6 ms·
China Wrestles with the Toxic Aftermath of Rare Earth Mining
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoThe eternal problem of externalities. They ought to be priced into the cost of the rare earths, but doing so means you lose out to your less scrupulous competitors.
- mrspuratic 7y agoCapitalism 101, get rich by plundering the earth (and leave someone else to clean up the mess). Mining is a truly nasty business, and not just environmentally. No small problem is that of assigning value to a clean environment, or to sustainable practises. ETS anyone?
- ThomPete 7y agoYou are most likely using products based on mining to write that comment. Doesn't that make you complicit if we are to follow your hard stance here?
- throwaway2048 7y agoDid you know by just being alive you are destroying the earth? Clearly anyone that dosen't immediately kill themselves has no grounds for criticizing anything.
- mathieuh 7y agoNo, this is just a reformulation of the same old facile "if you're such an anti-capitalist why don't you move to the DPRK" comment
- pjc50 7y agoEveryone is complicit in everything to a slight degree. That's simply no longer a useful thing to say, nor is it a means to dismiss an argument that something should not be done. It's just a statement that disentangling yourself from the system comes at an extremely high cost, if it is possible at all.
- ThomPete 7y agoPointing the ethical/moral finger at someone else while you are part of the problem is the very definition of disentangling yourself from the system. Some of us are perfectly fine with the negative consequences because we believe the positive far outweighs the negative. In other words, there are other ways to think about this which actually do make it useful to say.
- pjc50 7y agoThat doesn't make the negatives go away. Mining is a nasty business, even if it's also beneficial.
- ThomPete 7y agoIt doesn't make the negatives go away but it could mean it's a net positive which changes what to read into it.
- Al-Khwarizmi 7y agoAnd others among us think the negative in certain aspects of the system can outweigh the positive and things could be improved, and it doesn't mean that we should live in the wilderness hunting our own food if we want to criticise any aspect of said system. The computer mrspuratic is using exists thanks to products from current mining... true. But it could also exist thanks to products from more sustainable mining, if the world worked differently. It's not like he was given a choice. So your kind of argument, if you intend it to discredit criticism or making other people appear incoherent with their principles, is basically a fallacy.
- ThomPete 7y agoThe fallacy as far as I can see is yours. Mining companies don't have more choices than the consumer. The mining companies are also forced into making the choices they do or go out of business based on the reality around them.
- imtringued 7y agoOnly a little. Mining can be less environmentally harmful if we make that our priority. China didn't care and bankrupted the environmentally concious competitors.
- ljf 7y agoLet's not forget, that the buyers of the minerals had total choice where to get their supplies from. They could have purchased from American or other mines, but chose to go with the cheapest - knowing both that doing this would bankrupt safer mines, and leave environmental waste in China. The Chinese mines are not blameless, but they are only part of the 'profit at all costs' mindset that many shareholders demand.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThey didn’t really have a choice though. Oh sure, those companies could pay twice as much as their competitors, but they would simply go out of business and not exist anymore. So if they existed before, they can’t exist now. It’s all predicted by the free market: the mines that had higher costs because they followed environmental regulations can’t compete with those that don’t, likewise companies that purchase from more expensive sources can’t compete with those that purchase from cheaper ones, since ultimately consumers are going to choose the cheaper product. Hence the need for regulation and perhaps even trade restrictions to force the right choices to be made.
- bluGill 7y agoNo it is not predicted. The free market does not require you to use the cheapest supplier, it requires you to use the best for your situation. Sometimes it is worth paying for quality. If using the cheapest supplier causes your customers who care about the environment to boycott you, then using that cheap supplier isn't a good decision. So the failure comes back to people not actually caring about the environment in China.
- seanmcdirmid 7y ago
- patrickaljord 7y agoThe USSR was way more polluting than the US.
- ThomPete 7y agoWhat I really wanna see is both negative and positive externalities. It feels like we are always only including negative externalities when we talk about things we don't like and positive when it's things we do like. We should always look at both sides.
- throwaway2048 7y agoThe entire point of business and trade is to capture value from positive externalities, its delivered value is extremely apparent.
- ThomPete 7y agoExternalities are by definition not calculated positive or negative. So no it's not apparent by definition which is what makes it an externality.
- dalbasal 7y agoPricing externalities has become such a common comment. Does anyone know good examples (family led also, but successful mostly) of pricing externalities? I mean the alternative is regulation and/or legislation. Those work pretty well when a reasonable (ie production still happens) of harmful processes/methods. Eg banning CFCs in certain products. I know of examples where these were deployed. Tldr: what is the best, big example of a real, functional price system for "externalities?" I don't want to jump to conclusions, but it feels like this line of thinking is similar to state "retraining" to deal with unemployment due to economic changes. Very popular rhetorically, but very few encouraging examples.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoI think we hear a lot of them but don't see them in practice because it would reduce profits. It's like any other solution to a problem of capitalism. Regarding regulation: something like a carbon tax is arguably pricing-in of an externality, but mandated by the government. That's actually what I think of when I suggest this, because I don't expect captialist actors to deal with these problems without being forced to somehow. In the free market, if an externality can be ignored to gain a competitive advantage, it will be.
- dalbasal 7y agoThat's what I meant, except a mature, existing example. Carbon tax is the biggest question on the table. A lot of economists like it because theory. I'm skeptical, tbh, even of quasi-dynamic versions (like taxing fuel), and I tend to think taxes/subsidies (for example) on the purchase of vehicles would work better. Open to have my mind changed though, hence the question. Where have laws been used to successfully create externality price system?
- shawnz 7y agoSo rather than a cost proportional to how much waste you actually create, you'd rather have it be an equal tax on all drivers? That would eliminate the whole benefit of a carbon tax for middle class: If you're just driving to work every day then you shouldn't have to pay as much as the people and organizations who are creating substantially more waste than you are. I think this approach would ostracize drivers even worse than current approaches.
- slics 7y agoInteresting, although I wish more thought is put into the cost model upfront for any kind of mining that harms the environment prior to these excavations. By taking under consideration the cleanup process at the beginning, it eliminates the need to fight for funding after the mining is done. Although in communist countries all the government cares is to rip the benefits and not worry about the after effects.
- digitalengineer 7y agoIn the forth quarter of 2018, 46.89 million iPhones were sold worldwide. That's just the iPhones. Wouldn't it be great if products from Apple were easier to repair or upgrade instead of encouraging consumers to buy the latest model? It would also make it easier to recycle. How much mining would that prevent?
- Tepix 7y agoYes, it would be great. On the other hand Apple is already a lot better than the average Android phone when it comes to the availability of software updates, especially security updates by the vendor. However, we still have a long way to go. It looks like mobile phones will last longer now that we are seeing diminishing returns from the yearly updates. Perhaps vendors can be forced to release the software as open source when they no longer support it with security updates?
- keymone 7y agoSo what happens to old iPhones? Hard to believe they are all in a dump somewhere.
- ivanhoe 7y agoI still use my iPhone5 as a 2nd phone, and it's still totally usable after 10 years with the original battery and updates from Apple available until recently. I totally see myself buying 2nd hand iphones to my kids as a cheap solution to keep them off my phone (they're thankfully still young enough not to care about the fashion and brands)
- nerdponx 7y agoWhy is it hard to believe?
- indymike 7y agoIn the bottom of dresser and desk drawers all over the world.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIn places like China, where labor is very cheap, they're most likely disassembled into parts, which are then used to repair other iPhones - much like it happens with Android phones. In places where labor isn't cheap, I can't imagine where else would they go but a landfill.
- westiseast 7y agoPerhaps it’s churlish to mention, but... China was happy to ignore environmental standards in order to corner the market in rare earth minerals. American miners couldn’t compete because they were already “internalizing” the environmental costs, and were priced out of the market. Once China had put everyone else out of business (and blocked foreign businesses from mining inside China), it started not only reducing output to increase prices, but also started to very slowly apply environmental standards it previously ignored. The Chinese government also showed how willing they were to now use this almost complete monopoly for political purposes in 2010. And now in 2019 they’re calling for consumers and global companies to contribute to the costs of “internalizing” the pollution?
- titzer 7y agoNow you realize how the game theory of economics is fundamentally at odds with the natural world and sustainability. It always pays to defect now, and the loudest voices are usually the rich players who moan about economic growth and "burdensome regulations". Mining and logging in the US was very much like this before regulation, but that was on a much smaller scale, with simpler technology and less energy available to scale up. My advice: pay attention closely to environmental policy and don't let regulations be rolled back in the name of growth!
- wayoutthere 7y agoPolicy doesn’t even need to be rolled back much of the time: they can just stall progress while they figure loopholes around the existing policies. Which has been the GOP strategy for almost 40 years.
- bluGill 7y agoDon't blame the GOP, both parties have been doing it for the last 200 years (the republican party isn't that old, but the Whigs before them as well). They target different areas to stall progress. Sometimes the stalling is good, sometimes is bad - and it is often a matter of opinion which is good or bad.
- blunte 7y agoI disagree with this: "Environmental experts and local officials say the cost of the cleanup should not be shouldered by the Chinese government alone, but also by the rare earths industry and the global companies and consumers that benefit from these technologies." The mining companies should bear the cost, since it was a cost that they simply ignored at the time. If that cost had been factored into their business, prices for their materials would have been higher (and the consumers would have paid). Instead, like many businesses, they took responsibility for only the costs that they had to. In general, consumers should not shoulder the burden of corporations' bad business practices. If true costs were considered, there would be far less materialism (and corresponding pollution). All that said, sometimes everyone has to contribute to right a wrong. However, it's not ok that everyone pay for one party's past wrongs only to see other parties continuing to repeat those wrongs.
- ambicapter 7y agoYeah, all these experts happen to be Chinese.
- worklogistics 7y agoPSA: There is a disinformation campaign that pushes the narrative that renewables are big users of rare earth minerals. They are not. The #1 uses of rare earth is chemical catalysts (used for processing fossil fuels) and pollution control (also fossil fuels) Top uses of rare-earths in the US Chemical Catalysts 55% Metallurgy & Alloys 15% Ceramics and Glass Making 10% Glass Polishing 10% Other 10% Source: http://geology.com/articles/rare-earth-elements/ http://geology.com/articles/rare-earth-elements/ Batteries, solar panels and magnets are in that 'other' category.