I have an essay pending about how the burden of proof of innocence is passed onto the account holder wrt access to funds in the bank; the money in your accounts isn’t really yours and the fail-closed nature of it is more dangerous than most people realize.
- caymanjim 7y agoThe article has nothing whatsoever to do with the notion of coming up with $400 in hard currency on-demand.
- PeterisP 7y agoIf a millionaire has a $400 unexpected expense, then they'd most likely pull out a credit card to pay it. Which is additional debt, and according to the article's definition it'd mean that they're "living paycheck-to-paycheck" since they'd take up additional debt for that expense. Heck, I have reasonable savings but I'd not touch them for an unexpected large expense because it's a hassle to touch any long term savings and using short-term credit for that is simpler, faster and cheaper than breaking a deposit or selling stock or whatever. It has everything to do with that notion - the definition used in this research is ridiculous; having $2000 of unused, readily available credit limit is the functional equivalent of having $2000 cash under your mattress. A $400 expense is going to reduce your net wealth/increase debt by definition, so if the answer to "what would you do for a $400 expense" is "duh, I'd borrow 400 because for me being able to borrow 400 on a short notice is simple and certain to succeed" then that's a quite reasonable answer that doesn't imply any financial problems whatsoever.
- dgzl 7y agoI think when people come across extra funds they just use it to upgrade their life. Maybe they buy the nicer soft drink and snack, they spend more time at the bar with friends, they decide to buy audio equipment or another computer monitor, or they incorporate an extra prepared meal into their regular routine. There are so many small ways to spend money that make us feel like we're living a better life, but when the dust settles the improvement was only temporary.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI knew someone like this. At the risk of being super rude, in a post bragging about their tax return and new Playstation, I asked why they weren't paying down the debt they were recently complaining about. I forget the exact words but it was basically, "I'm paying down the debt on misery and depression." It reminded me of some of the sadder parts of my time in university. Sometimes you need a little injection of joy and you try not to burst into tears as you type your debit PIN in, knowing this is basically all you've got left.
- GreeniFi 7y agoI sometimes wonder how easy it is for the average person to practice prudent financial management when the entire economy is geared towards getting you to spend what you can? The advertising sector and one-click buying works out how to isolate you from your herd and then hunt you down like a lion hunts down a sick gazelle, and you have little to no chance of hitting your monthly saving targets, with the big beasts of the digital economy after your last cent. If this hypothesis is correct, is there a business here? Financial sergeant major - helping you hit your saving targets. Imagine: “GET THE FUCK OFF AMAZON, YOU SHAMBOLIC EXAMPLE OF AN OVERGROWN MAN BOY! AT THIS RATE YOU’LL DIE A POOR VIRGIN”. Business model: pay my automated system a % of the money it saves you every month. “NOW DOWN AND GIVE ME TEN”.
- lonelappde 7y agoThat business is called "power of attorney" -- you sign over your assets to someone you trust. Problem is the person you trust could steal from you, or just charge a lot for their time and effort.
- repolfx 7y agoTwo problems with that. Firstly if you want to personify the economy (don't), it has always been "geared towards getting you to spend what you can", from the first markets in antiquity through medieval times. Nothing about the modern economy is new. And please don't talk to me about targeted ads - the entire point of ad targeting is to avoid showing ads to people who aren't likely to purchase something. They're a way to utilise advertising budgets more effectively, but they aren't "hunting you down like a lion hunts down a sick gazelle". Nice imagery though. Second problem is that there are plenty of modern economies where average people are good at saving money. Germany is the most obvious example: it's the saving savannah of Europe. Germans saving too much money is actually regularly cited by (bad) economists as a macro-scale problem for all of the Eurozone. But Amazon exists in Germany, it has the internet and retailers. They are just financially responsible. Another good example is Switzerland. It doesn't run a budget deficit, it usually runs a small surplus: https://tradingeconomics.com/switzerland/government-budget https://tradingeconomics.com/switzerland/government-budget The Swiss government is also highly democratic, so presumably the Swiss people like it that way (well, sometimes they get annoyed if the surplus gets too big of course). Way too many people these days talk about ordinary retail businesses as if they had magical mind controlling powers. They don't. But culture can make a big difference.
- frankbreetz 7y agoI would struggle to pay an unexpected 400 bill and would definitely put it on my credit card. This seems like a smart decision to me. When I put that bill on my credit card it affords me an extra 30-60 days to come up with the money. I am in the process of paying off debt, acquiring money generating assets. I would eventually like to be in situation to pay a bill like this, but it seems better pay off as much debt as possible. I guess if I lost my job I would be in bad situation, it is hard to start making money without taking some risks.
- gridlockd 7y agoThe definition of "couldn't handle" is wrong. Most people could handle it, it just would mean extra debt - but so what? Average US credit card debit is over $5000. Who cares about savings when you can just get more debt? The fact that credit card debt is at 18% during a historically low interest rate environment also implies that a lot of people simply don't pay back their debt. The flip side of it is that people are willing to work for lower wages, because a steady income - even if it is low - means you can get more debt! Finally, of this money that shouldn't even exist in the economy drives up prices for everything, the best example for this of course is student loans versus the cost of education.
- RickJWagner 7y agoAmericans are tremendous spenders. Pay someone 100k a year, they'll spend 101. Then complain it's their student loans that are weighing them down. Seriously, since the great recession the American economy has absolutely boomed. If someone hasn't made money in these last few years, it's most likely going to be their own fault.
- war1025 7y agoI find that the people who complain about the economy and how the rich are taking all the money while the poor get nothing, are the same people who don't bother to buy any stock. If the rich are getting all the real gains in the market, do what they do. Which is buy into the stock market and make money off equity and not time.
- siphon22 7y agoDamn, if only I knew I just had to have 50k laying around to invest in stocks to not be poor...you figured it out! We have to let the world know about this.
- war1025 7y agoAs an example, I have a friend who just took out a $30k loan on a car because "interest is only 2% anyway, so might as well buy something with the money instead". I would guess that is an extremely common view for people to have. Yes there are people in actual poverty. But there are also many people who just think there is nothing to do with money besides spend it.
- mlguy456 7y agoTBH, 50k wouldn't help. It's a petty amount of money when it comes to investments. On average you can aim at 3% per year. That should be enough to support your lifestyle which is 30k if you are ok with being frugal. Would you live like a homeless if you had 1M in your investments accounts? No, you'd be paying off mortgage on a nice house while figuring out how to make more money, deal with inflation and rapidly rising property taxes, so you won't end up on streets when you retire. If 50k could solve your problems, I'd give it to you now because I believe that fixing someone's life is worth way more than 500 hundred dollar bills.
- gingabriska 7y agoI am living in India now and I realize how many things are very hard to get here. If India had a market like America, I am pretty sure most people in India would love to go into debt to experience the products and service which market has to offer. Here if I've to get something, either I've to import and pay import duties and IGST which effectively doubles the price of product and it's headache to deal with customs. Often it's not possible to find interesting products on local market as a techy.
- thekingshorses 7y ago> living in India now and I realize how many things are very hard to get here. What are the things is hard to get in India? There are tons of people in India spend/go into debt to buy a fancy motorcycle, card or cloths or house. Millions of people are in Debt. Thousands of farmers suicide every year because of debts. They may not buy the same thing as Americans, but a lot of people do live paycheck to paycheck.
- pmiller2 7y agoYou don't need debt to explain this: * Median US home price, $227k * Median US rent, $1400/month * Median US household income, $61k * Median US individual income, $31k All these facts are one google search away, on the front page. No need for a study to explain it.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoI'm confused. What picture does this paint? 20% of a $227k home is $45.4k down Zillow estimates that mortgage (with insurance + taxes) to be $1,230. A $170 premium to rent versus own seems like a wonderful price to pay to not have to come up with a $45k down payment. Are you saying houses are too expensive, or wages are too low?
- qes 7y ago> Are you saying houses are too expensive, or wages are too low? Median housing cost is 54% of median income. That's.. high. The general recommendation is 30%. > A $170 premium to rent versus own seems like a wonderful price to pay to not have to come up with a $45k down payment. On the other hand, you'll be building equity with a house instead of building someone else's equity with rent. And housing prices don't always go up, but they mostly do. 11 years into a $210k house and I'm walking with nearly $100k after subtracting maintenance costs (carpeting, dishwasher, washer/dryer, water heater, roof, gutters, interior drywall repair, and exterior paint). Total mortgage payments have been about $190k. So I effectively paid $750/month to live in a 2000+ sq ft, 4 bedroom, 2 car attached garage house in a first-ring suburb of our state's metro area (renting it would be well over $2k/month) and I have a nice pile of cash I otherwise wouldn't have saved.
- thekingshorses 7y agoInsurance, property taxes, maintenance adds up. Usually, you need at least $45k income to buy a $227k house. It is hard for a family of 4 to save $45k when they are living paycheck to paycheck.
- _ah 7y ago
- proee 7y agoTwo of my friends surprisingly told me they live paycheck to paycheck on salaries well into the six digit range. When I asked why, they both said "that's just how they've always lived." So having the discipline to save a little is clearly a challenge for them, despite having a very good income.
- rofo1 7y agoI know a lot of people like this. A lot! And they are not traditionally dumb either (about other things). It's amazing; it's like they are under some kind of spell and can't see right before their eyes, just when it comes to this. Frugality and being content with what you have goes a long way. People should stop comparing themselves to other people. That explosive emotional combination of greed and envy is behind so many bad financial decisions.
- lovehashbrowns 7y agoThat's me! I make a ton of money for where I am NOW, but there are certain circumstances that made it so that I'm now just trying to recover. Logically, I always knew that every single step I was taking would lead me to this. Emotionally, it didn't matter and I'd be able to deal with it.
- luckylion 7y agoThere's a difference between "all I'd need to do to put a thousand or more dollars aside each month is to not party hard each weekend" and "all I'd need to do to put a thousand or more dollars aside each month is to not pay rent or not buy food" though, isn't there?
- rofo1 7y ago"well into 6 figures" Do you understand how much money that is? Compared to the rest of the world population, I mean. Please don't tell me these people cannot food and rent.
- 7y ago
- tempsy 7y agoIf you take a look at the top finance apps there’s a disturbing number of “bridge loan” apps that are meant to front you money between paychecks.
- ericd 7y agoLargely a result of NIMBYism keeping home construction figures near economic centers low, resulting in a huge demand-supply imbalance, forcing renters into a bidding war for access to those markets, causing much of the surplus to go to landlords. Also, the treatment and legislation of housing as an investment asset class rather than as a life necessity. And then there's the healthcare industry, swallowing much of the real wage gains in recent decades in the form of rapidly rising insurance costs (cleverly decoupled from peoples' paycheck, so they feel like it doesn't cost them anything). And, of course, designing most of our cities to require that people maintain enormously expensive personal cars, or waste hours per day navigating sub-par mass transit systems. There are myriad other causes (advertising, consumer culture, extremely expensive infrastructure, government writing blank checks to universities, etc etc), but I think these are the majors.
- WalterBright 7y agoMy father was career Air Force. Once he was ordered to help privates who were having trouble with their finances. They were paid every 2 weeks, and it was embarrassing to the AF for them not being able to pay their bills in the wider community. My dad phrased it as half the privates had no trouble, the other half had steak and alcohol the first week, beans and begging for handouts the second. All the privates had the same pay, lived in the same base housing, etc. He said the feast/famine group simply could not control their spending impulses.
- otoburb 7y agoOut of curiosity, was your father able to help the feast/famine group in any way, or able to convince them to change their behaviour, short of the AF switching that specific group of privates to weekly paychecks instead of bi-weekly?
- WalterBright 7y agoNo, he said he failed miserably. He'd work out budgets with them, and they'd never stick to them. I suppose it's like a nutritionist giving out meal plans. People never follow them.
- echelon 7y agoThat's sad. I wonder how many people out there can't control their impulses. I also wonder how much of our economy depends on people spending beyond their means. Technically nobody needs to buy anything beyond bare necessities.
- magicalhippo 7y agoMy buddy is similar. He's got a decent enough salary, not a lot of mortgage, should be just fine. Not long ago he complained that he'd been eating instant noodles for two weeks straight because he was short on cash, and was looking forward to next payday. Literally the day after he called me up to tell me about the new GPU he'd bought. Payday had arrived. He'd immediately bought another 2080 Ti, so now he could run SLI! This is a guy who hardly plays games, and when he does it's like Diablo 3 or Civilization. And guess what was for dinner at the end of that month, again... I do impulse purchases as well. But not with purchases of that magnitude. Almost always I manage to restrain myself, take a few rounds. Almost always I end up not buying. And because of that, the very few times I allow myself to go wild, I can handle it without sweating.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- adrianmonk 7y agoThis research seems pretty obvious, or at least it doesn't tell me anything that's surprising. All I get out of it is that if your policy is to ride really close to the edge (between income and spending), and if you have credit available to you, then there will be times when you take on debt. OK, but what else would you expect? Some people are meticulous about finances, and some people aren't. Do you expect the people who aren't meticulous to constantly track both credit card balance and bank balance, then stop making credit purchases the moment they don't have the cash to back it? By definition, it's the sort of thing they don't typically do. With no process to prevent it, of course sometimes the credit card balance will grow larger. In other words, this doesn't really show that debt is the cause of the inability to come up with $400. It might be, if someone cannot reduce their expenses or increase their income, which of course is true for some people. But in general all it means is that they haven't, not that they can't.
- briantakita 7y agoIncome tax makes it difficult to catch up once you get behind.
- war1025 7y agoI never understood this mindset. All of my budgeting / financial calculations are based on the amount of money that shows up in my bank account each week. That number is significantly lower than what I"m "paid", but is the actual number that matters from a financial point of view. I have friends who like to talk about how much they make per year and how that means they can afford x,y,z. But it's always the sticker price, not the in the bank amount after all the taxes and benefits are taken out.
- superkuh 7y agoDebt literally is the problem. Specifically the creation of the money supply only by a select group of corporate banks. The practice of fractional reserve banking means they literally create money out of thin air as debt when they "give" out loans. This means that there will always be significantly more debt and money owed than money in circulation. And literally all of the value of the newly created money goes to the corporate banks. The problems in our society stem from this universal basic income for corporate bank persons.
- pessimizer 7y agoI honestly must be missing something about both this article and this discussion thread. > The Survey of Household Economics and Decision Making asks people how they would pay for an unforeseen $400 expense. If a respondent said they simply wouldn’t be able to or would have to borrow money, sell something or neglect other bills to do so, they were included in the share of people for whom coming up with the money would be a challenge, which added up to that alarming 40%. Yet the Survey of Consumer Finances, which asks respondents for their bank account balance, found the share of households who have less than $400 in their checking or savings accounts was closer to 20%. > For some reason, many people who had $400 on hand still said they’d struggle to come up with the money. “We were scratching our heads,” Chen said. What if that $400 (or even $1400) were for rent, or utility bills? Wouldn't it be obvious that you have to borrow money, sell something, or not pay a bill in order to use $400 of it? What's the confusing part? Also, I guess you could call your utility bills (but not your rent) debt, but that wouldn't be a normal usage. This article, and the vast response to it (which I can't connect to the fairly empty content) is confusing to me. Are they saying something I'm not seeing? edit: I mean, more than once in my life, I've had more than the money I've needed to cope with an unexpected event in the bank, and I sold something in order to pay for it, because no money fairy was coming before the end of the month to keep me off the street.
- soVeryTired 7y ago> What if that $400 (or even $1400) were for rent, or utility bills? I guess the key word here is unexpected - as in, outside of what you've budgeted for.
- cowsandmilk 7y agoI think parent was saying that the people who have over $400 in their account may already have it earmarked for rent or other bills. If my monthly rent is $1200 and I have $600 in my account, it doesn’t mean I have $400 I could spend in an emergency
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vgaldikas 7y ago>For some reason, many people who had $400 on hand still said they’d struggle to come up with the money. “We were scratching our heads,” Chen said. What exactly made them scratch head? I mean if you have 400 in account, doesn't mean you can just willy nilly spend it on unexpected expense. Maybe this 400 have to last you till the end of month