6 ms·
> NVIDIA doesn't support GBM If Nvidia don't support it, how much of a useful standard can it really be?
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> NVIDIA doesn't support GBM
If Nvidia don't support it, how much of a useful standard can it really be?
- jniedrauer 7y agoIt's an nvidia problem, not a standard problem.
- chrisseaton 7y agoBut I mean what's the point of declaring something to be a standard if the important people weren't interested in implementing and supporting it? Anyone can come up with a standard in isolation. Getting the relevant people on board and able and willing to support it is the useful bit. Did they say they'd support it? If they never said they did it seems unfair to criticise. Are you going to support my graphics standard that I just made up?
- rat9988 7y agoThis is a standard problem. You can't be a standard if the market does't care about you. You are just a specification and guidelines.
- boudin 7y agoIntel and AMD cares about it. If the Linux desktop market would grow, Nvidia would quickly change their mind. Now, this market growing is another question... But for me, nvidia gpu are just not a possibility because they lack good drivers on Linux.
- llukas 7y agoSo how do you want to grow Linux market share if you say FU to a significant part of the potential market? Steam hardware survey is pretty clear about AMD:Nvidia GPU ratio.
- ekc 7y ago(For gamers.)
- chungy 7y agoSteam is a pretty niche userbase and not at all representative of the desktop market at large.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI don't think so - I see nobody with a desktop computer these days except gamers or people running CAD or modelling who are basically doing the same thing as running a game.
- boudin 7y agoAnd all people using a computer for work...
- llukas 7y agoThe same can be said about Linux desktop share. Should we draw the same conclusions? Except gaming is not that "niche": 1.35 billion PCs worldwide - https://www.statista.com/statistics/610271/worldwide-personal-computers-installed-base/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/610271/worldwide-persona... 47M active daily and 90M monthly users for steam https://www.pcgamer.com/steam-now-has-90-million-monthly-users/ https://www.pcgamer.com/steam-now-has-90-million-monthly-use...
- krageon 7y ago> If the Linux desktop market would grow You can think of any number of fantasy scenarios that would make one of the biggest GPU vendors care about your standards, but sadly that is not the world we live in. The world we live in is one where Nvidia has the best game support on the market (far, far better than AMD - let's not even think about Intel here) and therefore anyone who still plays games on a PC will own one of them unless they are some sort of AMD advocate. At the end of the day, nobody wants to be reading "we don't support this because they're not nice to us". That's going straight back to the linux dark ages of 15 years ago, where you needed to care about all sorts of weird and arcane details to get a functioning desktop system.
- robert_foss 7y agoNVidia has a horrible history of Linux support. GBM works just fine, they've simply chosen not to support it.
- calcifer 7y agoNvidia has excellent support, I think you are conflating Linux with open source. For decades, Nvidia had (and arguably still has) excellent support for the former, without really caring for the latter.
- ori_b 7y agoHow long did it take to get multiple monitors working with xrandr, again?
- calcifer 7y agoFunnily enough, this is exactly what I was talking about. Nvidia supported multiple monitors on Linux for decades using TwinView, they simply didn't add support for the open source xrandr for 4-5 years, but even that has been supported for ~7 years now.
- ori_b 7y ago> Nvidia supported multiple monitors on Linux for decades using TwinView And Xorg supported them for decades before using Xinerama. Instead of collaborating with upstream, they just dumped something incompatible and broken, and said "Deal with it".
- p_l 7y agoMulti monitor display worked perfectly for long time, long before "it works on intel, let's call it new standard" crew decided that flat shared framebuffer is the only way to go (apparently because of compositors and nothing else), something that also broke support for multi-gpu and especially heterogenous multi-gpu.
- makomk 7y agoGBM is a very useful standard if you only ever want to request buffers from drivers that use the Linux kernel's GPU buffer management code and modesetting code. (Preferably only Mesa-based drivers too.) NVidia doesn't use this and probably can't for licensing and other reasons. If you want to talk to any graphics driver that isn't correctly and intimately entwined with the right parts of the Linux kernel, GBM is basically useless. It is not in any way, shape, or form a generic standard for buffer management. (In principle GBM isn't quite a single-implementation Mesa only standard - third party implementations are possible, though the only one that exists right now is by ARM for their newer Mali GPUs. People seem to have had mixed results with it and I'm not sure it's even intended to run desktop Wayland.)
- csande17 7y agoI'm not super familiar with the details of this stuff -- does this mean that there's basically no hope of any wlroots-based window manager ever working on non-Linux operating systems like BSD?
- makomk 7y agoMost of the BSD variants have some (generally outdated) port of the Linux kernel graphics stack, sometimes even with a wrapper layer to try and make the BSD kernel internals look enough like Linux for it to run unmodified. So it's probably not completely hopeless, but that's mainly because the best shot at getting the graphics accceleration it needs is a straight port of the Linux kernel drivers. (At least for non-NVidia users.)
- bojanz 7y agoThankfully, getting less and less outdated (thanks to FreeBSD's wrapper layer, and OpenBSD Foundation sponsoring its own work). FreeBSD 12.0 has Linux DRM 4.16 code (April 2018), while -current has Linux DRM 5.0 code (March 2019). OpenBSD -current (next release) has Linux 4.19 DRM code (October 2018, LTS), with initial AMDGPU backports from 4.20 (AMD Picasso & Raven 2 support).
- 7y ago
- pmlnr 7y agoa standard supported by nothing, that reminds me of xhtml2...
- imtringued 7y agoIt is very condescending to label Intel, AMD and pretty much every other GPU vendor other than Nvidia as nothing.
- chrisseaton 7y agoIf Nvidia don't support it, then it's just a standard, not the standard.
- darkpuma 7y agoMeanwhile X is still on death watch and Nvidia will be brought into the fold or be forced to stop pretending they support the linux desktop.
- michaelmrose 7y agoWherein "death watch" is expected to work without difficulty for the next decade or longer. They aren't pretending they support Linux, BSD, Solaris, Mac, Windows for a decade after each card is released. While this was true ATI/amd were shipping garbage that barely worked for a few years. This has only changed in recent years. We are a few years having one dedicated gpu maker in the fold and are already talking about using your massive 2% marketshare to strong arm the other. You could afford to be more humble and less entitled.
- darkpuma 7y agoIt really doesn't matter to me if Nvidia drops out of the linux desktop market or not. I've never owned their hardware and never will, so it makes not an iota of difference to me. I'm just observing that Redhat is the trendsetter and if they say X is legacy, that makes it so. Unless Nvidia or Nvidia customers decide to pick up where Redhat is leaving off and pay for developers to work on X, but I sincerely doubt that's going to happen. Unless Nvidia decides to support the new system, they can't plausibly claim to support the linux desktop. I just hope whatever happens will result in less online whining from linux-using Nvidia customers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- arghwhat 7y agoIntel and AMD maintain open source drivers that have supported this for ages. It's only NVIDIA that still tries to shovel outdated proprietary drivers without support for community developed standards down our throats. Adding that their proprietary drivers are not particularly good, NVIDIA is not a very popular choice for a Linux machine. Just remember that it took them almost a decade to add KMS support.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIt's an interesting position to suggest that nvidia which has no obligation to support you in any way shape or form is shoveling anything down your gullet by not supporting the standards you prefer. You could vote with your wallet but there aren't enough Linux users to move anyone's needles as far as gpus.
- arghwhat 7y ago> but there aren't enough Linux users to move anyone's needles as far as gpus. Well, for server and ML payloads, we are the vast majority. Things like Google Stadia is certainly enough to move needles, and if AMD ends up able to compete in ML with future products, then we'd be able to make a huge dent in NVIDIA revenue.