21 ms·
Renault's driver UX is a disaster waiting to happen
- amluto 7y agoIt appears to have a door lock button, so it scores at least one point against Tesla.
- cptskippy 7y agoWhich one? The S, X and 3 have very different interiors. I had an S for a week recently and it has physical controls for most everything. It felt like driving a normal car, I hated it. I don't really see a need. The Model 3 automatically locks when put in drive and unlocks when in park. You can disable the unlock on park option. Child locks are controlled via setting and not switches in the door panel that kids can easily play with. Apart from a scenario where you are in danger and need to quickly get in the car and lock your door, why do you need a dedicated button?
- amluto 7y ago> I had an S for a week recently and it has physical controls for most everything. It felt like driving a normal car, I hated it. What Model S did you drive? Unless new ones are radically different from any I’ve ever seen, there are no physical door lock controls, HVAC controls or audio controls (except on the steering wheel). Suppose you stop in a dangerous neighborhood for long enough that you want to put the car in park. The auto-unlock, especially in the absence of a button to re-lock the doors, is potentially dangerous. So you turn it off, and now you have to remember to double-tap to unlock. To make it more fun, the Model S can get into a state where the doors are nominally unlocked but the handles are retracted. Getting in the car when this happens is awkward at best. There’s a reason that almost every other car has a physical control for the door lock.
- cptskippy 7y ago> The auto-unlock, especially in the absence of a button to re-lock the doors, is potentially dangerous. So you turn it off, and now you have to remember to double-tap to unlock. Double tap to unlock? There is a padlock always in the same place at the top of the screen that you can see to get state and touch to change. If you need have auto-unlock on and put the car in park, your hand is inches from the padlock to re-lock the doors. The only scenario where a physical button makes sense is when you urgently need to lock the doors.
- amluto 7y ago> Double tap to unlock? Double-tap park. > There is a padlock always in the same place at the top of the screen that you can see to get state and touch to change. That’s newish, embarrassingly. And sorry, but a little tough target in a corner of the screen is nowhere near as ergonomic as a button you can feel.
- cptskippy 7y agoMaybe older models are different but I've driven both pre and post bumper redesign Model Ss and a Model 3. In all three Double-tap is for the emergency brake. Single tap on the control stalk parks the car. > That’s newish, embarrassingly. Newish? It's always been there to me and to anyone buying a vehicle after it's introduction, whenever that was years ago. How many other automakers add new functionality to their vehicles years after purchase? > And sorry, but a little tough target in a corner of the screen is nowhere near as ergonomic as a button you can feel. A dedicated physical button is always easier to locate/use but adds unnecessary clutter when there is a button for everything. I personally have never longed for the button as the only time I recall using it in other cars is to lock my partner out of the car just as they try to open it.
- lykr0n 7y agoI'd take that over a Tesla any day. Once you learn where the buttons are you can control them without taking your eyes off the road. That looks like most cards other than a Tesla.
- wlesieutre 7y agoExcept for the functions in the touchscreen, where it appears they’ve taken Tesla’s approach but done a shittier job of it
- lykr0n 7y agoYeah... Not the best, but I'm sure that head unit will be working in 10 years. Tesla? Don't think so. It's also a €27,900 car, vs a €58,000 Tesla.
- mrtksn 7y agoI used to drive a Renault, the functions on the central screen are mostly for the entertainment and communications and there's another stick with buttons to control these without the need to interact with the touchscreen. It's not perfect but pretending that you need to interact with the touchscreen to drive the car is ridiculous. The buttons may seem confusing at first glance but this is not a website but a car that you literally get trained to ride and stick with it for more than few seconds so in no time all these buttons become second nature. The website domain is "grumpy" so I guess the OP prides himself/herself of being grumpy but I don't think that everyone has to be grumpy.
- dmitriid 7y agoPlease tell me how you control the A/C without touching the screen. For example, for increasing/decreasing fan speed. And how you switch radio stations (I still haven’t figured that) out. Or how you get to a second/third/fourth screen because Renault couldn’t figure out how to show all useful info on one screen. Or, since Bluetooth is finicky, how to initiate phone connection. All the things I had to do while driving, multiple times.
- close04 7y ago> There are more times than I can count on my right elbow when I deactivated it by accident. The author manages to periodically elbow a button that is placed right next to the hand-brake switch and the seatbelt buckle receptacle, below the armrest? While that's an uninspired place to put half of the controls for assistive driving you'd have to adopt a pretty strange driving position to hit it with your elbow. Edit. Downvotes aside, I found this random image as a reference [0]. I'm having a hard time picturing the elbow naturally reaching below that armrest while driving. I'm sure someone can find a way to do it but not in any position that a driver should have. "On the highway. Doing 120Km/h." Even later edit. @dmitriid, any chance you can post a picture of what kind of body position leads to such an accidental press? Don't take this the wrong way, I am genuinely curious how the elbow can get there while driving. [0] http://www.renault-me.com/CountriesData/GCC/images/cars/Talisman/otherImages/LFD-UH-SdVAmbianceDrivingPleasure_R_ig_w965_h543.jpg http://www.renault-me.com/CountriesData/GCC/images/cars/Tali...
- notahacker 7y agoIronically, I assume it was placed there because the designers viewed it as less likely to be accidentally pressed there than somewhere on the steering wheel or centre console...
- close04 7y agoPerhaps, although this doesn't seem to be a problem on basically any other car I drove. Many times it's on a stalk behind the steering wheel and it requires twisting which you wouldn't do accidentally. But even looking at the picture in the article (the hand on shifter), there's no natural (or safe) position that would lead to multiple such occurrences.
- galkk 7y agoThe fact that it's even called "armrest" and on the picture the driver clearly doesn't have his arm there might give you some doubts that the picture clearly depicts real life scenario.
- 7y ago
- ousta 7y agowasnt there a ux designer a few weeks ago saying that renault had the best UX of all the vendors?
- mrpippy 7y agoWow, that touchscreen UI gave me serious flashbacks to Windows Mobile 6.1 (especially the dark theme used on the HTC Touch Diamond). Especially because the font looks like Tahoma, but even the appearance of the soft buttons is dated and the overall design is so bland. Barely looks better than the UIs that come on no-brand Chinese radios.
- riffic 7y agoeh, on the bright side your car has the correct number of pedals (three).
- nkrisc 7y agoMy commuter-mobile hauls me from point A to point B perfectly fine with only two.
- marmaduke 7y agoI have a recent megane with this and it really isn't a problem
- gouggoug 7y agoThe cruise control buttons being next to the handbrake button reminded me of the worst car I drove, I don’t remember the model, but the brand was Mercedes: The handbrake button was located on the windshield wipers handle, at the top of the handle itself. I had the misfortune to hit that button going 75 miles/hour while trying to find how to do something else (I can’t recall what). Thankfully the car detected I was going fast and quickly disengaged the parking brake. What a stupid idea to put such a dangerous button in such a weird place ... edit: as gambiting commented, the button I am referring to is the P button, it is located on a stalk on the right hand side of the wheel, which is dedicated to shifting P N D R. It is not on the windshield wipers stalk. The windshield wiper stalk on this car is located on the left hand side of the wheel, above another stalk for the turn signals. Driving this Mercedes was utterly confusing.
- gambiting 7y agoThat was never the case in any Mercedes ever - in some automatic models the "P" mode switch is at the top of the stalk(you use the entire stalk to move between R N D modes), correct. But pressing the button while moving does absolutely nothing - you get a beep telling you that you can't do this right now. The actual handbrake button is usually below the lights switch next to the steering wheel on the door side.
- gouggoug 7y ago> the "P" mode switch is at the top of the stalk, correct You are correct, I am referring to the Parking button, not the handbrake, my bad. However... > But pressing the button while moving does absolutely nothing This isn't true. In my case it definitely beeped, but also, jerked the car.
- rsync 7y ago"But pressing the button while moving does absolutely nothing - you get a beep telling you that you can't do this right now." Not quite ... We owned a 2013 Mercedes E320 4matic (wagon) (US version) and although these did not happen often, you could: 1) Hit park while idling and lurch to a park even though you were driving >0 MPH. 2) If you were creeping along into a difficult parking space and you opened the door at, say, 1-2 MPH to look down at the divider line or something, the car would insta-lock into Park. I assume it is a safety measure or something as the door was, indeed, open, but I really don't want the major driving mode of the car auto-selected for me ... also it's quite a KER-CHUNK to throw it into park at 1 MPH ...
- taco_emoji 7y agoTouch screens in cars should be banned. The interaction affordances are abysmal compared to physical controls, and tactile feedback is obviously non-existent. Not to mention that as the author mentions, many UI targets are too small to touch accurately without diverting a significant amount of your attention from driving.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> The interaction affordances are abysmal compared to physical controls I find scrolling a map is far more natural on a touch screen compared to physical controls.
- alanbernstein 7y agoDo you often need to scroll a map on your car's screen?
- chrisseaton 7y agoYes. To see where I'm going to be going or find something. Do you not?
- TylerE 7y agoNo? I just enter my destination and let it actually navigate
- chrisseaton 7y agoI often look around on the route to see if it's suitable, what I'm going to past, where I might stop, things like that. Just entering the destination and going without looking first is a recipe for being one of those idiots trying to drive down an unsuitable country lane, in my experience.
- TylerE 7y ago
- kazinator 7y agoAll that my eyes can see is the six-speed stick; all else is forgiven.
- nfRfqX5n 7y agoi find car UX very interesting and see them taking more chances with design sometimes. BMW's iDrive is a great example of where they do some cool stuff such in the music/contact search, lots of buttons, heads up display, and lots of customization
- russellbeattie 7y agoI bought a new X1 in December and I'm constantly amazed when people praise the iDrive system. The User Experience of the car as a whole is horrific, and yet apparently it's a great example in comparison to everything else. Like the article, I'm amazed at the dumb or careless decisions that have been made. No play/pause button anywhere for example (the on/off button is used instead). Music doesn't stop until you open the car doors after shutting it off. The backup camera doesn't turn off for several seconds - so whenever you take your car from park to drive, it turns on the camera and then just leaves it on for a while. Whenever my gas tank gets near to an 1/8th full an alarm which sounds like the Law & Order theme goes off and a [!] appears in the notifications. The nav system takes a while to start up, so you can't enter an address for a minute or so after getting in. The air conditioning won't let air just pass through from the outside (I'm in California, just let the Pacific chilled air in!). Also, when BMW says you need to change your oil (waaaay too often), you need to go through a secret reset method to clear out the message. Even many of the physical buttons and functionality are moronically missing. Want to put the back seats down from the back? You have to go around front to pull the tabs. Such a pain. Why?? I want my Kia Sportage back. It really does make you appreciate California tech companies and their attention to design and the customer experience.
- dawnerd 7y agoVW seems to have a nice balance between touch and buttons. All of the wheel buttons are useful and in a good spot. Physical buttons for climate also in a good spot. Touchscreen in the newer models is large and tap zones are pretty forgiving - although you shouldn't even need them while driving.
- geff82 7y agoVolkswagen really knows how to design cars that are 100% intuitive. Big, easy to find buttons in a spot where you can easily reach them. Hyundai, in my opinion, is similarily easy to operate.
- elisto 7y agoIt makes me curious to know how much is bad Ux design and how much is simply people not being able to transition into a new set of technology since they have grown acustomed to the previous way of doing things. It would be interesting to see the experience that new drivers may have with these designs and then ask them to compare it to the older version.
- tempguy9999 7y agoI think that's pretty much what user testing is, and it should be done long before releasing a product.
- mrpigeonpants 7y agoThat's a good point. Often when I see UX this bad, it's also usually the result of siloed teams or designers working on individual parts without thinking about the whole experience, and it all just gets stitched together at the end. I can see the console designer being like, "Oh cool, steering wheel designer is out of room, so I get to design cruise control buttons" rather than pushing back with, "This is a really bad idea"
- ryandrake 7y agoIf you've ever worked at a company whose bread and butter is hardware, you know many of them treat software like just some other line item on the BOM: Like a screw or nut that needs to be as cheap as possible and "meet the spec", however insufficiently defined that spec is. I'd be willing to bet that this attitude is what's ultimately behind crappy software in cars. They don't see software as value-add, they see it as a cost that they grudgingly must eat in order to barely compete with the other car companies who also have crappy software. Yet, these companies who are so bad at software, and obviously hate it, keep adding more and more of it into their products! It was a lot better when you could just ignore the bad software and use your phone for navigation/music. Now you need to use the bad software to operate more and more essential things in the car. What's next? A big screen in front of your face with a 10FPS animation of a steering wheel that you have to drag around with your finger to steer?
- deleted 7y ago
- tempguy9999 7y agoI assume the author is talking about user interfaces when he mentions UX, so... >Which is a shame because the elements of the design that don't have any actual UX are extremely well executed (both the aforementioned cruise control, lane assist and some minor things). That is UI design. An interface is a much broader thing than just computer interfaces. It most certainly encompasses placement and behaviour of physical controls. As for the touchscreen, I got a new MP3 player a while back. I could not find anything but touchscreens now. My old player had physical controls, I could do the common things like skip and fast forward without thinking, without looking. The new one, well, that touchscreen - put bluntly, I hate it.
- amatecha 7y agoYeah, I've rented latest-model Renault and Peugeot cars in Europe and I cannot believe this stuff. It's probably same in new North American vehicles, but I haven't driven those. This Peugeot 308 was trying to kill me with its "lane assist" in a construction zone, forcefully steering the car towards the concrete barrier because the painted lines on the road were tapering towards the concrete barrier (due to the construction). I finally found out how to turn that off _after_ nearly being killed. Make my car less like a desktop computer, please. My favorite is _waiting for the car to boot up_ so I can turn on the air conditioning in the sweltering heat :) There's also the joy of fumbling through terribly-designed touch screen menus so you can turn off the radio that for some reason auto-tuned to some nearby station. Since my FM transmitter wasn't broadcasting audio I guess the car just decides it needs to get something pumping through the speakers ASAP. The other hilarious thing is the cruise control pretty much slamming on the brakes because someone merged into my lane 300m+ ahead (not even slightly at risk of driving into them because they are about the same speed as me). I guess the system that detects an obstruction ahead cannot tell that it's moving at the same speed as me. Not surprising, but regardless, can I please be the driver of the vehicle? Oh yeah and how about those software-driven dash gauges that feel like they have a full second of latency? The ability to customize the UI skin is something I want for WinAmp, not my car's tachometer and speedometer.
- fwip 7y agoTeslas also do that, but I don't know about other lane assist systems.
- danpat 7y agoThe cruise control on our Subaru seems to behave like you’d expect here. If someone cuts in front of you going roughly the same speed, it backs off a bit to open up some space, but doesn’t slam on the brakes because someone is close.
- ansible 7y agoOn the Toyota Prius (2016-) you can have the lane departure warning on, while turning off the steering assist. The steering assist was one of the first things I turned off on it, otherwise it might activate literally every time I drive home. There's also construction all over the place, so... yeah. I pity someone stepping into one of these cars for the first time with this feature enabled.
- baron816 7y agoPlease watch this video on what’s probably the worst car ever designed: https://youtu.be/Y16ObVRvgOE https://youtu.be/Y16ObVRvgOE I’ve watched it probably two dozen times and crack up every time.
- crooked-v 7y agoThanks, I hate it.
- alanbernstein 7y agoThat is spectacular.
- carapace 7y agoUnbelievable.
- ptaipale 7y ago"- The steering wheel contains two dozen buttons" Actually, one dozen. I also have a Renault, but older, so the configuration is different, but I use regularly three of the cruise control buttons, and three or four of the audio control buttons, and I don't have the phone connection which I would use too if I had it. I can imagine many people using most of that dozen buttons on a very regular basis. And if you don't use them, you don't have to.
- gmueckl 7y agoI have a Hyundai i30 (Elantra GT in the US, I believe) with a similar set of buttons on the steering wheel. The only button I don't use is the one to activate voice recognition for Android Auto or Car Play (I use neither).
- bborud 7y agoThis is why I love old cars. And especially the "moderately expensive" cars of their era, like the Bertone-designed Alfa Romeo GTV from the early 1970s. A well kept specimen just feels so nice to drive and it is so easy to drive as well because there's nothing that needs fiddling with and nothing that is trying to meddle with your driving. I wish they'd make simpler cars. With physical knobs that have proper tactile feedback. (I'd wish for normally aspirated engines as well since they are nicer to drive, but turbos are the price we have to pay for 270-300hp 1.8 liter engines. sigh)
- nickserv 7y agoIf you can afford them, some of the Lotus models are definitely in that spirit.
- inferiorhuman 7y agothere's nothing that needs fiddling with On an old Alfa, everything needs fiddling with (including the things you can't adjust like the position of the pedals and other controls).
- bborud 7y agoOh yes. Plus you need to be built like a monkey. When the pedals are the right distance you can't reach the steering wheel. And when the steering wheel is close enough, your knees are pointing up at either side of the steering column. Glorious. Just glorious :)
- y_tho 7y ago> I wish they'd make simpler cars. With physical knobs that have proper tactile feedback. They do, they're just entry level, basic everything, fancy nothing. You get from A to B and that's pretty much it. Some may lack even a radio or a/c.
- bborud 7y agoModern entry level cars are still modern cars and they are very different from 50 year old cars.
- Tokkemon 7y agoAnd that's why I drive a Subaru.
- nickserv 7y agoI'm unfortunately in the market for a new car, and I'm having to look into work vehicles like small cargo vans to avoid all this nonsense. Touchscreens, radars, special Android apps, automatic climate control, buttons on the steering wheel... Enough already, I just want a fucking car! Airbags and antilock brakes save lives. A/C is useful in summer. Radio is nice. The rest is garbage.
- tjohns 7y agoThe radars can save lives by detecting an imminent collision and sounding an alarm ("pay attention!") or automatically breaking. The buttons on the steering wheel are also a safety feature, since it lets you keep your eyes on the road.
- andrewg 7y agoJust bought a ‘99 BMW and I couldn’t be happier. All the important stuff (airbags, ABS, etc), comfort (a/c, heated seats, power windows/top), and beautifully simple controls. Nothing else.
- agumonkey 7y agoOld car EV conversion is ready for your money
- gmueckl 7y agoThe right set of buttons on the steering wheel are a life saver. Quite literally. How often do you take the hands off the steering wheel to adjust the radio? Be honest. Even if you're not looking at the radio, your attention is focussed on finding and manipulating the controls by touch. The control over the car is diminished because you don't have both hands on the wheel (important for quick reactions, less so for driving straight). The same goes for cruise control that can be controlled entirely with the thumb and hands on the wheel. Maybe a set of useful buttons should be mandated on the steering wheel?
- Johnny555 7y agoMoving the cruise control on/off buttons off the steering wheel doesn't seem like the worst decision -- that's something that I usually press once per drive, and never touch it again, so in the interest of reducing the number of buttons on the steering wheel, putting the buttons elsewhere makes some sense. The center console seems like an unusual place to put it, the dashboard itself would seem to be a better place. Though I don't understand how he hits it accidentally with his elbow, the only way I could hit a button on the center console would be if I lean down and do it intentionally. In the photo with his hand on the shifter, his elbow is on the armrest and couldn't touch the red buttons accidentally
- amatecha 7y agoFor highway driving, having all the cruise control buttons on the steering wheel is a godsend. Guess it depends on the driver's usage of the car, but I'm a big fan of not having to fully take my hands of the wheel to enable/disable CC or alter the cruising speed/etc. :)
- Johnny555 7y agoMy cruise control has a "cancel" button on the steering wheel (which is not the same as "off"), but almost all the time, I just tap the brake pedal to disable it since I generally want to disable it when I want to slow down. As far as I can tell from his pictures, the Renault has only the main on/off button on the center console, and the rest of the cruise buttons are on the steering wheel. EDIT: I found the owners manual, and indeed the center console has only the main on/off button, the steering wheel has the speed up/down (+/-), Resume (R), Cancel (O) buttons. https://www.renaultusa.com/News/DriversManuals/talisman.pdf https://www.renaultusa.com/News/DriversManuals/talisman.pdf
- jedberg 7y ago> The touch screen is filled with insanely small targets I'm running the latest iOS beta. One of my biggest complaints is that they changed the CarPlay interface and made all the targets smaller! I had a hard enough time hitting them before, now it's even harder, especially when the car is moving and bouncing. Luckily the worst outcome is that I skip a song or something, and not safety related, but still, come on Apple. You should know better.
- CharlesW 7y ago> One of my biggest complaints is that they changed the CarPlay interface and made all the targets smaller! Do you mind elaborating? I'm also running CarPlay with iOS 13, and the apps all seem to have the same usual button sizes/target areas. I suspect you're thinking of the new "dashboard" view (pictured at https://www.macworld.com/article/3403343/everything-new-in-carplay-in-ios-13.html https://www.macworld.com/article/3403343/everything-new-in-c...), but even in that case I haven't run into a scenario where the buttons/targets seem smaller.
- jedberg 7y agoSpecifically the "Now Playing" screen. Before the cover of the album was a transparent background, but they instead made it a standalone picture on the right side, shrinking to forward and back controls (and in my podcast app, shrinking the skip 30 buttons).
- Zardoz84 7y agoThings like this, make to keep my two "analogic" cars for a long time.
- ZeKK14 7y agoRenault Megane owner here (the small Talisman), i want to address some of the criticism in this thread and the article. > The steering wheel contains two dozen buttons The buttons on the wheel are pretty well designed and usable. The left side is all about cruise control, one button for each action: faster, slower, ON, OFF. That's it, look at the picture to check it. All these buttons are close to your hand, have great feedback, and very simple to use. It's really nice to have them here. Right side is about phone handling and the (crappy) "Siri" or the car, I only use the button to answer the phone. Behind the wheel is the radio control, which is actually standard for a Renault car. > The cruise control buttons being next to the handbrake button reminded me of the worst car I drove The button in the middle of the car is only to choose between "Cruise control" or "speed limited". People rarely change it and I end up mainly using it after I moved it while cleaning the car. It's okay to place it here. > Touch screens in cars should be banned. I have to agree the UI on this car entertainment system is terrible and slow. Some controls such as the light power on the dashboard requires 3-4 presses, which can be difficult while driving. It's a shame they never addressed this problem, this UI can receive OTA updates. All in all, this is a really nice driving experience. The main feature are available on buttons and really fast to reach. I've droven a lot of rental cars, and I remembered fumbling several minutes in the menus of a GM to change the steering wheel settings, which is WAY simpler on a Renault.
- hn23 7y agoHave to agree. Moreover the cruise control reactions are petty fast. Also switch radio station is possible with the wheel on the stick behind the steering wheel.
- dmitriid 7y agoHow does one discover that wheel. Also: why the hell is it a wheel when there are no wheels for any other control on the steering wheel?
- kurtisc 7y agoThe manual or dealer? Most people aren't renting, I think it's fair to place function over discoverability in something you could spend years of your life operating.
- bjakubski 7y agoI drive 2017 Renault Talisman, which is basically the same as 2019 model (there was no facelift in the meantime). I really don't understand where some of the complaints from the article come from. The "another stick" to control audio is pretty nice. I find especially volume control pretty natural. Contrary to article it does allow switching tracks/radio stations. I don't mind the steering wheel controls. I don't use cruise control that much, so left side is mostly unused, but I often use right side). I drove 2004 Mazda 6 before this car, where I had volume control on the steering wheel and I do not find Renault's layout interior. The R-Link infotainment system is far from perfect. Menus are quite confusing to me. I don't find it slow though, but I guess the main point is that I do not use it much. I sometimes change something in the settings (usually when stopped), but more often I just start Android Auto and use that. I don't remember if the setup visible in photo in the article is the default, but there is a hidden option in Android Auto which allows it to take much more of the screen space than shown by author. It's kinda like square display then? I find using touchscreen then tolerable (but I do not advise to do it while driving). My son selects own music without problems though. One thing missing from the article is that the main infotainment system and Android Auto can be controlled via the knob/wheel controller visible in the photos. It supports rotating, 4 wheel directional action and press. The operations I perform the most while driving (that is controlling music via Spotify) are really quite comfortable when using this controller. Note that, unlike some other cars, there are two physical dials for setting climate control temperature. These I do use and can't imagine having to use touch screen for that (that eliminated for example Peugeot 308 when we were shopping for car) But how I (180cm height) or my wife (163cm height) accidentally press the cruise control/speed limit button? I have no idea. I have automatic gearbox, but quite often (when stopped and, obviously, when changing gears) I drive with one hand on the stick and elbow resting on the the elbow-rest and I can't imagine how that switch could be pressed. Maybe if someone is really short and the seat is in very forward position? Certainly not in position as shown in photo. Also never heard such complaint from other Talisman owners.
- dmitriid 7y ago> Contrary to article it does allow switching tracks/radio stations. I think I've pressed every single button on the wheel and all the sticks. Still haven't found a way. If you need to read the user's manual to figure out such a simple task, it's a failure of design. For example, I would think that the right thumb stick would do that. Because it literally does nothing. But no. In the end thanks to HN and elsewhere I found the wheel. And of course it's just as abysmal as the rest of the design: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20354178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20354178 > ne thing missing from the article is that the main infotainment system and Android Auto can be controlled via the knob/wheel controller visible in the photos. Yeah, no. It's much worse than glancing at the screen and reaching to touch it. Because you have to constantly look at the screen while manipulating the knob. Because at any point in time you don't know where the current selection is and what actions will be triggered by activating the knob. Unless, of course, you set it once (on the "change track" button) and never move it. > But how I (180cm height) or my wife (163cm height) accidentally press the cruise control/speed limit button? I have no idea. Having it done three times already, I also have no idea, but I did (I'm 178cm). Possible reasons: - While parked I had to reach to the passenger seat from the driver's door (the button is extremely easy to deactivate) - Fumbling with my water bottle when trying to put it into the compartment under the hand rest - Leaning over to the right and putting my elbow down for something (probably reaching for something or scratching my leg) However, "I can't imagine how" cannot be a justification for this design decision. The reasoning is simple: when you are already driving, how do you turn cruise control on?
- rsync 7y ago"There are more times than I can count on my right elbow when I deactivated it by accident. On a highway. Doing 120 kmh. Prime time to crane your head awkwardly down and slightly back while awkwardly bending your right hand to try and re-activate it." United 777 jets have buttons on the top surface of the armrest right where you put your elbow down. One of those buttons is the flight attendant call button: https://mk0runwaygirl0t0gjwt.kinstacdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/IMG_4019-Custom.jpg https://mk0runwaygirl0t0gjwt.kinstacdn.com/wp-content/upload... [1] I have inadvertently hit this several times. [1] https://runwaygirlnetwork.com/2017/03/09/review-uniteds-domestic-777-presents-mixed-bag-in-economy-class/ https://runwaygirlnetwork.com/2017/03/09/review-uniteds-dome...
- jimmaswell 7y agoFunny how technology keeps making cars in particular worse. I'll probably be sticking with 90s models for a very long time. My 99 JGC 4.7L has basically everything I want or need with an FM transmitter and phone mount added.
- Vordax 7y agoI tried going back to an old car, but 45mpg hybrid Kia Niro, push button to start, Android Auto, backup camera, blind spot warning, blue tooth, and adaptive cruise control, etc, never again will I drive an old car.
- iagovar 7y agoYou can get mid 2000s car with many of those features and without the bloat.
- dillonmckay 7y agoThat is like a $90 head unit from Amazon, my friend, except for adaptive cruise control and a pushbutton, though that is not difficult or expensive to add either.
- Vordax 7y ago
- avar 7y agoNo recent car UX I've seen has been worse than the Hyundai Ioniq. The button to toggle reverse is right next to the cup holder / center storage, and placed & designed such that it's easy to accidentally hit it as you put your drink down[1]. I took a sip of my drink while waiting on a red light. When it turned green I unexpectedly backwards and just narrowly avoided crashing into the car behind me by slamming the brakes. Turns out I'd switched it from "Drive" to "Reverse" accidentally. Toggling that button requires about the same amount of force you'd expect from a button that turns on the radio in any other car. 1. http://www.cleanmpg.com/community/index.php?media/31669/full&d=1488215988 http://www.cleanmpg.com/community/index.php?media/31669/full...
- choward 7y agoThat is awful. I can't believe you can accidentally put your car in reverse by dropping something. They created an unacceptable problem by solving a non existing problem like most car UXs these days.
- quickthrower2 7y ago> button to toggle reverse wtf! Anything that alters the transmission should be big and require definite intent to move.
- userbinator 7y agoShift buttons were around 60 years ago, but definitely in a more... tactile form: http://i.pinimg.com/736x/fa/3a/b3/fa3ab3fe7e72bd22fffcefe748798741.jpg http://i.pinimg.com/736x/fa/3a/b3/fa3ab3fe7e72bd22fffcefe748...
- aetherspawn 7y agoThat’s a shame because a lot of elements were copied from the Prius / Lexus CT200h for the IONIQ (I own the latter) and I was starting to think of switching up for the newer IONIQ hybrid power train since the CT200h has had a decade long technology stall. And the Prius is butt ugly.
- 7y ago
- rkagerer 7y agoI empathize, vehicle user interfaces are becoming terrible. How about forging a startup focused on doing outsourced UX for automobile cockpits? Aim to be the "Apple" of design for the automotive industry.
- colanderman 7y agoThe funny thing is, anyone who read Don Norman [1] could have told you this after 2 seconds' thought a decade ago. Why then, do multibillion dollar companies continue to produce such boneheaded designs in 2019? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Design_of_Everyday_Things https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Design_of_Everyday_Things
- Baeocystin 7y agoIt is even more baffling when we consider that his discussion of speed-adjusting cruise control (and how it works just well enough to lull drivers into a false sense of security, then bam sudden acceleration on the off-ramp, etc) came from his consulting with the car companies about this problem in the first place.
- ako 7y agoThey probably produce these designs because they sell better. I explicitly ordered a full screen dashboard on my skoda kodiaq (similar to vw/audio digital dash) because I like it better that analog dials. Companies produce things that sell, so probably better to ask why consumers buy these things...
- 734129837261 7y agoA touch screen is pure evil and stupidity and the product of grey old men dictating their products: "We NEED touch, build it in!" Thing is, roads are bumpy. G-forces make your extended hand go all over the place. A touch screen in a car is pure stupidity. You want to rest your arm and take control of ONE single controller, either an Apple-like quality touch pad, or a knob you can navigate and press. They'll get there, eventually. When those fossils die.
- mschuster91 7y agoIt's not that difficult lol. Important stuff (= what the driver needs to be able to access during driving) should be physical buttons that are unlikely to be hit by accident, the rest is well served by a touchscreen that optimally can be controlled and seen by the passenger. Oh and for what it's worth why are "map updates" still a thing in brand new 2019 cars? That's what OTA or, even better, live map fetching from the Internet is for? And why doesn't any car manufacturer work together with Google for the maps display?! Even a top notch BMW still looks gross compared to Google Maps.
- mey 7y agoThe current generation of Mazda have a very pleasant interface. Controls on the steering wheel are split by function. Left side is audio/comms, right side is cruise and driver MFD controls. Automation overrides (lane departure/awd) controls are on a panel left of the steering wheel only the driver can access. AC/Temp controls are physical, below the touch screen. Their is a jog/cmd dial just behind the shifter that controls the center touchscreen. The entire system can be operated from that dial. The system locks out certain center dash functionality when the car is moving. The colors of all displays are the same, including a heroic effort to match the brightness between the digital and analog displays. The only control oddity to me is the location of sports mode in relation the the parking brake switch. Both are next to the shifter which makes sense, but enabling/disabling sport mode is hard to do by touch. There is voice recognition for the av/nav but I have found it useless.
- ryeights 7y agoI agree. My only other complaint is the display latency/responsiveness... I don't understand why so many car manufacturers refuse to make their infotainment systems perform well.
- realshowbiz 7y agoI for one really dislike touch screens and menu driven controls in most applications. Especially if driving. Even controlling an iPhone is error prone when it’s mounted to a gps holder in a moving vehicle. Give me tactile buttons, switches and knobs that do one thing well, are keyed with different feeling textures and are backlit.
- floatingatoll 7y agoIt took nearly 6 months to learn to accidentally stop hitting the "reduce traction control" button in a 2013 Subaru BRZ with my arm. I considered printing a custom cover for it. In the end it turns out I learned not to hit it, but it's recessed and flat, unlike this Renault nonsense.
- spectramax 7y agoNo one is mentioning the most negative aspect of touch screens: Constancy. Arguably more important than feedback. When you are used a physical button, you can bet with quantum mechanical accuracy that the gluons are holding the quarks pretty well together and that button ain't going anywhere. A touch screen is configurable and hence I cannot be 100% sure that button is still there. You can count on it. Just like you can count on typing with a keyboard vs speaking to Siri. Yes, a particular job can be done both ways, but the former guarantees user interaction and feedback. Also, no one mentions that touch screens are introduced in cars as a cost-saving measure. Automotive grade buttons and encoders are expensive - check ALPS catalog. That's the main reason behind this fog of UI/UX bullshit that people are debating about. Fuck the modern life. As I age, I am getting more and more grumpy. Can someone explain why electric cars have to look like a fucking spaceship!? Why can't they just be regular cars with electric drivetrain? Why do men's stuff have to look like it came out of tron and women's design look like a decorative art piece in Cinderalla's castle? Design is a hot mess. I want to see a world with a design dictator - someone like Dieter Rams who approves every design. Joking.
- Bluestrike2 7y ago> Fuck the modern life. As I age, I am getting more and more grumpy. Can someone explain why electric cars have to look like a fucking spaceship!? Why can't they just be regular cars with electric drivetrain? That's probably the result of trying to appeal to early adopters. For all the progress that's been made in shifting how people view electric cars, making them appear a bit more futuristic through design is apparently still an advantage for the marketers. We're still early enough in the transition that you can feel like you're buying "the future" today. That said, the shift towards using touchscreens for everything is really an industry-wide trend, and not specific to electric cars. They appear futuristic (which appeals to consumers), and they're cheaper than physical buttons. If it makes you feel any better, time will probably erase that first consideration. It's the Tomorrowland problem[0]; eventually the future catches up to your design, and what once appeared futuristic becomes dated. It's the second one that's a sticking point for a future shift back towards physical buttons. 0. https://boardwalktimes.net/the-future-that-never-was-the-tomorrowland-problem-41829d45a933 https://boardwalktimes.net/the-future-that-never-was-the-tom...
- docker_up 7y agoI feel the same way about the Model 3. The touchscreen interface is fine for a computer or when you're parked but when you're driving it's utterly useless. At the very least, they need to move the AC to tactile knobs and buttons. I can't change anything to do with the air while driving because it takes too much of my concentration to figure it out. The glove compartment also needs to be moved off onto its own real button but that's minor compared to the AC.
- rmykhajliw 7y agoRented a new Opel GrandX (SUV) - the same issues described in auricle. Whole nightmare as a car for driver.
- ps 7y agoSo many HN folks suggest touchscreens are inferior to physical controls in cars (safety or UX wise) and I can't agree. Bad interface design is the culprit not the device. I did not need to read manuals for my iPhone, Polar watches (touch), more complicated machines in the garden, washing machine, fridge, coffee machine nor my Tesla Model S. On the other hand using my ventilation unit controls at home was impossible without manual (non-descriptive menu items, non-circular menu starting in the middle so up/down matters and remembering where is the entry you need when there are many of those you almost never need is painful). I love my Model S and I am satisfied with its UI design with some remarks like "Quick Controls" content I never use. There is no bullshit, no attempts to look too fancy and hinder the experience. Complete game changer of this car is the possibility of improving UI with software updates. I am yet to encounter the car without touchscreen that has intuitive controls. My current list of the cars and quirks I remember the most: 2007 Kia Ceed I do not know remember to change C to F degrees or setup clock after owning the car for the 12 years and driving it daily for almost 5 years. IIRC holding the Trip button (one of four in the main row of computer controls) changes something depending on the current context. Kids like to touch and hold buttons and I am doomed afterwards. 2011 Ford Mondeo Alerts present somewhere in the Settings. Paring the phone requires you to push the Phone button and the Menu button. Arrows are only for cycling, Enter is useless. 2017 Peugeot 5008 Rented it for a week on holiday, physical controls. Interface design was complete mess - confusing icons, excessive layers combined with "innovative"/unique naming of menu entries etc. I quit trying to comprehend it after a while. This was one of the worst interfaces ever encountered, on par with the Ford SYNC in the latest models I had the opportunity to use as loaners. 2017 Mercedes GLA Same holds for Audis I've driven. Graphic design is consistent and quite polished which might confuse you that the interface will be intuitive and carefully designed. Animations and images accompanying any task are definitely made for marketing purposes and sales people showing off and to hide the difficulty of achieving the tasks you are up to. Visual clues are often missing and using the control wheel was like spinning the roulette and waiting for the outcome. I believe people who drive Mercedes whole live like it and are used to it. Btw numerical keyboard in the car, really?! 2018 Volvo XC 60 Had it only for a day as a test drive, quite good, no major issues, definitely one of the best interfaces. However the graphic design was inconsistent and this car has touch screen. 2018 Hyundai Ioniq One weekend, no major issues for me, bad graphics design. Do not recall if it is touch based or not, but some buttons were present.
- artpi 7y agoI own a Renault Duster and I was convinced the UX is crappy by design to make me switch to a higher "tier" of a car (duster is about 12K USD for a new one) - Audio system has a huge knob that changes radio stations, but buttons for volume ️ - The "Turn off ECO" button that gets me higher RPM for overtaking is behind the cups on the cupholder. I cannot use it if I have a drink. Its quite dangerous when I want to overtake but dont have enough power and cannot get it - The magical buttons to control audio / phonecalls behing the wheel is a shitshow. There are some buttons I cannot see, but I have never pressed the correct one - Rearview mirror adjustement is under the parking break handle - Cruise control is such a shitshow that I never use it
- stef-13013 7y agoThey should have used Qt :)
- vbezhenar 7y agoI bought new Renault Logan Sandero in 2015 and couldn't be happier. No stupid assist stuff, no computer stuff, just engine, wheel, gearbox and brakes. The only safety stuff that I'm aware of is ABS and airbag which is more than enough for me. My next vehicle will absolutely be Renault Duster with a similar configuration. I need car to drive, not to think instead of me. Though some things would be nice to have. Like car detection in blind zones. I think that it's not invasive, just some kind of light bulb. I thought that I would want an advanced cruise control (which measures the distance and accelerates or decelerates a little bit) but I definitely don't want it to hit brakes instead of me. If this feature does more than controlling an engine, I don't want it.
- astannard 7y agoMy last few cars, were a confusing mess of UI. Both of which had poorly thought out touch screens. This Renault seems to have them both beet in bad ui though. I miss my mini with no touch screen and simple functional buttons!
- Robin_Message 7y agoI hired a Renault Mégane about five years ago. The headlight control was a rotational control with very low friction on the end of a stalk. The same stalk also did full beam and indicating. You can guess what happened repeatedly: whilst driving on dark country roads, I'd flick the beams up or down, or indicate, and that flick would also spin the headlights, turning them off. Happened several times to me and my wife who also drove it. I suppose maybe that car was faulty and the friction was lower than it was meant to be, but still, it was an accident waiting to happen: being plunged into darkness on a twisty country road after passing another car was not fun. So bad UX is not a new thing for them.
- alkonaut 7y agoHow can they not have designers? It's like they designed it explicitly to be both cheap and ugly looking and have a terrible UX. Making it one or the other could at least indicate a tradeoff being made (form over function or vice versa), but here it's just a complete horror show of too many colors, poor layout etc. Are "good looking" (boring looking at least) interiors such as VW or Volvos really that hard to make? Just do clean lines, a color scheme, keep things within reach etc. This looks like it was designed by children.
- Karto 7y agoI've been working for a few years for a large European trucks manufacturer. Two brands were co-developing a new range of models, one brand a bit more luxurious than the other. The "slightly lower end" brand were making a very fancy HMI with two large colour screens, lots of menus and the stuff. The top end stuff just had a huge bunch of well placed physical buttons and switches. When the prototypes came into drivers' hands, everybody liked the buttons, nobody liked the screens. It came as a bad slap to the people who had worked for years on it. "Those young drivers, the iPhone generation, think our screen based HMI is way too complicated and misleading." I drive a Dacia and I love its simplicity... I fear the day when they try to make a Dacia look fancy.
- geolgau 7y agoI have a Mazda 2 (2017 model) with a touchscreen, but my model also has a rotary control knob which works great - I never have to touch the screen - in fact it's being disabled when I reach 30km/h. The nastiest problem I have is bluetooth volume - where FM/USB (mp3) playback at volume 9-10 (out of 50) are perfect, for bluetooth I have to be at 34-37 to be on the same level. And the problem is when switching between them - the horror!!! But even worse is if I forget to activate bluetooth on my phone and start the car, which after a few seconds of trying to connect to the phone switches automatically to FM and BLARES the fucking sound at me! It's insane. I didn't have this problem with a Sony player in a rather old car (Opel Astra 2001). It remembered the volume setting for each function separately, so when you switched between FM, usb playback or bluetooth you had the volume you used previously for each. I contacted Mazda with this problem, but they never bothered to answer.
- toolslive 7y agoI'm driving a Renault Espace Initiale, and the mug holder is placed in the middle at shin height, below the big center block containing the stick shift. It is impossible to insert a full can of coke without spilling some because you have to tilt it. I'm not kidding.
- tepper43 7y agoDefinitely too many buttons