21 ms·
Libra, 2 Weeks In
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI have been following Libra very closely, and have read their white paper twice. There have been a few good discussions here on HN when it launched [0], but I think most of these have been very biased against anything Facebook-related. I find the launch of Libra a really interesting "experiment", with potentially big negative or positive consequences for the entire world. Right now, it's really hard to judge on the technical merits (e.g. the Move language, or the architecture, or how they're going to transition to a truly permissionless and decentralized consensus). However, I think that it's wise to follow Libra's evolution with attention, as it might, and probably will, have consequences in our lives. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20210791 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20210791
- hajile 7y agoWhen you're talking about controlling money, politics matter more than "technical merit". Libra is invite only and they invited their business friends. Libra consortium is based in Switzerland, so the businesses involved have guaranteed essentially zero government oversight. Libra's owners have complete control over how much currency, the currency exchange rate, and even inflation rates (note that inflation is actually a tax on wealth). I can't regulate it. I can't get my government to regulate it. I can't get a non-partisan consortium to regulate it (eg, Bitcoin). Businesses proven to put profits first have complete control. I have everything to lose and nothing to gain. I don't care about the technical merit; everything about this stinks. EDIT: and all that is before the privacy aspect. While accounts may be "anonymous", Facebook can use their data to identify you anyway. I don't like these big date companies tracking my friends or website visits. I certainly don't want them tracking my money too. There's also the wrongthink aspect. Recent leaks from different companies seem to show them exerting political power and banning dissent. My political opinions may align with their now, but I'd bet anything that sooner or later, I'll disagree with them on something. I don't want my financial stability based on a platform that punishes me for thinking or believing "the wrong thing" (which could just be saying something critical about the companies in control). Libra giving economic power to companies is straight out of fascism.
- dmix 7y ago> Libra consortium is based in Switzerland, so the businesses involved have guaranteed essentially zero government oversight. Do you really think a massive US company using some Switzerland corporation is going to protect Facebook and their investors against any regulatory scrutiny?
- hajile 7y agoYes. Facebook is undoubtedly incorporated in other countries as well. The US could pressure Facebook, but they could move servers elsewhere. Even if they didn't, the US would have to pressure every single company involved. More importantly, the US can't just audit bank records from another country. They can't go after Facebook unless they can prove wrongdoing. Offshore accounts protect a lot of bad people for this very reason. Edit: There also the long term issue. If their currency takes off, the economic power it gives also shields them. Remember too big to fail? We can hardly manage the federal reserve where the government is actually part owner. The situation here would be much worse.
- dmix 7y agoThe US just prosecuted Walmart in US courts for stuff their Brazilian HQ did in Brazil. I'm sure the US could find a way to do the same for Facebook and their investors for how they're using Libra inside the US.
- carlosdp 7y ago> Libra is invite only and they invited their business friends. That's a big assumption. They were able to get their business friends to sign on, probably because they are already friends. I'm sure they asked a lot of other groups that were more hesitant, it would have made the initial announcement much more powerful. Also important to note non-profits, NGOs, and universities are included, and they don't have to pay the $10m buy-in. > and all that is before the privacy aspect. While accounts may be "anonymous", Facebook can use their data to identify you anyway... The way Libra is designed, that would probably be a lot more trouble than it is worth. Tracking methods without direct trackers (like 3rd-party cookies) work because there are many data points. Like in browser fingerprinting, you have user agents, JS feature availability, history, etc. With Libra, you only have an account address and transactions to other anonymous account addresses. One dimension of data like that would be very very hard to trace back to the user, without direct participation from many many merchants. > There's also the wrongthink aspect. Fair, however afaik only 1 of the 28 current companies (Facebook) has this attribute.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> with potentially big negative or positive consequences for the entire world. What are some of the biggest positive consequences potentially offered by Libra in your opinion?
- carlosdp 7y agoLiterally what they say it's designed for: giving access to the digital economy to the 500m+ people in emerging markets that have internet + phone, but no banking services.
- fbi-director 7y agoIt's dauntingly scary that people seem to have already forgotten that FB is known and has been ousted for abusing every bit of power and information they are given. And now you're excited that there's another aspect of your personal info, perhaps the most important part that they'll get (some kind of) control over? Increasing their power as a company overall as well.. Really mind blowing!
- carlosdp 7y agoI don't have to have a Facebook account to use Libra, I don't have to give them any additional information unless I use their app.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> giving access to the digital economy to the 500m+ people in emerging markets that have internet + phone, but no banking services. I don't really understand the flow. They are paid in cash for working their low wage jobs now. How is the cash going to become Libra? Through... what is basically a banking service? Which they don't have access to now?
- dx87 7y agoMight be like how people without a bank go to various businesses that will cash their check for a fee, except they'll give the business cash and get Libra transferred to their account.
- jammygit 7y agoFacebook is enough of a problem without letting them control part of the money supply too
- hndamien 7y agoShort of transaction speed and cost, there is so little that is appealing in this compared to Bitcoin, and it has all of the centralisation and compliance pitfalls that a neutral, free (liberty), decentralised money already avoids.
- emef 7y agoTransaction cost and speed are enormous problems for bitcoin, not sure why that would only be mildly appealing to solve. Not vouching for Libra, but my understanding of bitcoin was that it caps out at something ridiculously low like 11 transactions/second, which each cost multiple USD. Clearly that is the bottleneck that needs to be addressed by whatever would lead crypto moving forward (I remember reading visa processes more than 10k transactions/s).
- wmf 7y agoBitcoin is the oldest and thus technically least advanced cryptocurrency. There are plenty of coins that are much better than Bitcoin in terms of privacy and scalability; Libra should be compared against these.
- r32a_ 7y agoWrong. Bitcoin will use Lightning Network for most everyday transactions and it's speed is only limited by network liquidity and bandwidth
- diab0lic 7y agoGenuinely curious: Does the lightning network provide all of the same guarantees that the standard Bitcoin network provides? What are the downsides? Why isn't the lightning network used all the time instead of the Bitcoin protocol?
- politician 7y agoLightning is new, so that's part of the adoption story. It suffers from a centralization risk similar to banks (viz a viz using a well-connected intermediary via a wide channel to transmit to arbitrary addresses off chain with less pain that establishing a dedicated channel directly).
- r32a_ 7y agoLet's call this for what it really is, they want to replace democracy with Corporatism. At least with a government backed currency we get a choice on who runs the government. Even though that power is constantly being eroded. The companies that run Libra however have 0 obligation to users of Libra but only to maximise profits for their shareholders. This is their plan: * Dedicate a lot of resources to spread the adoption of Libra * Change the language of what Libra is. * Extract as much value as they possibly can from Libra users. The proof is simple, If FB and all of those companies dedicated resources to development and adoption of Bitcoin itself then it would be able to reach the goals of Libra and be more decentralised than Libra. David Marcus and the entire Facebook Libra team make me sick to my stomach.
- conanbatt 7y agoAs a non-Us national, I prefer FB corporatism to US democracy. Puts more people on even ground.
- r32a_ 7y agoOr choose Bitcoin and have neither :)
- brighter2morrow 7y agoChoose a third position? Go ahead, throw your vote away!
- dane-pgp 7y ago"Don't blame me — I voted for Kodos."
- spookthesunset 7y agoGreat until you bump up against that 7 transactions per second limit, the entire planet adopts it and and you get to wait multiple decades between transactions. And before you say “lightning network” do realize that LN doesn’t exist and even if it did your solution is to avoid using bitcoin. Setting aside you still have to make transactions on the bitcoin blockchain before you can even play ball with LN. Bitcoin/cryptocurrency is a giant scam marketed toward libertarians and certain STEM types. Why Facebook decided to hitch its horse to a giant scam is beyond me.
- mromanuk 7y agoCall me pessimist, but cartelized private global corporations owning and “printing” money can only bring bad things. It is centralized and is controlled by an elite.
- whatshisface 7y agoThe Fed isn't? It has more private board members than appointed board members, and some have argued that it has consistently prioritized the interests of the banks at the expense of encouraging leverage like cash is going out of style. This is closer to a battle between west coast elites and east coast elites than it is about the people versus the elites.
- sidlls 7y agoWell, The Fed is a bit different. It's not exactly a private corporation that is not beholden to the voting public. More importantly, though, is your note about who this battle is between: it's a battle between groups of people who should both be viewed very skeptically when it comes to the interests of "the rest of us". Corporate controlled money has been tried in the past; it didn't end well for workers.
- StudentStuff 7y agoCompany scrip has a long and nebulous history, its great for tethering your workers to the company town (and company store) while keeping them indebted and unable to leave: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_scrip https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_scrip
- dragonwriter 7y ago> It has more private board members than appointed board members Only in the world where 0 > 7; there are 7 members of the Board of Governors, all Senate-confirmed Presidential appointees.
- mbesto 7y agoEven if it isn't fully apparent, the people can vote out a president that controls the Fed. There is no such option to the "100 member companies". Also, the Fed is US only...so there's that. The scary thing about Libra is that it truly has the potential for global-scale "boil the frog" ramifications.
- lanrh1836 7y agoMy biggest question right now is how many people will want to use Libra enough to pass stringent KYC checks for a wallet like Facebook’s Calibra? You’ll need to give Facebook much more information than they have on a user today, such as photo ID, address, SSN, etc (depending on country). My cynical view is that Calibra is actually the real value to Facebook here, and they are betting that it will be the biggest wallet by far. It will allow Facebook to reconcile millions if not billions of identities in ways they have not been able to to this date.
- 0xDEFC0DE 7y ago>With Libra, anyone with a $40 smartphone and connectivity will have the ability to securely safeguard their assets, access the world economy, transact at a much lower cost, and over time access a whole range of financial services. Bad actors will lift old exploitative models into Libra's ecosystem: payday loans with huge interest rates, wallet services that force a deposit and allow you to overspend and charge fees when you do, sign up people for accounts and services that they don't want and make commissions. Or maybe just wallet/business services that straight up scam people and disappear with no repercussions. The thing you set out to kill will just come back with a new flavor. Plus it's even easier now since you can do it all with a single click! Then someone has to decide what to do with bad actors involved with Libra and allocate resources to actually enforce some actions against them (legislative, the cops, server bans, ISP bans, etc.). Now you've got those services paid by tax dollars dealing with a corporate currency and taking time away from other enforcement actions. All of this is going to happen at the juicy, vulnerable threshold where the technical controls interface with the human element. I probably won't ever hack Libra/Move itself, but the human part is still there. If I can actually manage to get away with the crime and transact with a fake identity, it can't be reversed. Bonus: that same $40 phone stops getting updated by a phone carrier and some drive-by malware swipes all of your LibraBucks with a corrupt text message and no one can reverse the transaction. Or maybe that Bloomberg supply-chain attack article will finally become a reality once there's enough economy behind Libra. If this is widely adopted, it's going to have a pretty steep learning curve and plenty of real losses for everyone.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoWhere does Libra claim it's transactions are non-reversible? And by reversible I mean refundable.
- 0xDEFC0DE 7y agoThat’s a blockchain thing. They can fork, but they aren’t going to do that if I lose $150 in Libra. If they can single reverse transactions, there’s really no point to it being a blockchain. If it’s refundable then they are just paying for the crime itself out of their own pockets. They will still need a human layer to verify theft has occurred and it isn’t a fraudulent claim of theft where just I stole from myself.
- seibelj 7y agoOne thing that’s been nice since the Libra announcement is the number of knee-jerk reaction “cryptocurrency is 100% useless and look at this NIST blockchain flow chart hurrr hurrrr” comments have mostly disappeared. It seems like crypto is not totally useless after all, but the biggest threat to humanity ever created... or something...
- b_tterc_p 7y agoLots of useless things can become useful if powerful people say they’re important now. It doesn’t say much about the underlying tech.
- danShumway 7y agoCrypto isn't the reason why Libra is dangerous, Facebook is. If Facebook was launching their own business-controlled currency that was backed by an SQL database, you'd see the exact same reaction. The crypto part is just an implementation detail, what people are actually upset about is corporations trying to seize control of our currency.
- antpls 7y agoCorporations are subjects to local laws, so what's the issue ? It seems people are afraid of the unknown more than Facebook. My personal questions : If anything goes wrong with the Libra scheme, who will be responsible ? Who would be fined / sent to prison ?
- gexla 7y ago> At the core, we believe that a network that helps move more cash transactions — where a lot of illicit activities happen — to a digital network that features regulated on and off ramps with proper know-your-customer (KYC) practices, combined with the ability for law enforcement and regulators to conduct their own analysis of on-chain activity, will be a big opportunity to increase the efficacy of financial crimes monitoring and enforcement. I wonder how many people in the world can pass a KYC check right this moment.
- hartator 7y agoKnow your customer is BS. It's just an excuse to invade your privacy and ask you personal questions.
- javert 7y agoThat's not true. People who don't do KYC to their customers go to prison. KYC exists for the same reason the drug war exists: People believe in paternalism and want to feel that there is some greater power that is in control. And there are people with guns and throw-you-in-prison capability who are happy to make it so.
- dymk 7y agoAnd all efforts to curb money laundering, and all AML compliance laws are just to invade your personal privacy and nothing more too, right?
- gonational 7y agoYes. The worst way to try to catch or curb money launderers is to create some kind of monetary system in which they will take no part. Gold will not cease to exist because of a corporate “cryptocurrency”? As long as there are any fungible value stores in existence, there will be money laundering.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shitgoose 7y agothe moment libra is exchanged for fiat, it is under scrutiny (know your client etc). fbi routinely nails various e-gold enterprises, where clients exchange fiat for tokens and freely transact tokens across the globe. all it takes is to open a couple of libra accounts and send a transaction with "hurt as many americans as possible" in the details. a lot of people were busted for a lot less than that. imagine high volume small denomination libra transactions between florida and colombia - fb will spend the rest of their days trying to explain to fbi they didn't mean no harm.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoThe FBI has no jurisdiction outside the US and you are right that cash is more safe to use for buying cocaine, ordering hit men, buying child pornography, etc. Libra is probably not going to be popular for that sort of thing. The irony of a distributed ledger is that it actually makes enforcement a lot easier. Facebook will simply point to the ledger and tell the FBI that "everything you need to know is public information". FB is also uniquely positioned to facilitate all the required KYC and AML processes. The reason governments are worried about Libra is not his but the fact that people might choose to no longer exchange for fiat. If you are transacting and earning Libra, why would you swap for dollars/euros and pay the transaction fees for that? This is a much bigger concern for governments than the black market economy.
- shitgoose 7y ago"The FBI has no jurisdiction outside the US" tell this to Vinnik, a Russian national who was arrested in Greece on behalf of FBI and extradited to US:) if FB starts enforcing KYC, then the adoption will be very narrow - US and few other developed countries. even in US i doubt that many people will be happy to share their driver's licences and bank accounts with FB for obvious reasons. and without wide adoption there will be no libra "closed system" as you described. this is catch 22. i don't see how FB can pull this off. i don't even see any clear strategy behind libra.
- andreshb 7y agoYou should really update your stereotypes.
- b_tterc_p 7y agoLibra feels like a great new avenue for physical, violent crime.
- probe 7y ago"It’s easy to assume from the headlines that Libra is only associated with Facebook, but that is not the case." With the post on.... Facebook.com
- qwertox 7y ago"Oopsie" -- Facebook Marketing Department
- sophiebits 7y agoYou too can post anything you want on... Facebook.com
- IAmGraydon 7y agoI'm asking this in all seriousness. Why would anyone want to use Libra? Let's say a consumer wants to buy something. They can either pay with "normal" money in one step or they can use their phone to convert their money into Libra and then make the purchase with Libra. Why would they go through the extra step(s)? Am I to believe that the benefit is "lower transaction fees"? Because if so, Libra doesn't have a chance. Only vendors, not customers, see those fees directly. Even if the customers did see them, they aren't big enough to sway the inertia of the way things are. In the real world, the vast majority cares very little about things like decentralization. They don't care about how the banking system works and who controls the flow of money. They want to swipe their card and get what they want. Anything more than that is just an obstacle. At least BTC has the benefits of pseudo-anonymity and speculative appreciation. Libra has neither. Beyond all of this, people like to have control over their money. To feel they have control, people need to have understanding. Paper is easy to understand. Cryptocurrency makes people nervous. Facebook REALLY makes people nervous. Put the two together and it will feel like a big risk to users. I'm an open minded guy, but I don't see it. Someone please enlighten me as to why this won't be Facebook's biggest failure. Why would anyone want to use Libra?
- rtpg 7y agoMost payment apps are locked to a specific country. If Libra becomes "Alipay except cross-country" then a bunch of tourist-y places in (for example) southeast Asia could start using it to get tourist's money without much of a hassle (especially given how many people are already accepting QR code payments from some local app) Similarly, cross-border payments in general are a huge PITA and affect enough people that stuff like Transferwise exists. If Libra can help assuage that there's a nice market there. It might not be a resounding success but it could be enough to sustain an ecosystem.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y ago> Am I to believe that the benefit is "lower transaction fees"? I don't intend to speak to various other merits (or the lack thereof) of Libra, but to this: yes? Of course! Transaction fees are huge. If you are operating in a razor-margin business, which more and more businesses are these days, then it adds up. FasTrak, the Bay Area toll processor, charges your card when you drop below a certain balance, and also charges you what they think your average monthly rate will be. Why? To avoid excessive transaction fees on every toll eating into their coffers. If the only way to buy something is Libra, or if merchants prefer Libra, then folks will be using Libra. Just look at how much market share PayPal has conquered, and they're arguable garbage. If you can substantially beat PayPal, you win.
- sealthedeal 7y agoAre you saying with Libra, I will be able to let my balance fall below zero and you will take no recourse? This sounds amazing!!!! I can’t wait to spend money that’s not in my account with no penalty!
- sealthedeal 7y agoNumerous startups have come and gone with the goal of servicing the unbanked. Why do you think Facebook will be able to solve this?
- qwertox 7y agoVery telling that his article is hosted on facebook.com instead of libra.org. It kind of proves that the separation between Facebook and Libra is nothing but a lie. He just doesn't get it and he never will.
- sophiebits 7y agoIt isn’t an Official Facebook Announcement though. Think of it more like a Medium post.
- iamzozo 7y agoYou know, when the message is "this is not a facebook product", because some people confused about it and you post an "unoffical" announcement on facebook, then maybe it's not a good PR.
- qwertox 7y agoProbably Libra's hosting provider doesn't offer a one-click blogging plug-in that could get integrated in their website. What are they hosted on? WordPress? I'm pretty certain WordPress is all about blogging... So if even Libra's team isn't capable of posting on their own website, but instead have to "reach out" to Facebook, it isn't too far fetched to assume that they're sitting in Facebook's premises to begin with.
- xiphias2 7y ago> Is this really a blockchain? It’s not open. It’s not decentralized! > While the initial mechanism by which organizations can run a node and become a member of the Libra Association, is definitely not as open as, say Bitcoin, where anyone can participate in the consensus algorithm, the Libra Blockchain is absolutely designed to be open. They skip the first question: Libra is not a block chain. It uses Merkel tree accumulators for updating the state of the database, so it's definately not a block chain, it's just marketed as one.
- H8crilA 7y agoIt doesn't matter really. It's a political/financial experiment. Tech is of little relevance to the success.
- simplesleeper 7y agoDon't Merkle trees underpin bitcoin? Why does it disqualify it as a blockchain?
- simplesleeper 7y agowikipedia says - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockchain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockchain - that transaction data is generally represented by a merkle tree in block chains
- xiphias2 7y agoYes, the block of transactions is arranged in a Merkel tree, but that Merkel tree is finalized, chained to the previous block and secured by proof of work. Libra is changing the Merkel tree over time, it is never final, which is similar to pre-Bitcoin digital currencies.
- Lucadg 7y agoThis is the part where they reveal how they plan to negotiate with regulators: "At the core, we believe that a network that helps move more cash transactions — where a lot of illicit activities happen — to a digital network that features regulated on and off ramps with proper know-your-customer (KYC) practices, combined with the ability for law enforcement and regulators to conduct their own analysis of on-chain activity, will be a big opportunity to increase the efficacy of financial crimes monitoring and enforcement" In other words: let us do Libra and we'll help you win the war on cash. The biggest blow on privacy in the world's history, brought to you buy Facebook.
- H8crilA 7y agoNot to defend them, but this is exactly what happens to all non cash transactions. Which you kind of have to do to with any sizeable quantity of money (say over 100k) for practical reasons, like theft.
- Lucadg 7y agoTrue. This is exactly the problem with non cash transactions. Every single transaction, no matter how small, is recorded forever and shared with several governments and secret services. I never signed up for this. This is why we need cash and why they are fighting it.
- SuperNinjaCat 7y agoAnother question on my mind (again, just my random thoughts, not representing others) is: How could this be used to undermine countries economies who are possibly earmarked for regime change by a company with strong ties to the US State Department affect the current geopolitical landscape...especially when some "developing nations" populations literally see Facebook as the Internet?
- H8crilA 7y agoSame as Trump's (and his predecessors) financial blacklists. Huawei CFO is prosecuted and currently in home arrest in Canada awaiting extradition to the US for allegedly bypassing sanctions on Iran. In simpler words: another US-domiciled lever that can be switched to the off position.
- jddj 7y agoI'm pretty skeptical about Libra overall. In the case where it succeeds massively as in some of Matt Levine's recent thought experiments, I'm not convinced that Facebook has captured enough of the US regulatory framework for them to turn a blind eye to a new global currency which eventually rivals or overtakes the dollar in usefulness. If we accept, for example, that needing to buy and sell oil in dollars allows for a much more effective sanctioning infrastructure then it seems unlikely they will let a corporate-controlled currency whose ideals don't align explicitly with those of the US get too powerful without a fight. In the other case, where it just becomes a data-hoarding venmo, but initially for the unbanked global poor, I'm not convinced that a) those people are truly sitting around unable to transact while they wait for Facebook to provide the solution and b) that a payment token which is pegged to a basket of global currencies rather than their own is truly the solution that these people would be seeking. Now, the (theoretical) implementation makes it look more like it's aimed towards the first scenario, some kind of global-corporatist dystopia which we as a society walk into blindly because it's conveniently available within WhatsApp. And I don't doubt the value of convenience, nor that there are some very smart people behind this who may have estimated that with the right implementation and dark enough patterns, they can use their market share to break through the latter scenario and into the first. But these are interesting times - I don't expect governments to sit on their hands, and we're not exactly in the midst of a surge in the popularity of globalism right now.
- SuperNinjaCat 7y agoMy immediate gut reaction to this entire thing (and again, this is only a personal viewpoint not held by others) is along the lines of: What could go wrong with giving one of the most shady corporations on the planet the permission to print its own currency?
- on_and_off 7y agoSame. The only interrogation I have is what can be done to stop Libra.
- chicob 7y agoIn Portuguese, "libra" is the word for the British Pound Sterling (GBP). I wonder how it is being branded here and whether there will be some kind of confusion, or mandatory differentiation.
- kuu 7y agoSame in Spain...
- robteix 7y agoCurrency names are not unique. How many countries use "dollar" or "peso"? Portuguese-speakers don't seem to have a problem with that, so I'm sure they will somehow find a way to deal with two "libras"
- glitchdout 7y agoYou usually prefix it with the country name. So that leaves us with "australian dollar", "mexican peso" and, huh, I guess, "facebook libra"?
- nobrains 7y agoFrom the blog: "I wanted to remind everyone that Facebook, through its subsidiary Calibra, is just one of the initial 28 Founding Members that are coming together to form the Libra Association. It’s easy to assume from the headlines that Libra is only associated with Facebook, but that is not the case." Then why is Facebook the only entity making blog posts about Libra? Except, when you assume the reader is dumb.
- dnprock 7y agoFacebook is asking corporate interests of different sizes, big and small, to join Libra effort. They will all have equal stake, including the founding company, Facebook. It'll be the biggest, possibly only, corporate altruism experiment in history. I think they have a small chance of succeeding if they are willing to pump in billions of dollars without expecting any return.
- MH15 7y agoCorporate altruism experiment Libra is a tool to control the global poor, not an "altruism experiment".
- aliswe 7y agoSo sorry, I just found this being very funny: "Economic empowerment is one of our core values"
- stesch 7y agoWondering how normal Germans would react to Libra. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJ26TbhZW8k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJ26TbhZW8k (How to deal with money like a German | Meet the Germans)
- ilaksh 7y ago> transition to a truly permissionless and decentralized consensus The fact that this is something that is supposed to happen at some unspecified point in the future but the "blockchain" they have cannot handle it -- I think its just a lie. It looks like it would require a massively different codebase and hardfork to get to permisionless and decentralized. They are not actually planning on doing it. Also, the fact that its backed by Visa, Mastercard, and PayPal -- they are the absolute enemies of cryptocurrency. Real cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum will be able to scale. Ethereum in particular has very advanced plans for rolling out very high scalability in a matter of months. That is what I support. I do not think it makes sense to use a fake "cryptocurrency" just so that the old companies can continue to get a cut of my transactions and the government can more easily control my money if they want.
- p0nce 7y agoWhat is the value of tracking every transaction? For us.
- tigerlily 7y agoI like to think of cash as a kind of slack in the system. Yeah there's corrupt stuff going on, but I like its immediacy and utility. A digital currency that is under full surveillance would just cause the whole financial machinery to seize up like a rusted Rube Goldberg.
- antihero 7y agoWell I can't use Libra, because an algorithm banned me for an obvious joke post and has absolutely nothing in terms of a proper appeals process or accountability. So if I had ever depended on Libra I'd be up shit creek, I guess?
- mymythisisthis 7y agoI've noticed that power tools (cordless electric drills) have started to become the currency of the underground economy.
- gonational 7y agoPoe’s Law may apply here, but are you being serious? Please explain.
- gruez 7y agoPresumably because power tools are high value goods that are often stolen by addicts to pay for their addictions. Then they make their way up the value chain. It doesn't really make sense though - they're not really fungible, they're pretty hard to transact with, and converting them to cash is tricky (how are you going to find a steady stream of buyers?). Tide detergent is also used as currency, and it's better than power tools as a currency in all regards.
- towlinson 7y agoThey see easy money, they get easy money, poor people get f.
- Proven 7y agoFrom the Fab post: > Someone wrote that the key reason people are unbanked is that they don’t have enough money to actually be banked, and claimed Libra wouldn’t solve this. Lol, who was that moron? MMT to rescue!